,/ il Ie Hydropow€,r pro j ect

t Kotma
Lot 3 - Hydrymcchanical Works

il Table-6 (3)
Comparism of Material Weight

! ltem Descreption Unit

[:ttgirtce r's
Estimaitc
(a)
Bidder
(b)
I

(tr)r(
^ft"
(c)
Bidder 2
(c)/(af io

iu)' 9r,* 3tqlggq -

I ipif
ll Gate Leaf
Total rveight olgate leaf t l6s t Approx 269 5

.2
_..*,_
!
I Guide Frame
Total weight of guide frame -t-
20.5 Approx. 8 .2

1.5 Ancnorage

I --t
+__-_Jlr$
I otat werght of anchorage t t5r Approx. 8 7. 8

t r54 Approx. 3I

I 1.5
___
Electrical Controls
r !111 wergLgl electrtcat control t
,( Anorox
-
3 Local 3

Remote 0.6

Sprllway Uates and Hoists t 550 694.3 t26% 400. I 73%

Spillrvay Stoplog and Mobile Crane

2.1 Stoplog Segment
I otal werght ot-stoplog t 45 Approx. 52.2

l./. uutoe rrame

I-otal weight of guide frame t 22.5 Approx. 2l

2.3 Lifting Beam

we lght ot lltttng beam t 1.3 Approx" 1.7

_ 2.4 Base. frame for storage

werght ot base fiame for storage
- t 7.5 Approx. 12. I

/,.) Moblle urane

Gross vehicle weighr t 26.9 Approx. 28.3

t l n.5 103.2 93% I 15.3 l03o/o

-IETIY

J-Power r6 (3)
1of6 Bid Evaluation Rcport

ul
 KoEma
le HYdroPower Proi ect I-ot 3 - I{ydrpmechanical Works

I [lngineer's
Iliddcr idder 2
\
Itcrrr Ddscrcptitln tlnit Estinraitc I B
(at (h; (lr);la)'t (c) ( e)i (a )

I ],r Fluslr Gate and Hoists

-1 I
)o,.-,_=-
Gate l-eat'
'l'otal u'eiglrt ol-gate lc:rl' t 259 A pprox 40

I .i I Cuide l:ranre
T'ntoi *.,gt;i ;i i'la. iii ,i,. t 54 Approx l4

i -i ni,"f,oie"
I Total rveiglrt o[ anchoras,e t 14.4 Approx l0

-'-1 4 H",tt t"d C"*t

gtri ;a irydraulic hoist t 7 Approx l0

-=1- Hvdraulic Unit

fotat rveight of hydraulic unit t t.7 Approx I

I -Hoitt Cover
Total weight of anchorage t -, 1.5 Approx 5
1.

j 5 Steel Conduit and linine

I Steel Corrduit
Weight of steel conduit t l0l .7 Approx I50

Steel Lining
Weis.ht of steel linine t 29.9 Approx . 25

3.6 Electrical Controls

Total rveight t Approx.
0.5 Local 0.6
Remote 0.25

Sand Flush Gate and Hoist t25 r88 t50% 27 5.85 22t%

Stopl6g for Sand Flush Cate

4.1 Stoploe Segment
Total weight of stoplog t 17 I Approx. 16.9

4.2 Guide Frame

Total weight of euide frame t 5.4 Approx. 3.8

4.3 Lifting Beam

Weight of lifting bearn t 1.8 Approx. 1.5
4.4 Base frame for storage
Weight of base frame for storage t 7.5 Approx. 4.3

Stoplog for Sand Flush Gate 28 31.8 I l4o/o 26.5 95%

J.Power
r6 (3)
2 of 6 Bid Evaluation Report

Ia{ r# ",n
.
'.:i:,
'.

ir.
 I
il
llYdropower Project
4r (otrnalr: Lot 3 - I-l/dqlrnechanical Works

Iinginccr's
Ircrrr Dcscrellt iorr llrrit I:stirnaitc Iliddcr I R iddcr 2
1a) (t.,t (li1;1 (cJ {. )'(

I
)

filri,, L)anr Otrl!et Work.s

'[-olal u'cight oI trashrack

t Approx 0 5

I :I Steel Coila,,it
'l'utar t*cr[iit
of steel .o,,Jrit t t92 A pprox l7

< I Guard Gate

I Gate Leaf , Casing and Bonnet
Total rveight of gate t Main: 5 .
Main 7

Sub: 0.6 Sub: I

Hoist Assembly
Total weight of hydraulic hoist t Main: 0.3 03
Sub: 0.1

I 5.4 Service Gate

i' Gate Leaf, Casing and Bonnet
Total weight of gate t Main. 57 Main: 8

I Sub: 0.7 Sub: I

Hoist Assembly
Total rveight of hy,draulic hoist t Main: 0.3 Approx 0.3
-Sub: 0. I

5.5 Electrical Controls

Total rveight of electrical controls 0.8 Approx.
Local 0 85

Remote o2

Main Dam lntalie Gate and Hoist t 28 33. r t18% 36.15 r29%

Main Dam Intake Gate and Host

6.1 Gatp Leaf
log!_tl5 ight of gate leaf _
t r r.3 Approx. 12.5

6.2 Guide Frame

Totu!-*right of guid" fr.rr. t 5.4 Approx. 7 .5

6.3 Hoist Assembly

Total weight of hydraulic cylinder t 3.5 Approx. 3.5
Hydraulic Unit
Total weight of hydraulic unit t 1.5 Approx. 0.7

6.4 Electrical Controls

Total weight of electrical control t 0.5
Local 0-6

Remote 0.25

Main Dam Intake Gate and Hoist 27 22.2 82% 25.05 93o/o

r6 (3)
3 of 5 Bid Evaluation Report

w
-i,

,Di:,r;
 (otnra ) c: tiYclropower [)roject I-ot 3 - [{ydrpnrcchanical \\,orks

l.ngulccr :
Itcrrt I)e CI ;tlr n I Irr rt I'.strrnrr rtc ll icltlcr I It itlrlcr 2
| ;l) (b1 ll (;r l" ,, {c)
-l'rasltracks
arrcl Raking
[(ffifrnnr lrtta!':c I:<luiprrrcnr
I .l Irrrslrr;rckNol
I [,rtlrl rrcislrt ol'rr;rslrr;re k I
ir PI
I
I

| :l IrirslrrackNo2
i Iotal *ctslrt ol-traslrrack I
t
\ ppror

7 -1 \'lcclranical f!1kc
"f
9tal oerg![9 I1]:-.hanrcal qakc Appror

l1 !."l"sieltidl,
t A p pror

7 5 Storage f,opp.l
Total rveight of storagc hopper t
: nf,ptn\ 6_lj _

7 6 Electrical Controls
Total weight of electrical controls t
- -L--_
7 7 _ug{ tg::_q.!9_gli,,s gZ'9q

18 Crab
\\_e1gJ1t of grab I 23 -4i
I

Nlain Dani t^i;f; 1-rastuacis aid nur,,tg equipnlenr 873 120 9 I 38% tqlts t9!:
Guide Frarne of Intake Stoplog
t-
8 I Guide Franre
Total rveight of guide flranre I 79 Approx 96

G_r,o: tryy_gf l,L"\g Stoplog t 1 79 I l30h 96 1370/

!4t9.: JyU.] gggf and Dra in Fac iIi qv

-4_.g:[
i.] -d"ee:lPeqqrtle.o c"--
te13]_y:tshGadoor t
_t_1 Annrox I 6

9.) Gate Valve

Total weight of gate valve t I Approx 1.3

9 l Steel Conduit
Total weight of steel conduit t 6.2 Approx. I I

Headrace Tunnel Access Door and Drain I 4 86 215% rl9 348%

16 (3)
ower
4 of 6 Bid Evaluation Report

'L(- tr/ r,, l

n fiot ma J e HYd r opowe r Proj ec t

I I

tr.'rrt I \ I:rrgirrccr's ^
I-ot 3 - Ilydrprncchanical
Works

l l'"'t
Lt L: [)U()n
_ Iistinr;utc irlrl,.'

I
IJ I

-l-_-
I

i "r"'e. i ( lr; i l, r
Il irlrlcr l
I r)l .Str:cl I.irrirrr I

i
I
\\'c rg lrl I

Ste ul I rrrlrrs(liclrtlrilcc ancJ .\rlrrct:rrrl. I

I I
,
I
Iot;rl rrcrglrl ol stccl lrning
r

I'
i

68(t
Apprx (r,
.S tucl l,c-n.stock I

I
-l
:.
.(al rrglglrr ot'srect
-r__:.,:-_"
finstock
I /
I

I ,

ts2i ) /

l#: l;
'fi,rat t*:.igi,i
.irr.,"i".r ,-,,J r;,.,;.... I
I
I
I
zsn ) !--, /

Sleel Penstoc[ LinrnE

_c ___-_

25 t3.2

t-
97%
ll.qll Trrhe Gztec anrl Lr^: 2178 92

9.7
-l
I I 3 lJorsr
]-_- - __l
-t
- -l
I;,.r ;zuil;atrri--- -t
r i,l _E1.g*ut ;o,;i;;r, 1
lf,e ighi-o flor, I
"""
;i;;;
l ne I -- -:l I

Approx. l2
t
l8 4U.5 l--tu%
failr ce Gates; JJ) 88%

lr r0 3
[-
t-r
.---"
__i
I

l.-- t--_--
L-
---l-l I

_ __t
[:.__
--- -t
Tailrace Grt., and-Horst
-t- -
I E= {pprox 0.6 I

:-
_-t
-_-I
t 2t 226 ta8%
238 I t3%

t'Power
r6 (3 )
5 of 6
Bid Evaluar ion Reporr

1q _,- Vh
 Kotma
le H YdroPowe r Proj ect
Lot 3 - t{ydrprnectranicat Works

I Irctrr [)e .scrcyrtiott Ilrrit _

[:lrginccr's
I:stirtraitc Ilirlclcr

I
I
( lt I

Lorrtr(, - -----:, 1lo l'o\\'cr 5upp11'S1'slcnr

[Eta.,t,.r,
, (iatc ('orttrol fiquiprncn
I 'i I

rl
I
Ir
l'r,ra I u'eight o[ gate control crluiJrlrrgsl, I
\ ppror

lj I l)orrablc Diesel Cenerator

; -o1al
rrlglglrr
9t !ie99t_gcl91aror
I
I

I A_pprox I 2

I tj I Local biitriLriion Cabiner

rorol t*=igi,r of po*.rl...,rurg .rU.r.
I

-l
I
Appro,r 0.4
- _--
--11-4- DC Dl;ilu,,t,r" sl"r.,,
--..-.,.--------
-_-_ |

I Total rveight of po\\,e r receiving cubicle I t

_l - -4PPr;i -- --i

t
8.6 _ b72% 89 t18%

Grand Total 3,612 3803 1As% 3488.4 97%

I
I
I

l:lr

; r6 (3 )

6 of 6 Bid Evaluation Rcporr

'2/k