467 views

Original Title: CBBC or Turbos - Pricing and Risk

Uploaded by Jasvinder Josen

- 12 Investment Under Uncertainty 2
- Sas Mysql Matlab
- Testing Geometric Brownian Motion
- Shah1997_bms.pdf
- BOFa
- consistentfxsmile
- Don M. Chance_Derivatives & Risk
- Derivatives Performance Attribution
- Hedging
- Derivative Market Dealer Module Practice Book Sample
- markets98_smfm_appl.pdf
- Evolution of Market Uncertainty Around Earnings
- Project Overview
- CAPITALSTARS INVESTMENT ADVISORS
- 12
- Proctor and Gamble
- Hippo
- MOCB Finalest
- An Accurate Solution for Credit Value Adjustment (CVA) and Wrong Way Risk
- High Return Market Strategies

You are on page 1of 5

21, 2010

By Jasvin Josen

In the last two parts of this series, I explained how Callable Bull and Bear Certificates (CBBCs) evolved

from barrier options and its key features with some examples. This final article will discuss important

pricing and risk factors that investors must know when trading CBBCs.

From the previous article, we found that the theoretical price of CBBCs seems to just comprise its

intrinsic value and funding costs. Investors ought to note that this theoretical price is only applicable

when the product is called or settled at expiry. As the CBBC floats in the market, the trading price

quoted by market makers is not necessarily its theoretical price, but more likely a price backed by a

model.

As there is no information put forth by Bursa or CIMB (currently the single issuer of CBBCs in

Malaysia), my thoughts are based on experiences in other countries, mainly Hong Kong and Europe.

Issuers world-wide mostly use some variant of the Black Scholes model to price CBBCs. We were

briefly introduced to the Black Scholes model in my previous article, “Pricing and Risks of Structured

Warrants ”, Nov 16-22, 2009. This model has become the market standard to price options since

1970s. The basic model to price standard options can be modified in many ways to accommodate

the pricing of exotic options, one of which is the CBBC.

Here, we construct a portfolio of plain vanilla options (meaning standard options) to represent the

CBBC. Very briefly, if we need to value a callable bear (essentially a down-and-out put option) with

strike price ‘X’ and call price (barrier) B, we can construct a portfolio with a long position (buy) of an

ordinary put option with strike X and a short position (sell) of some ordinary put positions with strike

‘B’ along the tenor of the option. The calls and puts are constructed in such a way so that the

portfolio’s payout value is (X-B) at the points where the callable bear knocks-out.

In 2005, J. Eriksson derived the closed form solution for “turbo warrants” (the famous name for

CBBCs in many countries). The solution is based on the two main possible outcomes for the CBBC’s

payoff:

a) The stock price hits the barrier before expiration and is extinguished.

b) The underlying stock price does not hit the barrier. In this case, the callable bear has the

same value as an ordinary put option.

Chart 1: Random walk for a down and out call. Walk (a) results in a knock out; walk (b)

does not. [B=barrier; E=strike]

Source: Static Options Replication, Quantitative Strategies Research notes, Goldman Sachs, May 1994

Like structured warrants, investor must appreciate the key parameters of the model that affects the

CBBC’s price:

As the CBBC’s intrinsic value is the major component of the CBBC’s price, the underlying

share price movement is major driver of the CBBC price.

Finance cost can be considered as interest paid by investors to issuers for borrowing money

for investment. Therefore the longer the investment period (i.e. the maturity of the CBBC),

the higher the interest and CBBC price.

In the last article, we learnt that the price of a CBBC is expected to move in tandem with the

underlying share, thus making it less volatile (except when the share is closing close to its

barrier). A very important finding by Eriksson was that with the Black Scholes model, the

CBBC is less sensitive to the change in volatility when compared to vanilla options. This is

how the product became popular and marketable for investors. The CBBC is cheaper than

standard warrants, yet less volatile.

In 2006, the Chinese University of Hong Kong was of the view that CBBCs only

seemed less sensitive to underlying share volatility due to the Black-Scholes

dynamics where volatility is constant. In the real world, volatility or uncertainty in

the market is never constant over time.

In 2006, Hoi Ying Wong and Chun Man Chan, in their paper “Turbo Warrants under

Stochastic Volatility”, studied these callable bulls and bears using stochastic (i.e.

inconstant or random) volatility models which used volatility that changes over time.

They found that CBBCs can be very sensitive to volatility in the underlying shares.

Investors must note then, that the statement “CBBC is not sensitive to underlying

share volatility” is actually model-dependent.

