Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
* * * * * * TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 7, 2017 ~ VOL. CCLXX NO. 109 WSJ.com HHHH $4.00
DJIA 23548.42 À 9.23 0.04% NASDAQ 6786.44 À 0.3% STOXX 600 396.59 À 0.1% 10-YR. TREAS. À 7/32 , yield 2.318% OIL $57.35 À $1.71 GOLD $1,279.40 À $12.90 EURO $1.1610 YEN 113.71
Broadcom
What’s
Bid Marks
News
Business & Finance
Upheaval
roadcom made an unso-
In Chips
B licited $105 billion bid for
Qualcomm, the chip indus- BY TED GREENWALD
try’s boldest bet yet that size
will equal strength at a time Broadcom Ltd. made an un-
of technological upheaval. A1 solicited $105 billion takeover
bid for Qualcomm Inc., the chip
Disney recently held talks
industry’s boldest bet yet that
to purchase a large chunk of
size will equal strength at a
Fox’s entertainment busi-
time of technological upheaval.
nesses, but the discussions
The approach, which would
ran into an impasse over
mark the biggest technology
price and other key terms. A1
takeover ever, shows how tech
Saudi Arabia’s high-profile companies are positioning
arrests have raised the stakes themselves for a world where
for global investors just as the a range of chip-driven de-
country embarks on a drive vices—from phones to cars to
to lure foreign capital. B1 factory robots—are transmit-
ting, receiving and processing
Oil prices surged to
evermore information.
more than two-year highs
Broadcom Chief Executive
on rising tensions in the
Hock Tan already has used ac-
ERIC GAY/ASSOCIATED PRESS
in an attack by a neighbor. A4
Trump’s campaign team
was briefed before and after
Trail of Allegations down, despite thriving U.S. regional lingo
BY DOUGLAS BELKIN It begins with “aa” (rough
adviser Page’s trip to Moscow
last year, testimony reveals. A4 lava in Hawaii) and moves
Gubernatorial races in
Executives now wonder if the company’s LINK BETWEEN After 55 years, 60,000 words steadily through “fuzzywog” (a
and at least $25 million in re- roll of dust under the furniture
Virginia and New Jersey will hands-off approach gave Roy Price leeway SLEEP, ADHD search grants, the Dictionary of in Wisconsin) and “rap jacket”
be closely watched for
broader political signals. A3 Amazon.com Inc. is legend- address a range of concerns.
DRAWS FOCUS American Regional English has (a contest of endurance in
rung the knell, sugared off, fin- which people beat one another
Spain’s government and ary for trying to know every- Three of Mr. Price’s top lieu- ished out the row. with switches in the South).
thing about its customers. tenants have been fired or left. LIFE & ARTS, A12 The reason: the For 15 years, the
Catalan independence forces
have begun maneuvering When it came to its entertain- Interviews with current and small tribe of lexi- project’s motto
ahead of December votes. A9 ment unit and the executive in former executives, as well as cographers ran was “On to Z.”
charge there, though, the com- with producers who have out of cash. No When it finally got
pany appears to have fallen worked with Amazon Studios, more chink, boo- there in 2012 with
CONTENTS Markets.................... B13 down on the job. paint a picture of alleged mis- dle or do-re-mi. “zippy stick” (a
Banking, Finance.. B12 Opinion.............. A15-17
Business News.. B3,6,7 Sports....................... A14 conduct by Mr. Price that goes University of cricket in Ohio),
Capital Journal...... A4 U.S. News............. A2-5 By Joe Flint, well beyond the public allega- Wisconsin English “zune” (a go-getter
Crossword............... A11 Technology............... B4 Ben Fritz tions that appear to have Professor Frederic in Georgia) and
Heard on Street.. B13 Weather Watch.. A11
Life & Arts....... A11-13 World News... A6,8-9 and Laura Stevens played a role in his departure. Cassidy launched Shopping cart zydeco (a music
In addition, business troubles the project in or buggy? style in Louisiana),
>
Amazon Studios Chairman
Roy Price abruptly resigned in
were allowed to fester, some
of these people said.
BANKS’ CRISIS 1962. Lauded as federal grants and
“the greatest American lexico- private gifts began to dry up.
mid-October after details Mr. Price appeared inebri- WARRANTS graphical project of the latter In 2013, it launched a web-
emerged publicly of an alleged
incident of sexual harass-
ated at a number of profes-
sional functions, people who
PAY OFF half of 20th century” by the based version.
American Dialect Society, it “People were happy to help
s Copyright 2017 Dow Jones &
ment. Since then, Amazon worked with him said, and aimed to capture the nation’s us get to Z, but once we did,
Company. All Rights Reserved has made a series of manage- Amazon executives had to BUSINESS & FINANCE, B1 regional words, pronunciation there was little or no incentive
ment changes at the studio to Please see STUDIO page A10 and syntax. Please see WORDS page A10
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
A2 | Tuesday, November 7, 2017 * **** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
the article’s reporting. Some edi- ETFs report. Funds & ETFs report on Monday. tured Friday in Mansion’s Rela- Letters to the Editor: Fax: 212-416-2891; email: wsj.ltrs@wsj.com
tions Monday incorrectly said tive Values article is at the Park NEED ASSISTANCE WITH YOUR SUBSCRIPTION?
Ian Talley was a contributor. Donald Ellenberger, co-man- Sayfullo Saipov, the man ac- City Mountain Resort. In some By web: customercenter.wsj.com; By email: wsjsupport@wsj.com
ager of Federated Total Return cused of killing eight people and editions, its former name, Can- By phone: 1-800-JOURNAL (1-800-568-7625); Or by live chat at wsj.com/livechat
Investor Jeremy Grantham Bond Fund, said he doesn’t think injuring at least a dozen others yons Resort, was used and was
says both emerging and devel- yield spreads, or difference be- last week by driving a rented misspelled as Canyon’s. In other REPRINTS & LICENSING
oped markets outside the U.S. tween corporate bond and U.S. truck down a New York City bike editions, it was misidentified as By email: customreprints@dowjones.com; By phone: 1-800-843-0008
probably will deliver better re- Treasury bond yields, “will path, once lived in Cuyahoga Park City Resort.
GOT A TIP FOR US? SUBMIT IT AT WSJ.COM/TIPS
Readers can alert The Wall Street Journal to any errors in news articles by emailing wsjcontact@wsj.com or by calling 888-410-2667.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * Tuesday, November 7, 2017 | A3
U.S. NEWS
Tuesday’s gubernatorial
races in Virginia and New Jer- New Jersey
sey are the first big, statewide By most measures, this race
elections since Donald Trump looks to be a walk for Demo-
won the presidency. Both par- cratic diplomat Phil Murphy
ties will be looking at the re- over Lt. Gov. Kim Guadagno.
sults for signals about the Not a single poll in the Real
broader political landscape Clear Politics average has the
ahead of next year’s elections race in single digits.
for the House and Senate. A big reason for this is cur-
For Republicans, a victory in rent GOP Gov. Chris Christie,
Virginia would show that the who never recovered from the
party has power in a state that Bridgegate scandal.
backed Democrats in the past Middlesex and Somerset
three presidential elec- Republicans might have their best chance in Virginia, where GOP Counties: These largely subur-
tions. Democrats, having lost candidate Ed Gillespie, left, faces Democrat Ralph Northam. ban counties between Trenton
several special House elections and Newark went for Mr.
this year, want to show that Bob McDonnell won the gover- preparing for victory. Christie twice, in 2009 and T H E CR IS S CROS S CU FF
they can stay on top in Virginia nor’s mansion, the county pro- A win here probably won’t 2013. But they both also went
Ve rdura’s cl a ssic, wove n in 18k gol d
and gain ground in New Jersey. duced about 273,000 votes. come easily. Loudoun’s popula- for Hillary Clinton in 2016.
As the returns come in, the When Democrat Terry McAu- tion growth is high—up 24% These counties have diverse Yellow gol d , $18 ,0 0 0 • White or rose gol d , $18 ,950
cities and counties below will liffe won four years later, more since 2010—and the influx of populations with high educa-
give clues as to how these than 306,000 gubernatorial people could be creating a tional attainment, characteris-
races might turn out. votes came from Fairfax. more Democratic electorate. tics that signal Democratic
The vote is unlikely to in- City of Richmond: The cap- strength. If Mrs. Guadagno 74 5 F I F T H AV E N U E , 12 T H F LO O R
crease by that much this year. ital is also a good place to wins here, it’s a sign she may
Virginia But if it’s up by an additional measure the African-American do better than expected.
212 .758 . 33 8 8 • V E R D U R A .CO M
This is the race that gives 10,000 votes, with the Demo- vote in Virginia, as about half Essex, Union and Camden Original gouache by Duke Fulco di Verdura
Republicans their best crat winning 58% to 60% of the city’s population is black. Counties: These counties on
chance for a win. Many polls them, that would be a sign that The number of votes cast in the east and west borders of
show Democrat Ralph Northam upper-income, suburban Demo- Richmond can swing substan- the state all lean Democratic
with a slight edge, but Republi- crats are revved up—a good tially. In the 2005 election, the and have populations that are
can Ed Gillespie’s numbers sign for Mr. Northam. city produced 51,000 votes. In 20% or more African-Ameri-
have climbed. Loudoun County: This 2009, only 45,000. But in 2013, can. They will offer a sense of
Fairfax County: Democrats county on the outer edge of it produced 58,000 votes. black turnout in the state.
likely will win here, and by a the Washington suburbs may Democrats won the city in Salem and Gloucester
lot. The question is how many be the one to watch for Mr. every election. But those dif- Counties: These counties will
votes come from this suburban Gillespie’s prospects. In his un- ferences in turnout were im- offer a measure of turnout
county near Washington, successful 2014 Senate race, he portant to the state outcome. among Mr. Trump’s base in the
D.C. Higher turnout is likely to narrowly won Loudoun. If he Virginia Beach: The Tide- state. Both supported Mr.
be a good sign for Democrats. wins here again Tuesday night, water region traditionally fa- Christie twice, and both
In 2009, when Republican the Gillespie team may start vors Republicans, but Mr. backed Mr. Trump in 2016.
U.S. NEWS
Trump Trip Is Last Best Shot on North Korea already be too late to fully re- They feel few constraints at put into place an onerous set friends in Russia for re- Technically, at least, the
verse the nuclear ambitions home that limit what they of United Nations economic lief. “The more China squeezes U.S., China and Russia share
of its 33-year-old leader, Kim can do abroad. sanctions designed to exert a North Korea, the more poten- the same long-term goal,
Jong Un. But if those ambi- Moreover, China and Rus- much more painful economic tial there is that the North Ko- which is a Korean Peninsula
tions are to be reined in at sia bear as much responsibil- squeeze on Mr. Kim. reans turn toward Russia,” without nuclear weapons. It’s
all, these three men are the ity as any nation for the It may be working, to an says Stephen Hadley, national increasingly questionable
only ones who can accomplish North Korean nuclear and extent. China appears, per- security adviser for President whether that is realistic. Still,
that, and now may be the last missile threat. Both have haps for the first time, to be George W. Bush. “I don’t think let’s assume it is. There’s only
CAPITAL JOURNAL time to do so. The stakes, in provided military help over truly clamping down on trade [Russia and the Trump ad- one way to start down the
By Gerald F. Seib short, are very high. the years, and have been with North Korea to increase ministration] are on the path toward it: diplomatic en-
Pyongyang’s trading part- the economic price Mr. Kim same page at this point, and gagement to discuss the goal.
I
n meeting Chinese Presi- ners. The Central Intelli- that is why I think it is im- Though it’s little appreci-
President Donald Trump dent Xi Jinping and Rus- gence Agency estimates that portant for Trump to see ated, the Trump administra-
will meet this week with the sian President Vladimir North Korea sends 85% of its both Xi and Putin.” tion has repeatedly signaled
two other most powerful men Putin at separate stops on his exports to China, and re-
The danger now is its willingness to talk with
that North Korea
S
in the world, the leaders of current Asian tour, Mr. ceives 90% of its imports o let’s say this week’s North Korea. Mr. Trump did
China and Russia. There will Trump will be seeing leaders from there. And when China talks produce agree- so again over the weekend,
be much to discuss, but far at the top of their powers. began squeezing down its oil
turns to its friends in ment on exerting more reiterating that he’d actually
and away the most important The 64-year-old Mr. Xi just exports to North Korea re- Russia for relief. real and sustained economic be willing to meet Mr. Kim
item is this: finished a Communist Party cently, Russia stepped up to pressure on North Korea. personally at some point.
Can they congress in which he consoli- help fill the gap. What’s the broader goal? North Korea is refusing. It
together stop dated power, marginalized So the 71-year-old Mr. So far, the main, joint Chi- apparently wants to wait un-
a man half potential rivals and fostered a Trump this week will be see- pays for his nuclear brink- nese and Russian proposal til it has proven it has a nu-
their age, who cult of personality unlike any ing the elder statesmen with manship. Certainly China has has been an unhelpful “freeze clear warhead that can fit on
leads a coun- seen since Mao Zedong. The the power to do something ample reasons to do so. Mr. for freeze” plan, in which a missile capable of reach-
try smaller 65-year-old Mr. Putin has about North Korea. But what Xi has expansive visions of North Korea would freeze its ing, say, Chicago, before
than Mississippi, with a per been either president or is that something? spreading China’s economic nuclear program in return for agreeing to talk. That’s the
capita gross domestic product prime minister of Russia Mr. Trump’s strategy ap- primacy across Asia with in- the U.S. and South Korea obstacle to diplomacy—and
that ranks just below that of since 2000, and is about to pears to be to scare the vestments in infrastructure freezing any joint military ex- the one that Messrs. Trump,
Guinea-Bissau, from disrupt- announce that he’ll seek an- world into believing he is ca- and friendships, and a Korean ercises. That proposal seems Xi and Putin can try this
ing the world order on which other six-year term, which he pable of doing just about crisis could lay waste to to equate world-defying nu- week to knock down.
their prosperity depends? doubtless will win. anything to stop North Ko- much of that dream. clear misbehavior with rou-
That other country is, of Both may be on their way rea, including a military in- The danger now is that tine military exercises con- Trump urges Japan to buy
course, North Korea. It may to being leaders for life. vasion, while also helping North Korea turns to its ducted by longtime allies. U.S. military equipment....... A6
WASHINGTON—When Presi-
Moscow Visit
dent Donald Trump hosted BY BYRON TAU
leaders of a communications
company moving their head- WASHINGTON—President
quarters from Singapore to the Donald Trump’s campaign
U.S. in the Oval Office on Thurs- team was briefed before and
day, a single lawmaker was after foreign-policy adviser
JOSHUA ROBERTS/REUTERS
U.S. NEWS
DEAL Chipping In
Global semiconductor
M&A deal value
unveiling the chip industry’s
largest-ever acquisition: a $39
billion proposed deal for NXP
Semiconductors NV. The deal
Continued from Page One hasn’t closed yet, and Broad-
ing to some analysts. Under $175 billion 2017 $167B* com said Monday that its pro-
typical circumstances, un- posal would stand regardless
friendly bids like this are diffi- 150 of whether Qualcomm’s pro-
cult to pull off; given the sheer posed acquisition of NXP is
size and complexity of Qual- 125 consummated under the cur-
comm, this one could be espe- rent terms.
cially challenging, analysts 100 Since then, a string of hits
said Monday. by regulators, competitors and
Broadcom’s preference is to 75 customers including Apple has
strike a friendly deal, but if it left the industry titan in a vul-
fails to do so, it would con- 50 nerable position. Qualcomm’s
sider nominating Qualcomm profit in the fiscal year that
directors who may be more 25 ended Sept. 24 plummeted
amenable to a transaction, a 57%, and its share price de-
person familiar with the mat- 0 clined 18% in the 12 months
ter said. The nomination dead- 1995 2000 ’05 ’10 ’15 through Thursday’s close com-
line is Dec. 8 and the annual *Year-to-date; Includes Broadcom's pared with a 58% rise in the
meeting at which the director Qualcomm bid PHLX Semiconductor Sector
vote would take place is likely Source: Dealogic Index. That was before news
be around March. THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. of Broadcom’s interest sent
Broadcom offered $70 a Qualcomm shares up nearly
share for Qualcomm, repre- chips for Wi-Fi and Bluetooth 13% on Friday.
senting a 28% premium from technology that connect de- Funding for the deal would
its closing price on Thursday—
before news reports on the ex-
pected approach.
vices that are closer to-
gether—technologies that
some analysts say are likely to
come in the form of loans
from a gaggle of banks, with
additional cash from Silver
New direction
Qualcomm shares ended grow less quickly than 5G. Lake Management LLC. The
trading Monday up 1.2% to
$62.52, while Broadcom
shares were 1.4% higher at
“People will continue to use
short-proximity wireless like
Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, but the
private-equity firm, which al-
ready owns a stake in Broad-
com, provided a commitment
for your old 401(k)
$277.52. growth and money is clearly in letter for $5 billion in convert-
Mr. Tan said he has been 5G,” said analyst Patrick ible debt. Silver Lake said a
talking with Qualcomm for Moorhead of Moor Insights & substantial portion of that If you decide to move your old 401(k) to a
over a year about a possible Strategy. capital would come in the Fidelity IRA, we can help you make sure
tie-up. “Our strategy has been Overall, Broadcom and Qual- form of an equity investment
you’re clear on where you stand for retirement.
consistent,” Mr. Tan said in an comm have largely comple- from its Silver Lake Partners
interview. “When a business is mentary product lines. But the fund, with the remainder from
And we’ll make the rollover process easy,
No. 1 in technology and No. 1 in other sources. helping you:
market position, we acquire it Broadcom’s bid came days
and put it on our Broadcom after the Singapore-based • Choose the right IRA
platform and grow through
Broadcom would company announced plans to • Initiate the transfer from your former
that strategy. Qualcomm has a prefer to strike a relocate its headquarters to employer
very large sustainable franchise the U.S., a move that could
that meets those criteria.”
friendly deal with make it easier to pursue acqui- • Get status and confirmation updates for
Should the deal be com- Qualcomm. sitions of U.S. targets. your rollover
pleted, Broadcom would take Broadcom’s earlier $5.5 bil- • Select investments for your account
on Qualcomm’s leadership in lion offer to buy Brocade Com-
developing the next wave of munication Systems, based in It’s your retirement. Know where you stand.
cellular technology, known as possible Broadcom takeover is San Jose, Calif., has been de-
5G, which is expected to roll likely to face intense regula- layed due to a review by the
out over the coming two years. tory scrutiny, given the compa- Committee on Foreign Invest-
That could give Broadcom a nies’ combined scale and the ment in the United States,
new growth engine, as 5G is ex- fact that they are both leaders which reviews international
pected to dramatically acceler- in Wi-Fi and Bluetooth technol- deals that raise concerns
ate the speed and responsive- ogy. The companies share cus- about national security.
ness of cellular communications tomers including Apple Inc., Any deal to acquire Qual-
necessary for applications like whose iPhones and iPads in- comm would also receive close 800.FIDELITY | Fidelity.com
self-driving cars. clude components from both scrutiny, experts say. “Any-
Broadcom was formed Qualcomm and Broadcom. thing that has the word semi-
when Avago Technologies Ltd. Qualcomm already has been conductor in it gets rapt atten- Be sure to consider all your available options,
bought the former Broadcom under pressure from antitrust tion from CFIUS,” said James including staying in plan, and the applicable fees
in 2015 for $39 billion and agencies in several jurisdic- Lewis of the Center for Strate- and features of each before moving your retirement assets.
kept the name, and Mr. Tan tions, including the U.S. The gic and International Studies,
has continued growing by ac- company has paid hefty regu- a policy think tank. “The move Investing involves risk, including the risk of loss.
quisition. The company sells a latory fines in China, South to the U.S. is an effort to tamp The trademarks and/or service marks appearing above are the property of FMR LLC and may be registered.
diverse line of equipment for Korea and Taiwan. down CFIUS concerns.” Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC, Member NYSE, SIPC. © 2017 FMR LLC. All rights reserved. 812682.1.0
networking and communica- Qualcomm was riding high —Dana Cimilluca
tions. Its products include as recently as a year ago after contributed to this article.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
A6 | Tuesday, November 7, 2017 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
WORLD NEWS
Trump Urges Japanese Military Purchases
President says deals The two leaders are much
closer in their views on North
would raise security in Korea. Mr. Trump called North
region, add jobs in U.S.; Korea a “threat to the civilized
world,” again not ruling out
Abe plans upgrades military action. “Look what
happened with very weak rhet-
BY MICHAEL C. BENDER oric over the last 25 years—
look where we are right now.”
