Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
The study assessed body image satisfaction with diet, body mass index (BMI), waist circumference
(WC), waist-hip ratio (WHR), age, income, and education among 251 women in a depressed
urban barangay. Results showed that most women were younger, had low education, and had
no occupation. Using BMI, 28.7% were overweight and obese, and 11.6% were underweight.
Using WHR and WC, 59% and 13.5%, respectively, were at risk. Six out of ten women were
not satisfied with their body image. Nutrient intake and adequacy between women who
were satisfied and those who were not satisfied with their body image were not significantly
different. Adequacy of intake was below the Recommend Energy and Nutrient Intake (RENI)
for most nutrients except niacin. Women satisfied with their body image had lower BMI, WC,
and WHR. Body image satisfaction was associated with BMI, WC, and WHR but WHR was
the only significant variable affecting image satisfaction. Android or central body adiposity
affects body image satisfaction among women because of the change in body shape brought
by fat deposition.
Key Words: body image, body mass index, nutrient intake-adequacy, urban Filipino women,
waist-hip ratio, waste circumference
on measures of eating disorders, body dissatisfaction, One study conducted by Hawks et al. (2005) among
ascetism, drive for thinness, and perfectionism. It has working women in Bacolod revealed that a significant
been acknowledged from the results of a longitudinal number of women were unnecessarily concerned about
study of the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute reducing body size, and that this attitude was associated
that weight concerns and a drive for thinness at ages 11 with eating disorder attitudes and restrictive dieting
to12 are important risk factors leading to daily smoking behaviors. Studies of this kind may contribute to better
at ages 18 to19 years (NIH 2002). understanding of the relationship between body image
satisfaction among economically depressed women with
Studies show that cultural diversity in body image exists. their dietary intake, age, annual income, education and,
Black and white women differed regarding their ethnic obesity indices. Moreover, there is a need to establish
group’s ideal body image and their perceptions of how if there is such an existing body image dissatisfaction
they compared with their ideal body image (Mciza et among depressed urban Filipino women, in order to
al. 2005; Pan 2000; Perez et al. 2003). Women who guide nutrition planners plan for appropriate programs
perceived themselves as bigger or smaller than the and intervention to alleviate conditions associated with
ideal body size for their ethnic group showed bulimic overweight and obesity.
symptoms (Perez et al. 2003). Caucasian and Hispanic
Americans were found to exhibit more weight-related The study generally aimed to assess the relationship of
body image disturbance than African-Americans and body image satisfaction with dietary intake, obesity indices
Asian-Americans. Studies are needed to determine such as body mass index (BMI), waist circumference
whether the association between body dissatisfaction (WC), waist-hip ratio (WHR), and socio-demographic
and disordered eating attitude holds in various socio- factors (age and annual income) among economically
economic groups in developing countries. depressed urban Filipino women. Specifically, it aimed
to: (1) determine the socio-demographic characteristics
Foreign studies have shown that poverty and food of the women; (2) determine intake of nutrients among
insecurity without hunger may be contributing factors women who were satisfied and not satisfied with their
to adult obesity. The study of Drewnowski and Specter body image; (3) compare body mass index (BMI), waist
(2004) stated that the highest rates of obesity occur among circumference (WC), and waist-hip ratio (WHR) of
population groups with the highest poverty rates and respondents by body image satisfaction; and (4) determine
least education. He mentioned that energy-dense foods which of the factors (socio-demographic, obesity indices,
are mostly composed of refined grains and added sugars, nutrient intake) relate to body image satisfaction.
and fats which may be the least costly foods available to
consumers. Moreover, these energy-dense foods which are
high in sugar and fats are the most palatable and can easily
satisfy hunger. Although poverty and food insecurity are
METHODS
often associated with lower food expenditures, quality of
the diet is mostly affected, as there is lesser intake of fruits, Data from this study was taken from a previous project on
vegetables and other protein sources. In another study body image satisfaction, dietary intake, and health outcomes
done by Townsend et al. (2001), there was an association in urban Filipino women (Amarra et al. 2005 unpublished
between food insecurity and being overweight and obese report). The project was conducted in Barangay Bagong
in women resulting in chronic diseases. However, aging Silang, Caloocan City which is located north of the City
is also associated with alterations in body weight and may of Manila. Bagong Silang is a relocation area where
have an important impact on health. most of the households are classified as social class C, D,
and E based on the classification system developed by the
According to the 6th National Nutrition Survey Philippine Statistical Association (NSCB 1974).
conducted by Food and Nutrition Research Institute
(FNRI) in 2003 (FNRI 2006), undernutrition among A total of 251 women participated in the study from whom
Filipinos is still a problem; however, there has been an data on socio-demographic, body image satisfaction,
increased prevalence of overweight and obesity from dietary intake, weight, height, waist and hip ratio were
1998 to 2003. Among adults, 24% are overweight taken. Pre-tested questionnaires were used to collect socio-
to obese. In addition, chronic diseases are becoming demographic data and body image satisfaction. Two-day
number one problem of the country. To date, only a 24-hour food recall, done on a week-end and another
handful of studies were conducted to determine if the on a weekday, was used to gather data on food intake.
condition of being overweight or obese affects the Detecto weighing scales and microtoise were used to take
perception of body image of adult Filipino women. weight and height, respectively, using standard methods
and techniques. A fiberglass tape measure was used to
68
Philippine Journal of Science Aquino et al.: Body Image Satisfaction
Vol. 138 No. 1, June 2009 of Women and Correlates
get the waist and hip circumference measures. Waist body image satisfaction. Logistic regression was used in
circumference was taken at the narrowest point between determining which of the factors influence body image
the lowest rib and iliac crest while hip circumference was satisfaction.
obtained at the widest circumference around the greater
trochanter.
Household measures of the 24-hour food intake of two
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
non-consecutive days were recalled from the women
to estimate week-day and week-end intake, as studies
have shown differences of intake between these periods Respondents’ Profile
(Gibson 1990). Instruments such as measuring cups, ruler, Table 1 shows the distribution of the participants in
and portion size models were used as a way to prompt terms of age, education, and obesity classification.
and accurate recall of the food quantities. Household The findings reveal that majority of the respondents’
measures of the food items from the two-day food recall age were below 40 years, with the age group of 30-39
were translated into edible portion (EP) weights using years having the most number of participants. About
the standard weights and measures, Food Exchange List two-thirds of the women were non-working; one-tenth
(FEL) and actual weights.
Table 1. Profile of women respondents
The diet was evaluated for the nutritional content in Variables (N-251) No %
terms of energy, protein, fat, carbohydrates, dietary fiber, Age (yrs)
calcium, iron, vitamin A, thiamin, riboflavin, niacin, and 20-29 70 28
ascorbic acid using the Philippine Food Composition 30-39 80 32
Tables (FCT) (FNRI 1997) . A data base program was
40-49 51 20
used to compute the nutrient content of the diet on a daily
basis. Nutritional adequacy of the diet per respondent per 50-59 45 18
day was assessed using the 2002 Recommended Energy 60 & over 5 2
and Nutrient Intakes (FNRI 2002). Education
Elementary 37 15
BMI was calculated from the weight in kilograms divided
High School 56 22
by the square of the height in meters. From the calculated
BMI, the women were categorized into four classes based HighSchool graduate 83 33
on the World Health Classification (WHO) classification: College 47 19
underweight for BMI <18.5; normal, for BMI 18.5 - 24.9, College graduate 10 4
overweight for BMI 25.0 – 29.9, and obese for BMI ≥ Vocational 18 7
30.0. Waist-Hip Ratio (WHR) was obtained from the Occupation
measurement of the waist over the circumference of the None 159 63
hips. WHR of less than 1.0 for men and less than 0.85 for
Employee 5 2
women, and WC of less than 102 cm in men and 88 cm in
Sales/Service 23 9
women were considered to be of low risk in metabolic and
cardiovascular diseases, while levels above these cut off Sari-sari store owner 20 8
points considered the person at risk (WHO 1998). Vendor 28 11
Others 16 6
69
Philippine Journal of Science Aquino et al.: Body Image Satisfaction
Vol. 138 No. 1, June 2009 of Women and Correlates
were engaged in selling either as sari-sari store owner, in this sample was lower than the national prevalence
vendor, or buy and sell businesswoman; the rest were (17%) while for WHR, the proportion of at risk (59%)
engaged in service activities such as manicure or laundry, is slightly higher (54.8%) by about 4 percentage points
and very few (2%) were employed. Their mean income (FNRI 2006).
was Php 97,800.13 (SD ± 79,654.57) per annum (not
shown in table). The classification by BMI was normal in
Mean nutrient intake by body image satisfaction
almost half of respondents, while almost one third were
Table 2a shows the mean intake of macro and micronutrients
either overweight or obese and the rest (11.6%) were
by body image satisfaction category. The means showed
underweight. The proportion of overweight and obese
no significant differences between women in the satisfied
in this sample is similar to the national prevalence for
and not satisfied groups using the Mann-Whitney test.
Filipinos (27.3%), while for underweight, the proportion
Similarly, the means of percent nutrient adequacy (Table
of underweight is smaller (FNRI 2006). Almost 90% of
2b) were not significantly different between the two
the respondents had a WC of less than 88 cm, and, thus,
groups of respondents. Among the nutrients, only niacin
were classified as having no risk. Considering WHR,
reached a mean adequacy higher than the RENI. The mean
there were more (59.0%) at risk among women (≥ 0.85)
adequacy in most nutrients was less than 50% except for
but four out of ten respondents (41%) were classified as
protein and niacin. Nutrient intake is not directly related
having no risk. The proportion of at risk using WC (13.5%)
to body image satisfaction, but it affects body weight,
Table 2a. Mean energy and nutrient intake by category of body image satisfaction
Intake by Body Image Satisfaction
Nutrient
Not Satisfied (n=176) Satisfied (n=75) Total (N=251) P-Value*
Energy (kcal) 1326 ± 512.32 1420 ± 563.51 1354 ± 28.78 0
Protein (g) 35.90 ± 15.10 38.71 ± 16.51 36.72 ± 5.55 0
Fat (g) 25.10 ± 15.67 28.61 ± 15.45 26.76 ± 5.62 0
Carbohydrates(g) 237.0 ± 94.35 252.2 ± 106.08 241.5 ± 8.04 0
Dietary Fiber (g) 8.4 ± 4.60 9.3 ± 5.06 8.6 ± 4.75 0
Iron (mg) 9.3 ± 4.79 9.8 ± 4.74 9.4 ± 4.77 0
Calcium (mg) 323 ± 229.51 349 ± 266.96 331 ± 41.07 0
Thiamin (mg) .57 ±.33 .62 ±.40 .58 ±.35 0
Riboflavin (mg) .50 ±.24 .53 ±.26 .50 ±.24 0
Niacin (mg) 15.4 ± 6.28 16.7 ± 7.30 15.7 ± 6.62 0
Vitamin A (RE) 200 ± 204.07 217 ± 211.83 206 ±206.13 0
Ascorbic (mg) 22 ± 21.66 23 ± 21.93 22 ± 21.71 0
*p-value of >0.05 indicates no significant difference in mean intake of nutrients between women in the satisfied and not satisfied group
Table 2b. Mean energy and nutrient adequacy by category of body image satisfaction
Intake Adequacy by Body Image Satisfaction
Nutrient Not Satisfied
Satisfied (n=75) Total (N=251) P-Value*
(n=176)
Energy (kcal) 74.0 ±27.75 79.6 ± 31.89 75.7 ±29.10 0
Protein (g) 61.3 ± 26.23 66.7 ±28.46 62.9 ±26.97 0
Iron (mg) 34.5 ± 17.74 36.0 ± 17.55 35.0 ± 17.66 0
Calcium (mg) 42.6 ± 30.51 45.9 ± 34.91 43.6 ± 31.86 0
Thiamin (mg) 51.4 ±30.26 56.9 ±36.37 53.1 ±32.23 0
Riboflavin (mg) 45.0 ±21.68 47.7 ±23.56 45.8 ±22.25 0
Niacin (mg) 109.1 ±44.83 119.1 ±52.14 112.1 ±47.25 0
Vitamin A (RE) 40.3 ±40.85 43.4 ±42.36 41.2 ±41.25 0
Ascorbic (mg) 30.7± 30.95 32.9 ±31.32 31.3 ±31.01 0
*p-value of >0.05 indicates no significant difference in mean intake of nutrients between women in the satisfied and not satisfied group
70
Philippine Journal of Science Aquino et al.: Body Image Satisfaction
Vol. 138 No. 1, June 2009 of Women and Correlates
which has been linked to body image in some studies absence of a significant association between age and body
(Song et al. 1999; Monteath and McCabe 1997; Office image satisfaction could mean that women in the study
for Women 2003). Increase in BMI results from sustained might have a more tolerant attitude towards aging which
overconsumption of food, especially food rich in calories. leads to better acceptance of their current body shape. In
Underweight can result if a person consumes less calories the majority of the Filipino communities, people usually
than what is needed for energy. Besides food intake, other accept the fact that women get bigger as they become
factors such as sedentary lifestyle increase weight and, older. This acceptance in the immediate environment
subsequently, BMI. The non-significant differences noted of the woman makes her feel comfortable of whatever
between women who were satisfied and not satisfied with body shape she has. In contrast to other societies, people
their bodies suggest that other factors may have affected can become dissatisfied with their body shape as a result
the person’s BMI, but these were not covered in this paper. of other factors such as ridicule or teasing by others,
Moreover, the possibility of capturing the usual intake especially among young people (Levine et al. 1994).
may be missed with the use of recall methods such as the
two-day 24-hour food recall. Related limitations inherent The average income which was not different between
with this tool is the ability of the individual to accurately the two groups indicate that body image satisfaction
describe the dimensions of the food, deliberate refusal to does not discriminate between income levels, be it high
report intake, or memory lapse due to age or low education or low income bracket. Dissatisfaction with body image
(Gibson 1990). can also occur even in women who belong to depressed
communities as noted from other studies (Drewnowski
and Specter 2004; Office for Women 2003).
Obesity indices, age and income of participants by
body image satisfaction The higher means of BMI, WC, and WHR from the
Table 3 presents the means of BMI, WC, WHR, age dissatisfied group of women was an indication that
and income of participants classified by body image higher body weights may be a factor for the women’s
satisfaction. Age and annual income of women in the two dissatisfaction with their bodies. Obesity could affect the
groups did not differ significantly; but, the means of BMI, shape of one’s body. With an increase in body fat, weight
WC and WHR were significantly lower among women also increases. When more fat is deposited in the body,
who were satisfied with their body image. the distortion of the body shape becomes more evident,
leading to one’s dissatisfaction with his/her body image.
The relationship between age and body image has been Dissatisfaction with one’s body image can also happen
mentioned by Katzmarzyk and Davis (2001) from the when a person is too thin or underweight. Studies that
data of the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute relate body image satisfaction and BMI have already
of Growth and Health Study which said that even girls been reported by Song et al. (1999); and Monteath and
nine to ten years were trying to lose weight. Zerbe and McCabe (1997); and in other publications ( Office for
Domnitei (2004) also reported that older women tend Women 2003).
to become more negative about their body image due to
weight gain associated with aging. The present data does Table 4 shows that the levels of BMI, WC, and WHR
not agree with previous studies, but a similar result has by body image satisfaction are significantly associated.
been noted in the report of Haartl et al.(2003) that revealed With BMI as indicator, higher proportion of women
no association of age and body image satisfaction. The dissatisfied with their body image were either overweight
Table 3. Mean Age, Income, Body Mass Index (BMI), Waist Circumference (WC ), Waist-Hip Ratio (WHR) by body image
satisfaction
Annual Income Waist Circumference
Body Image Satisfaction Age (yrs) BMI (kg/m2) Waist-Hip Ratio
(PhP) (cm)
101,491.00 ±
Not Satisfied 37.66 ± 1.149 23.58 ± 4.18 78.21 ± 10.10 .87 ± .06
86,043.16
89,138.67 ±
Satisfied 38.33 ± 11.30 22.18 ± 3.06 74.9 ± 7.56 .85 ± .04
61,796.20
97,800.13 ±
Total (N=251) 37.86 ± 11.18 23.16 ± 3.93 77.22 ± 9.52 .86 ± .05
79,654.57
Mean Difference -0 12,352 1 3 0
P-value 0 0 .016* .019* .005*
* significant difference at α = 0.05
71
Philippine Journal of Science Aquino et al.: Body Image Satisfaction
Vol. 138 No. 1, June 2009 of Women and Correlates
(84.7%) or underweight (72.4%). This means that body body image satisfaction (p-value = 0.35; 95% C.I. :
dissatisfaction does not only arise from excess weight 0.000 to 0.196). The negative value of WHR indicates
but also from inadequate body weight. BMI is highly that an increase in WHR would correspond to decrease
correlated with fat; thus, distortion of body shape due to the degree of satisfaction with body image of the women.
excess or lack of fat is evident in people with extremely Between the obesity indices, WHR would give a more
high or low body weight (Song et al. 1999; Monteath obvious picture of the woman’s image based on the
and McCabe 1997). Similarly, using WC and WHR, a silhouette given, from very thin, to ideal body shape
greater proportion (85.3% and 75.1%, respectively) of and to the extremely large physical shape. Thus, it is not
those considered at risk were not satisfied with their surprising that WHR appeared as the significant predictor
body image. These indices considered as measures of of the outcome variable in this group of women.
central body obesity are known risk factors to metabolic
syndrome and related diseases such as diabetes mellitus,
cardiovascular disease, and lipid disorders, among others
(Alberti & Zimmet 1998; Dobbelsteyn et al. 2001; Woo CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
et al. 2002).
The study assessed body image satisfaction among
The variables BMI, WC, and WHR which were found to urban women and examined the factors that influence
be associated with body image in the previous Chi square satisfaction, such as socio-demographic characteristics,
test were entered in the logistic regression as shown in dietary intake, and obesity indices. In general, the findings
Table 5. Out of these variables, only WHR emerged as reveal that body image dissatisfaction exists in seven out
the significant factor that contribute to the variation in of ten women in this depressed urban community. The
conclusions specific to the objectives of the study are
the following:
Table 5. Factors Related to Body Image Satisfaction in the Logistic
Regression • Majority of the sampled women are less than 40
B S.E. Sig. Exp.(B)/(95 % C.I. for Exp B) years of age, have High School level of education,
WHRab -10 4 0 .000 ( 0.000 - 0.196) and no occupation. By nutritional status using
WAIST a
0 0 0 1.056 ( 0.965 – 1.55) BMI, 28.7% are overweight and obese and
BMIa -0 0 0 .845 (0.698 – 1.023)
11.6% are underweight while the rest are normal.
Android obesity based on WHR is noted in 59%
Constant 8 3 0 2181
a
of the women while based on WC, 13.5% are
Variable(s) entered :BMI, WAIST, WHR
b
Significant factor affecting body image satisfaction considered at risk.
72
Philippine Journal of Science Aquino et al.: Body Image Satisfaction
Vol. 138 No. 1, June 2009 of Women and Correlates
73
Philippine Journal of Science Aquino et al.: Body Image Satisfaction
Vol. 138 No. 1, June 2009 of Women and Correlates
LEVINE MP, HAYDEN LSM. 1994. The Relation of SONG HJ, OH MS, AHN SH, PARK MS, YOO TW,
Sociocultural Factors to Eating Attitudes and Behaviors KANG JH, CHOI YI. 1999. The factors associated
among Middle School Girls.The Journal of Early with satisfaction about body image and weight control
Adolescence 14(4): 471-490 behaviors in adolescents. J Korean Acad Fam Med
20(4):345-357
KATZMARZYK PT, DAVIS C. 2001. Thinness and body
shape of playboy centerfolds from 1978 to 1998. Int J TIGGEMANN M. 1999. Body image research summary:
Obesity. 25 ( 4): 590-592. body image & health inc. Research Summaries.
MARGRAF J. 2000. No, you can’t have the figure you TOWNSEND MS, PEERSON J, LOVE B, ACHTERBERG
want: Unrealistic expectations. In: Weighty Matters: C, MURPHY SP. 2001. Food insecurity is positively
Getting to grips with corpulence. Hoffman RF (ed). related to overweight in women. J Nutrition 1738-
Basel, Switzerland: La Roche Ltd. 84p. 1745.
MCIZA Z, GOEDECKE JH, STEYN NP, CHARLTON WOO J, HO SC, YU ALM, SHAM A. 2002. Is waist
K, PUOANE T, MELTZER S, LEVITT NS, LAMBERT circumference a useful measure in predicting health
EV. 2005. Development and validation of instruments outcomes in the elderly? Int J Obesity 26(10): 1349-
measuring body image and body weight dissatisfaction 1355.
in South African mothers and their daughters. Public
[WHO] WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION. 1998.
Health Nutrition 8 (5): 509-519.
Obesity: Preventing and Managing the Global
MONTEATH SA, MCCABE MP. 1997. The Influence of Epidemic. Geneva, Switzerland: In: WHO Technical
Societal Factors on Female Body Image. J Soc Psychol Report series 894. World Health Organization. 253 p.
137(6):708-27
ZERBE K, DOMNITEI D. 2004. Eating disorders at
[NIH] NATIONAL INSTITUTES OF HEALTH. 2002. middle age, Part 1 and 2. Eating Disorders Review
NIH News Release : NHLBI Study Shows Weight 15 (2).
Concerns Increase Girls’ Risk Of Becoming Smokers.
June 3, 2002. Retrieved from http://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/
new/press/02-06-03.htm on May, 2008.
[NSCB] NATIONAL STATISTICAL COORDINATING
BOARD. 1974. Presidential Decree No. 465 In:
Philippine Standard Geographical Code, 1997–2009.
Retrieved February 2007 from http://www.nscb.gov.
ph/activestats/psyc/articles/intro_PD465. asp
OFFICE FOR WOMEN. Australian Government. 2003.
Key Issues Affecting Women. Focus on Women. Issue
6. 2003. Retrieved from http://www.ofw.facsia.gov.
au/publications/focusonwomen/2003.htm. October
21, 2007.
PAN AS. 2000. Body image, eating attitudes, and eating
behaviors among Chinese, Chinese-American and
non-Hispanic White women. Dissertation-Abstracts-
International, San Francisco State University. Retrieved
from http://www.sfsn.edu/2multsowk/title/54.htm
PEREZ M, JOINER TE JR. 2003. Body image
dissatisfaction and disordered eating in black and white
women. Int J Eating Disorders 33(3) 342-350.
SLOAN B. 2000. Body image. Ohio State University
Factsheet. Retrieved from http://ohioline.osu.edu/hyg-
fact/5000/5238.html.August 18, 2006
74