Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
12024
I N T E R NAT I O NA L
J O U R NA L O F
Int J Soc Welfare 2013: 22: 431–439 SOCIAL WELFARE
ISSN 1369-6866
Invited Article
Environmental justice at the heart of
social work practice: Greening the
profession
Lena Dominelli. Environmental justice at the heart of social Lena Dominelli
work practice: Greening the profession School of Applied Social Sciences, Durham University,
Durham, UK
Social workers face many contemporary challenges. Along-
side the difficulties of upholding human rights, social justice
and active citizenship, are those of affirming environmental
justice and care for planet earth in and through social work
practice and addressing climate change and other disasters. I
call for social workers to take action that addresses these
issues as a strong, united profession that works alongside Key words: green social work, environmental justice, greening
dispossessed and marginalised people who do not get their the profession, interdependent world, climate change,
share of global resources, despite their limited ecological foot- disasters
print. I suggest a new paradigm for practice rooted in envi- Lena Dominelli, School of Applied Social Sciences, Durham
ronmental justice that enhances the well-being of people, the University, Durham DH1 3JT, UK
flora, fauna and the ecosystem that sustains and supports us all E-mail: Lena.Dominelli@durham.ac.uk
– green social work, for practitioners supporting life in one
interdependent world. Accepted for publication 1 January 2013
of disasters are becoming increasingly blurred. Poverty, issues and mobilising people to do something about
for example, aggravates the impact of all types of reducing vulnerabilities, enhancing resilience and
disasters, but the disaster literature seldom considers securing environmental justice before a disaster takes
it a disaster in its own right (Dominelli, 2012a). place and afterwards. Preventative planning and action
Furthermore, some scientists claim that climate change is essential in mitigating such risks.
will lead to an increase in volcanic activity and
earthquakes, especially if the Arctic and Antarctic ice
Differentiated experiences of disasters
sheets melt (Pearce, 2012). Climate change also has the
potential to make existing natural disasters worse, as However, environmental degradation and disasters do
super-storm Sandy demonstrated when it hit the USA not impact upon people equally. The differentiated out-
in November 2012. Additionally, regardless of the comes of environmental degradation and disasters
genesis of a disaster, its impact will be evident in the affect poor and marginalised people, poor regions and
lives of living things and the physical environment. The poor environments the most. Bullard (1990) coined the
degraded environment that disasters leave behind will word ‘environmental racism’ to describe the actions
intensify the experience of environmental injustice felt of industrial firms that dumped toxic substances on
by poor people. poor African American neighbourhoods without their
‘Natural’ disasters can cause severe environmental consent and destroyed their environments and health in
degradation and initiate ‘(hu)man-made’ disasters, for the process. Moreover, countries in the Global South
example the earthquake that produced the tsunami that bear a disproportionate burden emanating from dis-
damaged the nuclear reactors at Fukushima Daiichi in asters, particularly so-called ‘natural’ disasters because:
Japan in March 2011. The utilities company, Tokyo 76 per cent of the damages caused by disasters occur
Electric Power Company (TEPCO), had been advised there; 92 per cent of people affected by disasters live
to refrain either from building that particular type of in these countries; and 65 per cent of the economic
reactor in that spot or to strengthen its earthquake losses caused by disasters are incurred there [IFRC
proof-ness. However, this advice had been ignored for (International Federation of the Red Cross and Red
years under the guise of commercial interests linked to Crescent Societies) 2009].
profitability, leaving the plant vulnerable (Lovins, The damage caused to these localities is exacerbated
2011). After the disaster, the Japanese government was by the poor state of the built infrastructure systems –
compelled to step into the breach and provide resources transportation networks, communication links, power
when TEPCO found that it was unable to cover the costs and utilities supplies and buildings including houses,
and declared itself bankrupt (Sobie, 2011). In this case, hospitals, medical clinics and schools. The lack of
as in others when other nuclear reactors have broken availability and/or resilience in these structures is com-
down, for example Chalk River in Canada, Three Mile pounded by: the absence of important resources such as
Island in the USA and Chernobyl in the Ukraine, social networks and money for their development; the
human error has exacerbated mechanical malfunctions presence of corruption in governance systems that
and increased the damage caused to people and the permit the misuse of existing resources; and the failure
environment, often irreparably. of insurance companies to provide affordable cover in
Additionally, the solutions utilised in the case of the poor communities. Additionally, these factors make it
breakdown of nuclear reactors can store up other prob- difficult for communities in the Global South to recover
lems for the future, for example the pouring of kilome- easily from the impact of disasters that have occurred.
