Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Invited Paper
I. INTRODUCTION
IBER optics has undoubtedly had a profound impact on
signals [6]—the basis of another important class of fiber-optic mented—a source simultaneously of frustration, challenge, and
sensors. satisfaction to those within it. Fiber-optic sensing is therefore
So this brief paper will present a predominantly historical conceptually orthogonal to fiber-optic communications which
per- involves very large numbers of essentially the same system
spective on the evolution of research, development, and applica- configuration and components. There is very little spin-off
tion in fiber-optic sensor technology. From the early beginnings in practice from the communications industry into sensor
almost 35 years ago, the optical fiber sensor (OFS) community technologies. The fiber itself, some guided-wave components,
became infected with communications euphoria, and by the mid some, but by no means all, connectors and some, but by
1970s to the early 1980s felt OFS technology was the solution to no means all, sources and detectors are the common
everything. Realism percolated, though perhaps a little slowly, elements. Conceiving and realizing the necessary mechanical
and now we know that there are areas of real application, but that and elec- tronic infrastructure around the guided-wave
there are still interesting and relevant problems left to ex- cite components is the major portion of optical fiber sensor
the research community. technology. In particular, packaging is an immense challenge—
indeed the case with all sensing techniques.
II. SENSOR TECHNOLOGY Sensing techniques have another important generic feature.
Virtually all physical and chemical phenomena which are used
Sensing and measurement is a specialized art. Sensor tech- in the transduction process are temperature sensitive. Most mea-
nologies are applications specific. The thermometer switch surements are not concerned with temperature. Consequently,
which controls your central heating is totally unsuited to control most sensing and measurement systems must first of all correct
a cooling system in your automobile. Sensors all operate in for temperature variations. This is a perennial issue which has
niche markets. The sensing mechanisms are based on literally most certainly marked the process of fiber-optic sensor tech-
dozens of physical and chemical phenomena interfaced to nology, producing solutions and approaches with varying de-
electronic signal conditioning through dozens more custom grees of elegance and ingenuity.
designed protocols. The industry is consequently highly frag-
1077–260X/00$10.00 © 2000 IEEE
CULSHAW:
1016 FIBER OPTICS IN SENSING AND MEASUREMENT
IEEE JOURNAL OF SELECTED TOPICS IN QUANTUM ELECTRONICS, VOL. 6, NO. 6, NOVEMBER/DECEMBER 2000
1016
Fig. 3. Dual-beam all-fiber interferometers used in sensing—normally the interferometer is biased, dynamically or stastically, to the quadrature
optimum sensitivity point X.
blade clearances in gas turbine engines, for measuring angular Michelson configurations were designed for as near as possible
rotation instead of longitudinal displacement, and to monitor zero-path-length difference between the arms to avoid phase
the displacement of pressure diaphragms in pressure sensors for noise to amplitude noise conversion. Some heterodyne inter-
automotive and medical applications. ferometer detection systems were assessed, and while these
The Fotonic sensor exemplifies much of optical fiber sensor were in some ways simpler, they have now been almost totally
technology. It was conceived and demonstrated 35 years ago. It abandoned. The simplicity arises from the fact that quadrature
has been frequently reinvented. It has occasionally been used in operation need no longer be maintained (Fig. 3).
earnest in applications which were not dreamed of when the idea The optical fiber interferometer was hailed as among the most
was originally put forward. It uses simple intensity modulation sensitive and versatile of sensor technologies. Its sensitivity can
and it has within it the capability if needed for referencing to be increased simply by adding more fiber until the losses within
remove the impact of fluctuations in reflectivity, fiber loss, and the fiber begin to exceed the additional signal. It is straightfor-
source output. ward to show that this occurs when the total optical fiber length
And finally, temperature sensitivity is inherent within the me- is the inverse of the attenuation in nepers per unit length. Typi-
chanics of the reflector mounting and movement rather than the cally, many kilometers of the fiber can, if needed, be used.
