Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
THE AR-15
And the Winner Is...
By Denny Hansen
42 S . W. A . T. • MARCH 2002
WWW.SWATMAGAZINE.COM RUGER MINI-14 VS. THE AR-15
The Mini’s bolt hold-open device is a button located on the top The AR’s bolt hold-open is located on the left side of the frame
left of the receiver. and also serves as a bolt release.
MARCH 2002 • S . W. A . T. 43
RUGER MINI-14 VS. THE AR-15
keep a 5-round string barely under six ful of loose dirt into the magazine well "fixed" the questionable mag by placing
inches, while Flint inexplicably shot a of each rifle and then shook each of it on a flat rock and stomping it flat. No
larger group of 7 inches with the AR. This them to distribute the dirt. After running more problems were experienced with it.
reversal of who shot better with what gun a cleaning patch down the bore of each I highly suggest doing this with any
may be explained by the fact that Flint rifle to make sure the barrel was clean magazine that is not 100 percent reli-
can’t quite seem to get used the Ashley (no sense in being completely stupid and able. The odds of it somehow getting
dot front sight, and I kept losing the having a rifle blow up in your face) we mixed up with your good magazines is
Mini’s stainless steel front sight against attempted to fire a 20-round magazine not a coincidence you want to chance
the light-colored target at that range. rapidly through each. The Mini-14 ran with a defensive arm.
During the test we burned a total of without a malfunction. Much to my sur- The Ruger factory, Ramline, and one
almost 1,500 rounds of ammunition, split prise, my usually malfunction-free AR of the USA magazines worked beautiful-
evenly between the two rifles. Most of burped on the third round, and did not go ly in the Mini-14. Incidentally, Ramline
the shooting was done at less than 50 fully into battery. magazines work in both Mini-14’s and
yards to simulate more realistic "real During the test the only problem that AR-type guns with no modifications nec-
world" firing conditions. At times we shot I had with the Mini-14 was from one of essary—a bonus for those who own both
so much, so fast that the barrels became the USA 30-round magazines. This mag- type of rifles.
too hot to touch. azine would feed one round, and fail to Overall, there is no clear "winner" in the
To check the worst-case scenario, at feed the second. This was repeated 15 Mini-14 versus AR-15 debate. Both have
one point we dropped about half a hand- times until the magazine was empty. I features I like and dislike. As far as person-
The AR’s safety is a selector switch located on the left side of the
The Mini-14 safety is similar to the Garand, i.e. inside the trigger frame and easily manipulated by a right-handed shooter’s
guard. thumb. The author personally prefers this system.
44 S . W. A . T. • MARCH 2002
WWW.SWATMAGAZINE.COM RUGER MINI-14 VS. THE AR-15
MARCH 2002 • S . W. A . T. 45