Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Page 1 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
Table of Contents
TABLE OF CONTENTS ........................................................................................................... 2
1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .................................................................................................. 3
2 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................. 4
2.1 BACKGROUND ............................................................................................................. 4
3 PART 1: ANALYSIS ........................................................................................................ 6
3.1 STRATEGIC CONTEXT ................................................................................................... 6
3.2 OPERATIONAL CONTEXT..................................................................................................10
3.3 SIPOC – FROM TIMESHEETS TO INVOICE............................................................................12
3.4 PROCESS MAPPING – MONTH END PROCESS ........................................................................13
3.5 PROCESS PROFILING – FOUR VS .......................................................................................15
3.6 PERFORMANCE OBJECTIVES .............................................................................................17
4 PART 2: RECOMMENDATION ...................................................................................... 18
4.1 ACTIONS REQUIRED AND JUSTIFICATION WITH ANALYSIS ........................................................18
4.2 OUTLINE PLAN TO IMPROVE ORGANISATIONAL PERFORMANCE ..................................................20
5 PART 3: IMPLEMENTATION ........................................................................................ 22
5.1 GANTT CHART – PROJECT IMPROVEMENT PLAN .....................................................................22
5.2 FINANCIAL COST ...........................................................................................................23
5.3 JUSTIFICATION AND IMPACT OF RECOMMENDATIONS ..............................................................24
5.4 BUSINESS BENEFITS – CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT ...............................................................26
5.5 MEASUREMENT OF PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT...................................................................28
5.6 IMPLICATIONS OF CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT .....................................................................29
6 REFLECTION ............................................................................................................... 30
6.1 ELECTIVE PATHWAY – MANAGING THE PROJECT BASED ENVIRONMENT .......................................30
6.2 VALUE ADD ..................................................................................................................30
6.3 LEARNING EXPERIENCE ...................................................................................................31
7 REFERENCES............................................................................................................... 32
8 APPENDICES ............................................................................................................... 34
8.1 APPENDIX A – PROFESSIONAL SERVICES MATURITY MODEL .....................................................34
8.2 APPENDIX B –FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION INTERNAL CUSTOMER SURVEY RESULTS 2010 ...........36
8.3 APPENDIX C – FINANCE AND ADMINISTRATION TEAM BALANCED SCORECARD 2011 .......................38
8.4 APPENDIX D – SOLTIUS ORGANISATION CHART ....................................................................38
Page 2 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
1 Executive Summary
The report aims to critically evaluate process improvement concepts specific to the
organisational context of Soltius. It describes the process problem and identifies
opportunities to improve service delivery and strategic alignment. Specifically, the
report analyses the process-related problem that the current financial month end
close within Soltius is taking 2 days too long. In resolving this issue, the report
analyses both the strategic and organisational context to show how the issue has
arisen. Based on the analysis, the recommendation is to move from a monthly
process of timesheet report reviews and posting of timesheets to a weekly process.
This report also employs project management techniques using a comprehensive
Gantt chart to manage the steps of the process improvement plan. Due to the nature
of the process problem, the recommendation and implementation is largely based on
continuous process improvement methodologies which relates to achieving
improvements by using small-step improvements, rather than implementing one large
quantum improvement.
Finally this report ends with a reflective statement that includes insights into the
elective pathway ‘Managing the Project- based Environment’ and how this learning
has influenced the outcome of the findings in this report. The reflective statement
also includes the value gained from undertaking the ‘Managing Processes, Systems
and Projects’ course and the appreciation and contribution of systems and processes
that result in better performance within Soltius.
Page 3 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
2 Introduction
2.1 Background
Soltius was established in 1996 and today is one of New Zealand’s leading IT
consulting firms with annual turnover exceeding $22 million, and 85+ full time
employees offering an extensive range of IT services to New Zealand and Australian
businesses. The core operations is SAP (ERP) based solutions to New Zealand
based private and public sector organisations. Soltius is New Zealand’s second-
largest provider of ERP consultancy services behind only SAP. The Company is
100% New Zealand owned and the shareholders are the directors and part of
executive management.
