Name: __________________________________________________ Date: ______________ Name: __________________________________________________ Date: ______________

Group and Stance: ___________________________________________ Group and Stance: ___________________________________________

Rubric 10 8 6 4 1 Rubric 10 8 6 4 1
Arguments were Arguments lacked Arguments were Arguments lacked
Most of the Most of the Most of the Most of the
supported with some evidence and supported with some evidence and
arguments were arguments were arguments were arguments were
evidence and support. Student evidence and support. Student
supported with supported with Student did not supported with supported with Student did not
examples. Some relied too much examples. Some relied too much
ARGUMENTS accurate evidence accurate evidence give any ARGUMENTS accurate evidence accurate evidence
information was on notes and /or
give any
information was on notes and /or and examples and and examples and arguments.
and examples and and examples and arguments. inaccurate and/or too much
inaccurate and/or too much were well were well
were well were well not enough quality inaccurate
not enough quality inaccurate elaborated. elaborated.
elaborated. elaborated. information. information.
information. information.
Most of the Most of the
All of the rebuttals Rebuttals rarely All of the rebuttals Rebuttals rarely
rebuttals - Rebuttals rebuttals - Rebuttals
adequately addressed adequately addressed
adequately occasionally adequately occasionally
addressed each of opponents’ Student did not addressed each of opponents’ Student did not
addressed most of addressed some of addressed most of addressed some of
REBUTTALS the opponents’ arguments and/or give any REBUTTALS the opponents’
opponents’ opponents’
arguments and/or give any
opponents’ opponents’ arguments with did not present rebuttals.
arguments with did not present rebuttals. arguments with arguments with
arguments with arguments with sufficient sufficient
sufficient sufficient sufficient sufficient evidence.
sufficient sufficient evidence. evidence. evidence.
evidence. evidence. evidence.
evidence.
Student appeared Student was Student appeared Student was
Student was Student displayed Student was Student displayed
unsure at times and unprepared and unsure at times and unprepared and
clearly an adequate Student did not clearly an adequate Student did not
KNOWLEDGE appeared to lack full lacked significant KNOWLEDGE knowledgeable understanding of
appeared to lack full lacked significant
participate.
knowledgeable understanding of participate. knowledge of the knowledge of the
knowledge of the knowledge of the and well prepared. the material.
and well prepared. the material. material. material.
material. material.
Rubric 5 4 3 2 1 Rubric 5 4 3 2 1
- Student Student presented - Student Student presented
Student presented Student presented
presented several several different Student presented presented several several different Student presented
few arguments few arguments
different arguments and some arguments but different arguments and some arguments but
and hardly ever Student did not and hardly ever Student did not
TEAMWORK arguments and occasionally rarely defended their TEAMWORK arguments and occasionally rarely defended their
defended their participate.
defended their participate. regularly defended defended their teammates’
regularly defended defended their teammates’ teammates’
teammates’ their teammates’ teammates’ arguments.
their teammates’ teammates’ arguments. arguments.
arguments. arguments. arguments.
arguments. arguments.
Student appeared Student appeared
Student appeared Student appeared Student appeared Student appeared Student appeared Student appeared
extremely extremely
comfortable; uncomfortable; uncomfortable; comfortable; uncomfortable; uncomfortable;
ORAL comfortable; Student did not ORAL comfortable; Student did not
spoke clearly. student did not did not speak spoke clearly. student did not did not speak
PRESENTATION spoke clearly and participate. PRESENTATION spoke clearly and participate.
Eye contact could speak clearly. Poor really clearly. No Eye contact could speak clearly. Poor really clearly. No
confidently. Good confidently. Good
have been better. eye contact. eye contact have been better. eye contact. eye contact
eye contact. eye contact.
Student did not Student did not
follow the rules of follow the rules of
the debate. Talked Student was Student say bad the debate. Talked Student was Student say bad
Student was Student talked or Student was Student talked or
or whispered disrespectful and words and did or whispered disrespectful and words and did
respectful and whispered while respectful and whispered while
RESPECT repeatedly while did not follow the not really RESPECT followed the rules others were
repeatedly while did not follow the not really
followed the rules others were others were rules of the respect the
others were rules of the respect the of the debate. debating.
of the debate. debating. debating. Student debate. rules.
debating. Student debate. rules.
made inappropriate made inappropriate
comments. comments.
The student did The student did
Student did not The student Student did not The student
not wear any not wear any
Student dressed dress appropriately. wear school Student dressed dress appropriately. wear school
dress appropriate dress appropriate
APPEARANCE / as directed. Student did not Student did not uniform and APPEARANCE / as directed. Student did not Student did not uniform and
to the debate and to the debate and
POISE Student was well dress as directed. conduct conducted POISE Student was well dress as directed. conduct conducted
conducted himself conducted himself
poised. himself/herself in an himself in a rude poised. himself/herself in an himself in a rude
in an unpleasant in an unpleasant
appropriate manner. manner. appropriate manner. manner.
manner. manner.