tres of concrete to contain radioactive materials uses Furthermore, these problems make prevention and pre-
substances that deteriorate over time, thereby allowing paredness even more important for these locales and
radioactive materials and other heavy metals to seep the groups of people living in them.
into the water-table, causing further environmental Other (hu)man-made disasters that damage the envi-
damage and harm to living things (Zeller, 2012). ronment, injure people and destroy homes, which are
Limited redress in such cases increases people’s frus- rarely considered as perpetuating environmental injus-
trations about the lack of environmental justice for tices, involve aggravated violence, especially that per-
them as victims. For example, many survivors of petrated during armed conflicts. These contribute to
Bhopal are still struggling for reparations. environmental degradation through the ordinance that
The damage caused by disasters is embedded in is fired and contribute to global warming as a result.
everyday life practices or routines. Thus, they become Armed conflicts can also inhibit suffering people from
part of the taken-for-granted fabric of peoples’ daily receiving humanitarian aid or prevent them from reach-
existence and are not questioned either in terms of their ing humanitarian aid camps, as occurred, for example,
impact or in the formulation of measures that can miti- in the Sudan (Toole, 2006). Disputes in such situations
gate risk. In such situations, social workers have an may linger for years. The international community
important role to play in raising consciousness of such seems to be incapable of intervening to establish peace
because the principle of national sovereignty overrides possible is necessary to protect living things and
the state’s duty to protect its citizens/residents the physical environment. Such considerations are
(Dominelli, 2012a). Syria’s current civil war denotes an included in the development of risk reduction strategies
instance in which the international community has that aim to protect the environment and reduce the
failed to bring a halt to hostilities, whereas aid workers impact of environmental degradation on people.
risk their lives to provide limited support for the people Although all of the earth’s residents experience
who are forced to leave their homes to save their lives. the effects of climate change, their contribution to the
Once civilians have been evacuated, the destruction of problem and their experiences of it are differentiated.
homes and the physical environment proceeds rapidly. Unequal consumption patterns mean that rich people
Another seemingly intractable illustration is the UN’s have contributed much more to greenhouse gases, but
failure to resolve the long-standing dispute over land poor people experience their consequences more
and territory between Israel and Palestine. The periodic heavily: Currently, these disparities are indicated in the
armed conflict that flares up between these two nations following realities, and except for the first item, impact
has seriously degraded the daily life and environment most on people with low incomes:
of Palestinians living in the ‘Occupied Territories’.
• 1 billion people over-consume.
Social workers there are struggling both to establish the
• 1 billion people are dying of hunger.
profession in extremely onerous circumstances and
• 1 billion people are malnourished.
provide much needed services for victim-survivors,
• 1 billion people have no clean drinking water.
many of whom are children (Lavalette & Jones, 2011).
• 2.6 billion people have no sanitation.
Climate change itself, an important disaster, pres-
• 1.6 billion people have no access to electricity.
ages a type that blurs the boundaries between natural
• 15 million people die of diseases annually because
and (hu)man-made disasters because the cause of con-
drugs that could cure them are not cheap and
temporary climate change is deemed to be human
easily available.
activity linked to the usage of fossil fuels (Dessler
• Food prices are rising rapidly and in 2008 led to riots
& Parsons, 2006), but its impact on the environment is
around the world (Newsweek, 2012).
likely to occur through the storms and other ‘natural
events’ that follow in its wake. Moreover, scientists These conditions exacerbate the impact of climate
predict growth in the frequency and intensity of change on both the environment and people, especially
extreme weather events including storms, heat waves, during extreme weather events such as flooding, heat
cold spells and the associated flooding and drought that waves and cold snaps, and expose how poverty inten-
produce higher levels of death especially among sifies the damaging effects of environmental injustice.
women, children and older people (Oven et al., 2011; Children are particularly vulnerable during disasters.
Robine et al., 2007). Poor people suffer most when the Unfortunately, some adults, for example paedophiles,
built infrastructure fails in heat waves and cold spells, prey on them for sexual exploitation. They often define
too (Dominelli, 2012b). The impact of climate change children as orphans when they are not and pretend to
also impacts badly on the potential for the survival offer them assistance and care when they are grooming
and recovery of poor people, for example African them for exploitation as occurred in Sri Lanka during
Americans in Hurricane Katrina (Pyles, 2007). the 2004 Indian Ocean Tsunami and in Haiti after the
Although climate change is considered by many as the 2010 earthquake. Getting children back to the routines
most crucial contemporary social issue that requires of school is useful in preventing children from being
attention, there are many ‘sceptics’ (Giddens, 2009). taken advantage of by predatory adults and also
Some disasters have silver linings. For example, the enhances their recovery.