My role at Soltius is the Finance and Administration Manager, part of the executive
management team and I have 4 direct reports who look after the Finance,
Administration, HR and IT operations of the business. Whilst my responsibilities are
predominantly finance based and commercial in nature, I am also across any HR and
IT issues both from a process and risk perspective. Please refer to Appendix D
which outlines the Soltius organisation chart.
Following on, as the Manager of the Soltius Finance and Administration team; I have
several financial accountabilities including the month end turnaround, debtors ageing,
credit notes, and more importantly cash flow. The process problem for the purpose
of this report is in relation to inadequate turnaround of month end due to delays in the
timesheet report review process. Currently we are achieving on average a 7 day
close against a target of 5. Based on further analysis and improvement of the
timesheet report review process, (that is, posting time weekly instead of monthly) it is
expected to reduce the month end close by 2 days.
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
two forms of organisations, the mechanistic form, and the organic form. Soltius is
based on the characteristics of the organic form with a basic flexibility to re-shape the
company to address new competitive problems and uncertainty as they arise.
The first sections of this report 3.1 and 3.2 discuss both the strategic and operational
context relating to the process problem and the analysis. This is followed by a
recommendation and implementation plan to improve the process problem and
achieve business benefits as a result.
Page 5 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
3 Part 1: Analysis
The process-related problem: The month end close takes on average 7 business
days. By speeding up and improving the timesheet report review process could
reduce the month end close to 5 business days.
As part of the 2011 Business Plan process Soltius underwent a detailed exercise to
benchmark company performance against a global Professional Services Maturity
Model (refer appendix A for an outline of this model). This model was introduced by
SPI Research in 2008 and provides in-depth information on the best practices,
trends, and technology in the professional services industry. This provided Soltius
comparative analysis into all facets of business performance against best practices
and highlighted the strength and weaknesses to measure the maturity of Soltius as a
professional services organisation. In particular, it provided insight into current
process weaknesses and focus for process improvement in areas such as strategy,
finance and operations, human capital management (HCM), customers, and service
execution.
Figure 3.0 shows both Soltius current state and targeted future position in 5 key
areas of the business. Given the level of improvement and detailed analysis required
in all 5 areas of the business, the scope of this report is limited to the finance and
operations component of the model. In particular, a core process within finance.
Page 6 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
Human Capital
Service Execution
Management
Current Future
Table 3.0 below sets out what the Soltius business strategy requires the finance
operations process to be able to do.
Current Target
Finance and 2 3
Operations
Page 7 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
Current Target
As Microsoft founder Bill Gates once said, “The first rule of any technology used in a
business is that automation applied to an efficient operation will magnify the
Page 8 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
Below is a cartoon (author unknown) which clearly depicts the expectation gap
between what organisations system requirements are and how an organisation
operates. It is an appropriate analogy of the challenge Soltius faces in order to make
a quantum investment in technology.
Page 9 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
The team largely provides administrative support and assistance to the project
managers as well as collection, and reporting of the project data and financial
reconciliations.
The annual Finance and Administration internal survey is a useful feedback tool to
help isolate the weak processes and define a more feasible scope for the purpose of
this report. The most recent results from a survey conducted in late 2010 highlighted
three particular areas of weakness as per the following table:
Page 10 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
The results indicate that the level of communication has weakened as has the
timeliness and quality of reports. The reports relate to timesheets that are currently
reviewed monthly before the billing process starts.
The next section 3.3 provides a high level view of the timesheet review and billing
process. This high level process map is better known as SIPOC which is a six sigma
tool (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SIPOC). SIPOC is an acronym for suppliers, input,
process, output, and customers, and it is used during the define phase of this
process improvement problem to help understand the purpose and the scope of a
process.
Page 11 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
Page 12 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
Complete Compete
Update cash Payroll Enter Support Check 59990
Fixed Asset Prepayments
flow Journal Base Fees code in GL
Schedule Schedule
Page 13 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
Day five
Z-
Davids Enter all WIP Password
Update Contractors Finish Revenue WIP Review Bonus Post Back write-
Expense invoices in Accruals Reconciliation Protect
cash flow Schedule Billing IJ Provisions Financials Accrual Tax Up GL off
Schedule GL & APS Sheet Month
check
Day six
Process Mapping as per above visually depicts the sequence of events to complete the month end financial results for Soltius. The
highlighted red circles of the process indicate the timesheet review and billing process, and the areas most affected by this process.
The section below outlines the way in which the timesheet review and billing process needs to be managed based on the four
characteristics of demand.
Page 14 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
As in most PSFs the key transforming resources is the people with highly specialised
skills and how they are utilised is the key challenge in a PSF.
“The scheduling of work assignments is the single most important managerial activity
in a professional services firm. Whoever makes the work assignment decisions is the
person really managing the practice”. (Maister, 1997)
In the next figure 3.1 Soltius has been positioned on the Four Vs framework. In
addition, the way in which the timesheet reports and billing needs to be managed is
influenced by volume, variety, variation and visibility and is also positioned in the
framework. As Slack et al (2009) suggests it is typical to expect to see most points in
PSFs over to the left of the framework as in the Soltius profile highlighted in orange.
However, the internal profile of the actual process itself is quite different to how
Soltius operates externally as per figure 3.1 shows.
Page 15 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
Figure 3.1 Soltius and Timesheet and Billing Process Profiling (Adapted from
Slack et al (2009:23)
Soltius as a
Timesheet Review
Professional Services
Firm and Billing Process
Tasks spread
amongst staff Low High Specialisation
Low repetition Soltius Volume PROCESS High repetition, standardised
High unit cost Low unit costs
The aim is to have a straight line. With regard to the timesheet review and billing
process the profiling above indicates that there is high variety of services that are
complex in nature. Examples include complex support timesheet recording by call
number, detailed time and materials, and milestone billing. This requires a wide
range of inputs to the process from both customer and internal systems. A
specialised system was developed to handle support billing and meet customer
requirements, and this has created complexity in the month end billing process.
Page 16 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
Table 3.2 Describing and Rating Perfomance Objectives - (Adapted from Henley PSP module)
Internal
Competitive importance (1 =
importance (1 = High, 9 High, 9 low) -
low) - External Overall Soltius
Performance Objective Definition Aspects of this objective include customer perspective strategy
Correct timesheet/ information on
Quality Doing things right time and on budget 1 1
Timesheet review quick invoice
Speed Doing things fast sent > 3 days 2 2
Timesheet complete and reviewed
Dependability Doing things on time on time 5 3
Preparation of invoice and
Flexibility Changing what you do timesheet adjustments 8 4
Cost of resource time and systems
Cost Doing things cheaply cost 9 5
The next section proposes a future course of action likely to deliver business
performance improvements, specifically, to ensure month end is completed within 5
business days.
Page 17 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
4 Part 2: Recommendation
4.1 Actions Required and Justification with Analysis
The following table outlines approaches to process redesign and the actions that are
required to help implement change.
Based on the analysis in section 3.3, the SIPOC diagram identified possible
duplication in the timesheet and billing process with both the Administrator and
Accountant sending the same information to Project Managers but with different
output. That is, the Administrator sends the timesheet detail and the Accountant
sends the draft invoice. Furthermore, section 3.6 clearly identified quality and speed
as the most important performance objectives for the design process. Therefore, the
Project Managers need to see the timesheet detail in order to confirm the information
is correct and on budget. In order to improve the long term quality of the timesheet
data, employees need to be advised of errors and this adds further time to the
process. If the time is posted in a test environment first, and all the corrections are
made in the production system then this will improve the quality of the information
and reduce timesheet adjustments required at month end (currently approximately 1-
2 days each month is spent completing timesheet adjustments).
