Sie sind auf Seite 1von 5

Public Work Authority

Drainage Network Projects Department IA


Design, Build, Operate and Maintain (DBOM)of Al Dhakhira
Sewage Treatment Works, Transfer Pumping Station and Associated Pipelines
Contract No.: C2014/140 Civil Project No: CP652

Observations & Comments Sheet (OCS)


OCS Ref. No.: CP652-OCS-STR-LBI-HRC-046 OCS Rev. : 2 Project Stage: Construction
Engineer in Charge: OCS Date: 4-May-17 Discipline: Structural
Submittal Ref.No and Rev.: CP652-STR-046-02 Description : Structural Calculation and Drawings - TSE Pumping Station

For shop drawings, refer to the shop 1=No Exceptions Taken 2=Make Corrections Noted 3=Amend and Resubmit
Assessment : 2=Make Corrections Noted drawing's individual return code. 4=Rejected - See Remarks 5=For Informational Purposes Only 6=Not required for Review

CONTRACTOR’s Input
Current
Reviewer Identification of comment's Reference Number of Doc. Returned Sign-Off
S/N Ref. Observations / Comments Code Comments (if any) (Open/Closed)
Indicator source: (title /page /clause) or Drwg. (Open/Closed)

Allowable bearing capacity and soil subgrade modulus Allowable bearing capacity and soil subgrade modulus
shall be supported by geotechnical calculations based parameters considered in the design are conservative and
on the final geotechnical investigation report. the same shall be verified if the actual parameters are found
NA Structural Calculation to be less than the considered values.
1 1 Closed
Section 3 & All drawings

OP Complied
Foundation level should be confirmed based on final The foundation levels are as per the latest civil drawings
NA geotechnical investigation report recommendations. Structural Calculation
2 1 Closed
Section 3 & All drawings
OP No further comments
All structural drawings shall be coordinated with final Noted
NA approved MEP/Civil drawings
3 Approval of structural drawings is subject to approval of All Structural Calculation 2 Closed
OP MEP and Civil drawings

All levels shown in structural drawings should be Noted


coordinated with final approved civil drawings. Drawings
NA and calculations incorporating final level should be
4 submitted for review. All Structural Drawings 2 Closed
Contractor to update with any civil drawing changes
OP when required

Raft slab crack width, ULS and early thermal check Calculation sheets are added
MC calculation sheets are missing to be provided.

Structural Calculation 1 Closed


5
Complied Section 3
OP

Page 1 of 5
Public Work Authority
Drainage Network Projects Department IA
Design, Build, Operate and Maintain (DBOM)of Al Dhakhira
Sewage Treatment Works, Transfer Pumping Station and Associated Pipelines
Contract No.: C2014/140 Civil Project No: CP652

Observations & Comments Sheet (OCS)


OCS Ref. No.: CP652-OCS-STR-LBI-HRC-046 OCS Rev. : 2 Project Stage: Construction
Engineer in Charge: OCS Date: 4-May-17 Discipline: Structural
Submittal Ref.No and Rev.: CP652-STR-046-02 Description : Structural Calculation and Drawings - TSE Pumping Station

For shop drawings, refer to the shop 1=No Exceptions Taken 2=Make Corrections Noted 3=Amend and Resubmit
Assessment : 2=Make Corrections Noted drawing's individual return code. 4=Rejected - See Remarks 5=For Informational Purposes Only 6=Not required for Review

CONTRACTOR’s Input
Current
Reviewer Identification of comment's Reference Number of Doc. Returned Sign-Off
S/N Ref. Observations / Comments Code Comments (if any) (Open/Closed)
Indicator source: (title /page /clause) or Drwg. (Open/Closed)

Concrete cover for slab at 17,20m level is not correct Cheecked and incorporated
MC (less than 50mm). Please correct cover values and
update calculation accordingly. Structural Calculation 1 Closed
6
Sheet 46,48
OP Complied

Incremental deflection check for Roof slab at 28.40m Deflection check is carried out for the latest structural dwgs
level is not correct. As presented rel defl= 32,39- between grids F and G. The same is presented in the report
MC (24,46/2)=20,16mm which is more than 13mm. Please Structural Calculation
7 update deflection check considering that deflection at 2 Closed
Sheet 71
axis K is zero.

OP No further comments
Please correct the term "deflection" into term As per the latest drawings, slab @ 17.55 lvl is the slab
"settlement" considering that slab at +17,20m level is in covering Cable basement. However its noted for the grade
MC Structural Calculation slab at the same level.
8 contact with soil. 1 Closed
Sheet 49,50
OP No further comments
Reinforcement details for columns C1, C2 and C3 is not Column design is done for the revised column forces for
adequate. Please provide column elevation showing all which reinforcement is designed. Detailed drawings for the
reinforcement details. cloumns elevations shall be furnished during shop drawings
MC stage. Closed
CP652-STW-STR-CPL- 1
9
01746
No further comments
OP Closed

Acceptable CP652-STW-STR-CPL-
10 OP Closed
01730 Rev 01
Acceptable CP652-STW-STR-CPL-
11 OP Closed
01731 Rev 01

Page 2 of 5
Public Work Authority
Drainage Network Projects Department IA
Design, Build, Operate and Maintain (DBOM)of Al Dhakhira
Sewage Treatment Works, Transfer Pumping Station and Associated Pipelines
Contract No.: C2014/140 Civil Project No: CP652

Observations & Comments Sheet (OCS)


OCS Ref. No.: CP652-OCS-STR-LBI-HRC-046 OCS Rev. : 2 Project Stage: Construction
Engineer in Charge: OCS Date: 4-May-17 Discipline: Structural
Submittal Ref.No and Rev.: CP652-STR-046-02 Description : Structural Calculation and Drawings - TSE Pumping Station

