Sie sind auf Seite 1von 9

Ageing phenomena of cellulose/oil

insulation in natural ester and mineral oil

C. Perrier*, M-L. Coulibaly, (Alstom Grid - France)


J. Lukic, V. Vasovic, (Institute Nikola Tesla - Serbia)

Abstract
Degradation of electrical insulation due to ageing by were performed using copper, paper, pressboard and
combination of thermal, oxidative and hydrolytic processes insulating oils in proportions close to real design. Hermetic
is one of the main factors that affect power transformer systems were used and oxygen content in the oil was
service life. A better understanding of ageing phenomena is adjusted to simulate conditions of sealed transformers
of great importance for transformer condition assessment. (not free breathing). It was found that in conditions of
This enables reliable operation and affords application of particular ageing test, thermal degradation, i.e. oil pyrolysis
adequate mitigation action to slow down the degradation was dominant degradation mechanism, while oxidation
process of insulating materials and extend transformer and hydrolysis were minor processes. This was confirmed
service life. This issue is all the more important when by low to moderate rate of antioxidants depletion in
new insulating liquids as natural esters are being applied both, natural ester and inhibited mineral oil. Stability and
in growing number in transformer industry. For these performance of natural ester were found to be very good,
reasons, this paper is focused on the ageing phenomena of especially regarding the impact on solid insulation. Indeed,
cellulosic materials (paper and pressboard) impregnated degradation of solid insulation was present at lowest rate, in
with different insulating liquids as natural ester, inhibited comparison with mineral oils, on the basis of highest degree
and uninhibited mineral oils. of polymerization values at the end of ageing.

A first part is dedicated to moisture equilibrium in


impregnated paper and pressboard systems in order to give 1. Introduction
some guidelines on the evaluation of cellulose humidity
through the oil. Moisture equilibrium isotherms were created Power transformers are one of the vital and expensive
for temperatures from 40 to 120°C and for water content elements in the industry of electrical energy, having
in paper and pressboard from 0.5 to 5%. Differences in essential functions in power transmission and generation.
distribution of water within cellulose/oil insulation between Although transformers are very reliable devices, there
natural ester and mineral oil were observed and discussed. remains one inevitable type of failure called “end of life”
Natural esters have higher water solubility and therefore, for failure mode. Most, if not all, organic materials used within
the same water content in cellulose, at same temperature, the transformer are subject to aging processes which lead
water content in the oil was considerably higher in natural to the gradual degradation of their physical, chemical and
ester oil than in mineral oil. It was also found that water electrical properties. The most important of these organic
distribution between paper and pressboard in mineral and materials is the composite insulation system, i.e. cellulosic
ester oils is quite different. Established isotherms constitute materials (mainly paper and pressboard) impregnated with
a useful tool for the condition assessment of green power insulating liquid (mainly mineral and ester oils). Three
transformers [1]. main processes drive the aging of cellulose/oil insulation
systems. First one, pyrolysis is initiated by the temperature
A second part is dedicated to thermal ageing at 140°C up to as the main driving force behind the chemical reactions that
120 days in order to evaluate ageing profile and long term cause ageing. The other processes are hydrolysis, initiated
stability of different oils and solids. Ageing experiments by the presence od water and oxidation, initiated by the

*christophe.perrier@alstom.com

KEYWORDS
Cellulosic insulation, Mineral oil, Moisture equilibrium, Natural ester, Thermal ageing

