‘US 2008)
cu») United States
1304081
cz) Patent Application Publication co) Pub. No.: US 2008/0113040 A1
Doona et al.
6
(76) Inveators: Christopher J. Deona, Marlboro, MA
(US); Florence E, Feeherry, Wellesley,
MA (US); Kenneth Kustin, San Dicyo,
CA (US); Maria Curtin, Easton, MA
ws)
Coresponilence Address:
Natick Soldier RDEC
15 Kansas Street
Natick, MA 01760-5035 (US)
(21) Appl.Nos — 120008,035
(22) Filed
Jan, 8, 2008
(63) Continuation-in-pare of application No, 11/105,211
filed on Ape 13, 2005, which isa contination-in-pat
of application No, 10/988, 442, fled on Nov. 10, 2004
(43) Pub. Date May 15, 2008
ication Classification
SI) Inch
AOIN
(2) US.CL
som (2006.01)
424/661
on ABSTRACT
‘The present invention provides for a method of generating an
aqueous solution comprising chlorine dioxide using a chlo
rine-containing chemical oxidant; an effector having the
capacity to edice sad chlorine-contaning chemical oxidant
‘achemical reductant; and water and operating in either batch
‘or continuous-flow modes. In batch mode, the aqueons chlo
rine dioxide solution can be device,
erated in a spray
bottle, ora bucket to disinfect objects by spraying and wiping
by pouring, or by immersion, respectively. In continuous
flaw mode, the aqueons chlorine dioxide solution ean be
generated in low tubes of eoatinvousstieted tank reactors,
then placed inside a suitable sprayer device, botle, or bucket.US 2008/0113040 AI
PROCESS FOR PRODUCING AQUEOUS:
‘CHLORINE DIOXIDE FOR SURFACE,
DISINFECTION AND DECONTAMINATION,
(CROSS-REPERENCE TO RELATED
APPLICATION
[0001] This is. continuation-n-part of US. patent appli
‘eatin Ser. No, 11/105,21, filed Ape. 13, 2005, which i 3
‘contination in par of patent application Ser. No. 10/988.442
filed Nov. 10,2004, inthe names of Christopher J. Doons et
‘al, which applications are incorporated in thei entirety
herein by reference.
‘STATEMENT OF GOVERNMENT INTEREST
[0002] The invention described herein may be manufae-
tured and used by the USS. Government for governmental
purposes without the payment of any royalty thereon,
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
[0003] 1. Field oFthe Invention
[0008] The present invention relates to lightweight, por
lable, selecontained devices to disinfect microbiologically
‘contaminated surfaces andlor equipment and whose opera
tion does not require external power sources. The invention,
more specifically, relates to sch deviews that use chemical
methods fo generate aqueous solutions of disinfectant, which
allow: immersion of contaminated objects or ate dispensed
“iretly or sprayed as a ine mist onto contaminated surfaces,
for purposes of reducing or eliminating inhabitant microor
anisms,
[0005] 2. Description of the Prior Art
[0006] ‘There is # need for on-site decontamination of su
Tees, such as the surfaces of military field feeding equip-
ment, food contact surfaces, food processing or handling
‘equipment, and the surfaces of such foods as melons, strw=
berries, apples, tomatoes, and other sliced or whole fits and
vegetables. This need cannot be met by the application of
mild disinfectant solutions in which te disinfecting agent is
not poweeful enough (for example, hydrogen peroxide or
‘dotegent), the concentration ofthe disinfectant is too dilute
‘o rapidly Kill he target microorganisms insufficient mum
bers, o the concentration of the lethal chemical agent is 100
shortved due to chemical decomposition. In eontradistine-
tion, the power-fre generation af chlorine dioxide solution
meets the requirements for safe, rapid, and easily deployed
‘dccontamination system without altering the quality of food
stulls while minimizing potential hazards 10 the user, the
‘eaviroament, or consumer of such food-prepaation surfaces,
and equipment and food.
[0007] Powerful disinfectant agents such as chlorine,
‘ozone, oF cloransines utilize individnaized and often heavy
‘equipment that is electrically powered and require special
handling. Ozone rapidly degrades chemically and must be
‘continunvsly generated trough specialized electrically pow=
‘ered equipment to maintain an elfective lethal dose. During
fand alter the microbial decontamination process, these
‘chomical agents proxivce harmful by-products in the work
place atmosphere that potentially can be harmful to human
health or the environment. Chlorine isan effotve disintee
tant of wastewaters, but chlorine is also known to react with
‘organic matter to produce harmful ehlorinated by-produets oF
May 15, 2008
careinogenie compounds such as carbon tetrachloride, Aleo-
bolic solutions require immersion or scrubbing, which may
‘not reach inaccessible surlaees Suel as the calyx region of
‘apples or inside the webbing on the surlace of eanialoupe
‘inds), or may bo undesirable when contacting Food peepara-
tion surfaces, Zoodstulls, or other consumables
[0008] |The basis ofthe present invention isa novel method
‘hatha been developed fr the controlled generation of aue-
‘us solutions of ehlorine dioxide without requiring the nse of
power, or where sparks, flames and fre are hazardous, unat-
‘ainable, or otherse undesirable. This method is likewise
stitale fora lightweight, portable assembly for disinfection
of microbiologically contaminated equipment, surfiees, and
factual foodstuffs and iavolves small amounts of safe. dry
chemical reagents. The chemical combination that has been
‘developed for ths purpose is convenient to cary and mixes
readily with water to controllably generate biocidal chlorine
oxide solutions (US. patent application Ser. No, 10°88,
‘442, Publication Number US2006'0097222 Al, Chemical.
Combination for Chemical Generation of Disinfectant and
Heat, Doona etal),
[0009] This novel chemical combination has boen used
‘inside closed containers to generate humid gaseous chlorine
dioxide environments (US. patent application Ser. No.
11/105,21, Publication Number US200610099121 AI, Por-
‘able Chemical Sterilizer, Doona et a). One particular pur-
pose of this technology is the power-fre sterilization of
‘redical equipment and surgical insirumeats in austere cay
ronments as may be encountered by military farforwaed sur
sical teams, disaster lief workers, emergency fist-respond-
er, oF by humanitarian si workers in third workl countries.
This technology has also been used under less stringent con-
ditions to eliminate bacterial pathogens such as Listeria
‘monocytogenes and Escherichia coli from the surfaces of
tomatoes without diseoloring the fruit o to inactivate the
polyphenoloxidase enzyme in sliced apples, thereby prevent-
Jing enzymatic browning ofthe ext apple tissue with expostre
{o ambient oxygen. The container configuration has been
_gencmlly aimed at having sufficient size and capacity to ald
4 standard tray of surgical instruments, but the container
‘ontiguration can be varied without changing the fundamen-
‘al principles of operation or procedure for achieving target
‘microbial kills.
[0010] | Lare-scale food handling equipment and food eon-
fact surfaces such as countertops and cutting boards in need
of disinfection cannot ulwaysbe conveniently removed, sepa-
‘ated, or inserted into reasonably sized containers for expo-
sure ta ehlorine dioxide environment. However, chlorine
oxide cen be used o sanitize surfaces that come into contact
‘ith food, and thereby prevent the spread of food-borne i
‘esses through direct contactor through secondary conta
nation, by developing an alternative method of dispensing,
elivering, or contacting the chlorine dioxide to these con.
‘aminated surlaces.
[0011] ‘Therefore an object of this invention is to control
Jably generate aqueous solutions of bioeidal chlorine dioxide
‘using the chemical combination described above, anda nm
‘erat variants thereof, ina manner differnt from that used to
create humid gnseows chlorine dioxide environments in
closed containers for purposes of medical steilzation or
pradce decontamination, also described above. The chen
‘al combination consists of mixtures of prescribed amouUS 2008/0113040 AI
chlorite (NaClO,), sodium sulfite (Na,80,),
sodium hydrogen ascorbate (C,f1,0,Na),and water that react
in either batch mode or in continnous- ew processes to gen-
‘erate an agueous solution of ehlorine dioxide, The bate
mode generation of aqueous chlorine dioxide solution can
involve the use of a container comprising a lightweight, por
table, handheld, elosable plastic bottle (rigid plastic or flex-
‘ble plastic pouch material work equally well) and equipped
‘with an adapter to receive a manvally-operated tigger
sprayer commonly found on ordinary household cleansers
Aer generation, the aqueous chlorine dioxide solution ean
be dispensed directly onto the mierobiologically contami-
nated surfaces from the opened plastic bttleor delivered as @
fine mist or aerosol by spraying after losing the botle with
the spray device to achieve the intended surface disinfection
‘or decontamination process. Alternatively, the batch mode
‘Reneration of aqueous chlorine dioxide solution ean involve a
‘container comprising an open bucket that either allows for
‘immersion of contaminated objects suchas fresh produce into
the disinfecting solution, of into which can be immersed
sponges or mops to transfer the chlorine dioxide to the target
‘rea for leasing and disinfection, Another alternative com-
prises continuous-flow systems comprising tubes or eontin-
‘slow sted tank reactors that are open toa feed of fresh
reagents at a controlled rte and tht also allow chemical
reaction o fake place and produce the aqueous chlorine diox-
ide disinfectant solution that may thenbe placed into bucket,
bottle, or sprayer device
[0012] As indicated above, to accomplish these objectives,
‘one cannot simply ining procedures described i
patent application Ser. No. 11/105,211. Rather, one must
‘determine appropriate variants of the novel chemical combi
nation described in U.S. patent application Ser. No, 10988,
442, elect an appropriate sprayer deviee, bottle, or bucket,
and develop a mixing procedure. Tis disclosure details this
nove process apparatus, and procedure for accomplishing an
!aquects chlorine dioxide solution forelfctive disinfection
oodbomne or infectious microorganisms contaminating sur-
such as chlorine, ethylene oxide, and
‘Tuorine-containing interhalogens are stable but highly reae-
tive chemicals that must be teansported in bulky, secure con-
iners to ensure softy. While these chemicals can be trans-
ported they are not efficacious in. food-preparation
‘environments because of thor large weight, srs, and incon-
venient and ineffective methods of aplication. Traditional
micthods of generating chlorine diode are too cumbersome,
too slow, oF too hazardous to allow disinfection of surfaces
snd foodstlls,
[0014] Forexample, Svoboda etal. US, Pat, No. 4021 585
teaches the spraying of Ieshly slaughtered meat carcasses
With ehlorine dioxide solutions for disinfection without
bleaching or discoloring the meat surface. However, the chlo-
is generated “with commercially available equip
‘which would be unstable fora kitchen or dining
area Toeation, especially those that are transportable for mi
tary il feoding, forthe reasons indicated above.
[0015] Electrochemical methods usually mise the oxida-
tion number of chlorine within # elorine-containing eom-
pound, eg. oxidizing aqueous chloride solutions, often
brines, Rojas, Ser. No. 10/447.572, Publication Number US
20040104127. Chemical methods favor the formation of
May 15, 2008
chlorine gas for this purpose, Jeffies, Leta. US. Pat, No.
4,908,188. Alternatively, the oxidation number of chlorine in
@ chlorine-containing compound can be lowered. For
‘example, reductionof sodium chlorate by hydrogen peroxide,
alycerol or sucrose has been suggested, Khan etal. US, Pat
No. 6.287.533, These methods require high temperatures
andloreatalysts, andl are not suitable for sae, rapid generation
fof chlorine dioxide solutions in a hospital, ktehen or other
{ood processing environment,
[0016] Because of chlorine dioxide’s potential as a wor
‘lace, health clinic or home disinfectant, methods have been
‘developed to circumvent these of inconvenient and heavy oF
pressurized eylinder-requiring electrochemical equipment or
Fhazardous strong oxidants such as bypochlorous ack. ese
methods are based on proton transfer to sodium chlorite by
‘acidification, Acidification-generated chlonous acid dispro-
portionates, producing chloride and chlorate ions and various
mounts ofchlorine dioxide. The prior art shows tat chlorine
dioxide so produced can be used for disinfection in food
processing plans
[0017] For example, Mason etl. US. Pat, No. 4,731,193
And US. Pat No, 4.889.654 disclose an aqueous foam com-
taining chlorine dioxide for his purpose. The patent claims to
‘mask the odor of chlorine dioxide, because “is strong.
‘unpleasant odor when dissolved in water makes i impossible
to spray al concentrations necessary to achieve sanitation.”
‘Mason tal, do notteach anew method of generating chlorine
oxide, The patent states that"... generating the eblorine