Sie sind auf Seite 1von 8

IET Electric Power Applications

Research Article

ISSN 1751-8660
Application of grounded metallic enclosing Received on 7th October 2015
Revised on 4th December 2015
mesh for expanding rated voltage of Accepted on 26th December 2015
doi: 10.1049/iet-epa.2015.0449
dry-type transformer www.ietdl.org

Luiz F. de Oliveira 1, Sérgio H.L. Cabral 2 ✉


1
Departamento de Engenharia, WEG T&D, Blumenau, Brazil
2
Departamento de Engenharia Elétrica e Telecomunicações, Universidade de Blumenau, Blumenau, Brazil
✉ E-mail: scabral@furb.br

Abstract: Thanks to the awareness of safety, dry-type transformer has experienced a significant demand, lately. However,
a limiting condition for an even more significant increase in its demand is that its maximum rated voltage is about 36 kV, in
most of countries. Beyond this limit, dry-type transformer becomes definitely uneconomical in comparison to oil-filled
transformer because of the expressive increase in dielectric clearance distances and consequent drawbacks. Thus, the
aim of this work is to propose a way for overcoming this limit, based on shielding the electric field of the high-voltage
windings of the dry transformer with a grounded metallic mesh. The effectiveness of the proposition is shown whereas
most of the undesirable of its consequences are also evaluated. Namely, losses and temperature rise concerns as well
as items of standard dielectric tests, which are analysed through computer modelling and simulation. Due to its
outstanding importance, analysis of distribution of lightning impulse voltage along the high-voltage winding is also
experimentally performed. The result is a set of key hints given by the authors and to be observed by transformer
designers for making real the production of dry-type transformer with a rated voltage higher than 36 kV.

1 Introduction propositions, they do not present the main features for designing a
dry-type transformer with a rated voltage higher than 36 kV. Thus,
Despite some drawbacks, the dry-type transformer has some based on these concerns, this work brings a somehow new
well-recognised and unquestionable advantages over the oil-filled proposition for the effective reduction of the dielectric distances in
transformer [1, 2]. Ranging from the obvious impossibility of oil the design of a dry-type transformer with rated voltage higher than
leakage and a consequent environment pollution until the fact that 36 kV. This proposition is based on [6] and suggests the use of a
most of the types of resin practically do not propagate fire, dry grounded metallic mesh for enclosing the HV winding and
type is somehow famous for being safer than oil-filled transformer. confining its HV gradient for reducing its clearance radial distance
Yet, oil-filled transformer can even explode and spill off its hot oil to the low-voltage (LV) winding. For better illustrating this
as well as exhale toxic gases, in case of fire due to a short circuit, proposition, an analysis of the main features of the design of a real
for example. Thus, dry-type transformer is not only preferred for 1500 kVA, 13.8/0.38 kV, 60 Hz transformer is performed for
some applications in which people are around it but it is showing how the increase in its rated voltage may take place. On
sometimes strongly recommended, which may explain its the other hand, because this transformer has a very basic design, it
relatively high and increasingly demand. However, dry-type can play the role of a good reference for every transformer
transformer is not commercially available for the whole range of designer. Thus, key issues of transformer design like losses,
rated voltages of the power system. Despite some few exceptions, temperature raise and dielectric tests are carefully analysed through
as in [3, 4], its maximum rated voltage has roughly been limited to computer simulation. Still, because of its significant importance,
36 kV. Although dry-type transformer with a higher rated voltage the analysis of the performance under lightning impulse test is also
is technically feasible, the imperative reason for this limit is purely made through experimental simulations. The result is a set of
economic. It lies in the facts that, by taking all the usual hints, clues and analyses for all the well-known critical items of
procedures of transformer design, for any rated voltage higher than the design of a dry-type transformer for allowing every designer to
36 kV some of the clearance distances should increase so much. In be engaged in the production of dry-type transformer with a rated
consequence, the size as well as the weight and thus the price of voltage higher than 36 kV.
the dry-type transformer would become a drawback, in comparison
to an oil-filled transformer [2]. Other undesirable consequences
would be the significant increase in the value of the no-load losses 2 Concerns of insulating radial distance for
as well as the leakage impedance. Additional consequences are dry-type transformer
discussed in [5]. Specifically, the need in increasing clearance
distances occurs because of the significant difference between the Today, for most of transformer manufacturers and under normal
values of the dielectric permittivity of its two unique insulating conditions, the maximum rated voltage for a dry-type transformer
materials, resin and air, as well as of the relatively low value of is about 36 kV. The key reason for defining this limit is that a
dielectric withstand of the air, in comparison to that of the resin. significant increase in the radial distance between the HV and the
In consequence, when a high-voltage (HV) winding of a dry-type LV windings is necessary for any rated voltage higher than 36 kV.
transformer is energised a high value of electric field appears This is so because most of this radial distance is air filled since its
along the air distance, exactly where the dielectric withstand is primary function is to allow heat exchanging for both windings
lower. Nonetheless, overcoming suchlike barriers is a natural through the airflow between them. However, this air radial
challenge and need for all those who design transformers. Thus, distance also serves as a natural dielectric barrier between
although [3, 4] can be taken as significant examples of succeeded windings. On the other hand, since the radial distance is composed

IET Electr. Power Appl., 2016, Vol. 10, Iss. 5, pp. 411–418
& The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2016 411
by air and resin, the dielectric permittivity of the atmospheric air is ɛo allows reducing it as well as considering higher rated voltage for
and about 4.4ɛo for the resin that involves the windings, a the HV winding and for the transformer, as a whole. In its
significantly HV gradient appears along the air radial distance essence, the proposed method consists of enclosing the resin
when an abnormal but predictable voltage is applied to its HV external walls of the HV winding with a grounded metallic mesh.
winding, for example, during a dielectric test. Special attention must be paid to the shape of the enclosing mesh
For illustrating this situation, Fig. 1 shows the values of the rms for avoiding it to become a short-circuited coil and thus cause
electric field plotted along the radial distance of one phase of a transformer damages. Figs. 2a–c show some details of the design
1500 kVA, 13.8/0.38 kV, 60 Hz, dry-type transformer under a test of the proposed mesh.
voltage of 50 kV at industrial frequency to its HV winding. The From Fig. 2 it is noticeable that the proposed method is not that
Fig. 1a corresponds to the actual condition of design, whereas the same well-known electrostatic shielding, which consists of a
Fig. 1b corresponds to a hypothetic condition, if no resin is grounded solid metallic foil lying between the HV and the LV
applied on any of the windings. windings for providing their capacitive decoupling. On the other
Consider this analysis as done in a radial distance far from the hand, the proposed mesh covers the HV winding almost
edges of the concentric windings and therefore the electric field thoroughly with a layer of resin between them, whereas another
may be considered as uniform. Also, consider that the radial layer of resin covers the mesh, externally. One of the main reasons
distance is zero at the outer radius of the LV winding and 50 mm for taking a mesh as metallic enclosing is exactly for its easier
at the inner radius of the HV winding. In the case of the Fig. 1a, application before the resin may be dry, along its production.
the radial length of resin on the HV winding is about 6 mm. Fig. 3 shows the profile of gradient voltage along the radial
Thus, in accordance with the radial profiles of voltage gradient of distance for the same 1500 kVA, 13.8/0.38 kV, 60 Hz dry-type
Fig. 1 it is noticeable how the inherent use of the resin causes a transformer, in a similar condition as of Fig. 1, when the metallic
significant decrease in the voltage gradient along the distance mesh is included.
where it is applied, whereas it also causes an increase in the Comparison of results of Figs. 1 and 3 shows how effective the
voltage gradient along the remaining air radial distance. Therefore, proposed mesh is in mitigating the voltage gradient along the air
in the case of the presence of an even higher voltage across the radial distance between windings of each phase. In consequence,
HV winding, the voltage gradient along the air radial distance can the level of voltage gradient within the resin layer increases
reach its limit [Usually, 3 kV/mm for air and 20 kV/mm for resin significantly. However, the obtained level is far to reach the
are values taken as references at room temperature . However, for withstand limit of any usual type of resin, which means a more
temperatures up to 140°C, as in the case of an operating power efficient and rational use of the material.
transformer, both these limit become quite lower.] before voltage However, it is suspectable that the addition of the proposed mesh
gradient within the resin can reach its own limit. In Fig. 1b, may disturb negatively the performance of the transformer in other
maximum value of electric field is 0.9 kVrms/mm that corresponds items than the distribution of the electric field along radial distance
to 1.27 kVpeak/mm. of the windings, at industrial frequency. Especially, in regard to
Despite this is a very clear way to show how the resin causes the losses, for both conditions of on-load and no-load, that are expected
transference of voltage gradient, the most critical region for defining to increase after addition of the proposed enclosing mesh and thus
the radial distance is close to the edges of the windings. This is the maximum working temperature of the transformer may exceed
because in this area distortion of the electric field makes the limit acceptable limits. On the other hand, even about all the concerns of
of voltage gradient along the air radial distance to be quite lower the new distribution of the electric field along radial distances the
than 3 kV/mm. addition of the mesh is also supposed to compromise the
In any case, it is clear that the air radial distance is the weaker and performance of the transformer. That is why standard tests of
thus the key element for the definition of distance between LV and dielectric withstand are also analysed. Ranging from the applied
HV windings. voltage test to the induced voltage test, by including the lightning
Thus, for dealing with this matter, the authors propose a method impulse voltage test, the influence of this new and grounded
for confining the electric field of the HV winding within its resin element must be carefully analysed. Thus, this is what is done in
domain without any transference to the air radial distance, which the sequence, by exploring the most important tests.

Fig. 1 Profile of the amplitude of the rms voltage gradient (electric field) along radial distance
a Real condition, with cast resin
b Hypothetical condition, without cast resin on windings

IET Electr. Power Appl., 2016, Vol. 10, Iss. 5, pp. 411–418
412 & The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2016
Fig. 2 Profile of the amplitude of voltage gradient (electric field) along radial distance
a Basic view of the proposed mesh
b External view of a proposed mesh applied to a HV winding
c Cross-section view of a HV winding with proposed mesh in detail

Fig. 3 Profile of the amplitude of voltage gradient (electric field) along radial distance with proposed mesh applied to the HV winding

2.1 Temperature rise and loss measurement – no-load However, regarding voltage insulation, the presence of the grounded
and on-load conditions mesh will imply in the need of an increase of the resin layer between it
and the HV winding, in comparison to the condition of not existing this
Due to its concentric position in each HV winding of a three-phase mesh. For its turn, because of its relatively low capability in conducting
transformer, the proposed metallic mesh becomes naturally heat, this increase of the layer of resin will make the heat exchange of
submitted to the magnetic field leakage from the windings and it is the HV winding difficult and thus measures for decreasing the heat
thus possible that some current may be induced in it and give generation from the HV winding must be taken. Essentially, an
origin to significant additional eddy losses under both no-load and increase in the cross-section of the HV winding conductor is the very
on-load operating conditions of the transformer. If so, a consequent first and natural measure.
undesirable increase in temperature may be expected and the Thus, this clearly seems as being a very important compromise to
proposed method should be revaluated. However, the providentially take into consideration when analysing the addition of the grounded
proposed geometry for the mesh allows cancellation of all the enclosing mesh to the HV winding. In fact, the less is in the increase
internally induced currents and thus only a perimeter induced in the resin layer, the less is the increase in the cross-section of the
current flows in it, as shown in Fig. 4. Thus, for limiting the HV winding conductor. Therefore, taking a resin with value of
amplitude of this induced current it is recommended that a properly dielectric strength as highest as possible is desirable because of the
low conductive metallic material may be used for composing the less increase in resin layer and consequent lower increase of
mesh. In addition, some care must be taken for this choice not cross-section of the HV winding conductor.
affecting the requested mechanical flexibility of the metallic mesh
for the sake of its workability, which is not a very difficult task.
On the other hand, again because of its meshing design, the 2.2 Applied voltage test
enclosure does not disturb the heat exchange of the windings and
thus a very low or non-significant influence of the mesh on For an ordinary dry-type transformer, when the test of applied voltage
transformer losses is to be expected. In fact, since it is metallic, it at industrial frequency is performed through its LV winding, there are
may contribute for the temperature distribution to become uniform two regions where concerns with stressing electric field are
along the winding height, which can be taken as an advantage. considerably high. Namely and in accordance with Fig. 5a, obtained