TOKYO—President Donald The president called on
Trump pushed for Japan to buy North Korean leader Kim Jong
massive amounts of military Un to return Japanese citizens
equipment from the U.S., saying his country abducted.
it would help the country shoot “It would be a tremendous
down missiles like the pair that signal if Kim Jong Un would
nearby North Korea has fired send them back,” Mr. Trump
overhead in recent months. said. “That would be the start
GO TO WORK
IN BLISSFUL
COMFORT
Luxury Card is the industry leader versus the competition for airfare
and cash back redemptions. Cardmembers enjoy a first-class experience including
a 24/7 concierge service, patented metal cards, a members-only magazine and
VIP travel benefits at over 3,000 exclusive destinations around the world.
24K-GOLD-PLATED—PATENTED CARD DESIGN STAINLESS STEEL—PATENTED CARD DESIGN BRUSHED STAINLESS STEEL—PATENTED CARD DESIGN
*Quote from 6/12/17 article refers to redeeming points for unrestricted award travel.
Luxury Card marks are property of Black Card LLC. BLACKCARD is a registered trademark used under license. Luxury Card products are issued by Barclays Bank Delaware (Barclaycard) pursuant to a license by Mastercard
International Incorporated, owner of registered trademarks MASTERCARD and WORLD ELITE MASTERCARD. All trademarks are the property of their respective owners. © 2007—2017 Black Card LLC.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
A8 | Tuesday, November 7, 2017 * * THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
WORLD NEWS
P
Russia’s President Vladi- his worldview.” chilling effect, hampering the rince Mohammed may
mir Putin cemented his au- development of non-oil in- have more immediate
T
thority in the early years of his weekend’s purge, dustries and denting overall priorities as he seeks
the century by which follows an ear- investor interest. the repatriation of vast for-
jailing, dispos- lier wave of arrests and This crackdown played “a tunes that some of the de-
AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE/GETTY IMAGES
sessing or the dismissal of Prince Mo- vital role in helping Saudi tained princes and business-
driving into hammed’s predecessor as Arabia to realize its dream of men—and others not yet
exile many of crown prince, former interior a happy and prosperous soci- touched by the purge—have
his nation’s minister Mohammed bin ety,” Khalid al Mehaisen, amassed overseas, said An-
oligarchs, par- Nayef, is unprecedented in president of the national an- drew Bowen, a specialist on
ticularly those with political modern Saudi history. Those ticorruption commission, Saudi Arabia at the American
ambitions. China’s leader Xi detained include leading which is part of the new su- Enterprise Institute, a Wash-
Jinping harnessed a wide- business and media tycoons, preme committee alongside ington think tank.
ranging anticorruption cam- senior princes and the main other government agencies, “For Xi and Putin, there is
paign launched in 2012 in a policy makers of previous said Monday. “This will only a lot of domestic popularity
similar fashion, eliminating Saudi administrations. Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman’s crackdown shows he ‘will be possible when we com- in going after corruption, and
potential rivals and consoli- While corruption is wide- not tolerate any opposition to his worldview,’ one observer says. pletely weed out the cancer this is also popular with
dating power for the foresee- spread at the top rungs of of corruption, which is one of Saudi youth,” Mr. Bowen said.
able future. the Saudi royal family and justice, according to analysts ahead of the crackdown and the biggest stumbling blocks “But Mohammed bin Salman
By having much of the business elite, the reasons and diplomats. now lives in the U.S. “The to progress.” is also facing a fiscal hole in
kingdom’s ancien regime de- for targeting these individu- “It is very selective. Right royal family used to be part- No charges or evidence Saudi Arabia. A lot of these
tained on Saturday, Saudi als—just as was the case in now, there is corruption hap- ners: you steal and I steal, against the detainees have corrupt Saudi princes who
Arabia’s Crown Prince Mo- Russia’s and China’s anti- pening around him,” said Ja- you take a cut and I take a been made public, and they have taken money out of the
hammed bin Salman seems to graft campaigns—have more mal Khashoggi, a prominent cut. Now he has ultimate all remain in custody—many country are easy sitting tar-
be using the same playbook. to do with Prince Moham- Saudi commentator and for- power. It’s a game-changer.” of them in the comman- gets to bring money back into
The 32-year-old heir to the med’s consolidation of mer TV and newspaper exec- The question now is deered Ritz-Carlton hotel in the kingdom, regardless of
throne is, among other power than administering utive who left the kingdom whether Prince Mohammed, Riyadh. The new supreme the value of the Aramco IPO.”
LA SEXTA TV/REUTERS
with the documents, the Bronf-
man family lent millions of dol- U.N. Security Council
lars to help fund the offshore Presses on Rohingya
trust, set up in 1991 by Leo Kol-
ber for the benefit of Mr. Kol- The United Nations Security
ber’s son, Jonathan. At the time, Council stepped up pressure on
Mr. Kolber was chairman of the Myanmar by unanimously adopt- A video still shows former Catalan leader Carles Puigdemont, right, with his Belgian lawyer Paul Bekaert during a meeting in Brussels.
Bronfman family’s investment ing a presidential statement de-
ahead of the Dec. 21 vote that dence in late October failed to out of more than 80%.
will seat a new government for achieve secession for the In the interview, Mr. de
Catalonia and return control of northeastern region. les Puigdemont’s flight to Bel- Guindos warned that a pro-
the region to Catalan officials. “What are the pro-indepen- gium has also divided separat- tracted independence drive
“The independence of Cata- dence parties going to sell in ists, with some saying he could dent the economic
lonia is not possible,” Spanish the next elections? Are they should have remained in Bar- health of Catalonia, one of
Finance Minister Luis de Guin- going to sell the idea that celona and continued to lead Spain’s richest regions.
dos said in an interview. The they’re going to declare a re- the independence movement, The finance minister
future of a Catalonia that re- public if they’ve already done even if it were from jail. cracked open the door to the
mains part of Spain “could be so and it didn’t amount to But his decision to leave possibility of talks that could
ROYAL GREETING: The Prince of Wales fed an orangutan during a much better, could be much anything?” Inés Arrimadas, Spain hasn’t turned off as grant more fiscal autonomy to
visit Monday to a wildlife rehabilitation center in Kuching, Malaysia. more brilliant and could bring head of the opposition in Cat- many separatist voters as Catalonia.
We are honored to be named the Financial Times Group’s Best Private Bank in the U.S.,
Best Private Bank for Family Offices and Best Private Bank in the U.S. for Succession Planning.
These awards recognize — among other reasons — dynamic asset growth in our goals-based
wealth management program, low ratio of clients per advisor and outstanding transparency.
ACHIEVE GREATER
INVESTING \ BANKING \ TRUST & ESTATE SERVICES \ WEALTH PLANNING \ FAMILY OFFICE
The Northern Trust Company \ Member FDIC. © 2017 Northern Trust Corporation. 2017 Global Private Banking Awards presented by Professional Wealth Management and The Banker.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
A10 | Tuesday, November 7, 2017 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
IN DEPTH
year for the talent in Amazon’s episode. Ajay Patel, the studio’s ple close to Ms. Friel worked to to top roles in the television di-
shows, Mr. Price appeared in- associate general counsel, was keep the two of them separate vision.
ebriated and told a group of ex- made aware of the incident, this because she was uncomfortable At a recent town-hall meet-
ecutives he was looking for a person said. Mr. Patel declined with his interest, this person ing at Amazon Studios, Brad
young actress to sleep with that to comment, Amazon said. said. A spokesman for Ms. Friel Beale, Amazon’s Seattle-based
night, said a person present. Amazon executives in Seattle declined to comment. The per- head of digital-video-content ac-
Mr. Price disputes the two brought in an outside investiga- son close to Mr. Price said he quisition, told employees, “We
accounts of his behavior at the tor, Public Interest Investiga- disputed that account. broke your trust and we’re very
events, said a person close to tions Inc., a few weeks later, Frustration with Mr. Price ex- sorry,” said a person present.
him. people who took part in the tended to his demeanor in busi- Mr. Beale promised Amazon was
Amazon made a big push into television and movies—such as ‘The In July 2015, at a dinner with probe said. Public Interest de- ness. He often struck colleagues embarking on a “cultural shift”
Lost City of Z,’ above—under its studio’s chairman, Roy Price. the cast and producers of the clined to comment. as aloof and disengaged, said at its studio.
Joan Houston Hall, a former submarine sandwiches “hoa- DARE said. John P. Kaminski,
chief editor. “Fundraising be- gies,” but the pronunciation of director of the Center for the
gan to get really difficult be- “path” as pee-ath is disappear- Study of the American Consti-
cause it’s not sexy to say we ing. The word “days,” though, tution at the University of Wis-
need more money to update is morphing into “deeze.” consin, has asked Dr. Hall to
the digital version.” Words for objects that help decipher words in news-
Purchases—mostly by librar- didn’t exist a century ago are papers used to describe cele-
ies—didn’t generate enough also diverging. In Califor- brations following the docu-
funds. The web version, which nia, Northerners and Southern- ment’s ratification in the 1780s.
costs $49 a year for individuals ers giving directions on driving A “bumper,” he learned, was a
and about $5,000 for institu- routes disagree about whether tankard from which to drink
tions, will continue to operate to take “5” or “the 5.” In the rum.
and occasionally be updated by Midwest, a supermarket cart is Douglas Kelling, a medical
volunteer editors, DARE said. a “buggy” south of Ohio and doctor from rural Missouri who
The dictionary closes shop Pennsylvania. practices in North Carolina, has
even as the evolution of Ameri- Research for the Dictionary been flummoxed by the South- Regional dialects still thrive in the U.S. Above, a merry-go-round, or spinning jenny, or flying Dutchman.
can English forges energeti- of American Regional English ern dialect several times
cally, and chaotically, began in 1965 and the team throughout his career. An 80- schmar, a professor at the Uni- “People are endlessly cre- For 200 years, the Green
ahead, lexicographers say. De- grew to 80 field workers. year-old woman asked him af- versity of Georgia and editor of ative,” Dr. Kretzschmar said. Mountains, a north-south range
spite the influence of mass They carried surveys with ter a recent examination how the Linguistic Atlas Project, There are dozens of words for splitting the state, marked the
communications and social me- more than 1,600 questions such her “ticklebox” was faring. She which studies language as it is a heavy rain, from “toad-stran- line between dropped R’s in
dia, new words and pronuncia- as, “What’s another word for a was referring to her heart. spoken in the U.S. gler” in the Gulf states to words like “car” and “park”
tions rise up in one region as person’s mouth?” Among the Another man complained of Contrary to conventional “turd-floater” in Texas and and pronounced R’s. But a 2012
others fade away. 77 answers: maw, clam, jug, “having lost his nature,” Dr. wisdom, American English is “gully washer” out West. Dartmouth College study
“Dialects are changing but flytrap, boose and bugle. Kelling said. He was suffering growing less homogenized, not Country singer Mark Leach showed the line of demarcation
they’re not disappearing,” said Over the next five years, the from erectile dysfunction. more, he said. grew up outside Cleveland and has moved about 50 miles east
Laurel MacKenzie, a linguist at crew interviewed 2,777 mostly Allan Metcalf, a professor of That may appear counterin- learned to sing country songs as New Yorkers invaded Ver-
New York University. “Some- older residents of 1,002 com- English at MacMurray College tuitive to professionals, who listening to artists from the mont and the younger genera-
one who grew up in New York munities from Hawaii to Maine. in Jacksonville, Ill., and execu- tend to speak mostly to others Deep South. Now he speaks like tion began to favor harder R’s
today doesn’t sound like some- After that, researchers added tive secretary of the American like them, he said. But at a lo- he’s from Cleveland but sings to sound less “backwoods.”
one who grew up in New York words they found in books, Dialect Society, said language, cal level, American English is like he’s from Georgia. “When I Other New England stal-
50 or 100 years ago, but they magazines and newspapers. no less than people and events, more regional than ever. This sing it’s like a different part of warts hold strong, said James
don’t sound like someone from The troop blew past the ini- is an important record of his- complexity is fueled by people’s my brain takes over,” he said. Stanford, the Dartmouth pa-
Alabama.” tial 1976 completion target but tory. movement from one region of The dropped R that Bosto- per’s co-author. Rotaries are
In recent years, locals of managed to publish the first The dialect dictionary is sig- the country to another, where nians imported from southeast still New Englandese for traffic
eastern Vermont have found volume—A to C—in 1985. Prog- nificant because it is designed they introduce their own quirks England in the 17th and circles, packies are places that
long lost R’s they had been ress slowed with the advent of to capture not how people into new communities. These 18th centuries and exported sell liquor and something that
dropping for 200 years—but the internet because there was should speak, but how they do are absorbed into an ever- into New Hampshire and Ver- is exceptionally good is, of
they still hold fast to Vermon- that much more to examine speak, said William Kretz- changing local dialect, he said. mont has been in retreat. course, a “wicked pissah.”
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * NY Tuesday, November 7, 2017 | A10A
Police Officer Acquitted in Road-Rage Killing terests from governing,” his would vote no.
incident. preme Court was the first case police or there is a question as and testimony from Mr. Small’s
The case centered on prosecuted by New York Attor- to whether the civilian was relatives who were in the car
whether Officer Wayne Isaacs, ney General Eric Schneiderman armed and dangerous. in an attempt to sway the jury.
who was off-duty, acted in Those questions surfaced in “We are disappointed by the
self-defense when he shot Del- the trial when surveillance verdict,” Mr. Schneiderman
rawn Small, 37 years old, on video was discovered in the said in a statement. “But we re-
July 4, 2016.
‘We are disappointed days after the shooting that spect the jury’s determination.”
Officer Isaacs, who is cur- by the verdict. But we appeared to show Officer The courtroom erupted
rently suspended with pay Isaacs shoot Mr. Small almost when the verdict was read.
from the NYPD, was charged
respect the jury’s immediately when the motor- One activist shouted that the
with second-degree murder determination.’ ist came up to his car. jury were murderers and criti-
and first-degree manslaughter. Mr. Small, driving with his cized the justice system.
Stephen Worth, the attor- girlfriend and two children, Victor Dempsey and Victo-
ney for Officer Isaacs, credited believed the officer had cut ria Davis, Mr. Small’s siblings,
testimony by medical profes- under a 2015 executive order him off as he was trying to issued a joint statement say- TRIBUTE: Argentina’s President Mauricio Macri on Monday laid
sionals who said they treated Gov. Andrew Cuomo signed in turn on Atlantic Avenue just ing they felt an independent flowers at the Manhattan bike path where eight people, including
the officer after the shooting the wake of protests sparked after midnight, law-enforce- prosecutor was still valuable five Argentines, were killed by a man driving a rented truck.
as crucial in convincing the by the 2014 case of Eric Gar- ment officials said. He then for cases in which civilians are
jury of the self-defense argu- ner, who died after a police of- followed Officer Isaacs for a killed by police.
Elegance is an attitude
Longines Symphonette
Kate Winslet
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
A10B | Tuesday, November 7, 2017 NY * * THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
New Restaurants
Are Spicing Up
Newark Nightlife
BY JEANETTE SETTEMBRE been built in Newark since
2014, and another 900 units
Newark has long catered to are under construction, accord-
the business-lunch crowd. Now, ing to CoStar. Total investment
LIFE&ARTS
massively profitable hit.
Last year, concerned that their
superhero pictures were becoming
too dark and violent, Warner lead-
ers assigned comic-book
writer Geoff Johns and
production executive
Jon Berg to over-
see the DC movie
slate and give it a
more optimistic
tone. Their first
task was a re-
write of “Justice
League,” done with
the “Batman v Super-
man” team of Zack Sny-
der and screenwriter Chris Ter-
rio, to make the movie less serious
and more hopeful.
Mr. Tsujihara also made clear he
wanted “Justice League” to be un-
der two hours, said a person close
to the movie. “Batman v Super-
man,” by contrast, ran 151 minutes.
CLOCKWISE FROM TOP RIGHT: BRIAN ACH/GETTY IMAGES; WARNER BROS. PICTURES (2)
JON KRAUSE
tion began, compared with three
hours later for the ADHD group.
The hyperactivity that manifests
itself during the day for those with
ADHD may be a coping mechanism
for exhaustion, Dr. Kooij says. ADHD medications boost dop- psychiatry at the University of To- brain in SAD.” neuroscientist and head of the
In another 24-person study, Dr. amine levels. ronto, says he was doing a genetic He has used the same light psychology department at May-
Kooij and colleagues found that Dr. Kooij notes that ADHD pa- study on SAD when he noticed treatments used to treat SAD pa- nooth University in Ireland, has
core body temperature and moving tients also tend to suffer from sea- large numbers of people with SAD tients—30 minutes of ultraviolet- researched ADHD and sleep. He
patterns associated with sleep sonal affective disorder (SAD) also had ADHD. filtered light exposure in the examined levels of cortisol, a
were also delayed in people with more often than others, meaning morning—on those who also have stress hormone with ebbs and
ADHD, compared with a control they get more depressed in the ADHD. He found that they subse- flows over a 24-hour period in the
group. The body’s core tempera- winter when days are shorter. And quently performed better on neu- body controlled by the master cir-
ture drops during sleep, and move- they experience more fatigue and
‘It’s probably the ADHD ropsychology tests. They com- cadian clock in our brains. Cortisol
ment slows. weight gain. pathology that leads to a pleted more of their tasks levels generally peak on awaken-
Her patients will try going to Researchers are now studying accurately and more quickly. ing. Dr. Coogan found it peaks
sleep early to compensate for lack whether ADHD patients with a
sleep problem,’ Other groups have replicated about 30 to 40 minutes later in
of sleep, then return to their usual delayed sleep phase can be one researcher says. the findings. More researchers are adults with ADHD, suggesting a
rhythm of going to bed late, which treated with light therapy, which showing interest in using light for delay in the internal body clocks
results in a disrupted rhythm. “My is often used to treat SAD. In ADHD treatment, he says. of those patients.
hypothesis is that because ADHD such treatments, patients are ex- Dr. Levitan wouldn’t go so far as Dr. Coogan says that genes
and circadian sleep delay overlap posed to bright light for 30 min- He subsequently sampled a to say that ADHD is a sleep disor- aside, adults with ADHD may also
in around 80% of patients, they utes in the morning when they group of adults with ADHD and der. But he does believe there’s a be affected by medications they
might both be an expression of a wake up to reset their body’s in- found a very high number re- consistent pattern in a large num- are taking, which can impact sleep.
circadian-rhythm disorder,” she ternal clock. ported having SAD. “ADHD is ber of ADHD patients related to The interplay between ADHD
says. “Even if it’s not curing ADHD thought to be a disorder of under- sleep. and sleep in children is trickier,
ADHD patients have low levels but only diminishing its severity, it stimulation of the brain, so you “It’s probably the ADHD pathol- because their sleep patterns and
of dopamine, a neurotransmitter in will be very, very helpful,” Dr. treat it with stimulant medica- ogy that leads to a sleep problem,” circadian rhythms change as they
the brain whose levels start in- Kooij says. tion,” he says. “Similarly, we use he says. grow. “In adults, sleep is a little
creasing in the morning. Many Robert Levitan, a professor of light therapy to stimulate the Andrew Coogan, a behavioral bit more set,” Dr. Coogan says.
November
Books of
the Month Royal Legacy
flora Danica Service
Read ambitiously this November. From
Breathtaking detail. Royal heritage. Exceptional craftsmanship.
Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella’s personal
This complete 143-piece Flora Danica porcelain service for 12 is an
story of corporate reinvention to a mystery
extraordinary rarity, with each piece meticulously hand painted to
exploring faith and science—choose amongst depict a different Danish flower. First commissioned in 1790 by
10 new titles, including our favorites from King Christian VII of Denmark, Flora Danica has been synonymous
HarperCollins’ 200th anniversary collection. with royal prestige for over 200 years, and is regarded as one of
As always, enjoy 35% off plus free shipping. the most stunning porcelain patterns ever created. Complete
sets for 12 such as this are exceptionally rare. #30-7021
E XCLUSIVE TO WSJ MEMB ER S
REDEEM NOW AT WSJPLUS.COM/NOV17-BOTM
© 2017 Dow Jones & Co., Inc. All rights reserved. 3DJ6054
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
A14 | Tuesday, November 7, 2017 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
SPORTS
COLLEGE FOOTBALL
the result isn’t just stunning. It’s Patriots 2006-2007 +12.7 rated, most influential coaches of
unprecedented. The Rams are 6-2 Redskins 1982-1983 +12.7 the modern game—was Fraudiola.
and averaging 32.9 points per Vikings 1997-1998 +12.7 Guardiola finishing the year in
game. That’s not only the most in third place, without a trophy for
Falcons 2015-2016 +12.6
the NFL this year. It’s the biggest the first time in his career despite
single-season offensive leap in the Source: Stats LLC; WSJ spending more than $200 million,
Super Bowl era. was all the proof his detractors
But not even the Rams’ 18.9 needed. That is, until club soccer’s
points-per-game increase from last scratching are the cruxes of this most basic rule kicked in: brilliant
year captures how bewildering this evolution. Watkins is starting to manager plus unlimited funds for
is. Some context: Their 14.0 points look like the big-play threat the players plus just a little time al-
per game last year weren’t just the Rams have lacked for years, high- most always equals a contender.
fewest in the NFL, it left them light lighted by his 67-yard touchdown Which brings us to Guardiola’s
years behind the Browns, who had catch in Sunday’s 51-17 win against second season in England. Six Manchester City’s Sergio Aguero, center, and Leroy Sané, right, celebrate.
the league’s second worst offense the Giants. months and another $260 million
at 16.5 points per game. No team Andrew Whitworth, the 35-year- worth of players later, it’s barely Sergio Aguero if it means freeing Wembley Stadium. And Liverpool
had scored worse since 2012. old offensive tackle who they November and Manchester City up Raheem Sterling or Leroy suddenly discovered it had the
Now all the team’s questions signed this offseason, has shored seems a lock for a championship. Sané? Can you even cut off the leakiest defense in the top eight.
from a year ago are its biggest up one of the league’s worst offen- Between Sunday’s 3-1 win over supply to them when the team is United, meanwhile, matched
strengths. The Rams have gone sive lines to give Goff and Gurley Arsenal and second-place Man- quarterbacked by two of the best City’s pace through September be-
from having disastrous coaching the time and space they need. The chester United’s 1-0 defeat at Chel- passers in Europe in Kevin de fore its momentum ground to a
situation to one of the best, with Rams gave up 49 sacks last year, sea, City has an eight-point lead Bruyne and David Silva? halt when Mourinho deployed a
31-year-old Sean McVay a second most in the NFL, and this atop the standings. The gap be- No one has figured it out yet, particularly defensive approach for
favorite for Coach of the year they have allowed only 10— tween City and United is now the leaving City as the only team in a 0-0 draw at Liverpool in mid-Oc-
Year. the second fewest. same as the gap between United the league to average more than 10 tober. His side has since lost twice
Jared Goff (pictured), There’s really only one and Huddersfield Town in 10th. shots per game from inside the in three league matches.
the quarterback who Los team that can understand “We are worried,” Manchester penalty area. Opponents are forced The over-heated comparisons to
Angeles had mortgaged such a wild turn- United manager Jose Mourinho to play on the counter, because the historic Premier League teams of
its future to get but around. In 1999, the said on Sunday, but “there are 18 club also averages 65.4% posses- the past have already begun. City
looked like a flop, “Greatest Show teams more worried than us, be- sion, the highest in Europe. is comfortably on pace to beat the
has emerged as a on Turf” involved cause we are second.” In other words, Guardiola-ball, record points total of 95, posted
star. Todd Gurley, an offense Premier League front-runners the possession-based soccer he de- by Mourinho’s Chelsea in 2005.
the running back that, at the have thrown away larger leads veloped at Barcelona and refined Unless someone figures out how to
who broke out time, had later in the season. But the 2017 at Bayern Munich, is alive and well defuse its attacking weapons, City
as a rookie the big- version of Manchester City is al- and ruining the season for every- could also take aim at Arsenal’s
in 2015 gest of- ready in a class of its own. The one else in the Premier League. 2003-04 undefeated season. And if
and fell fensive club’s 31 points from 11 games, “The way they have started, the its form carries over into other
apart a leap (15.1 earned with 10 victories and a way they are on a run, the quality competitions, could it even match
year ago, ppg increase draw, are the most anyone has they have, they will be difficult to Manchester United’s 1999 “treble”
is back on over 1998) in posted at this stage of a season stop,” Arsenal manager Arsene by winning the league, FA Cup and
track as league history. since the Premier League began in Wenger said on Sunday. Champions League?
JULIO CORTEZ/ASSOCIATED PRESS
one of the That team was the 1992. Guardiola’s side has been so Especially when, one by one, the “We are still only in November
league’s most dan- St. Louis Rams. And overwhelming—averaging 3.5 goals other title contenders found ways and it is too early to talk of winning
gerous weapons. the season ended with per game and conceding just 0.6. to spot City points early on. the league, never mind anything
And the the team’s first—and For teams trying to stop City, Defending champion Chelsea else,” Guardiola said last week. “It
moves that once only—Super Bowl win. there seems to be no right answer had already lost three games by would be a big mistake.”
looked head —Andrew Beaton when three of the Premier mid-October. Tottenham dropped But as City runs away with the
League’s top 10 scorers are in the seven points in its first three league, the club’s attempt at a tre-
lineup. Do you beef up coverage on games at its temporary home of ble may be the only intrigue left.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Tuesday, November 7, 2017 | A15
OPINION
How Dare the GOP Pray for Texas? BOOKSHELF | By Douglas Smith
Imagine you
are a sane
Democrat who
prayers did anything, they’d
still be alive, you worthless
sack of [expletive].”
their distaste toward symbols
and beliefs important to ordi-
nary Americans. Until Sunday
an absolute faith that seems
immune to reason or evidence
to the contrary—a secular
The Man
recognizes
that a big rea-
son Hillary
Clinton lost to
Sen. Elizabeth Warren
chose less inflammatory word-
ing for her own tweet.
“Thoughts & prayers are not
this columnist thought it im-
possible to match the obtuse-
ness of millionaire athletes
showing disrespect for the na-
faith even the most fervent
Christian might envy. Or that
in their disdain for prayer they
ironically appear to have more
At the Vanguard
MAIN
STREET Donald Trump
in November
enough, GOP,” wrote the Mas-
sachusetts Democrat. “We
tional anthem and the fans who
pay their salaries. But give
in common with the shooter
than his victims.
Lenin
By William
was that she must end this violence. We credit where it’s due: the Surely it is possible to make By Victor Sebestyen
McGurn
alienated must stop these tragedies. thoughts-and-prayers police the case for gun control with- (Pantheon, 569 pages, $35)
H
many mem- People are dying while you make the NFL protesters look out mocking prayer. But as
bers of the white working wait.” In short, if you are a Re- like Gandhis. with Mrs. Clinton and her infa- istorians used to debate whether Stalin had been Lenin’s
class. In the year since, you publican praying instead of mous remarks about Trump rightful heir or an evil usurper. Following the collapse of
have been working on your fel- passing gun control, you’ve got voters—not only deplorable the Soviet Union and the opening of archives in Russia
low Democrats to change their blood on your hands. It is now deplorable but irredeemable—those de- during the 1990s, the debates stopped. Once the true Lenin had
message in hopes of wooing The Huffington Post de- to offer ‘thoughts nouncing Messrs. Trump and been exposed, no one in good conscience could deny the
these voters back into the fold. voted an entire piece to the Ryan’s offer of prayers don’t similarities between the two dictators. Dmitri Volkogonov’s
Then a gunman opens fire at a phenomenon, under the head- and prayers’ for really want an argument. They “Lenin: A New Biography” (1994), the first work based on
Baptist church in Texas, and line “People Fed Up With the First Baptist want to express their feelings access to evidence in once-closed archives, exploded like a
suddenly progressives are in ‘Thoughts and Prayers’ De- of moral superiority. bomb, with its horrifying quotations of Lenin’s calls to hang,
full deplorable mode, attacking mand Action After Texas church families. Never mind, too, that Ba- shoot and destroy anyone who stood in the Bolsheviks’ way.
anyone who dares offer . . . Church Massacre.” It featured rack Obama offered his Two years later a collection of hitherto-secret documents under
prayers. tweets from celebrities and “thoughts and prayers” as of- the title “The Unknown Lenin,” edited by the eminent historian
This is the extraordinary gun-control advocates who be- Second, those doing the ten as any president, such as Richard Pipes, appeared and confirmed Volkogonov’s dark por-
turn of events since Devin Pat- lieve they had discovered taunting apparently have no after a 2013 shooting in trait. And Robert Service, arguably the world’s greatest author-
rick Kelley turned his rifle on something big: Prayers aren’t idea how childish their under- Washington when he said, ity on Lenin, came to a similar conclusion in his meticulously
the innocent churchgoers in- always answered. standing of prayer is. As the “We send our thoughts and researched studies of the man published around the same time.
side First Baptist Church in Here’s how these new theo- families that come each week prayers to all at the Navy Yard Lenin, we now know for certain, spawned Stalin.
Sutherland Springs, Texas. logians put it. Keith Olber- to the First Baptist Church ap- who’ve been touched by this Now, to coincide with the occasion of the centenary of
What provoked the left, if it mann: “ ‘Thoughts and prayers’ preciate, prayer is not a magic tragedy.” No one complained the Bolshevik coup,
can really be called a provoca- again, @realDonaldTrump, id- talisman against suffering. In a then, either because they comes an accessible, fair
tion, was President Trump’s iot? These people were in faith that commands its adher- were comfortable that Mr. and marvelously written
statement from Japan Sunday, CHURCH. They WERE praying.” ents to pick up their crosses, Obama didn’t really believe in biography that reinforces
in which he said that “our Actress Marina Sirtis: “To all prayer is a way to praise the prayer or his faith in gun con- what we have learned in
thoughts and prayers are with those asking for thoughts and Almighty and, when necessary, trol was absolute. the past three decades. Vic-
the victims and families of to- prayers for the victims in ask for courage and resolve to Over the next few weeks, tor Sebestyen, a Hungarian-
day’s horrible and murderous #churchshooting, it seems that do the right thing. the surviving members of the born journalist and histo-
attack.” House Speaker Paul your direct line to God is not Finally, isn’t it curious how First Baptist Church in Suther- rian, signals his view of his
Ryan likewise set off the furies working.” Or MSNBC’s Joy the same folks who blasted Mr. land Springs will wrap their subject in the book’s punchy
by tweeting, “The people of Reid: “Remember when Jesus Trump for politicizing the re- fallen in love and lay them to subtitle: “The Man, the Dicta-
Sutherland Springs need our of Nazareth came upon thou- cent attack in Manhattan by an rest. What these survivors may tor, and the Master of Ter-
prayers right now.” sands of hungry people, and Islamic terrorist are now de- individually believe about gun ror.” For anyone interested in
The responses have to be rather than feeding them, nouncing prayer because of a control is anyone’s guess. But an introduction to the world’s
read to be believed. Here’s one thought and prayed?” political preference? it’s hard to believe that the greatest revolutionary that
of the more charming: “The The smugness is illuminat- They believe the answer is way to their hearts is by mock- draws on the latest research, Mr.
murdered victims were in a ing in three important ways. federal gun control, and this is ing offers of prayer, even from Sebestyen’s “Lenin” would be the place
church,” tweeted actor Wil First and most obvious, pro- their right. But it’s hard not to Republicans. to start.
Wheaton to Mr. Ryan. “If gressives simply cannot contain notice they believe this with Write to mcgurn@wsj.com. The man who dedicated his life to destroying the czarist
regime was one of its favored sons. Like other Russian
radicals before him—the Decembrists, Mikhail Bakunin,
Trump, ISIS and the Crisis of Meaning Prince Pyotr Kropotkin—Vladimir Ulyanov was born into
gentile luxury. He grew up in a manor house in the
provinces, his days spent playing out of doors, fishing, hunt-
By Eliora Katz London and Paris, to live, and genuine choice than ambition they are not America.” The ing, flying kites. He liked to have fun but was a serious child
T
perhaps die, for a cause. or consumerism. other half “are people who and showed an early love of reading.
hree years and many be- The Obama administration Mr. Trump should know this. feel that the government has This idyll came to an end when Vladimir’s brother Alex-
headings after Abu Bakr argued that young people join His campaign was a kind of call let them down, the economy ander was hanged in 1887 for his participation in a plot on
al-Baghdadi declared a ISIS because of poor economic for meaning. Whatever the has let them down, nobody the life of Czar Alexander III. Vladimir, then 17, had wor-
caliphate, Americans are re- prospects. “We can work with merits of Mr. Trump’s positions, cares about them, nobody shiped Alexander, but worse than the loss of his brother
joicing in its demise. “With the countries around the world to he framed his views on trade, worries about what happens was the reaction of polite society. Henceforth, it shunned
liberation of ISIS’s capital and help improve their gover- immigration and foreign policy to their lives and their fu- the Ulyanov family, as friends turned their backs and
the vast majority of its terri- nance,” State Department in terms of America’s national tures, and they’re just desper- stopped visiting. “The bourgeois . . . they will always be
tory,” President Trump said in spokeswoman Marie Harf said identity: “Make America Great ate for change.” The implica- traitors and cowards,” he would write later. Under his nom
a statement, “the end of the in 2015. “We can help them Again.” Hillary Clinton empha- tion is that the only du guerre Lenin, it was a maxim he would repeat through-
ISIS caliphate is in sight.” sized technical solutions. Can legitimate basis of political out his life.
But does the fall of Raqqa anyone remember her slogans, disagreement is over the This double tragedy of his childhood, according to Mr.
really mean the fall of Islamic When politics limits her rallying cries? There was means of attaining prosperity Sebestyen, politicized Lenin and turned him onto the path
State? One needs merely a “breaking down barriers” and and material security. The of revolutionary struggle. “He was driven by emotion as
sharp object—or as we saw itself to the material, “fighting for us” and “I’m with Trump movement perceived much as by ideology,” the author writes. “His thirst for
last week, a rented truck—and people seek spiritual her.” None stuck. She ended on that political differences run revenge after his elder brother was executed . . . motivated
a nearby group of “infidels” to “stronger together.” Together deeper—that they are civiliza- Lenin as powerfully as did his belief in Marx’s theory of sur-
be an ISIS soldier. purpose elsewhere. with what or whom? tional and cultural. plus value.” Indeed, there’s little about Lenin’s writings or
After the Oct. 31 New York It’s not a new problem. In The search for meaning can his theories in Mr. Sebestyen’s book. This is very much an
attack, Mr. Trump tweeted: Germany’s Weimar era, the ju- lead in monstrous directions— intimate portrait, squarely focused on Lenin the man.
“We must not allow ISIS to re- build their economies so they rist Carl Schmitt argued that as it does for ISIS recruits, and
turn, or enter, our country af- can have job opportunities for political liberalism, in deriving as it did for Carl Schmitt, who
ter defeating them in the Mid- these people.” That’s myopic. supreme political value from would become known as “the In his quest to overthrow the czar, Lenin was
dle East and elsewhere. Physicians, computer scientists individual liberty, gave rise to crown jurist of the Third motivated both by Marxist theory and by
Enough!” But ISIS’ most im- and star high-school students a paradox he called “depolitici- Reich.” That danger is all the
portant battlefield is not in the have been radicalized, too. zation.” For Schmitt, politics more reason to regard the revenge for the execution of his older brother.
Levant; it is online, in hearts People are motivated by mean- boiled down to disputes over matter seriously.
and minds. ISIS’ power comes ing more than money. fundamental principles. A state The Trump presidency, the
from ideas, not territory. While Western states do that enshrines individual free- European Union’s crisis and If, after the death of his brother, Lenin became withdrawn
The threat is from within as (or used to) provide good so- dom must allow citizens to the threat of ISIS all, in very and intensely focused, he was never the cool and self-
well as without. Sayfullo cial services, economic oppor- pursue their private ideas of different ways, point to a controlled figure of later mythology. Lenin was so maniacally
Saipov, the Uber driver who al- tunity and consumer goods, the good, as the state itself is yearning for a political ap- obsessed with the question of revolution that, at several
legedly murdered eight in ISIS’ they are increasingly indiffer- barred from laying claim on proach to life’s fundamental points in his life, he teetered on the verge of a nervous break-
name, had been living an unre- ent to questions of meaning— transcendent values. Liberal- questions rather than a merely down. The person who kept him whole and stood watch over
markable life in the U.S. for to principles worth living, and ism thereby shrinks politics to technocratic one. By all means, his volatile temperament was Nadya Krupskaya, Lenin’s
seven years. Thousands of perhaps dying, for. In the U.S. a series of technical arguments celebrate setbacks to the ca- dutiful wife of 25 years. They shared a commitment to radical
young Muslims have left Eu- we are proud of our free- over the most efficient means liphate. But recognize that in politics, and Lenin proposed to Nadya in a letter penned in in-
rope and the U.S. for Syria and dom—but freedom to do and for achieving material ends. the absence of good answers visible ink—Mr. Sebestyen calls this “the ultimate romantic
Iraq to answer Mr. Baghdadi’s care for what? For a small but For an example of depoliti- about what we’re fighting for gesture” for young revolutionaries.
call. Seduced via social media, not negligible number of cization, consider Mrs. Clin- at home, some people will be Much of their life together was spent in exile in western
young men and women, some young people, answering a ton’s “basket of deplorables” attracted to very bad ones. Europe, theorizing and arguing with other revolutionaries.
of them converts, are also tak- call to build a caliphate, alleg- remarks. Half of Mr. Trump’s When the pressure became too great, Nadya would take
ing up arms in the West, or edly based on the dictums of a supporters, she said, “are ir- Ms. Katz is a Robert L. Bar- Lenin hiking up in the Swiss alps or bicycling in the woods
leaving their homes in Chicago, holy book, will seem a more redeemable, but thankfully tley Fellow at the Journal. outside Paris. Lenin became a fanatic cyclist and was
forever cleaning his bike and checking to see that the chain
was well-oiled. (Mr. Sebestyen’s book is full of little gems
Please Pass the SALT like this.) But the intellectual battles of the exiles were
ruthless, thanks largely to Lenin’s win-at-all-costs attitude.
Though he could be kind and courteous when he wanted,
By Claudia Tenney Politicians in Albany have inter- Cortland County comes in at Mr. Cuomo’s economic-devel- Lenin had to win every argument, regardless of how insig-
T
nalized the state motto, “ever No. 6 and Oswego County at opment and job-creation pro- nificant the point of contention. Yuli Martov, leader of the
ax reform is the key to upward,” and applied it to No. 15. But these areas are far grams to the tune of nearly $8 Mensheviks, once remarked he hoped there was no afterlife:
unlocking the American taxes, with little regard to what from wealthy. To the contrary, billion. Although New York “Do you think it would be fun to continue arguing with
dream for millions of families and small businesses average family incomes are well spends more than any other Lenin even after death and in the hereafter listening to his
people. The Tax Cuts and Jobs can afford. New York’s many below the national average. My state on these programs, we gutter abuse?”