Cigre Science & Engineering • N°1 February 2015


6
presence of oxygen. Water is also recognized as the “enemy Since the cellulose insulation is more hygroscopic than the
number one” of liquid-filled transformers [2] because it oil it contains most of the water in paper/oil system and can
has detrimental effect to the dielectric properties of the constitute several percentages by weight of the total mass of
insulation system as well as its mechanical characteristics. solid insulation.
The mechanical life of the transformer insulation is halved
for each doubling in the water content [3]. In order to avoid premature degradation of the cellulosic
insulation, the water must be kept to a minimum value.
Although the end of life failure is inevitable, the life of the In a new transformer, the water content of the cellulose is
cellulose can be maximized through careful monitoring about 0.5% and is expected to gradually increase during
and maintenance. Proper condition monitoring of ageing the life of the transformer. Since it is not possible to remove
parameters for evaluation of the condition of insulation paper samples from the active windings of a transformer
system can improve replacement planning in order to under operation and measure water content of the paper,
avoid the consequences of a sudden and untimely failure of indirect measurements were developed as the assessment
transformer. End of life of cellulose insulation is determined through the oil humidity (chemical method), or dielectric
by the mechanical strength and best measurement to assess response measurements [5]. The chemical method is
this property is the degree of polymerization (DPv). From based on moisture partitioning curves between oil and
literature data, end of life is reached when DPv is below 250, paper under equilibrium conditions. Various researchers
this being the minimum strength considered necessary to had experimentally derived moisture equilibrium charts
withstand a short circuit. Since it is not possible to monitor showing moisture in cellulose insulation versus water
DPv values of transformers in service, laboratory models content in mineral oil [6, 7, 8]. It is generally not known
simulating ageing of paper/oil insulation in accelerated if the equilibrium curves were obtained from experiments
conditions enables a feasible way to analyze the effect of using paper and pressboard insulation in mass ratios
different oils and key ageing parameters: temperature, corresponding to actual ratios in transformers, and how
oxygen and water on cellulose ageing kinetics. the water is distributed between the paper and pressboard
insulation. In addition, due to increased applications of
With the growing interest to use alternative liquids as natural ester oils in transformers, moisture equilibrium
insulating fluids, such as natural esters (vegetable oils) charts become necessary tool to evaluate water content
instead of mineral oils, for some transformer applications, in insulation systems impregnated with natural ester
it becomes important to evaluate the applicability of current insulating liquids.
monitoring techniques and test methods for evaluation of
cellulosic insulation condition. For this reason, this paper 2.2 Experimental study
will be focused in a first part on experimental studies
related to humidity equilibrium curves and in a second part Moisture equilibrium charts were created for conventional
on ageing stability of composite oil/cellulose system. Kraft paper and pressboard immersed in mineral insulating
oil and natural ester oil. Oil, paper and pressboard
were heated in 50 ml sealed vials with butyl septa at the
2. Moisture equilibrium specified temperature. After reaching equilibrium, direct
measurements of moisture in the oil, paper and pressboard
isotherms were performed by Karl-Fisher titration. Moisture
2.1 Condition assessment equilibrium isotherms were created for temperatures from
40 to 120OC and for water content in paper and pressboard
Moisture in oil/cellulose insulation can affect the life of from 0.5 to 5 %.
transformers by leading to significant reductions in both
dielectric and mechanical properties. More precisely, water 2.2.1 Test conditions
increases the ageing rate and the dielectric losses, reduces
dielectric breakdown and mechanical strength and also Oil, paper, and pressboard (see table 1) were taken in
can introduce the risk of bubble formation during overload specified mass ratios (90% of oil, 4% of paper and 6% of
[4]. Water is one of the degradation products of cellulosic pressboard), corresponding to approximate mass ratios in
materials, but major amount of water in cellulose materials actual power transformers. To achieve the initial low water
is present due to moisture ingress from outside and retained content, the paper and pressboard samples were dried and
water in the solid insulation after manufacturing process. filtered under vacuum oven. This procedure was followed

Cigre Science & Engineering • N°1 February 2015


7
Materials Type Standard
Mineral oil Naphtenic, non inhibited IEC 60296
Natural ester Triester, inhibited IEC 62770
Paper Thickness 0.25mm, Density 1.2-1.3 g/cm3 IEC 60641-3-2
Pressboard Thickness 1mm, Density 1-1.2 g/cm3 IEC 60641-3-1

Table 1: Tested materials

by impregnation with dried and degassed oil, for 24 h, at in an oven at specified temperatures between 40 and 120
700C for mineral oil and 90°C for ester oil. The water content 0
C and for an equilibration time that was taken from the
in the mineral oil and ester oil used for impregnation was literature, taking into consideration the material type and
respectively up to 5 ppm and 30 ppm, and the oxygen thickness, which was extended slightly to verify the state of
level in the oils was kept below 10000 ppm. The moisture equilibrium [10-11]. The moisture levels were considered
contents of paper, pressboard, and the insulating liquids as reached when last three measurements matched closely.
were analyzed by the test method described in IEC 60814. All preparation procedures were made in a glove box with
argon atmosphere.
Initial water contents in the paper and pressboard at
selected moisture levels of 0.5 to 5.0 %, were achieved by Different equilibrium times obtained for each oil with paper
placing the impregnated specimens in a wet chamber for and pressboard, are presented on figure 1. Equilibrium was
certain time at specified temperature and humidity [4, 9]. reached at longer times for low temperatures as well as for
Prepared oils, paper, and pressboard specimens were placed low moisture contents. For the same moisture level and the
together in 50 ml vials crimped with butyl septa, leaving same temperature, equilibration time was longer with ester
the air space above the oil level. Then, they were heated oil, taking into consideration higher viscosity of ester oil.

Figure 1: Equilibrium times as a function of temperature and water content in the paper
and pressboard samples impregnated with mineral oil and natural ester

Cigre Science & Engineering • N°1 February 2015


8
2.2.2 Experimental results

The developed charts are referred to in this article as


the “Perrier-Lukic” equilibrium curves. Comparative
analyses of the moisture distribution between cellulose,
natural ester and mineral oil are presented for absolute
moisture content. Note that calculation of the total
moisture content in paper and pressboard, together, was
done using the following equation:

Figure 2: Perrier-Lukic equilibrium curves for paper/pressboard


in mineral and natural ester oils
Where Wcc is the total moisture content in the cellulose
materials (%mass), Wcpaper is the moisture content in the
paper (%mass), mpaper is the mass of the paper (g), Wcpress
is the moisture content in the pressboard (% mass) and
mpress is the mass of the pressboard (g).

Due to the higher solubility of moisture in natural ester


compared to mineral oil, the moisture equilibrium
curves are significantly moved on the right with natural
ester oil (figure 2). Therefore, for the same moisture
content in the cellulosic materials, the expected water
content in natural ester oil is significantly higher than
in mineral oil. For example, for equilibrium at 60OC,
and 3 % water in cellulosic insulation, water content
in natural ester oil is around 10 times higher than in
mineral oil.

Separate equilibrium curves for paper, pressboard,


paper and pressboard together, in both oil types are Figure 3: Perrier-Lukic equilibrium curves for paper and
presented in Figures 3 and 4. Distribution of humidity pressboard in mineral oil
between paper and pressboard in mineral oil is relatively
equivalent, whereas uneven distribution, i.e. lower water
contents in pressboard and higher water contents in the
paper were obtained in ester oil. The observed differences
with moisture distribution paper and pressboard
impregnated with natural esters can have an important
role in estimating the moisture content in transformer
insulation based on electrical measurements (FDS).
Indeed, the estimated moisture in the paper can be
underestimated. The use of equilibrium charts for paper
and pressboard together enables greater precision in
estimating the moisture content and likely closer to those
expected from electrical tests. This is why these curves
are even more important, as they can be used to evaluate
water content in the paper and pressboard separately, as
well as to evaluate cumulative moisture content in both
cellulosic materials.
Figure 4: Perrier-Lukic equilibrium curves for paper and
pressboard in natural ester

Cigre Science & Engineering • N°1 February 2015


9
3. Ageing stability With the emergence of new insulating liquids as natural
3.1 Ageing of transformer insulation ester, a comparative ageing study versus mineral oil was done
at laboratory scale under accelerated ageing conditions.
The exact life of a transformer is not a fixed period and
depends on many factors. These factors include the operating 3.2 Experimental study
and maintenance regime, the characteristics of the network,
and to a certain extent, the design and materials used. Oil, copper, paper and pressboard were aged in 50 ml
Experiences show that heavily loaded transformers have a headspace vials, crimped with silicone septa, and with
lifespan of 20-25years, and less heavily loaded transformers restricted oxygen ingress (initial oxygen content < 10
can last 40-60 years and even longer [12]. In this paper, we 000 ppm). The aim of this test set-up is to simulate sealed
are only focused on the ageing performance of insulating transformer conditions as it is requested for the use of natural
materials. esters. The test temperature was chosen at 140°C (for 120
days) to simulate an accelerated ageing. Indeed, based on
Temperature, water and oxygen are three main factors Arrhenius law and IEC 60076-7 standard (loading guide),
affecting the ageing of the cellulose/oil insulation system. 120 days at 140°C are equivalent to around 40 years at 98°C.
The critical parameter is temperature, with heat energy
being the main driving force behind the chemical reactions 3.2.1 Test conditions
that cause ageing. The presence of oxygen is particularly
detrimental to ageing of transformer oil, while the presence Cellulose materials have been dried in deep vacuum at
of water predominately speeds up ageing of solid insulation 60°C during 24h and immediately thereafter impregnated
by causing a cleavage of cellulose macromolecule chain. with respective dried and degassed oil during 48 h at 90
Water is also the main factor which affects the dielectric °C in deep vacuum. Water content of mineral oils used for
strength of the insulation system. impregnation was around 5ppm and 25ppm for natural
ester oil. Initial water content in kraft paper and pressboard
The most critical aspect of the ageing process of solid was around 0.5%. All materials (table 2) were taken in mass
insulation is reduction of its mechanical strength. Once and surface ratios close to real design: paper/oil mass ratio:
the cellulose has fallen below a critical level of mechanical 4 %, pressboard/oil mass ratio: 6 % and copper /oil mass
strength, the transformer is at risk from the mechanical ratio: 30%. For each oil, independent vials were heated at
forces arising under short circuit or even during normal 140°C during different periods: 10, 20, 40, 60, 100 and 120
operation. days. For each period, duplicate vials were used for heating
oil alone (“I exp”) and for heating oil in presence of paper,
Acids produced during oil ageing can increase paper pressboard and bare copper (“II exp”).
degradation and attack metallic parts in the transformer.
Decomposition products (from cellulose and oil itself) will Prior and after ageing, following measurements were
increase the concentration of polar compounds and cause performed: water content in oil and cellulose (IEC 60814),
the increase of dielectric dissipation factor. Sludge, as end 2-FAL content (IEC 61198), degree of polymerization (IEC
product of oil ageing, can be deposited on the windings and 60450), viscosity at 40OC (ISO 3104), pour point (ISO 3016),
decreases heat transfer by blocking cooling ducts. acidity (IEC 62021) and antioxidants content (IEC 60666).

Materials Type Standard


Mineral oil
Naphtenic, inhibited, high grade IEC 60296
(MOHG)
Mineral oil (MOSG) Naphtenic, non inhibited IEC 60296
Natural ester (VOR) Triester, inhibited IEC 62770
Paper Thickness 0.25mm, Density 1.2-1.3 g/cm3 IEC 60641-3-2
Pressboard Thickness 1mm, Density 1-1.2 g/cm3 IEC 60641-3-1
Table 2: Tested materials

Cigre Science & Engineering • N°1 February 2015


10
Figure 5: Evolution of acidity (left) and humidity (right) in mineral oils and natural ester

3.2.2 Experimental results studies [13, 14]. These acids seem not to be aggressive for
solid insulation and should be of high molecular nature,
Note that for all graphics, “I exp” means results on oil alone since they do not degrade cellulose insulation significantly
and “II exp” means results on oil in presence of paper, [15], as shown on figure 7.
pressboard and copper. As shown on figure 5, increase
of water content in the oil was significant after 10 days Consumption of detected antioxidants (figure 6) is more
of ageing in all investigated oils, but then decrease was pronounced in mineral oil (MOHG) than in natural ester
observed in all ageing periods for both oils. This peak was (VOR). This can be explained by higher thermal stability
the consequence of water migration from cellulose materials of ester oil and the fact that high temperature-low oxygen
into the oil. Water content in the cellulose decreased over testing conditions suited better for ester oil. Nevertheless,
whole ageing period in both oils. The increase and decrease the level of additive at the end of ageing in mineral oil
of water was more significant in ester oil VOR, (oil with still remained acceptable (IEC 60422). Low to acceptable
paper, pressboard and copper), due to higher rate of water decrease of inhibitor content can be explained by low
migration from cellulose materials to ester oil which has concentration of oxygen and reduced oxidation process
higher water solubility. Important increase of acidity in during ageing. These results are quite encouraging for
ester oil (figure 5) is correlated with water consumption and the use of natural ester in power transformers in sealed
can be explained by hydrolysis reaction, as shown by other applications.

Figure 6: Inhibitor consumption (left) and 2-FAL evolution (right) in mineral oils and natural ester

Cigre Science & Engineering • N°1 February 2015


11
Figure 7: Evolution of degree of polymerization (DPv) of pressboard (left) and paper (right)

Degradation of paper and pressboard aged with ester Kinematic viscosity of mineral oils did not change during
oil (VOR) was observed to be of slightly lower rate in whole period of ageing whereas small increase was detected
comparison to mineral oils (figure 7). Higher values of with ester oil (figure 8). This increase remains acceptable
degree of polymerization can be correlated to lower 2-FAL in comparison with previous studies under higher oxygen
values (figure 6), and this was observed in other studies concentration [17], thus confirming the possibility of using
[16]. natural ester oil in sealed units. Note that, pour point of all
three oils was not affected during whole period of ageing.
However, the difference in 2-FAL values between oil seemed
to be more significant than the difference between DP
values. This may be attributed to lower solubility of furans 4. Conclusion
in ester oil than in mineral oil. It was interested to observe
that after 120 days of ageing at 140ºC, paper and pressboard Moisture distribution between cellulose materials (paper
reached end of life in both mineral oils, with negligible and pressboard) and insulating oils (mineral and natural
difference in respect to different oil quality and presence of ester) have shown that natural ester oil has higher capacity
antioxidant in inhibited oil. to dissolve water comparing to mineral oils, as chemical

Figure 8: Evolution of oil viscosity (left) and pour point (right) in mineral oil and natural ester

Cigre Science & Engineering • N°1 February 2015


12
composition of natural ester is more polar nature. Moisture with natural ester oil. Acidity of natural ester oil increased
equilibrium in natural ester oil is moved towards the oil, significantly during ageing and it seems that some amount
more water is dissolved in the oil in comparison with of water in the oil was spent in hydrolysis reactions and
mineral oil, at the same temperature and water content formation of fatty acids. However, solid insulation was not
in the paper. Uneven distribution of water between paper degraded significantly in the presence of high acid content.
and pressboard was observed in ester oil, lower values were It seems that chemical composition of acids is more
measured in pressboard and higher water contents in the important than its total amount. Behavior of mineral oils
paper. This may cause underestimation of water content in related to paper ageing was similar regardless of difference
the paper when evaluation is done using electrical methods in oil quality and presence of antioxidant in inhibited
(FDS, RVM, PDC). The use of equilibrium charts for paper mineral oil. Flow properties were acceptable at the end of
and pressboard separately and together enables greater ageing for mineral oils and also for ester oil with acceptable
precision in estimating the moisture content in insulation viscosity increase of 15% from the initial value.
system, especially for natural ester.
Achieved results related to ageing of solid insulation and
Ageing mechanism was predominantly pyrolytic (low natural esters are quite encouraging for the use of natural
oxygen, at 140ºC) and was found to have more significant ester in power transformers in low oxygen environment
impact on degradation of solid insulation impregnated (sealed units).
with mineral insulating oils than on solid insulation filled

References
[1] H. Fink, F. Devaux, B. Dolata, C. Perrier, “New and innovative Smart and green transformer technologies”, CIRED conference, 6-9 June, 2011.
[2] A. Sierota, J. Rungis, “Electrical insulating oils-Part 1: characterization and pre-treatment of new transformers oils”, IEEE Electrical Insulation Magazine,
Vol. 11, No. 1, pp. 8-20, 1995.
[3] Y. Du, M. Zahn, B. C. Lesieutre, A. Mamishev, S. R. Lindgren, “Moisture equilibrium in transformer paper-oil Systems”, IEEE Elec. Insul. Mag., Vol. 15,
No. 1, pp. 11-20, 1999.
[4] Cigre brochure n°323, “Ageing of cellulose in mineral-oil insulated transformers”, Oct. 2007.
[5] Cigre brochure n°414, “Dielectric response diagnoses for tra,nsformer windings”, April 2010.
[6] J. Fabre, A. Pichon, “Deterioratiion processes and products of paper in oil”, Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Large Electric Systems,
p.137, 1960
[7] T. V. Oommen, “Moisture equilibrium in paper-oil system”, Electrical Electronics Conference, Chicago, October 1983.
[8] P. J. Griffin, C. M. Bruce, J. D. Christie, “Comparison of water equilibrium in silicone and mineral oil transformers”, Minutes of the fifty-fith annual
International conference of Doble clients, Sec. 10-9.1, 1988.
[9] CIGRE brochure n°349, “Moiture equilibrium and moisture migration within transformer insulation systems”, June 2008.
[10] L. J. Zhou, “Modeling of transient moisture equilibrium in Oil-Paper Insulation”, IEEE TDEI Vol. 15, No. 3, pp. 873-878, 2008.
[11] J. A. Thompson, “Transformer paper in oil water diffusion time constant”, presented at the IEEE Insulating fluids Subcommittee, C 57.106 WG, Apr.
2002.
[12] Areva T&D book, “Power transformers – Vol. 2 – Expertise”, August 2008.
[13] H. P. Gasser, C. Krause, M. Lashbrook and R. Martin, “Aging of pressboard in different insulating liquids”, ICDL conference, 26-30 June, 2011.
[14] M-L. Coulibaly, C. Perrier, M. Marugan and A. Beroual, ‘‘Aging behavior of cellulosic materials in presence of mineral oil and ester liquids under various
conditions”, IEEE TDEI, Vol. 20, No. 6, pp. 1972-1976, December, 2013.
[15] L. Lundgaard & al., “Aging of Kraft paper by acid catalyzed hydrolysis”, IEEE TDEI, Vol. 15, No. 2, pp. 540-546, 2008.
[16] M. A. G. Martins, “Vegetable oils, an alternative to mineral oil for power transformers – experimental study of paper aging in vegetable oil versus mineral
oil” IEEE Mag., Vol. 26, No. 6, pp. 7-13, November/December, 2010.
[17] C. Perrier and A. Beroual, ‘‘Experimental Investigations on Insulating Liquids for Power Transformers: Mineral, Ester, and Silicone Oils”, IEEE Elec. Insul.
Mag., Vol. 25, No. 6, pp. 6 – 13, November/December, 2009.

Cigre Science & Engineering • N°1 February 2015


13
Biographies

Christophe Perrier obtained his Ph. D degree in Jelena Lukic, PhD in Chemical Engineering is Head of
insulating materials in 2005 from the Ecole Centrale de Laboratory for insulating oil and paper testing, department
Lyon (France). He started his career in the R&D center for Electrical Measurements of Electrical Engineering
of Areva T&D (Villeurbanne) on insulating liquids Institute Nikola Tesla. Main field of her expertise are oil
to optimize power transformers reliability. In 2006, analysis, diagnostics, degradation phenomena of paper/
he moved to the R&D Center on Power Transformers oil insulation, corrosion phenomena induced by corrosive
(Massy) where he developed a laboratory and activities sulphur and for oil treatment processes. She is Serbia NC
dedicated to insulating materials. Since 2012, in Alstom representative in IEC TC 10 Committee and co-liaison of
Grid, he is in charge of R&D projects on materials, acts as IEC TC 10 for CIGRE SC A2. She is engaged in different
technical expert on insulating liquids and is Eco-design IEC TC 10 and CIGRE working groups and is a convenor
coordinator for Power Transformers. He is member of of CIGRE WG A2.40: “Copper sulphide long-term
CIGRE (A2, D1) & IEC (TC 10). Mitigation and Risk Assessment”.

Mamadou-Lamine Coulibaly has joined the Technology, Valentina Vasovic is working in Electrical Engineering
Innovation and Competence Development Centre Institute «Nikola Tesla», in Laboratory for Testing and
(TICC) of Areva T&D (presently Alstom Grid) at Massy, Calibration, department for mineral insulating oil testing,
France after receiving the Ph.D degree in Electrical at the position of associate research engineer. Her main
Engineering (Dielectric Materials and High Voltage) field of work is oil analyses, High-performance liquid
from the Ecole Centrale de Lyon in collaboration with chromatography, Infrared Spectrofotometry, Karl Fisher
Areva T&D in 2009, France. Coulometry, determination of viscosimetric degree of
polymerization of paper for electrotechnical purposes,
He is currently with Alstom Grid - TICC Massy and etc. She is engaged in research activities in the field of
works on R&D projects linked to insulating materials natural ester oils. In 2008. she took a university degree
involving solids and mixed solids/liquids for power B.Sc. Chemical Engineering at Faculty of Chemical
transformers. He is member of CIGRE and IEC Working engeenering, University of Belgrade, Serbia. Currently
Groups. she is in the course of PhD studies.

Cigre Science & Engineering • N°1 February 2015


14

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen