Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
GUIDE
Karina Kreja, Associate Director, CBRE:
After two decades of dynamic development the Polish retail market is now mature. Despite increasing competition it still offers considerable
development potential, albeit far more selective than in the past. We address the following publication to both seasoned and future retail
developers to support them in their retail investment plans. It is essential to understand that shopping center planning is a complex process that
requires in-depth knowledge of both consumer and competitive market.
the market with the right type of product. Already market saturation
is high in a number of medium-sized Polish cities such as Opole, 2000
The retail developers list is continuously being extended with many Source: GUS, CBRE, 2013
new players, often being established companies from the residential
sector or experienced main contractors, who are now trying their
Retail formats evolution in Poland
chances in the retail sector. But the times of the build and they will
in 000 sq m of GLA
come approach are now over, as both tenants and investors are
increasingly selective. The market is ever stronger in discriminating 12000
have seen their centres suffering, when built without sufficient market 8000
intelligence. It is essential for a shopping centres long-term success 6000
that a thorough and comprehensive assessment of its potential is
4000
undertaken.
2000
0
1993
1995
1997
1999
2001
2003
2005
2007
2009
2011
2013*
Source: CBRE
STARTING WITH THE
LOCATION
LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION
Location determines success! There is a suitable location for every use
and it is a precondition for any successful business. While seashore
rocks represent a stable and weatherproof location for a lighthouse, the
optimal location for a shopping centre is characterized by high ranking
accessibility, visibility and parking spaces. Even though these aspects
are relatively easy to measure, a great number of shopping centre
developments suffer compromises when the location is considered.
Seemingly irrelevant and justified by economizing on the often limited
resources, these compromises are sometimes fatal, particularly once a
competitor comes into play, who has respected all of the success factors.
In other words, too many compromises relating to the location make a
shopping centre vulnerable to better located competition.
Types of Catchment Areas
CATCHMENT AREA DELIMITATION
Sufficient knowledge about the catchment area is the basis for every 5 km
successful investment decision when it comes to shopping centre
development. The catchment area defines the market capacity of a 3 km
retail project and provides crucial information on demographics and
purchasing power.
catchment
1 600
As shown on the map above, a 20 minute drive-time zone of a 1 400
fictional small scale project at Stadion Narodowy covers large parts of 1 200
the city of Warsaw. Yet, its actual catchment area is much smaller as
1 000
several large scale competitors limit the potential reach of the fictional
800
shopping centre, especially in respect of areas east of the Vistula
River. Consequently, the actual catchment area comprises of about 600
600,000 inhabitants, while the 20 minute drive-time zone includes a 400
population of about 1.5 million people. To conclude, drive-time zones 200
are an important tool for estimations, but cannot replace the catchment 0
area method. Even though delimiting a real catchment area can be
primary catchment
secondary catchment
10 minutes zone
20 minutes zone
total catchment
total drive time zones
cumbersome and time-consuming, it represents the model which gets the
closest to reality.
Krakow
Wroclaw
Poland Average
project P1
project P2
analysed project X
center 2
100
80
60
40
20
Source: RegioPlan Consulting
0
Assuming X to be the analysed project, the assessment shows a relatively
project P1
project P2
analysed project X
center 2
best location in town, but currently a rather outdated and unattractive Other Tenants Layout and Interior
concept. From a strategic point of view, this centre could be refurbished Source: RegioPlan Consulting
in the future.and cou
ld thus become a potential major threat. Productivity in /sqm, min/max/average
DIMENSIONING OF THE PROJECT
Once the catchment area and the competitive situation are determined,
9 000
the next step is a simulation of the purchasing power flows. These flows
are represented by achievable market shares, which lead to the turnover 7 500
expectation for each retail sector. Finally, the turnover potential can be
6 000
transformed into a GLA potential by applying the average productivity
in EUR/sq m by retail sector or even by tenant. In other words, this 4 500
provides the answer to the question: Which GLA can be realised per 3 000
retail sector to achieve at least an average productivity per sq m? The
result generated reflects both the optimal total size and the optimal 1 500
merchandise mix. 0
drugstore/perfumery
sports
electronics
clothing
food
BUILDING A NARRATIVE
A shopping centre, unless it is a neighbourhood scheme, needs to
differentiate clearly from its immediate competitors. In an ever more 16%
21%
competitive retail environment shopping centres are increasingly
required to build their own identity based on location and brand. 2%
Therefore a consistent, strong narrative is needed in order to appeal 8%
to both tenants and customers. It is impossible to target everyone and 13%
clear choices need to be made. For example, a retail gallery could
be budget and family lifestyle oriented, target top market slice, or
combine some characteristics, but can never be all at once. Lack of a
clear shopping centre brand results in client confusion, which is always 40%
a drawback.
Key shopping centre profiles that currently dominate the Polish retail Ist generation shopping centres
landscape are: 1st generation hypermarket-anchored with a service 2nd generation shopping centres
gallery, 2nd generation scheme anchored with a hypermarket and 3rd generation shopping centres
mid-market fashion gallery, as well as 3rd generation retail gallery DYI/retail warehousing
with a sizeable leisure component. However, the spectrum of Outlets
available formats is much wider and many other concepts, including Retail parks
hybrids, or specialized and theme-oriented schemes, are feasible
Source: CBRE
if catchment and competition analysis indicate numerous available
market niches.
TENANT MIX SOLUTIONS Key Anchores
3%
between in-line tenants remain considerable. For example, 3%
3%
5%
5%
often similarly sized tenants coming from different market 33%
33%
5%
5%
segments can pay considerably different rental levels as their
6%
profit margins and sales profiles vary. 6%
6%
6%
tenant mix and a scheme layout are based on their merchandise and 11%
11%
Other Anchores
Other Anchores
Examples of
Category
tenants
CinemaCity
Cinema Mulitkino,
Helios, Imax
Independent
Bowling
tenants
Children Fantasy Park,
playgrounds Kidsplay,
Kinder Planet
McDonalds,
Foodcourt KFC,
Burger King,
NorthFish
Pure,
Fitness Gymnasion,
Fitness Academy
Source: CBRE
DESIGNING THE BEST Top 10 tenants in Polish shopping centres
Inmedio Multimedia 81
FROM TENANT MIX TO LAYOUT
CCC Shoes 73
A preliminary layout can be put in place once the first tenant mix has
been completed, after all key occupiers have been identified and their Triumph Fashion 61
size, as well as their position in the scheme, has been initially assigned. Inmedio
However, both tenant mix and layout creation are fine-tuning processes Apart Accessories 59
that are closely interlinked and typically are considered together through
a number of layout versions. Depending on the projects complexity, Deichmann Shoes 52
the tenant mix (re)drafting process takes from several to dozens of
Vision Express Health & Beauty 52
re-iterations between leasing and design teams. The most successful
project achieves a relative balance in customer traffic levels across a 5Sec Services 50
scheme, be-tween entrances, anchors and tenants clusters (such as a
food court or boutique fashion cluster), providing equally good retail Orsay Fashion 49
conditions for every unit in the scheme.
Reserved Fashion 48
The preliminary layout includes all key features of a given location, such
as access points to the site, a building location on a given plot, various Euro RTV AGD Electronics 47
entry points to the site and buildings, delivery zones, car parking,
Source: RRF, CBRE
as well as other key determinants such as shopping mall (horizontal Source: RRF, CBRE
and vertical) traffic. At this stage a specialised software package,
for example based on Space Syntax theory, can be used to simulate
traffic flows, but more often the expertise of both leasing agents and Examples of layout solutions
the management team is employed in order to anticipate levels of
customers activity in various parts of a centre. Fashion
Shoes
The anchor and other key tenants views are important in the layout Grocery
fine-tuning process, whereas the majority of in-line tenants, who join the Home Appliances
project later, have considerably less say with regards to their position
Media
and unit shape. Preferably, they are grouped in clusters to create the
equivalent of an anchor in terms of a traffic flow. However, such key Children
features as unit size and proportion, visibility, frontage and signage, as Restaurants & Bars
well as lighting and air-conditioning, must be provided in accordance Accessories
with market standards.
