Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background of the Study
The term ‘social media’ is quite often mentioned these days. It is a new phenomenon
and one would probably imagine that everyone knows or understands what it means.
Nearly ninety percent (if not more) of all online or internet users use social media in
one way or the other (Kietzmann and Kristopher, 2011; Dolwick, 2009). The
emergence of social media began in the early days of internet when people started
sharing information and communicating with one another (Boyd et al., 2010) but
unfortunately; the platforms used then were more ‘technology intensive’ and required
some level of expertise before use. Hence, the number of people using social media
platforms then was limited. Over a period of time as technology advanced, platforms
that are less sophisticated were developed thus, enabling billions of regular internet
users, without any technology background, to use the services (Boyd et al., 2010;
Baden et al, 2009) and this marked a turning point in the history of internet, making
the internet technology all inclusive in such a way that people no longer remain silent
spectators to the content being dished out to them. Now, they could create their own
content, share it with others, respond to people, collaborate with them and many more
(Andreas and Haenlein, 2010). This user interaction is what gave impetus to the
Social media network sites such as, Facebook, Twitter, Likedin, Youtube, Google+,
etc now allow member individuals to interact with one another and to build
relationships even many companies across the world have joined but they joined only
1
the fastest growing networks such as Facebook and Twitter, so as to connect with their
customers (Trattner and Kappe 2012). The social media networks act so fantastically
as the vehicle helping companies to gain traffic or attention to their own website
usually through the use of Links via the adverts they place on the social media
websites (Chinag and Chung, 2011; Deis and Hensel, 2010). It also acts just as the
uploaded on the sites spread very fast from users to users and presumably resonate in
favour of the company (Deis and Hensel, 2010). In these regards, social media
networks, ever since 2008, have become the new 21st century paradigmatic market
medium for businesses to exploit (IMAP, 2010) and influence their customers’
purchasing behaviour more. This is because, globally, a survey report reveals that
about half of the 400 million active users of Facebook alone log on each day and
spend over 500 billion minutes per month on the same site. (Oracle Retail, 2010) and
sequel to this notion, virtually all businesses now employ social media networks as an
extension of their existing corporate marketing strategies especially the retail industry
in order to capture and serve customarily those active users with a broad range of
lifestyle brands of products across the universe. And in the light of this, many firms in
Nigeria also have started plunging into using these platforms. This current study thus
seeks to explore the patronage behaviour of Nigerian consumers via these growing
social media networks especially from those companies that utilize them for their
marketing activities.
2
1.2 Statement of the Problem
The rapid adoption and evolution of social media networks across all countries of the
world today has spurred many businesses to devising strategies in order to invite
millions of active users of the networks to their product offerings usually on their own
the country now strive to replicate those online dealings and transaction patterns
which their counterpart abroad practice. An example of this is Amazon, the world’s
similar online retailers such as Jumia, Konga, Dealdey, 3Stiches, Taafoo, Buyright.bz
etc have now emerged and some are still up coming. They also offer a broad range of
appliances, toys, etc. also at customers’ doorsteps but within Nigeria only.
Apart from the rising competition among the currently existing rivals, there seems to
be a daunting tendency that Nigerians would never dare transact business via the
internet with any unseen person who displays many attractive pictures of product
items, tagged with prices and might not physically exist anywhere but prompting
prospective buyers to pay upfront so that the items would be delivered at their
doorsteps anywhere in the country. This has always been a questionable issue as a
result of the pervasive menaces of Yahoo-Yahoo internet frauds and has shaped the
perception of many Nigerians toward being careful when operating on the internet
3
many of the Nigerian online retailers have provided sufficient rooms for any likely
doubt about the authenticity of their transaction via the social media networks with
any prospective customers by allowing them to pay for any product of their choice on
delivery. But still, other numerous problems proliferate thus, impeding against the
customers want, how they want it, as well as how to cater for them satisfactorily since
the genesis of the transaction through these growing social media network platforms is
done without any physical contact between the retailer and prospective consumers.
The retailers might lack the knowledge or understanding of what the prospective
updating information regarding the available product items. This was the experience
of an individual who bought a blouse for a friend from JUMIA from their e-store.
Some days later, JUMIA sent him a mail that the dress was out of stock and that he
should pick another one. This went on for weeks and he then noticed he would no
longer need the product item but there were issues regarding refund of his money.
According to the individual, “They kept telling me to reorder. It was frustrating but
after I did thrice, my item was delivered to me”. There could be many people
suffering from this type of encounter out there. Some of whom might lose both their
money and the product item they ordered. And this might affect their continued
4
Even where the prospective customers are served well – in terms of the understanding
and fulfilment of their needs, accessibility problem could hinder Nigerians from
patronising the online retailers. In Nigeria, there is a problem of poor internet network
everywhere and since this retail business via social media networks is online,
accessing the product categories in the mall of the retailer would be difficult. Similarly
the problem of poor or inadequate power supply could affect prospective consumers’
access to the online retailers’ mall. Meanwhile, the problem of bad road network also
customers. For instance, the bad road network could make the retailer’s delivery
agents to spend more time on the road especially in traffic hence, causing delay as to
when the item is promptly needed. Subsequent orders may be impeded as result of
this. Still on the accessibility problem, the distance to cover before reaching the
customer may as well affect prospective consumer’s patronage if he/she considers that
Finally, the patronage of these today emerging online retailers may be jeopardized
might not know could avail them the most ever convenient shopping experience than
travelling uncomfortably and unsafely through Nigerian roads to the market. While
there may be some other likely factors affecting the patronage of online retailers by
Nigerian consumers, it is therefore against the forgoing observations that this current
5
study has been carried out so as to empirically obtain the impacts the social media
networks could have on the patronage of the online retailers by Nigerians who use the
media networks.
