Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
ABSTRACT
Introduction: Orthopedic surgery is one of the most painful surgeries. This study aimed to investigate the effect of aromathe-
rapy on pain after orthopedic surgery.
Methods: This study is a randomized and controlled clinical trial involving 82 patients undergoing orthopedic surgery of wrist
fracture in randomly selected hospitals of Tehran in 2015. The patients of the treatment group, 8 and 16 hours after surgery, sniffed 3
drops of essential oil of lemon for 20 minutes and the intensity of pain was measured half an hour after the intervention. For the con-
trol group, routine healthcare services continued. Data was analyzed using the SPSS 21 software and descriptive and inferential sta-
tistics. Moreover, in order to measure the effects of aromatherapy and change trends, repeated measures ANOVA was used. Chi-squa-
re test was also used to determine the success rate of the treatment.
Results: Comparison of changes in pain scores between the two groups showed that there is a significant relationship (p=.049)
between the intensity of pain in control and treatment groups during the examined intervals (mean of pain and anxiety reduction 8
and 16 hours after surgery). There was also a significant relationship between the recovery rates of the control and treatment groups
and different intervals (p=.008).
Conclusion: The results of the study indicate a positive impact of aromatherapy with essential oils of lemon on the reduction of
pain, 8 and 16 hours after orthopedic surgery. Therefore, it can be used as a non-pharmacological, inexpensive, and non-invasive
care nursing-method with no complication in the orthopedic surgical sections.
their mere health after this damage and always have stress, and depression and improve vital signs(21).
experienced a decline in their health-related quality Fragrances induce relaxation by stimulating the
of life(7). The distal radius fracture occurs during the olfactory system using essential oils (22) .
development of osteoporosis in employed and Aromatherapy is used to relieve pain, anxiety,
active patients(8). Treatment of distal radius fractures depression, insomnia, fatigue, asthma and even to
aims at providing the wrist without pain and restor- create self-confidence, success, and creativity(23).
ing the anatomy and its required function(4, 9). The Today, aromatherapy via using essential oils of
pain refers to unpleasant experience of an emotion- lemon peel is common and is used to reduce anxi-
al sensory that is caused by actual or potential tis- ety and depression and to strengthens the nerves
sue damage and it is the most common reason for and so on(24). The lemon essential oil is a safe herbal
visiting health centers. The pain community of remedy to reduce nausea and vomiting in pregnan-
America considers pain as the fifth vital sign and cy(25). The essential oil of lemon has shown an anal-
suggests that it should be automatically measured gesic effect through the descending inhibitory sys-
such as pulse and blood pressure(10). tem of mice(26). Given the importance of reducing
Studies conducted in America showed that the the postoperative complications and recognizing
prevalence of chronic pain after surgery is 60 per- that analgesic pharmaceutical techniques bear side
cent(11). Pain is also common in orthopedic surgeries effects such as nausea and vomiting, tolerance, itch-
because of its nature which always contains muscu- ing, urinary retention, respiratory depression and
lar and skeletal tissue reconstruction and reform(12). depressiveness, the use of complementary medi-
Orthopedic surgeons are the third prescribers of cine, hence, will be a better alternative.
opioid prescriptions among the practitioners of the According to the aforementioned issues, the
United States of America and contribute to drug implementation of this issue seems difficult because
epidemic(14). The primary use of opioids cause respi- of conflicting results of previous studies. In order to
ratory depression, hypnotic, drowsiness, itching, eliminate the problems faced in the previous
skin rash, urinary retention, delayed stomach and research studies and to provide access to easier and
bowel movements, nausea, and assessment of pain effective techniques, as well as the need to have
vomiting(15). Other pain-killer medicines are non- further investigation in this regard, the researchers
steroidal anti-inflammatory ones that cause side came up with a study to evaluate the effect of aro-
effects such as irritation of the gastrointestinal sys- matherapy on pain in patients undergoing orthope-
tem and bleeding, failure or reduced renal insuffi- dic surgery. If the effectiveness of complementary
ciency, cardiovascular disease and hypersensitivity, medicine in controlling pain is proved in this study,
renal dysfunction, inhibited platelet aggregation patients will be significantly helped.
