Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
It’s a HIIT!
by Michele Olson, Ph.D., FACSM, CSCS
A PRELUDE TO TABATA V THE EARLY STUDIES The results of Dr. Tabata’s study were
U
sually, it’s the music, movie, or fashion similar to Dr. Tremblay’s in that the improve-
industry that evolves one-name iconic ments experienced by the 4-minute HIIT group
identities such as ‘‘Madonna,’’ ‘‘Bono,’’ were remarkable given the mark of the 4-minute
or ‘‘Oprah.’’ But, even nonexercisers are fully exercise sessions. Comparing changes in cardi-
aware of the name ‘‘Tabata’’ and the sweat and orespiratory fitness (as measured by oxygen
exercise effort that the name implies! So, it is uptake, V̇O2max) between the Tabata (HIIT)
interesting that it was 18 years ago when group and a group that did 60-minute ET
Dr. Izumi Tabata from the University of sessions, the Tabata group experienced similar
Ritsumeikan in Japan published the results of a significant increases in fitness despite spending
high-intensity interval training (HIIT) protocol much less time engaged in exercise. For
that incorporated brief, supramaximal, 20-second accuracy, it should be noted that the HIIT
intervals into a 4-minute exercise bout. Although group did the 4-minute supramaximal interval
just 4 minutes in duration, Tabata yielded a sessions 4 times a week at 170% of V̇O2max and
notable improvement in aerobic fitness (10). also performed one 30-minute endurance ses-
Another early, yet still frequently referred to, sion on a separate day each week. The ET
HIIT study that also showed marked changes in participants did their sessions at a moderate
fitness dates back to 1994 (13). In this study, intensity (70% of V̇O2max) for 60 minutes 5 days
despite doing shorter exercise sessions that per week. Like the 1994 study of Tremblay
actually burned less calories, the group that did et al., the weekly amount of exercise undertaken
HIIT sessions lost substantially more body fat in Tabata’s HIIT group was remarkably lower at
compared with a second group of participants only 46 minutes compared with 300 minutes for
who trained for longer durations doing steady- the ET group.
state, continuous, endurance exercise (ET). Although these studies were published about
Although somewhat controversial, lead author 20 years ago, their counterintuitive results were
VOL. 18/ NO. 5 ACSM’s HEALTH & FITNESS JOURNALA 17
Copyright © 2014 American College of Sports Medicine. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Tabata
clearly precursors for prompting more research on HIIT. These initial HIIT. However, in a 2013 study, nonathletes who did one short,
studies also served as models for HIIT strategies and techniques that intense, 4-minute bout on treadmills at 90% of heart rate max,
are used more than ever in the real world of fitness today. Table 1 3 times a week, significantly increased cardiorespiratory
presents a number of HIIT studies and shows the changes in fitness by 10%. No adverse events were reported (12).
cardiorespiratory fitness and body composition (5,10,11,13). Within, Specifically, HIIT workouts generally alternate ‘‘effort’’ or
and even across studies, the changes in V̇O2max are quite similar. ‘‘burst’’ intervals, typically ranging between approximately 10
Once again though, it is important to remember that the HIIT groups, and 60 seconds, with ‘‘recovery’’ or ‘‘rest’’ intervals. Recovery
like the subjects in the Tabata study, did substantially less exercise intervals can vary but most often also span 10 to 60 seconds. In
and expended fewer calories than the ET groups. Therefore, the addition, the nature of the recovery intervals can range from full
contention that Tabata and HIIT could produce similar or even rest, which is during Tabata (2,10,13), or be composed of low-
superior changes in fitness, and do it fast, was demonstrated early on. to moderate- intensity movement (e.g., 4). See Table 2.
Both the Tabata and Tremblay studies (as well as many to follow) Because cycle ergometers and treadmills can both be set at precise
used stationary cycles equipped with ergometers for training. Cycles intensity levels, they are ideal for research and serious conditioning
with calibrated ergometers (i.e., work meters) can measure and where pinpoint precision is a must (i.e., 5,8,10,11,13,14). Consider
regulate exercise intensity accurately, which ensure that athletes or the original Tabata format that imposed an intensity effort of 170%
research participants exercise at a very precise and individually maximum. That intensity would be virtually impossible to
based exercise intensity. The precision to which exercise intensity reproduce without specialized equipment and also be unnecessarily
is monitored closely and maintained is related directly to the intense for nonathletes (Tabata used Olympic speed skaters in his
newsworthy changes in fitness and study outcomes. The original study). Likewise then, the changes in fitness found in well-
Tabata protocol, as noted previously, was done with a controlled scientific HIIT studies like the Tabata study may not
supramaximal effort. Each participant performed 8 rounds of always be duplicated in fitness and health club settings. This is
20-second HIIT intervals at 170% of V̇O2max with 10 seconds of important because Tabata is often promoted and advertised in the
downtime. Especially at this intensity, an aerobic-type modality media to produce incredible changes in fitness based on the
able to measure work performed is necessary to ensure that the original study. Yet, most trainers and health clubs actually are using
exercise effort put forth by each individual is 70% higher than modified forms of Tabata that elicit an intensity far below 170% of
the maximum aerobic power, which is a full-on anaerobic effort! V̇O2max. For instance, two Tabata-style formats developed and
Given this level of intensity, Tabata found that the HIIT group not tested in 2013 by Olson (9) and Emberts et al. (3) were found to
only experienced significant improvements in aerobic fitness but produce intensities of 95% and 74% of V̇O2max, respectively.
incurred major strides in anaerobic power too. In fact, the group Although these modified formats are sufficiently intense to
who did ET showed no change in anaerobic fitness, whereas the promote fitness effectively in a short time, it would be erroneous
HIIT group exhibited a 28% improvement in anaerobic fitness. to assume that the changes induced with power intensities would
parallel those seen for the original Tabata protocol directly.
TABATA OR HIIT? However, trainers readily can use the Tabata-style format
Although often used interchangeably, HIIT stands for ‘‘high- and/or many scientifically established HIIT protocols as models
intensity interval training’’ and is a model of ramped up aerobic to develop realistic interval programs using common gym
conditioning done close to maximum exercise intensity, that is, equipment. For instance, Dr. Melanie Hood’s team developed
equal to or greater than 90% V̇O2peak (4). Competitive athletes, and tested a 20-minute format alternating 60 seconds of aerobic
to enhance both aerobic and anaerobic endurance while cardio exercise at an intensity of approximately 80% of heart
matching the intensity and rapid bioenergetic shifts that rate reserve (80% to 95% range) with 60 seconds of recovery
frequently occur in sports and competition, commonly use (6) for 10 rounds. Using a heart rate monitor, this format could
Copyright © 2014 American College of Sports Medicine. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
TABLE 2: Published Research on HIIT, Tabata, and Tabata-Style Formats
Author (Year) Effort:Recovery Intervals Intensity Exercise Volume Modality
Tabata et al. (1996)+ 20:10 seconds Tabata 170% of max 4 minutes Cycle ergometer
Tremblay et al. (1994)* Short 30:HR 125 BPM 70% to 90% max 15 rounds Cycle ergometer
Long 90:HR 125 BPM 70% to 90% max 4 to 5 rounds Cycle ergometer
Trapp et al. (2008)** 8:12 seconds 960% max 20 minutes Cycle ergometer
Burgomaster et al. (2008)+ 30:270 seconds Supramax Wingate’s 4 to 6 rounds Cycle ergometer
Zong et al. (2013)*** 20:10 seconds Tabata 170% of max 3.5 minutes Cycle + treadmill
Little et al. (2010) 60:75 seconds 95% of max 8 to 12 rounds Cycle ergometer
Olson (2013) 20:10 seconds Tabata-style 95% of max 4 minutes Squat jumps
Hood et al. (2011) 60:60 seconds 80% to 95% HRR 20 minutes Cycle ergometer
Emberts et al. (2013) 20:10 seconds Tabata-style 74% of max 16 minutes Body weight circuits
+
Studies used anaerobic or supramaximal interval training.
*Participants did shorter 30-second effort intervals alternated by days composed of longer 90-second effort intervals. HR was allowed to drop to approximately
125 BPM before starting the next round.
**Participants’ initial exercise intensity was 60% of max, which was increased individually throughout the study based on a plateau in exercise HR at each level
of intensity.
***Participants alternated cycle ergometry with treadmill ergometry for each round.
be used readily with a variety of aerobic-type exercises and supramaximal Tabata anaerobic effort. The aerobic HIIT formats
machines such as running/jogging, elliptical trainers, electronic also can prove more ‘‘user-friendly’’ and suitable for the general
stair steppers, jump ropes, spin cycles, aerobic step-up benches, fitness setting while still being quite economical on time requiring
and so on. See Table 2, which shows the exercise equipment/ no more than minutes to complete. The following section provides
modalities that were used by the protocols (3,9). more detail and examples of Tabata and HIIT strategies that
combine good science with effective and more achievable formats.
AEROBIC OR ANAEROBIC? As always, any intense workout, like Tabata, should be preceded by
As previously noted, the intensity of HIIT is well above moderate at a proper warm-up and cool-down (see Sidebar, Prepare to Tabata).
approximately 90% of V̇O2max or higher. ‘‘Supra’’ intense
(supramaximal) formats include not only the original Tabata
PREPARE TO TABATA
format but also the formats developed and studied by Burgomaster
et al. (2) and Zong et al. (14) (Table 2). Because supramaximal First, break a sweat! Incorporate a 10-minute dynamic warm-up with
protocols are done with a full-on anaerobic effort, the actual jumping jacks, jogging in place, or similar multimuscle activities
volume of exercise is almost shockingly low V between approxi- before tackling 8 rounds of 20-second Tabata intervals.
mately 4 and 12 minutes. In sport training and conditioning,
athletes who must perform repeated bursts with an all-out effort
can benefit from these supramaximal HIIT protocols such as TABATA HITS THE GYM
Tabata because they match the athletes’ more extreme perfor- Classes and workouts ranging from Tabata Boot Camps to Tabata
mance needs and improve both aerobic and all-important Spin and Tabata circuit classes are multiplying. The exercise
anaerobic fitness. video market and many magazines regularly feature Tabata-style
Table 2 illustrates that many HIIT formats can require less programs that can be done in the gym, at a fitness park, or even at
than a maximal or supramaximal Tabata-like effort. For instance, home. The 20/10-second effort/rest Tabata format is simple, and
exercise physiologists Little et al. (8) and Hood et al. (6) adapted the 4-minute bout makes it easy to organize when creating
the pure anaerobic format by Burgomaster et al. (2) by reducing workouts that have multiple, submaximal, 4-minute bouts. For
the intensity and increasing the length of the effort intervals from example, the Tabata-style format developed and tested by
30 seconds to 60 seconds. Olson used body weight squat jumps Emberts et al. (3), although not requiring the intensity of the
with the Tabata 20-second effort and 10-second rest format. All original Tabata protocol (74% of max vs. 170% of max), has
three of these modified formats (6,8,9), although not four circuits. Although the intensity also is lower than the 90%
supramaximal, are not ‘‘soft,’’ though, on intensity. Table 2 shows of maximum criterion generally afforded for aerobic HIIT (4),
that these three formats can produce a high intensity effort (80% to Emberts’ workout is a robust 16-minute circuit-like format that
95% of max) and are labeled more appropriately ‘‘aerobic’’ burns an appreciable number of calories and includes a variety
interval training formats because they do not rely on a 100%+ of exercises nicely grouped into 4-minute segments. Here are
VOL. 18/ NO. 5 ACSM’s HEALTH & FITNESS JOURNALA 19
Copyright © 2014 American College of Sports Medicine. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Tabata
two of the four bouts featured in the report that first featured
this particular Tabata-style circuit workout (3).
Specifically, each exercise in a segment is done for 20 seconds
at high effort, followed by 10 seconds of downtime, then
repeated. All segments last 1 minute and are separated by just
10 seconds. After an entire (4-minute) bout is completed, there is
a 1-minute rest period before starting the next bout.
Bout 1
Segment 1: High Knee Run
Segment 2: Plank Punch
Segment 3: Jumping Jacks
Segment 4: Side Skaters
Bout 2 Spider push-up 1.
Copyright © 2014 American College of Sports Medicine. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Photos courtesy of Auburn University Montgomery.
13 women. Therefore, when corrected for the difference in body for improving cardiorespiratory fitness and modifying body
weight for men versus women and the difference in intensity composition. The intensity of Olson’s format is clearly in the HIIT
between the studies of Emberts et al. and Olson, a woman range (990% of max). However, the format of Emberts et al. is
weighing 140 lbs would burn approximately 11.1 calories per longer, using multiple 4-minute bouts, which yields a higher total
minute with the Tabata-style circuit workout of Emberts et al. caloric expenditure. These Tabata-style workouts and their diversity
and 12.2 calories per minute with Olson’s body weight squat in intensity, duration, and exercise movements illustrate how
jump format. For a heavier male body weight (i.e., 185 lbs), the trainers can select and organize a range of Tabata-inspired
calories expended would be about 15.5 per minute for the workout workouts depending on the needed intensity, such as training a
of Emberts et al. and 16.1 per minute for Olson’s 4-minute squat ‘‘Weekend Warrior,’’ competitive athlete, or apparently healthy
jump format. Both formats exceed the minimum recommendations adult whose quest is improved health and better overall fitness.
Copyright © 2014 American College of Sports Medicine. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Tabata
Speed skater 2.
Copyright © 2014 American College of Sports Medicine. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Photo courtesy of Auburn University Montgomery.
the muscles are able to use greater amounts of fat for fuel,
which, in turn, reduces the risk of cardiovascular and related
cardiometabolic diseases such as Type 2 diabetes. Therefore,
the overall impact of supershort 3- and 4-minute Tabata-style
workouts on metabolism is not only a greater efficiency in
energy expenditure but also the ability to use fat effectively
even at rest is increased.
Copyright © 2014 American College of Sports Medicine. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Tabata
and health fitness specialists should consider the needs, goals, 14. Zong YU, Y, Tsuji K, Iemitsu M, et al. Effects of two days with
high-intensity intermittent cross training on maximal oxygen uptake.
and appropriateness of Tabata when using it with athletes, In: Proceedings of the 60th ACSM Annual Meeting and 4th World
nonathletes, and those who may have health risks. Further- Congress on Exercise is Medicine. Indianapolis (IN): ACSM; 2013:171.
more, the additional health benefits afforded by Tabata-style
HIIT workouts also should be considered when designing the
format. Those who can benefit from this particular version of Recommended Readings
HIIT may extend beyond individuals who simply desire to Boutcher S. High-intensity intermittent exercise and fat loss. J Obes.
improve their fitness fast. For those who have body weight 2011;2011:868305 [Epub 2010 Nov 24].
concerns as well as risk factors for and/or facets of
Disclosure: The author declares no conflicts of interest and
compromised cardiometabolic health, Tabata could very well
does not have any financial disclosures.
be a ‘‘hit.’’
Michele Olson, Ph.D., FACSM, CSCS, is a
professor of exercise physiology at Auburn
References University Montgomery and a primary inves-
1. Babraj JA, Vollaard NBJ, Keast C, Guppy FM, Cottrell G, Timmons JA. tigator at the Scharff-Olson Kinesiology Labo-
Extremely short duration high intensity interval training substantially ratory where her research has focused on the
improves insulin action in young healthy males. BMC Endocr Disord.
2009;9(3):1Y24.
energy cost of well-known activities, including
spinning, step aerobics, Pilates, and Tabata.
2. Burgomaster KA, Howarth KR, Phillips M, et al. Similar metabolic
adaptations during exercise after low volume sprint interval and Olson also has published electromyographic
traditional endurance training in humans. J Physiol. 2008;586:151Y60. studies on yoga, Pilates, and programs marketed to train the core
3. Emberts T, Porcario JP, Steffen J, et al. Is Tabata all it’s cracked up to be? and abs. Her interest in body image includes research on eating
ACE Prosource. 2013;Oct:1Y4. disorders in active women and exercise leaders.
4. Gibala MJ, McGee SL. Metabolic adaptations to short-term high-intensity
interval training: a little pain for a lot of gain? Exerc Sport Sci Rev.
2008;36(2):58Y63. BRIDGING THE GAP
5. Helgerud J, Hoydal K, Wang E, et al. Aerobic high-intensity intervals
improve V̇O2max more than moderate training. Med Sci Sports Exerc. Tabata, like HIIT, is an exercise format that alternates
2007;39(4):665Y71. relatively brief periods of intense exercise, often called
6. Hood MS, Little JP, Tarnopolsky MA, et al. Low-volume interval ‘‘effort’’ intervals, with periods of rest or less-intense
training improves muscle oxidative capacity in sedentary adults. Med Sci
exercise, known as ‘‘recovery’’ intervals. Tabata is one of
Sports Exerc. 2011;43(10):1849Y56.
the most popular forms of shorter HIIT workouts and was
7. Ingle S. The Tabata workout programme: harder, faster, fitter, quicker?
The Guardian [Internet]. 2013 [cited March 24, 2014]. Available from: first popularized by Dr. Izumi Tabata. Dr. Tabata coupled
http://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2013/mar/25/tabata-harder-faster- 20 seconds of ‘‘supramaximal’’ anaerobic effort with just 10
fitter-quicker. seconds of recovery for 8 rounds, making the exercise
8. Little JP, Safdar AS, Wilkin GP, et al. A practical model of low-volume session quite short. At just 4 minutes in duration, Tabata’s
high-intensity interval training induces mitochondrial biogenesis in
research showed that this exercise protocol delivers
human skeletal muscle: potential mechanisms. J Physiol. 2010;588:
1011Y22. impressive changes in fitness. Modified Tabata workouts
9. Olson M. Tabata interval exercise: energy expenditure and post-exercise that range between 4 and 20 minutes in duration can be
responses. In: Proceedings of the 60th ACSM Annual Meeting and 4th less intense but still robust (i.e., 74% to 95% of max) such
World Congress on Exercise is Medicine. Indianapolis (IN): ACSM; as Tabata-style circuits. Research shows that Tabata and
2013:171.
HIIT produce similar changes in cardiovascular fitness, have
10. Tabata I, Nishimura K, Kouzaki M, et al. Effects of moderate-intensity the potential to improve body composition, and can even
endurance and high-intensity intermittent training on anaerobic capacity
and V̇O2max. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1996;28(10):1327Y30. ameliorate risk factors such as insulin action in far less time
11. Trapp EG, Chisholm DJ, Freund J, et al. The effects of high-intensity
compared with traditional, moderate-intensity, steady-state
intermittent exercise training on fat loss and fasting insulin levels in 30- to 40-minute cardio sessions. When implementing
young women. Int J Obes. 2008;32:684Y91. Tabata and Tabata-style HIIT workouts, trainers should
12. Tjonna AE, Leinan IM, Bartnes AT, et al. Low- and high-volume of determine the appropriateness of this intense type of
intensive endurance training significantly improves maximal oxygen interval training for a given client or group and select the
uptake after 10 weeks of training in healthy men. PLoS ONE. 2013;8(5):
365282.
volume, intensity, and specific exercise activities that best
match the needs and capabilities of the participant(s).
13. Tremblay A, Simoneau JA, Bouchard C. Impact of exercise intensity on
body fatness and skeletal muscle metabolism. Metab Clin Exp. 1994;43(7):
814Y8.
Copyright © 2014 American College of Sports Medicine. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.