Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
No 9
Pediatr Infect Dis J, 1993;12:751-761
Printed in L'.S.4
0891-3668/93/$03.00/0
Copyright @ 1993 by Williams & Wilkins
Diarrheal diseasescontinue to be an important pub- vance for current diarrheal disease control program
lic health problem in developing countries.1.2 Acute, efforts and recommending selected research topics.
short lived illnesses with dehydration can result in DEFINITION OF PERSISTENT DIARRHEA
death unless prompt and appropriate fluid replace-
ment is provided. Most efforts in national diarrheal Although most diarrheal episodesresolve within the
disease control programs are currently directed at first week, a small proportion continue for 2 weeks or
improving management of acute diarrhea. However, longer. Studies in a number of developing countries
more prolonged illnesses, although fewer in number indicate that the distribution of episode durations is
in comparison with acute episodes and not often as- continuous but skewed toward the longer durations
sociated with dehydration, may deserve more atten- (Fig. 1). Thus establishing a specific definition of
tion: (1) it is now appreciated that a substantial pro- persistent diarrhea as an illness of more than a gi\'en
portion of diarrhea-associated deaths in young chil- number of days is arbitrary. Nevertheless doing so is
dren are with persistent, not acute, diarrhea.3 desirable for gaining better comparability in research
studies and for implementing program strategies for
Furthermore as oral rehydration therapy programs
achieve greater success in controlling deaths from case management. For these reasons a World Health
acute dehydrating diarrheas, deaths from persistent Organization meeting in December, 1987, recom-
diarrhea become proportionally more important, (2) mended that persistent diarrhea be operationally de-
persistent diarrheas in developing countries have a fined as an episode that begins acutely and lasts for
striking association with growth faltering and mal- at least 14 days.5 Recent studies have largely adopted
nutrition, suggesting that even more attention to nu- this definition.
tritional management must be given to the long du- Previous studies used a variety of definitions of
ration illnesses4,and (3) the persistent episodes are persistent diarrhea which may have affected the rates
frustrating management problems for family members found.6,7 The term "persistent diarrhea" is not in-
as well as health professionals, resulting in a substan- tended to encompass chronic diarrheal disorders, such
tial cost in time and purchase of numerous drugs and as hereditary syndromes, gluten-sensitive enteropathy
other remedies in an attempt to terminate the illness. or blind loop syndrome, although these ma~' be diffi-
The epidemiology, pathophysiology and clinical cult to distinguish on initial presentation.8
management of persistent diarrhea have until recently
been ill-defined.s This paper constitutes a stock taking MORT ALITY ASSOCIA TED WITH PERSISTENT
of our understanding, providing information of rele- DIARRHEA
Recent information from four countries (India,
Bangladesh, Brazil and Senegal) indicates that acute
-": Accepted {or publication April 30, 1993. watery diarrhea may account for only 35% (range, 25
From the Department 0{ International Health, School 0{ Hygiene to 46%) of all diarrhea-associated deaths.3.9-12The
and Public Health, The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD. remainder of the diarrhea-associated deaths in these
Key words: Diarrhea, chronic diarrhea, persistent diarrhea, diar-
rhea epidemiology, diarrhea treatment. studies was associated with either dysentery (20%;
Address {or reprints: Robert E. Black, M.D., Department 0{ range, 8 to 24%) or persistent nondysenteric diarrhea
International Health, School 0{ Hygiene and Public Health, The (45%; range, 23 to 62%). Because these studies largely
Johns Hopkins University, 615 North Wol{e Street, Baltimore, MD
21205.
combined dysenteric illnesses of any duration, one
751
Vol. 12, No.9, Sept., 1993 THE PEDIATRIC INFECTIOUS DISEASE JOURNAL 757
pathogens were found in duodenal fluid, but many further study. Amebiasis is an unusual cause of per-
were less frequently identified from this source than sistent diarrhea in children in developing countries
from stool.84 For example EAEC-AA were found in and would justify treatment only after documentation
16% of stool samples but in only 1% of duodenal fluid of erythrophagocytic trophozoites in diarrheal stool.
samples. Studies in Brazil also identified all three Other drugs. A number of other drugs have been
types of EAEC in duodenal fluid, but their relative tried in the management of persistent diarrhea. Cho-
importance and role in pathogenesis could not be lestyramine has been used because it has been hypoth -
ascertained.34 In Peru specific enteric pathogens were esized that bacteria in the small bowel may result in
... isolated from duodenal fluid in only a few children.83 unconjugated bile acids which then result in mucosal
Although these studies are still inconclusive, they injury or a cathartic effect on the colonic mucosa.89, 90
would not support an argument that continued colo- In South Africa children with persistent diarrhea
nization of the small bowel with specific enteric path- treated with cholestyramine had a significantly
ogens is a frequent or necessary event in the patho- greater decrease in stool output during the first day of
genesis of persistent diarrhea. treatment, but not thereafter.85 Unfortunately little
other information is available from controlled trials
MANAGEMENT OF PERSISTENT DIARRHEA
in developing cotlntries. Thus the possible role of
Antibiotics. The observation that specific entero- cholestyramine in therapy of persistent diarrhea can-
pathogens such as EAEC or other forms of pathogenic not be assessed, but any such therapy should carefully
coli may be associated with persistent diarrhea and monitor adverse effects, such as the development of
the possible role of bacterial colonization of the small acidosis or the malabsorption of fat and fat-soluble
bowel in the pathogenesis of pers,istent diarrhea led vitamins, possibly leading to nutritional deficits. Even
some to speculate that antibiotics might be useful for if there is an effect of cholestyramine, this is not a
treatment of this illness. Investigators in South Africa practical means for management of persistent diar-
reported the use of oral gentamicin, metronidazole rhea in developing country children because of high
and cholestyramine for persistent diarrhea.85 In a costs and difficulties of administration.
small controlled trial with a factorial design, children Bismuth subsalicylate has been used for the treat-
with persistent diarrhea treated with oral gentamicin ment of both acute and persistent diarrhea, but fe\\'
appeared to have a greater decrease in stool output controlled trials for the latter have been published. In
than those not receiving the drug. Metronidazole had a double blind trial in children with persistent diar-
no effect on stool output. rhea in the United States, those treated with bismuth
Because preliminary findings in a study of persist- subsalicylate had significantly fewer and firmer stools
ent diarrhea in the United States also suggested a with less water content and gained more weight than
possible effect of oral gentamicin,86 two randomized, the placebo-treated children.91 The applicability of
double blind, placebo-controlled trials of oral genta- this study in relatively mild episodes of persistent
micin in the treatment of persistent diarrhea were diarrhea in nonmalnourished children to the more
initiated.87.88 In Guatemala among 92 cases entered in severe persistent diarrhea seen in malnourished chil-
the clinical trial, there was no efficacy of gentamicin; dren in developing countries is unknown.
42% of the 45 gentamicin-treated children and 43% Antimotility drugs, including codeine, paregoric,
of the 47 placebo-treated children stopped having tincture of opium, diphenoxylate and loperamide.
diarrhea, in both cases similar to the rate of sponta- should not be given because they are unlikely to be
neous cessation of diarrhea between Days 15 and 21 efficacious and are associated with serious side effects,
previously observed in this population.87 Although such as paralytic ileus, drowsiness and prolongation
EAEC were identified in 46% of children in this trial, of excretion of enteric pathogens.73 The so-called ad-
there was no significant treatment effect in children sorbants such as kaolin or charcoal are unlikely to
with this enteric pathogen. Furthermore children with have any significant clinical effect in persistent diar-
a high count of aerobic organisms in their small bowel rhea.
did not have an effect from the oral gentamicin. In Vitamins and minerals. Specific deficiencies in
India results were similar in finding no efficacy with vitamins and minerals in the pathogenesis of persist-
oral gentamicin treatment of children with persistent ent diarrhea may lead to possible therapeutic strate-
diarrhea.88 gies utilizing micronutrient supplements. Controlled
Because shigellosis is known to respond to appro- studies of supplementation with vitamins and other
priate antibiotic therapy and Shigella infection can be micronutrients, such as zinc, in persistent--diarrhea
associated with persistent diarrhea, specific therapy are needed.52.92
of shigellosis or perhaps empirical therapy of dysen- Fluid and dietary management. The principles
tery for Shigella infection would be justified. The need of fluid and electrolyte replacement have been well-
for treatment of a. lamblia is unknown and needs established for acute diarrhea and do not differ in
758 THE PEDIATRIC INFECTIOUS DISEASE JOURNAL Vo1. 12, No.9, Sept., 1993
persistent diarrhea. The aim of treatment is to restore Bangladesh, patients with more severe initial diarrhea
initial fluid deficits and to replace ongoing stool losses and more malabsorption of nutrients had delayed re-
until diarrhea stops. In nearly all casesthis should be covery .98
possible with the use of oral rehydration solutions.
Althou.gh dietary management also plays an important RESEARCH QUESTIONS
role in acute diarrhea, it may deserve special emphasis A partial list of pressing research questions is pro-
in persistent diarrhea becauseof the strong associa- vided to stimulate further work.
tion of this illness with malnutrition in developing 1. A methodology is needed to enable a country or
country children. Approaches to dietary management specific setting to determine whether persistent diar-
need to contend with the problem of anorexia in rhea is an important public health problem. Aspects
children with diarrhea, which may be compounded in of this methodology might determine the types of
prolonged illness by fatigue in the caretaker's attempts diarrhea associated with death. Additional work in -
to provide an adequate diet. volving community-based surveys is needed to deter-
Studies have indicated that the enteral route may mine the extent to which the magnitude of persistent
result in faster recovery from the illness compared diarrheal morbidity can be determined b;.' sur\'ey. The
with the parenteral route, as well as having the advan- needed methodologies would also determine the
tages of decreasedexpense, increased availability and groups, e.g. age, nutritional status, at highest risk of
lower risk of complications.93 In the management of morbidity or mortality from persistent diarrhea.
persistent diarrhea a reduced lactose diet should be 2. Further analyses are needed of existing or new
used. In a controlled trial in Peru one-third of children epidemiologic data to determine the extent to which "
consuming a low lactose diet ceased diarrhea within high prevalence of diarrhea and episodes of persiste
30 hours compared with only 3% on a full lactose diarrhea are found in a subset of developing country
diet.94 children and if so, what the associated child and family
In the community, where most cases of persistent unit characteristics are.
diarrhea must be managed, foods used must be cultur- 3. The role in persistent diarrhea of the immune
ally acceptable, available at a low cost and easy to system and of transient impairment. of cell-mediated
prepare in the home.59.60 Recent successeswith staple immune responsiveness must be better understood.
food-baseddiets in management of acute diarrhea give Such studies could include the determinants of im-
optimism that similar approaches can be used for munocompetence in young children and the role of
persistent diarrhea.95Other enteral diets, such as for- cell-mediated immune factors and the immune system
mulas that are free of cow's milk and lactose, are in the recovery from diarrhea and the persistence of
commonly recommended but are too expensive for some episodes.
wide use in most developing countries. In Pakistan 4. Additional information is needed on care-seeking
children with persistent diarrhea were randomized to behaviors related to diarrheal episodes, especiall;.'
be managed with a diet consisting of a local weaning those of long duration. Much of the work on care-
food of rice and lentils along with yogurt (Khitchri- seeking to date has focused on seeking ORS during
yogurt) or with soy formula.96 The children fed with the initial days of acute watery diarrhea. In relation
the Khitchri-yogurt diet had significantly lower stool to persistent diarrhea, attention must also be paid to
volumes and decreased stool frequency than children the second week of illness and beyond. Information i~
fed with the soy formula diet. In addition the children needed on the cost in time and mone)' of this caI
in the Khitchri-yogurt group had greater weight gains seeking, as well as the relationship of the care-seeking
than children in the other group during the first week and treatments used to the episode outcome.
of therapy, and addition of this diet to the soy formula 5. The association of enteroadherent E. coli with
group in the second week resulted in increased weight persistent diarrhea needs to be studied in a \.ariety of
gain in this group as well. In this setting a traditional settings and the relationships between these enteric
weaning diet could be successfully used for the dietary pathogens and important risk factors and the response
management of persistent diarrhea. to therapeutic approaches must be ascertained.
It is important to identify characteristics of the 6. The need for antimicrobial treatment of specific
children with persistent diarrhea or of the illness itself agents, e.g. G. lamblia or Entamoeba histolytica should
that could be used to predict delayed recovery or be determined. Even with shigellosis, in \\,hich indi-
treatment failure. In Pakistan a younger mean age at vidual cases are known to respond to treatment, it is
admission to the hospital and presence of vomiting in important to describe the costs and benefits of treat-
the first 8 hou~s were correlated with treatment fail- ment of dysentery at a population level.
ures; and young age, malnutrition (low weight for 7. Information is needed on how the usual weaning
length) and more severe watery diarrhea were associ- diets can be improved and utilized for the management
ated with delayed recovery.97Likewise in the study in of diarrhea, for convalescent feeding, and for nutri-
Vol. 12, Nc,. 9, Sept, 1993 THE PEDIATRIC INFECTIOUS DISEASE JOURNAL 759
ished children with acute diarrhea and sugar intolerance. J 85. Hill ID, Mann MD, Houseman KC, Bowie MD. Use of oral
Trop Pediatr 1990;96:86-9. gentamicin, metronidazole and cholestyramine in the treatment
71. Banwell JG, Boldt DH, Meyers J, Weber FL Jr, Miller B, of severe persistent diarrhea in infants. Pediatrics 1986;7i:4ii -
Howard R. Phytohemagglutinin derived from red kidney bean 81.
(PhaseolU$ uulgaris): a cause for intestinal malabsorption as- 86. Craft .}C. Efficacy of oral genamicin for treatment of persistent
sociated with bacterial overgrowth in the rat. Gastroenterology diarrhea. Persistent diarrhoea in children in developing coun.
1983;84:506-15. tries. Report of a WHO Meeting. Geneva: World Health Orga-
72. Banwell JG, Abramowsky CR, Weber F, Howard R, Boldt DH. nization, 1988.
Phytohemagglutinin-induced diarrheal disease. Dig Dis Sci 87. Bartlett A V, Torun B, Morales C, Cano F, Cruz JR. Oral
1984;29:921-9. gentamicin is not effective treatment for persistent diarrhea.
73. World Health Organization. The rational use of drugs in the Acta Paediatr 1992;81(Suppl 381):149-54.
management of acute diarrhoea in children. Geneva: World 88. Bhatnager S, Bhan MK, Sazawal S, et a1. Efficacy of massi\.e
Health Organization, 1990:71 pp. dose oral gentamycin therapy in nonbloody persistent diarrhea
i4. Harris S, Black RE. How useful are pharmaceuticals in man- \\'ith associated malnutrition. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr
aging diarrhoeal diseases in developing countries. Health Policy 1992;12:117-24.
and Planning 1991;6:141-7. 89. Tamer MA, Santora TR, Sandberg DH. Cholestyramine ther-
75. Sullivan PB, March MN. Small intestinal mucosal histology in apy for intractable diarrhea. Pediatrics 1974;53:217-20.
the syndrome of persistent diarrhoea and malnutrition: a re- 90. Freedman AM, Panayiotou H. Cholestyramine as an aid to
view. Acta Paediatr 1992;81(SuppI381):72-7. management of prolonged diarrhoea in the hospital drip-room.
76. Brunser 0, Reid A, Monckeberg F, et al. Jejunal mucosa in S Acr Med .1 1981;60:129-30.
infant malnutrition. Am J Clin Nutr 1968;21:976-83. 91. Gryboski JD, Hillemeier AC, Grill B, Kocoshis S. Bismuth
77. Guiraldes E, Hamilton JR. Effect of chronic malnutrition on subsalicylate in the treatment of chronic diarrhea of childhood.
intestinal structure, epithelial renewal, and enzymes in sucklin/( Am J GastroenteroI1985;80:871-6.
rats. Pediatr Res 1981;51:930-4. 92. Sachde\. HPS, Mittal NK, Yadav HS. Oral zinc supplementa.
78. Hopper AF, Rose PM, Wannemacher RW. Cell population tion in persistent diarrhoea in infants. Ann Trop Paediatr
changes in the intestinal mucosa of protein-depleted or starved 1990;10:63-9.
rats. II. Changes in cellular migration rates. J Cell Bioi 93. Orenstein SR. Enteral uersU$ parenteral therapy for intractabl~
1972;53:225-30. diarrhea of infancy: a prospective randomized trial. .1 Pediatr
79. Lebenthal E. Prolonged small intestinal mucosal injury as a 1981;99:360-1.
primary cause of intractable diarrhea of infancy. 1n: Lebenthal 94. Penny ME, Paredes P, Brown KH. Clinical and nutritional
E, ed. Chronic diarrhea in children. New York: Nestle, Vevey/ consequences of lactose feeding during persistent postenteritis
Raven Press, 1984:5-29. diarrhea. Pediatrics 1989;84:835-44.
80. Lunn PG, Northrop-Clewes CA, Downes RM. Intestinal perme- 95. Bro\yn KH, Gastanaduy AS, Saavedra JM, et al. Effect of
ability, mucosal injury, and growth faltering in Gambian in- continued oral feeding on clinical and nutritional outcomes of
Cants. Lancet 1991;338:907-10. acute diarrhea in children. J Pediatr 1988;112:191-200.
81. Walker-SmithJA,NazerH,Manuel P,JacksonD,Phillips AD, 96. Bhutta ZA, Molla AM, Issani Z, Badruddin S, Hendricks K.
Soeparto P. Protein intolerance as a cause of postenteritis Sn~.der .}D. Dietary management of persistent diarrhea: com-
diarrhea. In: Lebenthal E, ed. Chronic diarrhea in children. parison of a traditional rice-Ientil based diet with so~. formula
Ne~. York: Nestle, Vevey/Raven Press, 1984:407-23. Pediatrics 1991;88:1010-9.
82. Snyder JD. Dietary protein sensitivity: is it an important risk 97. Bhutta ZA, Molla AM, Issani Z, Badruddin S, Hendricks K.
factor for persistent diarrhea? Acta Paediatr 1992;81 (Suppl Sn~.der .JD. Nutritional management of persistent diarrhea:
381):78-81. factors predicting clinical outcome. Acta Paediatr 1992:
83. Penny M. The role of the duodenal microflora as a determinant 81(SuppI381):144-8.
of persistent diarrhoea. Acta Paediatr 1992;81(SuppI381):114- 98. Ro~. SK, Akramuzzaman SM, Haider R, et al. Persistent diar-
20. rhoea: factors affecting absorption and clinical prognosis during
84. Bhatnager S, Bhan MK, George C, et al. Is small bo\yel bacterial management with rice based diet. Acta Paediatr 1992;81 (Suppl
overgrowth of pathogenic significance in persistent diarrhea? 381 ):139-43.
Acta Paediatr 1992;81(Suppl 381):108-13.