(increased risk of bleeding at the surgical site) and
inhibited osteogenesis. The use of these drugs is Materials and methods
limited despite the fact that they are the most com-
mon pain reliever and anti-inflammatory drugs(16). In this randomized controlled trial, the effects
The presence of trained nurses considering the of inhaled aromatherapy on the pain of the patients
importance of early assessment of pain and appro- undergoing orthopedic surgery (distal radius frac-
priate for postoperative care is vital(17). ture) was investigated in the selected hospitals of
Although pharmacotherapy is the most effec- Medical Sciences Department of Shahid Beheshti
tive means available to reduce pain, regarding their including Ayatollah Taleghani, Imam Hussein (AS),
side effects, it is important to use these drugs along Akhtar hospitals. Since that study had one depen-
with non-pharmacological methods in order to dent variable (i.e. pain), 82 patients were randomly
reduce pain(18). The use of non-pharmaceutical mea- selected based on the random selection Table and
sures to manage pain such as cryotherapy, relax- were replaced with regard to the pre-test scores in
ation, guided imagery, and aromatherapy which are the treatment and control groups (each group 41
called complementary therapies are safer than phar- persons). The minimum of sample size for each
macotherapy and have fewer side effects. The use group was determined by the sample size equation.
of aromatherapy has clearly increased in compari-
son with other treatment approaches (19) .
Aromatherapy uses essential oils in the form of
inhaler techniques(20) which can reduce pain, mental
On the investigation of the effect of aromatherapy on pain after orthopedic surgery ... 1515
of injected sedative 3 hours earlier. Then, 2 drops of Table 1: Comparing the intensity of pain prior to and after
essential oil of lemon was dropped by a dropper on intervention between therapeutic and control groups.
1516 Mahboubeh Nazari, Farhad Kamrani et Al
seen in Table 2, mean scores changed to 6.52 and Table 3: Recovery frequency distribution for participa-
6.15. Sixteen hours after the intervention, there was ting patients in control and treatment group.
also a decline in both groups; however, the rate of
decline was higher in the treatment group (fig. 2).
treatment control
D.f. Wald statistic p-value The obtained results also significantly differed
from those of the study carried out by Vakiliyan et al.
Recovery time 1 0.177 0.674
(2011) entitled The benefits of regeneration with
Group 2 35.48 0 lavender essential oil during episiotomy recovery.
Time * Group 2 9.61 0.008 The pain rate showed no significant difference (P =
Test: GEE model
0/06) for treatment and control groups(36).
The results of this study is also not consistent
Table 4: Comparing the recovery rate of patients with those of the study conducted by Kim JT, et al
between control and treatment groups. (2006), which aimed to evaluate the effects of aro-
* Interaction of position with group variable
matherapy on pain after breast biopsy surgery per-
formed in New York. It directly rejected the effect of
aromatherapy as a painkiller. Patients in the group
using lavender essential oil were only more satisfied
than patients in the control group with regard to pain
control (p = 0.0001)(37).
In Iran, no similar study has been conducted with
regard to inhalned aromatherapy in reducing pain after
orthopedic surgery. The studies on patients with physi-
cal diseases have not confirmed the effects of aro-
Fig. 4: Comparing the recovery rate of patients between matherapy on pain relief(35, 36, 37). According to the
control and treatment groups. results of this study, it seems that using aromatherapy
has a significant impact on pain reduction; however,
Discussion
this effect is not confirmed with regard to physical dis-
eases. But its effect on pain reduction in patients
The findings has showed that inhaled aromather-
undergoing painful surgeries and procedures has been
apy with essential oils of lemon has a significant
approved. It seems that further research is necessary to
impact on pain reduction in patients undergoing ortho-
interpret the differences of effectiveness. Nevertheless,
pedic surgery of distal radius. Aromatherapy reduced
aromatherapy can be used to as a complementary or
the patients overall pain during 8 and 16 hours after
alternative method for other treatment methods(38,39,40).
intervention.
Undoubtedly, the positive effects of this method can
The results of this study are in the same line with
provide a useful treatment for those who are at risk of
the results of aromatherapy studies including the Yang
complications of narcotics and non-steroidal and anti-
Sak Johns et al. (2013) case study entitled The effect
inflammatory drugs, reduce the individual, family,
of inhalation of eucalyptus essential oil on inflamma-
school and community consequences which are linked
tion and pain after knee replacement surgery indicat-
to pain relief, and prevent the progression of symp-
ing a significant post-operational pain reduction after
toms and the severity of the disability after surgery by
the inhalation of eucalyptus essential oil (p <0.001)(32)
faster relief from pain. It seems that further research-
as well as the study conducted by Sue Hai Hang
in this regard after other types of surgeries, especially
(2014) entitled. The effects of aromatherapy with
in combination and comparison with other pharma-
lavender essential oil on pain reduction after arthro-
cotherapy, cognitive, and behavioral methods- is nec-
scopic knee surgery indicationd a significant
essary to determine the effectiveness of this technique.
