Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Annotated Bibliography
Primary Sources
ACLU Staff. “Reconciling Faith and Evolution in the Classroom: A Conversation with Susan
Epperson, 42 Years Later.” American Civil Liberties Union, American Civil Liberties
conversation-susan-epperson-42-years-later.
The article is an interview with Susan Epperson, the plaintiff in Epperson v. Arkansas.
The interview includes Epperson discussing how the trial impacted life for students and
teachers, and the long term significance of overturning religious laws. Epperson
discussed how her trial helped change the way religion and education interacted in the
United States. We used this information to help format a page on the significance of the
Scopes trial, as the Scopes trial directly caused the legislation being overturned in
Epperson's case.
ACLU. “Susan Epperson and John Scopes (1969).” American Civil Liberties Union, American
conversation-susan-epperson-42-years-later.
The photograph, from the ACLU, shows Susan Epperson, a teacher who sued against a
similar Act to the Butler Act, and an older John T. Scopes talking. The photograph was
used to connect the relevance of the two cases on the Conflict in the Courtroom section.
Bettman, Getty Archives. “The Scopes Trial during Its Period Outside the Courthouse.” Things
the Scopes Trial, of the members of the original meeting discussing the case. We used the
2
image on our website to provide a visual of what the first meeting that led to the trial
looked like.
Bryan, William Jennings, and Lowell Harris. Coate. The Dawn of Humanity.: The Menace
of Darwinism, and the Bible and Its Enemies. Altruist Foundation, 1925.
The book is a written piece by William Jennings Bryan, the prosecutor of the trial. The
book expressed Bryan's fundamentalist principles that would play a role in the trial
and as a concept created to destroy proper Biblical belief. We used this information in
several of our pages to depict Bryan's fundamentalist view through embedded quotes.
Bryan, William Jennings. The Bible or Evolution? Sword of the Lord Foundation, 1925. The
book is a piece written by William Jennings Bryan, and is extremely biased in favor the
Fundamentalists. It presents the point of view of Fundamentalists and how they view
religion. We used the information to present the Fundamentalist mindset to the audience
The Daily Republican. “1925 Scopes 'Monkey' Trial Guilty Verdict.” Timothy Hughes Rare and
www.rarenewspapers.com/view/592495?imagelist=1.
The website was able to provide our site with the first-hand newspaper of July 21, 1925,
when the Scopes trial occurred. The newspaper provided evidence on how the Scopes
trial was relevant across the country. This also added on to the idea of the Scopes trial
Darrow, Clarence. Attorney for the Damned: Clarence Darrow in the Courtroom. Simon and
Schuster, 1957.
3
The source is a book written by Clarence Darrow, the defense attorney in the trial.
Darrow discusses how the Scopes Trial changed American society. The primary print
source showed most of its attention on the "Significance" page, as it showed, directly, in
Darrow's eyes what the trial had intended to do. Even though it was very likely Scopes
had taught the concept, it was not a question of if he did, but more of the implications of
doing so.
Darrow, Clarence, et al. The Essential Words and Writings of Clarence Darrow. Modern
books.google.com/books?id=Sk8HPjc_khIC&printsec=frontcover&source=gbs_ge_sum
mary_r&cad=0#v=onepage&q&f=false.
The book is an autobiographical book by Clarence Darrow about many of his ideas and
thoughts. The book served as primary level background of how Clarence Darrow
connected to the Modernist principles and gave us background of those who identified
themselves as modernists and why they felt so passionately towards the case. Within our
website, the source was most useful in quoting Clarence Darrow in court and describing
Davis, Watson. “These Seven Scientists Volunteered to Travel to Dayton, Tennessee, to Testify
scopes-trial.
The image depicts the witnesses for the defense that were prevented from testifying in the
courtroom. This site contributed directly to our project with its picture of witnesses for
www.smithsonianmag.com/history/dayton-tennessee-evolved-scopes-trial-180958497/.
The article discusses the trial and its jurors from Scopes’ trial. This article was able to
connect the present with the Scopes trial and express the extreme relevancy of it today. It
worked primarily to discuss the huge effect the trial had on our lives and how far the
witnesses at the trial had come. We used the information to provide relevance for the
case.
www.smithsonianmag.com/history/dayton-tennessee-evolved-scopes-trial-180958497/.
