Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Against Anemia
March 26, 2018
Anemia: An Introduction
● Anemia is a condition that develops when an individual has severely low blood
count resulting in low haemoglobin levels. This means that their organs are not
receiving enough oxygen to properly function.
● Anemia is prevalent in South Asian countries such as Nepal, India, Pakistan and
Bangladesh, however it is most proliferated in India with approximately 87% of
the female population suffering from the condition. [1] The fact that 79.5% of
India’s population is Hindu might be a primary contributing factor to the
widespread prevalence of the condition, since Hindus believe the cow is sacred
and mainly subsist on vegetables, fruits and poultry; these are foods that lack the
adequate amounts of recommended iron intake.
● This instigated the search for a viable, non-intrusive, safe for general [2]"Anaemia prevention dr rabi", Slideshare.net, 2018. [Online]. Available:
https://www.slideshare.net/drrabi/anaemia-prevention-dr-rabi. [Accessed: 25- Mar-
consumption and dependable technology. Dr. Levente Diosady of the University 2018].
The table above details the threshold needed to determine whether or not an individual of each of the significant categories is anemic. For each
of the categories above, if the individual has a daily intake that falls below the threshold then they are considered to be iron deficient and in
need of intervention.
Global Anemia Prevalence Maps
Figure 1: a WHO world map showing the prevalence of Figure 2: a WHO world map showing the prevalence of
anemia in women aged 15-49, with Southeast Asia anemia in pregnant women, with Southeast Asia showing
showing the highest percentage afflicted. the highest percentage afflicted.
[4]Apps.who.int, 2018. [Online]. Available: http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/177094/1/9789241564960_eng.pdf.
[Accessed: 25- Mar- 2018].
Selection of Country
● After narrowing it down to South Asia, we considered various countries where, there is a need for iron
fortification, tea is consumed heavily, and the infrastructure can support it
● Based on these factors, India was found to be the optimal location to implement iron fortified tea.
● Tea consumption is high in India, anemia is a widespread issue, and the economy, specifically the tea industry
is growing at a fast pace. [5][6]
● Historically tea consumption has been very high and even with coffee a growing trend, it remains an important
part of their diet. [5]
● Nevertheless, there are regional discrepancies between states, for example Kerala has a per capita
consumption that is almost double the average, but even when considering the lower consumption states, they
are relatively high in comparison with other countries. [5][6]
[9] Revathy, "Tea Board chief sees a big market in rural India", @businessline, 2013. [Online]. Available: https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/economy/agri-business/Tea-Board-chief-sees-a-big-market-in-rural-India/article20654827.ece. [Accessed: 05- Mar- 2018].
Theory of Change
Political
Economical
Social
Technological
Legal
Environmental
The PESTLE method minimizes this risk by analyzing each component of the market environment (India), which in
turn creates a business case that can integrate with the existing physical and cultural infrastructure of India.
PESTLE: Technology
● Frequent tea consumption might be inhibiting the individual’s body from absorbing sufficient iron from their already
iron-deficient diet. Tea contains a chemical called Tannin which phenolically reacts with non heme iron (plant derived iron) in
food and hinders the body’s ability to absorb it efficiently. [10]
● Doctors recommend waiting an hour or two after eating to drink tea so that it does not interfere with adequate nutrient
absorption, however when you look at tea consumption rates in India, the average rate of consumption is 2 cups per day for
adults. Coupled with the fact that about 80 of the population is Hindu meaning that they do not consume red meat, which is a
primary source of heme iron, the vast majority of the population is anemic.
● This poses an even greater danger to expecting mothers, females that have reached the age of puberty and are at heightened risk
due to menstrual cycles and infants that are born to anemic mothers and thus also inherit the trait.
● Dr. Diosady directed the majority of the Grand Challenges Canada grant towards funding research on proper encapsulation of
the iron fortification so that it can be added to the tea without reacting with tannin, and so that it may withstand the heat of the
liquid surrounding it. He likened the coating of the capsule to that of the coating used on Aspirin so that it does not harm the
stomach wall lining prior to digestion, however he stated that this delivery system technology is utilized on the microscopic level
so that each iron particulate is coated.
● What this essentially means is that the iron will only be carried by the tea as a means of reaching the patient, and the iron will
begin to be broken down once it is nestled in the patient’s stomach and comes in contact with the stomach acid.
[10] ”Does Tea Cause Iron Deficiency? - Drinks and Water - Health-Communities.com”, Healthcommunities.com, 2018. [Online]. Avail-able: http://www.healthcommunities.com/healthy-drinks/does-tea-cause-iron-deficiencyucbwl.shtml. [Accessed:
08- Mar- 2018].
PESTLE: Technology
● Tea manufacturing is a lengthy process that determines the outcome of the taste, colour and strength of the tea. There are various
opportunities during this process to implement the iron fortification, however it is most likely best done just before the tea is
packaged into tea bags in order to contain the iron particulates.
● The tea bag is a partially permeable membrane that can allow the iron particles to flow through and mix in with the hot water in
order to be consumed by the drinker. These companies would most likely require financial incentives to allow their product to be
fortified with iron, but possible ways to circumvent or reduce resistance is to benchmark the salt iodization process used in
Somalia.
● The Indian government can possibly sponsor or erect a number of tea fortification plants for companies to outsource this process
and thus avoid implementing it into their in-house manufacturing processes, which could prove to be very expensive and might
discourage them from partaking. Smaller distributors can send their unpackaged tea to these fortification plants, where the tea
gets fortified and packaged and then sent back to the manufacturer, ready for distribution.
● Larger distributors like TATA could possibly field the costs themselves to create an in-house fortification process. It is important
to emphasize the fact that the iron addition will not affect the quality of the product since it is both colourless and tasteless.
TATA seems to be invested in providing nutritionally fortified solutions to its consumers since it was one of the leading
companies to adopt Iron Fortified Salt under its subsidiary TATA Salt Plus to combat anemia in 2012. [11]
[11] ”Indias first iodine plus iron fortified salt launched by TataChemicals via @tatacompanies”, tata.com, 2018. [Online]. Available:http://www.tata.com/media/releasesinside/rBRDxbNl5eM=/TLYVr3YPkMU=. [Accessed: 08- Mar- 2018]
The Process of Fortifying Tea
Durum Semolina +
Extrusion Cutting Sieving
Ferrous Fumarate
[12]K. Krishnaswamy, "Technologies for Food & Nutrition Security", 2018. [Online]. Available: https://portal.utoronto.ca/bbcswebdav/pid-6613099-dt-content-rid-43836891_2/courses/Winter-2018-APS420H1-S-LEC0101/Kiruba_Krishnaswamy_Week_9%281%29.pdf.
[Accessed: 26- Mar- 2018].
PESTLE: Legal
● Toxicity of iron is an important factor to consider when providing fortified tea.
● Toxicity Levels[13]:
<20 mg/Kg: 20 - 60 mg/kg: > 60 mg/kg:
Non-Toxic Moderately Toxic Can Cause Death
[13] G. OMalley and R. OMalley, ”Iron Poisoning - Injuries; Poisoning - MSD Manual Professional Edition”, MSD Manual Professional Edition, 2018. [Online]. Available:
https://www.merckmanuals.com/en-ca/professional/injuries-poisoning/poisoning/iron-poisoning.[Accessed:12-Feb-2018].
[14]”WO2010116379A1 - Iron fortified tea and a process for manufacture thereof - Google Patents”, Google.com, 2018. [Online]. Available: https://www.google.com/patents/WO2010116379A1?cl=en. [Accessed:12-Feb-2018]
[15] ”How to Measure Loose Leaf Tea for Brewing”, Teatulia.com, 2018. [Online]. Available: https://www.teatulia.com/tea-101/how-to-measure-loose-leaf-tea-for-brewing.htm. [Accessed: 13-Feb- 2018].
PESTLE: Legal
● Food imports are governed by the Food Safety and Standards Association of India
● Complex process to import any kind of food into india
● Since iron is not on the list of prohibited substances
or a high risk food such as baby powder, obtaining an
import license will not be too difficult [16]
● Tea tariff is 110% [17], and would make it difficult
to reach people in india at a reasonable price
● Solution is to work with local tea manufacturers to
make and supply the tea
[16] ”Manual for Food Import Clearance System”, Fssai.gov.in, 2018. [Online]. Available: http://www.fssai.gov.in/home/imports/Manuals.html. [Accessed: 12- Feb- 2018].
[17] A. Sinha, ”Tea concern over import tariff decrease”, The Telegraph, 2018. [Online]. Available:
https://www.telegraphindia.com/states/west-bengal/tea-concern-over-import-tariff-decrease-188670. [Accessed: 24 Mar 2018].
PESTLE: Political
The Indian government has increased public awareness of anemia and prompted
intervention programs throughout the years.
Tea manufacturing
companies such as TATA Iron Fortified Local community
coffee Tea
[23]"Market size of the coffee and tea industry across India in 2013 and 2017 (in billion Indian rupees)", Statista 2018, 2018. [Online]. Available:
http://motherchildnutrition.org/india/vitamin-ahttp://motherchildnutrition.org/india/vitamin-a-ifa-supplementation.html-ifa-supplementation.htmlhttp://motherchildnutrition.org/india/vitamin-a-ifa-supplementation.html. [Accessed: 25- Mar- 2018].
PESTLE: Economical - Present and Future
● GDP loss
○ As stated in a 2003 paper published in Food Policy, due to iron-deficiency anemia, India loses 0.9 percent of its gross
domestic product.. [24] This means that India loses up to $20.25 billion, according to the World Bank's estimate of
India's GDP in 2016.[25][26] Thus, iron-deficiency anemia has cost India significantly in the economic perspective.
● Tea industry in India
○ As the fourth largest exporter of tea in the world, India has one of the largest tea industries in the world. [27] Currently,
there are at least 1.1 million workers employed in various tea companies around the country. [27] The industry also
created income opportunities for almost another 10 million people. [27]
● Prospective future
○ If the iron fortification tea technology can be managed to be spread across the India, the whole economic condition of
India will be revitalized because of the boost in tea industry and the decreased cost spending in the health care.
○ When the iron fortified tea becomes a daily source of absorbing iron for the Indian population, the government will invest
more in the tea industry, and thus create more job opportunities. The economy of India will be boosted due to the iron
fortified tea.
[24]S. Horton and J. Ross, "The economics of iron deficiency", Food Policy, vol. 28, no. 1, pp. 51-75, 2003.
[25]"India | Data", Data.worldbank.org, 2018. [Online]. Available: http://data.worldbank.org/country/india. [Accessed: 11- Mar- 2018]
[26]"India tops the list of nations with most anaemic women and children - Firstpost", Firstpost, 2018. [Online]. Available: http://www.firstpost.com/living/india-tops-the-list-of-nations-with-most-anaemic-women-and-children-3075578.html. [Accessed: 11- Mar- 2018].
[27]"Top 10 Tea Brands in India, facts about tea industry and more", Business.mapsofindia.com, 2018. [Online]. Available: https://business.mapsofindia.com/top-brands-india/top-tea-brands-in-india.html. [Accessed: 11- Mar- 2018].
PESTLE: Social
● To understand the social aspect of Tea in Indian culture, it is important to
first consider the historical aspect of the product.
● During British Colonial rule in the 1800s, many Indians were employed for
tea growing and manufacturing, for the benefit of the British[28].
● One important aspect of British culture was ‘teatime’, drinking tea in the
afternoon, and during colonial rule this concept became adapted by
wealthier Indians[28].
● As tea become cheaper, teatime began spreading throughout India [28]. This
was aided by large amounts of advertisement [29].
● Tea was advertised in movies, commercials and even cartoons, many
claiming health benefits[30]. This advertising worked and the concept of tea
became an important staple in Indian culture.
[30]
[28] Pal, S. (2016). India in a Tea Cup: The Fascinating History of India's Best Loved Beverage, Chai. [online] The Better India. Available at: https://www.thebetterindia.com/78265/chai-tea-history-india/ [Accessed 11 Feb. 2018].
[29] Roshan, G. (n.d.). Formation and Expansion of Tea Culture in India. [online] Ci.nii.ac.jp. Available at: https://ci.nii.ac.jp/els/contentscinii_20180212042453.pdf?id=ART0009852117 [Accessed 11 Feb. 2018].\
[30] "Brooke Bond TAJ MAHAL Vintage Advertisement", Classic Indian Advertisements. [Online]. Available: http://classicindianads.blogspot.ca/2017/01/brooke-bond-taj-mahal-vintage.html. [Accessed: 20- Mar- 2018].
PESTLE: Social
● Tea’s importance in Indian culture can be seen in any gathering
of people. Weather it is a business meeting or just a social gather,
it is expected that tea will be served [31].
● Easy access to tea, specifically ‘chai’ (a mix of tea, milk and
sugar), makes this possible.
● Distribution of tea, in small towns and cities, is mainly done by
tea salesmen known as ‘chai wallahs’ (see picture). They can be
found serving hot tea on almost every street to wealthy people
like politicians, to poorer working-class people like drivers [32].
● Therefore, tea is always accessible to the general population, [32]
allowing for easier distribution.
● As previously mentioned, the taste will not change, and only 4% [31] Roshan, G. (n.d.). Formation and Expansion of Tea Culture in India. [online] Ci.nii.ac.jp. Available at:
https://ci.nii.ac.jp/els/contentscinii_20180212042453.pdf?id=ART0009852117 [Accessed 11 Feb. 2018].
● of the target market does not currently consume fortified food. [32] L. EPLETT, "Tea Tuesday: Meet The Chai Wallahs Of India", NPR.org, 2016. [Online]. Available:
https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2016/06/14/481878368/tea-tuesday-meet-the-chai-wallahs-of-india.
● Therefore, fortified tea is expected to be socially acceptable [33]. [Accessed: 05- Mar- 2018].
[33] R. Battalwar1 and B. Syed2, "A Study on Awareness and Consumption of Fortified Foods among Female
Adults of Mumbai", International Journal of Science and Research, 2015. [Online]. Available:
https://www.ijsr.net/archive/v6i4/ART20172675.pdf. [Accessed: 20- Mar- 2018].
PESTLE: Environmental
● Severe environmental consequences are present in the cultivation and processing stages of tea
production, not in the iron fortification process itself
● Given the potential scale of iron-fortification in tea, small environmental concerns should be taken
seriously
● As tea fortification requires a integration with the tea production process, this is an opportunity to
improve on current tea practices by reducing its environmental footprint
Deforestation + Use of
Habitat unclean
Fragmentation energy
Iron Fortified Tea
Production
Improper
Pesticide
wastewater
Usage
management
Pestle: Environmental
1) Deforestation + Habitat Fragmentation due to land use for tea cultivation
❏ Converting natural land to agricultural land requires deforestation, breaks up existing habitat [34]
❏ Global trend: ↑ Tea Production = ↑ Land Use for Tea [35]
2) Pesticide Usage
❏ Negative health effects on consumers and the environment
❏ 23/34 pesticides found in Indian tea are not registered for use [37]
❏ Alternative practices in pest control have been successful [38]
(e.g. light traps for moths)
3) Unclean energy used for tea processing [36]
❏ Tea drying - powered by firewood/gas/coal - is required to reach a certain moisture level [34]
❏ A shift towards renewable energy is required in India to mitigate this concern
4) Increased iron levels in ecosystem due to improper wastewater treatment
❏ Contaminated water used during processing is not treated [34]
❏ Although effects are indirect, increased iron levels in water can be harmful to ecosystems [39]
❏ Proper wastewater management should be required at tea manufacturing facilities
[34] M. Mukhopadhyay and T. K. Mondal, “Cultivation, Improvement, and Environmental Impacts of Tea,” Oxford Environmental Science, Apr-2017. [Online]. Available:
http://environmentalscience.oxfordre.com/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780199389414.001.0001/acrefore-9780199389414-e-373. [Accessed: 12-Mar-2018].
[35] A. Basu Majumdera , B. Beraa and A. Rajanb. “Tea Statistics: Global Scenario” Tea Board India, Jan-2012. [Online]. Available: http://teaboard.gov.in/pdf/Tea%20Statistics%20Global%20Scenario.pdf. [Accessed: 12-Mar-2018]
[36] G. John, “Habitat Fragmentation in the Western Ghats,” Conservation India, 26-May-2015. [Online]. Available: http://www.conservationindia.org/gallery/habitat-fragmentation-in-the-western-ghats. [Accessed: 09-Mar-2018].
[37] “Trouble Brewing” Greenpeace India, Aug-2014. [Online]. Available: http://www.greenpeace.org/india/Global/india/image/2014/cocktail/download/TroubleBrewing.pdf. [Accessed: 12-Mar-2018]
[38] M. Malgatti. “Non-Pesticidal Management in Crops: Community Managed Extension, Processes, and Impacts” Indian Agricultural Research Institute, 11-Nov-2014. [Online]. Available:
http://csa-india.org/non-pesticidal-management-in-crops-community-managed-extension-processes-and-impacts/. [Accessed: 12-Mar-2018]
[39] K. Vuori. (1995, Nov). “Direct and indirect effects of iron on river ecosystems.” Ann. Zool. Fennici. [Online]. Vol. 32. Available: http://www.annzool.net/PDF/anzf32/anz32-317-329.pdf. [Accessed: 13-Mar-2018]
Implementation - Results of PESTLE Analysis
● Shift from pesticides to alternative pest control ● Increased in public awareness of anemia and prompted
practices intervention programs throughout the years.
● Invest in renewable energy
● Implement wastewater management
Stage 2: if iron levels in treatment community increase to a healthy level, iterate stage 1 with new treatment
community
- If results turn out negative, analyze treatment community for factors contributing to ineffectiveness,
then adjust implementation method accordingly and iterate
The Team
Luckshya Mehta Mohamed Ali Andrew Lau Oliver Wu Hao Jin
Social analysis of tea in Technology analysis of Environmental Analysis Legal Analysis Political and economical
India tea fortification in India Impact Assessment analysis of tea
fortification in India