Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
INVITED ARTICLE
Classification of vitiligo:
a challenging endeavor
Jana Hercogov*, Robert A. Schwartz & Torello M. Lotti
*Department of Dermatology and Venereology, 2nd Medical School, Charles
University of Prague, Prague Czech Republic, Dermatology and Pathology,
New Jersey Medical School, Newark, New Jersey, University of Rome
G. Marconi, Rome, Italy and Vitiligo Research Foundation, New York,
New York
ABSTRACT: The classification of vitiligo is mandatory for clinical and research purposes. Although the
etiology and pathobiology of vitiligo remain unknown, a working classification of vitiligo is imperative
for the scientific community to communicate. The authors delineate herein their efforts for vitiligo
classification utilizing clinical, genetic, pathobiological, epidemiological, and molecular characteristics
of vitiligo. These different classification approaches may aid clinicians to identify the most suitable
treatment for each individual vitiligo subject.
Presently, there is no unanimously agreed classifi- instigate an autoimmune response that then could
cation of vitiligo (1). This fact represents a major cause melanocytes destruction in areas more or
limit to the design of clinical trials for vitiligo and less distant from the site of initiation (13).
personalized treatment(s) (13). As the etiology and pathogenesis of vitiligo are
Vitiligo is a complex and multisystem disease still unknown or uncertain, and considering that
that causes a selective, often progressive, loss of several hypotheses, sometimes supported by
functioning melanocytes, leaving white patches on intriguing but not always proven data, are circu-
the skin and occasionally mucose. Hair may be lated in the scientific community, the question if
devoid of pigment. Internal organs containing vitiligo should be classified as a disease or a spec-
melanocytes may be affected. trum of disorders is central to its classification (1).
The etiology underlying vitiligo remains to be It has been suggested that, although the clinical
elucidated. The pathobiology of vitiligo is still picture of vitiligo is similar, the etiology and
enigmatic. According to well-known models, one pathogenetic mechanism could vary individual by
or more environmental, physiological, or other individual. This could bring to the suggestive
triggers might induce localized inactivation or hypothesis that classification of vitiligo is pres-
death of melanocytes and eventually sometimes ently an impossible mission. Basic research has not
yet been translated into clinical benefit for patients
with vitiligo, and molecular classification of viti-
Address correspondence and reprint requests to: Torello Lotti, ligo is still impossible. This latter concept inhibits
MD, Chair of Dermatology and Venereology, University of movement toward personalized medicine in viti-
Rome G. Marconi, Via Vittoria Colonna 11, 00193 Rome, Italy, ligo patients and highlights an imperative corol-
or email: professor@torellolotti.it. lary: we must draft the classification of vitiligo.
S10
Vitiligo classification
Working classification of vitiligo More simply, vitiligo can be divided into three
types (2): localized, generalized, and universal
The scientific community is aware that there is no (when vitiligo involves more than 80% of the skin
reliable classification of vitiligo. Vitiligo profiling surface) (2,3).
is mandatory for designing clinical trials with
possible meta-analysis outcomes. The not-yet-
Practical implication of the working clinical classi-
universally agreed upon treatment of vitiligo
fication. The localized forms typically begin in
patients will improve according to a more precise
childhood. Among those, the most common is the
vitiligo profiling.
form affecting the trigeminal dermatome. It tends
These concepts have prompted the present
to be stable or regressive (4,5) and accompanied by
authors to enumerate their working classification
poliosis. Associated systemic autoimmune disor-
of vitiligo, hoping that it will be widely adopted by
ders are unusual. This has a relevant impact on the
the international scientific community until a
follow-up and on the treatment of the affected
consistent genetic etiologic, pathobiological, or
subjects.
molecular classification of vitiligo becomes avail-
The generalized vitiligo may begin later on in
able for the patients benefit.
life, in both sexes, at sites sensitive to confrication,
trauma, or pressure. This form is typically progres-
Working sections of classification sive, with flares that may involve hair in the later
stages.
of vitiligo Autoimmune disorders are often associated with
The present authors propose the following this form both in the affected subjects and in the
classifications: family members, stressing the concept of a consis-
1. Clinical classification of vitiligo tent follow-up and need of systemic treatments for
2. Genetic classification of vitiligo those subjects (6).
3. Pathobiological classification of vitiligo Universal vitiligo is often associated with mul-
4. Epidemiological classification of vitiligo tiple comorbidities both in the affected subjects
5. Multisystem organ dysfunction-based classifi- and in the family members. Melanocytes can be
cation of vitiligo affected in the inner ear and in the eye, requiring a
6. Trigger-based classification of vitiligo and other multidisciplinary diagnostic approach and follow-
leukodermas up of these patients (1).
7. Molecular classification of vitiligo
S11
Hercogov et al.
Human leukocyte antigen (HLA) haplotypes: expressed on the cell surface, against intracellular
1. Different ethnicities have different HLA- pigment, and even against nonpigment cell anti-
associated susceptibility gens (common tissue antigens) (15).
2. Particular HLA haplotypes are strongly asso- There is evidence of direct correlation between
ciated in patients (and in their family levels of some of these antibodies and disease
members) with vitiligo and autoimmune activity (16,17).
disorders (10) Cellular immunity is present in vitiligo in
3. Susceptibility loci similar to HLA, i.e., the selected groups of subjects. Melan-A-specific
CTLA4 (cytotoxic T lymphocyte antigen 4) CD8+T cells are highly represented in the blood of
could identify the cases in which vitiligo the vitiligo patients. Their number correlates with
is regularly associated with concomitant disease extent.
autoimmune diseases (11)
4. Similarly single nucleotide polymorphisms Neurohumoral hypothesis. Increased levels of neu-
(PTPN22, mannose-binding lectin, NALP-1 ropeptide Y have been shown intralesionally and
(12)) seem epidemiologically significantly perilesionally in vitiligo skin (18). Vitiligo patients
linked to autoimmune diseases like lupus with progressive disease have increased urine levels
erythematosus, Addisons disease, autoim- of homovanillic acid and vanillylmandelic acid (19).
mune thyroiditis, autoimmune gastritis, and
pernicious anemia (11,13) Autocytotoxic hypothesis. A defect in the melanin
Genome-wide association studies are presently receptor may result in concomitant increase in
being carried out by two main groups: one led by melanin synthesis, leading to cellular death or apo-
Xuejun Zhang in China and another headed by ptosis (20).
Richard Spritz (14) in the United States. Clinical implications: possible identification of
These studies have clarified the fact that differ- vitiligo subjects with cell receptor alterations.
ent populations may have varied susceptibility for
vitiligo, that different roles are played by genes Biochemical hypothesis. In some cases of vitiligo,
involved in vitiligo susceptibility versus vitiligo age melanocytes could autonomously undergo death
of onset, and that HLA haplotypes and similar sus- or apoptosis because of intracellular accumulation
ceptibility loci may account for a weak or strong of (6R) and (7R)-L-erythro-5,6,7,8-tetrahydro-
association with autoimmune disorders in the viti- biopterin (6BH4 and 7BH4).
ligo patient and in her or his family members. These substances could inhibit melanocyte phe-
nylalanine hydroxylase, the enzyme that converts
Practical implication of the working genetic classi- dietary phenylalanine to tyrosine, and the levels
fication of vitiligo. The evaluation of these studies of hydrogen peroxide-inducing cell damage or
will identify the genetic differences in the different apoptosis (20,21).
populations regarding susceptibility for vitiligo Clinical implications: if proved, this should
and age of onset. These studies will delineate bring to targeted biochemical treatments.
the vitiligo patient subgroups that are prone to
develop selected comorbidities, mainly autoim- Oxidative stress hypothesis. High hydrogen perox-
mune disorders. ide levels in vitiligo epidermis have been reported.