The main objective of this study is to harness the impact of social media networks on
consumer patronage of the products of online retailers who utilise them for
ii. To ascertain the match between the online retailers’ understanding and fulfilment
of consumers wants through the use of social media networks for e-trading.
iii. To determine the extent to which Nigerians patronize the online retailers.
accessibility
consumers’
6
wants when using social media networks for e-trading in Nigeria?
v. What effect does online retailers’ accessibility have on the patronage level of
Nigerian consumers?
vi. How does consumers’ patronage experience determine their subsequent orders
shopping
consumers’
have any functional relationship with their patronage behaviour toward online
retailers.
H05: Online retailers’ accessibility does not have any effect on the patronage level of
Nigerian consumers.
H06: Consumers’ patronage experience does not determine their subsequent orders
7
1.6 Significance of the Study
This study will be ubiquitously useful, particularly in educating and enlightening most
small and medium sized retailers in the Nigerian neighbourhoods, on how they can
plunge into this emerging opportunity of selling their products not only in their
locality but now to the entire world via social media networks. While this can
can also serve as a basis for planning, decision making and formulation of an
Meanwhile, marketing students in tertiary institutions are not exempted from the
beneficiaries of this study. It will not only broaden their understanding as per the new
development in retail business but help some of them who may wish to set up their
own business of buying and selling to tread through their career paths to reality. It
cannot be overlooked that the outcome of this study can be found useful as a basis for
any future similar studies but finally, the researcher of the study will benefit most.
This is because it will widen his knowledge as far as the use of social media networks
contributing to the body of knowledge of marketing with the outcome of this study, it
would earn the researcher a remarkable credit when the study becomes a reference
This study is scoped from two main angles: desk and field study areas. The desk study
part encompassed the review of literature with the aim of identifying lagging research
8
areas which this current study seeks to bridge. The review of the literature also
included the theorizations for describing the processes involved in the use of social
media networks for achieving consumers’ patronage. In this case, the Service Quality
Gap Model which views consumers’ continued patronage from the Understanding
Gap and Fulfilling Gap perspectives was employed. Other aspects of the desk study
part of this current study included the conceptualisation of the term ‘social media
network’ by first conceptualising the terms ‘social’, ‘media’, and finally, ‘network’.
On the other part of this study which is the field research study part, only two most
Nigeria were used as the case study. As for online shopping consumers, these were
captured from Lagos and Enugu state only. These two groups of respondents were
Some factors that hindered this study from being carried out more elaborately than the
Time
The available time duration for this study seemed to be very short. The researcher
could only carry out the study out in a miniature form. It ought to be extensively
This was another limiting factor that prompted the study to remain as little as this. The
inadequacy of funds and competent research assistants jeopardized the wish of the
9
Technical Inefficiency
There was a felt technical incapacitation as regard the data collection method adopted
for this study. The online shopping consumers who also are active users of social
media networks ought to have been contacted through the use of an online survey
method in such a way that they would be persuaded to complete the when they are
attempting to log on or after they might have logged on to their social networks. This
can only be helped done by the management of the social media networks such as
Facebook, Twitter, Likedin, etc but how to contact them was the technical problem
Jumia Nigeria is one of the today’s Nigerian one-stop online retail shops offering a
Appliances, Toys, Books, Wears and many more but not limited to either Men only or
Women's Fashion, thus, bringing them right to customers’ doorstep. Jumia was
formerly owned by Rocket Internet who sold all its African holdings including
Kasuwa, an online electronic, gadgets and content store like Amazon, and Sabunta,
also an online clothing and fashion store, both to Millicom who then consolidated
both companies into Jumia. As a global company which has assets under supervision
of approximately $2.0 trillion and assets under management of about $1.3 trillion (as
of June 30, 2012), Jumia’s clients include institutions, retail investors and high-net
worth of individuals in every major market throughout the world. Jumia Nigeria also
offers a wide selection of styles and brands, 100% convenience with 24/7 online
10
access from home or office, secure payment such as Bank Deposit/Online banking and
Cash on Delivery, exceptional customer care service, Fast next-day or two to five days
delivery and returns after 7 days and lots more. Jumia can be followed up on social
Konga Nigeria is also one of the today’s Nigerian one-stop online retail shops offering
Appliances, Toys, Books, Wears and many more just as Jumia, bringing them right to
currently only delivers to Lagos. It also offers a wide selection of styles and brands,
100% convenience with 24/7 online access from home or office, secure payment such
service, Fast next-day or two to three days delivery and lots more. Konga also can be
Social
particularly the way in which the people in the society relate, behave and interact with
one another. In this current study, the term ‘social’ however connotes the group or
society of Browsers. It refers to how they relate, interact and behave with one another.
11
Media
The term ‘media’ is the plural of ‘medium’. It simply refers to the various means of
etc. Here in this current study however, the term ‘media’ means or is used as the
various means through which the group of Browsers are reached in different parts of
the world.
Network
The term ‘network’ means an interconnection (via cable and/or wireless) of a group of
computers and peripherals which are capable of sharing software and hardware
resources between many users (Baden et al., 2009). Internet is an example of a global
each other through a system of routers, servers, switches, and the likes (Dolwick,
Social Media
The term ‘social media’ is any electronic medium of communication (such as Internet,
Websites or Mobile phones usually for social networking and blogging) through
12
Social Media Networks
This refers to the interconnection of the group of social media users (Browsers) across
the universe. Internet remains the network that is facilitating the interconnectivity.
There are however a numbers of social media networks connecting people into the
society of the users across the world. Some of which include; Facebook, Yahoo,
Google, Likedin, 2go, Baddoo, Whatsapp, Skype, YouTube, etc. Through all these
networks, users can blog, chat, relate with one another, exchange contacts, etc
Consumers
A consumer could be a person, group of persons or households who are final users of
a product and or services. The meaning of the term ‘consumer’ may vary significantly
for personal use and not for manufacturing other product items or for resale. Here in
this study, the term ‘consumer’ is referred to as the group of individuals who order for
products from online retailers via the social media networks for personal use. They
Patronage
This term simply refers to the support or kindness offered in a condescending way. It
is, in the context of this study, used to mean the support of the consumers by regularly
13
REFERENCES
Andreas, K., and Haenlein, M. (2010). Users of the World, Unite! The Challenges and
Opportunities of Social Media. Business Horizons 8(2): 44-67
Deis, M.H., and Hensel, K. (2010). Using Social Media to Increase Advertising and
Improve Marketing. Entrepreneurial Executives, 4(2): 87-93.
Nigel, M., Graham, J., and Hodges, A. (20120. Social Media: A complete Guide. New
York: McGraw-Hill Inc.
Trattner, C., and Kappe. F. (2012). Social Stream Marketing on Facebook: A case
Study International Journal of Social and Humanistic Computing.
14
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.0 Introduction
empirical reviews. The concept of social media network as well as other related
concepts were conceptualised under the first part. Existing theories on how social
media networks can form or help create holistic consumer patronage effect were
reviewed under the second section while existing related studies were empirically
reviewed in the third section. Gaps in the existing literature and studies which would
be filled through this current study were subsequently identified together with how
2.1 Conceptualizations
applicable to this current study, the various concepts or terms that make up these
The term ‘Social Media Network’ consists of three terms: social, media and network.
humans and to their collective co-existence irrespective of whether they are aware of
involuntary (Dolwick, 2009). Based on this definition, it can be inferred that the term
15
‘social’ reflects the characteristic of a society which allows a group of people living in
The term ‘media’ as the plural of ‘medium’, simply refers to the means of
magazines, TV, radio, billboards, direct mail, telephone, fax, and internet.
and/or wireless) of a group of computers and peripherals which are capable of sharing
software and hardware resources between many users (Baden et al., 2009). Internet is
each other through a system of routers, servers, switches, and the likes (Dolwick,
With the foregoing definitions, the term ‘Social Media’ can now be conceptualised.
Internet, Websites or Mobile phones usually for social networking and blogging)
16
through which users create online communities to share information, ideas, personal
messages, and other content (like videos). Tang et al., (2012) also define social media
as the means of interactions among people through which they create, share, and
and that allows creation and exchange of user-generated content. Simply put, it
through which individuals and communities share, co-create, discuss, and modify
aspects such as quality (Tang et al., (2012), reach, frequency, usability, immediacy
and permanence (Nigel, Graham and Hodges, 2012) all of which are enhanced by the
internet. There are many effects that stem from internet usage. As a result, according
to Nigel et al., (2012), many internet users would continue to spend more time with
From the meaning of ‘social’ and ‘network’ as given above, the term Social Network
construct a public or semi-public profile within a bounded system, (ii) articulate a list
of users with whom they share a connection, and (iii) view and traverse their list of
connections and those made by others within the system. The nature and nomenclature
17
of these connections may vary from site to site. While the term "Social Network Site"
(Keitzmann and Kristopher, 2011; Tang et al., 2012; Baden et al., 2009), it also
appears in most public discourses, and the two terms: Social Network Site and Social
Networking Site seem to be often used interchangeably. Here in this study, the term
network suffixing ‘social media’ would be employed and not "networking" simply for
often between strangers and while it may be possible on some sites, it might not be the
primary purpose of many of others, nor is it what differentiates them from other forms
What makes social network sites unique is not only that they allow individuals to meet
strangers, but rather that they enable users to articulate and make visible their social
networks. This can result in connections between individuals that would not otherwise
have been made, but that is often not the primary goal, and these meetings are
18
frequently between "latent ties" (Haythornthwaite, 2005) who share some offline
connection. Meanwhile, on many of the large social network sites [SNSs], many
participants are not necessarily "networking" or looking to meet new people; instead,
they are primarily communicating with people who are already a part of their
consists of visible profiles that display an articulated list of Friends who are also users
of the system. Profiles are unique pages where one can "type oneself into being"
(Sundén, 2003, p. 3). After joining an SNS, an individual is asked to fill out forms
containing a series of questions. The profile is generated using the answers to these
questions, which typically include descriptors such as age, location, interests, and an
"about me" section. Most sites also encourage users to upload a profile photo. Some
sites allow users to enhance their profiles by adding multimedia content or modifying
their profile's look and feel. Others, such as Facebook, allow users to add modules
("Applications") that enhance their profile. The visibility of a profile varies by site and
not the viewer has an account. Alternatively, LinkedIn controls what a viewer may see
based on whether she or he has a paid account. Sites like MySpace allow users to
choose whether they want their profile to be public or "Friends only." Facebook takes
19
a different approach—by default, users who are part of the same "network" can view
each other's profiles, unless a profile owner has decided to deny permission to those in
their network. Structural variations around visibility and access are one of the primary
After joining a social network site, users are prompted to identify others in the system
with whom they have a relationship. The label for these relationships differs
depending on the site—popular terms include "Friends," "Contacts," and "Fans." Most
SNSs require bidirectional confirmation for Friendship, but some do not. These one-
directional ties are sometimes labeled as "Fans" or "Followers," but many sites call
these Friends as well. The term "Friends" can be misleading, because the connection
does not necessarily mean friendship in the everyday vernacular sense, and the
networks. The Friends list contains links to each Friend's profile, enabling viewers to
traverse the network graph by clicking through the Friends lists. On most sites, the list
of Friends is visible to anyone who is permitted to view the profile, although there are
exceptions. For instance, some MySpace users have hacked their profiles to hide the
Friends display, and LinkedIn allows users to opt out of displaying their network.
Most SNSs also provide a mechanism for users to leave messages on their Friends'
profiles. This feature typically involves leaving "comments," although sites employ
various labels for this feature. In addition, social media networks often have a private
messaging feature similar to webmail. While both private messages and comments are
popular on most of the major social networks, they are not universally available.
20
Facebook for example is available universally unlike 2go which seem to exist only in
African countries. Although, it is not all social network sites began as such. QQ
Cyworld as a Korean discussion forum tool, and Skyrock (formerly Skyblog) was a
school affiliates launched in 1995, began supporting articulated lists of Friends after
SNSs became popular. AsianAvenue, MiGente, and BlackPlanet were early popular
ethnic community sites with limited Friends functionality before re-launching in 2005-
Beyond profiles, Friends, comments, and private messaging, SNSs vary greatly in
their features and user base. Some have photo-sharing or video-sharing capabilities;
others have built-in blogging and instant messaging technology. There are mobile-
specific SNSs (e.g., Dodgeball), but some web-based SNSs also support limited
mobile interactions (e.g., Facebook, MySpace, and Cyworld). Many SNSs target
people from specific geographical regions or linguistic groups, although this does not
always determine the site's constituency. Orkut, for example, was launched in the
quickly became the dominant user group (Kopytoff, 2004). Some sites are designed
categories in mind. There are even social media network sites for dogs (Dogster) and
cats (Catster), although their owners must manage their profiles. While social media
21
themselves by nationality, age, educational level, or other factors that typically
segment society (Hargittai, this issue), even if that was not the intention of the
designers.
Based on the foregoing, the term social media network however comprises the
network medium usually facilitated by the internet through people around the world
are connected to chat, interact, share contacts and photos, relate with one another, etc.
These media are platforms which many firms now increasingly exploit to showcase
their products and interested consumers or prospects then follow the firms up through
competitiveness, increase sales and make good profits. One of which is the today’s
proliferating usage of Social Media Networks. Since the 1990s, many retailers across
the world have been entering this enterprising marketplace and as a result, the rivalry
between domestic and foreign retailers becomes fiercer everyday (Anic and
Jovancevic, 2004). With the increasing expansion of these foreign retailers and shifts
make their competitive strategies more effective so that they can compete against the
foreign retailers who are already utilising social media networks to penetrate the
emerging competition among foreign online retailers like Amazon and domestic
counterparts like Jumia, Konga, Buyrite, Deealdey, etc. Strategic positioning has now
22
become the critical issue for gaining both a sustained long-term growth and persistent
customers’ patronage. The key question now has been how these domestic retailers
can get Nigerian consumers to visit their online stores more frequently and buy more
consumers, most domestic retailers are now also moving into social media which their
For consumers to patronize the domestic retailers, the study of Laroche et. al (2005)
product) through their beliefs about the product’s attributes such as quality, reliability
and pricing. Attitude theory may explain how countries are seen in the mind of the
consumers, what beliefs and emotions towards a country they have, how this
2009). Attitudes are complex system comprising the persons’ beliefs about the object,
their feelings towards the object, and action tendencies with respect to the object. As
such they include cognitive, affective and conative aspects, and represent the way
the product or retailer and form an impression of the benefits they provide. They
express the preference or lack of preference for stores, brands and other marketing
purchasing intention and purchases (Dmitrovic, Vida and Reardon, 2009). Many
studies have examined consumers’ attitudes towards domestic and foreign products
(Bhuian, 1997; Beaudoin, 1998; Dickerson, 1982; Wang and Heitmeyer, 2006), while
only a few studies explored the consumers’ evaluation of domestic and foreign
23
retailers (Hyllegard et al., 2005; Chaney and Gamble, 2008; Ilter, Aykol, Ozgen,
2009; Anic and Jovancevic, 2009). The results of those studies are inconsistent.
Although there is some indication that consumers have more positive attitudes
True, and Rody, 1995; Wang and Heitmeyer, 2006; Chaney and Gamble, 2008), other
retailers than foreign products or retailers (Dickerson, 1982; Hyllegard et al., 2005).
Domestic retailers were shown to be better evaluated than foreign retailers on several
store attributes, including product quality, product assortment, pricing, structure and
store layout (Hyllegard et al., 2005). International retailer is likely to be rated higher
by consumers in its home country than consumers in its foreign subsidiaries (Burt and
retailer might expect some resistance in terms of boycotts with consumers who are
more supportive to their domestic retailers (Zarkada- Fraser and Fraser, 2002) but in
Nigeria, the reverse might be the case simply because of the belief and attitude that an
It is assumed that any business with high service quality will meet its customers’
valid and reliable service performance measures and measuring customer satisfaction
and other performance outcomes are all however assumed to be the foundational
24
factors for firms with high service quality. Where these mismatches with customers’
expectations, there would be a gap and can jeopardize the firm’s success or customers’
patronage. Therefore, to understand the processes involved in the use of social media
toward shopping via a company’s website or from the online social networks, the
Berry (1985) has been considered appropriate. This model highlights the main
requirements for delivering high service quality. Customers generally have a tendency
to compare the service they 'experience' with the service they 'expect'. For example, if
a customer shops online from Jumia stores, he/she would have a predefined
needs as ordered, etc. If the experience of this customer does not match the
expectation, there arises a gap. There are seven major potential gaps in this service
25
Word of Mouth Personal Needs Past
Communications Experience
Expected
Service
Gap 5
Perceived Services
Gap 6
Service Delivery
Gap 4 External Communications
(Including Pre & Post
to Customers
Contracts)
Gap 1 Gap 3
Gap 2
Gap 7
Management Perception
of Consumer Expectations
26
Gap3: Service specifications versus service delivery: as a result of role ambiguity
and conflict, poor employee-job fit and poor technology-job fit, inappropriate
the service delivered: as a result of the influences exerted from the customer side and
the shortfalls (gaps) on the part of the service provider. In this case, customer
perceptions: as a result
providers.
These foregoing gaps can also occur in the online shopping by Nigerian consumers
from any of the today emerging online retail stores. Luk and Layton (2002) further
drew from Parasuraman et al., (1985) opinion that there many dimensions from which
27
A customer's expectation of a particular service is determined by factors such as
recommendations, personal needs and past experiences. The expected service and the
perceived service sometimes may not be equal, thus leaving a gap. Ten determinants
that may influence the appearance of a gap were described by Parasuraman, Zeithaml
Competence is the possession of the required skills and knowledge to perform the
service. For example, there may be competence in the knowledge and skill of contact
Courtesy is the consideration for the customer's property and a clean and neat
company name, company reputation and the personal characteristics of the contact
personnel.
Security is the customer feeling free from danger, risk or doubt including physical
understand and also listening to customers. A company may need to adjust its
language for the varying needs of its customers. Information might include for
28
example, explanation of the service and its cost, the relationship between services and
costs and assurances as to the way any problems are effectively managed.
they arrive and so on. This in turn helps in delighting the customers i.e. rising above
Tangibles are the physical evidence of the service, for instance, the appearance of the
physical facilities, tools and equipment used to provide the service; the appearance of
personnel and communication materials and the presence of other customers in the
service facility.
Reliability is the ability to perform the promised service in a dependable and accurate
manner. The service is performed correctly on the first occasion, the accounting is
providing prompt timely services, for example, mailing a transaction slip immediately
Extant related studies on the impact of social media networks over consumer
patronage vary a lot both in approaches and the scopes covered. Anic and Vouk’s
(2005) study for example, was carried out on Exploring the Relationships between
Store Patronage Motives and Purchasing Outcomes for Major Shopping Trips in the
Croatian Grocery Retailing using survey research design method. These authors drew
29
from their perceived limited choice of stores which Croatian consumers had for their
grocery shopping trips before the beginning of the 1990s. And since then, a fast
expansion of supermarkets, hypermarkets, cash and carry stores and discounters have
been witnessed. Even with the entry of multinational retailers, and the continued shifts
in consumers’ attitudes and behaviour, the Croatian grocery retailers also have felt
ever stronger pressures to make their competitive strategies more effective, so that
they can increase their store traffic, enhance store loyalty and improve performance.
Although this current study, by using social media networks, centres on the
consumers’ shopping behaviour, the main purport of Anic and Vouk’s (2005) study
was on the other hand meant to explore the relative importance of patronage motives
as individual values and factors, and link them with purchasing outcomes. Also, to
examine the relationship between consumers’ and managers’ view on store patronage
motives. The authors further conceptualize ‘store patronage motives’ as being “the
reasons for patronizing a store” – i.e. elements of a retailer’s merchandising mix that
are critical in customers’ patronage decision. Owing to the fact that, when designing
the retailing strategy, management first decides which store image to project to
selected market segment. Clearly, they need information not only about the target
market (consumers), but also on store attributes perceived by the market (consumers)
as important in store patronage decision (Osman, 2003). Several studies in this line of
thought have examined the question of how managers can understand consumer wants
(Understanding Gap) and the difference between consumer’s wants and retailer’s
delivery, i.e. Fulfilling Gap (Pathak, Crissy and Sweitzer, 2005; Nel, 2003). These
30
gaps are rooted in the service quality GAP model theory (Parasuraman, Zeithaml and
Berry, 1985). This theory rests on the notion that consumer perception of service
quality is influenced by a series of gaps that are occurring on the marketer’s side
associated with the design, marketing, and delivery of services. Little is known how
The findings of Anic and Vouk’s (2005) study however showed six (6) store
patronage motive factors with ‘shopping convenience’ being the most important factor
for generating store traffic. Four (4) shopper groups with significantly different
shopping behaviour were identified. Since retailers’ sales level is determined by store
traffic and not by the average spending per shopper, Anic and Vouk (2005)
recommended that retailers should focus on how to increase store traffic by offering
the best package of store attributes and loyalty programmes, targeting each shopper
group differently. Another existing related study which is also relevant to this current
work is the study of Tatt (2010) themed, Factors Influencing Consumer Buying
Behaviour of Luxury Branded Goods. This author also adopted survey research design
method by using questionnaire as the tool for data collection but premised the study
on the notion that consumer shopping behaviour is usually based on dollar value and
about acquiring needed goods and service whereas modern shoppers shop otherwise
themselves feel good, show off their personality or to boost their self-esteem. In other
words, the purchased items have become an affirmation of the shoppers’ psyche.
While this line of thought is not far from Anic and Vouk’s (2005) patronage motive
study, Tatt (2010) however sought to specifically focus on how consumer buying
31
behaviour reacts with regards to luxury branded goods, and to understand whether
there is any interaction between the independent variables (Price, Perceived Quality,
Perceived Societal Status and Brand Loyalty) and moderating variable (Income) with
the dependent variable (Consumer Buying Behaviour). His findings revealed that
Perceived Social Status and Brand Loyalty are significantly related factors affecting
monthly Income does not moderate the interactions between the independent variable,
Vijayasarathy’s (2004) study is another existing related study but more related to this
current study than the foregoing reviewed ones especially because of the online
shopping scope it covered. The study was themed, “Predicting Consumer Intentions
to Use On-line Shopping: the Case for an Augment Technology Acceptance Model”.
use on-line shopping using Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) which was derived
from the theory of Reasoned Action. This theory focuses on two specific salient
beliefs — ‘ease of use’ and ‘usefulness’ and has been applied in the study of user
adoption of different technologies. The theory emerged as a reliable and robust model.
Besides the ‘ease of use’ and ‘usefulness’ constructs, Vijayasarathy (2004) offers
additional constructs in his quest for determining the increased predictive power of
beliefs, and self- efficacy. A test of this model, with the data collected from 281
32
predictors of consumers’ attitude towards on-line shopping, but privacy was not.
attitude toward on-line shopping, normative beliefs, and self-efficacy. These entire
findings however show that there are indeed some strategic implications associated
with today’s increasingly used social media networks in retail marketing particularly
those ‘internet enhanced’ ones such as facebook, Youtube, Likedin, Yahoo, 2go,
Konga.com etc, now exploit them in order to serve their customers across different
parts of the world better. The increasing growth rate of the adoption of this new
phenomenon hence spurred Boyd and Ellison (2010) to qualitatively address the
Academic researches that harness the profitable impact of the use of social media
networks in marketing practices seem to be very few let alone addressing its specific
impact on consumer patronage. Some existing closely related ones have been
empirically and conscientiously reviewed here. The existing gaps among them remain
the drive for this current study. One of which is that, there is no study to point or
address the perceptual construct of Nigerians at large toward the use of internet in
transacting business despite the menace of efraud (internet fraud) like Yahoo-yahoo.
While this has been observed as an important factor that may militate against
consumer patronage of the today emerging Nigerian online retailers, this current study
would empirically address the gap. Furthermore, ever since Jumia, Konga, Dealdey,
33
and many others have started operating like the popular Amazon (World class online
retailer), no study exists yet on the match or otherwise of the understanding and
fulfilment of consumers’ need despite that the processes involved in such commerce is
especially in Nigeria. All these are areas of interest in this current study.
and empirical reviews. In the conceptualisation part, the term ‘social media network’
was conceptualised by first defining the concepts such as; social, media, network,
social media and social networking before finally conceptualising the main term.
Social media network was conceptualised to mean those network media usually
facilitated by the internet through people around the world are connected to chat,
interact, share contacts and photos, relate with one another, etc. and are also
however follow them up through the links provided on the social media site. In
addition to this, the patronage tendency of consumers via the social media networks
media networks as the internationalization strategy among both domestic and foreign
retailers usually because of the need to enhance their competitiveness, increase their
sales and make good profits, sequel to which the rivalry between the retailers becomes
34
fiercer everyday. Owing to need for the consumers to patronize the domestic retailers
like Nigerian online retailers, the study of Laroche et. al (2005) which suggests that a
their beliefs about the product’s attributes such as quality, reliability and pricing, and
Attitude theory which explains how countries are seen in the mind of the consumers,
what beliefs and emotions towards a country they have, how this information affects
their reactions towards a country, were used to justify the stances of consumers in
patronising the retailers via social media networks. Originally, consumers mentally
process objective information about the product or retailer and form an impression of
the benefits they provide. They express the preference or lack of preference for stores,
As for the theoretical framework, the theory of Service Gap Model propounded by
Parasuraman, Zeithaml and Berry (1985) which was premised on the notion that
customers would generally have a tendency to compare the service they 'experience'
with the service they 'expect'. If the experience of this customer does not match the
expectation, there arises a gap. There are seven major potential gaps in this service
35
management perceptions. Various dimensions of service quality include: Competence,
and Responsiveness.
Of all the empirically reviewed studies, no one of them addresses the perceptual
despite the menace of efraud (internet fraud) like Yahoo-yahoo. While this might be
empirically covers this research area. Furthermore, ever since Jumia, Konga, Dealdey,
and many other online retailers have started operating in Nigeria like the popular
Amazon (World class online retailer), no study exists yet on the match or otherwise of
the understanding and fulfilment of consumers’ need despite that the processes
Delivery’. This present study looks critically into this research area also by studying
Jumia and Konga in terms of how their customers patronize via the use of social
knowledge/awareness of the online shopping in Nigeria. This research area was also
36
REFERENCES
Agichten, E., Carlos, C., Donato, D., and Aristides, G. (2008). Finding High Quality
Content in Social Media. Business Horizons, 54: 24-251
Anic, I.D., Jovancevic, R. (2004). Foreign Direct Investment in the Trade Sector in
Croatia, Nase Gospodarstvo, 50(1-2):59 – 68.
Anic, L.D. and Vouk, R. (2005). Exploring the Relationships between Store Patronage
Motives and Purchasing Outcomes for Major Shopping Trips in the Creation
Grocery Retailing. Economski Pregled, 56 (9): 634-657.
Baden, R., Bender, A., spring, N., Bhattacharjee, B., and Starin, D (2009) Persona: An
Online Social Network with User-Defined Privacy Barecelina Sigcomm
Beaudoin, P. et al. (1998). Young Fashion Leaders’ and Followers’ Attitudes toward
American and Imported Apparel, Journal of Product & Brand Management,
7(3): 193-208.
Bhuian, S.N. (1997) Saudi Consumers’ Attitudes towards European, US and Japanese
Products and Marketing Practices, European Journal of Marketing,
31(7/8):467– 486.
Boyd, D.M., and Ellison, N.B. (2010). Social Network Sites: Definition History, and
Scholarship. International Journal of Web Based Communities, 1(4): 464-474
Davis, F.D. (1989). Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease of Use and User
Acceptance of Information Technology. MIS Quarterly, 13:318-339.
Davis, F.D., Bagozzi, R.P., Warshaw, P.R. (1989). User Acceptance of computer
Technology: A Comparison of two theoretical Models. Management Science,
35 (8): 982-1003.
Dickerson, K.G. (1982) Imported Versus US Produced Apparel: Consumer Views and
Buying Patterns, Family and Consumer Sciences Research Journal, 10(3): 241-
252.
Dolwick, J.S. (2009). The ‘Social’ and Beyond: Introducing Actor Network journal of
37
Social Anthropology, 3 (2): 451-459.
Dmitrovic, T., Vida, I., Reardon J. (2009). Purchase Behavior in Favor of Domestic
Products in the West Balkans, International Business Review, 18(5): 523-535.
Ilter, B, Aykol, B., Ozgen, O. (2009). Attitudes towards Purchasing from Foreign
Apparel Retailers: The Effects of Age and Foreign Country Visits, Ege
AcademicReview, 9(1): 43-60.
Nel, D. (2003). Service Quality in a Retail Environment: Closing the Graps. Journal
of General Management, 18 (3): 37-56.
Pathak, D.S., Crissy, W.J.E. and Swettzer, R.W. (2005). Customer Image Versus the
Retailer’s Antizipated Image. Journal of Retailing 50 (4): 21-28.
Strutton, D, True, S.L, Rody, R.C (1995) Russian Consumer Perceptions of Foreign
and Domestic Consumer Goods: An Analysis of Country-of-Origin Stereotypes
with Implications for Promotions and Positioning, Journal of Marketing Theory
and Practice, Vol. 3, No.3, pp.76-87.
Tang, Q.G.U.B., and Whinston, A.B. (2012). Content Contribution for Revenue
Sharing and Reputation in Social Media: A Dynamic Structural Model. Journal
of Management Information Systems, 29:41-75
38
Branded Goods. A Research Report Completed in Partial Fulfilment of the
Requirements for the Award of Online Master of Business or Administration,
University Sains Malaysia.
39
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.0 Introduction
This chapter discussed the methods employed in carrying out this study. These include
the design for the study that is the method for its logical enquiry, the determination of
an appropriately required sample size from the population, method for data collection,
data collection instrument, its validity and reliability, and finally, the method of data
analysis.
A cross- sectional survey research design was employed for this study. The persuasive
impact of the marketing efforts of Nigerian online retailers via social media networks
could not be easily evaluated through any means other than the use of either
This study was carried out both in Enugu and Lagos states in Nigeria specifically, in
Education, Private and Public institutions. Enugu state is one of the oldest southeast
states in Nigeria created out of the old Anambra state. The capital of Enugu state is
Enugu also. It was created in August 27, 1991. It derived its name from the capital
city, ENUGU (top of the hill) which is regarded as the oldest urban area in the Igbo
speaking area of Southeast Nigeria. Lagos state on the other hand is also one of the
Colonial masters came into Nigeria first, built their colony and settled in Lagos long
40
before Nigeria’s independence. The capital of Lagos state is Ikeja. Ikeja is the hub of
Since this current work was centred on the use of social media networks for arousing
consumers’ patronages toward most of the today’s Nigerian online retailers’ product
items, the study was however carried out across the Educational institutions
Two populations for this study consist of the members of Nigerian consumers and the
marketing staff of Jumia and Konga Nigeria Ltd. The United Nations Fund for
Population Activities (UNFPA) projected population figures for Enugu and Lagos
state using Nigeria’s 2006 National Population Census figure as basis were used for
this study Enugu and Lagos states were used as the population of the members of
Nigerian consumers which were used for this study. These include: Enugu state:
4,061,808; and Lagos state: 11,493,347 both as at 2013. The total population of these
consumers however is 15,555,155. On the other hand, the population of the marketing
staffs of Jumia and Konga Nigeria Ltd are 229 and 167 respectively. Summed up, this
gives 396.
The required sample size for the survey conducted for this study was computed by
using Taro Yamane’s (1968) sample size determination formula. This was
41
𝑁
𝑛=
1 + 𝑁(𝑒 2 )
Where
N is the population;
Therefore, at 95% confidence level such that 5% is the tolerable error margin, the required
15,555,155
= = 399.99 ≈ 𝟒𝟎𝟎
38,888.89
Based on the above computation, the required sample size of Nigerian consumers for this
study is 400. These were collected from Enugu and Lagos state in the ratio of the population
of the state. These were further computed as thus using the formula;
𝑎
𝑘= x𝑛
𝑁
where
4,061,808
𝑘= x 400 = 104.449 ≈ 104
15,555,155
11,493,347
𝑘= x 400 = 295.550819 ≈ 296
15,555,155
42
As for the required sample size of the marketing staffs of Jumia and Konga, this was also
computed by using the Taro Yamane’s formula at 95% confidence level such that 5% is the
Based on the above computation, the total number of marketing staff required as sample is
199. The number that was specifically obtained from each of Jumia and Konga were
computed as thus,
For Jumia:
229
𝑘= x 199 = 115.0782 ≈ 115
396
For Konga
167
𝑘= x 199 = 83.9217 ≈ 84
396
The sample sizes determined in 3.4 above were collected from their respective sources by
using Convenience Sampling Technique. Simple Random Sampling Technique should have
been considered appropriate but the researcher lacked an existing sampling frame for the
population members in Education, Private and Public institutions. The convenience sampling
technique however allowed the researcher to choose the required samples for the survey
conveniently using his own discretion but ensured unbiasedness in all ways.
The data for this study was collected through the use of a structured questionnaire. This was
worded in two different forms: one to the Nigerian consumers who shop online while the
other one was directed at the marketing staffs of Jumia and Konga. The data were gathered
43
by the help of four (4) research assistants [three (3) in Lagos and one (1) other in Enugu
together with the researcher] who were slightly orientated on the central theme and the
2001). There are many ways this could be ascertained. This includes: face validity, content
validity, predictive validity etc. The researcher here in this study used both content validity
and face validity to find out if the research instrument is valid or not. The researcher did these
by giving out the research instrument to research experts and his research study supervisor
who helped in vetting the instrument before using it in the actual survey conducted. The
research experts ascertained the face validity of the instrument while the supervisor helped in
the aspect of content validity by correcting and putting straight some of the wordings of the
instrument.
closely related responses from the subjects (that is, the respondents) on whom it is
discussed in 3.7.1 above, there are also many ways in which the reliability of a research
instrument also could be measured, such as: Test-Retest, Split-half, Internal Consistency etc.
Here in this study, the researcher adopted the Internal Consistency method by using Cronbach
Alpha test in ascertaining the reliability of the pre-study responses collected through the
research instrument.
44
Table 3.1: Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's Alpha Cronbach's Alpha N of Items
Based on
Standardized Items
.97 .960 20
Source: SPSS version 17.0
Table 3.1 above presents the reliability test result from SPSS version 17.0 for the internal
consistency of the items on the data collection instrument using the pre – study survey
responses. With the 0.60 Alpha Coefficient, it can be deduced that the data collection
instrument is reliable.
3.8 Methods of Data Analysis
Both descriptive and inferential statistical analytical methods were employed in this study.
The descriptive methods include the use tables, frequencies, charts (Bar and Pie Charts), and
percentages in analysing the responses obtained from the opinion survey while the inferential
statistical method include the use of appropriate Test of Significance methods in the
following order of the hypotheses set for this study.
Hypothesis One
One Way Classified Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) was used for testing this hypothesis.
The justification for choosing this method and not Independent Sample T-test which is an
alternative to this method is because ANOVA statistically helps in addressing or testing the
differences among three or more sample whereas, the Independent Sample T-test can only
help to test the difference between two samples only. As for the hypothesis, the researcher
sought to know whether there is a difference in the perception of consumers (in Education,
Private and Public Institutions) towards online shopping.
Decision Rule
Reject H0 if |p < 0.05| given the value of F computed. Otherwise, accept it.
Hypothesis Two
Hypothesis two sought to ascertain the match between the online retailers’ understanding and
the fulfilment of consumers wants through the use of social media networks for e-trading. To
test this hypothesis, Pearson’s Product Moment Correlation [PPMC] was used. This method
helped to check the strength of relationship (i.e. the match) between the understanding and
the fulfilment of consumers wants.
45
Decision Rule
Reject H0 if |p < 0.05| given the value of PPMC (𝜸) computed. Otherwise, accept it.
Hypothesis Three
Hypothesis three sought to determine the extent to which Nigerian consumers patronize the
online retailers and to test this, chi-square (𝜒 2 ) was used.
Decision Rule
Reject H0 if |p < 0.05| given the value of chi-square (𝜒 2 ) computed. Otherwise, accept it.
𝑌1 = 𝛼 + 𝛽1 𝑋1 +. … + 𝑈1 ......................eq 1
𝑌2 = 𝛼 + 𝛽2 𝑋2 +. … + 𝑈2 ......................eq 2
𝑌3 = 𝛼 + 𝛽3 𝑋3 +. … + 𝑈3 ......................eq 3
Where
Equation 1 stands for hypothesis four, equation 2 for hypothesis five and equation 3 for
hypothesis six. 𝑌1 , 𝑌2 and 𝑌3 stand for consumers patronage behaviour in terms of their level
of patronage and their patronage experiences. Furthermore, 𝛼 in each of the equations above
stands for y-intercept value of the models [i.e. the consumers patronage behaviour when or
where all other factors remain constant] while 𝛽1, 𝛽2 and 𝛽3 stand as the predictors of the
independent variables 𝑋1 , 𝑋2 and 𝑋3. 𝑋1 stands for consumers’ knowledge or awareness level
of online shopping opportunities; 𝑋2 stands for online retailers’ accessibility; while 𝑋3 stands
for consumers’ subsequent orders.
Decision Rule
In each of the hypotheses, reject H0 where |p < 0.05| given the computed value of the
coefficient 𝛽 for each model.
46
REFERENCES
Elegbede, A.O. (2001). Statistics for Social Sciences. Ibadan: Ollason Publishing Co. Ltd.,
p.72
Taro, Y. (1967). Elementary Sampling Theory. New Jersey:Prentice-Hall, Inc.,
Englewood Cliffs.
47