Page 18 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
In addition, Section 3.5 provided for process profiling and identified variety as high
and a deviation from the straight line. By enabling more routine behaviours and
increasing the standardisation of the timesheet review process should result in lower
variety therefore moving variety to fit with low variation in demand and visibility, and
higher volume. (Slack et al, 2009)
Therefore in order to develop a new process, all stakeholders who own the process
(Accountant, Administrator, and Project Manager) identified all activities performed in
the process, the order of the tasks, and agreed on realistic timeframes for completing
each task. The new process created is provided in the next section.
Page 19 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
Likewise, although the strategic initiative to evaluate ERP systems is also outside the
scope of this report, this process improvement will ensure greater efficiency of the
month end process and provide requirements for any system improvement.
Page 20 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
Notify IT when
complete
Page 21 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
5 Part 3: Implementation
5.1 Gantt Chart – Project Improvement Plan
Project Kaizen - Timesheet review process
Soltius New Zealand Today's Date: 26/09/2011 Monday
(vertical red line)
Project Lead: Amanda Goddard
Start Date: 27/06/2011 Monday
[42] First Day of Week (Mon=2): 2
Days Remaining
Duration (Days)
Days Complete
27 - Jun - 11
05 - Sep - 11
12 - Sep - 11
19 - Sep - 11
26 - Sep - 11
Working Days
01 - Aug - 11
08 - Aug - 11
15 - Aug - 11
22 - Aug - 11
29 - Aug - 11
04 - Jul - 11
11 - Jul - 11
18 - Jul - 11
25 - Jul - 11
% Complete
Task
WBS Tasks Lead Start End
1 Define the scope of the process problem CFO 6/27/11 6/27/11 1 100% 1 1 0
2.1 Identify issues w ith current timesheet report rev iew Accountant 7/16/11 8/04/11 20 100% 14 20 0
3 Design Accountant 8/04/11 9/01/11 29 100% 21 29 0
3.1 Simplify process and make changes Accountant 8/05/11 8/14/11 10 100% 6 10 0
3.2 Flow chart the rev ised timesheet rev iew process Administrator 8/15/11 8/19/11 5 100% 5 5 0
3.3 Identify if further improv ement feasible CFO 8/20/11 8/21/11 2 100% 0 2 0
3.4 Seek feedback from team CFO 8/22/11 8/26/11 5 100% 5 5 0
3.5 Refine process - approv al from team Accountant 8/20/11 8/26/11 7 100% 5 7 0
Checkpoint against performance objectiv es and
3.6 baseline targets CFO 8/26/11 9/01/11 7 100% 5 7 0
4 Implementation Accountant 9/01/11 9/12/11 12 100% 8 12 0
4.1 Plan to implement the process change Accountant 8/26/11 8/30/11 5 100% 3 5 0
4.2 Dev elop test platform Accountant 8/26/11 8/30/11 5 100% 3 5 0
4.3 Notify key roles such as Project Managers Accountant 8/30/11 8/30/11 1 100% 1 1 0
4.4 Implement the process change Accountant 8/31/11 9/01/11 2 100% 2 2 0
4.5 Seek feedback from team CFO 9/06/11 9/06/11 1 100% 1 1 0
5 Test Accountant 9/06/11 9/12/11 7 100% 5 7 0
Test process change against performance
5.1 objectiv es - quality and speed Accountant 9/08/11 9/10/11 3 100% 2 3 0
Test process change against baseline
5.2 measurement - 5 day close, credit notes <1% Accountant 9/08/11 9/10/11 3 100% 2 3 0
5.3 Report results to CFO Accountant 9/10/11 9/10/11 1 100% 0 1 0
5.4 Refine process if required Accountant 9/08/11 9/12/11 5 100% 3 5 0
6 Recommend CFO 9/12/11 9/25/11 14 31% 10 4 10
6.1 Complete recommendation Accountant 9/12/11 9/16/11 5 100% 5 5 0
6.2 Rev iew and approv e recommendation CFO 9/16/11 9/25/11 10 0% 6 0 10
6.3 Communicate recommendation to w ider group CFO 9/25/11 9/25/11 1 0% 0 0 1
A Gantt chart (Harry Gantt) is a common project planning tool for planning and
keeping track of individual tasks within a project, or in this case a process
improvement plan. The Gantt Chart above details the actions that will need to be
taken to implement the proposed process improvement. Section 5.2 outlines the
financial investment or opportunity cost of undergoing the process improvement.