Hopefully, these studies will, in the future, This could be the consequence of:
indicate to the clinician which follow-up is 1. Single nucleotide polymorphism in the catalase
required for the different vitiligo subjects and gene (22)
which systemic and/or topical approaches may 2. Increased levels of 6BH4 and 7BH4 (23)
be beneficial in the single case. Personalized treat- 3. Reduced glutathione peroxidase activity (24)
ments will follow. 4. Increase in norepinephrine levels (25)
5. Defective calcium uptake (20)
Clinical implications: high levels of H2O2 corre-
Pathobiological classification of vitiligo
late with low levels of the catalase enzyme. Thus,
Presently, several hypotheses are considered as at adequate supplementation of cutaneous and sys-
least partially documented in vitiligo. temic catalase enzyme could treat or possibly cure
vitiligo.
Autoimmune hypothesis. Auto-antibodies in the
sera of some vitiligo subjects have been shown. Melanocytorrhagy hypothesis. Melanocytes are not
They are directed against melanocyte antigens anchored to keratinocytes by desmosomes. They
S12
Vitiligo classification
are mainly attached to the extracellular matrix vitiligo mainly based on psychological and envi-
molecule fibronectin. High levels of tenascin are ronmental factors, with obvious impact on the
present in the vitiligo epidermis, facilitating a loss potential treatments.
of melanocytes (26,27).
Clinical implications: according to this hypoth-
Multisystem organ dysfunction-based
esis, a continuous Koebner phenomenon could
classification of vitiligo
represent the cause of vitiligo, and therapies
should focus on anchoring melanocytes properly Many disorders and syndromes are variably asso-
in the epidermis. ciated with vitiligo. Selected vitiligo subjects can be
affected by multisystem organ dysfunction, the
Decreased melanocyte lifespan hypothesis. vitiligo systemic syndromes. Most of those cases
Several cytokines, such as interleukin-1 and are discovered at birth or during infancy.
interferon-gamma, mainly produced and released
by keratinocytes, may induce apoptosis of melano- Disorders and syndromes possibly associated with
cytes because of a deficiency in survival signals vitiligo (in alphabetical order)
by interfering with the melanocyte membrane Less common associations:
tyrosine kinase receptor C-KIT (28). Reduced levels Acrokeratosis paraneoplastica of Bazex
of C-KIT receptors in vitiligo melanocytes or of Alezzandrini syndrome
growth factors could induce premature apoptosis APECED* syndrome
and decreased melanocytes survival. (*Autoimmune polyendocrinopathy candidiasis
Clinical implications: inactivating exceedingly ectodermal dysplasia)
apoptotic cytokines in the vitiligo skin and/or nor- Asthma
malizing the C-KIT melanocytes receptors may Ataxia-telangiectasia
prove beneficial. Deafness
DOPA-responsive dystonia
Overview Dysgammaglobulinemia
Hemolytic anemia (autoimmune)
All the previously mentioned hypotheses have
Hepatitis C
produced theories that could explain the onset
HIV
of vitiligo. Unfortunately, all vitiligo subjects are
Inflammatory bowel disease
included in one or more of the previously men-
Kabuki syndrome
tioned data and theories.
Kaposi sarcoma
Accordingly, vitiligo could instead represent a
More common associations:
spectrum of many different disorders with different
Addisons disease
etiologies and pathogeneses manifesting as a
Alopecia areata
common phenotype: the loss of melanocytes
Atopic dermatitis
and/or their products.
Autoimmune thyroid disease
Chronic urticaria
Epidemiological classification of vitiligo
Diabetes mellitus
The prevalence of vitiligo in the general population Halo nevi
ranges from 0.3 to 8.8 cases per 100 in different Hypoacusis
regions of the world. Genetic studies are non- Hypoparathyroidism
contributory (1,7,8). Ichthyosis
According to analytical epidemiology studies, Lymphoma
associating HLA antigens with vitiligo in the differ- Melanoma
ent ethnic groups is not explanatory; thus, assess- Mitochondrial myopathy, encephalopathy, lactic
ing the potential role of unknown environmental acidosis, and stroke (MELAS) syndrome
factors in the development of vitiligo may be Morphea
valuable. Multiple sclerosis
Clinical epidemiology also confirms patients Myasthenia gravis
quality of life and life stress events may contribute Non-melanoma skin cancer
to explain the onset and long-term outcome of Nail dystrophy
vitiligo. Ocular abnormalities
Clinical implications: epidemiological research Pemphigus vulgaris
may contribute to a working classification of Pernicious anemia
S13
Hercogov et al.
S14
Vitiligo classification
S15
Hercogov et al.
16. Cu J, Arita Y, Bystryn JC. Cytolytic antibodies to melanocytes 24. Beazley WD, Gaze D, Panske A, Panzig E, Schallreuter KU.
in vitiligo. J Invest Dermatol 1993: 100: 812815. Serum selenium levels and blood glutathione peroxidase
17. Norris DA, Kissinger RM, Naughton GM, Bystryn JC. activities in vitiligo. Br J Dermatol 1999: 141: 301303.
Evidence for immunologic mechanisms in human 25. Badri AM, Todd PM, Garioch JJ, Gudgeon JE, Stewart DG,
vitiligo: patients sera induce damage to human melano- Goudie RB. An immunohistological study of cutaneous
cytes in vitro by complement-mediated damage and lymphocytes in vitiligo. J Pathol 1993: 170: 149155.
antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity. J Invest Dermatol 26. Gauthier Y, Cario-Andre M, Lepreux S, Pain C, Taieb A. Mel-
1988: 90: 783789. anocyte detachment after skin friction in non lesional skin
18. AlAbadie MS, Senior HJ, Bleehen SS, Gawkrodger DJ. Neu- of patients with generalized vitiligo. Br J Dermatol 2003:
ropeptide and neuronal marker studies in vitiligo. Br J Der- 148: 95101.
matol 1994: 131: 160165. 27. Le Poole IC, van den Wijngaard RM, Westerhof W, Das PK.
19. Morrone A, Picardo M, de Luca C, Terminali O, Passi S, Tenascin is overexpressed in vitiligo lesional skin and
Ippolito F. Catecholamines and vitiligo. Pigment Cell Res inhibits melanocytes adhesion. Br J Dermatol 1997: 137:
1992: 5: 6569. 171178.
20. Schallreuter KU, Wood JM, Pittelkow MR, et al. Regulation 28. Kitamura R, Tsukamoto K, Harada K, et al. Mechanisms
of melanin biosynthesis in the human epidermis by tetrahy- underlying the dysfunction of melanocytes in vitiligo
drobiopterin. Science 1994: 263: 14441446. epidermis: role of SCF/KIT protein interaction and the
21. Schallreuter KU, Buttner G, Pittelkow MR, Wood JM, downstream effector, MITF-M. J Pathol 2004: 202: 463
Swanson NN, Korner C. Cytotoxicity of 6-biopterin to 475.
human melanocytes. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 1994: 29. Alikhan A, Felsten LM, Daly M, Petronic-Rosic V. Vitiligo: a
204: 4348. comprehensive overview Part I. Introduction, epidemiol-
22. Schallreuter KU, Moore J, Wood JM, et al. In vivo and in vitro ogy, quality of life, diagnosis, differential diagnosis, associa-
evidence for hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) accumulation in tions, histopathology, etiology, and work-up. J Am Acad
the epidermis of patients with vitiligo and its successful Dermatol 2011: 65: 473491.
removal by a UVB-activated pseudocatalase. J Investig Der- 30. Hann SK, Kim YS, Yoo JH, Chun YS. Clinical and histopatho-
matol Symp Proc 1999: 4: 9196. logic characteristics of trichrome vitiligo. J Am Acad Derma-
23. Schallreuter KU, Wood JM, Ziegler I, et al. Defective tetrahy- tol 2004: 42: 589596.
drobiopterin and catecholamine biosynthesis in the depig- 31. Ortonne JP. Vitiligo and other disorders of hypopigmenta-
mentation disorder vitiligo. Biochim Biophys Acta 1994: tion. In: Bolognia J, Jorizzo J, Rapini R, eds. Dermatology.
1226: 181192. Philadelphia: Mosby Elsevier, 2008: 928.
S16