spread of some diseases can be controlled through Extreme weather events also create stresses on
fires, some of which occur naturally through lighting health and social care provisions if the built infrastruc-
strikes that encourage regrowth in forests afterwards, ture fails, for example when the roads become impass-
for example the eucalyptus trees in Australia, or huge able due to snow and ice and the lack of vehicles that
swathes of evergreen forests devastated by pests like are equipped to navigate slippery and icy terrain. This
the pine beetle in British Columbia, Canada. However, situation calls for egalitarian partnerships between the
many fires each year are caused by people’s behaviour public and private sectors and informal carers living in
– untended campfires, dropping litter, cigarette butts the community and are essential in mitigating the
and arson. Wildfires caused by human negligence and effects of environmental injustice. However, the link
natural events such as lightning strikes have caused between formal and informal carers can become
millions of hectares of forests to burn in both temperate exploitative primarily of the women who provide the
and tropical climes. Those started by people are all caring that is needed because state agencies begin to
avoidable, whereas those caused by lighting are not. include the availability of informal and unpaid carers in
However, bringing both under control as quickly as their calculations of how extreme weather events will
be catered for (Dominelli, 2012b). Older people practitioners, they can also highlight how destroying
become particularly vulnerable in such situations – they the environment through climate change creates
lose formal services because providers are unable to winners and losers according to different scenarios that
reach them, and they become dependent on the good- identify risk and mitigation strategies. Social workers
will of family that may live outside the area and neigh- can also act as translators who explain mathematical
bours. As a service provider, interviewed in the Built models to people in ordinary, non-jargonistic language
Infrastructures and Health and Social Care Provisions that they can understand.
for Older People Under Conditions of Climate Change Investing in people through educational provisions is
(BIOPICCC) study, claimed: an important dimension in preparing for disasters. It
also indicates points at which ensuring environmental
when a person is being assessed we’ll be asking
justice coincides with securing social justice. Having an
about whether it is a family member or whoever,
aware, well-educated populace is integral to achieving
about what support they are willing and able to
this outcome. However, this reality is far from being the
actually provide to that person. There is no sort of
case. Globally, more girls and women than boys and
judgement made that someone must provide some-
men are illiterate. This has implications for the extent to
thing for their loved one, but we would ask them
which women can exercise agency and engage in sci-
because we don’t want to take that care away either.
entific discussions, especially if information is not
But it is important from that kind of area that this is
made available to them via other means, for example
something we think about – it is part of the contin-
through audio-visual means or photographs. Despite
gencies. (Dominelli, 2012b, p. 8)
attempts to increase primary school education for
Additionally, people’s expectations about receiving girls and women as a key element in the Millennium
health care at the point of need are being revised as Development Goals that aim to redress the literacy
higher costs provide the reason that politicians use to divide between and within countries, much remains to
justify demands for a greater financial contribution be done in this regard. Social workers have been
from the end user or the patient. These changes are involved in developing and promoting schemes that
becoming increasingly common in the West as they are enable women to become educated but need to do more
being incorporated into policy planning processes to promote environmental justice in situations where
during an age of austerity, as stipulated by policy women carry the major portion of the burden of caring
makers and service providers in the quote given above. for their families in distressed physical environments.
Moreover, policies of passing the costs onto marginal- This point is vividly portrayed by a woman villager
ised groups can become exclusionary because poor interviewed by Dominelli (2012c, p. 7) following the
people cannot afford to purchase medical care or other Indian Ocean Tsunami in Sri Lanka. She commented:
services normally provided through the welfare state.
If men’s economic activities were hampered [by the
For example, people who cannot afford to buy medi-
Tsunami], they are excused by society. . . . Women
cines privately in Greece are protesting the impact of
are not excused by the society. They are supposed to
public expenditure cuts.
do whatever . . . deal with the problems. They . . .
A crucial difficulty about extreme weather events is
take care of the household and the children.
that while their propensity to increase has been pre-
dicted, exactly when and where they will strike and who Meeting development needs, particularly those
they will encompass is less predictable. This makes linked to raising people out of poverty, can cause exten-
being aware of the consequences of preparing for them sive environmental degradation if the development is
(or not) complicated. In such circumstances, some not planned sustainably and if poor people are not
community residents indulge in what Dupuy (2005) involved in multi-stakeholder partnerships to find
called ‘enlightened catastrophism’ by focusing only on solutions alongside experts. Sustainable development
what must be done today. Preparedness, to them, makes according to the Brundtland (1987) Report refers to the
sense largely if the predicted disaster is imminent, not ‘capacity to meet the needs of the present without
one that might not occur for years or even decades destroying the potential of meeting the needs of future
into the future. Such responses emphasise the need for generations’. Regrettably, not all development follows
consciousness-raising and publicity that will alert sustainable principles. The issue of sustainability in the
people to the potential dangers and highlight what steps alleviation of poverty and in tackling climate change
they need to take to mitigate the risks they might face, has become a highly disputed issue in the United
be prepared to take action and know who and where to Nations Framework for the Convention on Climate
go to for help if disaster strikes. Social workers can play Change [Third World Network (TWN), 2012].
a crucial role in exploring such scenarios with local Although agreement in this forum has not been forth-
people in their communities and contribute to the coming, no one and nothing will escape the impact of
realisation of environmental justice in the process. As climate change. Unfortunately, the impact is variable,
In conducting their work, green social workers • therapist helping people deal with the emotional con-
uphold the duty to care for and be cared by others, sequences of disaster; and
including the duty to care for Planet Earth. Green social • protector of the ecosystem/physical environment
workers endorse a holistic approach that envisages a (Dominelli, 2009, 2012a).
unity between people and their physical, social, politi-
Intervening in disaster situations embedded in
cal, economic and cultural environments. These are part
environmental degradation can be complicated and
of one whole and not separate from it.
messy – physically, socially and emotionally. Clarity
Environmental degradation occurs in the course of
about cultural expectations and norms that can militate
meeting people’s needs. Much of it could be reduced by
against fairness and clearing rubble when the physical
more careful planning that draws upon holistic environ-
environment and infrastructures are damaged become
mental assessments that enhance existing forms of
relationship-building skills. In helping people piece
resilience. Involving local people in decision-making
their lives together, green social workers in such disas-
processes and disaster reduction initiatives that
ters undertake the following tasks:
promote sustainable development can avoid poor deci-
sions including those that undermine environmental • assessing need;
integrity. Additionally, such practices underpin the • coordinating and delivering goods and services;
co-production of knowledge and partnerships that cross • assisting in family reunification;
disciplinary divides and facilitate contact between local • supporting individuals and communities to rebuild
people and experts. their lives, develop resilience and build capacity to
Top-down decision making that ignores local minimise future risks; and
knowledge can destroy environmental integrity, force • advocating, lobbying and mobilising for changes
the migration of large numbers of people and produce that safeguard the environment and prevent
unforeseen social and environmental problems, for future disasters.
example the dead water and drought that has occurred
For green practitioners, supporting physically and
following the construction of the Three Gorges
psychosocially injured people and repairing damaged
Dam in China (Watts, 2011). Such projects also
environments become starting points for longer
highlight tensions between governments engaging
term transformative initiatives that develop environ-
in grandiose status-raising projects and the smaller,
mentally just, sustainable, life-enhancing forms of
life-sustaining ones preferred by local people who wish
being and doing.
to remain in their communities of origins rather than
migrate elsewhere.
Social workers are active if invisible players in tack-
Conclusions
ling social and environmental degradation associated
with disasters and reconstructing damaged communi- Green social work is essential for reducing the footprint
ties. A practitioner working in such situations assumes that people leave on the environment, ensuring that all
various roles that require understanding complex power the Earth’s inhabitants have an equitable share of
dynamics and relationships in pursuing environmental resources, protecting the Earth’s flora and fauna and
justice. These include that of: promoting sustainable forms of development that will
not cost the earth or forfeit the future. Green social
• facilitator; work is based on the idea of a citizenry that transcends
• coordinator; particular locales to acknowledge the interdependen-
• community mobiliser (of people and systems); cies between peoples and the realisation of peoples’
• mobiliser of resources; human rights, social and environmental justice and
• negotiator or broker between communities and dif- citizenship entitlements. It encompasses a critique of
ferent levels of government; consumerism, hyper-urbanisation, neo-liberalism and
• mediator between conflicting interests and groups, expert-led solutions to the social challenges that cur-
including gendered relations; rently face humanity. It contains a commitment to
• consultant to government and other agencies; facilitating local residents’ action (agency), valuing
• advocate for people’s rights and entitlements; their knowledge and co-producing solutions alongside
• educator, giving out information about how to access all other stakeholders with an interest in protecting
relief aid and avoid diseases that can erupt following people and the living environment from harm. In pro-
a disaster; moting and enhancing environmental justice, green
• trainer, particularly in how to respond effectively in social work practice is also good social work practice
mobilising local resources when disaster strikes; that draws on empowering values and skills. Hence,
• cultural interpreter; environmentally just, green social work practice lies at
• interdisciplinary translator; the heart of the profession.