The Black Scholes model also assumes that the underlying asset only moves in small

continuous random movements called the “Brownian motion”. However, in reality,

share prices do jump considerably especially in volatile periods. In another paper in

2006, “Analytical Valuation of TurboWarrants under Double Exponential Jump

Diffusion” Hoi Ying Wong and Ka Yung Lau found that the “turbo warrants” are less

sensitive to the jump parameters than vanilla options, but the sensitivity cannot be

ignored. They conclude that jump risk in asset price materially affects the value of a

turbo warrant.

Investors need to beware that the apparent “price transparency” hinges on the above key

assumptions of the Black Scholes model which is not true at all times. These unrealistic

assumptions can lead to a greater risk of knock-out than allowed for in the Black–Scholes price.

In actual fact, it is the behaviour of traders and investors that causes the shares to have

stochastic volatility and jumps. This behaviour directly affects the supply and demand of CBBCs,

which causes the price of CBBCs to move away from their theoretical pricing and the Black

Scholes model.

guide to manage this problem. In general, investors can measure market demand and supply by

observing the outstanding quantity of the CBBC. Outstanding quantity refers to the amount of

CBBC that investors hold overnight. The larger the outstanding quantity, the more the CBBC will

be affected by market force. In general, when the outstanding quantity exceeds 50%, the CBBC

price will be relatively more prone to be affected by market forces and deviate from theoretical

price.

Risks in trading CBBCs is explained in Bursa’s and other stock exchanges’ websites. Some of the most

crucial risk is discussed below:

Trading the CBBC close to the barrier can be very unsettling for the investor. In general, the

larger the buffer between the call price and the spot price of the underlying assets, the lower

the probability of the CBBC being called. However, the larger the buffer, the lower the leverage

effect (or the conversion ratio).

Liquidity

Liquidity is said to be one of the major factors influencing CBBC price. Since the delta of

CBBCs are close to 1, issuers apparently tend to hedge their exposures by buying / selling the

underlying shares with a 1:1 ratio (after considering the conversion ratio), thereby creating a

huge demand for the underlying shares. If there is insufficient liquidity in the underlying

shares, the hedging cost and finance cost for issuers will increase dramatically, resulting in a

wider bid/ask spread of CBBC.

Although CBBCs have liquidity providers, there is no guarantee that investors will be able to

buy/sell the CBBCs at their target prices any time they wish. The Bursa warns that although

market makers are committed to providing liquidity, there will be circumstances where

market makers are exempt from their obligations and these are stated in the issuer’s

prospectus.

However, as more issuers come into the Malaysian market, investors can compare Issuers’

ethic, i.e. whether issuers will quote the CBBC price and bid/ask spread and provide

sufficient liquidity in a reasonable manner under different circumstances of underlying share

price movement and liquidity.

While investors of structured warrants prefer high volatility stocks because it increases the

probability of the warrants being in-the-money, this is not the case for CBBCs. High volatility

of underlying shares increases the probability of the share price touching the barrier and

triggering a Mandatory Call Event. Therefore, investors should be watchful when trading

CBBCs in a high volatility environment.

Conclusion

It is quite obvious now that although the CBBC appears to be cheaper and more transparent than

normal warrants, they are in fact, rather complex. Investors may see their investment suddenly lost

if the product is terminated upon the call event. The investor will also be tempted to use the CBBC as

an alternative to buying the underlying share since the CBBC is claimed to closely track the

underlying share. However he should not take this assertion for granted due to the pricing

peculiarities around the CBBC. As all free lunches, there is always a price to be paid.

- 12 Investment Under Uncertainty 2Uploaded byjnfz
- Sas Mysql MatlabUploaded bykevinlan
- Testing Geometric Brownian MotionUploaded byOana Roxana Dumitru
- Shah1997_bms.pdfUploaded byJames Wycherley
- BOFaUploaded byRamchundar Karuna
- consistentfxsmileUploaded bybnsqtrading
- Don M. Chance_Derivatives & RiskUploaded byOat Kopkun
- Derivatives Performance AttributionUploaded bytachyon007_mech
- HedgingUploaded byRachit Munjal
- Derivative Market Dealer Module Practice Book SampleUploaded bymanirifm
- markets98_smfm_appl.pdfUploaded byLester Ingber
- Evolution of Market Uncertainty Around EarningsUploaded byteikkheong
- Project OverviewUploaded bySonu Joiya
- CAPITALSTARS INVESTMENT ADVISORSUploaded bysuhanisahani
- 12Uploaded byHarsh Mehta
- Proctor and GambleUploaded byGutsy Lim
- HippoUploaded byAndre
- MOCB FinalestUploaded byshivam_mastlife1
- An Accurate Solution for Credit Value Adjustment (CVA) and Wrong Way RiskUploaded byJamie Mcdonald
- High Return Market StrategiesUploaded byWill Rodgers
- PGDM-IB v Trimester Syllabus Copy (Class of 2019)-1Uploaded bychetan
- BLCUploaded byKhairy Rifqy
- FIN352 Part2 Answrs TextUploaded byChessking Siew Hee
- vixwhiteUploaded byOSR
- FIA AnalysisUploaded bypads_irl
- Shoestring MillionaireUploaded byMilan Đorđević
- Session Review Questions CMUploaded byrameessalam852569
- Derivatives Report 5 JUNE 2012Uploaded byAngel Broking
- Option Trading StrategiesUploaded bykayavinash

- 26 Structured RepoUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Leveraged Super Seniors – the valuation questionUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Negative Yield in BondsUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Pricing Convertible SecuritiesUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Converting Swap to FuturesUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Will you be paying more for your coffee soon? It all depends on hedging tactics.Uploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Will you be paying more for your coffee soon? It all depends on hedging tactics.Uploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Islamic Derivatives: Valuing Profit Rate SwapsUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Pricing the probability of a rare eventUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Measuring Delta in Derivative PortfoliosUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Leveraged Super Seniors of the pre credit crisisUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Measuring Market Risk : The DeltaUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- The Credit Hedging Agency Model vs Credit Default SwapsUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- CAT Bonds - Fear of the unknown?Uploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Delta One: What does it do?Uploaded byJasvinder Josen
- 26 Structured RepoUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Auditing Derivatives: Model ValidationUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Interest Rate Swaps: Pre-2008 CrisisUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Auditing Derivatives: Risk ManagementUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Wrong Way Risk - A PremierUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Gold ETFs and DerivativesUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Auditing Derivatives: Middle Office (Valuation)Uploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Interest Rate Swaps: Post-2008 CrisisUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Valuation of Derivatives: So what do we do?Uploaded byJasvinder Josen
- The Crash of 2.45: Lessons LearntUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Auditing Derivatives: Value at RiskUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Audit Derivatives: Product Control - Think of What Can Go WrongUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- The Crash of 2:45 - An AutopsyUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Valuation of Derivatives: The importance of getting it rightUploaded byJasvinder Josen
- Sovereign Bonds - The FundamentalsUploaded byJasvinder Josen

- Transforming Legal Aid QuestionnaireUploaded byAlex Bagnall
- REG_BOOK-NYTE13-LOW.PDFUploaded bypankaj thakur
- Unit 7Assignment.docxUploaded byElias Chembe
- TCM Practice QuestionsUploaded byNeeraj Jain
- The TurtlesUploaded byRohit Beria
- SLFI610-Project Appraisal & Finance[1]Uploaded byVivek Gujral
- Los Angeles Times 2005 Buyout OfferUploaded byinkstainedretch
- Ch 15 Hull Fundamentals 8 the dUploaded byjlosam
- Probity in Public Procurement-2Uploaded bysaumitra_m
- 4A Calculated RiskUploaded byjatingedia
- BONUS Identifying the Losing SideUploaded byJeff Greenblatt
- Project Appraisal Criteria Presentation.pptxUploaded bydebashis mondal
- FRM NewUploaded bynvijay
- Volume Price Level TradingUploaded byApril Clausen
- Villanueva Notes SalesUploaded byGabriel Pachoro
- Investor's Opinion on IVIX and VIX FuturesUploaded bysuryagc
- how to make money trading derivativesUploaded byVivek Pandey
- Rolando 1fUploaded byKhoi Nguyen Nguyen
- 2015 Mahler Sample m FeUploaded byKostasSoufras
- The Determinants of Price in Internet Auctions of Used CarsUploaded byalainvirgile
- Allotment of SharesUploaded byPooja Kapoor
- SAP SAP.docUploaded byrebecca
- Aircraft LeasingUploaded byBenchmarking84
- pag-ibig 2Uploaded bygdisen
- opdrachten ondernemingsfinancieringUploaded bySander Levert
- Lec4-06 Conditional Heteroscedastic ModelsUploaded byNuur Ahmed
- CR01Uploaded byJudielAnnHerediano
- A Study of Derivatives Market in India and Its Current PositionUploaded byShirsenduSarkar
- Lottery Players Stock TradersUploaded byzdfgbsfdzcgbvdfc
- Interest Rate Derivatives; Credit Default Swaps; Currency DerivativesUploaded byAtul Jain