optical system itself. Additionally, the optical fiber can be wound in numerous
shapes and sizes which in turn can determine the overall
V. USING PHASE: HYDROPHONES AND GYROSCOPES re- sponse of the sensor to a physical parameter field.
Furthermore, the transmission path is immune to
Interferometry is one of the favored tools of optics and most electromagnetic interfer- ence, is very light in weight, and is
of the many versions of interferometry have been incorporated chemically and physically compatible with a wide variety of host
into optical fiber sensor technology. The Fotonic sensor, based materials. The interfer- ometer remains the most utilized fiber-
as it was on a very simple concept, never really entered the op- optic sensor technology with a particular presence in
tical literature. It was more than a decade later that optical fiber gyroscopes, hydrophones, and strain-sensing applications.
sensors became a subject of optics when the dependence of the
phase delay through single-mode fiber on temperature, pressure,
VI. DISTRIBUTED SENSING
and strain became apparent [8], [9]—though the existence of this
phase dependence had already been noted by Snitzer [6] in a The interferometer measures the change in the end-to-end
different context. path length along the fiber configured to interact with the phys-
Around the same time [10], [11], the new dimension which ical parameter field. However, there are a multiplicity of ways
optical fibers could give to the Sagnac effect became apparent in which light may interact with the external world around it, and
and the fiber-optic gyroscope was conceived and demonstrated. some of these can be configured to enable a probe to be devel-
Demonstrating the concept is the simple but exciting phase. oped which reveals a parameter field as a function of position
A multiplicity of sensor architectures—most notably fiber-optic along the fiber length. Distributed sensing (Fig. 4) is a technique
Mach–Zehnder, fiber-optic Michelson, and fiber-optic Sagnac which is unique (or almost so) to fiber-optic technologies. While
interferometers were evaluated, calibrated, and tested. The there are a very few electrical cables which can be configured to
very basic sensitivities were assessed. The phase delay in an be read through a time-domain reflectometer, none has the
optical fiber changes by approximately 1 ppm per longitudinal ruggedness, flexibility, and accuracy of the fiber-optic model.
microstrain, 1 ppm per hydrostatic bar of environmental Distributed sensing relies upon backscatter and on modu-
pressure change, and 10 ppm per C change in temperature. lating the backscattered radiation produced by a forward-trav-
The influence of laser source noise on interferometer per- elling optical beam to reveal typically a temperature or strain
formance rapidly became apparent, and Mach–Zehnder or field. Three major backscattering processes have been used.
CULSHAW:
1018 FIBER OPTICS IN SENSING AND MEASUREMENT
IEEE JOURNAL OF SELECTED TOPICS IN QUANTUM ELECTRONICS, VOL. 6, NO. 6, NOVEMBER/DECEMBER 2000
1018
(a)
(b)
Fig. 4. Generic distributed sensing concept using elastically (linear) or
inelastically (nonlinear) backscattered light as the information carrier.
(b)
(c)
Fig. 6. Three intensity insensitive modulation schemes for optical fiber
sensors. (a) Spectral slicing. (b) Interferometric filtering. (c) Amplitude
modulation at a measurand-dependant resonant frequency.
(a)
(b)
Fig. 7. Bragg grating geometry and functions. The reflected spectrum closely
approximates to the Fourier transform of the grating. (a) Short broadband
reflector/mode coupler. (b) Long narrowband wavelength selective coupler
functions performed by fiber Bragg gratings.
Fig. 8. All fiber current monitor and crystalline current (magnetic field) or voltage (electric field) fiber sensor architecture.
an important role to play in optical fiber chemical measure- Tunnel as a fire-alarm system, in large process ovens for mon-
ment, though this emerged as a potentially viable technique a itoring temperature profiles, and in numerous other very spe-
decade or so later than the optrode was first mooted [27]. Gas cialized applications where temperature field measurements are
spectroscopy remains the most interesting potential application important. Brillouin scatter too has been used to measure tem-
though the strongest absorption lines for most species of interest perature, watching the concrete set in a major dam project in
lie outside the transmission window of optical fiber waveguides. Switzerland. It has also been used in earnest to measure strain
There are, however, frequently overtones in the near infrared, paradoxically in telecommunication cables especially in regions
and these have been used with some success in the detection of where landslip could cause local stresses which could compro-
methane, acetylene, hydrogen sulphide, and several other mise cable integrity. The Brillouin system also shows promise
species [28]. Once more, while there are niche applications, the in the oil industry to monitor the integrity of safety-critical and
peculiar properties of optical systems must be recognized. In this very expensive anchors and tethers.
