12/30/2017 What conversations on electoral technology are happening in the Philippines?

| International IDEA

NEWS

Home (/) / News & Media (/news-media) / News (/news-media/news) / What conversations on electoral technology are happening in the Philippines?
SHARE(https://www.addtoany.com/share#url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.idea.int%2Fnews-media%2Fnews%2Fwhat-conversations-electoral-technology-are-happening-
philippines&title=What%20conversations%20on%20electoral%20technology%20are%20happening%20in%20the%20Philippines%3F)
NEWS ARTICLE

What conversations on electoral technology are happening in the

Philippines? - PHILIPPINES
BY: Adhy Aman (/about-us/people/adhy-aman) Peter Wolf (/about-us/people/peter-wolf)
PUBLISHED: 28/09/2016 | ASIA & THE PACIFIC (/OUR-WORK/WHERE-WE-WORK/ASIA-PACIFIC) | ELECTIONS (/OUR-WORK/WHAT-WE-DO/ELECTIONS)

Philippine policy makers and civil society have interesting discussions ahead about the role of technology
in elections. What are the needs? What needs to be done differently? What needs to be improved? What
new goals are to be achieved? These questions guided discussions as International IDEA’s Election Tech
Tour of Asia moved on to Manila, the Philippines. T
he event was hosted in partnership with the Commission on Elections (COMELEC) and the Task Force Eleksyon comprising of the Legal Network
for Truthful Elections (LENTE), the National Movement for Free Elections (NAMFREL), Simbahamg Lingkod ng Bayan and De La Salle University’s
Robredo Institute of Governance and consisted of smaller meetings as well as a larger roundtable discussion.
One of the first issues addressed was the question of electronic voting machines, as the Philippines currently has two full sets. The Precinct Count
Optical Scanners (PCOS) used in the recent May 2016 General Elections were leased and cannot be used for the next general elections, unless they
are bought. The machines used for 2013 General Elections were bought, but need to be refurbished before another use. For the 2019 general
election, the Philippines has to decide if they will buy the machines used in 2016, refurbish the machines used in 2013 or buy new equipment,
which may entail the selection of a new technological solution such as touch screen voting machines.
Whatever option is taken in the end probably needs to be accompanied by a review of existing laws. The 1985 Omnibus Election Law has been
deemed outdated and needs to be adjusted to reflect contemporary situations. The Automated Election System Law, initially from 1997 and
amended 2007, features remnants of provisions for paper-based elections or specific to election technology that was not chosen in the end. For
example, the requirement for an additional paper trail for the ballot scanning machines as required by the Supreme Court is widely seen to have
come from a part of the law that was intended for touch-screen systems.
Another question discussed is whether sending the same election result data through three different tabulation systems creates the intended
transparency or whether it adds complexity to the tabulation process that is difficult to explain and understand. This is especially true if data from
those tabulation systems is observed in real time, as there are various factors that may cause data transmission be interrupted to some and not to
other servers. As a consequence, the different servers may have received different election result data at a certain point in time. This discrepancy
may give rise to allegations of fraud, which may have been the case in the May 2016 General Elections.
How much each of these features have added to the transparency of the automated election system, the extent to which some of them maybe
streamlined and what the impact of any changes would be on the credibility of the system will all be interesting discussions for any changes in the
legal framework.
The roundtable discussion in Manila also discussed the use of open source software. Currently, the COMELEC relies on software produced by the
supplier of the PCOS machines to operate them. There have been calls to employ Philippine experts to create the software in an open source
environment and some progress in developing such a system has already been made. The hope is that this would reduce cost and would make it
easier for the software to be tested independently and without any restrictions. The COMELEC Chairman expressed his interest in looking into this
issue further.
COMELEC intends to organise another ICT stakeholder consultation involving civil society organizations, academia and experts. Further, COMELEC
has important decisions to make regarding the technology to use in the 2019 General Elections. Due to state budgeting and procurement rules,
initial decisions will already need to be made before the first quarter of 2017. Whatever the course of the discussion may be, Commissioner Luie
Guia summarized the goals of the discussions by saying, “technology is merely a tool and it should not become the ‘end’. Upholding the electoral
principles set in law is the ‘end’”.

https://www.idea.int/news-media/news/what-conversations-electoral-technology-are-happening-philippines 1/3
12/30/2017 What conversations on electoral technology are happening in the Philippines? | International IDEA
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

SENIOR PROGRAMME OFFICER Adhy Aman is a Senior Programme Officer of International IDEA’s Asia and the
Adhy Aman Pacific Region Programme and Country Programme Manager for Bhutan.