The image depicts the annual reenactment of the Scopes Trial. The website served to
portray the reenactment of the Scopes Trial on an annual basis and contributed most to
our "Significance" page because the trial is relevant to our civil rights to this day.
Dembski, William A., and Jay W. Richards. Unapologetic Apologetics: Meeting the Challenges
This book talked about how students in theological study have not impacted their
surroundings to believe as much as previous years. This book simply stood out as a
discussion of the possible effects of Scopes trial and the compromise that occurred. We
used this information to represent the relevance of the Scopes Trial over time.
“Evolution No Foe to Faith.” Becoming Modern: America in the 1920s, America in Class,
americainclass.org/sources/becomingmodern/divisions/text5/text5.htm.
The image is a newspaper about “Curator Hrdlicka” claiming that religion and science
are not enemies. We used the image to represent theistic evolution, a new mindset that
Fausset, Richard. “Clarence Darrow and William Jennings Bryan at the Scopes ‘Monkey Trial’
www.nytimes.com/2017/07/14/us/darrow-bryan-dayton-tennessee-scopes-statues.html.
The image depicts Clarence Darrow and William Jennings Bryan side-by-side. We used
Fosdick, Harry Emerson. “Shall the Fundamentalists Win?” History Matters. 22 June 1922, First
The source is a sermon written by Harry Emerson Fosdick, describing why he believes
our "Modernists and Fundamentalists in American Life" page, as he played a major role
in sparking conflict between William Jennings Bryan and contributed to the later brought
Grabiner, Judith V, and Peter D Miller. “Effects of the Scopes Trial.” Science AAAS, 8 July
2014, www.jstor.org/stable/1738991 .
The journal describes the effect of the Scopes Trial on the educational forms of the U.S.
This source showed its importance on the "Reform of Education" page, specifically that
of teacher's speech, as the site itself depicted the short and long term effects of the trial.
www.christianitytoday.com/history/people/pastorsandpreachers/harry-emerson-
fosdick.html.
The image depicts Minister Harry Emerson Fosdick. The image provided from this
website was used to give background on Fosdick and why he was such a prominent
figure in the trial even though he was not directly on the bench.
6
In this book, Hofstadter traced the social movements that altered the role of intellect in
American society. In doing so, he questioned the democratization of our education, which
may have invaded our beliefs, but originated due to evangelical concepts stressed in
society. This was able to give us analysis of why some citizens may oppose the
expanding of science and education based on these factors. The source was most helpful
in our "Religion in 20th Century America" page to establish the setting of the conflict.
The Holy Bible: King James Version. American Bible Society, 1984.
The source is the Bible, notably the King James Version, as used in the Scopes Trial.
This was an imperative source within our research, especially since the conflict and
compromise had a huge religious component. Furthermore, the Biblical Literalism was a
concept widely covered by fundamentalists within the trial and within our project, which
included literally interpreting the Bible. Direct reference is found throughout the pages in
our website as the fundamentalists within the Scopes trial had used this version of the
Hunter, George W., and Leopoldo B. Uichanco. New Civic Biology: Presented In Problems .
archive.org/stream/newcivicbiologyp00hunt#page/442/mode/2up/search/natural+selectio
n.
The high school biology textbook represents present the changing educational
most to our "Road to Trial" page, as we were able to retrieve excerpts from the textbook
that Scopes had read out of to his class and was able to introduce the known conflict.
7
Hunter, George W. “Evolution .” A Civic Biology: Presented In Problems , Nabu Press, 2010,
moses.law.umn.edu/darrow/documents/Civics%20Textbook.pdf.
This particular image was the excerpt in which Scopes had read about evolution to his
class. This was crucial in our "Road to Trial" website in being able to depict the literal
James , Marquis. “Dayton, Tennessee.” The New Yorker , 11 July 1925. The New Yorker Archive
, www.newyorker.com/magazine/1925/07/11/dayton-tennessee.