For shop drawings, refer to the shop 1=No Exceptions Taken 2=Make Corrections Noted 3=Amend and Resubmit
Assessment : 2=Make Corrections Noted drawing's individual return code. 4=Rejected - See Remarks 5=For Informational Purposes Only 6=Not required for Review

CONTRACTOR’s Input
Current
Reviewer Identification of comment's Reference Number of Doc. Returned Sign-Off
S/N Ref. Observations / Comments Code Comments (if any) (Open/Closed)
Indicator source: (title /page /clause) or Drwg. (Open/Closed)

1. The base slab and basement walls concrete joints


shall be provided with water stop to prevent ground
surface water flooding to penetrate inside this dry wall
structure.
12 OP 2. Show and submit separately the layout and detail of CP652-STW-STR-CPL- 2 Closed
concrete joints, construction joint/control joints for base 01741 Rev 01
slab and basement walls showing the water stop detail.

Acceptable CP652-STW-STR-CPL-
13 OP 1 Closed
01742 Rev 01
Acceptable CP652-STW-STR-CPL-
14 OP 1 Closed
01743 Rev 01
See comment 12 CP652-STW-STR-CPL-
15 OP 2
01744 Rev 01
See comment 12 CP652-STW-STR-CPL-
16 OP 2
01745 Rev 01
Closed
See comment 12 CP652-STW-STR-CPL-
17 OP 2
01746 Rev 01
See comment 12 CP652-STW-STR-CPL-
18 OP 2
01747 Rev 01
Acceptable CP652-STW-STR-CPL-
19 OP 1 Closed
01748 Rev 00
Acceptable CP652-STW-STR-CPL-
20 OP 1 Closed
01749 Rev 00
See comment 12 CP652-STW-STR-CPL- Update on Revised Submission: Rev.
2 Open
21 OP
01750 Rev 00 03 - RFC Structural drawing (CP652-
22 OP
Acceptable CP652-STW-STR-CPL-
01751 Rev 00
1 STW-STR-CPL-01753) has been modify Closed
to include the pedestal reinforcement Page 3 of 5
details.
Public Work Authority
Drainage Network Projects Department IA
Design, Build, Operate and Maintain (DBOM)of Al Dhakhira
Sewage Treatment Works, Transfer Pumping Station and Associated Pipelines
Contract No.: C2014/140 Civil Project No: CP652

Observations & Comments Sheet (OCS)


OCS Ref. No.: CP652-OCS-STR-LBI-HRC-046 OCS Rev. : 2 Project Stage: Construction
Engineer in Charge: OCS Date: 4-May-17 Discipline: Structural
Submittal Ref.No and Rev.: CP652-STR-046-02 Description : Structural Calculation and Drawings - TSE Pumping Station

For shop drawings, refer to the shop 1=No Exceptions Taken 2=Make Corrections Noted 3=Amend and Resubmit
Assessment : 2=Make Corrections Noted drawing's individual return code. 4=Rejected - See Remarks 5=For Informational Purposes Only 6=Not required for Review

Update on Revised Submission:


CONTRACTOR’s Input Rev.
Reviewer Identification of comment's Reference Number of Doc.
Current
Returned
03 - RFC Structural drawing (CP652- Sign-Off
S/N Ref.
Indicator source: (title /page /clause)
Observations / Comments
or Drwg. Code STW-STR-CPL-01753)
Comments (if any) has been modify
(Open/Closed)
(Open/Closed)

Acceptable CP652-STW-STR-CPL-
to include the pedestal reinforcement
23 OP
01752 Rev 00
1
details. Closed

Acceptable
Rev. 03 RFC Structural drawing (CP652-STW-STR-CPL-01753)
CP652-STW-STR-CPL- 1 has been modify to include the pedestal reinforcement Closed
24 OP
01753 Rev 00 details.

Page 4 of 5
Public Work Authority
Drainage Network Projects Department IA
Design, Build, Operate and Maintain (DBOM)of Al Dhakhira
Sewage Treatment Works, Transfer Pumping Station and Associated Pipelines
Contract No.: C2014/140 Civil Project No: CP652

Observations & Comments Sheet (OCS)


OCS Ref. No.: CP652-OCS-STR-LBI-HRC-046 OCS Rev. : 2 Project Stage: Construction
Engineer in Charge: Update on Revised Submission: Rev.
OCS Date: 4-May-17 Discipline: Structural
Submittal Ref.No and Rev.: CP652-STR-046-02 03 - Calculation
Description : Structural RFC Structural drawing
and Drawings - TSE (CP652-
Pumping Station

For shop drawings, refer to the shop 1=No Exceptions Taken


STW-STR-CPL-01753) has3=Amend
2=Make Corrections Noted
been modify
and Resubmit
Assessment : 2=Make Corrections Noted drawing's individual return code. 4=Rejected - See Remarks to include
5=For the pedestal
Informational Purposes Only reinforcement
6=Not required for Review

details. CONTRACTOR’s Input


Current
Reviewer Identification of comment's Reference Number of Doc. Returned Sign-Off
S/N Ref. Observations / Comments Code Comments (if any) (Open/Closed)
Indicator source: (title /page /clause) or Drwg. (Open/Closed)

Rev 02 Comments
Minor changes of levels on base slab has no significant
effect on the structure design CP652-STW-STR-CPL-
25 OP 1 Closed
01741 and 01742 Rev 02

CP652-STW-STR-CPL- 1 Closed
26 OP
01744 and 01745 Rev 02

Th floor slopes are mostly called out incorrect as 0.4%.


They must be 1.0% minimum and the floor elevations
27 BWS revised accordingly on the Shop Drawings. Base Plan / 01741 2 Open

Reviewer Signature : Date PM Signature : Date

Page 5 of 5

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen