1/17/2018 Star Wars and the Trauma of Repeating History -

ALL CATEGORIES SEX & DADS & FAMILIES SPORTS MARRIAGE ADVICE & ETHICS
RELATIONSHIPS CONFESSIONS

Home / A&E / Star Wars and the Trauma of Repeating History

Star Wars and the Trauma of Repeating History

January 5, 2016 by David Odorisio 1 Comment

How do the complex familial

attachments and separations of the Star
Wars saga mirror our own traumas and
paths to healing?
—

My response to the amount of repetition in the recent Star

×
Wars release was not one of the ‘been there, done that’ sort of

a d h k f
feeling, but a profound awareness of the tragic repetition of
history
SHARESand Sigmund Freud’s notion of the “repetition
https://goodmenproject.com/arts/star-wars-and-the-trauma-of-repeating-history-ajrt/ 1/14
1/17/2018 Star Wars and the Trauma of Repeating History -

compulsion” — an “intra-psychic anti-life force” that Freud referred to as evidence of a “death principle” he
termed Thanatos.

Donald Kalsched remarked that, “Freud was struck by the fact that both inside and outside analysis, many
people seemed caught in a compulsive repetition of self-destructive behavior — a kind of undertow which
made them seem fated for a negative destiny,” and that “Freud was so affected by the self-destructive
‘repetition compulsion’…that he proposed…a ‘death instinct’ as an equal partner in the unconscious with the…
life instinct.”

““Without the consciousness that can only come in such a process of working through [i.e., in
psychotherapy], the inner world of trauma, with its archetypal defensive processes, duplicates
itself in the patient’s outer life (repetition compulsion) in a pattern which Freud justly called
daimonic.””

In the case of The Force Awakens, this repetition is both traumatic and tragic, as the heroes and villains of the
Star Wars/Skywalker legacy are again embroiled in the eternal “hero’s journey,” the quest for deliverance from
the Mother, atonement with the Father, and reception of the “ultimate boom”: mastery of knowledge in two
worlds, both the dark side and the light.

While each of these aspects of Joseph Campbell’s “monomyth” of the hero can be considered part of any
person’s individuation process, what makes this so unique in the Star Wars series is the origination of this
myth and heroic “call to adventure” within the realms of early childhood trauma, and its repetition within an
inter-generational setting.

This is, in part, I believe, what makes Star Wars so enduring, lasting, and profound.

Here I will trace the Star Wars/Skywalker legacy through its own traumatic repetition of history through the
lens of contemporary Jungian and psychoanalytic theory.

I believe it is the repetition of trauma that actually drives the plot points forward (or backward) from one
episode to the next, and has provided the material not only for the origin story of Anakin Skywalker (Dark

https://goodmenproject.com/arts/star-wars-and-the-trauma-of-repeating-history-ajrt/ 2/14
1/17/2018 Star Wars and the Trauma of Repeating History -

Vader) but catapults Luke Skywalker, and later, Kylo Ren (Ben Solo) and Rey into their own unique “call to
adventure” in just the way that trauma and its healing does for so many of us.

♦◊♦

Trauma and the Dark Side of the Force: From Anakin Skywalker to Darth Vader
The Skywalker legacy begins with young Anakin.

Born into slavery on the remote planet of Tatooine, Anakin is “discovered” by Jedi Qui-Gon Jinn, and trained
from an early age by the legendary Jedi knight, Obi-Wan Kenobi. It is predicted that Anakin will be the one to
“restore balance to the Force,” and, similar to other archetypal figures such as Moses or Christ, carries the
projection of the Divine Child as “chosen one.”

As with Christ, Anakin is also not only “fatherless,” but immaculately conceived — in his case, by the power of
the Force.

From a psychoanalytic perspective, Anakin’s early trauma can be traced to his tragic separation from his
mother when he makes the decision to leave home at a too-late, i.e., not yet securely attached, age to train as a
Jedi. Jedi Master Yoda himself warns the Jedi council that Anakin is indeed “too old” to train, which
culminates in Yoda’s powerful foretelling:

““Fear leads to anger. Anger leads to hate. Hate leads to suffering. I sense much fear in you.””

Anakin’s fractured attachment to his mother forms the early splits in his personality that lead to his gradual
and tragic devolution to the Dark Side.

https://goodmenproject.com/arts/star-wars-and-the-trauma-of-repeating-history-ajrt/ 3/14
1/17/2018 Star Wars and the Trauma of Repeating History -

This process begins first through the transference of his broken attachment to his mother onto his first love
and eventual wife, Senator Padme Amidala. Due to his traumatic separation from his mother, Anakin is
plagued by hostile dreams, first as a premonition of his mother’s sufferings, and later of Padme dying in
childbirth.

Both of these dreams serve as prophecies that Anakin will later witness or fulfill, and will ultimately lead to
his final corruption by the Dark Side.

Anakin’s defensive structures and path to the Dark Side portray the intimate correlation between personal
and archetypal evil. It is through his very human fear of separation and loss that temptation from the Dark
Side enters into his psychic space.

Anakin’s surrogate (negative) father figure, the Emperor, promises him immortality and tempts him with the
abilities to prevent the death and suffering of those whom he loves. However, it is only because Anakin’s
attachments — and sense of self — are rooted in a primitive fear of loss that this promise has any seductive
power over him.

As a direct result of his early trauma, Anakin cannot bear the anxiety of losing those whom he loves, so-called
“abandonment fears”. In order to heal these impulses he would need to first face them consciously in his
relationship with Padme, which he could then trace to his early separation anxiety from his mother.

However, in defense against these vulnerabilities, he attempts to gain heroic control over them and “save” or
“rescue” those he loves — a codependent, fear-based strategy that brings Anakin to slaughter the tribal people
that kidnapped his mother; the death at Anakin’s hands of the young Jedi Padawan; his battle with (and defeat
by) his former mentor and positive father figure Obi-Wan Kenobi; and eventually the death of his wife Padme
who is pregnant with their twins — Luke and Leia — thus fulfilling the prophetic aspect of his tortured dream
world, and setting the stage for the repetition of history in the major plot points of the second, or “original”
Star Wars trilogy.

https://goodmenproject.com/arts/star-wars-and-the-trauma-of-repeating-history-ajrt/ 4/14
1/17/2018 Star Wars and the Trauma of Repeating History -

““[For] the victim of early trauma… disowned material is not psychically represented but has
been… relegated to discreet psychical fragments… It must never be allowed to return to
consciousness… and the dissociation necessary to insure the patient against this catastrophe, is a
deeper, archetypal split in the psyche.””

“– Donald Kalsched, The Inner World of Trauma”

Fathers and Sons

It would be too much here to trace the entire legacy of the Skywalker family from a psychoanalytic or
archetypal perspective, so I will focus on only one additional thread before tying my points back into The
Force Awakens with its own, and much more overt, traumatic repetition of history for the Skywalker clan.

While the “first” Star Wars trilogy focuses on the broken attachment and failed relationships of Anakin within
his primary relationships, culminating in Anakin’s psyche being co-opted by the Dark Side of the Force, the
“original” trilogy unpacks the relationship between fathers and sons, particularly between Luke Skywalker
and Darth Vader, as Luke first battles with — and then uncovers his own likeness to — his own “Dark Father.”
The events of this trilogy also serve as the catalyst for the traumatic repetition of history that we will later see
in The Force Awakens.

The opening setting for the original trilogy is much the same as Episode I.

Again, we are on Tatooine, the desert planet, where we find a young man, fatherless, only now being raised by
a surrogate family. Precocious, inquisitive, he also contains the strong power of the Force. Luke’s “call to
adventure” begins with the relayed hologram “call for help” from his (eventually to be discovered) sister, Leia.

In one of the most classic scenes of the original trilogy, Luke Skywalker receives training from Jedi Master
Yoda on the swamp planet of Dagobah.

During his training, Luke is taken to a dark cave. In an extraordinary moment of dialogue, Yoda says to Luke:

““That place…is strong with the dark side of the Force. A domain of evil it is. In you must go.””

““What’s in there?””““Only what you take with you.””

In one of the most psychologically astute moments of the Star Wars films, Luke encounters the roots of his
own dark history, legacy, and origins of his inter-generational trauma — his own “dark father,” Darth Vader.
Luke battles the phantom Vader, decapitates him, and then, as the mask on Vader’s helmet mists away, Luke
sees his own face as that which he fears the most.

https://goodmenproject.com/arts/star-wars-and-the-trauma-of-repeating-history-ajrt/ 5/14
1/17/2018 Star Wars and the Trauma of Repeating History -

It is through, and because of, this direct, conscious confrontation with his own personal and archetypal
darkness, that Luke is able to resist the Dark Side of the Force and defeat Darth Vader.

Luke’s battle and defeat of Vader and the destruction of the Empire does not restore balance to the Force,
however.

In an ending fit for Greek tragedy, Luke learns on Vader’s deathbed that he (Vader) is his father. This final
scene follows an earlier battle scene where Luke is “wounded” by his father and loses his hand in the struggle.
By the time of Vader’s death, as with so much of the archetypal father-son dynamic, each has taken a part of
the other, only here Luke tragically takes his father’s life.

It is a complex moment. There is a cathartic release of the dynamic tension as Luke finally defeats Vader —
only for the now infamous revelation to follow: “Luke, I am your father.”

Does this moment of conscious recognition contain a healing awareness? Does Luke’s newly discovered self-
knowledge, gained through his father’s death, lead to a liberating moment, or has it perpetuated a cycle of
further violence only to be enacted further down the road? What is the effect of the discovery of “family
secrets,” the guilt/betrayal of a parental imago, or the lingering effect of the death of an aspect of one’s self
(Luke’s metaphoric ‘loss of limb,’ for example)?

““Forgive me. I feel it again… the call to the light… Show me again, the power of the darkness,
and I will let nothing stand in our way. Show me, grandfather, and I will finish what you
started.””

“– Kylo Ren to Darth Vader’s mask in Star Wars: The Force Awakens”

The Resurgence and Evolutionary Nature of Evil

While Luke has “killed” the enemy, and resolved the external drama of the trilogy, there is a lack of resolution
to the internal and inter-generational, as well as archetypal struggle that only later unfolds in Star Wars: The
Force Awakens.

Here, for the third time, an abandoned child carries the archetypal nature of the Divine Child/Hero and is
discovered as “the one” capable of bringing restoration and balance to the Force. Only now, it’s a she.

What I want to focus on here, however, is the unresolved father wound from the Luke-Vader genealogy that
resurfaces between Kylo Ren and Han Solo. In a brief, but tragic encounter that resembles (intentionally, I
would imagine) in so many ways the meeting of Luke and Vader, we learn that Kylo Ren, a Jedi turned to the
Dark Side, is no other than the son of Han Solo and Princess Leia.

Not only this, but in a fashion identical to Anakin Skywalker (his grandfather) and Obi-Wan Kenobi, Kylo Ren
also betrays the trust and love of his mentor (Luke Skywalker), kills the remaining few Jedi knights-in-
training, and consciously adopts the personality and visage of Darth Vader.

https://goodmenproject.com/arts/star-wars-and-the-trauma-of-repeating-history-ajrt/ 6/14
1/17/2018 Star Wars and the Trauma of Repeating History -

Kylo Ren is, in other words, consciously perpetuating the legacy and trauma of his family tree.

Additionally, he takes part in re-creating what for all intent and purposes is a glorified version of the Death
Star, which is identically destroyed in the same way of the Death Star by the rebel fleet. Additionally, the
lighting, acting, effects, props, and dialogue are cast almost entirely with a conscious nod toward the “original”
trilogy.

It is “retro-throwback” at its best, but it is quintessentially bittersweet, because it brings us face to face with
the current historical reality of our own personal and political scene. It “projects” onto a very big screen, with a
psychological depth often unparalleled in Hollywood, the painful and glaring realities of our own personal
and social repetitions of trauma.

“One of these things is like the other.” And those “others” are eerily similar to those who preceded them.

A father unconsciously attempts to kill the spirit of his son because the son won’t follow in his father’s
footsteps. So the son unconsciously — or unknowingly — kills his father. And then it happens again. Only this
time, consciously, coldly, and with much calculation. The darkness increases as personal trauma transforms —
slowly at first — then ever more quickly, into evil.

Perpetuated by the insecure and the scared, the traumatized inner child who takes his revenge as the all-
powerful Sith Lord, or Darth Vader, or Kylo Ren, or…

Who will the shadowy face of the next generation’s Dark Side be? Because it could be you. Or it could be me.
As personal trauma bleeds into archetypal evil. As more scared and fearful young men and women become
radicalized into terrorist religions.

The list grows long.

The only way out is to search within. Like Luke Skywalker in the cave of the evil, each of us must begin the
slow descent to conscious confrontation of our own inner demons. Only unlike Luke, may we not miss the
point. Just because we see our face in the dark mask of evil, it does not necessitate evil’s ultimate or vengeful
slaying.

Because, as we learn from Star Wars and the repetition trauma of history, evil never, ever does a “once and for
all” stage exit.

““It is where you are from. What you are made of. The Dark Side — and the Light.””

“– Snoke to Kylo Ren in Star Wars: The Force Awakens”

Personal Trauma, Archetypal Evil, and the Repetition of History

As I mentioned in opening, what I believe makes Star Wars such an enduring legacy is its creative portrayal of
the inter-penetration and cross-pollination surrounding personal trauma, archetypal evil, and the historical

https://goodmenproject.com/arts/star-wars-and-the-trauma-of-repeating-history-ajrt/ 7/14
1/17/2018 Star Wars and the Trauma of Repeating History -

repetition of trauma.

Personal trauma can be understood as anything from the “trauma of everyday life” to the kinds of unbearable
or “unendurable” experiences that happen to a person typically at a very young developmental age and cause
splitting and other defensive structures later in life. Anakin’s early separation from his mother is an example
of this.

Star Wars is rife, however, with examples of archetypal evil, which forms the basic structure of the series’
underlying plot — the battle of good/light over or against evil/darkness.

In Jung’s psychology of the unconscious, influenced heavily by early Christian Gnosticism and Chinese
Daoism, forces of light and dark inter-play and must be held in check or “balanced” in order to restore order to
the psyche (i.e., “The Force”). When one or the other of these forces win out over the other, there will
eventually be an enantiodromia — which means that if one aspect of the archetypal pairing goes too far to one
extreme, it spills over, becoming its opposite.

Star Wars portrays this principle magnificently as the entire crux of the galactic project is a balancing of the
forces of good and evil. What it depends on, however, is who is balancing these forces — the Jedi or the
Sith/Empire/First Order — and what their intent or purpose is — balance and harmony vs. a reign of darkness.

♦◊♦

Evil is an ever-present part of our political and social discourse these days, and will only become
more so as time progresses.
“Evil,” a term that was once used in the realm of theologians, has become common political and social parlance.
Star Wars shows us over the course of a multi-generational legacy that evil begins in the home through
personal trauma that takes on underlying — and eventually insidious — archetypal and daimonic powers as it
progresses.

What I believe is the yet-to-be-learned lesson from Star Wars is that evil, like trauma, cannot be conquered or
destroyed, it can only be healed through conscious integration, and therapeutic intervention.

If traumatic evil, whether personal or collective, is attempted to be forcefully or “heroically” overcome, it will
only return the stronger. That is the lesson of contemporary cinema from Star Wars to Lord of the Rings to the
Thor, Batman, X-Men movies, etc. What we still have yet to learn — collectively and in our cinema — is that
the only way to “end” evil is to integrate it.

This approach, to act hospitable in the face of our enemies, both within and without, is perhaps one of the
most challenging stances a person could take in modern society. And yet it is the only way. To heal collective
trauma is to bring it back home to its place of origination and necessitates a primary return to the self. When
we project our fear outwards, it turns to anger against another, and anger leads to suffering. Much suffering.

This is the as yet unlearned lesson that the Star Wars legacy challenges us to reach.

https://goodmenproject.com/arts/star-wars-and-the-trauma-of-repeating-history-ajrt/ 8/14
1/17/2018 Star Wars and the Trauma of Repeating History -

Photo credit: Flickr/57bLWy

YOU MAY LIKE Ads by Revcontent

Eddie Murphy's House Is So Secured Millions of People Are Cancelling Doing This Before Bed Could Help You
That Alcatraz Looks Like A Paradise Their Net lix Account Because of This Regrow Your Hair (Watch This)
Re nance Gold One Site Healthtoday
How Finance Daily

The Richest Doctor In The World Pillars of Eternity - Hero Edition PC Historical Photos Nearly Destroyed
Finally Reveals His Networth $11.99 - CD KEYS US Forever
Bradofo.com WrestleDrop

Filed Under: A&E, Featured Content

Tagged With: A & E, David Odorisio, Featured Content, Freud, history repeats itself, intergenerational cycle of trauma,
intergenerational trauma, Jung, Jungian archetypes, life force, PTSD, star wars, thanatos, The Force, The Force
Awakens, trauma

https://goodmenproject.com/arts/star-wars-and-the-trauma-of-repeating-history-ajrt/ 9/14
1/17/2018 Star Wars and the Trauma of Repeating History -

About David Odorisio

KENOBI: A Star Red Sparrow: Why Tiny Things 7 Reasons Why I'm
Wars Story - First Official Trailer [HD] About Our Done with Star
Look Trailer... 20th Century FOX - Partners Drive... Wars -

‘Star Wars: The ‘It has a real 6 Leadership How to Build a

Last Jedi’: This is spiritual depth to Lessons from Lightsaber Prop
the Leaked Plot,... it’: Will ‘Star... Ender's Game - from Home...

Leave a Reply

1 Comment on "Star Wars and the Trauma of Repeating History"

Join the discussion

Sort by:  newest|oldest|most voted

Vren07  

“In an ending fit for Greek tragedy, Luke learns on Vader’s deathbed that he (Vader) is his father. This final
scene follows an earlier battle scene where Luke is “wounded” by his father and loses his hand in the struggle.
Guest
By the time of Vader’s death, as with so much of the archetypal father-son dynamic, each has taken a part of
the other, only here Luke tragically takes his father’s life.” Are you sure you’ve watched Star Wars? Luke learns
that Vader is his father in episode V, long before Vader is “on his deathbed. In fact, he has to… Read more »

 0     1 year 4 months ago

https://goodmenproject.com/arts/star-wars-and-the-trauma-of-repeating-history-ajrt/ 10/14
1/17/2018 Star Wars and the Trauma of Repeating History -

TRENDING POSTS

The Dad Body: An Owner's Guide

Health & Wellness

A Guy’s Guide to the Gender-Minimized First Date

Editors' Picks

An Open Invitation to ‘Grace’ to Go on the Date you Should Have Had

Ethics & Values

H&M’s 'Monkey Business' & Trump’s '$#!*Hole' ... Happy MLK Day
Social Justice

I'm an Evolving 21st Century Man

Advice & Confessions

Trump's 'Sh*thole Countries' Commentary: A Metaphor for Centuries of Foreign Policy

Ethics & Values

Good People Don’t Defend a Bad Man

Ethics & Values

My Dudes, Nothing Tastes Sweeter than Her Enthusiastic Consent

Ethics & Values

Why Are So Many Men Out of Work and What You Can Do to Keep Your Job
Advice & Confessions

Does Facebook Cheapen Relationships?

Sex & Relationships

https://goodmenproject.com/arts/star-wars-and-the-trauma-of-repeating-history-ajrt/ 11/14
1/17/2018 Star Wars and the Trauma of Repeating History -

FEATURED CONTENT

https://goodmenproject.com/arts/star-wars-and-the-trauma-of-repeating-history-ajrt/ 12/14
1/17/2018 Star Wars and the Trauma of Repeating History -

Relationship Closure: What To Do When You Don’t Get It

“Closure” brings things full circle a ter a relationship ends. What happens when it isn’t available?

14 minutes ago

Practical Conversations About Single Parenting, Independent Women, and the

Evolving Roles of Men
“When you become a dad, it’s as if some part of your heart gets unlocked, and you begin to yearn for emotions you’ve never had before.”

44 minutes ago

https://goodmenproject.com/arts/star-wars-and-the-trauma-of-repeating-history-ajrt/ 13/14
1/17/2018 Star Wars and the Trauma of Repeating History -

Trump is the Child of White Male Immunity

Each morning that I awaken to Trump’s continued presence in the Oval O ce is a hard knee to the gut.

1 hour ago

https://goodmenproject.com/arts/star-wars-and-the-trauma-of-repeating-history-ajrt/ 14/14