Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Dr. Childers-Mckee
1 December 2017
Significance of Study
When most people register to vote, they are placed in districts based on their permanent
residence. Behind the scenes, many of the homeless population have the belief that they have no
right to vote because they have no permanent residency. This dilemma is at the heart of the
research that we have done this semester. Working alongside Helping Homeless to Housing
(HHH), we have sought to understand how homelessness affects individuals, and what can be
done to fight against it. HHH was founded in 2001 as an organization dedicated to advocating for
the homeless, informing them about their right to vote and reforming the current system for voter
registration. Over the years, HHH has also developed a keen interest in making affordable
housing more widespread. Led by Justin Markel, they have been heavily involved in rallying the
homeless population and speaking out for the voiceless. During our research, we have learned
from the homeless community and formed assertions about what must be done to help them.
Statement of Research
common stereotypes that are given to the homeless. Working alongside HHH, we investigated
what current work is being done to help the homeless. Finally, we decided what key things can
be done for the homeless, and formed a project that acts upon those principles.
2
Joshua Sun
During this research process, I learned a lot about homelessness and affordable housing
in Charlotte that I have never even heard of in my 17 years living in Charlotte. My family moved
to Charlotte when I was three, and I went to a predominantly white private Christian school in
South Charlotte from kindergarten to 8th grade. While I was at Carmel Christian School, I was
very isolated from the reality of Charlotte. My family was a middle-class family; however,
everyone else at Carmel Christian School was upper class and very wealthy. Because of that
exposure, I was in an environment separated from low income families and the situations that
low-income families face every day. South Charlotte has always been the richest part of
Charlotte; being in the suburbs, poverty and homelessness have not always been visible. Even
though we lived close to Uptown, we never had any reason to venture outside of the suburbs
because everything we needed was close. The high school I went to was a drastic change in
comparison to my private school. I went to Providence High School, a well off high school that
was less than a mile away from my old school. Providence allowed me to interact with a more
diverse group of students; however, I still did not have an accurate understanding of poverty and
homelessness because South Charlotte, as a whole, does not expose people to those issues. I am
not saying that there are not any homeless people in South Charlotte - I am sure that there are -
however, it is more difficult to spot homeless people in the suburbs. Because of my past social
locations, learning about homelessness and affordable housing in Charlotte has been a new
experience for me. I came into this research process with a clean slate with no prior opinions on
homelessness in Charlotte because I never had to consider those problems. During this process, I
3
was able to listen and learn, focusing on the stories, the people, and the harsh reality of
Philip Bazduh
parents. Their cultural background emphasized a strong value of education, and through their
rearing, this transferred into me. I began reading at a young age and performed well
Despite being son to immigrants, I found assimilation easy, since I was born in the US
and did not face a significant language barrier. This fact, coupled with my being white and
Christian, allowed me an educational experience similar to that of the native majority, and I was
granted all of the privilege afforded that station. I had never been exposed to homelessness, my
familys residences being isolated in economically well-off locations. Having lived in suburbs
my entire life, studying the city of Charlotte was a look at a larger social ecosystem, of which the
homeless are, unfortunately, a part. I am glad to have, through this project, learned that with the
Kyle Tucker
As far back as I can trace my family history, we have lived in America. Both sides of my
family are Caucasian, and my immediate family is middle-upper class. I have grown up living in
Charlotte, and while my dad has lived in Charlotte for most of his life, my mom has moved
around the east coast. Each of these factors play a small part in my positionality. Being white and
growing up in a majority white community, there are many issues that I am unaware of. Growing
up, white privilege was an urban myth. My family has never been rich, but by most standards,
4
we are well off. I have never had any close relationships with anyone living below the poverty
While each of these factors affect my positionality, the biggest factor is without a doubt
church. While there are many different viewpoints on how Christianity can affect positionality, I
think it has opened my eyes to many things that I would never have known. For instance, I have
learned about global poverty, and the drastic need for larger distribution of medicine. I was
taught from a young age that racism is vile because it defies Gods given structure for humanity.
