Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
https://support.industry.siemens.com/cs/ww/de/view/109480739
Warranty and liability
Note The Application Examples are not binding and do not claim to be complete
regarding the circuits shown, equipping and any eventuality. The Application
Examples do not represent customer-specific solutions. They are only intended
to provide support for typical applications. You are responsible for ensuring that
the described products are used correctly. These Application Examples do not
relieve you of the responsibility to use safe practices in application, installation,
operation and maintenance. When using these Application Examples, you
recognize that we cannot be made liable for any damage/claims beyond the
liability clause described. We reserve the right to make changes to these
Application Examples at any time without prior notice.
If there are any deviations between the recommendations provided in these
Application Examples and other Siemens publications – e.g. Catalogs – the
contents of the other documents have priority.
We do not accept any liability for the information contained in this document.
Any claims against us – based on whatever legal reason – resulting from the use of
the examples, information, programs, engineering and performance data etc.,
described in this Application Example shall be excluded. Such an exclusion shall
not apply in the case of mandatory liability, e.g. under the German Product Liability
Act (“Produkthaftungsgesetz”), in case of intent, gross negligence, or injury of life,
body or health, guarantee for the quality of a product, fraudulent concealment of a
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Security Siemens provides products and solutions with industrial security functions that
informa- support the secure operation of plants, systems, machines and networks.
tion In order to protect plants, systems, machines and networks against cyber
threats, it is necessary to implement – and continuously maintain – a holistic,
state-of-the-art industrial security concept. Siemens’ products and solutions only
form one element of such a concept.
Customer is responsible to prevent unauthorized access to its plants, systems,
machines and networks. Systems, machines and components should only be
connected to the enterprise network or the internet if and to the extent necessary
and with appropriate security measures (e.g. use of firewalls and network
segmentation) in place.
Additionally, Siemens’ guidance on appropriate security measures should be
taken into account. For more information about industrial security, please visit
http://www.siemens.com/industrialsecurity.
Siemens’ products and solutions undergo continuous development to make them
more secure. Siemens strongly recommends to apply product updates as soon
as available and to always use the latest product versions. Use of product
versions that are no longer supported, and failure to apply latest updates may
increase customer’s exposure to cyber threats.
To stay informed about product updates, subscribe to the Siemens Industrial
Security RSS Feed under http://www.siemens.com/industrialsecurity.
Table of contents
Warranty and liability ................................................................................................... 2
Table of contents ......................................................................................................... 3
1 Task ..................................................................................................................... 5
2 The solution ....................................................................................................... 7
2.1 Overview of the workflow in this application example .......................... 7
2.2 Example project .................................................................................... 8
2.3 Alternative workflows ............................................................................ 9
2.4 Required software components ......................................................... 10
3 Basics ............................................................................................................... 11
3.1 COMOS – General overview .............................................................. 11
3.2 COMOS P&ID .................................................................................... 13
3.2.1 Range of functions ............................................................................. 13
3.2.2 Benefits of COMOS P&ID .................................................................. 14
4 Configuring the example project ................................................................... 15
4.1 Opening the COMOS database and example project ........................ 16
4.2 Basic COMOS project settings ........................................................... 20
4.2.1 Basic information regarding language setting .................................... 20
4.2.2 Basic COMOS project settings ........................................................... 21
Open project properties ...................................................................... 21
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
1 Task
Challenges throughout the complete lifecycle of the plant
Global competition, shorter innovation cycles, tighter regulations regarding safety
and environmental protection and the growing demand for individual products
present enormous challenges to plant designers and operators.
The lifecycle of a plant can be divided into different phases:
Process design
Basic and detail engineering
Commissioning and installation
Operation and maintenance
Modernization.
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Plant engineering process: From initial process design right through to the operating phase
The possibilities for parallelizing the process by further development of the data
interfaces between the systems are largely exhausted.
Another challenge when operating the plant is to keep the plant documentation
always up to date so that it always corresponds to the current state of the plant.
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
This application example gives you initial insights on how the software solution
COMOS and in particular
COMOS P&ID fulfill the requirements listed here.
It also explains the benefits of the software.
You can find basic information on COMOS and the product COMOS P&ID in
Chapter 3 "Basics".
2 The solution
2.1 Overview of the workflow in this application example
Overview
The figure below shows the workflow of the COMOS P&ID application example.
The application example is based on project data from the COMOS FEED
application example and will be continued in the application examples COMOS
EI&C *, Logical * and MRO *.
Figure 2-1
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Note For information on further helpful articles and links, refer to chapter 6 "Further
information" in this document.
Based on the project data resulting from the Process design/FEED phase, you now
further specify the created data and carry out basic and detailed engineering.
In the first step you will learn how to convert a process flow diagram (PFD) into a
Piping and Instrumentation Diagram (P&ID).
Then you should extend it the P&ID. You will find descriptions of basic courses of
action and function processes, such as:
Basic project settings
Working on the P&ID diagram
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
CAUTION The pre-configured application example is for illustrative purposes only and it is
not a fully worked out solution to implement in your plant.
Note The product COMOS P&ID plays a central role in this application example.
You can find information about plant engineering with COMOS FEED, EI&C,
Logical and MRO in the overview of manuals, at the following link:
https://w3.siemens.com/mcms/industrial-automation-systems-simatic/en/manual-
overview/comos-manuals/Pages/Default.aspx
For information on further helpful articles and links,
refer to chapter 6 "Further information" in this document.
Software components
Table 2-1
Components MLFB/Order number
COMOS V10.1 SP3 Sales and Service contact persons for COMOS Software
(COMOS Platform + solutions (English)
FEED and P&ID license) http://w3.siemens.com/mcms/plant-engineering-
COMOS PipeSpec Manager license software/en/contact/Pages/Default.aspx
(necessary for Chapter 4.8)
Note If you have already purchased COMOS, at the following link you will find
information on how to download COMOS /COMOS Walkinside full versions
and updates or order them on DVD.
https://support.industry.siemens.com/cs/ww/en/view/67811976
For information about further useful articles and application examples refer to
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Note Under certain conditions, if you are using a COMOS database previous to
version 10.1 SP3 (which is based on the COMOS iDB), you won't be able to use
all the features described in this application example, for example:
Table 2-2
Components Note
109480739_COMOS_P&ID_best_practice_document_en.pdf This document
109480739_COMOS_P&ID_best_practice_example_project.zip This file contains
a pre-configured
COMOS project.
3 Basics
3.1 COMOS – General overview
With its unified data platform the integrated software solution COMOS provides
plant design engineers, plant operating personnel, company management, and
solution partners with a continuous flow of data that meet their specific needs
across all project phases.
One requirement for effective plant management is optimum networking and
coordination of all disciplines and departments involved in the engineering and
operation of a plant. The software solution COMOS is the basis for the cooperation
of worldwide collaboration across the entire lifecycle of a plant.
The integrated COMOS software concept is based on object orientation.
Components are described holistically and displayed graphically in their true-to-life
representation. The graphical and data-related description, which includes all data
associated with the component, forms a single unit within the database – the
object. Related data sheets, lists, and other documents are linked to the
corresponding objects.
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Procedure
1. Retrieve the supplied Zip file
"COMOS_P&ID_best_practice_example_project.zip".
This file contains the COMOS database with the pre-configured example
project (based on the iDB).
2. Open COMOS.
Figure 4-1
COMOS menu bar
Navigator
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Work area
Detail window
Note In the COMOS manual "COMOS Platform COMOS Platform Getting Started"
you can look up further useful information on basic COMOS operation.
For information on further helpful articles and links,
refer to chapter 6. "Further information" of this document.
7. Right-click the "User name" field and select the "Universal access" entry.
COMOS is now connected to the database. Next, you must open the relevant
project in the database (there is only one project present in the supplied
database).
The languages of your operating system, MS Office and COMOS must be identical.
Set the languages accordingly.
For example, German uses the comma whereas English uses the point as
a decimal delimiter. If settings are different, values may not be calculated correctly.
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
This section describes the project settings in the COMOS example project.
Figure 4-7
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Note This application example contains a general project template, as it will serve as
a basis for further application examples.
Figure 4-8
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-9
Figure 4-10
This option is required for you to carry out a redlining in the revision documents
and to display it in the corresponding report.
If you display the PDF revision files with Redlining, you can insert markings
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
and comments. They are stored in a separate Redlining file. The revision file
is not changed. The markings and comments are shown in the work area of
the open report (see chapter 4.7.2 "Redlining based on the example of a
document-spanning interconnection").
Figure 4-11
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Note For further information about the "Revisions" topic and the revision archives in
COMOS, including their properties, refer to the manuals:
"COMOS Platform Administration", in chapter 12.21.6 "Specify revision
archive"
"COMOS Platform Operation"
Figure 4-12
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-13
Figure 4-14
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
6. Click the "Apply" and "OK" buttons to save the changes and to close the
dialog.
Figure 4-15
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
templates.
Note If you still haven't assigned any default templates, you can click the "Yes" button.
It is to note that if you click the "Yes" button in an ongoing project, all previously
assigned templates are overwritten.
6. Then click the "Apply" and "OK" buttons to save the changes and to close the
dialog.
Figure 4-16
After copying the default templates, you will notice in the "Logtext" field, which
default templates have been assigned to which objects.
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
7. If you click the "Selection" button, you will get the complete overview in the
"Logtext" dialog.
Figure 4-17
Figure 4-18
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
11. Under the pump object "P001" you will find the corresponding P&ID default
template.
Open this by double-clicking on it.
Figure 4-19
Figure 4-20
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-21
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-22
18. Open the P&ID template below the pump object "P001".
As you can see, the new template is different than the previous one.
19. In the Report menu bar, click the "Save" button
and close the new template.
Figure 4-23
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-24
Figure 4-25
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-26
25. Click the "Save" button in the Report menu bar and close the process flow
diagram.
Figure 4-27
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-28
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
6. Open the corresponding shortcut menu by right clicking on the unit object
"Reaction 02".
7. Here, create a new P&ID diagram:
"New > P&ID diagram, DIN A0"
Figure 4-29
Figure 4-30
3
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
The objects placed on the process flow diagram and symbols are displayed
together with the anchor symbol of the process flow diagram on the P&ID.
11. Open the corresponding shortcut menu by right clicking on the anchor symbol.
12. Click on the entry "Convert placed document" to convert the process flow
diagram into a P&ID diagram.
Figure 4-31
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
The corresponding P&ID template is now placed for each piece of equipment,
the objects are linked automatically and the corresponding pipes, pipe sections
and segments are also generated in the database, thus creating the P&ID.
The following is performed in detail:
If an object that has a P&ID assembly is placed on the PFD, the
objects in the assembly are placed on the P&ID.
The objects placed on the P&ID are connected to one another by
means of pipes (pipes, pipe sections, and segments). Tees for
branches are inserted automatically. Pipes that connect objects in an
assembly are created under the assembly in the Navigator. Pipes that
connect two assemblies are created under the corresponding process
streams in the Navigator.
Tees for branches are automatically inserted in the P&ID and are
created under the assemblies in the Navigator.
Figure 4-32
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-33
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-34
Figure 4-35
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
6. In the next step, assign the relevant objects from the P&ID diagram to the
subunit.
In the P&ID diagram mark all objects belonging to the reactor
(see Figure 4-36).
7. In the menu bar of the P&ID diagram, click the "Assign object" button.
8. Select the subunit "Reactor" and move it to the marked area in the P&ID
diagram via drag-and-drop.
Figure 4-36
As a result, all marked objects of the subunit "Reactor" are assigned and the
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
corresponding P&ID objects are transferred from the FEED structure to the
P&ID structure.
Figure 4-37
Note The created P&ID objects are still linked to their objects in the FEED structure,
i.e. if for instance certain parameters change in a P&ID object, this data are
transferred automatically to the corresponding object in the FEED structure.
9. Repeat the process and assign the following objects to the subunit "Separator"
(see Figure 4-38).
Figure 4-38
3
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
10. Repeat the process and assign the following objects to the subunit "Column"
(see Figure 4-39).
Figure 4-39
11. Click the "Save" button in the menu bar of the P&ID diagram and close it.
12. Click the "Save" button in the COMOS menu bar to accept all changes.
Result
Thus, you have automatically created the P&ID diagram from the data in your
process flow diagram, and adopted the objects in the P&ID structure.
Note For further information on "how to convert process flow diagrams (PFD) into
Piping and Instrumentation Diagrams (P&ID)", refer to the manual.
"COMOS Process FEED Operation", chapter 13 "PFD and P&ID"
1. To do this, open the P&ID diagram of the subunit "Reaction 02" by double-
clicking it.
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-40
Figure 4-41
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-42
The view is split and the tab of the pipe section properties is displayed in the
right part of the work area.
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Note You can also merge the divided areas again. You can do this
by moving the mouse to the middle part of the View menu.
Figure 4-43
Some fields in the properties of the pipe section are displayed in orange.
This is it to the fact that for the corresponding parameters you can apply values
of associated objects from the process planning.
You have the option of deciding whether you want to apply the data for the
pipe section or if new values are required.
11. Move the mouse over one of the orange fields.
The data, which you can take over from the process technology, are shown in
a display panel.
12. Apply the data from the process planning to the example project.
To do this, open the corresponding shortcut menu by right-clicking on an empty
area of the tab and click the entry:
"Refresh static links on tab".
Figure 4-44
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
You have now applied and updated the values of the pipe section.
Figure 4-45
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
In the previous step you have changed the properties/specifications of the pipe
section.
You can also update the connected components. This is called horizontal data
flow.
1. Click the "Apply" button in the properties dialog where you have
applied/changed data.
The "Update devices" window opens. All the components in the P&ID will have
a yellow background if affected by the update.
In the "Update devices" window, you can select one of the following options:
"Always"
The components are always updated for the current session.
"User-defined"
(Selected by default, used in the application example) Confirm the dialog to
update the components. Here you get the option of selecting it specifically
for each component.
"Never"
The components are never updated for the current session.
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
2. Click the "OK" button to apply the data for the marked components.
Figure 4-46
3. Click the "OK" button in the Properties dialog of the pipe section to confirm the
entries.
This saves the changes of the properties/specifications.
The connected objects are updated in accordance with the setting and then
highlighted in magenta.
Figure 4-47
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
To see whether the data were successfully applied, you can for instance check
the properties of pump "P001".
Figure 4-48
4. Reselect the pipe section between the separator and valve "V101".
5. Open the "Properties tree" tab in the detail window.
6. Select the nominal size "DN100" in the drop-down list of the "Nominal size"
field.
Figure 4-49
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
7. Repeat the process by opening the drop-down list of the "Nominal pressure"
field and selecting the nominal pressure "PN4".
8. Then click the "Apply" button.
The "Update devices" window opens.
All the component symbols in the P&ID will get an olive color if affected by the
update.
9. Click the "OK" button to apply the data.
Figure 4-50
1
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
You have changed the value of the "Nominal size" and "Nominal pressure"
attributes.
The nominal size and nominal pressure attributes stop being forwarded to
a reducer or, in this case, to Pump "P001" because from a technical point of
view one has to expect the specifications of these components to differ.
You can check these as follows.
10. Select the pump "P001" in the P&ID diagram and open the corresponding
shortcut menu by right clicking on it.
11. Open the properties of pump "P001".
12. Open the "Design data" tab.
The values were only applied to the input of the pump, not the output.
This means that these values were not applied to the following pipes and
components.
13. Close the dialog by clicking the "OK" button.
14. The "Update devices" window opens. Confirm it by clicking the OK button.
Figure 4-51
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-52
Figure 4-53
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Note You can find further information about "Data flow" in the following manuals:
"COMOS Process, P&ID Operation"
Chapter 9, "Data flow between P&ID objects"
"COMOS Process, P&ID Administration":
Chapter 2.3, "Data flow for pipes via static connections"
Chapter 4, "Configuring components"
16. Click the "Save" button in the COMOS menu bar to confirm the changes.
Procedure
1. Open the P&ID diagram of the subunit "Reaction 2" by double-clicking it.
Figure 4-54
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-55
Figure 4-56
Figure 4-57
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
The associated object for the pressure measurement function was created
automatically in the Navigator below the P&ID diagram. However, this is still
not assigned to a subunit and it is therefore displayed in blue in the P&ID
diagram. The following description explains how to assign the measurement
function of a subunit.