+ SEND EMAIL + VIEW BIO (/about-us/people/adhy-aman)

(/email/node/256360/field_email)

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

TECHNICAL MANAGER Peter Wolf is Technical Manager in the Electoral Processes and Constitution-
Peter Wolf Building programmes. Wolf’s research and work focuses on the application of
ICTs in elections and online networking, with a special emphasis on sustainable
and trusted implementation of technology in electoral processes.

+ VIEW BIO (/about-us/people/peter-wolf)

RELATED NEWS & MEDIA

DEC NEWS ARTICLE

22
2017
Myanmar hosts its first Interparliamentary Conference on Budget Oversight (/news-
media/news/myanmar-hosts-its-first-interparliamentary-conference-budget-oversight)

(/news-media/news/myanmar-hosts-its-first-interparliamentary-conference-budget-oversight)
DEC NEWS ARTICLE
18
2017
Discussing the state of democracy in Indonesia (/news-media/news/discussing-state-democracy-
indonesia)

(/news-media/news/discussing-state-democracy-indonesia)
DEC From left to right:
FEATURE STORY
15 Deputy
2017 Commissioner
India joins the BRIDGE family (/news-media/news/india-joins-bridge-family)
Sudeep Jain (ECI),
Dr Quraishi
(International IDEA
Board of Advisors),
Programme Officer
DEC Erik Asplund,
PRESS RELEASE
13 Director Vivek Khare
2017 (ECI), Electoral
Despite growing challenges to democracy, data reveals that globally democracy is not in decline
Expert Dr. Noor
(/news-media/news/despite-growing-challenges-democracy-data-reveals-globally-democracy-
Mohammad (ECI)
not-decline) and Shanti Ram
Bimali (International
IDEA). Photo credit:
(/news-media/news/despite-growing-challenges-democracy-data-reveals-globally-democracy-not-decline)
DEC ECI.
SPEECH
08 (/news-media/news/india-joins-bridge-family)
2017
10th Bali Democracy Forum: Statement by International IDEA (/news-media/media/10th-bali-
democracy-forum-statement-international-idea)

https://www.idea.int/news-media/news/what-conversations-electoral-technology-are-happening-philippines 2/3
12/30/2017 What conversations on electoral technology are happening in the Philippines? | International IDEA

NOV NEWS ARTICLE

30
2017
Champion of democracy, Surin Pitsuwan, passes (/news-media/news/champion-democracy-
surin-pitsuwan-passes)

(/news-media/news/champion-democracy-surin-pitsuwan-passes)

KEEP IN TOUCH

International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance (International IDEA)

Strömsborg, SE-103 34
Stockholm, Sweden
Tel: +46 8 698 37 00
Fax: +46 8 20 24 22

CONTACT US (/CONTACT-US)

OUR WORK

Where We Work (/our-work/where-we-work)

What We Do (/our-work)

DATA & TOOLS

Data (/data-tools)
Tools (/data-tools)

PUBLICATIONS

Catalogue (/publications/catalogue)
Order Printed Publications (http://www.idea.int/order-printed-publications)
CC Licence (/creative-commons-licence)

NEWS & MEDIA

Press Releases (/news-media/news?field_news_type_value=press_release)

Events (/news-media/events/)
Media (/news-media/media)
Newsletters (/news-media/newsletters)

ABOUT US

About (/about-us)
FAQs (/faq)
Careers (/careers)
Procurement & Tenders (/about-us/procurement-and-tenders)
Partners (/about-us/partners)

NEWSLETTERS

Stay informed of our latest news!

SUBSCRIBE (HTTP://EEPURL.COM/CO3MI5)

GOVERNANCE LOGIN (/MEMBER-LOGIN)

(https://www.facebook
(https://twitter.co
(https://www
(/rss.x

© 2017 International IDEA. All Rights Reserved | Terms and Conditions (/terms-and-conditions) | Privacy Policy (/privacy-policy) | Cookie Policy (http://www.idea.int/cookies) | Sitemap
(/site-map)
https://www.idea.int/news-media/news/what-conversations-electoral-technology-are-happening-philippines 3/3