I have been taught to love the needy and outcast, even if I disagree with their worldview. All of
Dalton Pearman
Coming from a white, middle class family homelessness never seemed like a real issue to
me. I always had food to eat and somewhere to sleep. We always went on family vacations at
least twice a year and enjoyed more than enough gifts on Christmas. I was able to do well
enough in school to receive a significant scholarship to go to college and lucky enough for my
family to pay for the rest of my expenses. I come from a hard-working family where working
50+ plus hours a week is expected, and that family always comes first. I always saw poverty but
only through my window and never knew anybody who suffered with this issue.
Growing up I believed the common misconception that almost all homeless where
mentally ill or just lazy. Through this research project I have learned that this simply is not true.
Once you become homeless there is no easy way to get out of it. Especially because most of
these people do not have family that can help them or a support system and are completely on
their own. Once someone has nothing it is so hard for them to find food and shelter much less
5
find a job. There were so many things that I never thought off until I started this project like how
do the homeless register to vote? I thought some of the solutions HHH had were very creative
but had their own problems. This is unfair because your income or better yet lack of income
shouldnt determine if you have the right to vote. Also, if you have no home how do you apply to
jobs or file information for taxes if you have no mailing address? Therefore, I now believe
affordable housing allows the homeless to become re-engaged with the community and secure
Research Questions
What are stigmas surrounding homelessness, and how does this affect the homeless
population?
What key action steps can we take going forward to aid the homeless?
Literature Review
In our work with HHH, we were able to determine that the primary issue in Charlotte that
contributes to homelessness is the lack of affordable housing. Despite the prevalence of various
organizations that have been established in order to help the homeless obtain housing as a part of
the Housing First Initiative, the collective agency of their efforts is limited by the increasing
home prices in the area. Our aim was to explore the extent of the decrease in housing
affordability in Charlotte in the recent past. We found that housing prices have risen a rate faster
than that of personal income, that certain governmental policies help ameliorate the prevalence
of homelessness in Charlotte while others exacerbate it, and that an interesting solution to the
Over the past 15 years, housing prices in Charlotte have risen at a faster rate than wages;
the great increase in Charlottes population during this time has contributed to the citys
gentrification (Portillo, 2017). The median house/condo value has increased by over $57,000,
from $131,500 in 2000 to $188,800 in 2015, while the median household income has only
increased by less than $7000, from $46,975 in 2000 to $53,919 in 2015 ("Charlotte, North
Carolina (NC) Income Map", 2015). The graph below shows this disparity.
Figure 1. Comparison of the rise in median home sales price (MHSP) with that of per capita personal
income (PCPI) from 2000 to 2015. The rate of increase of MHSP was 3.21 times that of PCPI during this period.
Some homeowners benefit from the associative rise in their homes value and the
security of a fixed mortgage, which allows them to maintain residency. On the other hand,
renters, who are more likely to be lower-income individuals/families, experience rising rents that
match the rising value of rent units, making them most susceptible to the recent affordability
trend. When an individual loses everything and becomes homeless, this often implies a lack of an
ability to maintain an adequately-paying job. Thus, finding affordable housing in Charlotte for
7
the homeless in the housing-first approach has been more taxing on nonprofits and government
programs. To directly address the issue of affordable housing, there exist three primary means of
increasing affordability: 1) lowering the price of housing, 2) increasing the minimum wage,
and/or 3) increasing governmental subsidization of housing assistance programs. The first option
is not readily possible in a capitalistic economy and the second is likely to only provide marginal
relief. Thus, the third option is the best goal toward which Charlotte should work.
A major source of federal funding is the HOME program, which provides formula grants
to states and localities for use in nonprofit organizations focused on the building, buying, and
Partnerships Program", 2016). However, it has been a goal of Trumps administration to disband
the HOME program, an endeavor founded on the argument that state, and local governments
and the private sector [have a greater role] in addressing community development and affordable
housing needs than does the federal government (Krieg & Mullery, 2017). If this were to occur,
helping the homeless to housing would not only become more difficult in Charlotte, but
throughout the entire US. Protesting President Trumps proposition is one way that people can
Furthermore, current government funding works primarily to assist those that require the
aid of welfare and to minimize that need. The North Carolina Work First program, for instance,
helps people responsible for providing for their families to find employment and move off of
welfare. It shortens the time that families can be on welfare by making work mandatory and
limiting the duration that they can receive assistance. Additional aid with services like
transportation helps save money and allows people to get to work. In order to qualify for this
benefit program, you must be a resident of North Carolina, either pregnant or responsible for a
8
child under 19 years of age, a U.S. national, citizen, legal alien, or permanent resident, have low
or very low income, and be either under-employed (working for very low wages), unemployed or
about to become unemployed ("Benefits.gov"). Although this program helps the unemployed,
which the homeless often are, a precursor for eligibility is being on welfare. Currently, however,
proof of residency is required to claim unemployment benefits, SNAP food benefits, and TANF
assistance. Thus, government aid often isnt available to the homeless, who lack a residential
address, and they who need aid the most often are not able to ask for it.
There are 180 low income housing apartment complexes in Charlotte of which 56% are
based upon income. There are 7,134 apartments without rental assistance that are considered
affordable for low income families ("Low Income Housing in Charlotte", 2016) . The table
below shows how Charlotte determines income limits according to salaries of a certain
household size.
9
Income Limit Low (80%) Income Very Low (50%) Extremely Low
Family
2 45,250 $28,300 $16,960
Considering, however, that the salaries of nearly half of the households in Charlotte are
$55,000 or lower and the fact that the average household size in Charlotte is 2.45, the demand for
affordable housing is much greater than the supply ("Charlotte, North Carolina (NC) Income
Despite these facts, overall homelessness decreased by 36 percent from 2010 to 2016 ("
2016 Point-in-Time Homeless Count, 2016). This is likely due to the growing housing-first
approach to homelessness, an approach endorsed by HHH. There are six homeless services that
Mecklenburg County recognizes. This includes government sponsored services, like Shelter Plus
Care and Housing Stability funding, and private services like Moore place ("Homeless
Services").
10
A great solution to the lack of affordable housing is the idea of inclusionary zoning. This
requires the city to plan construction in a manner that makes housing available to various
economic classes and prevents the displacement of lower income people as driven by
political action is required. Advocacy and awareness of the need for inclusionary zoning, as well
as the homeless and lower-class population that it aids, is essential for promoting political
change. Thus, our websites function to disseminate information functions to indirectly promote
Whereas the norm for research is based off a hypothesis testing and data collection, we
utilized a different research technique, Community Based Research, that combines research with
community service, engagement, with the goals of improving societal issues. In Strands article,
Origins and Principles of Community Based Research, he writes, (1) Community Based
sources of knowledge and promotes the use of multiple methods of discovery (12/1/17 Strand
4), and (3) its goal is to initiate social action and change for the purpose of social justice. So, our
goal in our research project was to learn as much as possible about the issues of homelessness in
Charlotte. Besides finding and reading articles online, we wanted to be exposed to the homeless
community and truly see and try to understand the issues. As students, Community Based
Research allowed us to experience the issues of homelessness with a different lens. We were able
to engage and talk to members of the homeless community, confirming the information that we
researched online through articles. Throughout this research process, we strived to find ways we
11
could help our community partner while our community partners taught us about the issues of
homelessness and their personal stories. This continuous cycle of learning from interacting with
the community and helping out the community with our findings is the key idea of Community
Based Research.
We were able to attend two Helping Homeless to Housing meetings, conducted one
interview with Justin Markel - leader of HHH, and attend a Homelessness Vigil that
commemorated the homeless people that have passed away in the past year. In the first Helping
Homeless to Housing (HHH) meeting in September, we were given the chance to observe the
meeting as well as ask multiple questions about the issues surrounding the organization, and
issues regarding homelessness. During the meeting, Justin led the group in updates regarding
what he has done in communicating with city officials, as well as upcoming events that HHH is
expecting to host or participate in. Justin also took the time to explain the history of HHH, the
mission statement, and talked about homelessness and affordable housing. The main point that
Justin brought up to us was that there are good programs in getting homeless people off the road;
however, there are not enough houses to support the entire homeless population in Charlotte.
At the end of the first meeting we were able to ask a few questions such as their
definition of chronically homeless, their relationship with Moore Place and Urban Ministry,
and to elaborate on issues surrounding advocacy. Overall, the first meeting allowed us to meet
the people behind the organization and dive deeper into the issues that HHH is striving to tackle.
We learned a lot about the organization and the issues they are striving to mitigate.
During the second meeting on October 26th, Justin talked about how the organization
needed to make some changes. During this observation of the meeting, we were exposed to some
of the internal issues that HHH was facing as an organization as well as events that they have
12
been planning for a while. The main internal change they strived to implement was to try to
reignite some fire power within HHH. The organization was going through some leadership and
member commitment issues. Justin and the team started planning an open house that would
allow the new residents of Moore Place to come and ask questions and see what truly this
organization does, with the hope that they will join. Also, Justin taught us about how the
Charlotte government interacts with issues of homelessness. He talked about how many
affordable housing sites target individuals that earn 30 percent or more of the median income,
but the area that has the most need is the range of income below 30 percent of the median
income in Charlotte. The city of Charlotte has committed 20 million dollars to create more
affordable housing; however, 90 percent of that is going to support those who earn 30 percent or
more of the median income. Less than three percent will be supporting the people who are most
in need. Overall this meeting was just a quick update meeting that allowed members to stay in
the loop with what was happening regarding homelessness and housing. The information during
this meeting allowed us to gain a better understanding about what has been done, what has been
After that meeting, I was able to interview Justin. I asked him to tell his story about how
he became homeless, his transition out of homelessness, and the goals and accomplishments of
Helping Homeless to Housing. In summary, Justin started out as appraiser in Colorado; after a
rough divorce, Justin moved to Charlotte to work in the realtor business. However, in 2008 he
was laid off because of the economic recession. He worked for a temp agency and as time
passed, these temp jobs became scarce, and he had to start selling his possessions in order to
support himself. Justin was homeless for four years and during that time, he ended up in the
emergency room countless amount of times because he had no health care provider. He tried
13
various programs to get housing and jobs and nothing would help. In 2011 when Moore Place
opened, Justin was the tenth person granted housing in Moore Place. Justin described how
transformative living under a roof was. Within the first few months, Justin was able to connect
with a physician, start cooking for himself, and readjust his life positively. Justin has been living
in Moore Place for 6 years. Now, he is part of many organizations that strives to help homeless
people find housing. In the second half of the interview Justin spends time talking about the
goals and accomplishments of Helping Homeless to Housing, which was covered in the Phase 1
Reflection. He ends the interview talking about how many people have a large misconception of
how homelessness is like in Charlotte. People think that most homeless people have drugs or
mental health issues; however, Justin says that even though there are people who are homeless
and do drugs, most homeless people are not drug addicts. There is a stereotype that homeless
people are drug addicts, mentally challenged, or beg at intersections for money; however, a lot of
homeless people blend into the general population. Justin ends with the note that even if
homeless people look homeless or they look well-dressed, they have a passion, a talent, and a
story. This interview, Justins story, allowed us to gain a deeper level of understanding at an
individual level of what homelessness and the transition into affordable housing is truly like.
The final event that we observed was the November Homelessness Vigil. This vigil, that
commemorated the homeless people that have passed in the past year, was held at the Homeless
Resource Center on November 16th - the middle of the National Homeless Awareness Month.
Although, it was not an event planned nor sponsored by Helping Homeless to Housing, many
organizations across Charlotte came together to commemorate the lost. This final observation
was a good way in summarizing everything we had learned by simply experiencing the presence
The main research site that we conducted our observations was Moore Place. Moore
Place, outside the northern part uptown Charlotte, is an affordable housing apartment complex
that opened up in 2011. Moore Place is the home to many of the members in HHH and
conveniently, is where the meetings take place every 1st and 3rd Thursdays of each month. The
participants that we interacted with are all members of HHH and all have been homeless at one
point of their lives. Justin Markel, the leader of the organization, was homeless for four years and
has a compelling story and a passion to end homelessness in Charlotte. Overall, the people that
we interacted with and Moore Place, itself, has allowed us to fully experience how affordable
housing works, the transitions and steps that homeless people need to take to obtain housing, and
Results
From discussion with HHH we came to the conclusion that the best way to help them was
to create a website. To spread information in the past, HHH depended on word of mouth and
pamphlets which was inefficient and didnt provide enough information. We designed the
website to serve as a flexible advocacy platform that HHH can adjust to whatever direction that
group is going in at the time. The website is also supposed to serve as a way for people to get
connected with HHH to learn more information about the issue or seek help.
The website is divided into four sections: Home, Gallery, About and Contact. The home
page consists of basic information about HHH. This includes the Mission Statement, Our Creed,
and talking on why affordable housing matters. This page is dedicated to explaining the main
goals of HHH and understand what they are fighting for. Under the gallery tab there are pictures
of HHH in action and of Moores place, where they meet. This can be used by HHH to show
recent events in the community and create a visual connection with its viewers. The about tab is
15
divided into three pages: meet the people, meet the organization, and learn more about the issues.
The meet the people page is designed to be home of different interviews HHH can have of
current and formerly homeless. We currently have one interview on this page of Justin Markel.
We decided to add this page, so people will be able to understand that in many situations people
cant control that forces that make them homeless. Going forward we hope that HHH will use
this to give a voice to the voiceless and let their stories be told. The page titled meet the
organization discusses a brief history of HHH and speaks on the transition from focusing on
voting issues to more of a focus on affordable housing. This page will grow and change as HHH
does but will always be a reference point to show where HHH has been. The final page under the
about tab is learn more about the issue. We have decided to leave this page blank for now and
allow HHH to fill in the information they want to provide. Our thinking on this was that they will
be able to understand and express the issue better than we ever will. This will also allow HHH to
list different resources and ways to help the homeless that they think is best.
All the information for the website came from a variety of sources. The majority of
information was collected through Josh and Kyle attending an HHH meeting and an interview
conducted by Josh with Justin Markel. We were able to gather background history, goals, and
ways that HHH impacts the community. We complemented this information with ideas we
gathered from doing independent research about the homelessness epidemic. We also designed
the project and website to be continued by HHH or another Charlotte student group.
Discussion/Conclusions
As the literature sections above shows, affordable housing is lacking in North Carolina,
and government policies for the homeless often do not actually help the homeless. Much of the
data we collected showed this to be true. Individual testimonies made it clear that affordable
16
housing in Charlotte is a much-needed reality, despite the stigma that it has. Our action project
helps show how all of this is connected. For government policies to be changed regarding
homelessness, the homeless must have a louder voice. For the homeless to have a louder voice in
government, they must know about their right to vote. And for the homeless to know about their
right to vote, this information must be made more accessible. Our project was dedicated to this
goal. By making a website for HHH, we have given them a tool that will allow them to more
effectively penetrate the homeless population. Going forward, our hope is that they will continue
to modify this site, updating it to maintain accuracy. Internet availability is surprisingly high
among the homeless, meaning that this project can have an even further reach.
One of the greatest lessons learned during this research experience came from the mouths
of formerly homeless individuals. Listening to their stories, we heard about the hardships of
homelessness, including physical and psychological problems. One analogy from a member of
HHH made this point crystal clear. To describe her fight against homelessness, she compared
herself to a veteran who has fought in war. Their fight is full of pain, losses, and death, and yet
sometimes there is victory. Once the war is over, they physically return home, but in their mind,
they are still fighting for their life. This post-traumatic stress is present for every recovering
homeless individual, who has won their fight against homelessness and yet is still be fighting the
war in their mind. Learning to believe once again in the society that cast them out is an
Another big lesson learned is that ordinary people are susceptible to homelessness. While
much of the homeless population is comprised of those with substance abuse, some people just
find themselves in a situation where no work is available. As was the case with Justin, once they
enter homelessness, it becomes next to impossible to find work. Especially when the economy is
17
low, hardworking people find themselves left with nothing. This transforms the way that we
Another big lesson for us was learning how to work with volunteer organizations. Many
organizations, HHH included, are made up of people who sacrifice their time for what they
believe in. Sadly, this can also mean that organizations struggle with communication and
planning. For us, we had to learn how to patiently plan a project with an organization that
struggled with organization itself. Interestingly, this is actually quite ordinary, and it taught us a
valuable lesson. Being willing to wait for responses and change our plans helped us better
understand how the formerly homeless population operates. We are in no position to say that our
professionalism is the right way to operate. Instead, we have learned how to work alongside
others, even when the way that we think and work is very different.
There are two main things that must happen for homelessness to be eradicated in
Charlotte. First, the homeless population must know about their right to vote. Politics is not able
to solve every problem, but this is an important issue that has great potential. If the homeless are
heard in government, legislation can begin to change in their favor. Rather than being outcasts in
society, they can be equally heard in their communities and nation. Second, affordable housing
must be made more available. The first implication makes this second implication possible. As
previously stated, it costs roughly $39,000 per year in taxes to pay for a homeless individuals
expenses. With affordable housing, it costs only $13,985 per year to pay for their housing and
proactive medical services. From a simple economic perspective, this is a no brainer. There are
many barriers, such as Not In My Back Yard movements, and a potential danger of individuals
abusing the system, but neither of these barriers should prevent the creation of affordable
Works Cited
details/1219
http://charlotte.areaconnect.com/statistics.html
Charlotte, North Carolina. (2015). Retrieved October 11, 2017, from http://www.city-
data.com/city/Charlotte-North-Carolina.html
Charlotte, North Carolina (NC) income map, earnings map, and wages data. (2015). Retrieved October
FRED Economic Data. (2017). Per Capita Personal Income in Charlotte-Gastonia-Rock Hill, NC-SC
FY 2017 Income Limits Documentation System. (2017). Retrieved October 11, 2017, from
https://www.huduser.gov/portal/datasets/il/il2017/2017summary.odn
HOME Investment Partnerships Program. (2016). Retrieved October 11, 2017, from
https://www.hud.gov/program_offices/comm_planning/affordablehousing/programs/home/
https://www.mecknc.gov/CommunitySupportServices/HomelessServices/Pages/default.aspx
Krieg, G., & Mullery, W. (2017, May 23). Trump's budget by the numbers: What gets cut and why.
programs/index.html
Low Income Housing in Charlotte. (2016). Retrieved October 11, 2017, from
https://affordablehousingonline.com/housing-search/North-Carolina/Charlotte
Portillo, E. (2017, August 28). Charlotte has enough housing for moderate-income people. Low income?
http://www.charlotteobserver.com/news/business/biz-columns-
blogs/development/article169882122.html
2016 Point-in-Time Homeless Count Report Released. (2016). Retrieved October 11, 2017, from
https://www.mecknc.gov/news/Pages/2016-Point-in-Time-Homeless-Count-Report-
Released.aspx?redirect=charmeck
Strand. (2017). Origins and Principles of Community Based Research. Retrieved December 1, 2017.
Trulia. (2017). Real Estate Data for Charlotte. Retrieved from https://goo.gl/rj8NLc