Page 22 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
To date Forecast 27-Jun 4-Jul 11-Jul 18-Jul 25-Jul 1-Aug 8-Aug 15-Aug 22-Aug 29-Aug 5-Sep 12-Sep 19-Sep
Resource Budget Hours ETC Hours Budget $ rate Hours $ Hours Scope Analysis Analysis Analysis Analysis Design Design Design Design Implementation Test Test Recommend
Accountant 25 24.00 $4,580 $183.20 24 $4,396.80 0 0 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
Administrator 10 8.50 $1,432 $143.20 9 $1,217.20 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 1.5 1 0 0
Project Manager/CFO 10 9.50 $7,094 $709.36 10 $6,738.92 0 1 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 1 1 1 1 1
IT Administrator 2 3.00 $566 $283.20 3 $849.60 0 0 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25
Contingency 6 6.00 $1,099 $183.20 6 $1,099.20 0 0 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5
53.00 51.00 $14,771 51.00 $14,301.72 0.00 $142.37 $110.44 $110.44 $110.44 $110.44 $110.44 $110.44 $164.14 $154.77 $181.62 $172.67 $154.77 $154.77
Budget Reconciliation
Budget 14,771
Dif ference 469
3%
Page 23 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
“Six Sigma is a comprehensive and flexible system for achieving, sustaining and
maximising business success. Six Sigma is uniquely driven by close understanding
of customer needs, disciplined use of facts, data, and statistical analysis, and diligent
attention to managing, improving, and reinventing business processes” Pande et al
(2000)
Six Sigma principles were adopted as it helps remove errors and waste out of
processes. It also engages leadership by establishing linkage to strategic objectives.
It is a tried and tested process improvement methodology and it is flexible enough to
customise to fit the size of Solitus and the scale of the problem. The downside of the
Six Sigma approach is that it is resource heavy as is evident in the amount of hours
taken to implement the process (51 actual hours as per the financial reconciliation in
section 5.2 above).
Page 24 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
1. Increase throughput
2. Reduce inventory
3. Reduce operating expense
The recommendation engaged all affected staff to contribute to improvement and the
resulting impact of the recommendations is that August month end closed on day 6.
By spreading the tasks over the calendar weeks and utilising technology to test pilot
the data has had a positive impact on month end. Specifically, billing was completed
within 3 business days. The recommendations made were simple and were utilising
team based problem solving and very basic statistical data. The simple changes
ensured the performance objectives of the process improvement were achieved.
Page 25 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
What are the benefits? This is best answered with the question what are the benefits
of NOT having a continuous improvement plan? Why would a company not want to
pursue continuous improvement and not have a learning organisation?
By engaging in process improvement, Soltius and its employees will seek to learn
what causes events to happen and aim to:
The benefit of continuous improvement is that it does not cause any quantum scale
organisational change. In terms of operational strategy, if used correctly, it can
become part of the Finance and Administration team’s culture where as individuals
will feel they are making a meaningful contribution to the company. This is important
in an existing cultural climate where the ‘back office’ is viewed as pure overhead with
no billable opportunities. The disadvantage of this theory is that it does not provide
for innovation and the quantum investment in an ERP system which is the overriding
strategic initiative. However, any investment in technology will still require continuous
improvement methodology for ensuring a long term return on investment.
Page 26 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
1. Embed the principles of continuous improvement into the culture of the team
and make it an integral part of the way things are done
2. Improve systems and processes in the context of best practice and the
professional services maturity model
3. Ensure processes and services are shaped around both the internal and
external customer priorities
So, the team needs to continually search for more efficient ways of delivering
services, involve all stakeholders, and target individual’s strengths at the right tasks
in order to fully realise the benefits that can be gained.
Page 27 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
Page 28 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
Like many medium sized companies, Soltius struggles with cost and the day to day
operational pressures. In order to gain competitive advantage, Soltius needs to
invest in capital and developing people in order to improve systems and processes
as there is a current lack of capability in the back office team. Therefore one of the
implications of continuous improvement methodology is that staff will need training to
up-skill and become equipped with the process improvement toolkits as well as keep
on top of operational demands. Training budgets are often the first to be cut during
the normal budgeting process so the challenge will be to show the Strategy team
how this training investment will lead to bottom line results. However, it is not enough
to just focus on continuous improvement as the implications of this will inevitably lead
to being undermined by more innovative competitors. In today’s business
environment, competitive advantage lies in the company’s ability to innovate its way
out of market pressures facing them (Goshal, 1999). Therefore, it is important the
continuous improvement strategy is not viewed in isolation to the overall strategic
plan as provided in section 3.
“If you think of „„standardisation‟‟ as the best that you know today, but which is to be
improved tomorrow—you get somewhere. But if you think of standards as confining,
then progress stops” Henry Ford, (1926).
Page 29 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
6 Reflection
6.1 Elective Pathway – Managing the Project Based
Environment
The new challenge within a matrix project based company is to develop a ‘project
office’ team who can deliver on the challenge of continuous improvement. This will
incorporate training, active performance management, and targeted recruitment with
the goal to developing a performance led culture of continuous improvement and
innovation.
Shortly we will be embarking on our strategy offsite where I will develop a 2012
business plan for my team aligned to the overall 2012 strategic objectives. With my
new knowledge gained from the course module my goal will be to share the
continuous philosophy with my team and build the pathway to a more effective and
efficient working group to support the project managers and company.
Given a valuable part of my role within Soltius is to manage costs and improve
efficiencies, I found this module very rewarding in terms of gaining appreciation for
systems and processes and how this new knowledge can enable me to move
forward and focus on the strategic initiative to evaluate cloud based ERP technology.
My undergraduate study was focused on improving shareholder value, as did my
Chartered Accountancy training, and my experience to date has largely been looking
Page 30 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
at processes as ‘red tape’ and a ‘time waster’. It has changed my view of why having
the right processes in place will improve the systems and the management of the
organisation. The module has largely influenced my thinking that constantly looking
for new and better ways of doing things, will foster growth, raise performance
profiles, and provide a rewarding structure for even the more simple tasks. My
challenge now will be to empower my team to embrace methodologies of managing
systems and processes as I have.
Page 31 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
7 References
APM (2006) APM Body of Knowledge, 5th ed. Princes Risborough: Association for
Project Management.
Chapman, C & Ward, S (1997) Project Risk Management. Chichester: John Wiley &
Sons
Christensen, C M (1997) The Innovator's Dilemma: When New Technologies Cause
Great Firms to Fail. Boston: Harvard Business School Press
Davenport, T H (1993) Process Innovation: Reengineering Work Through Information
Technology. Boston: Harvard Business School Press
Dettmer, H (1996) Goldratt‟s Theory of Constraints: A Systems Approach to
Continous Improvement. Asq Pr
Harmon, P (2007) Business Process Change, 2nd ed. San Francisco: Morgan
Kaufmann
Kaplan, R S & Norton, D P (1992) The balanced scorecard: measures that drive
performance. Harvard Business Review, 70 (1), 71–9 Maister, D H (1997) Managing
the Professional Service Firm. New York: Free Press
Kotter, J P (1995) Leading change: why transformation efforts fail. Harvard Business
Review, 73 (2), 59–67
Page 32 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
Maister, D H (1997) Managing the Professional Service Firm. New York: Free Press
for the design of organizational control mechanisms. Management Science, 25 (9),
833–48
Midler, C (1995) ‘Projectification‟ of the firm, the Renault case. Scandinavian Journal
of Management, 11 (4), 363-75
Pande, P.S., Neuman, R.P. and Cavanagh, R.R. (2000) The Six Sigma Way,
McGraw-Hill, New York
Rummler, G A & Brache, A P (1995) Improving Performance: How to Manage the
White Space on the Organization Chart. San Fransisco: Jossey-Bass
Slack, N, Chambers, S, Johnston, R & Betts, A (2009) Operations and Process
Management: Principles and Practice for Strategic Impact, 2nd ed. Harlow: FT
Prentice Hall
Slack, N & Lewis, M (2008) Operations Strategy, 2nd ed. Harlow: Pearson Education
Swank, C K (2003) The lean service machine. Harvard Business Review, 81 (10),
123–9
Torrington, D, Hall, L and Taylor, S (2005) Human Resource Management, 5th ed.