context, the very specific wavelengths required to address the To attempt an exhaustive list of applications is impractical as
absorption bands are invariably outside the communications well as uninformative. The general observation that the princi-
spectrum, so optical sources with the appropriate power level ples first elucidated a quarter of a century ago are now emerging
and spectral purity remain relatively special items and are there- in practice can be applied for many of the techniques which have
fore expensive. However, a sufficiently large array of sensors been briefly mentioned herein. Additionally, every application
can make a system cost competitive, and its selectivity com- is manifestly unique and requires quite specific engineering to
pared to electrical pellistor technology (which simply detects translate the concept into reality. Fiber sensing has emerged as a
flammable gases) can be beneficial. The low attenuation of op- true parallel to everything else in the sensing and measurement
tical fibers also facilitates measurements over a very wide area industry with relatively small and specialized market opportu-
inaccessible to more established approaches. nities each with its own specific challenges.
XII. USING OPTICAL FIBERS SENSORS: THE APPLICATIONS XIII. WHAT OF THE FUTURE
Sensing and measurement are idiosyncratic niche-oriented Guided-wave optics, particularly fiber systems, continue to
activities, and the thought that optical fiber sensing can solve all offer unique possibilities in a measurement context. Where this
measurement problems has long since disappeared. will lead depends particularly on the initiatives of the research
Numerous niches have emerged.2 These range from moni- community. There remains considerable activity in chemical
toring pressure transients in diesel engines, to using white-light sensing with distributed measurement as one of many major
interferometry to measure strain in long-gauge-length (to 50 m) interests. Tapered fibers have emerged as means to monitor
sensors for civil engineering, to intravenous pressure sensing, to intracellular chemistry with significantly submicron resolution.
landfill monitoring for combustible gases. The same resolution too could be applied to measuring material
The Bragg grating strain gauge is arguably the most fre- properties in microengineered structures, though these have yet
quently quoted example in the literature, finding applications to to be demonstrated. There are also prospects for the very large
measure strain and/or temperature in bridges, in com- posite and gravitational telescopes, based on an enormous Sagnac
materials for marine and aerospace engineering and in down- interferometer, have been proposed though their realization is
hole pressure and temperature monitoring. Numerous probably unlikely.
experimental systems based on Bragg grating technology have So most of the work in fiber-optic sensors is now focused on
been demonstrated, and while these do illustrate the principles, developmental opportunities emerging from the very productive
the grating does remain very expensive equivalent to a strain era from the mid 1970s to the mid 1980s. But the more specu-
gauge and true commercial activity remains sparse. lative research will continue, and at least some will lead into
In contrast, the fiber-optic gyroscope is now a modestly demanding, exotic, innovative measurements.
high-volume production subsystem. The gyroscope first
appeared in commercial aircraft when the Boeing 777 was REFERENCES
introduced, where it was used as an aid to vehicle stabilization. [1] J. Hecht, City of Light. Oxford, U.K.: Oxford Univ. Press, 1999.
It has also been used in automobiles as a navigation aid, [2] C. K. Kao and G. Hockham, “Dielectric fiber surface waveguides for
in missiles and munitions for guidance systems, and even in pro- optical frequencies,” Proc. IEE, vol. 113, pp. 1151–1158, July 1966.
[3] J. C. Simon and E. Spitz, “Propagation guidée de lumière coherente,”
totype remotely powered lawnmowers for ultrastraight stripes on Commun. à la Societé Française de Physique, vol. 24, no. 2, pp.
football pitches. The hydrophone too has begun to make its mark 149–169, 1963.
where Mach–Zehnder interferometer configuration can be [4] R. B. Dyott and J. R. Stern, “Group delay in glass fiber waveguides,” in
made more sensitive with better directional control and in more IEE Conf. Trunk Telecommunications by Guided Waves, London, U.K.,
Sept.-Oct. 1970, pp. 176–181.
flexible packaging configurations than the piezoceramic [5] C. Menadier, C. Kissinger, and H. Adkins, “The fotonic sensor,” Instru-
equivalent. ments and Control Systems, vol. 40, p. 114, 1967.
Distributed sensing also has identified some of its niches. Dis- [6] E. Snitzer, “Apparatus for controlling the propagation characteristics of
coherent light within an optical fiber,” U.S. Patent 3 625 589, Dec. 7,
tributed Raman backscatter has found a place in the Channel 1971.
[7] B. Culshaw, Optical Fiber Sensing and Signal Processing. Stevenage,
2The European fiber optic sensor network FOS-EN list many producers of U.K.: Peregrinus, 1984.
[8] B. Culshaw, D. E. N. Davies, and S. A. Kingsley, “Acoustic sensitivity
optical fiber sensors on its web site. [Online.] Available: http://www.fbre.fos-
of optical fiber waveguides,” Electron. Lett., vol. 13, pp. 760–761, 1977.
en.net.
CULSHAW:
1024 FIBER OPTICS IN SENSING AND MEASUREMENT
IEEE JOURNAL OF SELECTED TOPICS IN QUANTUM ELECTRONICS, VOL. 6, NO. 6, NOVEMBER/DECEMBER 2000
1024
[9] J. A. Bucaro, H. D. Dardy, and E. F. Carome, “Fiber optic hydrophone,” [27] A. Mohebati and T. A. King, “Remote detection of gases by diode laser
J. Acoust. Soc. Amer., vol. 52, p. 1302, 1977. spectroscopy,” J. Modern Opt., vol. 38, pp. 319–324, 1988.
[10] G. Sagnac, “L’éther lumineux démontre par l’effet du vent relatif [28] L. S. Rothman et al., “The HITRAN molecule database editions of 1991
d’éther dans un interférometer en rotation uniform,” C. Royal Acad. and 1992,” J. Quantum Spectroscopic Radiation Transfer, vol. 48, pp.
Sci., vol. 95, 469–507, 1991.
pp. 708–710, 1913. [29] B. Culshaw and J. P. Dakin, Eds., Optical Fiber Sensors. Norwood,
[11] V. Vali and R. W. Shorthill, “Fiber ring interferometer,” Appl. Opt., MA: Artech, 1988, 1989, 1996, 1997, vol. 1–4.
vol. [30] E. Udd, Fiber Optic Sensors. New York: Wiley, 1990.
15, pp. 1099–1100, 1976. [31] R. Willsch and R. T. Kersten, Eds., Fiber Optic Sensors. ser. SPIE
[12] A. J. Rogers, “POTDR: A technique for the measurement of field Mile- stone. Bellingham, WA: SPIE, 1995, vol. MS108.
distri- butions,” Appl. Opt., vol. 20, pp. 1060–1074, 1981.
[13] M. C. Farries and A. J. Rogers, “Distributed sending using stimulated
Raman interaction in a monomode optical fiber,” in Proc. 1st Optical
Fiber Sensors Conf., London, U.K., 1983, pp. 121–133.
[14] D. Culverhouse, F. Farahi, C. N. Pannell, and D. A. Jackson,
“Exploita- tion of stimulated Brillouin scattering as a sensing Brian Culshaw (M’83) was born in Ormskirk, Lan-
mechanism for dis- cashire, U.K., on September 24, 1945. He graduated
tributed temperature sensors,” in Optical Fiber Sensors, Arditty, Dakin,
with the B.Sc. degree in physics in 1966 and the Ph.D.
and Kersten, Eds. New York: Springer Verlag, 1989, pp. 552–559.
degree in electrical engineering in 1970, both from
[15] A. D. Kersey and A. Dandridge, “Distributed and multiplexed optical
fiber sensors,” in Proc. 5th Optical Fiber Sensors Conf., 1988, University College London, London, U.K.
pp. He joined Strathclyde University,
Glasgow, Scotland, as Professor of Electronics in
60–72. September
[16] B. Culshaw, G. Stewart, C. Tandy, and D. Moodie, “Fiber optic tech- 1983. He was formerly Vice Dean of the Engi-
niques for methane gas detection-from detection concept to system re- neering Faculty at Strathclyde and is currently
alization,” Sensors and Actuators B Chemical, vol. 51, pp. 25–37, 1998. Head of the Department of Electronic and Electrical
[17] J. P. Dakin, “Analogue and digital extrinsic optical fiber sensors based Engineering. He had previous appointments as a
on spectral filtering techniques,” in Proc. Fiber Optics London, Postdoctoral Fellow at Cornell University, Ithaca, NY, Technical Staff Member
1984, at Bell Northern Research, Ottawa, Canada, Lecturer and later Reader,
pp. 219–226. University College London, and Senior Research Associate, Applied Physics
[18] S. Venkatesh and B. Culshaw, “Optical activated vibration in a micro- Laboratory, Stanford University, Stanford, CA. He worked on microwave
machined silica structure,” Electron. Lett., vol. 21, pp. 315–317, 1985.
and semiconductor devices and their design and technology until 1975, when his
[19] E. W. Sasski, J. C. Hartl, and G. L. Mitchell, “A family of optical fiber
sensors using cavity resonator microshifts,” in Proc. 4th Optical Fiber interests evolved into guided-wave optics with particular applications in
Sensors Conf., Tokyo, Japan, 1986. sensing, signal processing, and instrumentation. His interests include optical
[20] S. A. Al-Chalabi, B. Culshaw, and D. E. N. Davies, “Partially coherent fiber gyroscopes, hydrophones, accelerometers, temperature probes, strain and
sources in interferometric sensors,” in Proc. 1st Optical Fiber Sensors pressure measurement, sensors, and a host of other measurement systems, also
Conf., 1983, pp. 132–135. venturing into signal processing architectures, micromachining techniques,
[21] K. O. Hill et al., “Photosensitivity in optical fiber waveguides: Appli- and high-speed network design. It was from this background that his interest in
cation to reflection filter fabrication,” Appl. Phys. Lett., vol. 32, smart structures evolved through the appreciation that guided-wave optics could
pp. make a significant contribution to structural instrumentation. Subsequently, he
647–649, 1978. has become involved in a number of projects on smart structures, especially in
[22] G. Meltz, W. W. Morey, and W. H. Glenn, “Formation of Bragg composite materials and civil engineering. He has written extensively on
gratings in optical fibers by a transverse holographic method,” Opt. microwave semiconductors, fiber optics, and smart structures and materials,
Lett., vol. 14, having authored or co-authored over 300 papers and seven textbooks. He has
pp. 823–825, 1989.
[23] A. J. Rogers, “Optical measurement of current and voltage on power chaired major international conferences in these areas and also acts as a topical
systems,” IEEE J. Electric. Power Appl., vol. 2, p. 120, 1979. editor for Applied Optics (Optical Society of America). He is a director
[24] T. Bosselman, “Current sensors for power industry: Considerations,” in of SPIE and a founding director of OptoSci Ltd., a campus spin-out
Proc. 12th Optical Fiber Sensors Conf., Williamsburg, VA, 1997. company specializing in optoelectronic instrumentation.
[25] J. I. Peterson, S. R. Goldstein, and R. V. Fitzgerald, “Fiber optic pH
probe for physiological use,” Anal. Chem., vol. 52, p. 864, 1980.
[26] A. M. Scheggi, “Optical fiber sensors in medicine,” in Proc. 2nd
Optical
Fiber Sensors Conf., 1984, pp. 91–102.