Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Unit- 2
Consumer Behavior
In Services
Unit-2 Consumer Behaviour in Services
4
Information search,
Evaluation of alternatives,
4
Consumption Value
Consumers services and service providers choice
is influenced by consumption value.
Consumption value is the perceived value or utility that an
individual believes a specific choice will provide.
Conditional value
6
……Consumption Value
i)Functional Value is the perceived utility acquired
when a particular choice provides utilitarian or
functional benefits for the consumer.
the functional value of any automobile is to
provide a transportation service.
…..Consumption Value
ii)Social Value is the perceived utility acquired
from making a purchase decision that is
associated with a particular referent group.
….Consumption Value
v)Conditional Value is the perceived utility
provided when an alternative is chosen
an consumptio
Clothing
Jewelry
Most
Furniture
Easy to evaluate
Houses
Automobiles
Most
d
Restaurant meals
Goods Services
Vacations
n
Haircuts
Child care
Television repair
Legal services
Root canals
Auto repair
Medical diagnosis
Continuum of Evaluation for Different Types of Products
Difficult to evaluate
1
3
High in search High in experience High in credence qualities qualities qualities
Experience Qualities
5
Attributes that can only be discerned after purchase or during
consumption.
Experience qualities include taste and we arability.
Examples: vacations and restaurant meals are high in
experience qualities
Unit-2 Consumer Behaviour in Services
Credence Qualities
Ctd….
Goods high in search qualities are the easiest to evaluate
(left end of the continuum).
Goods and service high in experience qualities are more
difficult to evaluate because they must be purchased and
consumed before assessment is possible (center of
continuum).
Goods and services high in credence qualities are the
most Unit-2 Consumer Behaviour in Services difficult to evaluate because the
Information Search
17
…Information Search
…..Most managers in service industries recognize
the strong influence of word of mouth in services.
Consumers find post purchase information seeking more
essential with services than with goods because services
possess experience qualities that cannot be adequately
assessed before purchase.
consumers select the first acceptable alternative rather than searching Service
Purchase and Consumption - Emotion and Mood
Emotion and mood are feeling states that influence people's perceptions
3 and evaluations of their experiences.
1
encounters succeed.
Moods and emotions influence service customers is to bias
the way they judge service encounters and providers.
Moods Unit and -2 Consumer Behaviour in Services emotions affect theway
3
3
Service environment
Values,
Experiences,
Unit-2 Consumer Behaviour in Services
Abilities to pay,
3 Appearance,
5
Age,
…..Innovation Diffusion
An Offering:
That has a relative advantage over existing or
competing products;
That is compatible with existing norms, values,
and behaviors;
4
0
…..Innovation Diffusion
Services are :
Less communicable,
Less divisible,
More complex, and
Less compatible than goods.
4
8
Services are less communicable because they are intangible (e.g.,
their features cannot be displayed, illustrated, or compared) and
often unique to each buyer (as in a medical diagnosis or dental
care).
…..Innovation Diffusion
Services are less divisible because of Impossibility to
sample or test on a limited basis (e.g., how does one
"sample" a medical diagnosis or a haircut?).
Greater search costs and monetary costs may be involved in changing brands of
services than in changing brands of goods
Brand Loyalty
Consumers have more difficulty being aware of the
availability of substitutes, and higher risks may
accompany services because of the:
difficulty of obtaining information about service,
consumers may be unaware of alternatives or substitutes for
their brands
4
8
the recognition of the need for repeated patronage in order to
obtain optimum satisfaction from the seller .
Unit-2
Consumer Behavior
In Services
The primary objective of service producers is to develop and provide offerings that satisfy consumer needs and expectations, thereby ensuring
their own economic survival.
To close the customer gap between expectations and perceptions service providers need to understand:
Consumers have a more difficult time evaluating and choosing services than goods, because;
Consumer evaluation processes for goods and services varies in all stages of the buying process.
Information search,
Evaluation of alternatives,
Consumption Value
Consumption value is the perceived value or utility that an individual believes a specific choice will provide.
Emotional value
Epistemic value
Conditional value
5
0
……Consumption Value
i)Functional Value is the perceived utility acquired when a particular choice provides utilitarian or functional benefits for the consumer.
…..Consumption Value
ii)Social Value is the perceived utility acquired from making a purchase decision that is
value.
….Consumption Value
within a consumer.
Tattoos are as a means of self-expression iv)Epistemic value is the value acquired when a purchase decision is perceived to satisfy a desire for
knowledge, provide novelty, or arouse curiosity.
Museums, historical sites, zoos, and botanical gardens are visited because of the epistemic value provided.
because of temporary situational factors that will enhance one of the consumption values.
Time pressure or
2.Experience Qualities: attributes a consumer can determine after purchase (or during consumption) of a product
Most Most
Goods Services
Easy to evaluate
an consumptio
d n
5
3
Difficult to evaluate
Restaurant meals
Medical diagnosis
Television repair
Legal services
Automobiles
Root canals
Auto repair
Child care
Vacations
Furniture
Haircuts
Clothing
Jewelry
Houses
Search Qualities
Search qualities include color, style, price, fit, feel, hardness, and smell
Experience Qualities
5
5 Attributes that can only be discerned after purchase or during consumption.
Credence Qualities
Ctd….
Goods high in search qualities are the easiest to evaluate (left end of the continuum).
Goods and service high in experience qualities are more difficult to evaluate because they must be purchased and consumed before assessment is
possible (center of continuum).
Goods and services high in credence qualities are the mostUnit-2 Consumer Behaviour in Services difficult to evaluate because the
Services
14
Specific areas where characteristics of services may lead to divergent evaluation processes and altered consumer behavior are:
1) Information search 2) Evaluative criteria 3) Size and composition of the evoked set of alternatives 4) Perceived risk 5) Adoption of
innovations 6) Brand loyalty 7) Assessment of value
1
3
Services: Categories In The Decision-Making Process
Information Search
5
7 Evaluation of Alternatives
16
Information Search
17
…..Most managers in service industries recognize the strong influence of word of mouth in services.
Consumers find post purchase information seeking more essential with services than with goods because services possess experience qualities that
cannot be adequately assessed before purchase.
Perceived Risk
19
More risk is involved in the purchase of services than in the purchase of goods because services are:
Intangible
Non-standardized
Unit-
Performance Risk - the chance that the service will not perform or provide the benefit for which it was purchased.
2 Consumer Behaviour in Services
5
4
Financial Risk - the amount of monetary loss incurred by the consumer if the service fails.
Process
21
Opportunity Risk - The risk involved when consumers must choose one service over another
Psychological Risk - the chance that the purchase of a service will not fit the individual’s self-concept.
Continue to patronize the same firm which has offered with a positive experience.
Financial risks can be reduced by offering trial purchases, sampling, and promotional incentives.
opinio
wil mee
leaders,
the oapproval
expertsoinothers
th field.
wh are
n
l t r f e o
Testimonials are especially effective to reduce psychological and social risks because they tend to be more believable.
Evoked Set
Evoked set is smaller with services than with goods for the following reasons.
Consumers are unlikely to find more than one or two businesses providing the same services in a given geographical area.
consumers select the first acceptable alternative rather than searching Service Purchase and Consumption - Emotion and Mood
Emotion and mood are feeling states that influence people's perceptions and evaluations of their experiences.
If a service customer is in a "bad mood" service provision will likely be interpreted more negatively
Any service characterized by human interaction is strongly dependent on the moods and emotions of the service provider, the service
6 customer, and other customers
3
Unit-2 Consumer Behaviour in Services
In what specific ways can mood affect the behavior of service customers?
Positive moods can make customers more obliging and willing to participate in behaviors that help service encounters succeed.
Moods and emotions influence service customers is to bias the way they judge service encounters and providers.
6
5
Services Drama
Selection of personnel Auditioning the actors Creation of the service Setting the stage
Service environment
provision Deciding which aspects of the service should be Onstage and performed in the
aim to Deciding which should be Backstage create performed in the back room and maintain a
The presence, behavior, and similarity of other customers receiving services has a strong impact on the satisfaction and dissatisfaction of any given
customer.
Beliefs,
Values,
Experiences,
Abilities to pay,
Appearance,
30
Because consumers participate to a greater extent in the definition and production of services, they may feel more responsible for their
dissatisfaction:
Innovation Diffusion
The rate of diffusion of an innovation depends on consumers' perceptions of the innovation with regard to five characteristics:
…..Innovation Diffusion
An Offering:
…..Innovation Diffusion
Services are:
Less communicable,
Less divisible,
Services are less communicable because they are intangible (e.g., their features cannot be displayed, illustrated, or compared) and often unique to
each buyer (as in a medical diagnosis or dental care).
…..Innovation Diffusion
Services are less divisible because of Impossibility to sample or test on a limited basis (e.g., how does one "sample" a medical diagnosis or a haircut?).
Services are frequently more complex than goods because they are composed of a bundle of different attributes, not all of which will be offered to
every buyer on each purchase.
Brand Loyalty
The degree to which consumers are committed to particular brands of goods or services depends on a number of factors:
Consumers are more loyal with services than with goods because:
Greater search costs and monetary costs may be involved in changing brands of services than in changing brands of goods
Brand Loyalty
Consumers have more difficulty being aware of the availability of substitutes, and higher risks may accompany services because of the:
the recognition of the need for repeated patronage in order to obtain optimum satisfaction from the seller.
Customer Service
Customer Service
Customer Service is defined as the ability of knowledgeable, capable, and enthusiastic employees to deliver products and services to their internal
and external customers in a manner that satisfies identified and unidentified needs and ultimately results in positive word-of-mouth publicity and
return business. (Robert W. Lucas).
Customer Service
Definition -2
Customer Service is a series of activities designed to enhance the level of customer satisfaction – that is, the feeling that a product or service has
met the customer expectation. Its importance varies by product, industry and customer. Although the goal of providing customer service may vary
depending on the focus of the organization, such as retailing, industry, or service- all organizations provide some degree of customer service.
(Jamier L.Scott)
3. determines and meets the needs of its internal and external customers
policies are in place to allow employees to make decisions in order to better serve customers.
the management and systems support and appropriately reward employee’s effort to serve customers.
Reevaluation of the way business is conducted is on going and results in necessary changes and upgrades to deliver timely, quality service to the
customer.
Learning Organizations
A customer- focused company emphasizes providing service excellence and an environment in which customer needs are identified and satisfied.
To achieve the objective of becoming a customer- focused, a company has to become a learning organization.
In a learning organization
Employees are provided with on going training development opportunities so that they gain and maintain cutting- edge skills and knowledge while
projecting a positive can- do customer focused attitude.
Systems that can adequately compensate and reward employees based on their performance are present.
The six components that make up the customer service environment are:
1. The customer 2. Organization culture 3. Human resources 4. Product/ deliverables 5. Delivery systems 6. Service
Service Culture
Culture includes the values, beliefs, norms, rituals, and practices of a group or organization.
Any policy, procedure, action, or inaction on the part of your organization contributes to the service culture.
Many companies are product centered and view customers from the stand point of what company products or services they use.
Successful organizations are customercentered and focusUnit-3 Customer Servcie on individual needs.
Management support
Training
11
7
8 In a customer- oriented environment, it is important to constantly gauge service effectiveness.
Mystery shoppers
Walk-through audits
Customers expect effective, efficient service and value for their money.
What customers want is value for their money and effective, efficient service.
Personal Recognition
Courtesy
Timely Service
Empathy
Patience
Customer Service
13
Communication is a key element that make the relationship between service personnel and customers successful.
Elements of two-way communication that facilitate- performance of job efficiently, goodwill, and customer loyalty for company and provide
service excellence.
Customer service professionals have the power to make or break the organization.
A service provider’s
Appearance,
Ability to communicate say volumes about the organization and its focus on customer satisfaction.
7
8
A service provider should continually strive to project a polished, professional image and make a customer’s visit or conversation a
pleasant and successful one.
A key element in making interactions with customers successful is to recognize how you tend to communicate.
Ask a variety of people for their feedback because each person will likely have a different perspective Unit- .
Two-way communication involves the sender and the receiver who each contribute to the communication process.
Part of the process is deciding which is the best channel to ensure clear message delivery.
As a customer service professional, you are responsible for ensuring that a meaningful exchange of information takes place.
Through effective two way communication, you can perform your job more efficiently, generate goodwill and customer loyalty for the
organization, and provide service excellence.
Be aware of all the elements of two-way communication and the importance of each. (See the communication process) Avoiding
Negative Communication
Your choice of words or phrasing can often lead to either satisfaction or confrontation or it can destroy a customer- provider
relationship.
3 Customer Servcie
78
Customers do not want to hear what you can’t do; they want to hear how you’re going to help satisfy their needs or expectations.
Focus your message on how you can work with the customerUnit - to accomplish needs satisfaction.
Be careful about “Verbal Finger Pointing,” especially if your customer is already upset.
Avoid expressions like you didn’t follow the directions I gave you.“
This is like pointing your finger at someone people are likely to react powerfully and negatively to this type of treatment.
Relationships
Uniton) a second.
3 Customer Servcie
80
Relationships
Do you understand?
You’re right.
Thank you.
May I…?
Unit-
However, and or yet (instead of but). I understand (appreciate) how you feel
3 Customer Servcie
Situation, issue, concern (instead of problem) Would you mind…?
I appreciate…
Communication Positively
Be specificUnit-
….Communication Positively
Paraphrase
….Communication Positively
Visual (Seeing) – Focus on images or pictures, amount of stimulus, lighting, colors, etc
Aural (Hearing) – Focus on words or language, voice level, sound pitch, speed of message, etc
Kinesthetic (Touching) – Focus of experience of practical applications, proxemics (space), room arrangement, etc
82
Unit-
……Communication Positively
Ask permission
participation
3 Customer Servcie
……Communication Positively
28
Disinterest in serving
……Communication Positively
The two modes of dealing with customers create very different service experiences.
3 Customer Servcie
84
The manner in which you nonverbally or verbally approach, address, and interact with customers may label you as either assertive or aggressive Unit- .
Assertiveness means that you project an image of confidence, are selfassured, and state what you believe to be true in a self –confident manner.
3 Customer Servcie
8
8
Assertive Versus Aggressive Service
2)
Aggressio
Nonverbal Communication
33
55 percent of message meaning (feelings) is extracted from facial and other body cues,
Background, culture, physical conditions, communication ability, and many other factors influence whether and how well people use body cues.
Unit-3 Customer Servcie
Body Language
Eye Contact
86
Posture
Facial Expressions
Unit-
Vocal Cues
Pitch
Volume
Articulation
Pauses
Effective hygiene :
3 Customer Servcie
Semantic
s
Bathing,
Brushing teeth,
Washing hands and cleaning fingernails is basic to successful Unit- customer service.
Spatial Cues
Miscellaneous Cues
Personal Habits
Unit-
3 Customer Servcie
9
3
Miscellaneous Cues
Follow- Through
Scratching,
Pulling an ear, or
Fidgeting
Nervous mannerisms or signals that you are anxious, annoyed, or distracted and lack confidence should be avoided.
Playing with or putting hair in your mouth, handwringing, throat-clearing, playing with items as you speak (pencil, pen, or other object),
biting or licking your lips, or drumming your fingers can all send annoyingUnitand/-3 Customer Servcie or negative message.
Image is enhanced
Attitude Is Everything
44
Courtesy……
3 Customer Servcie
96
Attitude Is Everything
Attitude…………..
Believe in yourself
Effective Communication
Step 1: Saying What You Mean and Meaning What You Say
Make sure your tone fits the message you are sending
……Effective Communication
98
Smile often
…..Effective Communication
Speak clearly
….Effective Communication
Correctly
99
Step 5: When the Customer Says No
…..Effective Communication
Listen completely
Be friendly
Be interested
Be sensitive
Be trustful
53
Be helpful
Be committed
Be a problem solver
Be credible
…..Relationship Building
Ask questions
Handle objections
…..Relationship Building
95
1
0
3
Step 5: Maintaining Ongoing
Relationships
Based on the work of Harrison and Handy, the following cultural typologies are significant for service organizations:
Fast, efficient systems designed to produce uniform and pre dictable outcomes
Demand can outstrip organization’s capacity to cope, e.g. plumber, garage, hairdresser, guest house
Task Culture
Staffed, usually, by young, clever, energetic people, e.g. advertising agency, consulting firm
Person Culture
Support Culture
The essence of the support culture is ‘what can we do for you?’, e.g. the caring services like social work
62
Unit-
The product component of the marketing mix is the outcome of the service.
a) The technical
The technical outcome is the end result of the service or the “what” of the service.
The functional outcome is the process of receiving the service or “how” the service was provided.
Functional service is the way the customer or client was treated by the firm’s staff.
For dental service, it is the way the dentist, the dental assistant, and the receptionist interacted with the patientUnit- .
2)Price
Because services are intangible and experiential in nature, the price becomes more important to consumers as a cue of what to expect.
Consumers often use price as one of the inputs or tangible cues into forming expectations of a service and in making purchase decisions.
The more consumers pay for a service, the more they expect.
Lower prices tend to convey lower quality but for some services and for some consumers, this is acceptable.
Restaurants, movie theaters, and airlines often use this strategy when demand exceeds supply.
Price Determinants
Cost
Demand/price curve
Elasticity of price
Competition
Profit Maximization - the price is set at the level that will yield the highest total revenue for the firm within a pre specified profit constraint.
Sales Maximization - the price is set at the level that will yield the highest total revenue.
Market Share Maximization - the price is set at the levelUnit-4 The traditional Services Marketing Mixesthat will provide the firm with the
largest
The Traditional Services Marketing Mix
1 2)Cost Analysis
1
Costs normally serve as a pricing floor.
1
To remain a viable business, firms must obtain a certain level of gross profit to cover overhead expenses.
variable costs.
Demand/ Price Curve shows the demand for a service at various prices.
The demand/ price schedule can be generated from historical data or sales
4)Price Elasticity
Price elasticity of demand is the percentage change in demand divided by the percentage change in price.
If the percentage
difficul
Customer’ fee
tha fochange
for the
a good. in deman
quality io les
the
ts n rl d sf s
The Traditional Services Marketing Mix
101
If the percentage change in demand is greater than the percentage change in price, the price is said to be elastic at that Unitprice-4 The
traditional Services Marketing Mixespoint.
1
1
4 The Traditional Services Marketing Mix
5)Competition
Unit-
competitors.
6) Operational Position
Theoperationalpositionchosenbytheservice willhaveamajorimpactontheprice.
Firms using the cost efficiency operational approach will have a lower price than firms using the other approaches.
Firms using the customization approach will tend to have the highest prices.
If a service is going to use a multi distribution strategy with multiple outlets, normally the service will be priced lower.
The image consumers have of a service firm will impact on how much that firm can charge. Firms with better images can obtain higher prices
for their service than firms with poorer consumer images.
PricingModifications
Service firms have four variations of pricing which they can use to boost sales and profits.
i. Differential pricing ii. Yield management iii. Price bundling iv. Multiple-Use discounts
Unit-
i)Differential Pricing
The purpose of differential pricing is to either shift demand from high- demand periods to low- demand periods or to stimulate demand
during low- demand periods.
to increaseUnit-4 The traditional Services Marketing revenues Mixesit must meet the
The cost of implementing the differential pricingUnit-4 The traditional Services Marketing Mixessystem must not exceed the
Passengers who reserve their seat 30 days in advance will pay less than passengers who reserve their seat 40 days in advance.
21
A cinema charges less for children under say 12 than it does for adults.
ii)Yield Management
YMGT-is a differential pricing methodology designed to produce the highest revenues based on a detailed analysis of the past purchase behavior of
each market segment served by a company.
The goal of yield management is balancing capacity utilization, pricing, market segmentation,
The goal is to produce the best possible financial return from a limited available capacity.
Potential revenue
Yield management is primarily used in the airline industry but has also been used in other service industries such as hotels, trucking, restaurants,
and banking.
Price bundling is offering consumers two or more goods or services in a single package for a
special price.
When a petrol station offers vehicle lubrication, oil change, and other fluid checks in one
1
1
9 The Traditional Services Marketing Mix
a)Pure Bundling
Pure bundling is combining two or more goods or services not sold individually into a single package for the consumer.
Pure bundling is used when the combination of goods or services is more valuable to the consumer than any of them would be
independently.
b) Mixed bundling
MB- is combining two or more goods or services sold individually into a single package for a special price.
By combining all of these services into one package, greater revenue is generated than if each were sold individually.
by combining all of the services into one package, economies of scale and operating
Mixed Leader Pricing offers service B for a discount, if you purchase service A.
Mixed Joint is when two or more services or products are offered together at a fixed price.
Items are packaged together that are complements and that are often purchased together.
By pricing the package cheaper than the combination of items individually, consumers feel they are getting a bargain.
Multiple-Use Pricing discounts are price reductions given to customers for repeat usage of a service.
$50.00”
Price Increases
Consumers react positively to price wars and price reductions, but negatively to price increases.
Price increases will not normally affect market share of a single vendor if all of the firms in an industry increase their prices.
If all firmsUnit-4 The traditional Services Marketing Mixesdo not raise their prices, price
1
2
6 The Traditional Services Marketing Mix
A common strategy is to simply wait until someone else increases their prices, and then quickly follow.
Another approach for instituting price increases is to do it in small increments over a period of time.
For Example,
A 10% increase in price may be done in three installments over four or five months.
1
2
5 When choosing a service, consumers tend to pick the brand that offers them the best value.
If past experiences have been positive, the customer will tend to place a higher value on the service provider’s offering.
Suppose a hotel manager wants to install a swimming pool with four bids for installing the pool were Birr 2,000,000Birr1,900,500,Birr
1,800,700andBirr1,600,600.
Consumers will shy away from purchasing from low- priced vendors because of
perceived risk.
Personal level of involvement in the purchase affects how consumers view the price of a service.
1
2
5 exams and treatments, Bekele will probably not
Final factor buyers consider when evaluating price is their level of participation in the service.
The more customers are involved in the production of the service, the less theyUnit-4 The traditional Services Marketing Mixesexpect to pay.
Distribution
Since the channel tends to be shorter and often direct for services, distribution of service is not as easy as it is for good.
Channel Structures
The channel length tends to be shorter for services than for goods.
Direct Channel - Many services are performed by a service provider for the consumer with no intermediaries using a distribution system
called a direct channel.
Indirect Channel - Other services use agents or intermediaries to perform one or more functions.
The service process rendered by service providers to customers can be divided into 4 components:
Information,
Reservation,
Payment, and
Consumption.
Service providers can use agents or third parties to perform any of the 4 functions.
1
2
9
The Traditional Services Marketing Mix
Channel Options
Exclusive Distribution - involves the use of a limited number of agents or outlets who sell only the one brand.
Selective Distribution - involves the use of a few intermediaries but not all who would like to carry the brand.
Multichannel Systems
To increase market coverage, many service firms are using a multichannel approach.
Multichannel distribution involves the use of two or more channels to reach one or more market
segments.
multichannel lowers
1
0
9 Distribution Growth Options
Multisite,
Multiservice,
Multisegment.
Multisite, multiservice
Multisite, multisegment
Multiservice, multisegment
Unit-
A Multiservice Distribution Strategy is the addition of a new service to a firm’s existing portfolio.
131
A Multisite, Multisegment Strategy involves serving different market segments with different site locations.
A Multiservice, Multisegment Strategy is an option allowing firms to expand their operation by offering new services to new
Unit-
market segments.
strategy
Multisite 1) 2)
rapid expansion 3)
sales growth 4)
good locations financial resources managing multiple
easiest to manage 5) outlets quality control too rapid growth
133
3)
Unit-
132
Multisite, multiservice, 1)
multisegment 1)
2)
2) sales growth one-stop shopping
3)
3) prevent competition from eroding Overhead costs. managing service structure
market share 4) quality of service financial resources
5) customer confusion
Unit-
134
Franchising
Franchising is a multisite distribution growth strategy involving the selling of a service concept to a third party who
Benefits of Franchising
Franchising provides additional management with prior experience for managing the business.
Franchising provides lower risk for a franchisee than building ones own business.
The franchise offers an established brand name and a business plan that has proven to be successful.
operations management.
Additional income
136
Lower risk
Expert assistance
Franchise fees
Lack of freedom
Branding
becom a commodity
.
e
The Traditional Services Marketing Mix
116
Branding provides value by enhancing the efficiency and effectiveness of the marketing programs.
behavio ar increase .
r e d
The Traditional Services Marketing Mix
138
To maximize the benefit of a brand, service providers should meet the following four characteristics:
Distribution
Manageme
ntUnit-
A multisite growth strategy because of the highly standardized, branded service offering.
234
A customer-focused distribution strategy involves managing five components of distribution from the viewpoint of the customer.
Unit-6
Learning Objectives
Recognize that customers hold different types of expectations for service performance
Distinguish between customers’ global expectations of their relationships and their expectations of the service encounter
Acknowledge that expectations are similar for many different types of customers
DelineateUnit-6 Service Qulity, Expectation, and Perceptionthe most important 01/03/2018current issues surrounding customer expectations
1) Desired Service
The level of service the customer hopes to receive - the "wished for" level of performance.
Desired service is a blend of what the customer believes "can be" Expectations, and Perception
2) Adequate Service
The extent to which customers recognize and are willing to accept service variation is called the Zone of tolerance.
Unit-6 Service Qulity, Expectation, and Perception 01/03/2018 with the company undermined.
If a service performance is outside the zone of tolerance at the top end where performance exceeds desired servicecustomers will be very
pleased and probably quite surprised as well.
Zone of Tolerance is the range or window in which customers do not particularly notice
Levels
Desired
Service
Zone of
Toleranc e
Adequate Service
Zones of Tolerance VARY for Different Service Dimensions
Desired Service
Level
of
Expectation Zone of Desired
Tolerance Desired Service
Service
Adequate Service
Zone
of
Tolerance
Adequate
Adequate Service
Service
First-Time
ServiceOutcome
Process
Recovery Service
Outcome
Process
Desired Service
Enduring Service
Intensifiers
Zone
of
Tolerance
Personal Needs
Adequate Service
146
1) Personal Needs
Those states or conditions essential to the physical or psychological well-being of the customer ,pivotal factors/critical factors that shape what
we desire in
For Example’
A fan who regularly goes to the baseball games right from work ,and is therefore thirsty and hungry ,hopes and desires that the food and drink
vendors will pass by his section frequently ,where as a fan who regularly has dinner elsewhere has a low or zero level of desired services from
the vendors.
A customer with high social and dependency needs may have a relatively high expectations for a hotel’s
.
1
4
9 A parent choosing a vacation for
the family,
cleaning service ,
2) Enduring
Service Intensifiers
Individual
Factors that Influence Adequate Service
Transitory Service
Intensifiers Desired
Service
Alternatives Tolerance
Adequate Service
Self-Perceived
Service Role
Situational
Factors
Expectations, and Perception
16
The five factors that influence adequate service:
Consists of temporary, ,usually short term ,individual factors that make a customer more aware of the need for service.
Personal emergency situations in which the service is urgently needed such as accident and the need for automobile insurance or a breakdown in
office equipment.
17
PSAsareotherproviderstochoosefromwhom thecustomercanobtainservice.
18
CustomerPerceptionisthedegreetowhichcustomersexertan influenceonthelevelofservicetheyreceive.
19
4) Situational Factors
Situational factors are defined as the service performance conditions that customers view as beyond the control of the service provider.
For Example,
Where personal emergencies serious automobile accidents would likely intensify customer service expectations of insurance companies,
Explicit Service
Promises
Implicit Service
Promises
Desired Word-of-Mouth
Service
Zone
Past Experience
of
Tolerance
Adequate Predicted
Service Service
Factors That Influence Customer Expectations of Service
21
Unit-6 Service Qulity, Expectation, and Perception 01/03/2018
1
5
6 Expectations, and Perception
Predicted Service
Unit- 01/03/2018
23
Are personal and non-personal statements about the service made by the organization
to customers.
1
5
2 2) Implicit Service Promises (IPS)
ISP-are services –related cues other than explicit promises that lead to inferences about what the service
In general the higher the price and the more impressive the tangibles ,the more a customer will expect from the
service.
25
Personal and non-personal statements made by parties other than the organization convey to customers what the service will be like and influence
both predicted and desired service.
Word of mouth communication carries particular weight as an information sources because it is perceived as unbiased.
Word of mouth tends to be more important in services that are difficult to evaluate before purchase and direct experience of them.
4)Past Experience(PE)
The customer’s previous exposure to service that is relevant to the focal service force in shaping predictions and desires.
The service relevant for prediction can be previous exposure to the focal firms service's experience.
For Example ,
You probably compare each day in a particular hotel is likely to be a very limited view of your past experience.
You may also compare each stay with your experiences in other hotels and hotel chains.
CustomerPerceptionsofService
Provide you with definitions and understanding of customer satisfaction and service quality
Show that service encounters or the “moments of truth” are the building blocks of customer perceptions
Product/Service Quality
Consumer Emotions
29
Managing Consumer
Expectations
expectations.
1
6 6 Service Qulity, Expectation, and Perception 01/03/2018
2
Outcomes of Customer Satisfaction
Increased revenues
Unit-
Relationship between Customer Satisfaction and Loyalty in Competitive Industries
Loy
Satisfaction measure
Source: James L. Heskett, W. Earl Sasser, Jr., and Leonard A. Schlesinger, The Service Profit Chain, (New York, NY: The Free Press, 1997), p. 83.
Expectations
160
Expectations, and Perception
Unit- 01/03/2018
The goal during this phase is to ensure the service being provided matches the consumer’s expectations :
Service personnel must communicate with the customer during the service encounter.
The service providers should modify the service to meet the customer’s expectations.
Managing consumer expectations does not stop after the service is performed.
Companies should communicate with customers immediately after the service is completed to see if expectations were met.
161
Companies should have a procedure for dealing with dissatisfiedUnit - customers that will assist01/03/2018in managing future expectations.
were met.
Unit-
repeat purchase.
SERVQUAL
Consumers evaluated service quality by comparing expectations with perceptions on ten dimensions (Parasuraman et al.,1985)
Tangibles
Reliability
Responsiveness
40
Communication
Credibility
Security
Competence
Courtesy
Access.
42
scores.
Unit-6 Service Qulity, Expectation, and Perception 01/03/2018
G=P-E
165
Reliability
Maintaining error Unit-6 Service Qulity, Expectation, and Perception -free records. 01/03/2018
Responsiveness
Unit- 01/03/2018
44
Assurance
Empathy
Givingcustomersindividualattention.
Havingthecustomer’sbestinterestatheart.
Employeeswhounderstandtheneedsoftheir
46
Tangibles
Modern equipment.
Convenientbusinesshour.
Visually appealing materials associated with the service.
Unit- 01/03/2018
1
7 Expectations, and Perception
1
Limitations of the SERVQUAL Model (Buttle and
Sureshchandar et al. )
Conceptualization
Dimensionality
1
7 Thefiveservicequalitydimensionscannothavea universal application as they can’t be used uniformlyacrossallcountriesandsectorsasthe:
2
Organizational,
Technological,
Economic,
Unit- 01/03/2018
Social, and
SERVPERFusesonlytheperformanceitemsoftheSERVQUALscale.
Satisfaction Versus
Service Quality
customersatisfaction.
It is a judgment that a product or service feature, or the product or service itself, provides a pleasurable level of consumption-related
fulfillment.
Productorservicefeatures
Customers'emotionalresponses
Customersattributions,and
Customers’perceptionsofequity
Service encounters or the "moment of truth" are the "building blocks of satisfaction and service quality.
The service encounter or the moment of truth is what is termed as interactive marketing in
the Unittriangle- .
1
7
5
Each encounter presents an opportunity to prove its potential as a quality service provider and to increase customer loyalty.
Restaurant
Meal
Wake-Up Call
Checkout
Sales Call
Delivery and
Installation
Servicing
Ordering of Supplies
Billing
Remote encounters
Face-to-face encounters.
1
8
2
Expectations, and Perception
i) Remote Encounters
Encounters can occur without any direct human contact (remote encounters)
Example:
The ATM
serviceUnit-6 Service Qulity, Expectation, and Perceptionand the quality of the technical01/03/2018 processes
Encounters
TheUnit- 01/03/2018most
1
8
3
Both verbal and nonverbal behaviors are important determinantsof quality, as are tangible cues such as employee dress and other symbols of
service (e.g. equipment, informational brochure, physical setting).
Inface-to-faceencountersthecustomeralso
Service Encounters
1)Recovery
2)Adaptability
3)Spontaneity
and requests
.
1
8
2
Satisfying incidents in this group represent very pleasant surprises for the customer (special attention, being treated like royalty, receiving
something nice but not requested).
Satisfactory Dissatisfactory
I had made an advance reservation at the hotel. We had made an advance reservation at the hotel.
They lost my room reservation but the manager gave me the When we arrived we found we had no room-no explanation, no
suite room for the same price. apologies, and no assistance in finding another hotel. (external
customer)
(external customer)
01/03/2018
1
9
4
A gentleman left his shoes outside his room door to be shined. One of my suitcases was all dented up and looked like it had been
When he went to retrieve them, they were gone, and could not dropped from 30,000 feet.
be found.
When I tried to make a claim for my damaged luggage, the employee
The hotel staff took responsibility and with in an hour a insinuated that I was lying and trying to rip them off.
representative had
(external customer)
arrived withUnit-six6 Service Qulity, Expectatiopairs of shoes
n, and Perception 01/03/2018
for the gentleman to choose
01/03/2018
from. (employee
)
1
9
3
atisfactory Dissatisfactory
01/03/2018
1
9
4
lthough it was not our regular order time, I needed some suppliers My young son, flying alone, was to be assisted by the stewardess from
hat we did not have in stock. start to finish.
called the supply office and the gentleman on the phone said, “No At the airport she left him alone in the airport with no one to escort him
roblem. to his connecting flight. (external customer)
received the supplies the next day. His word was as good as gold. n, and Perception 01/03/2018
nternal customer)
01/03/2018
1
9
3
Satisfaction Dissatisfaction
time to explain exactly what I would be aware of and promised to take I needed a few minutes to decide on a dinner. The
special care in making sure I did not wake up. waitress said, “If you would read the menu and
not the road map, you would know what you
It impressed me that the anesthesiologist came to settle
want to order.” (external
my nerves and explain the difference in the medicine I was getting because
of my cold. customer)
It was a nice bit of extra attention that he did not have to give.
(external customer)
Unit-6 Service Qulity, Expectation, and Perception 01/03/2018 Examples of Coping Incidents, Both Good and Bad
01/03/2018
1
9
4
atisfactory Dissatisfactory
Thefatherknockedalloftheplatesandglasses offthetablebeforeleaving.(Employee)
01/03/2018
1
9
3
Unit-6 Service Qulity, Expectation, and Perception 01/03/2018
Measureandmanagecustomersatisfactionand servicequality
Aimforcustomerqualityandsatisfactioninevery serviceencounter
Planforeffectiverecovery
Facilitateadaptabilityandflexibility
Encouragespontaneity
Helpemployeescopewithproblemcustomers.
01/03/2018
1
9
4
01/03/2018
1
9
3
Unit-7
Service Recovery
Service Recovery
Learning Outcome
Complaint handling
Effects of poor service failure Effects of effective service recovery Why do/don’t people complain?
Service Recovery
01/03/2018
1
9
4
Meaning of Service Recovery
Service recovery is the action taken by the organization in response to service failure.
01/03/2018
Service Recovery
Complaint Handling
6
5
4
Complaints are defined as any expression of dissatisfaction or concern made to the organization by, or on behalf of, an individual client,
group related to the organizations products or services.
Unit-
Service Recovery
To support the provision of the highest possible quality service to external clients;
To increase the level of client satisfaction with the delivery of the organization’s services and products; and
Service Recovery
Complaint Handling
Recognizing a client's right to make complaints, comments or suggestions about the level and quality of services and products provided;
Ensuring that all complaints are heard and equitably resolved as soon as possible;
9
8
7
Monitoring complaints in an endeavor to improve the quality of services and Products;
Providing clients with information about the complaint handling process; and
Service Recovery
Complaints Handling
Fairness: Recognize the need to be fair and equitable to both the complainant and the employee and/or part of the organization against
whom the complaint is made.
Resources: Provide adequate resources with sufficient levels of delegated authority to ensure complaints received are addressed and
concluded in a timely
Service Recovery
Access: Ensure the complaint process is available to all external clients of the organization.
Responsiveness: Deal with complaints quickly, treat complainants with courtesy and wherever possible resolve complaints at the first point
of contact.
Assistance: Provide assistance for complainants in the formulation and placement of complaints if
Charges: If a client has a complaint about a product or service, the complaints handling process shall be provided free of charge.
12
11
10
Remedies: The service provider will review the need to develop remedies that are fair and reasonable in the circumstances, to meet any legal
obligations and generally comply with good management principles and practice.
Data Collection: Collect and record data on complaints lodged or placed and outcomes to assist in the identification of systemic and recurring
problems and/or potential improvements
Service Recovery
Accountability: All employees shall take responsibility for effective complaints handling. Managers are responsible for implementing the
policy and the procedures outlined in this document in their respective Branches.
Reviews: Regularly review the complaints handling process to ensure it is efficiently delivering effective
Service Recovery
be heard;
know whether the organization’s relevant service and products as well as procedures have been followed;
01/03/2018
Service Recovery
14
13
What makes a complaint handling system of a
Employee
Service Recovery
Managers Shall:
Appoint and empower employees in their organization with the authority to resolve complaints quickly and effectively;
Provide sufficient resources within their area of control to ensure the efficient and effective management of customer complaints;
Ensure appointed service providers are trained in general and specific complaint handling skills;
Ensure all complaints are dealt with in an acceptable and timely manner;
A complaint is a Gift
16
15
17
A complaint is a gift because it provides an opportunity to:
Fix things
Service Recovery
Evaluate the data and determine the causes of complaints and whether remedial action is required;
Develop and implement continuous improvements to services and products that are the cause of complaints
Service Recovery
Service Recovery
19
18
Customer defection
Legal liability
Service Recovery
Customer satisfaction
Customer loyalty
Repurchase effect
22
21
20
Customers who are dissatisfied but experience a high level of excellent service recovery may become more satisfied and more likely to
repurchase than those who were satisfied in the first place.