Act, released last week, would constituents are struggling to have little to show in return Lenin’s belligerent style that aimed to destroy his
raise the standard deduction pay for Albany’s litany of costly except record out-migration opponent as much as his ideas would leave its mark on
for families from $12,700 to The deduction is rules and regulations. of jobs and people. Much of the Bolshevik party. From the moment of the Bolshevik
$24,000, increase the Child New Yorkers’ only The ability to deduct state this spending is corporate coup in October 1917, he showed not the least hesitation in
Tax Credit from $1,000 to and local taxes on their federal welfare designed to curry fa- crushing any threat to his party’s hold on power. A
$1,600, and cut the tax rate on relief from Albany. return matters because these vor with Mr. Cuomo’s donor stifling censorship of the press was introduced, political
workers with low and middle New Yorkers cannot count on class at the expense of the parties were outlawed, opponents were jailed, and terror
incomes. Albany to protect them. While taxpayers. was unleashed on society in the form of the Cheka, the
Each of these provisions is taxes—income, property, sales families are falling behind or The bad habits in Albany brutal political police. Mr. Sebestyen correctly notes, how-
aimed squarely at providing and excise—are among the leaving the state, spendthrift won’t change. That’s why it’s ever, that although these tactics were taken to a height-
necessary and overdue relief. highest in the nation, and New liberals in the capital continue vital to retain the SALT deduc- ened level of savagery by the revolutionaries, none of
Today’s tax code is not only out- York is often ranked the least to waste money on boondog- tion, which for now will remain them were new. In fact, they had all been learned from the
dated and onerous, it favors the tax- friendly state. gles like the Buffalo Billion, the taxpayers’ only source of czarist regime, the “violent, tyrannical and corrupt Rus-
wealthy and well connected. Albany has also increased Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s costly significant relief. sia” that had produced Lenin. His being a Russian was as
But I worry about the way the weight of local taxes by effort to revitalize Western Congress has a historic op- important as being a Marxist.
this bill erodes the deduction imposing one unfunded man- New York’s economy, which portunity to pass a compre- As Chairman of the Council of People’s Commissars
for state and local taxes, which date after another on local has so far led to nine federal hensive tax reform that would (effectively the prime minister) Lenin subjected himself to a
has been in place since 1913. governments. Nowhere is this corruption charges; Start-Up truly level the playing field for punishing schedule, often working 17-hour days in his Krem-
Although the Tax Cuts and more apparent than in the NY, the governor’s signature American families and small lin office. He suffered his first stroke in May 1922; more fol-
Jobs Act would let Americans property taxes my constitu- job-creation program, which businesses. Then the onus will lowed. Lenin died in January 1924 at the age of 53. His
continue deducting up to ents pay. A 2013 study from has produced a tiny fraction of be on Democrats in Albany to corpse still lies encased in glass for all to see on Red
$10,000 of property taxes, it the Brookings Tax Policy Cen- the jobs it promised despite a get on board, put taxpayers Square, although his star no longer shines as it once did.
would eliminate the deduction ter ranked more than 3,000 $53 million advertising budget; first, and make New York com- According to the latest poll, Russians now consider Lenin
for state income taxes. counties by their ratio of and “film tax credit” give- petitive again. only the fourth most outstanding man of all time, behind
This would compound the al- property tax to home value. aways to Hollywood elites Stalin, Pushkin and Vladimir Putin.
ready excruciating financial All eight of the counties I rep- worth hundreds of millions of Ms. Tenney, a Republican, is
burden that my state’s lawmak- resent in upstate New York dollars. a U.S. representative from New Mr. Smith, the author of “Former People” and “Rasputin,”
ers have placed on New Yorkers. are in the top 36 nationwide. Each year, taxpayers fund York. is writing a book on the Soviet famine of 1921-23.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
A16 | Tuesday, November 7, 2017 * *** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
OPINION
REVIEW & OUTLOOK LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
The Sorry State of New Jersey The Government and Free Speech on Campus
G
ov. Chris Christie’s election in New Jer- raised the retirement age for new employees to Frederick M. Hess and Grant Addi- In practice, the authors’ suggestion
sey in 2009 augured a bumper crop of 65 years. But the reforms didn’t do enough to son contend that colleges and univer- would have unintended consequences
sities should be subject to federal including more regulation, more bu-
GOP reformers, and now progressives are curb the rich benefits for current workers.
funding risk if they fail to enforce reaucracy (on the part of both the
hoping that a victory by Demo- Mr. Christie has also con- free-speech standards (“Colleges government and the university) and
crat Phil Murphy in the state’s After Christie, Trenton tinued his predecessors’ habit Should Protect Speech—or Lose harmful impacts on many innocent in-
gubernatorial election on Tues- is headed toward more of skimping on pensions. The Funds.” op-ed, Oct. 31). That risk al- dividuals who have in no way im-
day will presage an upswell of state has lost billions in com- ready exists. It is precisely federal peded free speech.
Sandernistas. One lesson from tax-and-spend decline. pound interest on the more legislation—Title VI of the Civil There are other ways to address
Mr. Christie’s tenure is that than $20 billion in missed Rights Act—that has university ad- the problem. One is being tried in
voters will turn left if Republi- payments, and the state’s pen- ministrations tripping over them- North Carolina, where the legislature
cans fail to deliver on growth and reform. sion shortfall has ballooned to $136 billion from selves to avoid a violation with po- has passed a law requiring its public
Mr. Christie defeated Democrat Jon Corzine $54 billion in 2010. Democrats and Mr. Christie tentially deep legal, financial and universities to protect speech, includ-
in 2009 by promising to drain the swamp in this year decided to raid the state lottery to pay reputational ramifications. ing protests, and to discipline stu-
The concept of discrimination, dents or others who prevent other
Trenton, challenge public union rule and revive for pensions, but this isn’t sustainable.
which Title VI addresses, has been so people’s free speech. Experiments in
the state’s economy. But after some modest Better solutions are within reach. In 2015 a ideologically empowered that broad the states like this law will lead to
early successes, the Governor gave up to run for bipartisan commission convened by the Gover- speech acts, or merely protests, rallies more effective and fairer efforts to
President and now the state is heading back to nor recommended scaling back public workers or other forms of assembly, can be in- foster freedom.
the policies that brought it low. platinum health benefits to levels offered by terpreted as per se hostile, and JANE S. SHAW
New Jersey (like Connecticut) was once a tax private employers, which could save $3.7 bil- thereby construed as discrimination. Raleigh, N.C.
haven for New Yorkers, but in 1968 the state al- lion. Replacing defined-benefit plans for cur- Moreover, it isn’t just running afoul
lowed collective bargaining by public unions. rent workers with a defined-contribution hy- of federal rules and financial largess Forget about focusing on campus
Eight years later the state adopted an income brid could yield an additional $1.5 billion. that frightens college administrators, administrators and faculty members.
tax with a 2.5% top rate to boost spending on Yet after winning re-election in 2013 in a but the potential interruption of cor- Instead, focus on students. A large
education and reduce property taxes. Thus be- 22-point landslide, Mr. Christie invested little porate donations that may arise in the proportion of college students receive
face of campus unrest and conten- federal assistance. Most aren’t left-
gan the state’s road to fiscal perdition. political capital into persuading the legislature tions. That tells us the nature of the wing fascists, and they want to keep
Politicians captive to public unions have re- and public to support more reforms. He in- current speech issue on America’s their federal aid. They are the most
peatedly raised income taxes to sweeten worker stead hit the road to run for President. The campuses isn’t so much about the effective lobbyists for free speech on
salaries and benefits. The state’s 8.97% top rate Governor’s public support also sank after his Constitution or First Amendment, as it campus.
on households earning more than $500,000 is aides shut down the George Washington is about tort law and liability. And it’s The Education Department should
the highest in the Northeast after New York Bridge to spite a Democratic mayor who re- also about university economics, or issue a regulation that all federal fi-
City. Revenues have been steered to low-income fused to endorse him. A court-approved gerry- what the University of Chicago calls nancial student assistance can only
school districts but have produced little im- mander in 2011 locked in Democratic majori- “its vital interests.” Those include the be available to students attending
provement in student learning. Asbury Park re- ties in the legislature. economic well-being of the institute “safe” institutions of higher learning.
ceives $28,884 in state per-pupil aid. The Governor has vetoed tax increases and and its employees, many enjoying un- Then define safe as one in which
precedented pay and benefits. Colleges there are no speech codes or free-
School districts have also piled on property protected Garden Staters from Democrats’
should get out of the way, and out of speech zones, etc. This regulation
taxes, which are the highest in the country. Be- worst impulses, but he has alienated would-be the speech business. Then student ed- would exempt the military academies
tween 1980 and 2007, property taxes increased supporters and his 18% approval rating is half ucation will really begin. and religious institutions.
by more than 100% on a per capita basis while of President Trump’s in the state. Democrats in MATT ANDERSSON JOEL MARGOLIS
school spending per pupil grew by nearly 140%. Trenton concluded they were better off oppos- Oak Brook, Ill. Albany, N.Y.
The average property tax bill on a median ing Mr. Christie while unions figured they could
$427,000 home in Essex County is $11,597— wait him out.
about twice as much as in Bucks County, Penn-
sylvania.
Voter frustration with higher taxes, deterio-
rating public services (e.g., New Jersey Transit)
On Getting Children’s First Three Years Right
All of this has hurt the economy, which has and slow growth has fueled Mr. Murphy’s popu- Thank you for publishing letters what babies need from mothers for
depressed tax revenues. Since 2010 the state’s list campaign. The former Goldman Sachs exec- (Nov. 2) that thoughtfully engage in emotional stability.
the discussion of what is best for our I must also call into question her
GDP has grown at an annual 0.9%, less than half utive has endorsed a millionaire surtax, single-
children. Open dialogue, especially claim that the NICHD study “laid to
as fast as the U.S. A net $8.5 billion in adjusted payer health care and a $15 minimum wage, all that which references research, must rest” the idea that day care is univer-
gross income left the state between 2012 and of which would accelerate the exodus of people be encouraged. Too often this conver- sally harmful. That research suggests
2015, according to the IRS. and employers. sation takes place not in an open fo- that children who have spent in-
During his first year, Mr. Christie midwifed The state would need to impose a tax of rum but behind each other’s backs, to creased time in day care “show some-
a 2% annual cap on property tax increases with nearly 20% on millionaires to pay for pensions. the detriment of our children and so- what more behavior problems.” Mod-
exceptions for debt service, emergencies and The GOP nominee is Lieutenant Governor Kim ciety. ern research on early day care is also
pension and health benefits. The cap has kept Guadagno, who has pitched sound ideas to re- I must disagree with Angeline S. problematic. See Allan Schore’s 2017
annual property tax increases to less than 2.1% duce property taxes and fix pensions. But she Lillard’s reference to Ruth Feldman’s article “All our sons: . . . The Neuro-
on average. In 2011 the Governor struck a deal trails Mr. Murphy by double digits in the polls research that fathers and mothers are pendocrinology of Boys at Risk” in the
interchangeable to children. Ms. Feld- Infant Mental Health Journal. Incon-
with Democratic Senate president Steve as she struggles against the anti-Christie un-
man’s findings suggest that oxytocin sistency in caregivers, improper ratios
Sweeney on pension reform that eliminated re- dertow. Sorry to say, New Jersey’s tax-and- has different effects on each parent’s of children to adults and overstimula-
tirees’ automatic cost-of-living adjustments and spend decline seems likely to accelerate. interactions with their offspring. tion are issues that make it impossi-
Mother’s oxytocin is associated with ble for me to recommend it as an al-
nurturing and affection, while father’s ternative to maternal care.
A Plumber With a Rifle oxytocin levels associate with tactile, We are all ultimately on the same
T
roughhousing-like behavior. Fathers team as women and as mothers.
he world is trying to figure out what evil, who was discharged from the Air Force for bad will always be important, but they ERICA KOMISAR, LCSW
or madness, caused Devin Kelley to kill conduct, should not have been able to obtain a provide something different from New York
26 people and wound 20 more at the gun legally, but the Journal reports that the mil-
First Baptist Church in Suther- itary failed to send his convic-
land Springs, Texas, on Sunday A neighbor saves lives in tion record to the FBI. The
morning. But forgive us if we Texas with a legal gun harsh reality of mass murders Think of the Public Before the Broadcasters
focus on Stephen Willeford, is that often only the presence As the son of a broadcast pioneer this?” Using that measure, it was of-
the local plumber who saved and some quick action. of someone with a legal who got his license from the Depart- ten difficult to fill the four news-
lives by grabbing his rifle and weapon to shoot back can stop ment of Commerce in 1923 and as a casts we did each day. News quality
firing at Kelley. the rampage. former broadcaster myself, I read went downhill fast when the 24/7
Freeman Martin, the Texas Department of We saw this in Virginia this year when Capitol with great sadness “FCC to Lift Lim- news formats began. The Kar-
Public Safety chief, said Mr. Willeford “grabbed Hill police saved the lives of many Members of its on Media Deals” (page one, Oct. dashians never would have made it
his rifle and engaged the suspect” as he left the Congress. Security officers in Garland, Texas, 26). Although FCC Chairman Ajit Pai into a legitimate news broadcast
church. Kelley dropped his Ruger AR-15 and fled, prevented mass casualties by killing two jihad- justifies his proposal by saying it back then.
and Mr. Willeford jumped in a truck driven by ists in 2015 trying to shoot up a contest featuring will lead to more news gathering lo- Second, allowing ownership of
cally and more news for consumers, multiple stations in a given market
another local resident, Johnnie Langendorff, cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad.
my experience tells me it will be the will drive the last nail in the coffin
and pursued the killer. After a 95-mile-per-hour No one wants crowds of vigilantes looking for opposite. of the local “multiplicity of voices”
chase, Kelley crashed his vehicle, where police someone to shoot, but we’re sure glad Stephen First, viewers and listeners don’t that broadcasting originally sought
found him dead a short time later. Police believe Willeford had a rifle and knew how to use it. need more news, they need better to bring to the public. There will be
Kelley killed himself. Like the passengers aboard Flight 93 on 9/11, or news. In my day the yardstick by but one voice, that of the corporate
The two locals are being hailed as heroes the Yanks who foiled a terror attack on a train which we decided what we covered owner of the stations.
since their quick action was the only deterrent in Belgium in 2015, he didn’t wait for orders to was “Does the public need to know Mr. Pai’s proposed changes are all
to more murders until police arrived. Kelley, protect his fellow human beings. about allowing the broadcasters to
get bigger and make more money,
Remembering the Golden and nothing about getting the public
Bad Marks for a Good Military Age of Open-Outcry Markets the fact-based, credible news we so
drastically need.
T
I empathize with David Tung TOM MORGAN
he military is one of the few institutions Fitzgerald and USS John S. McCain. The colli- Wai’s sadness for watching the de- Oviedo, Fla.
that Americans still hold in high esteem, sions—off the coast of Japan, and in the Singa- mise of the Hong Kong stock ex-
but that should never be taken for pore Strait, respectively—resulted in the deaths change trading floor (“At 87, a Sto-
granted. Two events late last of 17 sailors. gie-Toting Legend Mourns the End Watch That First Step Up
week suggest that even the The Bergdahl sentence The 71-page report, which of Trading Floors,” page one, Oct.
Regarding the Oct. 24 letters:
military’s culture of high per- and a Navy report says both collisions were 26). My first visits to the Chicago
Eliminating the step-up basis on
formance can be eroded with- “avoidable,” is damning about Mercantile Exchange began in 1956,
death would create huge bookkeep-
out constant attention. are dispiriting. the Navy’s training practices when I would go downtown to visit
ing problems for taxpayers who
The first was a military and makes for dispiriting read- my father and grandfather who
hold assets which have passed
traded for themselves, speculators
judge’s decision to let off U.S. ing if you are a civilian who through multiple generations with-
and their butter, egg and onion
Army Sergeant Bowe Bergdahl with a slap on thinks the U.S. Navy is the best in the world. The hedging clients. I started working
out being sold. Imagine winding up
the wrist for desertion in Afghanistan in 2009. report says watch team members on the Fitzger- with stock which has had an auto-
on the CME floor in 1967 and later
After a court martial, Army Colonel Jeffery ald “were not familiar with basic radar funda- matic dividend reinvestment fea-
on the Chicago Board of Trade floor,
Nance recommended that Bergdahl be dishon- mentals.” And it cites a failure to plan for safety, ture for decades.
first in high school and then as a
JAMES M. KLEBBA
orably discharged, demoted to private and for- adhere to sound navigation practices, properly college student. I couldn’t imagine
New Orleans
feit $10,000 in pay. Prosecutors had sought 14 use available navigation tools, and respond ef- doing anything else. Years later I
years in prison. fectively in a crisis. taught courses for the CME as men
Bergdahl was captured by the Taliban and As for the McCain, the Navy cited a loss of sit- and women flocked to Chicago to
held prisoner for nearly five years, a terrible or- uational awareness in response to mistakes in learn the art of open outcry. I recall Pepper ...
how crowded the visitors’ galleries
deal to be sure. But those most outraged by the operating the ship’s steering and propulsion sys-
were. The trading floors in the
And Salt
wrist slap are other members of the armed ser- tem. It also cited the failure to follow the Inter-
1970s and ’80s were major tourist THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
vices who fear the damage to military discipline. national Nautical Rules of the Road that govern attractions for the city of Chicago.
Bergdahl deserted on the battlefield in a forward maneuvering vessels amid high-density mari- But like the village blacksmith or
post—the worst betrayal you can make against time traffic. These are mistakes of basic seaman- the attendant who’d pump your gas
your fellow soldiers save for fragging them with ship that suggest inadequate training, or shifts and clean your windshield, technol-
friendly fire. that are too long and cause a loss of concentra- ogy changed the way stocks and de-
Members of Bergdahl’s unit were killed or tion and crew cohesion. rivatives will forever be traded.
maimed when they were sent to search for him, The Navy had already relieved the ship cap- LAWRENCE SCHNEIDER
not knowing that he had been preparing to walk tains and even the commander of the Pacific Lincolnshire, Ill.
away for weeks and had even dispatched per- Fleet. This accountability is a credit to the Navy
sonal effects to the U.S. before he walked off the and will be a lesson to other commanders. But Letters intended for publication should
forward base. The court-martial sentence must it should also be a warning that Congress needs be addressed to: The Editor, 1211 Avenue
of the Americas, New York, NY 10036,
be demoralizing to those who do their duty and to allocate enough money to adequately train or emailed to wsj.ltrs@wsj.com. Please
risk their lives without fanfare. sailors so they can fulfill their missions. Colli- include your city and state. All letters
Even more distressing is the Navy’s report on sions with civilian ships in peacetime are awful, are subject to editing, and unpublished
its investigation into the collisions with civilian but seamanship failures during wartime would letters can be neither acknowledged nor
returned.
vessels this year in the Pacific theater by the USS be disastrous. “Your fake news or mine?”
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Tuesday, November 7, 2017 | A17
OPINION
C
Riyadh, Saudi Arabia the past year taking control of inter- The international audience is as im- Saudi government revenues, and re- prince says.
hange is accelerating in nal security and defense. The mes- portant to Prince Mohammed as are straining production hasn’t led to All over Riyadh young Saudis are
Saudi Arabia. Over the sage is clear: Get behind reform or be the opinions of his own people. To ap- higher prices. The prince may well be buying and operating portable food
weekend King Salman bin silenced. peal to both, over the past 18 months right that social change will usher in trucks to earn cash, as government
Abdulaziz removed his pre- Already the Saudi public is tweet- he has overseen a remarkable liberal- his economic goals, but freeing soci- cuts generous subsidies. Saudi men
decessor’s powerful son as ing its support. Yet Western inves- ization of Saudi society. Citizens now ety is so far proving easier than re- are notorious for refusing to do me-
head of the national guard. The king tors, whose money and expertise the enjoy many long forbidden social free- tooling the stultified economy. nial work, but these entrepreneurial
detained 11 princes along with cur- kingdom needs, are unsure if this doms, including the public mixing of Saudi Arabia, with its austere brand young men hustle to serve customers
rent and former ministers on corrup- campaign is proof of modernization unrelated men and women. of fundamentalist Islam, has been a hamburgers, chicken wings, tacos,
tion charges. Behind the move is or autocratic business as usual. In global outlier for decades. It has been pasta or whatever the truck special-
Saudi Arabia’s young reformer, Saudi Arabia, the rule of law is the a segregated, repressive society that izes in. One young man told me last
Crown Prince Mohammed bin Sal- king. So long as he lives, he is all- The young crown prince has subjected women to men’s rule week that he learned business in
man. He is gambling that the moves powerful; once dead, his legacy and and micromanaged every aspect of cit- China while on university scholar-
will be seen at home and abroad as projects are at risk. Foreign investors is gambling that personal izens’ lives—down to the proper way ship. He works seven-hour days for
cleansing the kingdom of tarnished may think this system still entails too freedom will encourage to enter and exit a toilet and how Airbus—then sells from his food
old ways—not as the whim of an au- many risks. menstruating women must behave. All truck late into the night.
thoritarian ruler. Prince Mohammed, a millennial financial responsibility. this to align Muslims with the Islam of Some 40 of these trucks are con-
This crackdown is intended to popular with young Saudis, is not so the Prophet Muhammad. gregated on an empty lot in northern
frighten anyone with power—not much an idealistic social reformer as Prince Mohammed is rapidly re- Riyadh, forming a small outdoor vil-
only the prince’s royal and religious a pragmatist. He desperately wants The young prince clearly believes moving the traditional guardrails on lage where young Saudis relax with
opponents. In a monarchy infamous to diversify the economy. Standing in that social change is the essential Saudi society. Gone are the religious family or friends. Among the food
for widespread malfeasance, an anti- his way are decades of dependence prerequisite for economic moderniza- police who enforced gender segrega- trucks is one operated by a mother
corruption campaign means almost on oil and an exploding population of tion. While some of his reforms have tion. Women will be allowed to and daughter who are selling Arabic
every prince and current or former young people lacking education and been dramatic, the country is still a drive beginning next June. Already coffee to a line of male customers.
minister is vulnerable to being tar- the will to work. Western assistance long way from becoming a diversi- some dare to congregate in restau- The women chat casually with their
geted, detained, blocked from travel, will not come without a modern work fied, post-oil economy. The growth rants without a male guardian. Jog- clients. Only a year ago such forbid-
and stripped of his assets. Not even environment that includes female forecast for this year is zero. Foreign ging, hiking and bike riding in mixed den interaction between women and
aides and associates are safe. But it’s employees and after-work options investors are intrigued, but so far few company is becoming more popular. unrelated males most likely would
have landed them in jail.
Prince Mohammed is gambling
100 Years of Communism—and 100 Million Dead that once Saudis control their per-
sonal lives, they will take responsibil-
ity for their livelihoods, reducing de-
By David Satter Such convictions set the stage for While the Soviet Union redefined Today the Soviet Union and the pendence on government handouts.
A
decades of murder on an industrial human nature, it also spread intel- international communist system But food trucks and cinema do not a
rmed Bolsheviks seized the scale. In total, no fewer than 20 mil- lectual chaos. The term “political that once ruled a third of the modern economy make.
Winter Palace in Petrograd— lion Soviet citizens were put to correctness” has its origin in the as- world’s territory are things of the So far, the social liberalization has
now St. Petersburg—100 years death by the regime or died as a di- sumption that socialism, a system of past. But the need to keep higher wide support among young Saudis and
ago this week and arrested minis- rect result of its repressive policies. collective ownership, was virtuous moral values pre-eminent is as im- the acquiescence of the silent majority.
ters of Russia’s provisional govern- This does not include the millions in itself, without need to evaluate its portant now as it was in the early The Saudi religious establishment is
ment. They set in motion a chain of who died in the wars, epidemics and operations in light of transcendent 19th century when they first began largely silent while some other conser-
events that would kill millions and famines that were predictable con- moral criteria. to be seriously challenged. vative critics have been silenced by se-
inflict a near-fatal wound on West- sequences of Bolshevik policies, if When the Bolsheviks seized In 1909, the Russian religious phi- lective arrest. But if economic growth
ern civilization. not directly caused by them. power in Russia, Western intellectu- losopher Nikolai Berdyaev wrote remains stuck at zero, unhappy royals
The revolutionaries’ capture of The victims include 200,000 als, influenced by the same lack of that “our educated youth cannot ad- may not be Prince Mohammed’s great-
train stations, post offices and killed during the Red Terror an ethical point of reference that led mit the independent significance of est threat. A society liberated from its
telegraphs took place as the city (1918-22); 11 million dead from fam- to Bolshevism in the first place, scholarship, philosophy, enlighten- traditional moorings and disappointed
slept and resembled a changing of ine and dekulakization; 700,000 exe- closed their eyes to the atrocities. ment and universities. To this day, with its economic prospects may
the guard. But when residents of cuted during the Great Terror When the killing became too obvious they subordinate them to the inter- prove difficult to control.
the Russian capital awoke, they (1937-38); 400,000 more executed to deny, sympathizers excused what ests of politics, parties, movements Prince Mohammed acknowledged
found they were living in a differ- between 1929 and 1953; 1.6 million was happening because of the Sovi- and circles.” as much last month, when he labeled
ent universe. dead during forced population ets’ supposed noble intentions. If there is one lesson the commu- the young generation a “double-
transfers; and a minimum 2.7 mil- Many in the West were deeply in- nist century should have taught, it edged sword.” Young Saudis, he said,
lion dead in the Gulag, labor colo- different. They used Russia to settle is that the independent authority of can create a new Saudi Arabia “but if
The Bolshevik plague nies and special settlements. their own quarrels. Their reasoning, universal moral principles cannot be they go the other way, they will bring
To this list should be added as the historian Robert Conquest an afterthought, since it is the con- destruction.”
that began in Russia was nearly a million Gulag prisoners re- wrote, was simple: Capitalism was viction on which all of civilization
the greatest catastrophe leased during World War II into Red unjust; socialism would end this in- depends. Ms. House, a former publisher of
Army penal battalions, where they justice; so socialism had to be sup- The Wall Street Journal, is author of
in human history. faced almost certain death; the par- ported unconditionally, notwith- Mr. Satter is the author of “Age “On Saudi Arabia: Its People, Past,
tisans and civilians killed in the standing any amount of its own of Delirium: the Decline and Fall of Religion, Fault Lines—and Future”
postwar revolts against Soviet rule injustice. the Soviet Union” (Yale). (Knopf, 2012).
Although the Bolsheviks called in Ukraine and the Baltics; and dy-
for the abolition of private property, ing Gulag inmates freed so that
their real goal was spiritual: to their deaths would not count in offi-
translate Marxist-Leninist ideology cial statistics.
into reality. For the first time, a If we add to this list the deaths
state was created that was based ex- caused by communist regimes that
plicitly on atheism and claimed in- the Soviet Union created and sup-
fallibility. This was totally incompat- ported—including those in Eastern
ible with Western civilization, which Europe, China, Cuba, North Korea,
presumes the existence of a higher Vietnam and Cambodia—the total
power over and above society and number of victims is closer to 100
the state. million. That makes communism
The Bolshevik coup had two con- the greatest catastrophe in human
sequences. In countries where com- history.
munism came to hold sway, it hol- The effect of murder on this scale
lowed out society’s moral core, was to create a “new man” suppos-
degrading the individual and turning edly influenced by nothing but the
him into a cog in the machinery of good of the Soviet cause. The mean-
the state. Communists committed ing of this was demonstrated during
murder on such a scale as to all but the battle of Stalingrad, when Red
eliminate the value of life and to de- Army blocking units shot thousands
stroy the individual conscience in of their fellow soldiers who tried to
survivors. flee. Soviet forces also shot civilians
But the Bolsheviks’ influence was who sought shelter on the German
not limited to these countries. In the side, children who filled German wa-
West, communism inverted society’s ter bottles in the Volga, and civilians
understanding of the source of its forced at gunpoint to recover the
values, creating political confusion bodies of German soldiers. Gen. Vas-
that persists to this day. ily Chuikov, the army commander in
In a 1920 speech to the Komso- Stalingrad, justified these tactics in
mol, Lenin said that communists his memoirs by saying “a Soviet citi-
subordinate morality to the class zen cannot conceive of his life apart
struggle. Good was anything that from his Soviet country.”
destroyed “the old exploiting soci- That these sentiments were nei-
ety” and helped to build a “new ther accidental nor ephemeral was
communist society.” made clear in 2008, when the Rus-
This approach separated guilt sian Parliament, the Duma, for the
from responsibility. Martyn Latsis, first time adopted a resolution re-
an official of the Cheka, Lenin’s se- garding the 1932-33 famine that had
cret police, in a 1918 instruction to killed millions. The famine was
interrogators, wrote: “We are not caused by draconian grain requisi-
waging war against individuals. We tion undertaken to finance Soviet
are exterminating the bourgeoisie as industrialization. Although the
a class. . . . Do not look for evidence Duma acknowledged the tragedy, it
that the accused acted in word or added that “the industrial giants of
deed against Soviet power. The first the Soviet Union,” the Magnitogorsk
question should be to what class steel mill and the Dnieper dam,
does he belong. . . . It is this that would be “eternal monuments” to
should determine his fate.” the victims.
Cancer is smart…and relentless. At Dana-Farber, we are too. Each year, we conduct over 800 clinical trials
THink like
giving patients access to the latest advances. And, in partnership with Brigham and Women’s Hospital
cancer
and Boston Children’s Hospital, we’re mapping out the genetic weaknesses of 25,000+ tumors to create
to beat
precision treatments that destroy cancer. These are just a few reasons why U.S. News & World Report
cancer
has recognized us as a national leader in cancer for 17 years straight. It’s also why, here, cancer is quickly losing ground.
S&P 2591.13 À 0.13% S&P FIN g 0.13% S&P IT À 0.35% DJ TRANS g 0.24% WSJ $ IDX g 0.33% LIBOR 3M 1.397 NIKKEI (Midday) 22733.68 À 0.82% See more at WSJMarkets.com
700
Crude Prices Climb
winner for investors who purchased them
at auction after the crisis ended.
600
500
As Tensions Build
November 2012
Treasury sells Zions
warrants for $1.35 apiece.
Zions Bancorp performance
Warrants Common stock
400
300
In Middle East
200 BY ALISON SIDER lows hit in June as investors
have become more attuned to
100 Oil prices surged to more whether conflicts in the Mid-
than two-year highs after a dle East could disrupt oil
0 wave of arrests in Saudi Ara- flows as supplies have tight-
–100
bia and a missile attack on Ri- ened around the world.
yadh signaled escalating ten- “It is an extremely long list
2012 ’13 ’14 ’15 ’16 ’17
sions in the Middle East. reminding the market how
Crude for December deliv- fragile the oil market is,” said
Capital One performance SunTrust performance Gains since 2016 U.S. election
ery gained 3.1%, to $57.35 a Gary Ross, head of global oil
Warrants Common stock Warrants* Common stock Warrants Common stock barrel, on the New York Mer- analytics at S&P Global Platts.
400% 1,400% cantile Exchange on Monday, Investors are concerned
219% while Brent for January deliv- that the power struggles in
1,200 Bank of ery, the global benchmark, Saudi Arabia, the world’s top
300 America† 63%
1,000 rose 3.5% to $64.27 on ICE Fu- exporter of crude, bring a new
65% tures Europe. Both settlements source of uncertainty to the
800 Wells Fargo are the highest since June global oil market.
200 23% 2015.
600 Over the weekend, officials
400 J.P. Morgan
111% in Saudi Arabia detained more Breakthrough
100 than five dozen princes, min-
44% U.S. crude-oil prices rose Monday
200 isters and prominent busi- to a more than two-year high.
145% nessmen in a bid to tackle al-
0 0 PNC leged corruption. Analysts $70 a barrel
2009 ’10 ’11 ’12 ’13 ’14 ’15 ’16 ’17 2011 ’12 ’13 ’14 ’15 ’16 ’17 43% described the sweep as a
*Class B warrants †Class A warrants shake-up as Crown Prince Mo- 60
Source: FactSet THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. hammed bin Salman consoli-
dates power. 50
A
Advanced Micro Devices
............................. B4,B13
Bond Fund.................A2
G
General Electric ........ B12
Qualcomm............A1,B13
R
Rockwell Collins..........B3
SPRINT cause it would help Sprint in-
stall antennas more quickly.
The Altice partnership would
have happened regardless of a
Calling Plans
Sprint’s spending on its wireless
network, in billions
would have hurt the company
over the long term.”
Sprint said it plans to raise
money to fund its network in-
Airbus..........................B3 Continued from the prior page T-Mobile deal, he said. vestment. Because the carrier
Goldman Sachs Group S
Altice USA .................. B1 $5-6
...................................B12 Salesforce ................... B4 Shares in Sprint fell 12% on Meanwhile, Sprint parent has struggled to turn a profit,
Amazon..................A1,B4
Anthem ....................... B6
Google ......................... B4 Saudi Aramco............B13 Monday, while T-Mobile company SoftBank Group $5.4 traditional debt is expensive.
Apple ............ A10,B1,B13 I Saudi Electricity ....... B13 shares declined 5.7%. Corp., based in Japan, said it $4.7 In recent years, it has found
B Intel.............................B4 Shanghai Brilliance During a call with analysts would buy shares of Sprint in $3.5-4 creative ways to use its assets
International Credit Rating & on Monday, Sprint finance the open market and increase to finance cheaper loans.
Boeing ......................... B3 Investors Service....B12
Consolidated Airlines chief Tarek Robbiati acknowl- its stake from roughly 82% to Mr. Robbiati said the car-
Broadcom.............A1,B13 Silver Lake
Group.........................B3 edged investors’ disappoint- closer to 85%. If it exceeds rier would do that again and
C J Management ............ A5
SoftBank Group...B2,B13 ment with the scuttled talks. 85%, it would have to make an $2.0 raise money using its airwaves
Cardinal Health...........B6
Cathay Pacific Airways
Jana Partners ........... B13 Sprint...................B1,B13 “I will not venture in selling offer to buy out the remaining licenses as collateral.
J. Crew Group.............B7 Swire Pacific...............B3 this [Altice] transaction as shareholders—a provision of For Altice, the Sprint part-
.....................................B3
CenturyLink.................B6 K T making up for the tens of bil- the acquisition of its stake in nership will allow it to con-
projected
China Chengxin Kingboard Chemical T-Mobile US.........B1,B13 lions of dollars of synergies Sprint. tinue growing in the U.S. Al-
International Credit Holdings....................B3 TripAdvisor..................B6 that we would have had jointly At a Tokyo news conference FY ’14 ’15 ’16 ’17 ’18 tice, whose parent company
Rating......................B12 Kingdom Holding........B1 Twitter ........................ B1 with T-Mo had we merged on Monday, SoftBank Chair- has significant operations in
Note: Fiscal year runs from April 1 to March 31
China Investment.....B12 M 21st Century Fox........A1 with them,” he said, using a man Masayoshi Son said he Source: the company France, entered the U.S. in
China Lianhe Credit
Rating......................B12 Maltese Capital U nickname for T-Mobile. “These still sees value in Sprint as THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. 2015 when it acquired regional
Citigroup......................B1 Management.............B2 UnitedHealth Group....B6 synergies were enormous by network connectivity becomes cable company Suddenlink.
CVS Health..................B6 Michael Kors Holdings United Technologies...B3 every analyst’s account.” increasingly important to de- ical for SoftBank as a group in In 2016, it acquired New
.....................................B6 Still, Mr. Robbiati said the vice makers, and he defended five years’ to 10 years’ time,” York-based Cablevision.
D V
Microsoft.....................B4
Dandong Port Group Valeant Pharmaceuticals Altice partnership would de- his decision to end the merger he said. “I’m glad we were not —Mayumi Negishi
N International.............B6 liver real value, primarily be- talks. “Sprint will become crit- rushed into a decision that contributed to this article.
...................................B12
Dongfeng Motor Group Nvidia...................B4,B13 W
...................................B12 NXP Semiconductors
...................................B13 Walt Disney
DowDuPont...............B12
.................. A1,A10,B4,B6
E P Weight Watchers
Equifax ...................... B12 PHLX Semiconductor . A5 International.............B6
F Priceline Group ........... B6 Y
Fast Retailing ............. B7 Q Yum Brands.................B4
Federated Total Return Qatar Airways.............B3 Yum China Holdings...B4
INDEX TO PEOPLE
A Kelley, John J............B12 Ross, Gary...................B1
Ackman, William ........ B6 Kenny, Gregory ........... B6 S
B L Salman, Mohammed Bin
Barrett, George...........B6 Lewis, James..............A5 ............................. B1,B13
Blankfein, Lloyd........B12 Liveris, Andrew N.....B12 Short, Marc.................A4
Boudreaux, Gail K.......B6 Loeys, Jan...................B2 Smith, Richard..........B12
Brady, Kevin................A4 M Son, Masayoshi ........ B13
Broderick, Craig W....B12 Maltese, Terry ............ B2 Spajic, Luke...............B12
BUSINESS NEWS
Qatar Air
To Acquire
China Jet Exports Set for Takeoff
Pact with FAA opens
9.6% Stake door to the sale of
airplanes, parts in the
In Cathay U.S., other nations
BY GAURAV RAGHUVANSHI BY TREFOR MOSS
Please consider the charges, risks, expenses and investment objectives carefully before investing. For a prospectus or, if available, a summary prospectus containing this and other information, please
call Janus Henderson at 800.668.0434 or download the file from janushenderson.com/info. Read it carefully before you invest or send money.
Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal and fluctuation of value. Fixed income securities are subject to interest rate, inflation, credit and default risk. As interest rates rise, bond prices
usually fall, and vice versa. High-yield bonds, or “junk” bonds, involve a greater risk of default and price volatility.
Foreign securities, including sovereign debt, are subject to currency fluctuations, political and economic uncertainty, increased volatility and lower liquidity, all of which are magnified in emerging markets.
© 2017 Morningstar, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Janus Henderson is a trademark of Janus Henderson Investors. © Janus Henderson Investors. The name Janus Henderson Investors includes HGI Group Limited, Henderson Global Investors (Brand Management) Sarl and
Janus International Holding LLC. Janus Henderson Distributors. C-0917-12312 09-15-18
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
B4 | Tuesday, November 7, 2017 * * THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
TECHNOLOGY WSJ.com/Tech
ingly competitive business of ple pinned the problem on the and then tap Save in the up-
providing web-based, on-de- newly released iOS 11.1 and per right corner. Then do the
mand computing services. suggested a workaround. opposite: Add “i” for the
The deal, announced Mon- However, in our testing, sev- phrase and “I” for the short-
day at the start of Salesforce’s eral phones that were still on cut.
Dreamforce customer confer- iOS 11.0.3 were manifesting I began to see the bug on
ence in San Francisco, comes a the bug. Apple now says the the iPhone X this weekend,
year and a half after the cloud- bug could also appear in ear- after I completed my review.
based business software ven- lier versions of iOS 11. Being unable to type the let-
dor said it would move some Marc Benioff, chief executive of Salesforce.com, which is a cloud-based business software vendor. Some are floating theories ter “I” in emails, tweets, In-
computing operations to data on why this is just popping stagram posts was madden-
centers run by the market regulators to scrutinize Micro- Executive Marc Benioff said in something else that they are up and why it is only affect- ing—certainly there are
leader, Amazon Web Services. soft’s $27 billion acquisition of an interview. using, this gives them a ing some users. Apple better ways to get us to re-
Salesforce also operates its LinkedIn Inc., though the deal “We will in short order have chance to experience” Google’s wouldn’t comment on the flect on how self-absorbed we
own data centers. ultimately won approval and all of our products running on apps with Salesforce services, bug’s characteristics. are on social media.
World-wide revenue for the closed in December. Google Cloud,” he said. Google Cloud CEO Diane Nevertheless, Apple said it Needless to say, people
business of providing cloud in- Google Cloud, meanwhile, is As part of their deal, Sales- Greene said in an interview. would patch the problem in quickly began making fun of
frastructure—that is, comput- working to build credibility force will offer Google’s G Suite “It’s a change for us to bring an iOS update. “A fix will be Apple and the fact that the
ing processing and storage among corporations wary of productivity applications free all of this to Salesforce’s cus- released very soon,” an Apple company’s beloved letter “i”
service—hit $22.2 billion last committing to a company that tomers with very little fric- spokeswoman said. It will be was affected.
year, and is expected to climb has little experience supporting tion.”
to $67 billion by 2020, accord- the technology needs of big Salesforce also intends to
ing to industry research firm companies other than its own.
Global revenue for weave Google Analytics, which
Gartner Inc. Its cloud-infrastructure service, firms providing cloud helps marketers analyze cus-
One big cloud-infrastructure which provides computing pro- tomer behavior, with its own
provider Salesforce hasn’t cessing and storage from its
infrastructure hit Sales Cloud and Marketing
partnered with: Microsoft’s massive data centers around $22.2 billion last year. Cloud services. The combined
Azure service. Salesforce and the globe, trails Amazon, Mi- services are aimed at helping
Microsoft announced an alli- crosoft and Alibaba Group marketers more effectively tar-
ance in 2014 to enable their Holding Ltd., according to in- get email campaigns.
products to work together dustry research firm Gartner for up to one year to its cus- Mr. Benioff acknowledged
smoothly, but Salesforce is fac- Inc. tomers who aren’t already us- that money was being ex-
ing increased competition in its Salesforce already is run- ing them. Salesforce has more changed between the compa-
core sales-force automation ning its Advertising Studio ser- than 150,000 customers, and nies as part of the deal, but
business from Microsoft’s Dy- vice, which helps companies the company said less than half both he and Ms. Greene
APPLE
namics applications. run digital ad campaigns, on of them currently use G Suite. declined to disclose terms of
Salesforce last year pressed Google Cloud, Salesforce Chief “If people already have the deal. Apple pins the problem on the newly released iOS 11.1.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Tuesday, November 7, 2017 | B5
USE EVERY
ASSET CLASS
TO YOUR
ADVANTAGE
jpmorgan.com/funds/4solutions
Investors should carefully consider the investment objectives and risks as well as charges and expenses of a fund. The prospectus
contains this and other information about the fund and should be read carefully before investing. To obtain a prospectus for Mutual
Funds: Contact JPMorgan Distribution Services, Inc. at 1-800-480-4111 or visit jpmorganfunds.com. Exchange Traded Funds: Call
1-844-4JPM-ETF or visit jpmorgan.com/ETF. International investing has a greater degree of risk and increased volatility due to
political and economic instability of some overseas markets. Changes in currency exchange rates and different accounting and
taxation policies outside the U.S. can affect returns. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. J.P. Morgan ETFs are
distributed by JPMorgan Distribution Services, Inc., which is an affiliate of JPMorgan Chase & Co. Affiliates of JPMorgan Chase & Co.
receive fees for providing various services to the funds.
J.P. Morgan Asset Management is the brand for the asset management business of JPMorgan Chase & Co. and its affiliates worldwide. This communication is issued by Distribution Services Inc. and J.P. Morgan Institutional
Investments, Inc., both members of FINRA/SIPC.; and J.P. Morgan Investment Management Inc.© JPMorgan Chase & Co., September 2017
B6 | Tuesday, November 7, 2017 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
BUSINESS NEWS
Valeant to Sell Maker Anthem Turns to Industry Veteran for Top Job company will offer free same-
day delivery service starting
Dec. 4.
BUSINESS WATCH
PRICELINE GROUP
Notice of Redemption of
Outlook Dims
Banco Central de la República Dominicana
Collateralized Discount Bonds Due 2024
Despite Growth
ISIN: XS0052684601 Priceline Group Inc. lowered
In accordance with the provisions of the Fiscal Agency Agreement dated its profit outlook for the final
August 30, 1994, the Issuer has elected to redeem and pay in full the quarter of the year even as it
remaining outstanding principal in the amount of US$4,461,000.00 together
with all interest due in the amount of US$51,301.50 for a total final amount
continued to report rapid reve-
of US$4,512,301.50 on November 30, 2017. nue growth from customers
booking vacations and hotels on
Citibank Agency & Trust 7th of November, 2017
its travel sites.
The company forecast ad-
justed per-share earnings in the
current quarter at $13.40 to $14,
ADVERTISEMENT significantly below the $15.56 a
share analysts had expected.
The Mart
To advertise: 800-366-3975 or WSJ.com/classifieds
The Connecticut company
said travel bookings—the total
dollar value of travel services
purchased by customers includ-
SPENCER PLATT/GETTY IMAGES
BUSINESS NEWS
Annual
Meeting
November 13–14,
2017
Washington, D.C.
In a time of political tumult, the new administration in Washington
is already recasting trade relations, health-care policy, tax rates,
regulation and America’s role in the world.
Join The Wall Street Journal as we explore these topics with key
officials, industry leaders and global CEOs.
Speakers include:
Anne Case Kevin Hassett Mike Pence
Professor, Economics and Public Affairs Chairman, White House Council Vice President of the United States
Emeritus, Princeton University of Economic Advisers
Wilbur L. Ross, Jr.
Angus Deaton Jerry Kaplan U.S. Secretary of Commerce
Nobel Laureate in Economics; Adjunct Professor, Stanford University;
Senior Scholar, Princeton University Author, “Humans Need Not Apply: Lawrence H. Summers
A Guide to Wealth and Work in the Age President Emeritus, Harvard University;
Betsy DeVos of Artificial Intelligence” U.S. Secretary of the Treasury
U.S. Secretary of Education (1999-2001)
Amy Klobuchar
John Ferriola U.S. Senator (D., Minn.) Jay Walker
Chairman, President and CEO Founder and CEO, Upside;
Nucor Corporation Chris Liddell Founder, Priceline.com;
Assistant to the President and Director Founder, Library of the History
Martin Ford of Strategic Initiatives of Human Imagination
Author, "Rise of the Robots:
Technology and the Threat Steven Mnuchin Mark Warner
of a Jobless Future" U.S. Secretary of the Treasury U.S. Senator (D., Va.)
© 2017 Dow Jones & Co., Inc. All rights reserved. 6DJ5125
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Tuesday, November 7, 2017 | B9
MARKETS DIGEST
EQUITIES
Dow Jones Industrial Average S&P 500 Index Nasdaq Composite Index
Last Year ago Last Year ago Last Year ago
23548.42 s 9.23, or 0.04% Trailing P/E ratio 21.29 19.97 2591.13 s 3.29, or 0.13% Trailing P/E ratio 24.33 23.02 6786.44 s 22.00, or 0.33% Trailing P/E ratio * 16.10 23.75
High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 19.35 16.91 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 19.39 17.78 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 21.55 18.79
trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield 2.16 2.55 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield 1.92 2.20 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield 1.05 1.25
All-time high 23548.42, 11/06/17 All-time high: 2591.13, 11/06/17 All-time high: 6786.44, 11/06/17
Session high
DOWN UP 23000 2550 6650
t
Close Open
t
Session low
22000 2490 6450
New car loan Venezuela b. fuerte .097427 10.2641 2.7 Russia ruble .01716 58.281 –4.9
2.50 0.00 –15
Broadway National Bank 2.50% Asia-Pacific Sweden krona .1191 8.3980 –7.8
1 3 6 1 2 3 5 710 30 2017 Switzerland franc 1.0026 .9974 –2.1
San Antonio, TX 210-283-6500 Australian dollar .7691 1.3002 –6.4
2.00 month(s) years Turkey lira .2612 3.8280 8.6
Cambridge Savings Bank 2.59% China yuan .1507 6.6348 –4.5
ND J FMAM J J A S O N maturity Ukraine hryvnia .0373 26.8050 –1.0
Hong Kong dollar .1282 7.8020 0.6
2017 Cambridge, MA 888-418-5626 UK pound 1.3171 .7592 –6.3
India rupee .01548 64.599 –4.9
Sources: Ryan ALM; Tullett Prebon; WSJ Market Data Group Middle East/Africa
Indonesia rupiah .0000742 13486 –0.3
Yield/Rate (%) 52-Week Range (%) 3-yr chg Japan yen .008795 113.71 –2.8 Bahrain dinar 2.6470 .3778 0.2
Interest rate Last (l)Week ago Low 0 2 4 6 8 High (pct pts)
Kazakhstan tenge .002978 335.74 0.6 Egypt pound .0567 17.6515 –2.7
Federal-funds rate target 1.00-1.25 1.00-1.25 0.25 l 1.25 1.00 Corporate Borrowing Rates and Yields Macau pataca .1239 8.0710 2.0 Israel shekel .2851 3.5070 –8.9
Malaysia ringgit .2362 4.2331 –5.6 Kuwait dinar 3.3038 .3027 –1.0
Prime rate* 4.25 4.25 3.50 l 4.25 1.00 Yield (%) 52-Week Total Return (%)
Bond total return index Close Last Week ago High Low 52-wk 3-yr New Zealand dollar .6944 1.4401 –0.3 Oman sul rial 2.5972 .3850 0.02
Libor, 3-month 1.40 1.38 0.88 l 1.40 1.17 Pakistan rupee .00950 105.300 0.9 Qatar rial .2618 3.820 4.9
Money market, annual yield 0.33 0.32 0.26 l 0.36 -0.09 Treasury, Ryan ALM 1464.514 2.102 2.127 2.237 1.520 –0.871 2.209 Philippines peso .0196 51.116 3.0 Saudi Arabia riyal .2667 3.7499 –0.02
Five-year CD, annual yield 1.47 1.47 1.19 l 1.47 -0.07 10-yr Treasury, Ryan ALM 1739.136 2.318 2.374 2.609 1.826 2.382 2.101 Singapore dollar .7345 1.3614 –5.9 South Africa rand .0709 14.0970 2.9
30-year mortgage, fixed† 3.90 3.99 3.61 l 4.33 -0.20 South Korea won .0008986 1112.84 –7.9
DJ Corporate 379.766 3.063 3.026 3.390 2.750 2.973 4.076 Close Net Chg % Chg YTD%Chg
Sri Lanka rupee .0065108 153.59 3.5
15-year mortgage, fixed† 3.23 3.28 2.85 l 3.50 -0.03 Aggregate, Barclays Capital 1945.330 2.590 2.590 2.790 2.130 1.022 2.559 Taiwan dollar .03311 30.198 –7.0 WSJ Dollar Index 87.67 –0.29–0.33 –5.67
Jumbo mortgages, $424,100-plus† 4.28 4.34 4.23 l 4.88 -0.04 High Yield 100, Merrill Lynch 2865.366 5.213 5.193 6.448 4.948 8.558 4.134 Sources: Tullett Prebon, WSJ Market Data Group
Five-year adj mortgage (ARM)† 3.45 3.50 3.13 l 4.03 -0.31
Fixed-Rate MBS, Barclays 1991.160 2.840 2.860 3.120 2.290 0.688 2.216
New-car loan, 48-month 3.01 3.02 2.85 l 3.36 -0.25
HELOC, $30,000 5.03 5.19 4.57 l 5.30 0.58
Muni Master, Merrill 522.602 1.962 1.968 2.516 1.680 1.924 2.824 COMMODITIES
Bankrate.com rates based on survey of over 4,800 online banks. *Base rate posted by 70% of the nation's largest EMBI Global, J.P. Morgan 800.735 5.547 5.450 6.290 5.279 5.153 5.676 Commodities Monday 52-Week YTD
banks.† Excludes closing costs. Pricing trends on someClose
raw materials, or commodities
Sources: SIX Financial Information; WSJ Market Data Group; Bankrate.com Sources: J.P. Morgan; Ryan ALM; S&P Dow Jones Indices; Barclays Capital; Merrill Lynch Net chg % Chg High Low % Chg % chg
WSJ
TR/CC CRB Index 3.19 166.50 0.03
stocks, new highs/lows and mutual funds. Plus, Compare the performance of selected global stock Crude oil, $ per barrel 57.35 1.71 3.07 57.35 42.53 27.76 6.76
deeper money-flows data and email delivery of key indexes, bond ETFs, currencies and commodities at Natural gas, $/MMBtu 3.134 0.150 5.03 3.93 2.56 11.29 -15.84
.COM WSJ.com/TrackTheMarkets
stock-market data. Available free at WSJMarkets.com Gold, $ per troy oz. 1279.40 12.90 1.02 1346.00 1127.80 0.09 11.25
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
B10 | Tuesday, November 7, 2017 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
COMMODITIES WSJ.com/commodities
Metal & Petroleum Futures Milk (CME)-200,000 lbs., cents per lb.
Agriculture Futures Nov 16.54 16.63 16.54 16.56 .02 4,527 Currency Futures
Contract Open Dec 15.74 15.74 15.59 15.62 –.07 4,212
Open High hi lo Low Settle Chg interest Corn (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Japanese Yen (CME)-¥12,500,000; $ per 100¥
Cocoa (ICE-US)-10 metric tons; $ per ton. Nov .8761 .8799 t .8719 .8792 .0031 2,682
Copper-High (CMX)-25,000 lbs.; $ per lb. Dec 348.50 350.25 347.75 348.00 –.25 761,359 Dec 2,059 2,123 2,052 2,117 56 65,377 Dec .8777 .8812 .8731 .8805 .0031 276,460
Nov 3.1490 3.1530 3.1440 3.1505 0.0400 934 March'18 362.25 364.00 361.25 361.50 –.50 381,471 March'18 2,051 2,113 2,049 2,109 53 121,302 Canadian Dollar (CME)-CAD 100,000; $ per CAD
Dec 3.1130 3.1730 3.1115 3.1575 0.0400 146,579 Oats (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Coffee (ICE-US)-37,500 lbs.; cents per lb. Nov .7835 .7870 .7832 .7863 .0026 1,259
Gold (CMX)-100 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. Dec 262.50 270.00 260.50 269.00 6.00 4,597 Dec 123.95 126.40 122.25 125.55 1.60 108,465 Dec .7838 .7875 .7825 .7865 .0026 146,226
Nov 1269.00 1280.50 1269.00 1279.40 12.90 140 March'18 268.00 273.00 266.25 272.25 3.75 2,905 March'18 127.50 129.80 125.85 129.05 1.55 72,865 British Pound (CME)-£62,500; $ per £
Dec 1270.70 1283.90 1266.40 1281.60 12.40 358,880 Soybeans (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Sugar-World (ICE-US)-112,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Nov 1.3084 1.3173 1.3081 1.3175 .0104 1,280
Feb'18 1274.70 1288.10 1270.90 1285.90 12.50 107,147 Nov 977.25 985.50 975.25 984.00 7.00 4,451 March 14.38 14.58 14.23 14.56 .18 410,704 Dec 1.3096 1.3190 1.3073 1.3187 .0104 173,149
April 1277.00 1292.00 1277.00 1290.00 12.60 16,685 Jan'18 987.25 995.75 985.00 994.00 7.25 328,977 May 14.47 14.67 14.34 14.65 .17 136,970
Swiss Franc (CME)-CHF 125,000; $ per CHF
June 1279.30 1296.00 1279.30 1294.00 12.60 15,321 Soybean Meal (CBT)-100 tons; $ per ton. Dec 1.0021 1.0054 .9997 1.0047 .0028 79,627
Sugar-Domestic (ICE-US)-112,000 lbs.; cents per lb. March'18 1.0070 1.0117 1.0067 1.0116 .0029 195
Dec 1294.60 1308.10 1294.60 1306.40 12.60 11,025 Dec 314.30 316.80 313.70 316.10 2.20 119,690 March 27.16 27.25 27.10 27.24 –.05 2,816
Palladium (NYM) - 50 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. Jan'18 316.40 318.70 315.90 318.10 2.10 96,053
Australian Dollar (CME)-AUD 100,000; $ per AUD
May 27.10 27.15 27.10 27.15 .05 1,805 Nov .7645 .7687 .7640 .7687 .0039 1,324
Dec 995.60 1003.10 990.30 995.10 3.60 29,403 Soybean Oil (CBT)-60,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Cotton (ICE-US)-50,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Dec .7650 .7690 .7635 .7685 .0039 120,495
March'18 987.75 995.15 s 982.95 987.10 3.40 5,406 Dec 34.40 34.99 34.26 34.73 .31 140,804 Dec 68.86 69.12 68.23 68.85 .13 97,267 Jan'18 .7643 .7686 .7636 .7683 .0039 705
Platinum (NYM)-50 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. Jan'18 34.59 35.16 34.42 34.89 .30 109,023 March'18 68.75 69.25 68.37 69.10 .33 93,503 Feb .7641 .7681 .7634 .7682 .0039 504
Nov 931.70 933.80 931.60 931.00 12.50 9 Rough Rice (CBT)-2,000 cwt.; $ per cwt. Orange Juice (ICE-US)-15,000 lbs.; cents per lb. March .7639 .7680 .7636 .7681 .0039 924
Jan'18 922.10 938.50 919.60 935.00 13.10 69,944 Nov 1119.50 1121.50 1119.50 1124.00 –4.50 37 Nov 151.90 152.80 151.90 160.40 2.55 47 June .7667 .7667 .7667 .7678 .0039 244
Silver (CMX)-5,000 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. Jan'18 1159.00 1159.00 1142.50 1152.00 –5.50 9,283 Jan'18 157.00 160.00 155.85 159.90 3.30 5,700 Mexican Peso (CME)-MXN 500,000; $ per MXN
Nov 17.205 17.225 17.205 17.195 0.401 13 Wheat (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Dec .05171 .05221 .05170 .05212 .00027 177,435
Dec 16.835 17.270 16.795 17.235 0.401 137,547 Dec 427.00 431.25 427.00 430.75 5.00 279,025 March'18 .05119 .05139 .05096 .05134 .00027 550
Crude Oil, Light Sweet (NYM)-1,000 bbls.; $ per bbl. March'18 445.50 449.50 445.50 448.25 3.75 144,986
Interest Rate Futures Euro (CME)-€125,000; $ per €
Dec 55.97 57.61 55.66 57.35 1.71 540,082 Treasury Bonds (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100% Nov 1.1618 1.1628 1.1586 1.1612 –.0001 5,357
Wheat (KC)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Dec 1.1640 1.1650 1.1606 1.1633 –.0002 426,649
Jan'18 56.20 57.83 55.88 57.57 1.71 353,925 Dec 427.75 431.00 427.00 430.00 3.25 156,057 Dec 153-240 154-120 153-120 154-070 18.0 737,362
Feb 56.25 57.95 s 56.02 57.70 1.72 157,371 March'18 445.25 448.50 444.75 447.00 2.50 97,374 March'18 152-170 153-070 152-100 153-020 18.0 10,308
March 56.27 57.98 s 56.07 57.72 1.70 248,901 Index Futures
Wheat (MPLS)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Treasury Notes (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100%
June 55.70 57.40 55.60 57.21 1.63 226,050 Dec 624.75 631.75 624.75 631.00 6.25 34,630 Dec 125-075 125-135 125-035 125-115 6.5 3,195,816 Mini DJ Industrial Average (CBT)-$5 x index
Dec 53.92 55.20 53.72 55.04 1.27 265,597 March'18 638.25 644.75 638.25 644.00 5.50 26,241 March'18 124-290 125-040 124-265 125-025 7.5 33,480 Dec 23444 23507 s 23407 23487 38 155,788
NY Harbor ULSD (NYM)-42,000 gal.; $ per gal. Cattle-Feeder (CME)-50,000 lbs.; cents per lb. 5 Yr. Treasury Notes (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100% March'18 23441 23496 s 23401 23477 36 1,673
Dec 1.8830 1.9468 s 1.8814 1.9422 .0556 132,851 Nov 160.875 161.100 159.000 160.150 –.725 7,603 Dec 117-077 117-105 117-057 117-087 2.5 3,077,750 S&P 500 Index (CME)-$250 x index
Jan'18 1.8864 1.9493 s 1.8835 1.9449 .0560 88,029 Dec 2581.30 2590.00 s 2575.00 2588.70 6.00 60,444
Jan'18 161.550 161.875 159.275 160.875 –.650 29,702 March'18 117-030 117-032 117-010 117-017 2.7 42,992
Gasoline-NY RBOB (NYM)-42,000 gal.; $ per gal. Mini S&P 500 (CME)-$50 x index
Cattle-Live (CME)-40,000 lbs.; cents per lb. 2 Yr. Treasury Notes (CBT)-$200,000; pts 32nds of 100% Dec 2580.00 2590.00 s 2575.50 2588.75 6.00 3,163,563
Dec 1.7902 1.8390 s 1.7767 1.8300 .0366 150,433 Dec 127.250 127.675 124.825 125.325 –1.975 124,174 Dec 107-205 107-212 107-200 107-205 .2 1,696,803
Jan'18 1.7575 1.8057 s 1.7442 1.8017 .0457 89,564 March'18 2580.50 2590.50 s 2575.75 2589.00 6.00 71,890
Feb'18 131.650 131.950 s 129.825 130.650 –1.100 107,816 March'18 107-160 107-160 107-152 107-157 .7 35,805 Mini S&P Midcap 400 (CME)-$100 x index
Natural Gas (NYM)-10,000 MMBtu.; $ per MMBtu. Hogs-Lean (CME)-40,000 lbs.; cents per lb. 30 Day Federal Funds (CBT)-$5,000,000; 100 - daily avg. Dec 1832.40 1845.20 1829.20 1842.30 7.50 91,983
Dec 3.085 3.143 3.051 3.134 .150 306,161 98.845 98.845 98.843 98.843 … 211,883 Mini Nasdaq 100 (CME)-$20 x index
Dec 65.075 65.150 64.425 64.625 –.475 98,756 Nov
Jan'18 3.180 3.242 3.154 3.232 .135 232,808 98.620 98.620 t 98.615 98.620 … 354,635 Dec 6285.3 6317.5 s 6268.0 6313.5 23.0 267,910
Feb'18 71.875 72.325 71.700 72.225 .250 68,808 Jan'18
Feb 3.184 3.240 3.157 3.231 .129 85,917 March'18 6298.8 6330.8 s 6281.5 6327.3 23.8 1,755
Lumber (CME)-110,000 bd. ft., $ per 1,000 bd. ft. 10 Yr. Del. Int. Rate Swaps (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100%
March 3.153 3.197 3.118 3.189 .121 171,846 Mini Russell 2000 (ICE-US)-$100 x index
Nov 448.60 464.20 448.40 461.60 12.60 565 Dec 101.281 101.469 101.281 101.438 .297 28,538
April 2.950 2.968 2.928 2.953 .050 122,526 Dec 1493.30 1503.30 1489.50 1497.10 2.10 68,392
Jan'18 437.50 449.60 437.50 449.60 10.00 5,436 1 Month Libor (CME)-$3,000,000; pts of 100%
May 2.915 2.944 2.909 2.928 .043 78,345
Nov ... ... ... 98.7500 … 928
Mini Russell 1000 (ICE-US)-$100 x index
Dec 1432.00 1435.80 s 1432.00 1434.60 3.10 256
Eurodollar (CME)-$1,000,000; pts of 100% U.S. Dollar Index (ICE-US)-$1,000 x index
Nov 98.5850 98.5850 98.5825 98.5825 –.0025 94,703
94.83 95.00 94.61 94.66 –.20 48,971
Cash Prices | WSJ.com/commodities
Dec
Dec 98.4800 98.4850 98.4750 98.4750 –.0050 1,666,525
Monday, November 06, 2017 March'18 98.3350 98.3400 98.3250 98.3300 … 1,275,193
March'18 94.54 94.67 94.33 94.37 –.20 2,295
These prices reflect buying and selling of a variety of actual or “physical” commodities in the marketplace— Dec 98.0750 98.0850 98.0600 98.0700 .0050 1,623,624 Source: SIX Financial Information
separate from the futures price on an exchange, which reflects what the commodity might be worth in future
months.
Monday Monday Monday Bonds | WSJ.com/bonds
(U.S.$ equivalent) 16.9150 SoybeanMeal,Cent IL,rail,ton48%-u 312.10
Energy Coins,wholesale $1,000 face-a 12983 Soybeans,No.1 yllw IL-bp,u 9.4700 Tracking Bond Benchmarks
Propane,tet,Mont Belvieu-g 0.9573 Other metals Wheat,Spring14%-pro Mnpls-u 7.6100
Butane,normal,Mont Belvieu-g 1.0436 LBMA Platinum Price PM *922.0 Wheat,No.2 soft red,St.Louis-bp,u 4.3750 Return on investment and spreads over Treasurys and/or yields paid to investors compared with 52-week
NaturalGas,HenryHub-i 3.030 Platinum,Engelhard industrial 922.0 Wheat - Hard - KC (USDA) $ per bu-u 3.7250 highs and lows for different types of bonds
NaturalGas,TranscoZone3-i 3.000 Platinum,Engelhard fabricated 1022.0 Wheat,No.1soft white,Portld,OR-u 5.3038 Total Total
NaturalGas,TranscoZone6NY-i 3.030 Palladium,Engelhard industrial 999.0 return YTD total Yield (%) return YTD total Yield (%)
Food close return (%) Index Latest Low High close return (%) Index Latest Low High
NaturalGas,PanhandleEast-i 2.700 Palladium,Engelhard fabricated 1099.0
NaturalGas,Opal-i 2.980 Aluminum, LME, $ per metric ton *2165.0 Beef,carcass equiv. index Mortgage-Backed Bloomberg Barclays
Broad Market Bloomberg Barclays
NaturalGas,MarcellusNE PA-i 1.540 Copper,Comex spot 3.1505 choice 1-3,600-900 lbs.-u 191.82
NaturalGas,HaynesvilleN.LA-i 2.930 Iron Ore, 62% Fe CFR China-s 62.7 select 1-3,600-900 lbs.-u 177.68 1945.33 3.5 U.S. Aggregate 2.590 2.130 2.790 1991.16 2.5 Mortgage-Backed 2.840 2.290 3.120
Coal,C.Aplc.,12500Btu,1.2SO2-r,w 57.850 Shredded Scrap, US Midwest-s,w n.a. Broilers, National comp wghtd-u,w 0.8635 1957.78 2.0 Ginnie Mae (GNMA) 2.790 2.200 3.090
U.S. Corporate Indexes Bloomberg Barclays
Coal,PwdrRvrBsn,8800Btu,0.8SO2-r,w 11.750 Steel, HRC USA, FOB Midwest Mill-s 615 Butter,AA Chicago 2.2250
Cheddar cheese,bbl,Chicago 171.50 2787.01 5.9 U.S. Corporate 3.150 2.970 3.520 1167.93 2.7 Fannie mae (FNMA) 2.860 2.320 3.120
Metals Fibers and Textiles Cheddar cheese,blk,Chicago 169.25
2625.03 4.1 Intermediate 2.710 2.390 3.010 1798.60 2.8 Freddie Mac (FHLMC) 2.870 2.330 3.130
Gold, per troy oz Burlap,10-oz,40-inch NY yd-n,w 0.6100 Milk,Nonfat dry,Chicago lb. 72.75
Engelhard industrial 1275.31 Cotton,1 1/16 std lw-mdMphs-u 0.6810 Cocoa,Ivory Coast-w n.a. 3868.37 10.0 Long term 4.100 4.100 4.710 522.60 4.8 Muni Master 1.962 1.680 2.516
Cotlook 'A' Index-t *79.75 Coffee,Brazilian,Comp 1.2315
Engelhard fabricated 1370.96 568.85 4.4 Double-A-rated 2.640 2.320 2.870 365.74 5.3 7-12 year 1.968 1.678 2.618
Hides,hvy native steers piece fob-u 68.500 Coffee,Colombian, NY 1.4341
Handy & Harman base 1270.90
Wool,64s,staple,Terr del-u,w n.a. Eggs,large white,Chicago-u 1.0150 719.81 6.5 Triple-B-rated 3.430 3.340 3.870 410.36 6.4 12-22 year 2.401 2.119 3.047
Handy & Harman fabricated 1410.69
Flour,hard winter KC 15.70
LBMA Gold Price AM *1275.30 Grains and Feeds High Yield Bonds Merrill Lynch 396.46 6.8 22-plus year 2.849 2.601 3.622
Hams,17-20 lbs,Mid-US fob-u 0.81
LBMA Gold Price PM *1267.20
Barley,top-quality Mnpls-u n.a. Hogs,Iowa-So. Minnesota-u 66.92 417.49 7.4 High Yield Constrained 5.546 5.373 6.858 Global Government J.P. Morgan†
Krugerrand,wholesale-e 1332.45
Bran,wheat middlings, KC-u 74 Pork bellies,12-14 lb MidUS-u 1.2449
Maple Leaf-e 1345.26 418.32 8.8 Triple-C-rated 10.465 9.584 13.189 545.11 1.5 Global Government 1.400 1.080 1.560
Corn,No. 2 yellow,Cent IL-bp,u 3.1550 Pork loins,13-19 lb MidUS-u 0.9188
American Eagle-e 1345.26
Corn gluten feed,Midwest-u,w 93.2 Steers,Tex.-Okla. Choice-u 125.00 2865.37 6.8 High Yield 100 5.213 4.948 6.448 757.68 0.6 Canada 1.990 1.390 2.190
Mexican peso-e 1552.74
Corn gluten meal,Midwest-u,w 473.0 Steers,feeder,Okla. City-u,w 165.75
Austria crown-e 1258.83 379.24 7.7 Global High Yield Constrained 5.035 4.934 6.450 373.01 1.1 EMU§ 1.028 0.835 1.363
Cottonseed meal-u,w 230 Fats and Oils
Austria phil-e 1345.26
Hominy feed,Cent IL-u,w 88 308.64 7.5 Europe High Yield Constrained 1.900 1.900 3.814 713.99 1.1 France 0.790 0.540 1.210
Silver, troy oz. Meat-bonemeal,50% pro Mnpls-u,w 220 Corn oil,crude wet/dry mill-u,w 34.5000
Engelhard industrial 16.9500 Oats,No.2 milling,Mnpls-u 2.9900 Grease,choice white,Chicago-h 0.2400 U.S Agency Bloomberg Barclays 510.86 -0.7 Germany 0.410 0.170 0.620
Engelhard fabricated 20.3400 Rice, 5% Broken White, Thailand-l,w 370.00 Lard,Chicago-u n.a. 1641.46 2.2 U.S Agency 1.980 1.360 2.010 288.50 0.1 Japan 0.390 0.170 0.460
Handy & Harman base 17.1900 Rice, Long Grain Milled, No. 2 AR-u,w 24.00 Soybean oil,crude;Centl IL-u 0.3336
Handy & Harman fabricated 21.4880 Sorghum,(Milo) No.2 Gulf-u 7.6875 Tallow,bleach;Chicago-h 0.2550 1467.07 1.4 10-20 years 1.820 1.170 1.840 563.72 -0.5 Netherlands 0.540 0.290 0.760
LBMA spot price £12.9000 Tallow,edible,Chicago-u n.a.
3374.01 7.9 20-plus years 2.900 2.710 3.460 920.50 0.8 U.K. 1.590 1.340 1.790
KEY TO CODES: A=ask; B=bid; BP=country elevator bids to producers; C=corrected; E=Manfra,Tordella & Brooks; G=ICE; H=Hurley Brokerage; I=Natural Gas Intelligence; 2462.01 5.0 Yankee 2.810 2.490 3.090 800.73 8.3 Emerging Markets ** 5.547 5.279 6.290
L=livericeindex.com; M=midday; N=nominal; n.a.=not quoted or not available; R=SNL Energy; S=Platts-TSI; T=Cotlook Limited; U=USDA; W=weekly, Z=not quoted. *Data *Constrained indexes limit individual issuer concentrations to 2%; the High Yield 100 are the 100 largest bonds † In local currency § Euro-zone bonds
as of 11/3
Source: WSJ Market Data Group ** EMBI Global Index Sources: Merrill Lynch; Bloomberg Barclays; J.P.Morgan
Continued From Page B7 52-Wk % 52-Wk % GlbX Robotics&AI BOTZ 23.84 0.7 JackHenry JKHY 111.99 0.2 PayPal PYPL 74.76 1.8 SEI Investments SEIC 65.83 1.3 VicShUS500Vol CFA 46.86 0.1 ClearOne CLRO 7.00 -1.0 NumereX NMRX 3.65 -5.6
Sym Hi/Lo Chg GlbXS&P500Catholic CATH 32.08 0.2 KellyServices A KELYA 27.31 0.1 PennNational PENN 26.84 2.1 SMTC SMTX 1.70 4.5 ViperEnergyPtrs VNOM 20.65 5.4 ConsldComm CNSL 15.48 -2.7 OriginAgritech SEED 1.25 -2.3
52-Wk % Stock Sym Hi/Lo Chg Stock
GoldenEnt GDEN 29.68 3.6 Kulicke&Soffa KLIC 23.71 3.8 PinnacleEnt PNK 27.13 1.4 SareptaTherap SRPT 57.29 3.9 WisdTrChinaxSOE CXSE 84.05 2.0 DarioHealth DRIO 1.43 -2.6 PacBiosciCA PACB 2.85 -5.0
Stock Sym Hi/Lo Chg Celcuity CELC 21.35 7.7 FT APxJapan FPA 35.45 0.7 Groupon GRPN 5.63 0.4 LGI Homes LGIH 62.19 3.0 PlugPower PLUG 3.15 9.8 Skyworks SWKS 117.65 2.8 WynnResorts WYNN 154.28 0.9 ElPolloLoco LOCO 9.60 -0.8 PapaJohn's PZZA 58.64 -4.2
CenturyCasinos CNTY 9.50 3.9 FT CloudComp SKYY 44.21 0.1 H&E Equipment HEES 34.03 2.4 Lantheus LNTH 24.10 2.9 PwrShDWA Mom PDP 51.16 0.6 SolarEdgeTech SEDG 34.65 -0.4 Xilinx XLNX 74.51 2.3 2.33 1.1 Patterson PDCO 34.17 -3.2
AlliedMotionTech AMOT 34.83 -0.8 ElbitImaging EMITF
ChemungFinl CHMG 48.92 1.2 FT DevMktsXUS FDTS 42.94 0.4 HealthEquity HQY 55.31 6.2 LendingTree TREE 276.60 1.0 PwrShDWATactical DWTR 28.45 0.3 StarsGroup TSG 20.95 1.7 Zogenix ZGNX 42.60 0.6 Precipio PRPO 1.30 -1.7
AltairEngg ALTR 19.60 -2.1 Energous WATT 7.07 -4.2
ClearBrLCGrw LRGE 27.90 1.5 FT DorseyIntl5 IFV 21.97 0.8 HeritageFin HFWA 31.65 1.6 LigandPharm LGND 147.13 0.4 PwrShDynFinl PFI 34.69 1.0 SunHydraulics SNHY 59.97 1.2 ProfDiversity IPDN 2.45 -4.2
Amazon.com AMZN1125.41 0.8 Essendant ESND 9.10 -0.4
AnalogDevices ADI 92.96 0.5
Cognex CGNX
CumberlandPharm CPIX
134.92
7.90
1.2
-1.2
FT NasdTechDiv TDIV
FT GlbNatRscs FTRI
34.80
12.29
0.5
1.1
HorizNasd100 QYLD
Hortonworks HDP
24.47
18.69
0.3
1.8
LimelightNetworks LLNW
LivaNova LIVN
5.47
81.85
4.8
-1.3
PwrShDynHlthcr PTH
PwrShDynTech PTF
70.25
54.42
-0.3
0.6
SuperCom
Talend
SPCB
TLND
4.58 1.2
44.72 3.2
Nasdaq lows - 68 FTD
Finisar
FTD
FNSR
10.24 4.3
18.77 -0.8
ProShUltraProShQQQ SQQQ
ProteostasisTher PTI
22.56 -1.0
1.61 1.2
Apple AAPL 174.99 1.0 CypressSemi CY 16.51 2.5 FT LC US Equity RNLC 20.93 0.4 ADMA Biologics ADMA 2.01 -8.0
I-AM Capital IAM 10.52 0.6 MMACapitalMgmt MMAC 25.75 6.2 PwrShFTSEIntlLow IDLB 29.63 ... TexasInstruments TXN 98.67 0.6 Fred's FRED 4.22 -0.2 RaPharm RARX 11.20 0.9
ArenaPharm ARNA 28.97 -1.3 DASAN Zhone DZSI 8.57 9.9 FT MC GrwthAlpha FNY 38.39 0.2 AMC Networks AMCX 47.13 5.4
ILG ILG 30.70 0.7 Marriott MAR 123.03 0.4 PwrShGlbWater PIO 25.45 0.2 TivityHealth TVTY 48.50 -34.2 FrontierCommPfA FTRPR 13.00 6.0 RestorationRob HAIR 6.50 -6.1
Atlassian TEAM 52.09 2.1 DavisUSEquity DUSA 22.88 0.5 FT MC US Equity RNMC 21.05 0.5 AcaciaComms ACIA 36.50 ...
Icon ICLR 124.48 -0.1 MarvellTech MRVL 21.08 9.1 PwrShQQQ 1 QQQ 153.85 0.3 TransActTechs TACT 13.25 0.8 Sanfilippo JBSS 56.48 -2.3
AxoGen AXGN 24.95 -3.5 DavisWorldwide DWLD 25.74 1.5 FT MCGrAlpDX FAD 64.00 0.1 1.29 -13.0 FulgentGenetics FLGT 3.41 17.1
Insulet PODD 71.16 0.6 MaximIntProducts MXIM 54.84 2.5 PwrShWaterRscs PHO 29.53 0.2 TrilliumTherap TRIL 10.00 3.9 AchieveLifeSci ACHV SearsHoldingsWt SHLDW 0.42 -13.2
BldrsAsia50ADS ADRA 34.35 0.5 DentsplySirona XRAY 67.95 -1.4 FT NasdCleanEdge QCLN 20.70 1.6 Airgain AIRG 7.50 -3.1 GenMarkDiagn GNMK 3.63 -10.6
IntegratedDevice IDTI 33.02 5.5 MelcoResorts MLCO 26.54 -0.2 PrincplMillennials GENY 32.70 1.8 Trupanion TRUP 33.00 3.0 Shutterfly SFLY 40.22 -1.9
BallardPower BLDP 5.90 3.9 Diodes DIOD 35.36 1.8 FT NasdGlblAuto CARZ 42.18 0.2 AmbacFin AMBC 15.52 -2.5 GenoceaBiosci GNCA 1.03 21.0
Intuit INTU 154.19 -0.6 MonolithicPower MPWR 124.81 2.0 ProShEquRising EQRR 43.81 ... TrustcoBank TRST 9.38 3.9 SonomaPharm SNOA 4.16 -2.6
Biomerica BMRA 3.85 -3.0 DoubleEagleWt EAGLW 0.85 5.2 FT Nasd100Tech QTEC 73.62 0.8 iShAsia50ETF AIA 65.78 0.5 NVE NVEC 88.62 2.6 ProShUltPrQQQ TQQQ 134.28 1.0 TwinDisc TWIN 25.76 12.3 Astrotech ASTC 2.48 -5.3 GreatElmCap GECC 9.75 -1.1 Stericycle SRCL 66.27 -0.1
BisonCapAcqn BCAC 9.95 1.0 EXACT Sci EXAS 58.96 2.8 FT NasdSmartphone FONE 52.43 1.0 iShCommodSelStrat COMT 37.02 1.8 NektarTherap NKTR 25.35 2.2 ProvidentBancorp PVBC 25.80 3.0 2U TWOU 65.90 0.1 Atomera ATOM 2.45 -6.3 HabitRestaurants HABT 9.00 -1.1 Teligent TLGT 4.99 1.5
BldrsDev100 ADRD 23.23 0.4 Ebix EBIX 69.20 0.4 FirstUnited FUNC 18.30 2.3 iShCoreS&PUSGrowth IUSG 52.65 0.3 Neurocrine NBIX 75.22 1.4 PumaBiotech PBYI 132.35 0.6 USA Truck USAK 15.50 7.1 BedBath BBBY 19.31 2.1 HalladorEnergy HNRG 4.79 -3.0 21stCenturyFoxB FOX 24.30 9.0
BlueprintMed BPMC 74.42 -5.1 ElectroScientific ESIO 23.10 4.6 Flex FLEX 18.47 0.9 iShMSCIACWIETF ACWI 70.82 0.3 NewaterTech NEWA 16.25 -2.4 QAD A QADA 39.60 -0.1 UniversalDisplay OLED 164.00 3.4 Big5SportingGoods BGFV 6.05 -7.6 HenrySchein HSIC 69.51 -9.8 21stCenturyFoxA FOXA 24.81 9.9
Broadcom AVGO 281.80 1.4 EnantaPharma ENTA 50.92 -0.7 FoundationMed FMI 55.95 4.0 iShMSCIACWIexUSETF ACWX 49.64 0.4 NuvNasd100Dyn QQQX 23.92 0.2 QAD B QADB 31.85 1.3 VangdRuss1000 VONE 118.94 0.2 BisonCapAcqn BCAC 9.67 1.0 IconixBrand ICON 1.44 -8.6 UnivElectro UEIC 48.50 -4.5
CadenceDesign CDNS 44.34 0.9 EntegraFin ENFC 28.05 1.6 FullHouse FLL 3.10 11.1 iShMSCIACxJpn AAXJ 76.53 0.8 NVIDIA NVDA 209.98 0.5 Qualys QLYS 58.25 ... VangdRuss1000Grw VONG 134.36 0.2 CafePress PRSS 1.67 4.0 iShMSCIQatarCapped QAT 14.75 -0.8 VS2xVIXShortTerm TVIX 8.05 -2.1
CalamosGlblTot CGO 14.52 0.4 Equinix EQIX 493.09 1.0 GilatSatellite GILT 7.56 1.2 iShMSCIChinaETF MCHI 66.88 1.5 OptiNose OPTN 21.46 3.4 ROBOGlblRobotics ROBO 40.98 0.7 VangdRuss3000 VTHR 118.99 0.2 CambridgeBncp CATC 70.00 ... KayneAnAcqn KAAC 9.68 -0.1 VSVIXShortTerm VIIX 14.06 -0.9
CallidusSoftware CALD 29.70 0.3 Exactech EXAC 42.75 -0.2 GladstoneInvt GAIN 10.75 1.7 iShMSCIEmMkAsia EEMA 74.21 0.3 Orbotech ORBK 52.90 8.2 Radware RDWR 19.68 0.7 VascularBiogenics VBLT 7.35 4.9 Cardtronics CATM 16.99 -1.5 LexiconPharm LXRX 9.79 -1.9 Vical VICL 1.80 -13.8
CalumetSpecialty CLMT 9.95 3.7 FSB Bancorp FSBC 16.77 0.7 GlbXFinTech FINX 21.82 1.2 iShMSCIEMxChina EMXC 53.26 1.3 OrthoPediatrics KIDS 23.00 4.9 RedRockResorts RRR 25.23 0.7 VSInverseVIXSTerm XIV 113.81 1.0 Cemtrex CETX 2.61 -4.3 MartinMidstream MMLP 15.30 1.3 WestmorelandCoal WLB 1.64 7.7
CanadianSolar CSIQ 19.09 -0.2 FidelityNasdComp ONEQ 267.11 0.4 GlbXInternetThings SNSR 20.30 0.8 iShMSCIUSAESGOpt ESGU 56.82 0.1 PCSB Fin PCSB 19.68 -0.2 Retrophin RTRX 26.44 4.1 VeriskAnalytics VRSK 91.73 0.1 Ceragon CRNT 1.82 -11.1 Net1UEPS UEPS 8.90 -1.3 WestwaterRscs WWR 0.76 -3.6
Cavium CAVM 76.75 12.0 FirstSolar FSLR 62.57 2.7 GlbXMillThematic MILN 18.75 0.6 iShPHLXSemicond SOXX 178.57 1.4 PatriotNatlBncp PNBK 17.70 0.6 SBA Comm SBAC 167.44 6.4 VicShIntlVolWtd CIL 40.12 0.1 Cherokee CHKE 1.95 -6.0 Novogen NVGN 1.63 -4.7 WheelerREITPfdD WHLRD 19.02 -0.8
Goldman,
CIC Plan
Joint Fund
To Invest
Goldman Sachs Group Inc.
and China Investment Corp.
are joining on a multibillion-
dollar fund to help the Chinese
sovereign-wealth fund invest
Beijing’s willingness Diverging Assessments such an environment can be northern Chinese city with the ceremony presided over by Mr.
challenging. same name, missed a payment Trump and Chinese President
Moody's Investors Service and its Chinese joint venture, China
to open up sector to Chengxin International Credit Rating*, have sharply differing credit
The fate of the ratings on a 1 billion yuan ($150.6 mil- Xi Jinping in Beijing’s Great
firms in China isn’t a matter lion) bond issued in 2014. Just Hall of the People.
international rivals ratings on some debt issuers.
only for the industry. The before its default, Dandong Other contracts, letters of
Noninvestment Investment country has been trying to in- had a high investment-grade intent and agreements involve
BY SHEN HONG, MANJU DALAL grade grade ternationalize its bond mar- rating of AA from China Li- aviation, liquefied natural gas
AND GUNJAN BANERJI Rating scale kets, and while many yield- anhe Credit Rating Co., a and soybeans, and the deals
hungry foreign investors are company that is 49%-owned are being presented as prog-
The world’s largest bond- C B1 AAA eager to buy Chinese debt, a by Fitch. The domestic firm ress in a trade relationship
rating firms are on the verge lack of faith in the grading downgraded its rating to C af- that Mr. Trump has criticized
of gaining unfettered access to system has given some pause. ter the default. as lopsided in China’s favor.
an arena they have long cov- China Moody’s A1
Foreign bond raters could The international raters are Goldman Sachs Chairman and
eted: China’s booming market (sovereign) potentially “bring expertise allowed to assess offshore Chief Executive Officer Lloyd
China Chengxin AAA
for corporate debt. and, more importantly, inde- bond deals. That has resulted Blankfein, General Electric
It won’t be an easy task. pendent thinking” to the Chi- in diverging credit ratings on Co. Vice Chairman John G.
Even before the big credit nese market, said Luke Spajic, some companies. Rice and DowDupont Inc. Ex-
Postal A2
raters gain the right to oper- Savings Bank an emerging-markets portfolio Consider the case of Dong- ecutive Chairman Andrew N.
ate independently within of China AAA manager at Pacific Investment feng Motor Group Co., a Liveris are among the dozens
China, they are already in Bei- Management Co. in Singapore. state-run car maker in central of U.S. executives coming to
jing’s crosshairs. Both Moody’s The ultimate test will come Hubei province that in May Beijing during Mr. Trump’s
Investors Service and S&P A2
when domestic and foreign was downgraded by Moody’s visit.
Global Ratings this year low- Dongfeng raters have vastly diverging to A2 from A1, shortly after it The delegation and the
ered their ratings on China’s Motor Group views on credit risk, he said, lowered its China rating. China deals are meant to show that
AAA
sovereign debt, citing con- adding, “Calling out bond de- Chengxin, the domestic rater the Trump administration is
cerns about the country’s in- faults should be the credibility in which Moody’s has a stake, working to reduce the U.S.
creasing debt pile. A3
marker.” has a AAA rating on Dongfeng trade deficit with China and
The downgrades drew a Anhui Conch In the late 1990s, interna- Motor.
hostile response from China’s Cement tional rating firms were al- As of Oct. 10, Moody’s had
AAA
government. And when China lowed to establish a limited upgraded 13 and downgraded
last month issued $2 billion in foothold in China, and they 40 Chinese companies’ off-
The fund is targeting
U.S. dollar bonds—its first B1
took minority stakes in com- shore ratings since the start of as much as $5 billion
such sale outside the country Yanzhou panies controlled by Chinese this year. Its joint venture in
in 13 years—it didn’t seek a Coal Mining firms. China upgraded 99 and down-
to invest in various
AAA
rating from any of the big for- Moody’s owns 30% of a graded 18 onshore ratings over U.S. industries.
eign firms. joint venture called China the period.
*Moody’s owns 30%.
The tension comes at an Chengxin International The international raters are
Sources: the rating companies THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
important juncture. After be- Credit Rating Co. S&P doesn’t considering options that could
ing restricted for decades have ownership interest in a include exiting their joint ven- promote American jobs, ac-
from operating freely in China, pledge to open up the sector. Moody’s, S&P and Fitch re- domestic ratings firm but has tures and setting up their own cording to U.S. business
Moody’s, S&P and smaller ri- The deeper dilemma for the serve for only the safest and a partnership with Shanghai China subsidiaries, or boosting groups. In pushing for deals,
val Fitch Ratings now have a U.S. raters is whether they can most financially sound compa- Brilliance Credit Rating & In- their presence under the cur- some executives with these
path to start offering credit- be successful in a country nies. vestors Service Co. and rent structures, people famil- groups are concerned that Bei-
rating services in the country where most bond issuers, Bond defaults in China’s $9 mostly provides help with iar with the matter said. jing is deflecting pressure to
under a trade deal Beijing and which pay for credit ratings, trillion debt market are rare, technology and training. Simon Jin, S&P’s president provide greater access to the
Washington struck in May. are used to lofty grades from because many firms are widely The foreign firms don’t for Greater China, said he ex- Chinese market for foreign
When they can actually do so domestic assessors. Among perceived to have some sort of control the joint ventures, pects Chinese regulators, who businesses.
is unclear. The companies the 4,484 corporate bond issu- implicit support from the gov- whose ratings are in some are in talks with the three big Mr. Trump has railed about
need to be licensed to operate ers in China, 3,883, or 87%, ernment, which could step in cases different from the for- firms, to release a framework the trade deficit, which came
on the mainland, and Beijing have a domestic credit rating to backstop issuers that run eign raters’ own assessments. before the end of the year that to $347 billion last year. Over
has made little progress on its of AA or higher, grades that into financial trouble. Trying Last week, Dandong Port would guide how they operate. the past year, Chinese acquisi-
tions of U.S. companies have
come under scrutiny from a
To Leave Wall Street BY ANNAMARIA ANDRIOTIS people familiar with the mat-
ter.
allegations that China pres-
sures U.S. high-tech firms to
turn over intellectual prop-
BY LIZ HOFFMAN nancial-crisis commission. The An Equifax Inc. board com- On July 31, Mr. Kelley erty.
AND WILLIAM LOUCH firm’s memo highlighted the mittee is continuing to exam- emailed Richard Smith, the For China’s sovereign-
central role he played in deal- ine the role of the company’s company’s CEO at the time, to wealth fund, the tie-up with
Craig W. Broderick, a mem- ing with the ramifications of chief legal officer in approving tell him David Webb, chief in- Goldman will help it expand
ber of Goldman Sachs Group the financial crisis, praising share sales by four executives formation officer at the time, its U.S. investments to include
Inc.’s management committee his “sure and steady hand” days after suspicious activity would likely be sharing some more than publicly traded se-
and “deep understanding of
RON SACHS/CNP/ZUMA PRESS
and the firm’s chief risk offi- was discovered in the com- news pertaining to suspicious curities, real estate and pri-
cer, is retiring in January, ac- risk.” pany’s systems, according to activity, according to another vate-equity assets.
cording to an internal memo. A 32-year Goldman vet- people familiar with the mat- person familiar with the mat- With more than $200 bil-
Mr. Broderick is Wall eran—he joined the firm from ter. ter. lion in foreign assets, CIC is
Street’s longest-serving chief Chase Manhattan in 1985 as a That inquiry remains open Mr. Smith has said in writ- casting an eager eye at U.S.
risk officer and held the post credit officer—Mr. Broderick even though the committee, ten testimony that he learned high-tech manufacturing, high-
through most of the financial became the first chief risk of- comprised of independent di- of the suspicious activity on ways, rail lines and other proj-
crisis, during which Goldman, ficer in Goldman’s history to rectors, on Friday issued a re- July 31 in a conversation with ects, looking to generate
while bruised, made out better be appointed to the firm’s port exonerating the execu- Equifax’s ex-CEO Richard Smith Mr. Webb. Messrs. Smith and steady, long-term returns for
than others. He will become a management committee. That tives who sold stock. Three of Webb retired after the breach the fund and acquire the tech-
senior director at the firm move was widely viewed as the four executives sold sales. In addition to his legal was disclosed. nological know-how to help
upon retirement, signaling he marking the ascendancy of around $1.8 million of com- duties, Mr. Kelley was in The board committee is upgrade China’s industrial
won’t be heading to a rival, risk and control functions in pany shares combined. charge of security at Equifax continuing to review the level base. In return, CIC officials
according to the memo re- the wake of the crisis. The share sales were called and the company’s former of information Mr. Kelley had have said the fund can serve
viewed by The Wall Street Earlier this year, he helped into question after Equifax in chief security officer reported at that time, the people added. as a stable source of long-term
Journal. oversee a reorganization early September disclosed that to him. That executive, Susan The executives, after receiving capital for U.S. projects.
Robin Vince will succeed meant to ensure the risk divi- it was the subject of a massive Mauldin, retired after the approval from Mr. Kelley’s of- CIC has complained about
Mr. Broderick effective Jan. 31, sion remains independent from data breach that exposed vital breach disclosure. fice, sold their shares on Aug. what it says is an unfair re-
the memo said. A Goldman the businesses it oversees. personal information of poten- Mr. Kelley is no longer 1 and Aug. 2. view process by the Commit-
veteran who has been at the “People sometimes talk tially 145.5 million Americans. overseeing security, according The board committee re- tee on Foreign Investment in
firm for more than two de- about building an airplane The board committee said to people familiar with the port did say that neither Equi- the U.S. By collaborating with
cades, Mr. Vince is currently while it’s flying,” Mr. Broder- the executives who sold stock, matter. The change occurred fax’s “chief legal officer nor a top Wall Street firm, CIC is
the firm’s treasurer. ick told The Wall Street Jour- including finance chief John after the breach disclosure, his designated preclearance seeking to diminish the
Mr. Vince was named to nal in 2014, speaking about his Gamble, didn’t have knowl- they added. officer had reason to believe” chances its investments will
that position in 2015, succeed- firm’s efforts to revamp its edge of the suspicious activity. Equifax didn’t respond to that the four executives knew be blocked, one of the people
ing Liz Beshel. He is co-chair- oversight and management It added that “none of the four requests to comment. about the security incident familiar with the matter said.
man of the firmwide finance systems. “To me, it feels like executives engaged in insider Neither Mr. Kelley nor Ms. when they submitted their CIC went to Goldman with the
committee and will become a we’re turning a two-engine trading.” Mauldin could be reached to preclearance requests or on idea for the fund, a second
member of the management plane into a four-engine plane But the report didn’t ad- comment. the date of their trades. person said.
committee. in flight.” dress the level of knowledge Equifax became aware of Mr. Kelley himself, though, For Goldman, it may better
Mr. Broderick became Gold- Beth Hammack, Goldman’s John J. Kelley, Equifax’s chief the suspicious activity on its was aware of the suspicious position the New York firm if
man’s chief risk officer in global head of rates trading, legal officer, had about the systems on July 29. Mr. Kelley activity on Equifax’s systems Chinese authorities grant for-
2008 and later testified in will become treasurer in Mr. suspicious activity when his was made aware of this when his office approved the eign firms greater access to
front of the congressional fi- Vince’s stead. office approved the share on July 30, according to the trades, the people said. China’s financial sector.
For personal non-commercial use only. Do not edit or alter. Reproductions not permitted.
To reprint or license content, please contact our reprints and licensing department at +1 800-843-0008 or www.djreprints.com
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Tuesday, November 7, 2017 | B13
Email: heard@wsj.com
HEARD ON THE STREET FINANCIAL ANALYSIS & COMMENTARY WSJ.com/Heard
A Saudi Crackdown Doesn’t Guarantee an Aramco IPO so far. Much of that came
from its 4.9% stake in chip
designer Nvidia.
A sweeping palace crack- so the Saudis, under their as- open the kingdom to lawsuits guarantee U.S. shale drillers The fund’s other invest-
down in the dead of night Mind the Lag sertive leader, will be more related to 9/11. A London list- will sit on their hands as ments seem odd, including a
under the Arabian stars: It is Change from a year earlier likely to carry out production ing would require rule prices move higher. Oil bulls minority stake in Saudi Elec-
the stuff of novels and, ap- cuts. changes to allow smaller free are taking comfort from the tricity Co. It also plans to
parently, oil investors’ 200% Or so the theory goes. floats, and similar time zones falling oil rig count in the build the world’s biggest so-
dreams. U.S. oil rig count Still, Saudi elite politics are a mean it would compete for U.S. But even for nimble U.S. lar power plant in a new city
Oil prices are now up 3% 100 Oil price black box. If this intrigue funds with any listing in Ri- wildcatters, supply adjust- in Saudi Arabia called Neom,
since Thursday’s close. Driv- ushers in a significant period yadh. And in Hong Kong, Chi- ments don’t happen in- which has yet to be built.
ing the action is slowing sup- 0 of instability at the top of nese capital controls mean a stantly. After oil prices began How are such investments
ply growth in the U.S., and a Saudi government, pushing big chunk of mainland cash rebounding in early 2016, the consistent with SoftBank’s
lightning strike against po- through a contentious $2 would be locked out of any U.S. rig count kept falling for aim of leading the “informa-
tential rivals by Saudi crown –100 trillion IPO might prove IPO. Given all this, the king- three to four months more, tion revolution”? Mr. Son’s
prince Mohammed bin Sal- 2007 ’09 ’11 ’13 ’15 ’17 tricky, to say nothing of en- dom has been considering about as long as the current answer: Saudi Arabia “has
man on Saturday night that Sources: Baker Hughes; forcing painful oil-production selling a chunk of Aramco oil rally has lasted so far. great sunshine” and that
left more than 60 Saudi roy- Energy Information Administration (oil price) cuts. privately to deep-pocketed A triumphant crown “without electricity, you
als and other elites in deten- The legal and technical Chinese investors reportedly prince and desultory supply can’t use phones.” That is a
tion, including the former strength, and that makes it barriers to Aramco’s IPO re- including China National Pe- growth in the U.S. next year practical response, but not
head of the country’s Na- more likely the initial public main formidable. President troleum Corp. and Sinopec, would indeed be bullish for one that burnishes his cre-
tional Guard. offering of Saudi Aramco— Donald Trump may have instead. Aramco and for oil—but it is dentials as a tech-investing
Oil markets seem to be in- his pet policy—will go ahead. tweeted in favor of a New Finally, even if Prince Mo- still early days to conclude visionary or gives confidence
terpreting the arrests as a An Aramco float would fly York listing, but Saudi Arabia hammed successfully consoli- that both those chickens are he can solve problems faced
sign of the crown prince’s better if oil prices are high, has long feared that would dates power, there is no hatched. —Nathaniel Taplin by Sprint. —Jacky Wong
MARKETS
MARKETS
Investors Face New Turmoil in Mideast Recent high-profile arrests in Saudi Arabia are raising concerns outside the country’s
borders. Some investors are revisiting their expectations for the prices of crude oil
and domestic stocks, markets in which the kingdom plays a significant role.
Americas
$34.9 trillion Saudi stock market’s total value
in relation to the rest of the world Asia-Pacific
New York Stock Exchange Nasdaq
21.22 9.26 $27.1 trillion
Europe, Africa
and Middle East Japan Shanghai Stock
$19.4 trillion Exchange Exchange
Group 4.92
5.72
Euronext Deutsche SIX
4.34 Boerse AG Swiss
2.18 Exchange
1.68
Rest of
Asia-Pacific
Nasdaq Johan- BME 16.48
Nordic nesburg Spanish
Exchanges Stock Exchanges
London 1.56 Exchange 0.89
Stock Exchange 1.11
Group
4.26
Moscow Rest of
Exchange Europe
0.62 and Africa
Rest of Americas 1.47
4.39
The sharp decline in recent years of the global oil price A yawning fiscal deficit as a result of lower oil prices Risk-sensitive investors pushed up yields
forced changes in the economics of Saudi Arabia, has forced the Saudis to raise revenue by selling Monday for Saudi Arabia’s benchmark bond.
bolstering the case for seeking out foreign investment. bonds and a possible initial offering of the state oil
company, Aramco.
Percentage change since end of 2013 Largest bond deals in emerging markets Saudi Arabia’s benchmark bond due 2046
40% Saudi Arabia (2016) $17.5B 4.6%
Sources: World Federation of Exchanges (market value); FactSet (indexes); WSJ Market Data Group (brent); Dealogic (bond deals); Thomson Reuters (yield) THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
U.S.
BONDS
AGG
INT’L
STOCKS
WHEN INSPIRATION HITS, IEFA
BUILD FOR WHAT’S NEXT.
U.S.
STOCKS
IVV
1. Source: BlackRock and Morningstar, as of 12/31/16. Comparison is between the average Prospectus Net Expense Ratio for the iShares Core Series ETFs (0.08%) and the
average Prospectus Net Expense Ratio of active open-end mutual funds (1.17%) available in the U.S. on 12/31/16. Visit www.iShares.com or www.BlackRock.com to
view a prospectus, which includes investment objectives, risks, fees, expenses and other information that you should read and consider carefully
before investing. Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. Buying and selling shares of ETFs will result in brokerage commissions. TheiShares funds
are distributed by BlackRock Investments, LLC (together with its affiliates, “BlackRock”). © 2017 BlackRock. All rights reserved. iSHARES and BLACKROCK are registered trademarks
of BlackRock. All other marks are the property of their respective owners. 285131