The article is a firsthand account of the Scopes Trial. We gained a new perspective on the
trial from reading the article that helped us construct our website. We were able to insert
images from the source to depict the widespread media coverage in "Modernist and
“John Scopes .” Daily News New York , Daily News New York , 21 July 2015,
www.nydailynews.com/news/national/scopes-convicted-teaching-theory-evolution-1925-
article-1.2298732.
The photograph is of John Scopes. It was used on the Road To Trial page, to establish the
“John T Scopes .” New York Times, New York Times, 21 July 2015,
www.nydailynews.com/news/national/scopes-convicted-teaching-theory-evolution-1925-
insignificant figure in his own court case, and this image was used as an establishing
Johnson, Alvin W., and Frank H. Yost. Separation of Church and State in the United States.
The print source was able to provide us with base information for how compromise
between those who valued religion most and education most occurred throughout the
years and it discussed the Scopes trial in specific. This book was also able to establish
that the conflict was not new, but simply recurring. We used this information to establish
for the audience how little the conflict changed over time.
evolution, and included many sentences in that regard. The source provided a quote in
The source is a high school biology textbook written by a firm believer in evolution,
Alfred Kinsey. The textbook is a reprint of the original, published after the Scopes Trial.
The book reflects how even strong believers in evolution were forced to change their
textbooks. We used a quote from Kinsey that was changed dramatically as compared to
Kramer, Stanley, director. Inherit The Wind. Metro Goldwyn Mayer, 1999.
The motion picture gave us in-life view of what the Scopes trial was like. This movie
served as a base from gaining more knowledge on the tension and conflict within the
courtroom.
9
Lebo, Lauri. “Susan Epperson and John Scopes .” Religion Dispatches , Religion Dispatches , 15
administration/.
The image is of Susan Epperson and John Scopes during a meeting. The image was
incorporated into the website to provide a link between the two cases on the Legacy page.
Linder, Douglas. “Susan Epperson .” The Evolution, Creationism, and Intelligent Design
law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/conlaw/evolution.htm.
The photograph is of Susan Epperson, who participated in a similar case to John Scopes.
The image was used to establish who Epperson was, on the Significance page.
Long , Tony. “Clarence Darrow Presents His Case to the Dayton County Courtroom.” WIRED,
verdict/.
The image is of Clarence Darrow in the courtroom. It was included in the website to give
Matzke,Science, Nicholas J. “67 Anti-Evolution Acts in the United States.” The Atlantic , The
of-teaching-creationism-in-public-schools/421197/.
The image depicts a phylogenetic tree of anti-evolution acts in the United States since the
early 2000s. The image was incorporated into the Signifiance page, to inform viewers
McCoy, David B. “The Scopes Monkey Trial.” The Dispersal of Darwin, The Dispersal of
evolution-in-cartoons-and-caricatures/.
The cartoon depicts three monkeys in the positions of "Hear Not, See Not, and Speak
Not". The cartoon inspired the title to the website, and was used on the home page.
Muller, H. J. “One Hundred Years Without Darwinism Are Enough.” School Science and
Mathematics, vol. 59, no. 4, 1959, pp. 304–316. Wiley Online Library,
doi:10.1111/j.1949-8594.1959.tb08235.x.
The journal, written by H.J. Muller, describes the changing textbooks of the era and why
curriculum had to reflect the new culture of the time period. We used this source to
provide an example of the legacy of the Scopes trial, and how the trial led to the return of
Osborn, Henry Fairfield. “The Earth Speaks to Bryan.” American Journal of Public Health, vol.
15, no. 10, 1925, pp. 906–906. US National Library of Medicine National Institutes of
The journal was written by a critic of William Jennings Bryan and gave perspective to
those with different mindsets. We used the information to help provide us with a different
Pace, E B. “Another Pied Piper, The Path of Education.” Seven Questions in Dispute, Fleming H.
The cartoon is an image drawn by a Fundamentalist artist during the 1920s, depicting the
Modernists and their teachings. We used the image to help juxtapose the Fundamentalists
11
and Modernists perspectives and show the diverted path of education in our "Religion in
Company, 1924, p. 9.
This cartoon was an image drawn by a Fundamentalist during the 1920s. We used it on
our website to show how the Fundamentalists saw their opposition, the Modernists, as
pioneerinstitute.org/know-nothing/.