4. To define the start point of the pipe, click on a connector point of the
measurement function.
A green point is displayed above the connector point. The color of its object
changes to yellow.
5. To define the end point of the pipe, click on the connector point of the
connecting piece.
Figure 4-58
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
6. Right-click on the P&ID to place the pipe and deactivate the "Connection" tool.
The object is represented in blue, as it is placed underneath the P&ID diagram
and still doesn't have any associated subunit.
Figure 4-59
In the next step, assign the created pressure measurement function to the
subunit "Reactor".
To do this, select the pressure measurement function and the connected pipe.
7. In the menu bar of the P&ID diagram, click the "Assign object" button .
8. Select the subunit "Reactor" and move it to the pressure measurement function
you created in the P&ID diagram via drag-and-drop.
You have now assigned the selected objects to the subunit "Reactor".
Figure 4-60
3
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
The object of the pressure measurement function is now applied into the
structure of the subunit "Reactor".
Figure 4-61
Figure 4-62
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
11. Enter "PISA" in the "Label" entry field and click the "Apply" button to save the
changes.
Figure 4-63
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-64
In the next step, define three design data values for the motor of the reactor.
12. To do this, select the motor on the P&ID diagram and open its shortcut menu
with a right-click.
13. Open the properties.
Figure 4-65
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
16. Then click the "Apply" and "OK" buttons to accept the changes.
Figure 4-66
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Result
You have extended the P&ID flow chart by one measurement function and edited
the properties of the agitator motor.
Note For further basic information on how to work in P&ID diagrams, refer to
chapter 4.10 "Working in the P&ID diagram".
For information on further helpful articles and links,
refer to chapter 6 "Further information" in this document.
Procedure
1. Open the P&ID diagram of the subunit "Reaction 2" by double-clicking it.
2. Select the reactor and the associated objects as shown in the following figure.
To do this, hold down the "Ctrl" button and click the corresponding object with
the left mouse button.
Figure 4-67
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
3. Open the corresponding shortcut menu by right clicking the selected objects.
4. Click the left mouse button on the entry:
"Create template".
Figure 4-68
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
The "Note" window is opened, as the example project still doesn't have
a "Template" folder.
5. Confirm the dialog by clicking the "OK" button.
Figure 4-69
Note The template was created as a global template by means of the "Base project"
option.
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-70
1
2 1
3
The "@Template Templates" folder is created in the plant view of the example
project. This contains the template.
Figure 4-71
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
12. In the next step, set the point of origin for the template. Double-click the
template to open it.
13. Right-click to open the shortcut menu of the template.
14. Click the entry:
"Options >Set point of origin".
Figure 4-72
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-73
Figure 4-74
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-75
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-76
Figure 4-77
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Note The previously defined point of origin is the point at which you place the template
before placing it on the flow chart.
The template objects are displayed again in blue, as they have not been
assigned to a subunit yet.
Figure 4-78
Figure 4-79
3
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
In the P&ID diagram, connect the template to the pipe section between the
valve "V002" and the separator.
26. To do this, click on the "Connection" button in the P&ID diagram menu bar
and create a new pipe from valve "B002" all the way to pipe "Q008" (see
Figure 4-80).
Figure 4-80
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-81
28. Click the "Save" button in the P&ID flow chart menu bar .
29. Click the "Save" button in the COMOS menu bar to save all project data.
30. Close the P&ID diagram.
Result
You have now created, placed and integrated a template in the engineering
project.
Figure 4-82
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
4.7 Revisions
This chapter shows you how to carry out a revision of your documents in COMOS
and what benefit this has on your system planning.
You can use revisions to check and save the editing statuses of documents.
The result is a revision file which permanently documents the working version
of a document. You can print it out, archive it, and compare it to other revision
statuses.
In the application example you should carry out a revision for the P&ID diagram
of the unit "Reaction 02". During the revision process, you also carry out "redlining"
in the revision document and extend the process flow diagram.
The following description highlights the advantages gained from the revision
function of COMOS.
Note To carry out the steps in this chapter you require basic project settings
(see chapter 4.2.2 "Basic COMOS project settings").
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
This section describes how to carry out an "individual revision" of the P&ID diagram
of the unit "Reaction 02".
Procedure
1. Create a revision file of the P&ID diagram you created for the unit "Reaction 2".
To do this, open the corresponding shortcut menu of the unit "Reaction 2" by
right-clicking the P&ID diagram.
2. Open the properties of the process flow diagram by clicking on the entry
"properties".
Figure 4-83
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-84
Note The *revision is present because revision monitoring is activated in the project
properties.
If no *revision is present, the revision monitoring feature is not activated.
Open the "Revision options" of the project and activate it. The description for
this process can be found in chapter 4.2.2 "Basic COMOS project settings".
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
4. Click on the arrow symbol next to the button for the revision step.
Normally, the steps are performed in sequence and the document is checked
by the appropriate or authorized persons.
Note Steps which have already been executed are locked. The next step in the
revision process is marked with a dot.
In the application example, you will skip these steps and release the document.
5. To do this, click on the last entry "Released by".
If you select one of the subsequent steps instead of the step marked with
a dot, the steps are carried out in sequence.
Figure 4-85
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Note If you want to create or release a revision but the corresponding document is still
open in COMOS, the following dialog appears.