Health & Beauty
Services
Other
Foodcourt
Preliminary layout Final layout
VALUE ADD
INVESTMENT
REFURBISHMENT OPPORTUNITIES AND Retail stock growth
in million sq m of GLA
PITFALLS
Refurbishment and revitalization of shopping centres will be gaining in 3,0
importance in the next few years. Not only does this apply to shopping
centres of the first generation, but also to hypermarkets, which have
2,0
been growing rapidly in number between 1996 and 2005. Since 2005,
however, the expansion of this format has experienced a substantial
slowdown, which is a consequence of the high hypermarket density and 1,0
-1997
1998-2002
2003-2007
2008-2012
2013-2017
developers.
At present, the leasable area of shopping centres, retail parks and Hypermarket
hypermarkets opened until 2002 amounts to about 4.1 million sq m. Retail Park
Even though some of these investments have already been revitalized, Shopping Center
the Polish retail real estate market offers tremendous opportunities Source: RegioPlan Consulting
for successful refurbishments. Possibilities for extension need to be
examined at each site in advance, and should form the part of a
comprehensive assessment of the property and location. Compromises
in layout, tenant mix, or architectural design represent risk factors and
need to be avoided by all means.
Current retail stock by age
Despite the high value-add potential of refurbishments, such in million sq m of GLA
investments are very complex and often involve greater risks than new
developments. Developers of green field projects can be largely flexible Under Construction
in designing access roads, ensuring visibility and sufficient advertising (2013 - )
area, as well as in determining the centre layout and position of anchor
tenants. Refurbishments on the other hand considerably narrow these
New additions
elements of flexibility. (2008 - 2012)
Architects may also face structural limitations, whereas the leasing and
marketing teams might in some cases have a tough time dealing with Maturing schemes
(2003 - 2007)
the established negative image of a given retail destination. Moreover,
non-cancellable, long-term lease agreements may seem favorable
from an economic and legal perspective, but for the restructuring of the Mature stock
tenant mix such agreements can become problematic. (1998 - 2002)
Location
o Does the site have an intact image as a retail destination?
o Do you have full control of the land required for the retail
facility, including accesses and parking spaces?
o Does the location offers sufficient space to achieve the
adequate size necessary for the intended market positioning?
Building
o Does the existing building offer the structural (especially in
terms of statics, storey height, vertical connections, sightlines,
mall width, etc) and technical (IT, home automation, etc.)
conditions necessary for creating a modern shopping
environment?
o Given the existing building structure, is it possible to implement
a compromise-free solution for access roads, parking spaces,
optical image and visibility of the building and the advertising
space?
Competitiveness
o Given competitors performance, is it possible to achieve the
targeted market positioning or strengthen the existing one?
o Can, even in a tougher competitive situation, a sufficiently high
productivity and rental income be achieved?
o Are you ahead of competitors with your concept or are others
already filling that market gap?
Tenants
o Does the centre have a critical mass of existing tenants who are
suitable for the new market positioning of the project and who
should remain in the centre?
o Can you attract at least one of the top three out of the five
leading tenants in the most relevant retail sectors for the
targeted positioning?
o Is there a time window of concurrent lease contract expiries,
which is favorable for the realization of the refurbishment?
Strategic issues
o Does your intended concept meet the expectable demands of
real estate investors?
o Do you have a clear exit strategy?
o Is your financing structured accordingly?
MARKET PRACTICE KEY SHOPPING CENTRE
FORMATS
LEASE LENGTH AND TERMS Typical lease contract period is 5 to TRADITIONAL SHOPPING CENTRE a scheme that is planned, built
10 years with an option to extend. Most rents are denominated in Euro and and managed as a single entity, comprising of units and common areas, with a
paid in zlotys, but service charges and other payments (e.g. marketing fees) minimum Gross Leasable Area (GLA) of 5,000 sq m and at least 10 shops and
are often denominated in the local currency. Only the oldest leases can still be services.
denominated in dollars. Rents are typically the subject to annual indexation by the
European (Eurostat) price index. 1ST GENERATION Hypermarket driven (accounting for 40-50% of the
total GLA) scheme together with a small, service-oriented accompanying gallery.
RENTAL PAYMENTS Rent is payable monthly in advance, and is quoted
without VAT. 2ND GENERATION A shopping centre driven by a retail, typically fashion
gal-lery, that represents over 70% of the total centre space.
SERVICE CHARGES Service charge payments cover ordinary building
maintenance costs such as repairs, cleaning and security. Denominated in zlotys, 3RD GENERATION A lifestyle scheme enhanced with and often driven by
they typically reach between 25 50 PLN /sq m/month. a leisure element, such as a multiplex cinema, fitness element, or increasingly a
food court offer.
MARKETING COSTS Additional regular payments covering shopping
centre management expenses on advertising and events. Denominated in zlotys, SPECIALISED SCHEMES:
typical mar-keting payments vary between 5 20 PLN /sq m /month.
RETAIL PARK Consistently designed, planned and centrally managed scheme
TENANTS COVENANT Covenant strength is very important within the that comprises of mainly medium - and large-scale specialist retailers (big box
Polish market. Rental deposit, bank or parent companys guarantee equivalent or retail warehouses).
to 3-6 months rent, service charge, marketing costs and VAT is expected from all
tenants. FACTORY OUTLET Shopping centre scheme where manufacturers and
retailers sell merchandise at discount prices that may be surplus stock, prior-
INCENTIVES Incentives include capital contributions towards shop fitting and season or slow selling items.
rent-free periods, individually negotiated between the parties. Anchor tenants can
expect a fit-out contribution. THEME-ORIENTED - A consistently designed, planned and managed
scheme that can either be leisure-based or non-leisure-based. This scheme
includes some retail units and typically concentrates on a narrow but deep
selection of merchandise within a specific retail category, such as home furniture
KEY TERMS or hobbies.
OTHER FORMATS:
MARKET TRANSPARENCY the property market has strong and
NEIGHBOURHOOD CENTRE often small or very small (below 5,000
transparent fundamentals regarding property titles but a degree of opacity persists
sq m of GLA) scheme that serves almost exclusively its immediate catchment and
with regards to the availability of market information. The information on historical
concentrates on a FMCG offer complemented with services or value fashion
freehold and perpetual usufruct transactions registered as Notarial Deeds is freely
merchandise. Typically anchored by a supermarket grocery store (below 4,000 sq
accessible to the listed property valuers, but there is no public record on lease
m of GLA).
transactions.
RETAIL SPACE GLA gross leasable area in sq m refers to the area leased to
tenants and includes all other construction elements.
LAYOUT A shopping centres layout is the design in which the interior is set up.
It is important to provide good shop window exposure, a good width of the malls
and clear communication.
CONTACTS
For more information regarding CBRE and RegioPlan Consulting reports or any other CBRE and
RegioPlan Consulting services please contact
karina.kreja@cbre.com n.mumdziev@regioplan.at
http://www.cbre.pl http://www.regioplan.eu
joanna.mroczek@cbre.com h.bomba@regioplan.at
http://www.cbre.pl http://www.regioplan.eu
Disclaimer
CBRE Sp. z o.o confirms that information contained herein, including projections, has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. While we do not doubt
their accuracy, we have not verified them and make no guarantee, warranty or representation about them. It is your responsibility to confirm independently their
accuracy and completeness. This information is presented exclusively for use by CBRE clients and professionals and all rights to the material are reserved and
cannot be reproduced without prior written permission of CBRE.
RegioPlan Consulting GmbH confirms that information contained herein, including projections, has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable. However,
not all data has been verified and we make no guarantee, warranty or representation about them. Anyone who uses the data should independently verify their
accuracy and completeness. This information is presented exclusively for use by RegioPlan clients and professionals and all rights to the material are reserved and
cannot be reproduced without prior written permission of RegioPlan Consulting.