The website was great in providing comics to depict the cause and effect of the Scopes
Monkey trial. Moreover, the comic we implemented into our website showed the cross as
a shadow in a science class a teacher lectures. Thus, there is an implication that schools at
the time weighed Christian teachings into schoolwork. The prevalence of the conflict
“A Portrait of William Jennings Bryan.” Historical Solutions , Historical Solutions , 9 June 2015,
historicalsolutions.com/and-this-date/.
The image depicts William Jennings Bryan. We used the image on our page about
Ratliff, Evan. “The Crusade Against Evolution.” Wired, Conde Nast, 1 Oct. 2004,
www.wired.com/2004/10/evolution-2/.
This article was written in the modern world about evolution being taught in schools. We
incorporated the information into the Significance portion of the website to represent the
“Reverend T. Martin during the Scopes Monkey Trial in 1925.” Chicago Tribune, Chicago
In the image, Reverend T. Martin hangs a sign reading "Read Your Bible" in reference to
the Modernist belief in a reliance on modern science and the Bible. The image was used
in tandem with our thesis statement to present the strong opinions of regular citizens on
Rhea County Courthouse . State of Tennessee v. John T. Scopes. Fifth and Sixth's Day
moses.law.umn.edu/darrow/documents/Scopes%206th%20&%207th%20days.pdf.
These transcripts of the trials helped provide information about trial's occurrences. These
were referenced on our website to provide direct testimony to the audience about the trial
“Scopes Guilty, Fined $100, Scores Law; Benediction Ends Trial, Appeal Starts; Darrow
Answers Nine Bryan Questions.” The New York Times, The NewYork Times,
www.nytimes.com/learning/general/onthisday/big/0721.html.
Newspapers were not only detailed in the new case that would test faith and education,
but also fed the curiosity of citizens. The website consists of a political cartoon used
within our website to depict a modernist perspective in some media displays the trial as
“Scopes Trial Newspaper .” The New York Times, The New York Times, 3 Sept. 2015,
www.nytimes.com/interactive/projects/cp/summer-of-science-2015/latest/blue-marble-
earth-photos-comparison.
13
The initial image was a newspaper with daring headlines. We used particularly these
headlines on the 'thesis' page to establish the enormous conflict of the time.
www.mensetmanus.net/dayton-scopes-trial/.
The site helped our project in that it established a setting for the Scopes trial and the
social environment it was set in. Many digital images were able to give us first-hand
views of what the court looked like, and were used on the website to provide our
www.spiegel.de/fotostrecke/evolution-vor-gericht-der-scopes-prozess-von-dayton-
fotostrecke-128340-7.html.
The website served as an archive and provided us with a modernist political cartoon
depicting the jury bench on the Scopes trial as monkeys. This allowed us to stress the
chaos of the trial, but it also hinted at the presence of evolution that the artist agreed was
Staff, LII. “First Amendment .” LII / Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law, 5 Feb. 2010,
www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/first_amendment.
This is the First Amendment of the United States Constitution, laying out the rights of
man, including the freedom of speech and religion. The amendment was juxtaposed on
the website with the confining terms of the Butler Act that prevented the freedom of
Sunday Magazine. “A Talk With William Jennings Bryan, Evangelist.” Sunday Magazine, Sept.
1911, sundaymagazine.org/2011/09/a-talk-with-william-jennings-bryan-evangelists
Newspapers were common mediums for Bryan to discuss his views on the debate. Within
this article, his strong beliefs and, moreover, rejection of evolution was based on the idea
of soul, that of which he believes can only be granted by the words of the Bible. This
quote is able to illustrate Bryan’s, but also the fundamentalist view on the scientific
doctrine.
“ The Defense for John Scopes Prepares Experts Statements, in 1925.” The Chicago Tribune
140123-clarence-darrow-scopes-monkey-trial-evolution-pictures/.
The image depicts the defense counsel for John Scopes going over their case.The image
helped provide evidence for the ACLU's aid in the case and was used on the Road to
Trial page.
Tennessee, Congress, House of Representatives, and John W Butler. “The Butler Act.” The
Butler Act, Tennessee State Legislature. National Center for Science Education,
ncse.com/files/pub/legal/Scopes/Butler_Act.pdf.
The publication, from the Tennessee House of Representatives, is the Butler Act that led
to the Scopes Trial. The act prohibits the teachings of non-Biblical versions of the
creation of man, as referenced from Genesis. It was used in the Road to Trial portion of
Vernon Dalhart and Company . The John T. Scopes Trial, 10 June 1925.
15
The song describes the journey of John T. Scopes and his trial, as well as the religion
centered Dayton County. The song was used on the website to complement the thesis and
Wessner , Otto, director. Felix: Doubles for Darwin. Pat Sullivan Cartoons , 1924. Archive ,
archive.org/details/Felix_DoublesforDarwin_NoAudio.
The video is a cartoon character named Felix the Cat, as he investigates the authenticity
of Darwin's theories. The video was used on the website to provide context for the media
www.history.com/this-day-in-history/monkey-trial-begins.
The image depicts William Jennings Bryan in the courtroom. We used it on our website
to depict Bryan presenting his defense to the courtroom, and to give our audience a
visual. This helped to give background on Jennings Bryan himself in our page about
Zaleski, Mark. “Clarence Darrow Statue .” Knox News , USA Today, 14 July 2017,
www.knoxnews.com/story/news/local/tennessee/2017/07/14/statue-scopes-monkey-trial-
is of a statute of Clarence Darrow in the Rhea County area. We used the image to show
Secondary Sources
“ACLU History: The Scopes 'Monkey Trial'.” American Civil Liberties Union, American Civil
The website describes the American Civil Liberties Union's role in the Scopes Trial, and
how the organization played a role in the case. This website gave us the ACLU
perspective of the Scopes Monkey trial, taking us back in history to why the trial was
brought up in the first place. The website also gave us images of the ACLU lawyers
religion.oxfordre.com/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780199340378.001.0001/acrefore-
9780199340378-e-419.
The journal describes what Fundamentalism is, and how it developed during the
twentieth century. This source was implemented within our site to give readers
“The Century: America's Time - 1920-1929: Boom To Bust.” American Broadcasting Company
, 1999.
The documentary depicted the 1920s in the United States. The video was used to
establish the religious foundations that had compromised the US up until the Scopes Trial
on the website.
Chandler, Daniel Ross. “The Modernist-Fundamentalist Controversy and Its Impact on Liberal
huumanists.org/publications/journal/modernist-fundamentalist-controversy-and-its-
impact-liberal-religion.
The journal served primarily to help us connect Modernism with the principle of
Darwin's Theory of Evolution and how this connection was crucial within the Scopes trial
itself. We built this information into the website as part of the legacy of the trial long
Cohen, Charles Lloyd., and Paul S. Boyer. Religion and the Culture of Print in Modern America.
The website discusses the impact of religion on the culture of America shown throughout
American media. Pace’s comics is what we used in our website as it was major in
depicting the Scopes trial setting and the environment. Pace’s comics depicted the
true science would not question religious belief of Americans. We used this information
on the website to represent the important role of the media in shaping public opinion
Collins, Francis S., and Jonathan Davis. The Language of God: A Scientist Presents Evidence for
This print was particularly useful in providing us with ways the trial conflict had
compromise on both ends. Theistic evolution, the concept addressed within the book,
helped us picture this. We implemented theistic evolution into the website to help prove
“Darwin's Challenge to Religion and the Religious Response.” The Ethical Culture Society of
religious-response/.
The website depicted the conflict between religious and scientific ideals. With this
source, we were able to get a bigger picture of Bryan’s challenge to Darwinism and
This becomes key to the examination of the testimony where Bryan admits the Bible
cannot be interpreted literally, a major part of our website. We presented this information
about how William Jennings Bryan often used newspapers to debate his stand in the
conflict, continually defending his Biblical beliefs and shaping America life.
www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/393/97.
The website had a huge purpose in informing us about the Epperson v. Arkansas trial that
happened and is extremely connected to the Scopes trial in significance. Hence, the
Gould, Stephen Jay. Hen's Teeth and Horse's Toes: Further Reflections in Natural History.
Norton, 1994.
The book is a set of essays from This View Of Life, a National History Magazine.
Through one of the essays, we were able to ascertain Scopes' own perspective on how his
trial shaped the century and religion in the United States. We presented this perspective
Grabiner, J. V., and P. D. Miller. “Effects of the Scopes Trial.” Science, vol. 185, no. 4154, June
The journal describes the immediate changes that occurred after the Scopes Trial in
textbooks. The textbooks changed to reflect the lack of belief by the citizens in Darwin's
theories. The journal was used to provide context on the website about how academia
History.com Staff. “William Jennings Bryan.” History.com, A&E Television Networks, 2009,
background base for our topic and its information was most prevalent in "Modernist and
Bryan and the specifics of his life with the backgrounds of the website.
Kersten, Andrew Edmund. “War or Regret.” Clarence Darrow: American Iconoclast, Hill and
books.google.com/books?id=jJOgLx6XvqQC&lpg=PT168&ots=hFeACL6G1n&dq=The
istic%20Evolution%20darrow&pg=PT135#v=onepage&q=theistic%20evolution&f=false
. The book discussed many parts of Clarence Darrow's life and we used the chapter that
discussed theistic evolution. The information was used on the website to provide a
definition of theistic evolution, a mindset that Darrow adopted during the trial..
Larson, Edward J. Summer for the Gods: the Scopes Trial and America's Continuing Debate
The book provided detailed descriptions of the events leading up to, through, and post the
trial. It was used on the website for basic information about Fundamentalism.
Lesiak, Christine. American Experience: Monkey Trial. Public Broadcasting Service, 2002.
Youtube, www.youtube.com/watch?v=ahH6IwTmw-Q&t=3781s.
20
The video is a documentary created by PBS about the Scopes Trial. The video was
cropped and used in our website to provide a dramatic reading of the testimony in the
Moore, Randy. “The Lingering Impact of the Scopes Trial on High School Biology Textbooks.”
3568(2001)051[0790:tliots]2.0.co;2.
The journal reports on how high school biology textbooks changed after the Scopes Trial
overturned current ideas about religion and evolution in schools. We used Moore's words
to inform our audience how the Scopes Trial radically changed the direction of education
Moran, Jeffrey P. American Genesis: the Evolution Controversies from Scopes to Creation
The book helped establish the circumstances in America during the era. The information
was used to create a foundation for John Scopes and his character. The source contributed
the most to our "Road to Trial" page in showing that Scopes supported the evolutionary
theory but, at first, was not in strong opposition to the Butler Act.
Sarat, Austin, and Thomas R. Kearns. Law in the Domains of Culture. University of Michigan
Press, 1997.
The website gave us insight on the impact of media on the trial itself. Media itself was
how most people heard of the conflict and were able to show interest in the outcome.
However, the website was also able to show the ‘media circus’, how obsessive the people
“‘Shall the Fundamentalists Win?": Defending Liberal Protestantism in the 1920s.” HISTORY
MATTERS - The U.S. Survey Course on the Web, George Mason University,
historymatters.gmu.edu/d/5070/.
The article was able to provide us with the view of Harry Fosdick, strong fundamentalist,
that went head-to-head with William Jennings Bryan. Though he was a minister, he still
leaned towards the presence of evolution. This source was the most essential in Harry
Fosdick's coverage in our page about modernist and fundamentalists in American life.
Sweeney, Douglas A. “Who Were the ‘Fundamentalists’?” Christian History | Learn the History
www.christianitytoday.com/history/issues/issue-92/who-were-fundamentalists.html.
The article describes the guiding principles Fundamentalists followed in order to respect
the Bible and its role in life. The article gave a firsthand view of what the
Fundamentalists like William Bryan and the creators of the Butler Act thought. The
source was used to define the Fundamentalists and their viewpoint going into the Scopes
Trial.
Wolf, John, and James S Mellett. “The Role of ‘Nebraska Man’ in the Creation-Evolution
ncse.com/cej/5/2/role-nebraska-man-creation-evolution-debate.
The source is an article about the Nebraska man, an evolution related case during the
1920s. The information was used in the "Fundamentalism in the 1920s " page to help