Confirm this by clicking the "OK" button and close the document. You can then
create a revision file.
Figure 4-86
Figure 4-87
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Result
You have now generated a revision of the P&ID diagram.
Note The "Redlining" function is available for the PDF revision files.
For further information, refer to the manual:
"COMOS Platform Administration", in chapter 12.21.6 "Revision options:
Specify revision archive (specify print format)".
For information on further helpful articles and links,
refer to chapter 6 "Further information" in this document.
In the application example, you will create PDF revision files and perform the
"Redlining" function. In this process, markings and comments are added.
Inserting a note
Insert a note saying that the second reactor should be placed in a separate
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
P&ID diagram.
1. Open the previously created revision document
(see chapter 4.7.1 "Creating a revision of the P&ID diagram").
2. Click the "Inspection stamp error" button in the menu bar of the revision
document.
3. In the pipe of the reactor you added, place the error message with a left-click
on the revision document.
Figure 4-88
Figure 4-89
4. Place a note so that, for instance, the competent engineer knows what is
wrong and how this error can be corrected.
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-90
Figure 4-91
Figure 4-92
Note When you open a report which has a completed revision with Redlining files,
you see the markings of the last completed revision in the working area.
Figure 4-93
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-94
1
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-95
Figure 4-96
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-97
Figure 4-98
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-99
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-100
Figure 4-101
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-102
Note A description on how to update devices has already been given in chapter 4.4
"Updating connected components and pipe sections".
Here you can find further information about this topic.
You have now created a document-spanning pipe reference and placed the
reactor on a separate flow diagram.
Figure 4-103
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
If the reference arrows are not displayed, click on the "Reevaluate document"
button in the menu bar of the flow diagram.
Figure 4-104
Figure 4-105
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-106
Figure 4-107
Figure 4-108
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-109
Figure 4-110
diagram does not differ from the last revision document of the flow diagram.
This section describes how to create a revision of the data sheet for valve "V001".
It also shows you how to export, edit and (re)import it to an Excel file, and how to
update the data in the example project.
It clarifies the effect of changes in the project and how they are documented.
Figure 4-111
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
2. Move the mouse from the P&ID flow chart to the pipe that leads to valve
"V001".
3. Select the pipe and open its shortcut menu by right clicking on it, then click on
the properties of the pipe.
Figure 4-112
Figure 4-113
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-114
You have now applied and updated the values from the process engineering
planning to the pipe section.
You have changed the properties/specifications of the pipe section. These will
be transferred to the connected components in the next step. The "Horizontal
data flow" applies here (see chapter 4.4.2 "Horizontal data flow").
6. Click on the "Apply" and "OK" buttons.
7. Click the OK button to confirm the "Update devices" dialog.
Figure 4-115
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-116
The values on valve "V001" are passed on to the connecting piece of the
reactor.
8. Select the valve "V001" in the P&ID diagram and open its shortcut menu by
right clicking on the valve.
9. Navigate to the object of the valve:
"Navigate > Object".
Figure 4-117
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-118
Figure 4-119
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-120
16. Confirm the displayed "Update devices" dialog by clicking the "OK" button.
Figure 4-121
Figure 4-122
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
18. Click the "OK" button to confirm the "Update devices" window.
Figure 4-123
You have now applied the data and transferred them from valve "V001" to the
connecting piece of the reactor via "horizontal data flow".
Figure 4-124
Figure 4-125
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
In the next step, you will create a revision of the data sheet.
For instance, you export the data sheet of the valve "V001" to an Excel file
so that a sub-supplier completes it.
This way, changes are identified during reimport and documented
automatically.
You also have the option of releasing or discarding the changes made to the
project. The procedure is described in the following step.
Figure 4-126
Figure 4-127
Figure 4-128
Figure 4-129
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-130
Figure 4-131
Figure 4-132
Figure 4-133
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-134
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-135
Figure 4-136
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-137
Note You can find further information on working layers in the following manuals:
Figure 4-138
The process takes some time and if it completes successfully, the "Reimport"
dialog is displayed.
Figure 4-139
Figure 4-140
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-141
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-142
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
You can either apply or discard the newly imported values. If, for instance, you
discard a value, the previous value is accepted.
In this application example, you accept the new "Medium" Ethylene and the
new value for "Operating temperature max.".
4. For instance, to accept the new medium, move the mouse on the field of the
"Medium" parameter and open its shortcut menu by right-clicking it.
5. Click the entry:
"Static link: Accept Difference".
Figure 4-143
You shouldn't accept the new value for the "Operating pressure max."
parameter, therefore discard it.
7. To do this, move the mouse to the field of the parameter
"Operating temperature max." and open the corresponding shortcut menu
by right clicking on it.
8. Click the entry:
"Update static link".
This reapplies the old value.
Figure 4-144
Figure 4-145
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-146
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
If you wish to display the previous value (the last released revision) for
parameters that are marked with the "*" symbol in the data sheet, proceed as
follows:
10. Open the last revision document of the data sheet.
11. Select the modified value, delete the content and click in an empty area of the
data sheet.
Figure 4-147
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-148
Figure 4-149
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
12. In the data sheet, re-enter the value "220" for the "Operating temperature
max." parameter.
The values are no longer highlighted in orange.
4. Then click the "Apply" button followed by "OK", and confirm the dialogs for the
"Horizontal data flow" with the "OK" button. The data will be transferred to the
connected components.
5. Reopen the properties of valve "V001".
If any fields are highlighted in orange here, it is a representation issue.
The values have already been transferred correctly to the connected components.
If the markings are no longer displayed, reconfirm the corresponding fields
highlighted in orange, the same way as before.
6. Then click the "Apply" button followed by "OK", and confirm the window for
the "Horizontal data flow" by clicking the "OK" button.
7. The orange fields are no longer displayed.
13. Then click the "Apply" button and confirm the window for the "Horizontal data
flow" by clicking the "OK" button.
Figure 4-150
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-151
14. Then click the "OK" button and confirm the window for the "Horizontal data
flow" by clicking the "OK" button.
Figure 4-152
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-153
The modified data are transferred again to the components connected to valve
"V001".
15. Then click the "Save" button in the COMOS menu bar to accept the
changes.
Figure 4-154
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-155
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-156
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-157
Figure 4-158
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
The "Update devices" dialog is opened because you have defined a "nominal
size" and a "pipe spec".
COMOS checks automatically to see if the corresponding P&ID objects are
stored as specific 3D components in the pipe parts catalog of the COMOS
database.
The valve "V001" is displayed in the left list of the dialog because specific
components have been stored in the COMOS database for this object.
6. Click on the "Execute pipe spec mapping" check box to display it.
Figure 4-159
Figure 4-160
Note The pipe parts that are assigned to the classes come from the pipe part catalog
supplied with the COMOS DB. They reference a geometry standard, and thus
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-161
Figure 4-162
9. Select valve "V001" in the P&ID flow chart and open its shortcut menu by right
clicking on it.
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-163
Figure 4-164
Figure 4-165
Opening 3D view
1. Select the "3D Object" of valve "V001".
2. Open "3D view" from the COMOS menu bar:
"Extra > 3D review > 3D view".
Figure 4-166
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-167
Figure 4-168
Revision rectangles
1. By defining the "Nominal size", the "Pipe spec" and the transmission via
"horizontal data flow", a green rectangle is displayed around valve "V001" in
the P&ID diagram.
This is a revision rectangle.
Figure 4-169
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Note If a report was revised and you then change the report, the changes will be
marked by a revision rectangle in the report. In this case, the following applies:
Green: Changes in the current, open revision.
When you create a revision file, these revision rectangles are also printed. You can
change this setting.
Gray: Changes in the last completed revision.
When you print a revision file, these revision rectangles are also printed.
Changes that date back to the revision prior to the last one (or earlier) are not
displayed on the report. In the following example you see the green revision
rectangle around valve "V001":
Only objects that also have a counterpart in the Navigator are monitored in the
report. Graphical report objects, such as circles, are not monitored. The revision
rectangles become effective only after the first revision. Revision rectangles are
not visible on new documents.
Figure 4-170
Figure 4-171
Figure 4-172
Figure 4-173
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-174
Figure 4-175
Figure 4-176
Figure 4-177
Figure 4-178
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-179
Figure 4-180
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Result
You have conducted a pipe spec mapping and assigned specific components
to your objects in the P&ID diagram. These are needed for creating subsequent
isometrics and 3D models.
It has also been explained how to use revisions in order to see changes quickly.
Note You can find further information about "Pipe spec mapping" and "Revision
rectangles" in the following manuals:
"COMOS Process, P&ID Operation"
Chapter 7.12, "Pipe spec mapping"
"COMOS Platform, Operation":
Chapter 3.8.10, "Displaying revisioned reports"
Creating queries
1. Open the drop-down list of COMOS standard queries in the COMOS menu bar
by clicking the "Query" symbol.
2. Select the entry:
"Query for engineering objects > Query: Engineering objects".
Figure 4-181
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-182
Editing a query
This query is used for displaying the valves of the unit "Reaction 02".
1. For instance, open the underlying structure of the unit "Reaction 02".
2. Navigate to the folder "A30 Valves" and open the underlying objects.
3. Drag-and-drop any valve object to the field
"Class(es)" of the query.
4. Then move the unit node "Reaction 02" to the "Start object(s)" field of the query
via drag-and-drop.
5. Click the "Search" button in the menu bar of the query.
This will show all the valve objects present in the unit "Reaction 02".
Figure 4-183
4
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-184
Edit the query in such a way that even the "Operating temperature" and the
"Operating pressure" of the valve are displayed.
6. Select a valve object in the Navigator. The corresponding object attributes
are displayed in the detail window.
7. Open the underlying attributes of the valve in the detail window.
8. Open the underlying attributes of the attribute folder
"Process data".
9. Select the "Operating temperature" attribute and move it to the "Description"
column in the query via drag-and-drop.
Figure 4-185
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-186
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-187
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-188
11. In the query, change the value of the "Min. operating pressure" of valve "V001"
from "20" to "19" and then click in a new field.
The new value is highlighted again in orange to indicate that the value
changed.
Figure 4-189
In the previous chapter, you have created a data sheet revision for valve
"V001" (see Chapter 4.7.3 "Data sheet revision").
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-190
The "Min. operating pressure" is highlighted in orange and marked with the "*"
symbol. This means that the value is different than the one of the last revision.
For a detailed description, please refer to the Chapter 4.7.3 "Data sheet
revision".
Figure 4-191
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-192
Figure 4-193
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-194
Figure 4-195
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
21. To edit all the valves in a project, drag the project node "P&ID Application
example…" to the "Start object(s)" field.
Figure 4-196
Figure 4-197
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-198
23. You can sort the valves according to their plant unit to obtain a better overview.
To do this, right-click in the header of the "Label" column to open its
corresponding shortcut menu.
Click the entry:
"New > Owner".
Figure 4-199
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
A new column is created and the corresponding plant unit of the object is
displayed in it.
Figure 4-200
24. Reopen the shortcut menu by right-clicking the header and click the entry:
"Sorting / Filter".
Figure 4-201
You can sort the objects according to plant unit from this dialog.
To do this, double-click the first field of the "Column" column.
Figure 4-202
Figure 4-203
Figure 4-204
Figure 4-205
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-206
You have now sorted the valves according to their plant unit.
Figure 4-207
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Saving queries
In order to be able to reuse the query you just created, you have to save it.
1. To do this, click the "Save" button in the menu bar of the query.
2. A shortcut menu opens. Click the entry:
"Save As...".
Figure 4-208
3. Drag, for instance, the node "@Q Queries" and drop it in the field
"Save As...".
Figure 4-209
Figure 4-210
Figure 4-211
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
5. Reopen the query. If it is empty, click the "Search" button to search and
display the data.
Figure 4-212
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
The next time you open the query, the search will start automatically and you
will be shown the current valve data.
Figure 4-213
Note If you activated the automatic search feature and it contains a query with many
objects, the search might have a negative impact on the software performance
when processing the query.
Therefore, you should only activate the automatic search feature for smaller
queries.
Result
You have created, edited and saved your own query.
Therefore, you can use it over and over again.
This section describes how to create pipes and how to edit them.
In the case of the application example, you should create two intersecting pipes
and prioritize them.
Figure 4-214
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-215
4. Select the "Connection" tool in the toolbar of the P&ID diagram and draw
a horizontal pipe with it.
a. To define the start point for the pipe, left-click on the P&ID working area.
b. To specify the pipe run and define intermediate points, move the cursor
over the P&ID and click it with the left mouse button. The flow direction
corresponds to the direction in which you draw the pipe. The flow direction
is shown at the start of the pipe as an arrowhead.
c. To specify the end of the pipe, right-click anywhere on the P&ID.
Note If you draw a pipe with the drawing type "M22_P1" in a P&ID, a three-stage pipe
structure is created by default.
Pipe (container)
Pipe section
Pipe segment
If you draw a pipe with the drawing type "M22_P2" (KKS normal) or "M22_P3"
(KKS with small symbols) in a P&ID, a 2-stage pipe structure is created by
default.
Pipe section
Pipe segment
Figure 4-216
Figure 4-217
Note Two pipes that cross one another can be displayed in various ways.
You will find more detailed information on this topic in the manual: "COMOS
Process P&ID Administration", keyword "display types"
Figure 4-218
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-219
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-220
Figure 4-221
6. Repeat the steps and change the pipe priority of the vertical pipe to
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
"Secondary".
In the flow diagram, the priority pipe is displayed in bold and orange.
The vertical one is thinner and blue.
Figure 4-222
Figure 4-223
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-224
Note If, for instance, a frequently needed object cannot be found in the toolbar,
you can also edit it and extend it according to your needs.
The following manual gives you a detailed description on how to do this:
"COMOS Platform Getting Started", Chapter 11 "Base objects per toolbar"
For information on further helpful articles and links,
refer to chapter 6 "Further information" in this document.
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
2. Move the cursor to the pipe position where you wish to place the measurement
function.
Position the cursor in such a way that the lower connector point touches the
pipe.
If the symbol does not have any predefined connector points, place the
function and connect it subsequently with the "Connection" tool.
Figure 4-225
3. Pause briefly and then move the cursor from the pipe upwards.
The function docks automatically to the pipe and a measuring line is drawn
in between the pipe and the function.
Figure 4-226
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Note If a function was docked in the wrong position during placement, move the cursor
out of the drawing area and then back in again. The function moves again over
the P&ID, together with the cursor.
Note The function is created in the engineering data in accordance with the
configuration set by the administrator:
If all P&ID objects should be sorted according to category in parallel with your P&ID,
the function is created in the "A50 I&C (Instrumentation & Control)" folder under an
undefined position.
If all P&ID objects are supposed to be compiled under the P&ID, the function is
created directly underneath the P&ID.
Note The pipe segment is split automatically after placing the measurement function
inline device.
You will find more information on this topic in the manual:
"COMOS Process P&ID Operation", Chapter 10.3.4 "Sorting components under
pipe elements by pipe cut mode".
Figure 4-227
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-228
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-229
When you select this, the measurement function in the P&ID diagram changes
the corresponding representation automatically.
Figure 4-230
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
5. You can also define the "Function type" in the same way.
6. Open its tab and select, for instance, the entry "PLC, SPS".
Figure 4-231
Figure 4-232
Figure 4-233
Note You can find additional information on this topic in the "COMOS Platform
Operation" manual, keyword "Placing objects".
For information on further helpful articles and links,
refer to chapter 6 "Further information" in this document.
This section describes how to place and edit a control valve on the P&ID via the
base object view.
Figure 4-234
Figure 4-235
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Editing components
Define a membrane as an actuator type for the control valve.
1. To do this, select the control valve and open its shortcut menu with a right-
click.
2. Select the entry:
"Graphical settings > Actuator type > Membrane".
Figure 4-236
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-237
5. Then move the function upwards and left click on it to place the function.
Figure 4-238
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-239
Procedure
1. Use the "Connection" tool to create a signal line on the right connector
point of the measurement function.
2. Also create a signal line on the left connector point of the actuating function.
Figure 4-240
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
2 3
Figure 4-241
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-242
7. Select the left signal line of the actuating function and open its shortcut menu.
Figure 4-243
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-244
4.10.5 Pipe labels related to the pipe spec (spec break labels)
A pipe label is shown if objects are connected with each other whose pipe spec-
related attributes do not have the same values, e.g. pipe spec, nominal diameter
and nominal pressure.
In the application example, the nominal size and the nominal pressure of a pipe
are changed in order to trigger a pipe label on the control valve.
It contains a text showing which attributes vary between connected objects.
When you update the values, even the entry in the pipe label is updated.
Procedure
1. Open the P&ID diagram (DIN A1) of the unit "Reaction 02".
2. Select the pipe leading to the control valve.
Figure 4-245
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-246
Note Detailed information on horizontal data flow can be found in the chapter 4.4.2
"Horizontal data flow" in this document.
For information on further helpful articles and links,
refer to chapter 6 "Further information" in this document.
Figure 4-247
Figure 4-248
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
This section gives you a description of how to show/hide or freeze the contents
of a layer.
Procedure
1. Open a P&ID diagram.
2. In the P&ID menu bar, click on the "Layers" button .
Figure 4-249
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-250
Figure 4-251
Figure 4-252
Note You can find further information on this topic in the manuals:
"COMOS Platform Operation", keyword "Layers".
"COMOS Platform Administration", keyword "Setting up layers for reports".
Procedure
1. Open the P&ID diagram you created previously (DIN A1).
2. In the COMOS menu bar, click the "Status window" button .
The status window is displayed as a tab in the detail area of the Navigator.
Figure 4-253
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Note If, for instance, a frequently needed object cannot be found in the toolbar,
you can also edit it and extend it according to your requirements.
The following manual gives you a detailed description on how to do this:
"COMOS Platform Getting Started", Chapter 11 "Base objects per toolbar"
For information on further helpful articles and links,
refer to chapter 6 "Further information" in this document.
4. Move the cursor on the P&ID diagram and place the pump by clicking on the
desired spot.
Figure 4-254
2
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-255
5. Use the "Connection" tool to create a pipe in the reverse flow direction at
the pump output.
Figure 4-256
The pipe is also displayed in red for you to identify the error quickly.
6. If the chart is very large and confusing, click on the "Navigate" icon in the
status window and the defective object is displayed directly in the P&ID.
Figure 4-257
Figure 4-258
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
Figure 4-259
9. The status window shows the number of objects and connections placed in
the P&ID together with the corresponding number of inconsistencies.
Figure 4-260
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
This section shows you how to show the placing information of objects.
This allows you to see which objects have been placed and which not.
Note This function can have a negative effect on performance in big projects.
Therefore it is suggested to switch on this function only temporarily, for checking
purposes.
Procedure
1. Open the "View" menu in the COMOS menu bar.
2. Click the entry:
"Icon with placing information > For all placed objects"
Figure 4-261
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
A magenta check mark will now be shown in the Navigator next to the
corresponding object ( ) to indicate whether it has already been placed in
a report or not.
Figure 4-262
5 Conclusion
Thanks to this application example you have gained insight into the basic functions
and operating instructions of COMOS P&ID.
Further possibilities for efficiency improvement can be achieved by integrating the
areas of EI&C technology, pipe spec design and pipe spec management,
isometrics or 3D integration, as well as in subsequent plant operation thanks to
consistent data management in COMOS. The open system architecture also offers
the export of COMOS data to external formats or the import of data from external
applications, such as:
AUTOCAD DWG/DXF
ISO 15926 compatible Proteus-XML (formerly XMpLant)
Excel lists and data sheets (XLS/XLSX).
Export of P&ID data to SIMIT
Interface to Open Plant 3D
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
6 Further information
6.1 Websites
Table 6-1
Topic Title
\1\ Siemens Industry http://support.industry.siemens.com
Online Support
\2\ Download page for https://support.industry.siemens.com/cs/ww/en/view/109480739
this entry
\3\ COMOS P&ID http://w3.siemens.com/mcms/plant-engineering-
Product page software/en/comos-process/comos-p-and-id/Pages/Default.aspx
6.4 FAQs
Table 6-4
Topic Title
\1\ COMOS FAQs https://support.industry.siemens.com/cs/search?search=COMOS
&type=Faq&lc=en-WW
overview
\2\ How do you download https://support.industry.siemens.com/cs/ww/en/view/67811976
full versions of
COMOS/COMOS
Walkinside and
Service Packs or
order them on DVD?
\3\ How do you set up a https://support.industry.siemens.com/cs/ww/en/view/109474953
WebKey access for
COMOS in the GTAC
portal?
6.6 Manuals
Table 6-6
Topic Title
\1\ Manual: https://support.industry.siemens.com/cs/ww/en/view/60596677
COMOS Platform
Getting Started
\2\ Manual: https://support.industry.siemens.com/cs/ww/en/view/102422097
COMOS Platform
Administration (2014)
\3\ Manual: https://support.industry.siemens.com/cs/ww/en/view/109475960
COMOS Platform
Administration (2015)
\4\ Manual: https://support.industry.siemens.com/cs/ww/en/view/109475941
COMOS Platform
Operation
\5\ Manual: https://support.industry.siemens.com/cs/ww/en/view/109475944
COMOS Process
FEED Operation
\6\ Manual: https://support.industry.siemens.com/cs/ww/en/view/109475946
COMOS Process,
P&ID Administration
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved
7 History
Table 7-1
Version Date Change
V1.0 07/2016 First edition
Siemens AG 2016 All rights reserved