Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
grin.com/document/280463
TABLE OF CONTENT
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
TABLE OF CONTENT
LIST OF TABLES
LIST OF FIGURES
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
CHAPTER-1 INTROCUCTION
1.1 Background of the Construction Industry
1. 2 Statement of the Problem
1. 3 Objective of the Study
1.5 Limitation of the Study
References :
Bibliography:
APPENDICES :
Annex A : Figure of Special Purpose of Company
Annex B :Requirement of Machine & Equipment as per CBR
Annex C : List of Class A Contractors
Annex D :Overall Standard Meeting of Equipment as per CBA 2055 & CBR 2056 by Class
A Firms
3/40
LIST OF TABLES
2.1 Classification of Construction Firms in 1974 & 1999 as per Bidding Limit (In Million’s)
4.6 Status of Machine & Equipment Capacity of Class A Entrepreneurs as per CBA 2055 &
CBR 2056
4.9 Annual Turnover of Class A Construction Entrepreneurs for F.Y 069/070 , F.Y 068/069
& 067/068
4.15 Difficulties Felt in Revenue & Taxation Part by Class A Construction Entrepreneurs
4.16 Difficulties Felt in Hiring Qualified Human Resource in Different Construction Sector by
Class A Construction Entrepreneurs
4.17 Insecure Felt During Stages of Tender Purchase, Tender Drop and Construction Site
Execution Works by Class A Construction Entrepreneurs
LIST OF FIGURES
2.1 Distribution of Foreign Aid Disbursement per Policy Cluster of the Three Year Plan
4.6 Annual Turnover of Class A Construction Entrepreneurs for F.Y 069/070 , F.Y 068/069
& 067/068
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
illustration not visible in this excerpt
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
It is realized that Nepalese construction had undertaken a high rise in its image
internationally and nationally and has been participating in various organization as an active
member. Besides these, there are many rumours and conflicts about the capability of
Nepalese contractors about their technical and financial ability for not completing the
projects undertaken by them within the given timeframe and of standard quality. Although
construction entrepreneur of Class A in Nepal, have the opportunities to withstand in
construction industry (as country is still in construction phase of infrastructure
development) with full enthusiasm and effort, they seems to be demoralized by the policies,
rules, guidance and support from the government and procedure of procurement of donor
agencies during bidding in Mega Projects.
The study has covered construction firms registered as class A construction entrepreneur.
The numbers of construction firms studied were fifty one (51). Random sampling method
was performed to select the respondents. A questionnaire was developed to collect the
datas for the study. The close ended question, open ended question, and ranking method
of prioritization was adopted to obtain the necessary datas from the respondents.
The purpose of the study was to compare the existing equipment capabilities of Class A
construction entrepreneurs with the prescribed requirement as per CBA 2055 & CBR 2056
and also to determine the current capacity of the class A construction entrepreneurs in
terms of technical and financial capabilities. The study also has covered the exploration of
common problems and difficulties felt in criteria of achieving qualification documents during
bidding procedure , receiving payment during payment schedule, , taxation part, hiring
5/40
qualified human resource in different construction sector and insecure felt during stages of
tender purchase, tender drop and construction site execution works by class A construction
entrepreneurs.
Percentage, frequency and charts were used to analyze the data. The result has showed
that, in owning equipments most of the companies have failed to meet the prescribed
standard as per CBA 2055 & CBR 2056. Only few numbers of contractors are extremely
satisfied with their business. There are various factors like annual turnover & similar
experience part in qualification procedure, escalated amount & running bill payment in
payment procedure, insecurity due to hooliganism in construction business during site
execution and tender drop, taxation system during refunding of the tax deducted at source
amount. The research has also shown the unavailability of human resources in tunnel
sector, hydropower sector and bridge sector in construction sector in present context.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I wish to express my gratitude to my advisor, Assoc. Prof. Er. Ramesh Banstola,
Coordinator of M.Sc. Program in PEC, who guided and helped me greatly to complete my
thesis.
I am also deeply indebted to Dr. Prof. Rajendra Prasad Adhikari, whose guidance from
initial phase upon this completion had broaden mine vision more in setting up my objective
more clearly on my research.
My heartful thanks goes to my father Mr. Mohan Prasad Adhikari, proprietor of Mangsuwa
Nirman Sewa, for supporting me morally from my initial phase of this research till to the final
publication.
I would also like to thank Mr.Keshab Prasad Gautam, vice-president of FCAN who helped
me in providing his valuable suggestion and in arranging meetings with contractors for my
necessary data collection. Also, I would like to thank all the official staff member of FCAN,
who has provided me the necessary information that I have asked at any time.
I would also thank to my brother, Mr. Hem Kumar Adhikari, for his support in using
SPSS.16 software during data analysis. I shall not forget my friends Er.Ujjwal Dahal, Er.
Sandeep Gyawali and Mr. Jyoti Khatri for their help in distribution and collection of
questionnaire. I am also highly debted to my friend Er. Sunder Adhikari for his help in
everyway by providing me environment during preparation of final report.
To my wife Jyoti Shiwakoti for her spiritual support through prayers and encouragement, I
thank you for providing me environment of study.
Lastly my sincere thanks goes to all who, in various ways have helped to make my
research work complete especially contractors who were respondents to my questionnaire.
16 March, 2014
Suresh Adhikari
6/40
CHAPTER-1 INTRODUCTION
This industry is one of the major contributors to the process of the development of the
country. The wide range of output provides the basis for social and economic development
of many sectors. In addition, it also stimulates significant economic development through
its backward and forward linkages like manufacturing, transportation and other sectors of
the economy. Contractors are one of the most significant enteritis within the industry. They
are the ones who actually convert the designed facility into a tangible output. Much of the
resources are spent through them and success of the project is heavily dependent on the
firm’s competence (Pandey, 2069).
Nepalese construction industry has taken a leap since 1990s with significant growth in the
number of construction and consulting firms. However, we need to actively wok on the
capacity building of all the stakeholders in the industry especially at the dawn of the nation
building efforts that could evolve the end of current political transition period (Pandey,
2069).
The licensing and classification of contractors came into practise after implementation of
the construction classification Regulation in 1975 as Class A, B, C & D respectively
depending upon their physical facilities, resources and experience which again was
amendment in 1994 and 1999.
i) The major challenges for the contractor is to complete project within the given timeframe
with quality, which is seen difficult in most of the cases and may be due to the unavailability
of owned full time technical personal, equipments or financial resources by the concerned
firms.
ii) Most of the reputed and well established contractors are being harrased by the different
political parties and holligans for large sum of money, which inturn has created insecurity
among these contractors. Also, inconsistent and ineffective price escalation techniques
used by the governments and unfavourable contract documents to contractors and high
7/40
unhealthy competition during tendering due to current policies, rules and guidance had lead
the contractor to get demoralized towards the profession. As a result, many of the firms
registered as Class A who are responsible to undertake high active role and participation
towards building the nation seems not being as active as they owned to be.
iii) Construction industry being root for the development of infrastructure of the nation and
Class A contractor being the major party to perform such role for development activities, no
thorough study about the current status of Class A contractor has been done so far.
iv) Also, current data about the Class A contractor in terms of their technical and financial
capacity strength is unknown in order to perform or execution of construction projects.
Thus, these are the main problem to be identified during the research study.
i) To compare the existing equipment capacity of class “A” construction entrepreneurs with
the prescribed requirements as per CBA 2055 & CBR 2056 ii) To find out the financial
capabilities of class “A” construction entrepreneurs. iii) To explore the common problems
and difficulties felt in criteria of achieving qualification documents during bidding procedure,
receiving payment during payment schedule, taxation part, hiring qualified human resource
in different construction sector and insecure felt due to hooliganisms during stages of
tender purchase, tender drop and construction site execution works by Class A construction
entrepreneurs.
i) The respondents of the study are presumed to provide all the relevant and valuable
information during the research and unbiased.
ii) This study has excluded the status of lab equipment as mentioned in machine and
equipment defined by schedule-10 in CBA 2055 & CBR 2056.
iii) This study has not cover bank statement in order to find out the financial capabilities of
the Class A registered firms.
iv) This study has only considered civil engineer, junior engineer, accountant and
supervisor in determining the human resources available with Class A construction
entrepreneurs.
8/40
CHAPTER-2 LITERATURE REVIEW
Public Roads Act, 2031 , Local Self Governance Act 2054 and Regulations 2055 ,Public
Procurement Acts 2063 and Regulations 2064 , Contract Act, 2023 and 2058 , Construction
Industry Acts 2055 , Private Investment in infrastructure, Build and Operate Ordinance 2060
, BOOT Acts 2063 and Regulations 2064 ,Roads Board Act 2059 , Engineering Council
Acts 2055 and Regulations 2057 , Road Sector Policy 1999 , Public Infrastructure Build,
Operate and Transfer Policy 2057 ,Priority Investment Plan 1997- 2007, Priority Investment
Plan 2007 - 2017, The Department of Roads Strategy 1995, Road Maintenance Training
Policy 2001, Human Resource Development Policies and Strategy 2002 ,Bridge
maintenance Policy, 2004 , Consulting Industry Acts (Development phase)
(www.scaef.org.np).
9/40
i) To grant construction business license.
ii) To renew the license granted, maintain inventory of the revenue from renewal, prepare
financial statements and have revenue earnings audited.
iii) To maintain updated records and data of the firms, companies or corporate bodies
carrying on construction business.
iv) To give necessary direction and carry out monitoring in order to maintain quality
standards of public construction works and enhance and upgrade capabilities of
construction entrepreneurs.
v) To act as member secretary of the implementation committee in respect of promotion
and management of construction business.
vi) To monitor implementation of the prevailing Acts and Regulations for the promotion of
construction business, and take necessary action to make it further effective
(www.cbps.gov.np).
10/40
According to Development Corporation Report (DCR) F.Y 2010/011 foreign aid plays an
important role in Nepal’s socio-economic development, representing 26 percent of the
national budget. In addition, significant aid flows are channelled directly to beneficiaries
outside the national budget. The main sectors receiving external support are education,
local development, health, roads followed by drinking water, energy, agriculture, and peace
and rehabilitation. Various economic and financial reform programs also receive significant
external support.
Also the DCR report has mentioned that Nepal receives official development assistance
from over 40 donors, including 35 resident agencies. About half of aid resources use
national systems such as the budget or procurement systems, and a significant portion of
aid is spent outside national systems. The Ministry of Finance is mandated for the overall
coordination of foreign aid in Nepal, including its allocation in line with national priorities.
The Foreign Aid Coordination Division (FACD) of the Ministry of Finance is empowered,
among others, to oversee the Government's activities in the area of aid coordination,
harmonization and alignment. The FACD of the Ministry is the focal point for this purpose.
The FACD has also been acting as the secretariat to the high level committee on foreign
aid coordination and mobilization and provides technical input to the committee in the
implementation of foreign aid policy.
Figure 2.1: Distribution of Foreign Aid Disbursements per Policy Cluster of the Three Year
Plan (Source: www.mof.gov.np)
a) Turnkey projects
b) Loan projects
Turnkey projects are implemented by the donor countries or agencies themselves. Such
projects are formally handed over to the government on completion. The government
provides the land required for individual projects and makes available other facilities such
as customs and taxation concessions and import licences. With such projects, the
procurement of construction material, award of contracts and execution of works are the
responsibility of the respective donors. Projects being implemented through loans are also
financed jointly by the government and donor agencies. The proportion of funds to be
contributed from each of these sources is determined when individual agreements are
signed. Donor agencies provide most of the finance for civil works, procurement of
equipment and consulting services.
Also the (ASOSAI) report mentioned that for large projects assisted by external agencies,
competitive bids are invited internationally for construction and the procurement of
machinery and consultancy services according to the official guidelines of donor agencies.
Bids received are evaluated by a technical committee of the respective ministry and
11/40
approved by the competent authority based on the provisions of the government's Financial
Administration Rules. However, concurrence of the particular agency involved is also
required for bid approvals. Project identification, feasibility studies, investment criteria,
budgeting, funding and implementation procedures are common for all public works and
projects. These procedures are guided by the existing financial rules and regulations of the
government. Public works and projects carried out with external assistance are also guided
by the terms and conditions of the particular agreement signed between the government
and the donor agency (ASOSAI, Sep 1995) (www.asosai.org) .
The first act which defined ‘Contractor’ was the Industrial Enterprises Act, 1974(A.D). It
made provision for the classification and registration of contractor. According to this act, all
construction firms must register themselves with the Ministry of Works and Transport in
Class A, B, C or D contractors depending upon the technical manpower, value and number
of works done, machinery and liquid assets available.
Industrial Enterprises Act 1974 provided for registration and classification of contractors.
Accordingly contractors were classified as Class A, B, C and D depending upon their
physical facilities, resources and experience.
The licensing and classification of the contractors came into practice after implementation
of the construction classification Regulation in 1975. There were twice amendment of the
regulation in 1994 and 1999.
Table 2.1: Classification of Construction Firms in 1974 & 1999 as per Bidding Limit (In
Millions)
But, there is a debate regarding classification of contractors. The debating article is 10.3 of
the act PPA 2063 & PPR 2064 which ignores the existing bidding limit of contractors by
classification for the qualification criteria. Despite of this debate still the classification of
contractor has been defined by CBA 2055 & CBR 2056 during registration of firms.
Realizing the need for enhancement of the construction industry, Construction Business
Act CBA 2055 was promulgated and came into force from Baishak 1, 2056 (April 14, 1999).
This is an effort made to institutionalize and systematize the construction sector. The act
had defined the procedures and requirement relating to issues and renew of license and
classification of obligation of construction entrepreneurs (FCAN 2007, vol. 14.).
12/40
construction entrepreneur as Class A, Class B, Class C and Class D according to in
Construction Business Rule CBR, 2056(2000A.D) Schedule10, Schedule-11, Schedule-12
and Schedule-13 respectively.
To be Class A ‘A’ construction entrepreneur as defined by CBA (2055) & CBR (2056) in
Schedule-10, the following criteria must be meet by the registered firms:
Provided that, nothing in this clause shall be deemed to prevent the classifying of a
company having at least Two civil engineers with at least Twenty years of experience in
public construction works or of a company with an engineer or equivalent being its
shareholder or promoter, having experiences in construction works valued at Sixty million
rupees in last Ten years as the class “A” construction entrepreneur.
Description of Key Human Resources: There should be a provision to avail the whole time
service of two technicians having passed graduation level in civil engineering and four
technicians having passed certificate level in that subject, Two persons having passed
graduation level in any subject, three persons having passed certificate level in any subject,
one person having passed graduation level in commerce and one person having passed
certificate level in that subject.
Machine and Equipment: The checklist for machine and equipment as per CBA 2055 &
CBR 2056 has been attached in Annex-B.
13/40
According to PPR 2064, “A public Entity may, in specifying the criteria for qualification of a
bidder or a pre-qualified proponent participating in procurement proceeding of a
construction work above six million, specify such criteria by taking into account any one or
all of the following matters according to necessity” ( PPR, 2064).
Namely two methods of qualification procedure are followed depending upon project
sensitivity. i) Post qualification ii) Prequalification
i) Postqalification
An assessment made by the employer after the evaluation of bids and immediately prior to
award of contract, to ensure that the lowest-evaluated, responsive eligible bidder is
qualified to perform the contract in accordance with previously specified qualification
requirements ( SPD, 2009).
ii) Prequalification
An assessment made by the Employer of the appropriate level of experience and capacity
of firms expressing interest in undertaking a particular contract, before inviting them to bid
(SPD, 2009).
Applicants should demonstrate that they have successfully carried out work, substantially of
a nature, size, value, and complexity similar to that of the contract in question. There are
two principal criteria for prequalification.
(a) The Applicant should have carried out similar work of a magnitude approximating that of
the package of Work for which prequalification is sought. Depending on the nature of the
works to be bid, the criterion should be related to the Applicant having completed or
substantially completed one or more contracts each of a value (not less than about 80
percent) of that of the proposed contract over the last five to ten years.
(b) The Applicant should have performed operations of a volume, quality, and rate of
execution similar to those required for the timely completion of the subject contract. For
example, where large-volume earthmoving, tunnelling, or concrete placing is involved, the
applicant should demonstrate experience in those operations, having performed them at the
rates necessary to meet a percentage (e.g., 80 percent) of the estimated peak monthly
and/or annual rates required for the subject contract.
14/40
The range should be one to three (and is normally two), depending on the size and
complexity of the subject contract. For example, for small- to medium-sized contracts in a
country with newly privatized, but competitive construction firms (which have had some
experience as parastatals), an employer may be prepared to risk an award to an applicant
with only one previous similar contract completed. For contracts in a developed
environment with a high potential supply of construction services, three similar contracts
may not limit applications, but would reduce the risk of contractor default. The range is
normally five to ten years, and should be related to the number of similar contracts stated
above and to the duration of the subject contract, e.g., ten years for two contracts of about
five years’ duration, or six years for two contracts of about three years’ duration (SPD,
2009).
2.1.6.1.2 Turnover
Turnover for construction works of or above the threshold as referred to in the bidding
documents. Generally, turnover represents the total revenue received by the company. ie.,
Sale of goods, Service Revenues (depending upon the nature of the business) and here
mainly concerned with supplies and construction works of public entities (PPR, 2064).
The time period is normally five years or more, but may be reduced to not less than three
years (in agreement with the Financing Agency) under special circumstances, such as to
provide opportunities for new coming construction entrepreneurs for more competition, etc.
The amount stated should normally not be less than 1.5 to 2 times the estimated annual
turnover or cash flow in the proposed works contract (based on a straight-line projection of
the employer's estimated cost over the contract duration). The multiplier of 2 may be
reduced to 1.5 times but should not be less than 1.5.The number of years is normally ten
years but not less than three years (in agreement with the Financing Agency). Also clarify
whether the annual turnover amount of past years are evaluated in the current year with
inflation/ price index. Clarification on whether the average annual turnover for ten years is
considered or average of best three years annual turnover is considered in the evaluation
(SPD, 2009).
Calculate the construction cash flow requirement for a number of months (to the nearest
half-month), determined as the total time needed by the employer to pay a contractor’s
invoice, allowing for (a) the time of construction, from the beginning of the month invoiced,
(b) the time needed by the engineer to issue the monthly payment certificate, (c) the time
needed by the employer to pay the amount certified, and (d) a contingency period of one
month to allow for unforeseen delays. The total period should not exceed six months. The
assessment of the monthly amount should be based on a straight-line projection of the
estimated cash flow requirement over the particular contract period, neglecting the effect of
any advance payment and retention monies (SPD, 2009).
Minimum Bid Capacity (BC) to meet cash flow requirement for this and other contract
commitment through the leveraged value of the applicant’s available resources: [ enter
amount equal to the value of the work]
Where,
Bid Capacity (BC) = 5× total financial resources - 40% of total contract value of current
commitments
The Applicant’s Net Worth calculated, as the difference between Total Assets and Total
Liabilities, from the audited balance sheets of the last [ insert No. of years] should be
positive (SPD, 2009).
16/40
to specify that certain positions are filled by individuals who have held posts of comparable
authority for, say, three years with the applicant, so that key staff in executive site positions
have sufficient knowledge of the applicant's management, policy, procedures, and practices
to act with confidence and authority within that framework ( SPD,2009).
17/40
2.1.7.4 Security Money
Security Money refers to the performance security amount and fifty percent amount
retention money deducted that is five percent of the running bills specified which shall be
returned back after expiry of the defects liability period. The remaining fifty percent amount
of the retention money shall be paid after the concerned supplier, construction
entrepreneurs or service provider, as the case may be, submits evidential documents of
having submitted income return issued from the concerned Inland Revenue Office.
Provided that if the concerned construction entrepreneur does not correct the defects
liability period, the public entity may correct the defects by using the retention money or the
amount for security (SPD, 2009).
Also it has mentioned that PPP is regarded as the revolutionary approach towards
infrastructure development which pulling in resources, pulling in expertise, maximizing
service delivery, magnifying scope opportunities and creates the employment opportunities
for the contractors also. The following are regarded as the prospective PPP projects now in
Nepal.
i) Ordinary Member
ii) Associate Member
iii) Honorary Member
i) All the registered Regional and District Level Contractors’ Associations are capable to get
the Ordinary Membership of FCAN. Till this date all 5 Regional Contractors' Associations
and 75 District Contractors' Associations are associated with FCAN.
ii) Associated Members are those construction firms/companies, which have taken direct
membership from FCAN. Currently more than 275 firms and companies are registered
under this category.
iii) The Executive Board of FCAN may grant the Honorary Membership to those person,
firm, company, institution or any international organization who has done specific
contribution towards the field of construction business, science, technical know how or
national development.( www.fcan.org.np)
According to article ‘Contractors warned for work delay’ published on Himalayan times daily
newspaper dated Nov 15, 2011, the Ministry of Physical Planning and Works has issued a
warning to 151 contractors and seven consultants for delaying various projects, including
bridge and road construction. “The ministry has published the names of contractors and
consultants who have not made expected progress in projects that have already been
launched,” said Suman Sharma, spokesperson for the ministry. “If they do not complete the
projects on time, we will take legal action against them,” he added
(www.thehimalayantimes.com).
According to article ‘Development projects run late due to slow govermrnt, contractors’
published on ekantipur.com dated April 16, 2013, the 50th annual report from Office of the
Auditor General (OAG), Out of the 1,748 contracts of type big and small awarded under 10
government agencies, the deadlines for 1,518 projects were extended in the last fiscal
year. The time extensions ranged from 50 percent of the original period for 572 projects to
50-100 percent for 581 projects. The time limit was doubled for 365 projects. “This show a
weakness in contract management and upgrading managerial capacity is essential,” the
report states (www.ekantipur.com).
According to an article ‘Kalika Construction bags FCAN's Class 'A' Gold Award’ published
in online magazine ‘Housing Nepal’ dated on Dec 9,2012, Bishnu Bhai Shrestha, vice
president of FCAN, said emphasizing on the government´s role to make contractors are
more efficient, contractors said that there were many opportunities within and outside the
country. "We just need a supportive bureaucracy and policies to work constantly". Also in
same heading, Bikram Pandey, chairman of Kalika Construction said the government was
not supportive to uplift the quality of the contractors within the country. The government
imposes unnecessary criteria in the bidding process to avoid participation of domestic
contractors. (www.housingnepal.com).
Deepak Bhattarai argues that specializing in one area is more important than classification
of contractor from D to A. For example in macro level there is a need of Building Contractor,
Road Contractor, Pavement Contractor, Bridge Contractor, Tunnel Contractor, Hydropower
Contractor or similar specialist contractor then in such case quality would enhance at
competitive cost also. Therefore he have thought about Super Speciality Contractors which
would lead a construction industry to a new height (FCAN Journal, 2012).
3.2 Data Collection: All the information were collected by using various
sources like primary and secondary sources.
- Primary Sources: Primary sources of the study had included the sources like
questionnaires survey via direct interview and online interview with the respondents
selecting 30 % randomly from the list of class “A” contractors provided by the FCAN i.e. 30
% of total 194 of population is 59 number of Class A contractor which was taken as
respondents sample for questionnaire survey.
- Secondary Sources: Additional information are collected through secondary sources such
as : related websites, a journal of Federation of Contractor’s Associations of Nepal which is
from Nepalese Construction Souvenir (Volume-1 to Volume 18) ,Construction News from
Tri-annually Published Magazine from FCAN , daily national newspapers and others related
published or unpublished materials such as thesis & reports.
3.3 Population of the Study: The population of the study includes all the Class A
contractors of Nepal i.e 194 Class A contractors/construction company of Nepal as being
listed in FCAN journal, Vol. 18, 2012 .(Annex C)
3.4 Sample of the Study: For the sample size, 30 % of total population i.e. 59 numbers of
registered Class A contractor had been chosen by random sampling method, from the list
of total population 194 as listed in FCAN Journal, Vol. 18, 2012.
3.5 Research Instrument: The instrument used in collecting data was through prepared
questionnaire which was prepared after thorough study of literature review so that the
defined objective of this purpose of research is fulfilled. The method followed during
distribution of questionnaire was in the following ways:
- Explaining to respondents that the information they have provided shall be kept very
confidential and shall be used for the research purpose only where overall data shall only
be presented in research report rather then single firm’s information.
- Also, questionnaires were made to fill up by the concerned office representative personal
(Engineers and Accountants) after permission from the managing directors and directors of
the firms in the cases where the concerned respondents were unavailable to fill up by
themselves.
The questionnaire contains four major section which includes general information of firms,
technical information, financial information & problems, difficulties and satisfaction under
which sub-section information are provided for respondents to fill up to obtain the
objectives of the research. The first part, general information includes about the partners
status and specialization of the firms in construction sector. The second part, technical
information includes equipments hold by the firm as reference with the prescribed
requirement defined by CBA 2055 & CBR 2056. In this part, the firm answered only the
22/40
quantity of equipments they owns in whatever condition they acquired. The human
resources available in the firm include only the numbers of engineers, junior engineer,
supervisors, accountant and general labor. The third part financial capability includes the
turnover of the firm of the three fiscal years 2069/70, 2068/069, 2068/067 B.S. , credit limit
and permanent overdraft of the firm. The fourth part common problem and difficulties
includes the questionnaire regarding satisfaction and common problems and that Class A
construction entrepreneur are being mostly tackled with. Also, for satisfaction question
respondents were asked to indicate with 5-point Likert-type rating scale: 1=Not at all
satisfied, 2=Slightly satisfied, 3=Somewhat satisfied, 4=Very satisfied, 5=Extremely
satisfied. Also for other ranking question respondents were asked to rank by their priority
that they have felt during their business.
As shown in figure 4.1, 37.3 % of the firms of Class A construction companies includes
family member as partners in the firm where as again 37.3 % includes partners as other
than family. Similarily, percentage of firms that has both family member and professional
members as partners is 19.6 % and 5.8% of the construction companies is either owned by
single investor respectively.
The figure 4.2 depicts that out of the total respondents, 49% consists of active partners and
the remaining 51 % of companies are operated by single entreprenuers.
Generally, there are many sectors in which any firm can take part in construction work of
interested area after meeting specific criteria of qualification. But there has also been argue
that there is a need of Building Contractor, Road Contractor, Pavement Contractor, Bridge
Contractor, Tunnel Contractor, Hydropower Contractor or similar specialist contractor so as
to enhance at competitive cost also.
24/40
Table 4.3: Experience on Specialized Construction of Work by Class A Construction
Entrepreneurs
As shown in figure. 4.3, 7.8 % of the firm are specialized in particular construction works
where as, remaining 92.2 % of the firm are engaged in two or more than two areas of
construction work.
Figure 4.4: Work Experience Sector of Class A Construction Entrepreneurs Source: Field
Survey, 2013.
Table 4.5: Budget for Fiscal Year 2013/014 in Major Infrastructure Projects
Source: http://www.nepalenergyforum.com/
Figure 4.5: Budget for Fiscal Year 2013/014 in Major Infrastructure Projects
Source: http://www.nepalenergyforum.com/
25/40
highest amount of budget is for the energy sector among other infrastructure development
and the participant of contractors are very few in number as compare to other
infrastructures.
A machine is a tool that consists of one or more parts, and uses energy to meet a particular
goal. Machines are usually powered by mechanical, chemical, thermal, or electrical means,
and are often motorized. Construction equipment refers to heavy- duty vehicles, specially
designed for executing construction tasks, most frequently ones involving earthwork
operations. They are also known as, heavy machines, heavy trucks, construction
equipment, engineering equipment, heavy vehicles, or heavy hydraulics.
Table 4.6: Status of Machine & Equipment Capacity of Class A Entrepreneurs as per CBA
2055 & CBR 2056
Table 4.6 shows that only 33.3 % of the respondents out of 51 respondents seem to meet
the standard as prescribed by CBA 2055 & CBR 2056. (Annex-D)
Human resources are the set of individuals who make up the workforce of an organization,
business sector, or economy. Human resources in construction sector generally refers to
the various personal like civil engineers, overseers, supervisors, accountant, general
labour, various equipment operators etc.
Table 4. 8 shows that overall average numbers of civil engineer held by Class A firm is
2.92, junior engineer 3.25, accountant 2.06 and supervisor is 5.08.
Turnover represents the total Revenue received by the company. ie., Sale of goods,
Service Revenues (depending upon the nature of the business) and here mainly concerned
with supplies and construction works of public entities. (PPR, 2064).
Table 4.9 : Annual Turnover of Class A Construction Entrepreneurs for F.Y 069/070 , F.Y
068/069 & 067/068
Figure 4.6: Annual Turnover of Class A Construction Entrepreneurs for F.Y 069/070 , F.Y
068/069 & 067/068
Figure 4.6 shows that the majority of number of Class A firm’s annual turnover is below 10
crore and is by 64.52 % of firms in F/Y 067/068, 51.61 % in F/Y 068/069 and 61.29 % in
F/Y 069/070. From table 4.9 it is also seen that numbers of firms having annual turnover in
the recent three fiscal years above 20 crore is very less in number.
A credit limit is the maximum amount of credit that a financial institution or other lender will
extend to a debtor for a particular line of credit by mortgaging the properties. It is also
known as credit line, line of credit, or a trade line.
As shown in figure 4.7, most of the firms have the credit limit between 5 to 10 crore (50.9 %
respondents) where as, only 11.8 % of the firms have credit limit above 10 crore.
A bank overdraft is a credit agreement made with a financial institution that permits an
account holder to use or withdraw more than they have in their account, without exceeding
a specified maximum negative balance, by mortgaging their properties. Establishing an
overdraft facility with a bank can help an individual or small business with short term cash
flow problems.
27/40
Table 4.11 : Bank Overdraft of Class A Construction Entrepreneurs
As shown in figure 4.8, most of the firms have overdraft below 1 crores (62.74 %
respondents) whereas, only 1.97 % of the firms have overdraft above 10 crore.
29.41 % of the respondents has overdraft between 1 to 5crore. Also from fig.4.8 it is seen
that 5.88 % of the respondents has overdraft of 5 to 10 crore .
Fig.4.9 shows that construction entrepreneurs who are slightly satisfied and somewhat
satisfied with their business is 33.33 % out of 51 respondents while those who are very
satisfied is 11.8 %. From figure 4.9 it is seen that construction entrepreneurs who are not at
all satisfied is 17.6 % and extremely satisfied is only 3.9 % out of 51 respondents.
28/40
Table 4.13 : Difficulties Felt in Criteria of Achieving Qualification Documents During Bidding
Procedure by Class A Construction Entrepreneurs
From Table 4.13, it is seen that the weighted average mean of 12.24 is highest for the
annual turnover and second highest 11.38 for similar nature of work experience in
prequalification part of bidding documents by the respondents.
Similarly from Table 4.13, it is seen that the weighted average mean for equipment
required is 9.19, manpower engaged is 7.05, credit line information is 6.81 and bid security
is 4.33 giving the third, fourth, fifth and sixth priority finding difficulties in prequalification part
of bidding documents by the respondents.
From Table 4.14, it is seen that the weighted average mean of 10.48 is highest for the
escalation amount and second highest 9.86 for running bill payments in the process of
payment procedure made by public entities.
Similarly from Table 4.14, it is seen that the weighted average mean for final bill payment is
8.90, bonus amount is 8.81, refunding of the security amount is 8.14 and advance payment
is 4.95 giving the third, fourth, fifth and sixth priority finding difficulties in the process of
payment procedure made by public entities.
29/40
Table 4.15: Difficulties Felt in Revenue & Taxation Part by Class A Construction
Entrepreneurs
From Table 4.15, it is seen that the weighted average mean of 12.23 is highest for the
refund of the tax deducted at source amount and second highest 10.57 for obtaining tax
clearance certificate in the part of taxation process.
Similarly from Table 4.15, it is seen that the weighted average mean for issuance of license
is 9.24, registration at vat office is 7.81, yearly renewal of firm is 7.71 and monthly tax
submission at revenue office is 6.14 giving the third, fourth, fifth and sixth priority finding
difficulties in the listed taxation parts.
Table 4.16 : Difficulties Felt in Hiring Qualified Human Resource in Different Construction
Sector by Class A Construction Entrepreneurs
From Table 4.16, it is seen that the weighted average mean of 11.79 is highest for the
tunnel sector and second highest 10.57 for hydropower sector in the part of manpower
unavailability as felt by Class A contractors.
Similarly from Table 4.16, it is seen that the weighted average mean for bridge sector is
8.21, road sector is 6.04, irrigation sector is 5.32, water supply sector is 4.61 and building
sector is 4.46 giving the third, fourth, fifth , sixth and seventh priority in the part of
manpower unavailability as felt by Class A contractors.
30/40
A notice for invitation to bids or prequalification proposals shall have to be published in a
daily newspaper of national circulation and, in the case of an international bid, it may also
be published in any international communication media. Then, interested firms shall
purchase the tender document from concerned offices upon submission of specified
amount providing along with the necessary documents like registration certificate of a firm,
organization or company, value added Tax registration certificate and permanent account
number (PAN) registration certificate, tax clearance certificate and a written declaration
made by bidder with a statement that he/she is eligible to participate in the procurement
proceeding. Due to the hooliganism that had entered into the tendering process in
contractor profession, it has become very difficult for most of the interested contractor for
even to purchase tender document from concerned authority.
Table 4.17 : Insecure Felt due to Hooliganism During Stages of Tender Purchase, Tender
Drop and Construction Site Execution Works by Class A Construction Entrepreneurs
From Table 4.17, it is seen that the weighted average mean of 21 is highest for the
construction site execution, second highest 19.83 for tender document drop and third
highest 10.17 for tender document purchase.
6.1 Conclusion
6.1.2 Existing Equipment Capacity of Class A Entrepreneurs as per CBA 2055 &
CBR 2056
- Most of the construction entrepreneurs of Class A firm (66.7 %) in Nepal does not meet
the standards of equipment as prescribed by CBA 2055 & CBR 2056.
- Most of the firm(51 % to 64 %) has the annual turnover below ten crore on viewing the
recent three fiscal years F.Y 069/070, 068/069 & 067/068
- The credit limit for most of the firm (50.9 %) ranges between five to ten crore.
- Most of the firm(62.74 %) has the overdraft facility below one crore.
- Most of the construction entrepreneur (96.1 %) is not extremely satisfied with the current
situation ongoing in their business.
6.2 Recommendation
6.2.2 Equipment Capacity of Class A Entrepreneurs as per CBA 2055 & CBR
- It was clear from the study that most of the firm were not following the standards to own
heavy equipments, which means they are using these heavy equipments on rent or
outsourcing from other. This means that these firm are still not following the standards on
the ownsership of equipments as prescribed by CBA 2055 and CBR 2056. Hence these
companies need to consider in purchse and ownership of heavy equipment as per the
prescribed standards of CBA 2055 & CBR 2056. There should be a systematic monitoring
system for to maintain the standard of equipment of class A contractors after the issuance
of license as class A .
Furthermore, this study enclose particular scope. There can be requisite for a further
research into other areas in the construction entrepreneur’s status. The following
recommendations are suggested for future research on:
References:
Bhattarai, Deepak, (2069, Mangsir), The Neplease Construction Industry is at Risk,
Nepalese Construction Souvernir , Vol: 18, No.21, Federation of Contractors’ Associations
of Nepal (FCAN), Kathmandu
35/40
Deoja, B.B, Adhikari R.P, and B.R Pandey, Prospects and Approaches to Public Private
Partnership in Transport Infrastructure(August 2009), Economic Policy Network
Lama, Ang Dorje, 2002. “Present Status of ‘A’ Class Contractors in Nepal and Qualification
Criteria for them” Centre for Post Graduate Studies, Nepal Engineering College
Pandey, Birendra Raj ( 2069, Mangsir,), Capacity Building of Construction Industry- Project
Level, Nepalese Construction Souvernir , Vol: 18, No.21, Federation of Contractors’
Associations of Nepal (FCAN), Kathmandu
http://scaef.org.np/conference/conference/pdf/Session-3/2.%20Tulasi%20Sitaula%20-
%20Theme.pdf cited on 2013-05-28
http://www.asosai.org/R_P_auditpublicworks_projects/chapter_15_nepal.htm cited on
2013-15-18
http://www.myrepublica.com/portal/index.php?action=news_details&news_id=45497 cited
at 2013-05-20
http://www.thehimalayantimes.com/fullNews.php?headline=Contractors+warned+for
+work+delay++&NewsID=309390 cited at 2013-05-22
http://www.ekantipur.com/2013/04/16/development/development-projects-run-late- due-to-
slow-govt-contractors/370063.html cited at 2013-05-24
http://stats.kkk.com.np/2013/04/08/business/two-more-infra-projects-under-ppp-
model/369671.html cited at 2013-05-24
http://www.housingnepal.com/news/national/kalika-construction-bags-fcans-class-a- gold-
award cited at 2013-05-28
http://www.abhiyan.com.np/article-
thecorporate_vol2_Issue51_mainnews1#.UZ8l_XWNFzU cited at 2013-05-24
36/40
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brain_drain cited at 2013-09-20
http://www.nepalenergyforum.com/govt-emphasizes-hydropower-infrastructure-
development/cited at 2014-01-09
Bibliography:
Journal of Federation of Contractor Associations of Nepal (FCAN), “Volume; 9,
no.12,Feburary 2000” ; “Volume 17,no.20, September 2011”; “Volume 18 , no.21,
November 2012”
Appendices
Annex-A
(Figure of Special Purpose of Company)
Annex-B
(Requirements of Machine & Equipments as per CBA 2055 & CBR 2056 for Class A
Construction Entrepreneurs)
Annex-C
(List of Class A Contractors affliated with District Association)
Annex-D
(Overall Standard meeting of equipments as per prescribed in CBA 2055 & CBA 2056 by
Class A Firms)
Equipment Analysis
37/40
Annex-E
(Questionnaire for Contractors)
The research is being undertaken by Mr. Suresh Adhikari, a third semester student in MSc.
Construction Management. This study is being undertaken to identify the “Status of Class A
Construction Entrepreneurs in Nepal of Nepalese Construction Industry”. You are kindly
requested to participate by completing the questionnaire. The information you provide will
be used together with other information to come out with finding, suggestions and
recommendations on finding Status of Class A Contractors.
It is hoped that you will complete the questionnaire as frankly and honestly as possible.
Please be assured that your responses will be treated as confidential and used only for the
purpose of this research study only.
Thank you.
Note: Please [illustration not visible in this excerpt] wherever is correct. For subjective
question, please provide answer with specific response.
While ranking the answers please start from lower values of ranking number as quoted in
each of the questions. Eg. 1,2,3,4,5,…. and so on. The lowest numerical means highest
priority & highest numerical means lowest priority. For example numeric value 1 means the
most priority you have given, 2 means less priority you have given, 3 means least priority
you have given and so on.
Address:
A. General Information
2. Are all partners listed in your company registration actively working in the firm?
3. Has your firm only worked under a particular construction area (specialized) (eg.
Building, Road, Bridge etc. Only one sector) construction, from the date of establishment of
your firm?
4. Please provide the information about the nature of works that your firm had constructed
from the date of establishment till present. Please mention
38/40
illustration not visible in this excerpt
B. Technical Information
5 . Please provide the information about equipments and machineries your company has
been holding till the date.
C. Financial Information
8. Please list out the present credit limit of yours firm in Nrs..
10. Are you satisfied with your profession as Class A construction entrepreneur. Please
rank .The lowest numerical means highest priority & highest numerical means lowest
priority.
Please mention which of the following parameter has been hindering you for being not
satisfied. Please rank .The lowest numerical means highest priority & highest numerical
means lowest priority.
11. Please mention which part of tender document you feel as tough pre-qualification
procedure as per your experience. Please rank .The lowest numerical means highest
priority & highest numerical means lowest priority
12. Please mention in which part of payment procedure you have been delayed during
project run from employer as per your experience. Please rank .The lowest numerical
39/40
means highest priority & highest numerical means lowest priority.
13. Please mention where have you felt not insecure during your profession as per your
experience. Please rank .The lowest numerical means highest priority & highest numerical
means lowest priority.
14. Please rank the part of taxation system you have found has been tough in your
profession as per your experience .The lowest numerical means highest priority & highest
numerical means lowest priority.
15. Please mention the sector where s you found deficit (unavailability) of skilled manpower
during execution of project as per your experience. Please rank .The lowest numerical
means highest priority & highest numerical means lowest priority.
16. Please suggest based on your experience in Construction Field, how can we uplift the
profession of Class A contractor in future. Please rank .The lowest numerical means
highest priority & highest numerical means lowest priority.
40/40