Congress of the United States
Washington, DE 20510
April 4, 2018
The Honorable Scott Pruitt
Administrator
U.S Environmental Protection Agency
1200 Pennsylvania Avenue, N. W.
Mail Code: 101A
Washington, DC 20460
Dear Mr, Administrator:
As you are aware, all EPA employees, including the Administrator, must abide by the Standards
of Ethical Conduet for Employees of the Executive Branch (5 C.F.R. 2635), as well as other
Federal conflict of interest statutes. The American public must be able to trust that you are carrying
out your duties in a manner that avoids any financial conflicts of interest, inappropriate favoritism
or partisan political influence.
Given these obligations, we are very concemed by recent reports that you and at least one other
member of your family were afforded a room in a prime Capitol Hill location for what appears to
be unusually favorable terms by a landlord with personal connections to you and to an industry
regulated by the agency that you lead. We are also troubled by the circumstances surrounding the
agency's ethics review process, which led EPA to issue a retroactive approval of the rental
agreement more than a year afler the fact—and only after media reports disclosed the highly
‘unusual nature of the arrangement.
We believe it is imperative that you answer questions fully and transparently regarding the
circumstances of your rental agreement and its approval. Therefore, we request that you provide
a response to the attached list of questions and requests for documentation by no later than April
17, 2018.
Sincerely,
Jorn (dare
Tom Udall Donald S. Beyer Jr. T
United States Senator Member of Congress
; —
fu Fhe TRB) Las
Brian Schatz Ted W. Lieu
United States Senator Member of Congress,Request for Information:
1.
10.
i
How did you learn about the availability of the property you rented at 223 C Street,
Northeast (“rental property”)? Does this property advertise rooms for rent to the general
public?
What were the specific dates of the rental agreement, and whet is the total amount you
paid the landlord for the use of the rental property during that time?
Were any employees of the Office of the Administrator or other EPA employees involved
in locating the property, or otherwise negotiating, facilitating, or executing any portion of
your rental agreement? Did any EPA employees communicate with the landlord or other
‘owners or representatives of owners of the property on your behalf?
What is your relationship with the landlord or other owners of the rental property? Please
describe any interactions you had with Ms. Vicki Hart, Mr. Steven Hert, or any other
‘owner or representative of an owner of the property prior to the date on which you
entered into the rental agreement.
‘Was the room rented to you available for your exclusive use for the duration of your lease
agreement, despite reports that you only paid for nights when you actually used the
property? Was the room rented to other people when you were not using the rental
property?
thas been reported that your daughter also lived at the rental property for some duration.
of your rental agreement. How did you secure the arrangement for your daughter to stay
at the rental property? Did the arrangement to use the rental property extend to any other
family members? Ifso, which members of your family? Did you have other family or
guests stay at the rental property who were not a part of your rental agreement?
Did you set a schedule ahead of time for your usage of the rental property? Did you pay
any utilities, cleaning, or other fees? Did you receive mail or other packages delivered to
the property?
Did you attend any fundraisers or other political functions that occurred at the rental
property during your stay? Ifso, on how many occasions and by whose invitation?
Did you discuss any EPA official business with the landlord, their affiliates, or other
visitors at the rental property? If so, what topics were discussed, and with whom?
Did you agree to undertake any official actions that benefited the landiord, their affiliates,
or other visitors you met at the rental property? If so, what actions were taken, and on
whose behalf?
Did you ever discuss your trip 1o Morocco to promote liquefied natural gas with the
landlord, their affiliates, or visitors you met at the rental property? If so, what topics
were discussed, and with whom?12. Who requested review of the rental agreement by EPA’s designated agency ethics officer
or related ethics staff, and on what date was that request made? Please describe any
review—formal or informal—of the rental agreement that occurred by EPA staff between
January 20, 2017, and the release of the agency’s March 30, 2018, memorandum titled
“Review of Lease Agreement Under the Federal Ethics Regulations Regarding Gifts”.
13, The agency's March 30, 2018, memorandum appears to address only the narrow question,
of whether the rental agreement in question constitutes a gift under Federal ethics
regulations. Did agency ethics officials determine whether the agreement was fully in
compliance with the entire Standards of Ethical Conduct for Employees of the Executive
Branch and other applicable Federal ethics statates or standards of conduct?
14, How did the agency determine that the fair market value described by the rental
agreement was “reasonable” as cited by the March 30, 2018 memorandum? Please
provide the analysis used to reach that conclusion, including comparable rental agreement
costs used in making that determination.
15, Were any employees of the Office of the Administrator or other EPA employees involved
in making subsequent housing arrangements for any other property other than the rental
property in question for you or your family?
Request for Documentation:
* Please provide copies of any of the following documents that may have been developed
since December 7, 2016, when President Trump announced his intention to nominate you
as EPA Administrator:
L.A copy of the rental agreement for the rental property;
2. Any communications between yourself and Ms, Vicki Hart, any other owner of
the residence, or anyone representing the owners;
3. Any communications between yourself and Mr, Steven Hart, any person
employed by Williams & Jensen, and any calendar entries or notes relating to any
meetings or conversations between yourself and Mr. Hart or any other person
employed by Williams & Jensen;
4. Any communications between anyone working in the Administrator's office and
Mr. Hart, any other person employed by Williams & Jensen, and any calendar
entries or notes relating to any meetings or conversations between anyone
working in the Administrator's office and Mr. Hart or any other person employed
by Williams & Jensen; and
5. Any communications between yourself or anyone working in the Administrator's,
office and any other official or employee of EPA regarding Mr. Hart, any other
person employed by Williams & Jensen, or any client of Williams & Jensen,