Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
2017
JHLXXX10.1177/0890334416680176Journal of Human LactationAsztalos et al.
Original Research
Journal of Human Lactation
EMPOWER Trial
Abstract
Background: Mothers of preterm infants often are at risk of expressing an inadequate amount of milk for their infants and
the use of galactogogues is often considered. Domperidone is a widely used galactogogue with little information available to
guide clinicians regarding initiation, timing, and duration of treatment.
Research aim: The primary objective of this study was to determine whether administration of domperidone within the
first 21 days after delivery would lead to a higher proportion of mothers achieving a 50% increase in the volume of milk at
the end of 14 days of treatment compared with mothers receiving placebo.
Methods: Eligible mothers were randomized to one of two treatment arms: Group A—domperidone 10 mg orally three
times daily for 28 days; or Group B—placebo 10 mg orally three times daily for 14 days followed by domperidone 10 mg
orally three times daily for 14 days.
Results: A total of 90 mothers of infants ≤ 29 weeks gestation were randomized. Mean milk volumes at entry were similar
for both groups. More mothers achieved a 50% increase in milk volume after 14 days in Group A (77.8%) compared with
Group B (57.8%), odds ratio = 2.56, 95% confidence interval [1.02, 6.25], p = .04.
Conclusion: A greater number of mothers experienced a 50% or more increase in human milk volume, but the absolute
increase in milk volume was modest.
Keywords
breastfeeding, breast milk expression, galactogogues, human milk, human milk production, lactation difficulties, milk supply,
randomized controlled trials
1
Department of Newborn and Developmental Paediatrics, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada
2
Izaak Walton Killam Health Centre, Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS, Canada
3
Perinatal and Women’s Health, London Health Sciences Centre, Western University, London, ON, Canada
4
Division of Clinical Pharmacology & Toxicology, Department of Paediatrics, Hospital for Sick Children, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada
5
Sunnybrook Research Institute, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada
6
School of Pharmacy, University of Waterloo, Kitchener, ON, Canada
*EMPOWER Study Collaborative Group (number of participants in parentheses): London Health Sciences Centre (7), London, ON: Orlando da Silva,
Nicola Geoghegan-Morphet; Hamilton Health Sciences Centre (4), Hamilton, ON: Christoph Fusch, Geoff Travis; Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre
(36), Toronto, ON: Elizabeth Asztalos, Afsheen Ayaz; Jewish General Hospital (17), Montreal, PQ: Lajos Kovacs, Sandy Ho; Sainte-Justine Hospital (8),
Montreal, PQ: Annie Janvier, Julie Lavoie; Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Quebec (6), Quebec City, PQ: Georges Cauoette, Mylene LeBlanc; Foothills
Medical Centre (3), Calgary, AB: Abhay Lodha, Linda Lavoie; Everett Chalmers Regional Hospital (1), Fredericton, NB: Barbara Bulleid, Judy Neal; Izaak
Walton Killam Health Centre (8), Halifax, NS: Doug MacMillan, Balpreet Singh, Marsha Campbell-Yeo, Kim Caddell.
Corresponding Author:
Elizabeth V. Asztalos, MD, MSc, FRCPC, Department of Newborn and Developmental Paediatrics, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, University of
Toronto, M4-230, 2075 Bayview Avenue, Toronto, ON M4N 3M5, Canada.
Email: elizabeth.asztalos@sunnybrook.ca
Asztalos et al. 183
reported data. All the mothers who participated provided a at the calculated term gestation (40 weeks postconceptual
written informed consent before being enrolled. Because the age) and at 6 weeks corrected gestational age (6 weeks post-
study was using an off-label indication for domperidone, the term gestation). Mothers were asked questions regarding
study was conducted under the Food and Drug Act of Health feeding patterns, continued frequency of breast stimulation,
Canada. additional use of galactogogues or alternatives after the study
medication period, and the use of feeding supplementation
for their infant(s) at each time point. If an infant was trans-
Setting
ferred to another care facility outside of the study site before
EMPOWER was conducted in eight level 3 neonatal inten- 28 days, the center was asked to remain connected with the
sive care units across Canada. Using a 24 hour/day web- mother to maintain compliance with the study medication,
based randomization service at the coordinating center, pumping, and diary entries and maintain follow-up at term
mothers were assigned to one of two groups: Group A (inter- and at 6 weeks postterm gestation.
vention group: domperidone 10 mg orally three times daily
for 28 days) or Group B (comparison group: placebo 10 mg
Measurements
orally three times daily for 14 days followed by domperidone
10 mg orally three times daily for 14 days). The treatment The primary outcome measure was the proportion of mothers
protocol design enabled the following aims to be evaluated: who achieved a 50% increase in milk volume from the base-
(a) an earlier introduction of domperidone compared with line expressed milk volume at study entry to the end of the first
later introduction, and (b) efficacy for a 2-week versus a 2-week period on Day 14. If human milk volumes were miss-
4-week treatment approach. The study treatment was ran- ing on Day 14 and/or Day 28, volumes were checked for the
domly assigned in a 1:1 ratio in blocks of four and eight, preceding 2 days to determine inclusion. The secondary out-
stratified by center, gestational age (23–26 and 27–29 weeks come measures were (a) the proportion of mothers who
gestation at delivery), and days postdelivery (7–14 and 15– achieved a 50% increase in expressed milk volume on Day 28,
21 days). All study personnel, point of care personnel, and (b) mean milk volume on Days 14 and 28, and (c) mean per-
mothers were masked to the allocation. centage volume change from Days 0 to 14 and Days 15 to 28.
The centers were encouraged to maintain their standard
approach in supporting the mothers as it related to duration
of pumping and the types of pumps used in their centers. For
Data Analysis
the purpose of the trial, all mothers enrolled were encour- The sample size for the trial was 560 mothers (280 per
aged to pump six to eight times daily for the 4-week study group). With the trial stopping early at 90 mothers, we had
period. The mothers were asked to maintain a diary provided 80% power to detect a 20% difference in proportions in the
by the study to record pumping times, milk volumes, and any two groups, anticipating that 60% of the mothers in Group B
side effects daily. Human milk volumes were verified regu- who were receiving placebo would still be able to achieve a
larly by study personnel at each center. Each mother was 50% increase in milk volume at the end of the initial 14-day
asked to immediately report to the study site any adverse period with nonpharmacologic approaches.
events experienced. Nonpharmacologic (skin-to-skin, No formal interim analysis was planned; safety reviews
Kangaroo care, etc.) approaches were encouraged. Serum were to be conducted by an independent Data Safety
prolactin levels were not measured for this study because Monitoring Board after the first 175 and 350 mothers were
past studies showed an increase in prolactin levels but an randomized and enrolled into the study. At both of these
inconsistent relationship between these levels and the vol- reviews, serious adverse events would be assessed and data
ume of milk produced. analyzed.
Because of concerns of Q-Tc interval prolongation related An a priori intention-to-treat analysis was conducted: all
to domperidone, each mother had two electrocardiograms of the mothers who were enrolled and randomized were
(ECGs) performed during the study period: at entry and at included and analyzed in the groups to which they were ran-
the end of the 4-week study medication period. Each infant domized. The analysis was carried out using SAS Version 9.3
had ECGs completed at the start and end of the study period (SAS Institute, Cary, North Carolina, USA). Descriptive sta-
if the mother consented to these ECGs. The ECGs, maternal tistics were calculated for all variables of interest. Continuous
and infant, were reviewed centrally by an adult and a pediat- measures were summarized using means and standard devia-
ric cardiologist, respectively, at prespecified times during the tions (SDs), whereas categorical measures were summarized
study to determine the presence of a Q-Tc interval prolonga- using counts and percentages. Where applicable, nonpara-
tion during the 4-week study medication period. metric statistics (Wilcoxon rank sum test) were used.
During the 4-week study medication period, mothers The primary and secondary outcomes were assessed
were provided two 2-week supplies of the study medica- between groups using a logistic regression model.
tion—the first at study entry, and the second prior to Day 15 Specifically, generalized estimating equations with a logit
of the study. Follow-up was conducted by phone or in-person link function were used to account for correlation among
184 Journal of Human Lactation 33(1)
Table 1. Baseline Characteristics of Mothers at Study Entry. Table 2. Outcomes on Days 14 and 28.
Table 3. Mean Milk Volumes on Days 14 and 28. Table 5. Follow-Up at Term and 6 Weeks Postterm Gestation.
Table 7. Neonatal Adverse Events. our collaborators, the lower incidence may also be the result
of activities initiated through a national neonatal endeavor
Neonatal event Group A Group B
conducted in Canada to reduce neonatal morbidity, called
Cardiac arrhythmia 0 (0.0) 0 (0.0) Evidence-Based Practice for Improving Quality (EPIQ;
Q-Tc interval: 442 to > 500 ms 2a 3b www.epiq.ca). Many of our centers participated in EPIQ and
Infection 6 (43.0) 8 (57.0) focused on reducing necrotizing enterocolitis as a morbidity
Pulmonary 1 (7.0) 0 (0.0) of interest. One strategy among the centers was to improve
Gastrointestinal 2 (14.0) 3 (21.0) the early provision of mother’s own milk by initiating lacta-
Neurological 2 (14.0) 0 (0.0) tion support immediately following delivery as well as
Genitourinary 1 (7.0) 0 (0.0) improving lactation support for this group of mothers.
Death 2 (14.0)c 3 (21.0)d Even though we were able to demonstrate that domperi-
Note. Data are given as n (%). Group A: 4 weeks of domperidone (no. of done was effective, there were several concerns for both
events = 14). Group B: 2 weeks of placebo + 2 weeks of domperidone groups of mothers. They continued to have milk volume
(no. of events = 14). issues over the remaining time of hospitalization and early
a
The event was present in two infants at study end electrocardiogram.
b
The event was present in three infants: two at study start and one at
postdischarge. They remained on a variety of lactation-
study end electrocardiogram. cDeath was due to respiratory failure and inducing compounds for an extended period of time. This
extreme prematurity, respectively. dDeath was due to sepsis in two reaffirms that these mothers represent a subgroup of preterm
infants and extreme prematurity in one infant. mothers who need ongoing support and encouragement to
provide human milk for their preterm infants throughout
galactogogue (Campbell-Yeo et al., 2010; da Silva, Knoppert, their infants’ neonatal hospitalization and postdischarge.
Angelini, & Forret, 2001; Ingram, Taylor, Churchill, Pike, &
Over the 3 years of the study, there were four warnings
Greenwood, 2012; Knoppert et al., 2013). Our study focused
issued by Health Canada regarding the risk of prolongation
on an earlier timing of introduction, within 21 days postde-
of the Q-Tc interval and the risk of cardiac arrhythmias and
livery, to determine if this approach would be more helpful.
sudden death (Health Canada, 2012a, 2012b, 2015a, 2015b).
Even though we found that an earlier introduction was ben-
The information had a cumulative effect on recruitment and
eficial, we also found that delaying treatment with domperi-
a decision was made to stop the trial early at 16% of its tar-
done still enabled mothers to demonstrate a response to
geted sample size. Despite these warnings, there was never a
treatment some 22 to 35 days following delivery. Our study
request from Health Canada to stop the trial. This is not the
was not able to demonstrate a significant measure of effec-
first trial having challenges in recruitment in the face of an
tiveness for a 4-week treatment approach compared with the
unfavorable environment. The DART study also became a
more studied 2 weeks. There appeared to be no more appre-
victim of a climate not conducive to the study of dexametha-
ciable gain with respect to human milk supply from a 14- to
28-day treatment course, but supply was essentially sus- sone in the management of chronic lung disease in very pre-
tained, which may be clinically important. term infants and terminated at 9% of the projected sample
Because of the cardiac concerns that were presenting size (Doyle et al., 2006).
prior to the start of this trial, we did ECGs to track any poten- A strength was the rigor of the study conduct to ensure
tial changes. We did not see any Q-Tc abnormalities during consistency and integrity of the results. Coordinators were
the conduct of the trial. We recognize that conclusions encouraged to maintain contact with the mothers on a weekly
regarding safety along that line cannot be drawn because of basis to ensure compliance, to ensure that the mothers
our small sample size, but we were reassured that we did not recorded milk volumes as diligently as possible, and to
see any effects as described in the literature (Paul et al., 2015; ensure that adverse events were appropriately monitored.
Rossi & Giorgi, 2010). We did not have consistency in the This study was conducted as a masked trial with a modified
infants’ ECGs to draw any conclusions. Because of different placebo arm, as there was concern that mothers would not
feeding policies in the centers, it was not always clear if an participate if they did not receive any domperidone during
infant had received human milk pumped during the time his the study period. Recruiting mothers in future trials involv-
or her mother was on the study medication. There were five ing domperidone and a placebo may be impossible; mothers
neonatal ECGs with a Q-Tc interval > 500 ms in clinically know that domperidone appears to have some benefit and
asymptomatic preterm infants, at the start and end of the may not be willing to consider being randomized to a pla-
study medication period; these may be innate findings related cebo. Finally, our aim for this article was to estimate the
to the electrophysiologic mechanisms of preterm infants effects of allocating an approach in care with domperidone in
requiring more evaluation (Ulrich et al., 2014). clinical practice, that is, whether initiating treatment with
The incidence of mothers experiencing an inadequate domperidone earlier would achieve a 50% increase in human
milk volume and the rate of recruitment into the trial were milk volume compared with initiating later. It will be impor-
less than originally anticipated, despite adjustments in the tant to assess the effects of domperidone more clearly to see
inclusion criteria early into the trial. Although this may, in which mothers truly benefited or did not benefit from this
part, be due to an overestimation on our part and the part of approach in care.
Asztalos et al. 187