Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
- Shall be in writing
- In the name of People of the Philippines against all person who are
responsible for the offense involved.
Note: For purposes of PI the complaint is usually in the name of the offended
party as complainant.
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
GROUP 2
2
Always signed by the fiscal (indispensable requirement) Motion to Dismiss case in court
it is filed with the court
Rule: When the information has already been file in court, the court steps in
need not be under oath
and takes control of the case until the same is finally disposed of, so that the
Who are the Persons authorized to file information? fiscal has no more control over it.
1. City or Provincial prosecutor and their assistants If a public prosecutor (fiscal) file a motion to dismiss, it should be
2. Duly appointed special prosecutors properly address to the sound discretion of the trial court.
3. Lawyer ( appointed by the Secretary of Justice If the court refuses to grant the fiscals motion to dismiss:
-the fiscal should continue to appear in the case although he may
SECTION 5: WHO MUST PROSECUTE CRIMINAL ACTION? turn over the presentation of evidence to the private prosecutor.
In the event that the court decides to dismiss the case upon
Prosecution of criminal cases, direction and control motion of the prosecution:
-the court should make independent evaluation or assessment of
General Rule: All criminal actions either commence by complaint or by its merit and not to solely rely on the said motion as this will be
information shall be prosecuted under the direction and control of the public an abdication of its duty and jurisdiction to determine a prima
prosecutor (fiscal) facie case.
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
GROUP 2
3
SC or CA- Solicitor General The offended party may not appeal from an order of dismissal by the
court entered upon motion of the fiscal, tho he may do so on the civil
General Rule: The office of the Solicitor general is the sole representative of aspect thereof is concerned.
the “People of the Philippines” on appeals before CA or SC through:
RIGHT OF THE OFFENDED PARTY TO FILE SPECIAL CIVIL ACTION
1. Writ of error INDEPENDENTLY OF THE STATE
2. Petition for review
3. Automatic appeal Rule 65 Sec 1:
4. Special civil actions
PRIVATE CRIMES: CRIMES THAT’S INSTITUTED BY PRIVATE PARTY
Exception: The Office of the Ombudsman, through its Special Prosecutor, shall
represent the “People of the Philippines” in all cases elevated to the Supreme Article 360 of the Revised Penal code provides:
Court by way of:
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
GROUP 2
4
These crimes which cannot be prosecuted de oficio and requires that 1.It can be prosecuted exclusively and successively by the following
the criminal action be brought at the instance of andupon complaint persons in this order:
expressly file by the offended party: 1. By the offended woman (party)
1. Adultery 2. The parents, grandparents or legal/judicial guardian in that
2. Concubinage successive order
3. Seduction 3. By the state in the exercise of the right of parens patriae,
4. Abduction or acts of lasciviousness when the offended party dies or becomes incapacitated
5. Action for defamation before she could file the complaint and she has no known
Reason: imposed out of consideration for the aggrieved party who parents, grandparents or guardian.
mightprefer to suffer the outrage in silence rather than go through the scandal DEFAMATION CASES
of a public trial.
2. A defamation imputing to a person any of the foregoing crimes of
Note: concubinage, adultery, seduction, abduction, rape or acts of
lasciviousness can be prosecuted only by the party or parties
Private crimes may be prosecuted only at the instance of and upon defamed
express complaint by the offended party. Failure to comply deprives
the court of jurisdiction to try the action. SECTION 6: SUFFICIENCY OF COMPLAINT OR INFORMATION
PROSECUTION OF A PRIVATE CRIM COMPLEXED WITH A PUBLIC OFFENSE 1. Name of the accused
2. The designation of the offense given by the statute
In complex crim , where one of the component offenses is a private 3. The acts or omissions complained of as constituting the offense
crim and the other a public offense, the fiscal may initiate the 4. Name of the offended party
proceedings de oficio 5. The approximate date of the commission of the offense
6. The place where the offense was committed
Reason: since one of the component offenses is a public crim, the latter should Purspose:
prevail, public interest being always paramount to private interest.
1. To notify the defendant of the criminal acts imputed to hime so that
WHO MAY PROSECUTE? he can duly prepare his defense
Only the offended spouse who should have the status, capacity, legal - The acts or omissions complained of as constituting the offense must
representation at the time of filing of the complaint, regardless of age. be stated in ordinary and concise language without repetition,not
necessarily in the terms of the statute defining the offense, but in
Cannot institute criminal prosecution without including the guilty such form as is sufficient to enable a person of common
parties, if they are both alive, nor, in any case , if he shall have understanding to know that offense is intended to charge and enable
consented or pardon the offenders the court to pronounce judgement.
SEDUCTION, ABDUCTION AND ACTS OF LASCIVIOUSNESS TEST OF SUFFICIENCY OF COMPLAINT OR INFORMATION
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
GROUP 2
5
General Rule: that if the complaint or information clearly and succinctly sents Sec. 8 – Designation of the Offense
out:
The information or complaint must state or designate the following whenever
1. The names of accused possible:
2. The designation of the crime charged
3. The acts or omissions complained of as constituting the offense
4. The name of the offended party 1) The designation of the offense given by the statute.
5. The approximate time of the commission of the offense 2) The statement of the acts or omissions constituting the offense, in
6. The place wherein the offense was committed ordinary, concise and particular words.
Note: Substantial defect in the information cannot be cured by evidence that 3) The specific qualifying and aggravating circumstances must be
would jeopardize the accused’s right to be informed of the true nature of the stated in ordinary and concise language.
offense he is being charged with.
The complaint or information must state name of the accused in any of the ffg 1) The accused should be fully appraised of the true charges against him
ways: to avoid any possible surprise which might be detrimental to his
rights
1) Name and surname 2) To afford the accused of the opportunity to prepare his defense
2) Nickname and appellation by which he has been or is known accordingly
3) Fictitious name with statement that his true name is unknown
Designation of the Offense
Purposes for this rule:
- Facts must be sufficient to enable a person of common understanding
1) To make a specific identification of the person to whom the to know what is being alleged
commission of an offense is being imputed - It is sufficient if all the essential elements constituting the particular
2) To preclude the possibility of having a wrong person apprehended offense in the statute are present
and brought to trial while the real culprit goes scot-free - Real name of the offense in the crime is determined not by its title but
by the facts alleged in the accusation
Error in name
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
GROUP 2
6
3) To serve as a protection against further prosecution for the same the light of the fact that such allegation commonly serves the dual purpose of
cause. informing the defendant of the nature and cause of the accusation against him,
Rule on Negative Averments and of fixing jurisdiction and venue (Pamaran,M.R. 2012 Ed. p. 106).
GENERAL RULE: Where the statute penalizes generally the acts therein Crimes Where Place is Essential
defined and is intended to apply to all persons indiscriminately, the
a. Violation of domicile;
information is sufficient even if does not allege that the accused falls within
b. Penalty on keeper, watchman and visitor of an opium den;
the excepted situation, for then the complete definition of the offense is
c. Trespass to dwelling;
entirely separable from the exceptions and can be made without reference to
d. Violation of election law, e.g., 30 meter-radius carrying of deadly
the latter. In this case, the exception is a matter of defense which the accused
weapon prohibited.
has to prove.
Sec. 10 Place of commission of the offense Venue in criminal cases is an essential element of jurisdiction. To determine
venue in libel cases, the complaint or information should contain allegations
General Rule: as to whether, at the time the offense was committed, the offended party was a
public officer or a private individual and where he was actually residing at the
The complaint or information is sufficient if: time. Whenever possible, the place where the written defamation was printed
and first published should likewise be alleged. That allegation would be a sine
4) It can be understood from the allegations in the complaint or
qua non if the circumstances as to where the libel was printed and first
information that the offense was committed.
published is used as the basis of the venue of the action.
5) Some of the offense essential ingredients occurred at some place
within the jurisdiction of the court. Jurisdiction - treats of the power of the court to decide the case on merits.
Exception to the rule: Venue - deals with the locality, the place where the suit may be had.
3) The particular place where the offense was committed constitutes an Sec. 11 Date of commission of offense
essential element of the offense charged.
4) Necessary for the identification of the offense committed. General Rule:
Purpose of Rule: The necessity and sufficiency of an allegation in an It is not necessary to state in the complaint or information the precise date the
information of the place of commission of the offense must be considered in offense was committed.
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
GROUP 2
7
The offense may be alleged to have been committed on a date as near as BUT in U.S. v. Smith — it was held that the proof need not correspond to the
possible to the actual date of its commission. allegation, unless the time and place is material and of the essence of the
offense as a necessary ingredient in its description.
Exception to the rule:
The evidence is admissible and sufficient if it shows:
When the precise date is a material ingredient of the offense.
(1) That the crime was committed at any time within the period of limitation
"Time" of the commission of the offense was changed to "DATE." (statute of limitations) and
Crimes Where Time is Essential (2) Before or after the time stated in the complaint or indictment and before
the action is commenced.
a. Infanticide;
b. Violation of Sunday Statutes (Election Law); and Thus, an information charging the commission of the crime of robbery in
c. Abortion. December 1902, was filed in March 19, 1903.
The complaint must allege a specific time and place when and where the It was held that the complaint was sufficient to sustain a conviction even if the
offense was committed, but when the time so alleged is not of the essence of proof showed that it was committed in January 1903.
the offense, it need not be proved as alleged, and the complaint will be
sufficient if the evidence shows that the offense was committed at any time It was, however held, in U.S. v. Dickao, that an allegation from October 1910 to
within the period of the statute of limitation and before the commencement of August 1912 is defective:
the action.
“To allege in an information that the accused committed rape on a certain girl
Where the complaint for rape charges accused with having committed the between October 1910, and August 1912, is too indefinite to give the accused
crime "on or about the month of June 1978" and the affidavit shows that it an opportunity to prepare his defense, and that indefiniteness is not cured by
was committed for "sometime prior to said period and subsequent thereto," setting out the date when a child was born as a result of such crime.
attaching thereto the affidavit of the complainant that she was abused before
An information for bigamy must state the time and place of the second
the start of classes in June 1978 which may thus be considered as part of the
wedding.
complaint, the discrepancies between the accusation and the complaint as to
the time of occurrence of the carnal copulations in rape do not affect the Variance, however, on date of commission of rape is irrelevant. Time is
essential rights of the accused, where the acts occurred within the period of irrelevant in ”rape" and violations of the Dangerous Drugs Law cases.
time alleged in both writings, and the difference noted in other respects was
of a formal, rather than a substantial, character. Statute of Limitations:
"About" is a very comprehensive term which when used with regards to time, Statutes of limitations are construed as acts of grace, and a surrender by the
may cover a considerable extent thereof. sovereign of its right to prosecute or of its right to prosecute at its discretion.
Such statutes are considered as equivalent to acts of amnesty founded on the
liberal theory that prosecutions should not be allowed to ferment endlessly in
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
GROUP 2
8
the files of the government to explode only after witnesses and proofs In rape cases, or in cases involving violence against women and their children
necessary for the protection of the accused have by sheer lapse of time passed the court shall withhold the real name of the victim and shall use fictitious
beyond availability. The periods fixed under such statutes are jurisdictional initials to represent her.
and are essential elements of the offenses covered (People v Lacson, G.R. No.
149453, April 1, 2003). Case Study:
--> The property must be described with such particularity as to properly Issue:
identify the offense charged.
Whether the accused committed the crime of Rape through Sexual Intercourse
B. Disclosed or Ascertained true name of the person against whom or against or Rape by Sexual Assault.
whose property the offense was committed
Ruling:
--> The court must cause such true name to be inserted in the complaint or
information and the record. The Court find appellant guilty of rape by sexual assault. It cannot be denied
that appellant inserted an object into "AAAs" female organ. "AAA" categorically
C. The Offended party is a Juridical Person testified that appellant inserted something into her vagina. She claimed to
have suffered tremendous pain during the insertion. The insertion even
--> It is sufficient to state its name,, or any name or designation by which it is
caused her vagina to bleed necessitating her examination at the hospital. Both
known or by which it may be identified, without need of averring that it is a
the trial court and the CA found "AAAs" testimony to be credible. We find no
juridical person or that it is organized in accordance with law.
compelling reason not to lend credence to the same.
Exception to the Rule:
Dispositive Portion:
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
GROUP 2
9
WHEREFORE, the December 29, 2006 Decision of the Court of Appeals in CA- People vs Chingh G.R. No. 178323, 16 March 2011 – “when two or more offenses
G.R. CR-H.C. No. 01442 is AFFIRMED with MODIFICATIONS. Accused- are charged in a single complaint or information, the accused must object to
appellant Benjamin Soria y Gomez is found guilty beyond reasonable doubt of such fact before trial. If he does not so object, the court may convict him of as
the crime of rape by sexual assault and is sentenced to suffer the penalty of many offenses as are charged and proved, and impose on him the penalty for
twelve (12) years of prison mayor, as minimum, to twenty (20) years of each offense.”
reclusion temporal, as maximum. He is also ordered to pay "AAA" the amounts
of P30,000.00 as civil indemnity, P30,000.00 as moral damages, and
P30,000.00 as exemplary damages. "AAA" is entitled to an interest on all
AMENDMENT OR SUBSTITUTION (Section 14, Rule 110)
damages awarded at the legal rate of 6% per annum from the date of finality
of this judgment until fully paid. - A complaint or information may be amended, in form or in substance
which may be made before or after the accused enters his plea or
Application of Rule 110 Sec. 12 in the case presented:
during the trial.
Justice Del Castillo withhold the name of the rape victim and used a fictitious
initials to represent her which is “AAA”.
AMENDMENT BEFORE PLEA
DUPLICITY OF OFFENSE (Section 13 Rule 110)
- Can be amended without leave of court.”
General Rule:
Exception:
“a complaint or information must contain only one offense.”
When Leave of Court is required before plea in the following:
Exception:
- Amendment intended to downgrade the nature of the offense in; and
“when the law prescribes a single punishment for various offenses.” - or excludes any accused from the complaint or information.
WHEN THE INFORMATION OR COMPLAINT CONTAIN MORE THAN ONE This requires the following:
OFFENSE
- motion by the prosecutor;
- notice to the offended party; and
- Under Sec. 3 of Rule 120, the accused must object to it before trial.
- with leave of court.
- Failure to object the court the court may convict the accused for as
many offenses as are charged and proved. RULES AS TO AMENDMENT AFTER PLEA AND DURING THE TRIAL.
People vs Tabio G.R. No. 179477, 6 February 2008 – “Failure of the accused to
Any formal amendment may only be made under two (2) conditions:
interpose an objection on the ground of duplicity of the offenses charged in the
information constitutes waiver.” - Leave of court must be secured; and
- The amendments does not cause prejudice to the right of the accused.
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
GROUP 2
10
In this stage only formal amendment is allowed, since the law makes Criminal action shall be instituted and tried in the court of the municipality or
reference to “formal amendment may only be made”. However, in the case of territory:
Ricarze v Court of Appeals, G.R. No. 160451, 9 February 2007, citing the case of
Matalam vs Sandiganbayan, 455 SCRA 736, states that “after arraignment, a - Where the offense is committed; or
substantial amendment is proscribed, except if the same is beneficial to the - Where any of its essential ingredients occurred.
accused.” EXEMPTION:
The following are mere formal amendments, Ricarze vs CA: The law provides an exemption to the rule that it is subject to existing laws,
such as written defamation.
- New allegations which relate only to the range of penalty;
- Does not charge another offense separate or distinct from that Whether committed by a private or public officer, the complaint may be filed
charged in the original; with the RTC of the place where such libelous article is printed and first
- Additional allegations which do not alter the prosecution’s theory of
published.
the case so as to cause surprise to the accused or affect the form of
defense he has or will assume;
- Does not adversely affect any substantial right of the accused; and
- Which merely adds specification to eliminate vagueness in the RULE WHERE OFFENSE I COMMITTED IN A TRAIN, AIRCRAFT OR VEHICLE
information and not to introduce new and material facts, and merely
states with additional precision something which is already Criminal Action shall be instituted and tried in court of any municipality or
contained in the original information and which adds nothing territory:
essential for conviction for the crime charged.
- Where such train, aircraft, or other vehicle passed during its trip,
Substitution of the offense, when to be made:
including the place of its departure and arrival.
- If it appears at any time before judgement that a mistake has been This rule only applies when the offense is committed in the course of the trip
made in charging the proper offense, the court shall dismiss the of the above mentioned vehicles.
original complaint or information upon filing of a new one charging
the proper offense.
Exception:
RULE WHERE OFFNESE IS COMMITTED ON BOARD A VESSEL
- When the accused will be placed in double jeopardy. Criminal Action shall be instituted and tried in:
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
GROUP 2
11
General Rule
Exemption:
GENERAL RULE
- Every person criminally liable for a felony is also civilly liable (Article
100 RPC).
- When criminal action is instituted the civil action for the recovery of
civil liability arising from the offense charged shall be deemed
instituted (Rule 111)
EXCEPTION
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
GROUP 2