Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Received: 17 November 1998 Abstract Background: Congenital 25/27 eyes (92.6%) after 1 year, in
Revised version received: 8 July 1999 glaucoma is a potentially blinding 15/18 eyes (83.3%) after 2 years, in
Accepted: 8 July 1999 disease that requires surgical therapy. 8/12 (66.7%) eyes after 3 years, in
This paper describes the outcome of 4/8 eyes (50%) after 4 years and in
trabeculotomy in primary congenital 4/4 (100%) eyes after 5 years of fol-
glaucoma. Methods: Thirty-nine low-up. Complications included hy-
eyes of 22 children with congenital potony (three eyes), subchoroidal
glaucoma who underwent trabeculot- bleeding (one eye ), detachment of
omy with or without a simultaneous Descemet’s membrane (one eye) and
trabeculectomy between 1992 and macular pucker (one eye in which la-
1997 were retrospectively analyzed. ter mitomycin C was used). Visual
Results: Mean follow-up was acuity (VA) was tested with various
24.7±17.9 months. A mean of 1.3 op- methods in 35 eyes. VA was within
erations per eye were performed. The the normal nomogram range in
mean IOP at the end of follow-up 12 eyes and below the normal range
(n=39) was 17.7±6.0 mmHg; in in 23 eyes at the end of follow-up.
8 eyes (20.5%) the IOP was >21 Axial length measurements showed
G. Meyer (✉) · F. Grehn mmHg, in 31 eyes (79.5%) it was normalization according to the age
Department of Ophthalmology, ≤21 mmHg. The mean difference be- nomogram in 22 of 35 eyes.
University of Würzburg, tween pretreatment IOP and IOP at Conclusion: This study shows that
Josef-Schneider-Strasse 11,
D-97080 Würzburg, Germany the end of follow-up (n=39) was trabeculotomy is an effective surgical
Fax:+49-931-201-2245 –10.5±9.4 mmHg (–37.2%). Success procedure in congenital glaucoma
D. Schwenn · N. Pfeiffer rates were calculated: IOP was with satisfactory success rates up to
Department of Ophthalmology, ≤21 mmHg in 36/39 eyes (92.3%) 5 years of follow-up.
University of Mainz, Mainz, Germany after 1/2 year of follow-up, in
Complications Number
of eyes
Complications
In our series of 39 eyes the mean IOP at the end of trabeculotomies (mean follow-up 5.6 years). Trabeculot-
follow-up was 17.7±6.0 mmHg. As IOP measurements omy was also successful in four of eight eyes when used
in small children usually have to be done under general as a secondary procedure after a different type of opera-
anesthesia (as in most cases of our series), IOP may be tion had been unsuccessful.
altered by the anesthetics and may be measured too high Luntz [28] obtained a success rate of 90% (26 of 29
(ketamine) or too low (inhalation anesthesia). When IOP operations) after one trabeculotomy (mean follow-up
≤21 mmHg was taken as success criterion, the success 2 years). This study included no patients with Axenfeld-
rates were 92.3% after 1/2 year, 92.6% after 1 year, Rieger syndrome. The study of Quigley [38] described 28
83.3% after 2 years, 66.7% after 3 years, 50% after operations resulting in a success rate of 80% (17 of 22
4 years and 100% after 5 years. When calculating the eyes) with a single trabeculotomy after 1-year follow-up.
success rate at the end of follow-up of all eyes, 79.5% of At a glance the results of most of these authors [22,
eyes fulfilled the above success criterion. When IOP 28, 33] seem to be slightly better than our results. How-
≤21 mmHg plus an IOP drop of ≥20% was used as suc- ever, it has to be considered that in our study cases with
cess criterion, the success rate at the end of follow-up Axenfeld-Rieger syndrome were included. Furthermore,
was 71.8% (28 eyes). We also followed axial length, cor- there was also a Turkish family with four sisters who all
neal diameter and refraction under general anesthesia. had remarkably severe atypical congenital glaucoma,
With IOP ≤21 mmHg, IOP drop of ≥20% and normal- probably of pseudodominant inheritance. The study of
ized axial length growth as combined criterion, the suc- Quigley [38],who also included cases with Axenfeld-
cess rate at the end of follow-up was only 54.5% (18 of Rieger syndrome and other secondary glaucomas, seem
33 eyes). to better correspond to the conditions of our study. All
The latter criterion, however, overestimates the failure eyes with primary glaucoma were successfully treated in
rate, because some eyes tend to develop myopia despite his study.
normalized IOP. The ≥20% IOP drop criterion may also In severe or refractory cases of congenital glaucoma,
lead to overestimation of failures, because many preop- trabeculotomy may be supplemented by trabeculectomy
erative IOP measurements were made under inhalation with or without the use of antimetabolites [2, 7, 15, 30,
anaesthesia, which leads to a considerable artificial de- 31, 41].
crease in IOP, whereas postoperative control measure- We used additional trabeculectomy in cases of Axen-
ments were mostly done in ketamine anaesthesia, which feld-Rieger syndrome, in eyes that had excessive en-
provides normal or raised IOP readings [36]. In contrast largement of the globe and in patients who underwent a
to adult primary open-angle glaucoma the ≤21 mmHg second operation. Racial factors were also an indication
success rate criterion seems appropriate for congenital for combined surgery (in one of the Turkish sisters).
glaucoma, where many of the eyes have not yet devel- 5-fluorouracil was used in one eye during reoperation.
oped optic nerve damage. A surgical problem may occur when the probe is in-
Visual acuity measurements are difficult in congenital troduced in the subciliary space and the ciliary muscle
glaucoma, with a mean presenting age of 15.7 months is erroneously disinserted from the scleral spur. A cyclo-
and a mean follow-up of 24.7 months. Therefore, the fi- dialysis or disinsertion of the iris base instead of trab-
nal rate of amblyopia in these cases cannot be deter- eculotomy then results. This was reported in two of
mined at the present follow-up. McPherson’s cases [33] but occurred in none of our
Trabeculotomy is considered an adequate procedure cases. Moderate bleeding into the anterior chamber is a
in congenital glaucoma by many other surgeons [22, 28, regular event in correct trabeculotomy due to reflux of
29]. A number of articles on trabeculotomy have been blood from Schlemm’s canal, which is a continuation of
published during the past decades in primary and sec- episcleral veins. If the IOP drops to below the episcleral
ondary congenital glaucoma [1, 5, 11, 12, 14, 22, 26, 28, venous pressure during the procedure, blood flows back
34, 38–41] and in adults [8, 10, 16, 23–25, 44–46]. into Schlemm’s canal and enters the anterior chamber
Harms and Dannheim [22] found a postoperative IOP through the trabeculotomy site due to the lack of venous
≤22 mmHg more than 3 months after uncomplicated pri- valves.
mary trabeculotomy in all of 18 eyes with primary con- Detachment of Descemet’s membrane is also one of
genital glaucoma and in 4 of 7 eyes which either had the possible complications of trabeculotomy and oc-
secondary congenital glaucoma or had already under- curred in one of our cases. Quigley [38] reported two
gone other types of antiglaucomatous operations. cases of Descemet detachment. Prolapse of the iris oc-
Authors of other studies analyzed eyes with Axen- curred in nine cases of the series of Luntz [28]. Howev-
feld-Rieger syndrome separately from eyes with primary er, no prolapse of the iris was seen in our series. Postop-
congenital glaucomas. In the study of McPherson and erative subchoroidal bleeding (one operation) and hypot-
Berry [33], 19 of 23 eyes (83%) were controlled (IOP ony with transient shallowing of the anterior chamber
<21 mmHg) with one primary trabeculotomy and 22 of (two operations) or with choroidal detachment (one op-
23 eyes (96%) were controlled with up to three eration) occurred in our series (see Table 3).
212
Comparison between trabeculotomy and goniotomy cornea or lens is low and the operation can even be
has shown equal efficacy of both procedures in congeni- done in cases where the cornea is cloudy [3]. The tra-
tal glaucoma [5, 33]. becular meshwork can be cleaved reliably if the trabec-
A comparison of the two techniques in similar groups ulotomy probe is correctly introduced into Schlemm’s
of patients with congenital glaucoma was made by canal. In contrast, goniotomy may incise various struc-
McPherson and Berry [33]. Both types of operation re- tures of the chamber angle, as has been shown by his-
sulted in a similar lowering of IOP, although a higher tology [27]. In goniotomy it may be helpful to remove
number of operations per eye were performed in goniot- the corneal epithelium in cases of corneal cloudiness
omy eyes (2.6 operations) than in trabeculotomy eyes [13].
(1.6 operations). In the study of Anderson [5] the first On the other hand, some authors emphasize that
eye was randomly assigned to either goniotomy or goniotomy, due to its transcorneal access does not dam-
trabeculotomy and the other eye to the other procedure. age the conjunctiva and sclera [19]. This is of impor-
If the IOP was controlled in the first eye, it was also con- tance if filtration surgery later becomes necessary.
trolled in the fellow eye by the other operation. If, how- Miller and Rice [37] showed that previous surgery in-
ever, either goniotomy or trabeculotomy was unsuccess- volving the conjunctiva significantly increased the risk
ful in the first eye, the other eye also failed after the oth- of failure of trabeculectomy in congenital glaucoma.
er operation. This is a strong argument for the proposi- On the other hand, Akimoto et al. [3] emphazise that
tion that the individual situation of the glaucoma influ- the area of conjunctiva involved in trabeculotomy is so
ences the outcome more than does the type of operation. small that trabeculectomy can easily be performed sub-
On the other hand, comparisons also depend largely on sequently.
the individual experience of the surgeon with one or the In a modified technique trabeculotomy can be done
other procedure. over 360°. In this technique a thread is placed into
In our own retrospective study of goniotomy with a Schlemm’s canal. By pulling the suture into the anterior
mean follow-up of 51.6 months, the success rate at the chamber Schlemm’s canal is opened over 360°. The
end of follow-up of all eyes was 70.6% according to the study of Beck and Lynch [6] shows success in 87%
IOP criteria used in the present study and 59.4% if nor- (13 of 15) of the eyes that underwent surgery by this
malization of axial length growth was also a criterion technique, whereas the report of four cases by Gloor
[35]. showed a high rate of complications [17].
A clinical study of patients who underwent gonioto- Our study shows that trabeculotomy is an effective
my for primary congenital glaucoma at the University surgical technique for the treatment of congenital glau-
Eye Hospital Würzburg in the period from 1965 to 1983 coma. However, it must be emphasized that adequate
[18] focussed particularly on the visual outcome after follow-up examinations have to be done, especially in
goniotomy. After a mean follow-up of 11 years (3–28 cases of unilateral congenital glaucoma, where the risk
years), visual acuity was ≥0.4 in over 50% of 60 eyes of amblyopia and anisometropia is a major problem.
and the visual field was normal in 74.3% of 35 eyes. Regular orthoptic examinations are therefore mandatory,
The main advantage of trabeculotomy is the external and patching should be started if necessary.
microsurgical approach. Thus the risk of injuring the
References
1. Adachi M, Dickens CJ, Hetherington J 4. Allen L, Burian HM (1962) Trabeculo- 9. Burian HM (1962) A case of Marfan’s
Jr, Hoskins HD, Iwach AG, Wong PC, tomy ab externo. Am J Ophthalmol syndrome with bilateral glaucoma:
Nguyen N, Ma AS (1997) Clinical ex- 53:19–26 with description of a new type of oper-
perience of trabeculotomy for the sur- 5. Anderson DR (1983) Trabeculotomy ation for developmental glaucoma
gical treatment of aniridic glaucoma. compared to goniotomy for glaucoma in (trabeculotomy ab externo). Am J
Ophthalmology 104:2121–2125 children. Ophthalmology 90:805–806 Ophthalmol 50:1187–1192
2. Agarwal HC, Sood NN, Sihota R, 6. Beck AD, Lynch MG (1995) 360 de- 10. Chihara E, Nishida A, Kodo M,
Sanga L, Honavar SG (1997) Mito- grees trabeculotomy for primary con- Yoshimura M, Matsumura M,
mycin-C in congenital glaucoma. Oph- genital glaucoma. Arch Ophthalmol Yamamoto M, Tsukada T (1993)
thalmic Surg Lasers 28:979–985 113:1200–1202 Trabeculotomy ab externo: an alterna-
3. Akimoto M, Tanihara H, Negi A, 7. Biedner BZ, Rothkoff L (1998) Com- tive treatment in adult patients with
Nagata M (1994) Surgical results of bined trabeculotomy-trabeculectomy primary open-angle glaucoma. Oph-
trabeculotomy ab externo for develop- compared with primary trabeculotomy thalmic Surg 24:735–739
mental glaucoma. Arch Ophthalmol for congenital glaucoma. J Pediatr
112:1540–1544 Ophthalmol Strabismus 35:49–50
8. Bloomberg LB (1996) Modified
trabeculectomy/trabeculotomy with no-
stitch cataract surgery. J Cataract Re-
fract Surg 22:14–22
213
11. Dannheim R, Haas H (1980) Seh- 24. Honjo M, Tanihara M, Negi A, Hangai 36. Meyer G, Haigis W, Lieb W (1997)
schärfe und Druckverhalten nach Ope- M, Taniguchi T, Honda Y, Mizoguchi Ultrasonographic biometry in congeni-
ration wegen kongenitalen Glaukoms. T, Matsumura M, Nagata M (1996) tal glaucoma. Invest Ophthalmol Vis
Klin Monatsbl Augenheilkd Trabeculotomy ab externo, cataract ex- Sci 38:S1068
177:296–303 traction, and intraocular lens implanta- 37. Miller MH, Rice NSC (1991) Trabec-
12. Dascotte JC, Asseman R, Francois P, tion: preliminary report. J Cataract Re- ulotomy combined with beta irradia-
Houliez T, Huron JC, Castier P, fract Surg 22:601–606 tion for congenital glaucoma. Br
Rouland JF (1991) Traitement chirur- 25. Honjo M, Tanihara M, Inatani M, J Ophthalmol 75:584–590
gical du glaucome congenital. Resul- Honda Y, Ogino N, Ueno S, Negi A, 38. Quigley HA (1982) Childhood glauco-
tats a long terme. J Fr Ophthalmol Ichioka H, Mizoguchi T, Matsumura ma: results with trabeculotomy and
14:229–233 M, Nagata M (1998) Phacoemulsifica- study of reversible cupping. Ophthal-
13. De Luise VP, Anderson DR (1983) Pri- tion, intraocular lens implantation, and mology 89:219–226
mary infantile glaucoma (congenital trabeculotomy to treat pseudoexfolia- 39. Sampaloesi R (1987) Congenital glau-
glaucoma). Surv Ophthalmol 28:1–19 tion syndrome. J Cataract Refract Surg coma: long-term results of surgery.
14. Detry-Morel M, Feron EM (1996) 24:781–786 Dev Ophthalmol 14:166–176
Trabeculectomy in congenital glauco- 26. Hoskins HD, Shaffer RN, Hetherington 40. Sampaolesi R (1987) Congenital glau-
ma: retrospective medium and long- J (1984) Goniotomy vs trabeculotomy. coma: Long-term results of surgery.
term results. Bull Soc Belge Opthalmol J Pediatr Ophthalmol Strabismus Glaucoma update III. Springer, New
262:143–151 21:153–158 York, pp 154–161
15. Elder MJ (1994) Combined trabeculot- 27. Lütjen-Drecoll E, Draeger J, Rohen JW 41. Sampaolesi R (1988) Congenital glau-
omy-trabeculectomy compared with (1972) Histologische Untersuchungen coma: long-term results after surgery.
primary trabeculectomy for congenital über die strukturellen Veränderungen Fortschr Ophthalmol 85:626–631
glaucoma. Br J Ophthalmol in der Kammerwinkelregion nach 42. Smith R (1960) A new technique for
78:745–748 mikrochirurgischen Glaukomopera- opening the canal of Schlemm. Br
16. Gimbel HV, Meyer D (1993) Small in- tionen. Klin Monatsbl Augenheilkd J Ophthalmol 44:370–373
cision trabeculotomy combined with 160:281–292 43. Smith R (1969) The comparison be-
phacoemulsification and intraocular 28. Luntz MH (1974) Primärbuphthalmus tween a group of drainage operations
lens implantation. J Cataract Refract (kindliches Glaukom)-behandelt durch and trabeculotomy, after a follow-up of
Surg 19:92–96 Trabekulotomie ab externo. Klin five years. Trans Ophathalmol Soc UK
17. Gloor BR (1998) Risks of 360 degree Monatsbl Augenheilkd 165:554–564 89:511–518
suture trabeculotomy. Ophthalmologe 29. Mackensen G, Harms H (1989) Chirur- 44. Tanihara H, Honjo M, Inatani M,
95:100–103 gie der Glaukome. In: Mackensen G, Honda Y, Ogino N, Ueno S, Negi A,
18. Gramer E, Tausch M, Kraemer C Neubauer H (eds) Augenärztliche Ope- Ichioka H, Mizoguchi T, Matsumura
(1996) Time of diagnosis, reoperations rationen, vol 2. Springer, Berlin Heidel- M, Nagata M (1997) Trabeculotomy
and long-term results of goniotomy in berg New York, p 158 combined with phacoemulsification
the treatment of primary congenital 30. Mandal AK, Naduvilath TJ, and implantation of an intraocular lens
glaucoma: a clinical study. Int Jayagandan A (1998) Surgical results for the treatment of primary open-angle
Ophthalmol 20:117–123 of combined trabeculotomy-trabeculec- glaucoma and coexisting cataract. Oph-
19. Grehn F (1990) Chirurgische tomy for developmental glaucoma. thalmic Surg Lasers 28:810–817
Glaukomtherapie. Fortschr Ophthalmol Ophthalmology 105:974–982 45. Tanihara H, Negi A, Akimoto M,
87 [Suppl]:175–186 31. Mandal AK, Walton DS, John T, Terauchi H, Okudaira A, Kozaki J,
20. Grehn F (1995) The value of trabeculo- Jayagandan A (1997) Mitomycin C- Takeuchi A, Nagata M (1993) Surgical
tomy in glaucoma surgery. Curr Opin augmented trabeculectomy in refracto- effects of trabeculotomy ab externo on
Ophthalmol 6:52–60 ry congenital glaucoma. Ophthalmolo- adult eyes with primary open angle
21. Harms H (1966) Glaukomoperationen gy 104:996–1001 glaucoma and pseudoexfoliation syn-
am Schlemm’schen Kanal. Ber Vers 32. McPherson SD Jr (1973) Results of ex- drome. Arch Ophthalmol
Ver Rhein-Westf Augenärzte ternal trabeculotomy. Am J Ophthalm- 111:1653–1661
994:93–100 ol 76:918–920 46. Wada Y, Nakatsu A, Kondo T (1994)
22. Harms H, Dannheim R (1969) Erfah- 33. McPherson SD Jr, Berry DP (1983) Long-term results of trabeculotomy
rungen mit der Trabeculotomia ab Goniotomy vs external trabeculotomy ab externo. Ophthalmic Surg
externo beim angeborenen Glaukom. for developmental glaucoma. Am J 25:317–320
Ber Dtsch Ophthalmol Ges 69:272–276 Ophthalmol 95:427–431
23. Harms H, Dannheim R (1987) Glau- 34. Meyer G, Grehn F (1998) Die chir-
komoperationen bei offenem Kammer- urgische Therapie des kongenitalen
winkel: Trabeculotomie. Fortschr Glaukoms. Search on Glaucoma 6 :8–14
Ophthalmol 84 [Suppl 1]:148–177 35. Meyer G, Grehn F (1998) Goniotomy
in congenital glaucoma.
URL:http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00417
98c0072
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.