Harlow: Prentice Hall Europe
Page 33 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
8 Appendices
8.1 Appendix A – Professional Services Maturity Model
Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 Level 5
Initiated Piloted Deployed Institutionalized Optimized
Initial strategy
PS has become
is to support Service leads PS is critical to
a profit centre PS is important
product sales products. PS is a the company.
but is revenue &
and provide vital part of the Service strategy
subordinate to margin source
reference company. is clear.
product sales. but channel
customers Solution selling is Complimentary
Leadership Strategy is to conflict still
while providing a way of life. PS goals %
drive customer exists. Services
workarounds to is included in all measurements in
adoption and differentiate
complete strategy place for all
references products.
immature decisions. functions.
profitably.
product.
> 40% margin.
PS generates > Continuous
5 to 20% 20 to 30% 20% of overall improvement &
The PSO has enhancement.
margin. PS margin. PS is a company revenue
been created High profit.
becoming a complete P&L. and contributes >
but is not yet Global with
Finance & profit centre but Standard 30% margin.
profitable. disciplined
Operations still immature method for Well-developed
Rudimentary processes,
finance & resource mgmt., finance &
time & expense controls &
operations time, expense & operations
capture. optimization.
processes. billing. processes &
controls.
Continually staff
Resource Business process & train to meet
Hire as needed. Begin future needs.
management, & vertical skills in
Generalist forecasting Highly skilled,
skill mgmt, addition to
skills. workload. Start motivated
Human career mgmt, technical &
Chameleons, developing job workforce.
Capital employee project skills.
Jack of All & skill Outsource
Alignment satisfaction Career ladder.
Trades. descriptions & commodity skills
surveys. Training Training
Individual compensation or peaks.
plans. Attrition investment. Low
heroics. plans.
>20% attrition.
Collaborative An integrated
portal, begin solution drives
Skeleton Integrated project
looking at performance.
No scheduling. methodology in & resource
Service Earned Value Continual checks
Reactive. Ad place. Initiating management.
Execution Analysis. Project & balances to
hoc. Heroic. project mgmt. & Using portfolio
dashboard & assure superior
technical skills. management.
quality utilization & bill
measurements. rates.
Opportunistic. Start to use Marketing, inside Business process Executive
Client
No defined marketing to sales, solutions & vertical relationships.
Relationships
solution sets. drive leads. sales with solutions in Thought
Page 34 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
Current Target
Client Relationships 2 5
Service Execution 2 3
Page 35 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
8.2 Appendix B –Finance and Administration Internal Customer Survey Results 2010
Page 36 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
Finance and Administration Internal Customer Survey Results Comparisons between 2009 and 2010
Page 37 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”
MPP Assignment Two – Stream HB46
Perceived value of the Finance 70% or above for internal back Measurement to be taken in
Customer
& Admin Team office customer survey November each year
Acrobat Document
Page 38 of 38
PSP Assignment
Amanda Goddard 18905119
“Talent and Attitude to deliver the right business solutions whatever it takes.”