Even if do it right the first time is preferable, when a failure occurs everyUnit-7 Service Recovery Strategy effort should be01/03/2018made
for superior
Service Recovery
Complain to provider
Complain to friends
24
23
Take action or do not take action
Service Recovery
Types of Complainers
i)Passives
Believe that the consequences of complaining will not merit the time and effort they will expend.
25
26
Are the service providers best friend
Switch Stay with
Complain to the service provider
Providers Provider
Do not complain to third parties
Uni- 01/03/2018
Do not spread negative word of mouth t
Do not switch patronage
Service Recovery
Irate
Service Recovery
Activists
01/03/2018
benefi an positiv outcome .
t d e s
Complain to friends and relatives
28
27
Are alienated from the market place.
Service Recovery
The consequence
Personality
30
29
Complain
Steve Brown and Steve Tax has documented three specific types of justices that customers are looking for following their complaints:
outcome fairness, procedural fairness and interactional fairness
i) Outcome Fairness
Service Recovery
ii)Procedural Fairness
Clarity
Speed
Absence of hassle
Service Recovery
31
iii)Interactional Fairness
This form of fairness can dominate the others if customers feel the company and its employees have uncaring attitudes and have done little
to try to resolve the problem.
32
Do it right the first time
Act quickly
34
3
2
1
Unit-
Learning objective
(ThomasUnit- )
Insufficient demand
Poor location
Poor timing
How The Front And Back Office Should Be Organized And Coordinated.
The front office is that part of the system directly experienced and visible to the customer.
6
5
This is where the service is performed and is thereby open to customer scrutiny, e.g. the hotel dining room.
The back office is that part of the system from which the customer is (physically) excluded, e.g. the hotel kitchens.
It is often referred to as the manufacturing side of the service, not seen by the customer.
How The Front And Back Office Should Be Organized And Coordinated.
A framework has been suggested as to how the front and back office should be
Unit-8 Service Development and Design 12/21/2015 options and conduct of service work
How The Front And Back Office Should Be Organized And Coordinated.
1) Input Uncertainty – refers to the service organization’s incomplete knowledge of what the customer is going to bring to the service and
how he or she is likely to behave.
environmental variables:
How The Front and Back Office Should Be Organized and Coordinated.
8
7
Customer willingness to participate – refers to how far customers wish to play an active part in the service.
Customers’ capacity to become involved can be limited by lack of knowledge, skills and understanding of their role.
customer demands.
How The Front And Back Office Should Be Organized And Coordinated.
2) Interdependencies – refers to different patterns with respect to division of service work (between front and back office and customer)
and customization versus standardization of standard actions and interdependencies.
11
10
Patterns Matching Input Uncertainty
Where,
C = customers,
F = front-office employee(s);
B = back-office employee(s).
The four service design options can be seen in Figure 8.3. A brief explanation of each follows.
A customer-dominated design in which they serve themselves after service employees have provided the goods and facilities needed for
self-service.
14
13
12
Patterns Matching Input Uncertainty
Participation of the parties ‘in which the output of each becomes the input for the others’.
The service is produced largely on the basis of significant interactions between front-office employees and customers.
the bulk of the work here is performed by the service employees in a system of strong interdependence between back and front offices.
Most of the work done by an efficient back office, largely decoupled from front-office disturbances.
Customers do not interact extensively with service employees but engage in the sharing of resources that makes mass
service possible.
15
Business strategy review/development
Idea generation
Market testing
Commercialization
Planning
Business Analysis
ImplementationMarket Testing
18
17
I) Front End Planning
Assuming that an organization will have an overall strategic vision and mission Review the vision and mission of the organization.
Offerings Markets
Unit-
3)Idea Generation
The idea should fit the basic business and new service strategies.
Contact personnel
Brainstorming session
Employees
CustomersUnitUser research
Once an idea surfaces that is regarded as a good fit with both the basic business and the new service strategies, it is ready for initial
development.
At this stage:
5) Business Analysis
24
228
Assuming the service concept is favorably evaluated by customers and employees at the concept development stage then one has to Determine the
feasibility of the service concept and its profit potential.
Demand analysis, revenue projections, cost analysis ,and operational feasibility are assessed at this stage.
The organization will pass the results of the business analysis through its profitabilityUnit-8 Service Development and Designand feasibility
screen12/21/2015to determine whether
Once the new service concept has passed all the front-end planning hurdles ,it is ready for the implementation stages of
the process
Unit- 12/21/2015
Services Development and Design
This stage of service development should involve all who have a stake in the new service :
27
26
25
Customers and contact employees as well as functional representatives from marketing, operations and human resources.
Unit-8 Service Development and Design 12/21/2015 where a detailed service blueprint representing the
7)Market Testing
It is needed to determine:
8)Commercialization
Commercialization is the introduction stage of the service to the market place./the service goes to live.
Unit- 12/21/2015
Services Development and Design
29
28
30
If the customer needs six months to experience the entire service ,then careful monitoring must be maintained through at least six months.
Every detail of the service should be assessed –phone calls, face-to-face transactions, billing,complaints,and delivery problems.
Changes will be made to the delivery process, staffing, or marketing mix variables based on the response of the market to the new service
offer.
As service is a process where people interact with the production and delivery of an experience, service design should encapsulate all aspects
of that experience:
Unit- 12/21/2015
Unit-
Services Development and Design
33
32
31
The nature of the service process, e.g. standardized, customized
a)Equipment-based
Automated (vending machine, car wash), monitored by relatively unskilled operators (taxis, dry cleaning),
b)People-based
34
35
39
38
37
36
a)Degree of Contact : whether the customer has to be present, as is the case with a haircut;
standardization is possible, e.g. can a standard programme be devised for all customers of a health club?
Where a service is low in all three dimensions (cell 1 e.g. the back office of a bank) it is like a factory, with emphasis on quality control and
focusing on physical facilities and procedures.
1) Where the service is low in labor intensity, the customer’s impression of the physical facilities, processes and procedures is important and
care must be taken to make sure equipment is reliable, easy to use and user proof.
1) As high contact and interaction services increase in labor intensity, more attention must be paid to making sure staff behave appropriately.
As customization increases (moving towards cells 3, 4, 7 and 8) the service process and product must be designed to fit the customer.
40
41
42
Utilities, transportation of goods
SB is a picture or map that accurately portrays the service system so that different people can understand and deal with it regardless of their
roles.
It visually displays:
1. The process of the service deliveryUnit-8 Service Development and Design 12/21/2015
To make employees and customers see their roles in the service delivery.
43
To understand all of the steps and flows involved in the service process.
45
44
Customer Action
4) Support Process.
1)Customer Actions
a)Line of Interaction
b) Line of Visibility
Support Processes
47
46
Customers actions in legal service.
A face-to-face meeting
Receipt of documents
Receipt of a bill
All the steps and activities that the contact employee performs that are visible to the customer.
Initial interview
Intermediate meetings
48
50
49
Actions that occur behind the scenes to support the onstage activities.
Covers the internal services, steps, and interactions that take place to support the contact employees in delivering the service.
51
taken place.)
This line separates all service activities that are visible to the customer from those that are not visible.
Identify the process Identify the customer or customer segment.o be blue-printed.Map the process from the customer’s point of view.Map contact
employee actions, onstage and backLink customer -sta
ver may
y
and contact person activities to needed su
54
53
Services Development and Design
Building a Blueprint
Blue prints can be developed at a variety of levels, and there needs to be agreement on the starting point.
Example:
Blue print for Express mail service or Blue print for overnight hotel stay Service
If the sort packages and loading elements of the process were found to be problem areas or bottlenecks that were slowingUnit-8 Service Development and
Designservice to customers , a detailed12/21/2015blueprint of the sub-processes at work in those two steps could be
A common rational for market segmentation is that each segments needs are different and therefore will require variations in the service or product features.
Blue prints need to be prepared for a particular customer or customer segment assuming that the
55
Bill
EVIDENCE
CUSTOMER PHYSICAL
Desk
Hotel Cart for Desk Elevators Cart for Room Menu Delivery Food Lobby
Exterior Bags Registration Hallways Bags Amenities Tray Hotel
Parking Papers Room Bath Food Exterior
Lobby Appearance Parking
Key
Arrive Give Bags Call Check out
Go to Receive Sleep Receive
at to Check in Room Eat and
Room Bags Shower Food
Hotel Bell person Service Leave
CONTACT PERSON
SUPPORT PROCESS(Back Stage) (On Stage)
Greet and
Process Deliver Deliver Process
Take
Registration Bags Food Check Out
Bags
Take
Take Bags Food
to Room Order
56
Source: Shostack
(1984)
Unit-8 Service Development and Design12/21/2015
A Process Flow Diagram For The Auto Repair Business
57
59
58
This step involves charting the choices and actions that the customer performs or experiences in purchasing,consuming,and evaluating the
service .
Identifying the service from the customer’s point of view first will help avoid focusing on processes and steps that have no customer impact.
Often managers and others who are not on the front lines do not actually know what the customers are experiencing and what it all looks like
form theirUnit- points of view.
Step 4 :Map contact employees actions, onstage & backstage actions and or Technology Actions
For Existing: Services this will involve questioning front-line operations employees to learn what they do and which activities are performed in
full view of the customer versus which activities are carried out behind the scenes.
In the case of technology –delivered services or those that combine technology and human delivery , the required actions of the technology
interface will be mapped above the line of visibility as well.
If no employees are involved in the service at all ,then the area can be relabeled “on stage technology actions.”
It is in the process of internal actions on customers becomes apparent Internal service processes take on added importance when viewed in
60
connection with their link to the customer.
62
61
Finally the evaluation of service can be added to the blueprint to illustrate what it is that the customer sees and receives as tangible evidence of
the service at each step in the customer experience.
The photograph blueprint including photos ,slides, or video of the process can be very useful at this stage as well as to aid in analyzing the
impact of tangible evidence and its consistency with the overall strategy andUnitservice-8 Service Development and Designpositioning.
The 3 Logics
a ‘perspective’.
Brundidge stressesUnit-8 Service Development and Designthat they are ‘crucial12/21/2015to accurate
The 3 Logics
Customer Logic is the underlying rationale that drives customers’ behaviour, based on their needs and wants
12/21/2015
osis f ny ice ion’
It will be evident in what customers expect of the service and how it might compare with other services.
63
It is essentially concerned with the way things are done dictated largely by organization policy, rules and regulations.
It will be evident in employees’ perception of working conditions, working methods, organization of work and role clarity.
12/21/2015
2
65
6
1
1 Unit-9
Learning Objectives
Capacity factors
Capability
Services cannotUnit-9 Managing Demand & Capacitybe transported from one place to another or transferred from person to person.
Where service capacity is largely fixed and demand is subject to variation, organizations can experience any of the
following situations:
Demand and capacity are well balanced – this is the level of optimum capacity
From Figure 9.1 it is evident that the level of capacity utilization will impact on the quality of service.
As the name implies, the optimum is the best level in most cases for all parties concerned – customers, employees and the organization.
Operating at maximum capacity, however, or even beyond as with some transportation services, is seen as a desired feature of some service
situations, namely nightclubs and bars.
(The trend is now for ‘vertical bars’, standing room only, where most of the tables and chairs are removed allowing a much higher number of
customers to enter.)
Unit-
For an airline it is said to range from 65 to 75% and for most services the optimal capacity appears to be between 70 and 90% of maximum
capacity.
See the figureUnit-9 Managing Demand & Capacityentitled as "The impact of capacity utilization in a restaurant”
1. Excess Demand.
Quality mayUnit-9 Managing Demand & Capacitynot match what was promised because of crowding or overtaxing of staff and
No one is being turned away, but the quality of service suffers because of;
Overuse,
Crowding, or
abilitiesUnit-
No one is overworked,
Productive resources in the form of labor, equipment, and facilities are underutilized, resulting in lost productivity and lower profits.
Customers may receive excellent quality on an individual level because they have the full use of the facilities, Unit- no waiting, and complete
Capacity Constraints
service,
Facilities – Hotel rooms, no. of airplane seats, no. of class rooms in universities, etc
Service organizations draw on the following resources and assets in varying degrees depending on the type of service :
Physical facilities designed to house customers, the obvious ones being hotels, hospitals, airplanes, schools.
Each facility will be defined in terms of number of rooms, beds, seats and classrooms.
Examples would include washing machines (launderette),Unit-9 Managing Demand & Capacitycomputer technology (banks), X-ray
equipment (hospitals), turnstiles (football stadium).
Unit-9 Managing Demand & Capacity
254
Labor is a key element in the provision of service, e.g. waiters in a restaurant, cabin crew on an aero plane, tellers in a bank.
A umber of services rely heavily on labor where the service comes to the customer, as in breakdown services, cleaning, gardening, roof
repair, postal services
Time is a resource that serves as the basis upon which several services may be sold, e.g. a consultant, lawyer, plumber, car repair,
counselor.
To anticipate and alleviate pressures on capacity, services need to have, as clearly as possible, an understanding of demand patterns.
First, by how much does demand vary or fluctuate? There may be extreme variation to very little.
Unit-9 Managing Demand & Capacity a predictable cycle or pattern is detectable its
16
17
The causes of these cyclical variations may be many and will vary by type of service.
Causal factors for a bus service are likely to be employment/school hours, shopping behaviour and entertainment.
Service demand
Unit-9 Managing Demand & Capacity
18
supply
in demandUnit-
20
Differentiate on price
Offer incentives to customers for usage during no peak Modify the service offering to appeal to new market segments.
times
Take care of loyal or "regular" customers first Offer discounts or price reductions
Advertise peak usage times and benefits of no peak use Modify hours of operation
Charge full price for the service - no discounts Bring the service to the customer
22
Stretch Facilities
Stretch Equipment
Due to the relative inflexibility of service capacity coupled with the variability of service demand, aligning the two remains a challenge.
Relatively recent writing, incorporating the original thinking, suggests four options are available to service organizations in determining a
relationship between demand and capacity.
They are:
Provide – where sufficient capacity is available at all times to meet peak demand.
This may mean periods of excess capacity but that is to be preferred to a situation where business is lost due to insufficient capacity.
Match – where attempts are made to anticipate demand pattern so that capacity levels can be changed to accommodate.
It would involve careful scheduling of work as well as considering subcontracting or outsourcing.
Influence – where demand patterns are changed, if possible, to obtain effective utilization of capacity.
Responsibility for changing demand will lie with marketing deploying elements of the marketing mix as appropriate.
Control – where capacity remains fixed in service situations that are unique and high cost resources are needed to provide the level of service
expected.
Each of these options in relation to an actual demand pattern is shown in Figure 9.3.
Actual demand in Figure 9.3 is presented as more of a random rather than regular fluctuation across the six time periods.
Should a company provide excess capacity to improve customer service or minimize excess capacity to maximize resource utilization.
The ‘match’ option (managing the capacity) is shown as parallel to, but slightly higher than, the actual demand lines.
This option is more easily managed with employees than equipment and facilities.
The influence option attempts to smooth the actual and match capacity by shifting the peak demands to the low demand periods.
It is slightly higher in low demand periods and slightly lower in high demand periods.
The provide option shown as the straight horizontal line at the top of Figure 9.3 presupposes that enough capacity is available to meet even the
peak demands.
It could be thought of as a wasteful option as resources will inevitably be underutilized, particularly through periods 1, 4 and 6.
Specific Actions:
The goal is to produce the best possible financial return from a limited available capacity.
Potential revenue
Application has been most successful in services that have the following characteristics:
Relative fixed capacity – e.g. once a hotel has rented out all its rooms further demand cannot be met without substantial capital investment.
Perishable inventory – a major constraint for services is time or more specifically time during which a unit of capacity is available. If a hotel
room (unit of capacity) is not sold for a particular date the revenue that would have been gained is lost
Segmented Markets – where the market for a service can be segmented according to certain criteria, e.g. price sensitivity Unit.-
Fluctuating Demand – where the adoption of various pricing approaches enables the reduction of peaks and valleys in variable demand.
Services that can be sold in advance through reservation systems – allows for better use of capacity.
Low variable to fixed cost ratio – in service pricing some contribution must be made towards fixed cost.
The low level of variable cost, e.g. cleaning a hotel room, coupled with discretion in pricing means that the revenue expected from selling it
is invariably greater than if it was not sold.
1. Moderate – theatres, trains, hairdressers, small/medium hotels use less advanced systems and technologies in the deployment of classic
yield management techniques.
3. Potential – restaurants and golf courses are current and notable examples of services ready for yield management were it not for, in both
cases, variability and unpredictability over the duration of service.
For yield management to work there must be a fixed length of time within which the service is consumed.
38
Yield Measurement
Revenue potential is the revenue that could be secured if 100 per cent of capacity is sold at the maximum price possible.
In more detail, yield is a function of price efficiency and capacity used, namely:
Yield Measurement
269
Terminology can vary according to industry, e.g. hotel capacity is occupancy rate, transport capacity is load factor, hotel price is rate, and so on.)
Yield Measurement
270
Yield Measurement
800).
On the other hand, average capacity utilization across the two categories of room is:
45
Yield Measurement
46
Yield Measurement
47
An example from the airline industry18 illustrates the calculation of revenue per available seat mile with the additional consideration of cost.
To begin with, operational expenses are calculated for each flight and then divided by the number of available seats on that flight.
This means each seat has a fixed cost associated with it.
To make this figure even more meaningful the cost is then broken down to cost per kilometer.
Therefore, each flight has an available seat kilometer (ASK), which is computed by multiplying the number of seats on the aero plane by the distance
of the flight. For example:
Yield Measurement
48
49
To find out if the yield on revenue of the above flight is good, bad, or indifferent a further calculation is required.
The marketing team needs to know the revenue per passenger kilometer (RPK) of each flight.
Using the same flight and costs as above, theUnit- RPK would be worked out Yield Measurement
276
51
‘Waiting is frustrating, demoralizing, agonizing, aggravating, annoying, time consuming and incredibly expensive.’
This view of waiting is offered in an advertisement for Fedex, an American parcels carrier.
Since one of the company’s selling propositions is that they can deliver goods to customers sooner
9 Managing Demand & Capacity than their competitors, it is not surprising that
Transaction processes include selling tickets, having documents checked, passing through security and immigration checks, and being sorted into
categories.
2.The slowing of a flow because there is a physical constraint which slows things down.
This constraint is usually called a bottleneck, and if you up end a bottle of water you can see why.
Bottlenecks occur because several flows converge (as at road junctions or transport
3. Queues occur because people arrive before the service is open for business.
Such queues include those waiting for a bus driver to arrive and open the doors, those outside shops waiting for opening time, and people
waiting in areas of famine for food donations.
This last example gives the reason why many service opening time queues occur.
Aqueue ensures ‘first come first served’, which is particularly important if there is a belief that there will not be enough to serve everybody
who waits.
Uncertainties – there is nothing worse from a customer’s point of view than not knowing how long you will have to wait.
People must be given an indication of how long they should expect to wait and it should err on the side of caution.
For example, it is obviously better to say ‘you will be seen in 20 minutes’ or ‘the takeoff will be delayedUnit-9 Managing Demand &
Capacityby 30 minutes’ where the wait is anticipated by the service provider to be less in
2
9
6
The essential characteristic and apparent attractiveness of the appointment system are its complete lack of uncertainty.
Unless you arrive early, there is no waiting involved as people expect to be taken at their allotted time.
What is not always understood or tolerated is why a service does not adhere to the appointment schedule.
Explanation – the length of a delay can be given meaning if people are told the reason(s).
There are innumerable reasons for delay but the important point is that customers will make a judgment as to whether it is reasonable,
acceptable, or justifiable.
One might speculate that failure to inform customers is as much to do with avoiding unnecessary ridicule and censure.
Train companies revelations that a particular type of snow or leaves on the line, or excessive heat, can cause severe disruption are usually
met with incredulity and annoyance, particularly as there appears to be nothing that can be done about it.
There is nothing more frustrating from the customer’s viewpoint than serving points, e.g. in post offices, banks, supermarkets, suddenly
closingUnit-9 Managing Demand & Capacitywithout any explanation, or where service employees are seen to be ‘sitting idly by’ while the
queues get
longer
.
280
Anxiety – this feeling can often be the consequence of uncertainty and no explanation.
It is the product of thinking ‘I’ll never be seen to’, which with the advent of appointments and take-anumber systems is less frequent.
However, it can be felt when standing far back in a very long queue entering a capacityconstrained facility, e.g. a pop concert, a football
match.
Organizers can eliminate it with the reassuranceUnit-that ‘everyone will get in’.
If organizations can offer some desirable distractions that take customers’ minds off the time the response might well be one of ‘how time
flies’.
There has not been a great deal of imagination generated in this area.
Successfully filling unoccupied time is a difficult exercise and an area where there is enormous scope for experimentation
Unit-
and development.
Pre-process versus in-process – this is partially related to the previous point in that although customers have to wait they want to feel as
soon as possible that progress is being made towards the service commencing.
The obvious example is being given a menu on sitting down for a restaurant meal.
The important point is that customers need to feel they are involved as quickly as possible.
Anything the provider can do to fill in the customers’ time before the core service begins will achieve that objective. Unit-
Value – in general people value their time, so what they are waiting for has to be worth it .
What customers define as ‘valued’ is as diverse as the reasons for delay mentioned earlier.
It is not simply a matter of what is valued being seen as something highly priced.
People camp out overnight or wait many hours to obtain entry to various forms of entertainment.
It works well when all customers’ transactions require about the same amount of time, but not where markedly different amounts of time are
in evidence.
There are instances where FIFO and FCFS would seem to be violated, e.g. an emergency arrival at a hospital, but this is an example where
customers accept non-observance of the rule.
Multiple-queue alternative
284 "Queue discipline" - management policies regarding who to select next for service.
66
The more valuable the service, the longer the customer will wait
Unit-
Queuing theory is the application of the mathematics of probability to the likelihood of queues.
Those managing systems wish to ensure that the maximum duration of queues stays within given limits, because they do not wish to exceed the zone
of tolerance of the customers, who may renege if queues are too long.
These models may become quite complex, but they all start with two basic sets of data:
the average arrival rate, denoted by (the Greek letter lambda) and the average service rate, denoted by (m).
From these two statistics a value for the traffic intensity, shown by , can be derived.
Traffic intensity can best be thought of as the average utilization of the service facility with the formula:
Unit-
71
73
‘Relationship marketing’,
‘technology enabledrelationship
(CMR) OR
‘Customer management’ (CM). Data warehouse Campaign management or Sales force automation.
(TERM),
CRM is a business strategy combined with technology to effectively manage the complete customer life-cycle.
CRM is a term for methodologies, technologies and ecommerce capabilities used by companies to manage customer relationships.
CRM is a comprehensive strategy and process of acquiring, retaining and partnering with selective customers to create superior value for the
company and the customer8
CRM is about the development and maintenance of long-term mutually beneficial relationships with strategically significant customers.
CRM is concerned with numerous aspects, but the basic theme is for the company to become more customercentric… methods are primarily Web-
based tools an Internet presence…
CRM can be viewed as an application of one-to-one marketing and relationship marketing, responding to an individual customer based on what the
customer tells you and what else you know about that customer.
CRM is a management approach that enables organizations to identify, attract and increase retention of profitable customers by managing
relationships with them
CRM involves using existing customer information to improve company profitability and customer service.
Relationship Marketing - a paradigm shift from an acquisitions/transaction focus ( the “first act”) toward a retention/relationship focus(the
“second act”).
8 Relationship Marketing
Relationship marketing (or relationship management) is a philosophy of doing business, a strategic orientation that focuses on keeping and
improving current customers, rather than on acquiring new customers.
Relationship Marketing
Relationship Marketing philosophy assumes that consumers prefer to have an ongoing relationship with one organization than to switch
continually among providers in their search for value.
Hierarchy
or
Types of CRM
Analyst firms, including Meta Group, classify CRM into several types:
Together, these three components of CRM support and feed into each other.
Operational CRM
Analytical CRM
Collaborative CRM
Successful CRM, which results in a superior customer experience, requires integration of all three of these
Types of CRM
i)Operational CRM
This is the area that is concerned with the automation of business processes involving front-office customer
contact points.
These areas include sales automation, marketing automation and customer service automation.
Historically, Operational CRM has been a major area of enterprise expenditure as companies
Types of CRM
CRM Vendors focus on offering an increasingly wide range of operational CRM solutions.
Operational CRM facilitates the customer contacts with the organization and subsequent processing and fulfillment of their
requirements.
This involves the capture, storage, organization, analysis, interpretation and use of data created from the operational side of the business.
Integration of analytical CRM solutions with operational CRM solutions is an important consideration.
Analytical CRM enables the right customers to be targeted with appropriate offers and permits personalization and one-to one-
This involves the use of collaborative services and infrastructure to make interaction between a company and its multiple channels possible.
This enables interaction between customers, the enterprise and its employees.
Collaborative CRM enables customers to contact the enterprise through a range of different channels and undergo a common experience
across these
Five Key Cross-functional CRM Processes
There are five key cross-functional CRM processes that need to be considered by most organizations .
These are:
Who are the customers that we want and how should we segment them?
What are the best ways for us to get to customers and for customers to get to us?
What does an outstanding customer experience, deliverable at an affordable cost, look like?
How can we ‘replicate’ the mind of customers and use this to improve our
CRM activities?
The Strategic Framework For CRM
How should we set standards, develop metrics, measure our results and improve our performance?
Relationship Marketing
There are a number of factors that have impacted organizations 'ability to build more sustained relationships, especially for those businesses with a
large customer base.
the availability of increasingly sophisticated tools to undertake data analysis, data mining and data visualization
Relationship Marketing
the rise of e-commerce and the ability to be able to target customers via the Internet at a
an increased recognition of the importance of customer retention and customer lifetime value, and
an increased sophistication in marketing approaches and the development of better ways of targeting customers, including: oneto-one marketing
permission marketing mass customization.
Relationship Marketing
CRM, also more recently called ‘customer management’, is a business approach that seeks to create, develop and enhance relationships with
carefully targeted customers in order to improve customer value and corporate profitability and thereby maximize shareholder value.
CRM is often associated with utilizing information technology to implement relationship marketing strategies.
As such, CRM unites the potential of new technologies and new marketing thinking to deliver profitable, long-term relationships.
Relationship Marketing
An approach which addresses multiple ‘market domains’, or stakeholder groups – not just the traditional customer market
A shift from marketing activities which emphasize customer acquisition to marketing activities which emphasize customer retention
Relationship Marketing
28
a well a acquisition.
s s
Relational and service values – bureaucratic– legal values are discarded in favor of treating customers asUnitdiffering-10 Relationships Marketing.
First, you can only optimize relationships with customers if you understand and manage relationships with other relevant stakeholders.
Most businesses appreciate the critical role their employees play in delivering superior customer value, but other stakeholders may also play an
important part.
Second, the tools and techniques used in marketing to customers, such as marketing planning and market segmentation, can also be used equally as
effectively in managing non-customer relationships.
The figure above 10.1 suggests three distinguishing characteristics of relationship marketing.
The first is an emphasis on customer retention and extending the ‘lifetime value’ of customers through strategies that focus on retaining targeted
customers.
The second is a recognition that companies need to develop relationships with a number of stakeholders, or ‘market domains’, if they are to achieve
long-term success in the final marketplace.
The third feature of relationship marketing is that marketing is seen as a pan-company or cross-
10.1)
327
Figure- 10.1
Limited customer commitment High customer commitment
The emergence of CRM as a management approach is a consequence of a number of important trends. These include:
the realization that customers are a business asset and not simply a commercial audience;
the recognition of the benefits of using information proactively rather than solely reactively ;
the greater utilization of technology in managing and maximizing the value of information ,
the acceptance of the need for trade-off between delivering and extracting customer value;
Relationship Marketing
Relationship Marketing
Equity Theory
Resource-Advantage Theory
Institutional Theory
35
Emphasizes on profit maximization in competitive markets in explaining relative prices, market equilibrium, and income distribution.
Exchange parties are price takers seeking to maximize utility in price equilibrium markets.
Market transactions incur the costs associated with the price paid, searching costs, negotiating and contracting costs, and costs of monitoring
supplier performance.
10 Relationships Marketing
Relationship Marketing
Economists have generally viewed markets as social ‘vacuums’ in which buyers and sellers only know each other in their roles as dictated by the
market (i.e. as no more than buyer and seller).
Relationship Marketing
Every market transaction involves transaction costs that lead to inefficiencies for those engaged in exchanges.
Transaction costs include costs of information search, of reaching a satisfactory agreement, of relationship monitoring, of adapting agreements to
unanticipated contingencies, and of contract enforcement.
Transaction costs are minimized by selecting a mode of relationship10 Relationships Marketinggovernance that is
Unit-
‘optimal’
Relationship Marketing
330
Major limitations Transaction cost theory
Transaction cost theory focuses on the single criterion of cost-efficiency for shaping
transactions.
311
3)Relational Contracting Theory (MacNeil (1980)
Rooted in contract law that applies to the legal rights of exchange parties and guides the planning and conduct of exchange.
Relationship Marketing
40
Deals with the criticisms that have been directed at transaction cost theory by including social dimensions of exchange, and by making clear that
hierarchical relationship governance mechanisms are not the only mechanisms
available
Relationship Marketing
Criticized for failing to prescribe optimal types of governance to deal with specific characteristics of the exchange.
Relationship Marketing
42
The basis of social exchange theory is derived from marital theory, bargaining theory, and power theory.
Social,
Technological ,
Knowledge,
Planning,
333
5)Equity Theory
Equity theory postulates that parties in exchange relationships compare their ratios of exchange inputs to outcomes.
Inequity is said to exist when the perceived inputs and/or outcomes in an exchange relationship are psychologically inconsistent with the perceived
inputs and/or outcomes of the referent.
Equitable outcomes stimulate confidence that parties do not Unittake-10 Relationships Marketingadvantage of each other and that they are
concerned about each other’s
Relationship Marketing
44
The political economy paradigm integrates economic efficiency theories of organizations with behavioral power theories.
Economy refers to institutions that transform inputs into output and to the processes by which goods and services are allocated within and between
institutions.
Polity refers to the power and control systems that legitimize, facilitate, monitor, and regulate exchange transactions.
The economy and polity can be considered as allocation systems, allocating scarce economic resources and power.
Relationship Marketing
Comparative advantage in resources allows the firm to occupy a position of competitive advantage in the marketplace.
Relationship Marketing is theoretically supported by the possibility that some kinds of co-operative relationships can enhance competition.
Relationship Marketing
Hunt’s Resource-Advantage Theory; Hunt, 1997) allows resources to be: financial, physical, human, organizational, informational, and
relational.
Resources need not be owned by the firm, but must be available for the purpose of producing value for some segment(s).
Relationship Marketing
9)Institutional Theory
This is an alternative, multi-constituent, and dynamic view that sees social actors in support of the corporation when institutional norms are
upheld.
Relationship Marketing
336
According to James L. Schorr marketing can be thought of as a big bucket with a hole in the bucket.
When the business is running well and the firm is delivering on its promises, the hole is small and few customers are leaving.
When customers are not satisfied they start failing out of the bucket.
50
The primary goal of relationship marketing is to build and maintain a base of committed customers who are profitable for the organization.
A firm which holds the view of relationship marketing shall focus on the attraction, retention, and enhancement of customer relationships.
Relationship Marketing
Customers’ retention through quality products and services and good value over time.
Loyal customers not only provide a solid base for the organization, they may represent growth potential
52
Retaining
Satisfying
Getting
53
Consumers are more likely to stay in a relationship when the gets (quality, satisfaction, specific benefits) exceed the gives (monetary and non
monetary costs.
2)Relational benefits
Confidence benefits - Feelings of trust or confidence in the provider, along with a sense of reduced anxiety. Social benefits and the personal banker
Relationship Marketing
55
The benefits to an organization of maintaining and developing a loyal customer base are numerous.
Unit-10 Relationships Marketing
The major benefits include:
Lower costs
Employee retention
Relationship Marketing
56
A concept or calculation that looks at customers from the point of view of their lifetime revenue and profitability contributions to a company.
The average revenues generated per relevant time period over the lifetime,
Relationship Marketing
57
58
Retention Strategies
1) Financial bonds
Continuous relationships
Personal relationships
Relationship Marketing
59
3)Customization bonds
Anticipation/innovation
Mass customization
Joint investments
CRM leaders should ask the following questions in considering the role of CRM in their organization :
the realization that customers are a business asset rather than a commercial audience
the greater utilization of technology in managing and maximizing the value of information
Do we view CRM from a strategic perspective where it is concerned with how the organization can create increased shareholder value
through developing superior customer relationships?
Are we clear on the distinction between operational CRM, analytical CRM and collaborative CRM?
5. Do we understand the rationale behind addressing CRM from the perspective of the following five processes?
Development
CRM leaders need to review the following issues about the Strategy Development Process.
Business strategy (including leadership and sponsorship)
Senior management in my organization has demonstrated strong leadership in introducing and supporting CRM initiatives
There is a strong and well-supported board level executive who is a committed sponsor of
Development
My organization has a vision, mission, purpose, or statement of direction that clarifies its commitment to quality and customer focus and
that is clearly understood by staff. My organization has a clear set of values that support the vision and these are shared by most of our
staff.
My organization develops and reviews strategic and annual business plans that incorporate an analysis of market trends, customer
characteristics, industry evolution, the competitive landscape and technology impacts
6.My organization has a clear view on the value discipline on which it competes: customer intimacy, operational excellence or product
leadership
7.The future impacts of electronic commerce and shifts in role of channels and intermediaries are considered on a regular basis by senior
management
8.The overall strategic plan serves as the basis for the annual business plans of the organization and its functional departments
Development
9. Managers and supervisors understand their specific responsibilities in carrying out the actions in the strategic plan
Development
Customer Strategy
1. My organization has a clear view on which customers it wishes to serve and which ones it does not wish to serve
2.My organization considers not only its immediate customers but also its customer’s customer in making its marketing
decisions
Development
4.My organization has selected the appropriate level of segmentation of its customer base, i.e. macro- segments, micro-segments or one-to-
one
5.We consider customer segments in terms of value preferences of benefits sought, in addition to more general customer
characteristics
Development
7.At least annually my organization seeks new customer opportunities beyond its existing offer to customers
Development
Rating for our organization (5 applies fully; 0 does not apply at all)
CRM leaders need to review the following issues about the Value Creation Process.
6.My organization has developed a written value proposition identifying the value offered to customers
My organization assesses customer value and end-user customer satisfaction and quantifies overall satisfaction with specific attributes
such as responsiveness, accuracy and timeliness
9.We set targets using comparative data drawn from highperforming organizations
10.We measure complaints and other key indicators of customer (end-user) dissatisfaction (e.g. returns, warranty claims), record these
indicators by cause and act on them.
We utilize an appropriate level of segmentation based on satisfaction measures, sales, profits and other
My organization has identified how acquisition costs and annual profit earned per customer vary at the segment level. We have identified
our most
We have identified the amounts we spend on both customer acquisition and customer retention at the aggregate and segment levels and
have confirmed these are well-balanced
The organization understands the value that each customer segment brings to the company in terms
We use a comprehensive set of metrics to measure customer acquisition, retention, profitability and lifetime value at the segment level and
these are reported to senior management at least quarterly
Rating for our organization (5 applies fully; 0 does not apply at all)
CRM leaders need to review the following issues about the Multi-Channel Integration Process.
We have a clear view on the future impact of electronic channels in our industry
3.Possible structural changes in our industry (disintermediation or reintermediation) have been fully considered
4.We fully understand the advantages and disadvantages of the major channel categories (sales force, outlets, telephony, direct, e-
commerce, mobile, etc.) when developing our channel strategies
5.Our organization formally reviews the range of channel strategy options every year
Integration Process
My organization understands the channels our customers wish to use at different stages of their relationship with us, e.g. pre-sales, sales
and post sales
We know how customer channel preference varies at the segment level across different products or services sold
We monitor the customer experience within channel and across channels and compare our performance with that of our competitors
Integration Process
Rating for our organization (5 applies fully; 0 does not apply at all)
CRM leaders need to review the following issues about the Information Management Process.
Where data on customers reside in different databases we know their location, accuracy and completeness
5.Our customer information links with the company’s existing systems such as fulfillment, service and finance
6.We have an appropriate strategy for our IT systems including hardware and software. We have taken account of the potential of
developments such as web services, business process outsourcing, and/or use of a business service provider, and/or use of an application
service provider
We effectively utilize general data mining tools for customer insight and task-specific analysis tools for market segmentation, customer
profiling, profitability analysis, predictive modeling, etc.
My organization has introduced processes to provide relevant data and information for all appropriate staff
Our organization ensures the integrity of the data it collects in terms of relevancy,
My organization has implemented processes to prevent the unauthorized use or alteration of sensitive and proprietary data
We regularly consider opportunities to introduce new ecommerce applications to improve customer service or to reduce costs
There is an integrated plan agreed across all channels and functional departments for the collection and use of customer information
My customer information system allows information about individual customer to be recognized and used to produce summary
information about the customer for use in customer applications and campaign management
My company uses customer analysis Each issue should be considered in terms of:
Rating for our organization (5 applies fully; 0 does not apply at all)
0 no importance)
The Performance Assessment Process
CRM leaders need to review the following issues about the Performance Assessment Process.
Shareholder Results
1.Our top management recognize the importance of leadership in creating employee, customer and shareholder value
2.The key drivers of shareholder results – employee value, customer value, shareholder value and cost reduction – are fully understood
4.We rank ourselves highly in terms of recruiting, selecting, developing and empowering our employees
6.We rank ourselves highly in terms of delivering superior customer value opportunities in every attractive
customer segment
8.We rank ourselves highly in terms of creating shareholder value compared with our major competitors
9.We take full advantage of all opportunities for cost reduction. Cost reduction
1.We have developed our own standards across all the areas of CRM that are
important to us
2.We have adopted standards developed by others (e.g.CMAT or COPC standards) and used these to benchmark our performance against relevant
external comparators
6.We have identified and put in place appropriate output and comparative metrics
A strategy map (or success map) has been developed that identifies the chain of ‘cause and effect’ logic that connects our company’s strategy with the
drivers that lead to commercial success
Our organization has identified the most important KPIs and these are reported to
Rating for our organization (5 applies fully; 0 does not apply at all)
104
Unit-10 Relationships Marketing