IET Electr. Power Appl., 2016, Vol. 10, Iss. 5, pp. 411–418
& The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2016 413
Fig. 4 Process of cancellation of currents induced by the leakage magnetic field in the bulk of the mesh

from computer simulation with FEMM [7] of the same transformer influence of the mesh. However, for the applied voltage test to the
taken for obtaining Fig. 3, two of these regions are along the whole HV winding the use of the mesh will allow reducing significantly
radial distance of the volume between the LV winding and the core the distance between LV and HV windings, since the HV winding
leg (region I) and along the radial distances at the edges (upper and will have its electric field confined to the region of resin between
lower) of the layers of the LV winding (region II). it and the mesh, as obtained by computer simulation and shown in
On the other hand, two other regions present stressing electric Fig. 6.
field if the same test is performed through its HV winding. These Therefore, the key region to where all the concerns converge
regions are presented in Fig. 5b, also obtained from FEMM lies exactly on the HV winding disks. More exactly, between
simulation. One of them is along the whole radial distance the HV disks and the evolving grounded metallic mesh. Thus,
between the LV and the HV windings (region III), whereas the since this region is filled with resin, it is interesting to take the
other is at the edge of the upper and lower disks of the HV advantage of using some with a value of dielectric strength as
winding (region IV). It is thus noticeable that except for the highest as possible for this task, for the distance between the
change of the winding to be under applied voltage at industrial HV winding and the mesh may be as shortest as possible.
frequency, the regions III and IV can be considered as equivalent Therefore, it will not jeopardise the heat exchange of the HV
to the regions I and II, respectively. winding, as pointed out in the previous section. However,
Regarding the stressing electric field, it is important to mention additional precautions like taking disks with cross-section with
that since the electric field is not uniformly distributed, the limit round edges for avoiding highly stressing electric field are
taken for the voltage gradient along any air distance is not 3 kV/mm, mandatory.
anymore, but rather lower. At last, about the curing process of the resin, much more care than
The region I is filled with air that has a lower dielectric strength is regularly required is necessary for avoiding the presence of any
than the resin. On the other hand, since the voltage of the minimum air bubble and consequent air void that might trigger the
energised winding is relatively low, the definition of this radial process of insulating disruption.
distance is not so critical and it is usually based on the experience
of the designer. For its turn, the region II becomes stressed because
of the influence of the yoke of the core, which is grounded and it 2.3 Impulse voltage test
thus gives origin to a significant axial component of the electric
field between the yoke and the edge of the layers of the LV winding. Due to the concerns with high frequencies associated to this kind of
On the other hand, the adoption of the proposed enclosing metallic solicitation, in which the impulsive voltage becomes non-uniformly
grounded mesh will cause some significant changes on the electric distributed along the length of the winding, this issue has been
field distribution during the test of applied voltage at industrial intensively investigated as in [6, 8], for example. In fact, the
frequency that will allow significant changes in clearance distances winding response to any applied impulsive voltage will strongly
of some of the previously analysed regions. depend on the wave shape of the voltage as well as on its
At first, for the applied voltage test through the LV winding, geometry, which implies in the value of its distributed parameters,
electric field in the regions I and II will not suffer any significant namely, inductances, capacitances and resistances.

Fig. 5 Computer simulation of the distribution of electric potential with definition of the regions where the voltage gradient is critical during the applied voltage
test
a Regions I and II, around the LV winding
b Regions III and IV, around the HV winding

IET Electr. Power Appl., 2016, Vol. 10, Iss. 5, pp. 411–418
414 & The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2016
Regarding the relevance of this item and as already mentioned, the Table 1 Resumed data of comparison between measured and
same 1500 kVA, 13.8/0.38 kV, 60 Hz, Dyn1, dry-type transformer simulated results shown in Fig. 7
was taken as a practical, well-known and thus a confident Item Measured Simulated Error
reference. This transformer has 13 turns foil windings in the LV
side, whereas in the HV side there are ten continuous disks, casted peak value of input voltage, V 94.1 94.1 –
in epoxy resin. Thus, one of its ten disks HV winding was time to peak value of the input voltage, 1.7 1.7 –
modelled through the most well-recognised finite-element µs
peak value of voltage to ground for the 70 65.5 −6.43%
techniques for obtaining its distributed parameters [8–10], whereas fifth disk, V
its LV winding was taken as grounded element, as it is usually resonant frequency of the response, kHz 58.8 49.5 −15.82%
done. On the other hand, one of its HV winding was submitted
to a practical application of a standard 1.2/50 μs low-amplitude
(94.1 V) lightning impulse voltage and measured results were
compared with its computer modelling simulation of this same allowing the simulation to be performed in a commonly available
condition, performed with PSPICE simulator [11], as in [6]. Due personal computer as well as the use freely available circuit
to the impossibility of access to most of the disks of the HV simulators.
winding but only to that connected to its regulating winding, disk Aside the indicated minor differences, the computer model of the
number 5, practical measurement results are only from it. HV winding that has been taken is validated and it is henceforth
Fig. 7 shows the comparison between both results, whereas supposed to represent confidently the HV winding of the actual
Table 1 indicates the resumed data of the comparison of its graphics. transformer.
Data of Table 1 allow considering that computer modelling results Thus, additional extrapolating results of computer simulation for
of the real transformer are satisfactory because of their relatively low the application of a 1.2/50 μs impulsive voltage are presented in
difference to practical results, namely, the peak value of the applied Figs. 8a and b that show the behaviour of voltage to ground for all
impulse voltage and its time, the peak value for the voltage to ground the disks and between every two adjacent disks, respectively.
for the fifth disk and the resonant frequency of the response. In While Fig. 8a shows some well-recognised and quite predictable
accordance with [8], all the differences related to time between the results for the behaviour of the voltage to ground of each disk,
two responses are due to modelling principles. Ideally, each turn Fig. 8b shows a very important result that is the existence of a
of the HV winding should be modelled by one circuit with RLC maximum value of voltage between two adjacent disks. It is
lumped parameters. However, the computational effort would between the tenth (to which the impulse voltage is applied
increase significantly and a more capable computer would be whereas the end of first disk is grounded) and the ninth disks. The
necessary for simulation. On the other hand, the authors have amplitude is about 20 V, or about 20% of the input voltage, which
preferred a simple approach with one circuit with RLC lumped suggests that some additional concerns with insulation between
parameters for modelling each disks of the HV winding in view of these two disk must be taken into account.

Fig. 6 Computer simulation of the distribution of the electric potential around the LV and the HV windings with the presence of the grounded metallic mesh

Fig. 7 Graphics of voltage to ground of disk 5. Computer simulated, experimental and input voltages

IET Electr. Power Appl., 2016, Vol. 10, Iss. 5, pp. 411–418
& The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2016 415
Fig. 8 Computer simulation of the input impulsive voltage and the responses of all the ten disks of the HV winding of the real transformer
a Voltage of each disk to the ground
b Voltage to between two adjacent disks

3 Behaviour of HV winding under impulse voltage considered for the simulation of the application of the same
with grounded metallic mesh standard lightning impulse to the HV winding and this condition
was simulated with the validated computing model. Thus, Fig. 9
On the basis of the same transformer taken as reference for the shows the graphics of the input voltage and the voltage to ground
previous analysis, the addition of the grounded mesh was then for the fifth disk of the HV winding.

Fig. 9 Computer simulation results for the input impulsive voltage and the response of the fifth disk – the presence of the grounded metallic mesh is taken into
account

IET Electr. Power Appl., 2016, Vol. 10, Iss. 5, pp. 411–418
416 & The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2016
Fig. 10 Computer simulation of the input impulsive voltage and the responses of all the ten disks – the presence of the grounded metallic mesh is taken into
account
a Voltage of each disk to the ground
b Voltage to between two adjacent disks

In this case, simulation shows that peak value of voltage to ground overcome the adoption of a rated voltage higher than the limit
for the fifth disk is significantly higher than in that case in which the of 36 kV.
metallic mesh is not present, as shown in Fig. 9. Thus, that same
96.1 V input voltage of before gives origin to a 89.8 V of peak
value to ground as response of the fifth disk, whereas it had been 4 Conclusions
about 65.5 V for the condition without metallic mesh. For its turn,
this increase of stressing voltage may not be taken as significantly In accordance with the analyses of results obtained from computer
worrying for harming the winding insulation because the distance and experimental simulations as well as on discussions about the
between HV and the grounded metallic mesh is filled with resin behaviour of losses, the proposal of the use of a grounded metallic
that is adequate to withstand such an increase of voltage stress, mesh presents itself as a feasible alternative for the desired
proportionally, without any significant need in increasing the resin increase in the maximum rated voltage of the dry-type transformer.
layer between them. While the presence of the grounded metallic mesh does implicate
In addition, Fig. 10a shows the computer simulation of the voltage in the increase in the voltage stress for most of the standard
to the ground for all the ten disks. Thus, it basically shows that dielectric tests, the intrinsically requested increase in the thickness
maximum peak of voltage to ground has the same level of about of layer of resin between the HV winding disks and the grounded
90 V for all the disks. On the other hand, Fig. 10b shows the mesh properly allows the dielectric withstand. This is so because
computer simulation of the voltage between every two adjacent the proposed mesh transfers the highest valued electric field from
disks. Thus, in a similar way that it has obtained for the HV disks the air to the resin radial distance of the HV winding, thanks to a
without the grounded mesh, shown in Fig. 8b, a maximum voltage providential increase in the thickness of the layer of resin between
of about 60 V takes place between the initial disks, 10 and 9. In the HV winding and the mesh. On the other hand, unavoidable
this case, the peak voltage is about three times the value for the and undesirable consequences of that increase in the thickness of
same position when the grounded mesh was not present. the layer of resin can be easily mitigated by two propositions,
However, in the same way as done before, this result does not given by the authors, namely, the increase in the cross-section of
mean any additional worry for the transformer designer if the the conductor of the HV winding and the use of a very
thickness of layer of cast resin between the HV disks and the high-quality resin. Thus, based on what is available and feasible,
grounded mesh has dielectric withstand enough for not collapsing the transformer designer can decide the amount of each of the two
during such a solicitation. propositions to be taken.
Therefore, none of the main aspects of the dielectric concerns of a At last, it is important to mention that besides allowing the
transformer design seems to represent a very significant barrier to increase in the rated voltage beyond 36 kV, the presented