decrease in pain intensity after surgery (p=0.002)(33)
and Olapours et al. (2013) study entitled. The effects
of aromatherapy with lavender essential oil on pain
References
reduction after cesarean surgery: A complementary
treatment (p=0.001)(34). 1) Sanjeev Kakar (2015) Clinical Faceoff: Controversies
The result of this research study is not consistent in the Management of Distal Radius Fractures. Clinical
with those of Salamatis et al. (2014) study entitled. Orthopaedics and related Research. Vol. 473(10), pp:
The impact of inhaling lavender essential oil on pain 3098-3104 First online: 21 May 2015 / DOI
reduction after open heart surgery. The results 10.1007/s11999-015-4335-5
2) Soleiman pour J., Ghorbanzade M, Ganjpor sales,
showed that inhaled aromatherapy technique has no Eslamian F, (2011). Comparison of Outcomes and
impact on reducing pain after open heart surgery (p> Complications of 1- and 4-week Cast Immobilization
0.05)(35). after Distal Radius Fracture. Journal of Kerman
1518 Mahboubeh Nazari, Farhad Kamrani et Al
University of Medical Science .Vol. 18 (1). pp: 49-54 Orthop Relat Res .Vol ;( 463). PP: 7-12.
50. 18) Bagherinesami M, Zargar N, Baradari AG, Khalilian A
3) A.R. Sadeghifar, A .Heshmaty, A.R. Saied, A. (2012). The Effect of Foot Reflexology Massage on
Ayatollahi Mousavi, A.R. Pooladsanj, F. Arabnejhad pain and Fatigue of Patients Undergoing Coronary
(2014). The Effect of Prophylactic Corticosteroid Artery Bypass Graft (persian). Mazandaran Univ Med
Injection in Decreasing the Ulnar Sided Wrist Pain in Sci Vol.; 22(92):56-62.
Patients with Acute Distal Radius Fracture. J Babol 19) Fayazi S, Babashahi M, Rezaei M (2011). The effect of
Univ Med Sci; 16(7). pp. 7-13 7 inhalation aromatherapy on anxiety level of the
4) Nellans KW, Kowalski E, Chung KC (2012). The epi- patients in preoperative period. Iran J Nurs Midwifery
demiology of distal radius fractures. Hand Clin Vol; Res.Vol 16(4). Pages 278-283.
28(2): 113-25. 20) Myung-Haeng Hur, Myeong Soo Lee, Chan Kim and
5) Shauver MJ, Yin H, Banerjee M, Chung KC (2011). Edzard Ernst (2012). Aromatherapy for treatment of
Current and future national costs to medicare for the hypertension: a systematic review. Journal of
treatment of distal radius fracture in the elderly. J Evaluation in Clinical Practice. Vol. 18(1), pages
Hand Surg Am. VOL (36). PP: 1282-1287. 3741, February 2012 DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-
6) Iyer, K. Mohan (2013). Trauma Management in 2753.2010.01521.x
Orthopedics. 1 ed. Springer-Verlag London. P. 234 21) Ali Bikmoradi, Zahra Seifi, Jalal Poorolajal, Malihe
eBook ISBN: 978-1-4471-4462-5 DOI: 10.1007/978-1- Araghchian, Reza Safiaryan, Khodayar Oshvandi
4471-4462-5 (2015). Effect Of inhalation aromatherapy with laven-
7) Van Son MA, De Vries J, Roukema JA, Den Oudsten der essential oil on stress and vital signs.
BL (2013). Health status and (health-related) quality of Complementary Therapies in Medicine Vol. 23, Pages
life during the recovery of distal radius fractures: a 331-338 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ctim.2014.12.001
systematic review. Qual Life Res. Vol; 22.pp:2399416. 22) Valipour NS, Kheirkhah M, Neisani L, Haghani H
doi: 10.1007/s11136-013-0391-z. (2012). Comparison of the effects of aromatherapy with
8) P. Lips et al (2010). Validation of the IOF quality of life essential oils of damask rose and hot footbath on the
questionnaire for patients with wrist fracture. first stage of labor anxiety in Nulliparous women.
Osteoporos Int .Vol 21. PP. 6170 DOI Complement Med. J. Faculty Nurs. Midwifery. VOL. 2
10.1007/s00198-009-0946-6 (2): 1-9.
9) Jafari D, Najd Mazhar F, Jalili A, Zare S, Hoseini 23) Sahebalzamin M, Khanavi M, Alvi majd H, Mirkarimi
Teshnizi S(2013). The Inter and intraobserver reliabili- S, Karimi M. (2010). Effects of inhalation aromathera-
ty of measurements of the distal radius radiographic py on female students' anxiety and depression settling
indices. Shafa Orthopedic Journal. 2013.1(2): 22-25. in dormitory of Tehran University of Medical Sciences.
10) Smeltzer CS and Brenda GB. (2014). Brunner and J; Islamic Azad University Tehran Branch. Vol. 2(3).
Sudarths Textbook of Medical-Surgical Nursing. 10th pp: 175-181.
ed. Lippincott Williams and Wilkins, Philadelphia pp: 24) Maghsoudi Shahram. Lemontherapy. 1 st ed. Iran.
231. (p: 2364). Tehran: Agriculture Science; 2012.P:156 ISBN: 978-
11) Morshedi A, Dashti - R M, Dehghan - H M, 964-683283-1
Bagherinasab M, Salami A (2011). The Effect of 25) Lua PL, Zakaria NS (2012). Abrief review of current
Artemisia sieberi Besser on Infkammatory and scientific evidence involving aromatherapy use for nau-
Neurogenic Pain in Mice. JMP. Vol; 4 (40): 48-57 URL sea and vomiting. J Altern Complement Med; 18(6):
http://www.jmp.ir/browse.php?a_code=A-10-154- 534-40.
1&slc_lang=fa&sid=1 26) Hiroshi Ikeda, Syuntaro Takasu and Kazuyuki Murase
12) Buyukyilmaz FE, Asti (2010). Postoperative pain char- (2014). Contribution of anterior cingulate cortex and
acteristics in Turkish orthopedic patients. Pain Manag descending pain inhibitory system to analgesic effect of
Nurs; 11(2): 76-84. lemon odor in mice. Mol Pain. 2014; 10 (14).pp:1-8
13) Ko YL, Lin PC (2012). The effect of using a relaxation doi: 10.1186/1744-8069-10-14 PMCID: PMC3936890
tape on pulse, respiration, blood pressure and anxiety 27) Heydar Noroozinia H, Mahoori A, Hassani E, Akhbari
levels of surgical patients. J Clin Nurs; 21(5-6):689-97. P. Diclofenac suppository versus intramuscular pethi-
14) Morris BJ, Mir HR (2015). The opioid epidemic: dine in post herniorrhaphy pain relief. (persian).
Impact on orthopaedic surgery. J Am Acad Orthop Tehran Univ Med J 2011; 69(3): 198-203.
Surg. Vol 23(5).PP:267-271 doi: 10.5435/JAAOS-D- 28) Vahid Zamanzade, Alehe Seyyedrasooli, Kobra Parvan,
14-00163 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed Mehdi Aghakeshizade (2015). The effect of music on
/25911660 anxiety and pain in patients undergoing cholecystecto-
15) Jahr JS, Filocamo P, Singh S (2013). Intravenous my. Medical - Surgical Nursing Journal, Vol; 3(4): 203-
acetaminophen: a review of pharmacoeconomic sci- 209.
ence for perioperative use. Am J Ther Vol: 20. PP: 189- 29) Mohseni M, Ebneshahidi A, Yazdkhasti P(2012). The
99. effect of patient-selected music on early postoperative
16) Ippokratis Pountos, et al (2012). Do Nonsteroidal Anti- pain, anxiety, and hemodynamic profile in cesarean
Inflammatory Drugs Affect Bone Healing? A Critical section surgery. Anesth Pain Med. Vol; 2(7): 88-95.
Analysis. The Scientific World Journal. Volume 2012, 30) Gillian A. Hawker, Samra Mian, Tetyana Kendzerska,
Article ID 606404, 14 pages Review Article and Melissa French (2011). Measures of Adult Pain.
doi:10.1100/2012/606404 Arthritis Care & Research. Vol. 63, No. S11, pp S240-
17) Dorr LD, Chao L (2007). The emotional state of the S252 DOI 10.1002/acr.20543
patient after total hip and knee arthroplasty. Clin
On the investigation of the effect of aromatherapy on pain after orthopedic surgery ... 1519
Acknowledgments
This article is extracted from the thesis approved by the Ethics _______
Committee of the Islamic Azad University with code No. 1045- Corresponding author
12 / 93 and is registered in the clinical trial database under No. MAHBOUBEH NAZARI
IRCT2015081723655N1. I would like to express my gratitude Msc student in Nursing, Department of Nursing, Tehran
to dear authorities of Medical Sciences Department of Shahid Medical Sciences Branch, Islamic Azad University
Beheshti University and the personnel of selected hospitals of Tehran
the university and all patients who participated in the study. (Iran)
mahnazari2010@yahoo.com