ETHICAL MATRIX OF THE CLONE MOVIE

By :
Name : Safira Dwi Oktaviani
Student ID : B1B015002
Class : D / 2015
Subject : Ethical Biology

STRUCTURE TASK OF ETHICAL BIOLOGY

MINISTRY OF RESEARCH, TECHNOLOGY, AND HIGER EDUCATION

JENDERAL SOEDIRMAN UNIVERSITY
BIOLOGY FACULTY
PURWOKERTO

2018
 ETHICAL MATRIX OF THE CLONE MOVIE

Interest group Principle

A. Well Being B. Autonomy C. Justice
Patients in chronic Clue : produce a new Clue : The cloned Clue: Get maximum
diseases and organ organ organism is sacrificed treatment and get a
damage Answer : Yes for use as a drug or new organ that
Argument: Because used as an organ works well
in the presence of donor for the patient Answer: Yes
cloning, patients who Answer : NO Argument: in the
suffered damage to Argument : Cloning damaged organ is
their organs of new treatment using very difficult to
organs with a high embryonic cells that return in full, this
cost. will eventually grow makes the cloning
into the desired organ treatment is very
appropriate to do to
replace the organ
that is not
functioning with
healthy organs that
are still working
properly

Endangered animals Clue: Conservation of Clue: Using other Clue: Sustainable

rare animals animals as a place of Answer: Yes
Answer: Yes embryo growth Argument: in the
Argument: in one Answer: Yes presence of cloning
endangered Argument: using technology can make
population it is very other animals as a animals with low
difficult to develop a place of embryo populations able to
 culture in a natural growth of cloned defend the
way, cloning can animals can certainly population.
produce the animal's damage the cloning
animal without having result and can also kill
to sacrifice the brood the animal

Livestock Clue: Livestock can Clue: Using other Clue: Renew organs
live longer, and there animals as a place to using a young
is repair of damaged test the function of immune system
organs in farm cloned cells cloned
animals Answer: No Answer: Yes
Answer: Yes Argument: because Argument: the
Argument: the every organ in living renewal of immunity
increasing age of the things has different can help repair
animal causes the specific functions damaged organs, so
older tissues and cells different. as to make the
in the organs to cause damaged organs can
damage return to function
properly.
Embryo Clue: The required Clue: The captured Clue: Embryo
cells can be used cell can turn off the cannot grow into
properly embryo adulthood
Answer: Yes Answer: Yes Answer: Yes
Argument: cells in Argument: cells that Argument: because
the embryo will grow are used and derived the one taken for
into specific organs from embryos are cloning is a core part
with the same embryonic stem cells of embryo growth,
function and can be that determine growth causing the embryo
used to die
Conclusion: cloning is basically very helpful in overcoming the problem of treatment that
requires organ donation, besides without sacrificing other creatures the time needed
is not so long, and also can be used as one of the solution for conservation of rare
animals with very low population. However cloning uses embryos thus inhibiting
even the embryo's own shutting down. Until now cloning solutions for both
treatment and conservation are still being debated by experts.