IET Electr. Power Appl., 2016, Vol. 10, Iss. 5, pp. 411–418
& The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2016 417
propositions can be also applied for reducing the size of any dry-type 6 Oliveira, L.F.: ‘Blindagem para Confinamento de Campo Elétrico em Enrolamento
transformer with rated voltage <36 kV. de Alta Tensão de Transformador a Seco’ (In Portuguese). Bachelor dissertation,
Universidade de Blumenau, 2012. Available at www.bc.furb.br/docs/MO/2012/
357516_1_1.pdf
7 Meeker, D.C.: ‘Finite element method magnetics’, Version 4.2 (x64) (15
5 References November 2013 Build). Available at http://www.femm.infoFEMM 4.2
Magnetics, Electrostatics, Heat Flow, and Current Flow
1 Dooley, P.K.: ‘A comparison of liquid-filled and dry-type transformers for 8 de Lima, P.A.P.: ‘Análise da Distribuição de Transitórios de Tensão em
industrial applications’, IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., 1998, 34, (1), pp. 222–226 Enrolamentos de Transformadores Imersos em Óleo’ (In Portuguese). Master
2 Eslamian, M., Vahidi, B., Eslamian, A.: ‘Thermal analysis of cast-resin dry-type dissertation, Univeridade de Blumenau, 2011. Available at https://drive.google.
transformers’, J.Energy Convers. Manage., 2011, 52, (7), pp. 2479–2488 com/open?id=0B0OIGFb3BvMTYVlpNkhCMlRsU3c
3 Carlen, M., Berrogain, M., Ortiz, S., et al.: ‘HiDry72: safe and eco-efficient 9 de Lima, P.A.P., Cabral, S.H.L.: ‘Practical application of the rabin’s method for
solution for sub-transmission lines’. 2014 IEEE Central America and Panama inductance calculation in power transformer design’. Brazilian Congress on
Convention (CONCAPAN XXXIV), 12–14 November 2014, pp. 1–6 Electromagnetism – MOMAG, August 2012. Available at https://drive.google.
4 Yuen, D.C.M., Choi, V., Gao, L.Z., et al.: ‘The first 110 kV /35 kV – 31.5 MVA com/open?id=0B0OIGFb3BvMTamJrVFA0VjRWU1k
cast resin transformer’. Conf. Record of the 2004 IEEE Industry Applications 10 de Lima, P.A.P., Cabral, S.H.L.: ‘A comparative analysis of performance of
Conf., 2004, 39th IAS Annual Meeting, 3–7 October 2004, vol. 2, pp. 763–767 well-known methods for conforming distribution of impulsive voltage along
5 ‘Electrical engineering portal: right choice of dry type or liquid-filled transformer’. regulating winding’. 2013 IEEE Electrical Insulation Conf. (EIC), 2–5 June
Available at http://electrical-engineering-portal.com/right-choice-of-dry-type-or- 2013, pp. 168–172
liquid-filled-transformer, accessed 17 June 2015 11 PSpice Reference Guide

IET Electr. Power Appl., 2016, Vol. 10, Iss. 5, pp. 411–418
418 & The Institution of Engineering and Technology 2016

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen