Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
PLAY THERAPY
Volume 2 December 2006
SUBSCRIPTIONS SCOPE
The British Journal of Play Therapy is The British Journal of Play Therapy is a
currently published once a year on behalf of national journal with a focus on the theoretical
the British Association of Play Therapists. The and research aspects of Play Therapy practice.
cost reflects this and will be adjusted when Its aim is to bring together the different
more frequent publication is resumed. theoretical and professional disciplines
involved in Play Therapy and this will be
Subscription rates include delivery (but not reflected in the composition of the Editorial
VAT or Sales Tax where this is payable). Board. Nevertheless we welcome submission
from all relevant professional backgrounds.
T h e a n n u al su b sc r i p t i o n r a te s p e r The journal thus aims to promote theoretical
volume are as follows: and research developments in the fields of Play
Therapy practice. Submission of reviews,
Britain (England, Scotland and Wales) systematic reviews and research papers which
Institutions £25 support evidence-based practice are also
Individual £15 welcomed. Papers may assume any of the
following forms:
Europe
Institutions £30 (a) Papers reporting original research findings.
Individual £17 (b) Theoretical papers.
North America (USA, Canada and Mexico) (c) Review papers, which need not be
Institutions £35 exhaustive, but which should give an
Individual £20 interpretation of the state of research or
practice in a given field and, where
Orders, which must be accompanied by appropriate, identify its clinical implications.
payment, may be sent to: Journal Department, (d) Systematic reviews.
The British Association of Play Therapists, (e) Brief reports and comments.
1 Beacon Mews, South Road, Weybridge,
Surrey KT13 9DZ
CORRESPONDENCE
COPYING Correspondence to the Editor should be sent
to BAPT, 1 Beacon Mews, South Road,
No part of this publication may be
Weybridge, Surrey KT13 9DZ
reproduced, stored or distributed by any
info@bapt.uk.com
means without permission in writing from the
British Association of Play Therapists. Copyright © The British Association of Play Therapists (2006) All
rights reserved.
Registered Charity No. 1115673
Organisations authorized by the UK The British Association of Play Therapists is the trading name of
Copyright Licensing Agency may also The British Association of Play Therapists Ltd, registered in
England & Wales (Company number 5477406). Registered
photocopy material subject to the usual address: 47 Sedlescombe Road South, St. Leonards-on-Sea, East
conditions. Sussex TN38 0TB
BRITISH JOURNAL
OF
PLAY THERAPY
Editor
ANNE BARNES
Notre Dame Centre, Glasgow, Scotland
Editorial Board
ANN CATTANACH VIRGINIA RYAN
Department of Social Policy and Social Work, Department of Social Policy and Social
University of York, York, England Work,University of York, York, England
SUE JENNINGS
Glastonbury, England
Advisory Board
MERKEL SENDER (Educational Psychology)
Summerfield Centre, London, England
Correspondence to the Editor, Editorial Board and Advisory Board should be sent to the
Administrator, BAPT, 1 Beacon Mews, South Road, Weybridge, Surrey KT13 9DZ
info@bapt.uk.com
BRITISH JOURNAL OF PLAY THERAPY
2006 VOLUME 2 DECEMBER
EDITORIAL
Anne Barnes 3
PAPERS
Book Reviews 63
Table of Contents 66
2
Bri. J. Play Therapy, Vol. 2 (2006)
British Association of Play Therapists
Editorial
I should like to thank readers for their patience and Casson's article introduces us to his invention of the
continued willingness to bear with us in the Communicube, a structure that may appeal to play
uncertainty about publishing dates. Initially my therapists, and have applications for direct work
hopes of being inundated with suitable material with some clients. Strands from play therapy and
were not realised. Waiting has been rewarded as I from dramatherapy are inherent to this expressive
am now pleased to present a selection of articles that process. Casson introduces interesting case
will satisfy varied interests. The scope of this edition examples to show how practitioners have been able
includes crisis intervention with a traumatised to adapt the approach for use with groups as well as
child, research issues, and a small cluster of for individual work with children.
variations on the theme of play therapy.
Daniel-McKeigue intrigues us with a fascinating
Diana Jansen is an experienced and insightful account of developments in her thinking about
sandplay practitioner. After attending a workshop research. She shares her quest for exciting and
with her earlier in the year, I was delighted when she innovative ways to try to capture creative principles
agreed to contribute an account of her work. She at work in the therapeutic process that emerge
describes, with utmost sensitivity, how a very young through the dynamic matrix of exchange between
child’s grieving for his father was permitted to two human beings. In a complementary piece
unfold within the trusted relationship with his Naylor provides us with a thorough exploration of
therapist. Jansen draws on Jungian theory to add the literature surrounding the ethics of research in
dimension and depth to her understanding of the play therapy. She tackles a thorny dilemma familiar
wisdom of the psyche to heal. to the play therapist who does not want personal
research agendas to impinge on the delicate process
In a brief report Leong Min See, a UK trained play of therapy with a child. She shares questions on how
therapist from Malaysia, continues the theme of an essentially non-directive process may be
sudden loss. She describes a short intervention with investigated in ways that are both rigorous and truly
a young girl affected by the tsunami of 2004. This free from negative impact on a vulnerable client
is a timely item as we reach the second anniversary group. Naylor raises valuable points and in so doing
of the tragic catastrophe that devastated coastal I feel also sets challenges both for debate and
regions in southern Asia. It is striking how this practice that invite response.
child, with an essentially secure family structure,
was able to use therapeutic help to process her Given that suitably rigorous articles were initially
trauma and begin to make sense of her loss in a slow to appear, it seemed wisest to produce Volume
remarkably rapid space of time. 2 in one larger edition this year, hence the
adjustment to cost. If I am able to hold back the
An increasing number of play therapists are seeking tide of those wishing to contribute to Volume 3 the
additional training in attachment related current status quo will also apply in 2007. However,
approaches such as Theraplay in order to enhance as I have some material already waiting, I feel
their skills in working with children and families. confident in forming the plan to publish earlier in
This is especially important when new attachments the year, and will aim for summer. The first edition
need to be formed, and where children may present of Volume 4 will then be produced at the very
beginning of 2008, to be followed by a second later
with early, unmet needs. Dave Myrow and his wife, in the year. I hope that my prediction of a gathering
Sue Bundy Myrow, have visited the UK and Ireland momentum proves accurate. I will keep you
to give presentations and training on behalf of the informed of progress via the BAPT magazine, and
Theraplay Institute. In the autumn I was able to ask for your forbearance in this, trusting that when
satisfy a long held ambition to have them introduce it arrives the journal will be a treat worth the
Theraplay north of the border. I am pleased to waiting.
present an article here that will provide a useful
introduction for those who would like to know I should like again to thank my colleagues on the
more about this rather different take on play and Editorial Board for their support, and also Lisa
therapy. Myrow takes us through the history and Gordon Clark for her eagle-eyed proof reading. It
framework of Theraplay, and illustrates its practice has been sad to lose Jo Carroll’s excellent services.
with a generic case example. He then considers Her careful reading and clear comments on items
recent research outcomes that strongly support the submitted to her is greatly missed. We wish her well
efficacy of Theraplay with a range of presenting in her adventures.
problems. Anne Barnes
3
Bri. J. Play Therapy, Vol. 2 (2006), pp 4-13
4
Diana Jansen
Psychotherapist and Sandtray Therapist
Abstract
In this paper I have given a brief description of Sandplay as it was first conceived by the Swiss psychotherapist,
Dora Kalff. Sandplay is used with wonderful results with both adults and children. I attempt to convey how the
unconscious can, without interference from the conscious mind, lead towards what Jung referred to as ‘the self
healing of the psyche’ within a sandplay process. This process is enabled within the therapeutic relationship and
what Kalff referred to as ‘the free and protected space’ of the sand tray itself. I have tried to illustrate this process
by describing the therapy of a three-and-a-half year old boy who created fourteen sandtrays. Through his ‘play’
in the sand he was able to mourn for the father he had lost and to re-connect with his own internal father. The
process led from a state of fragmentation to one of integration, and this coincided with a leap in his development
in his outer life.
people maintain that the sand itself has calming and It is this possibility of bypassing the conscious mind
healing properties. I find sometimes that with a that makes sandplay such a powerful medium. The
distressed or troubled client just standing beside my early experiences can be re-lived, remembered and
sand trays and sifting sand through their fingers can integrated into the conscious personality. Sandplay
have a calming effect. allows the expression of every level of development
from pre-verbal and pre-symbolic to verbal and
For Dora Kalff, there was an ineffable quality to finally to mental integration (Ryce-Menuhin,
play in the sand. The pictures her patients created in 1992). Jungian Sandplay is based on the Jungian
the sand were not merely descriptive of something concept of the spontaneous self-healing of the
that was consciously known. This play could go to psyche, which can take place if the conditions are
a much deeper level and produce psychic images; favourable. In the holding environment of the
‘images of the internal landscape’ was the way she therapeutic relationship and what Kalff referred to
referred to this (Kalff, 1986), which were not as the ‘free and protected space’ of the sandtray, this
available to the conscious mind. It is often this process is enabled (Kalff, 1986).
bypassing of the conscious, which happens far more
readily in children, that can effect healing in a The concept of the importance of play is a familiar
sometimes almost miraculous way. one also in the work of Winnicott. He believed that
it is through play that we are most completely
Dora Kalff was a student and near neighbour of the ourselves. He writes: ‘It is in playing, and only in
Swiss psychiatrist, C.G. Jung, on the outskirts of playing, that the individual child or adult is able to
Zurich. In the 1950’s Jung had heard of the work of be creative and to use the whole personality, and it
Margaret Lowenfeld, a child psychiatrist working in is only in being creative that the individual discovers
London. He suggested that Kalff went to London the self ’ (1988, p63). Through play the child can
to study this new therapy, which Lowenfeld called express his/her spontaneity; what Winnicott
‘The World Technique’ (Mitchell & Friedman, referred to as the ‘true’ rather than the ‘false’ self.
1996). Kalff returned to Zurich in 1956 and Through play in early life we discover the
adapted Lowenfeld’s work to her own Jungian transitional space (which lies between mother and
orientation. infant) where mother is a secure and affirming
presence and where we are free to play and to be
The essence of Dora Kalff ’s sandplay is this: the ourselves (Winnicott). It is vitally important in the
inner world can be given substance and materialised development of the young child to have this space.
through the hands. Through the combination of a Schiller once said that ‘man is most completely
conscious and unconscious process the landscape of himself when at play’ (as cited in Jung, 1936, p76).
the patient’s inner world can be represented in a Perhaps the sand can lead us back to this early
visible and three-dimensional form. For a moment experience of unselfconscious play when our play is
psyche and matter become indistinguishable. It a pure expression of the self and no expectations or
allows a return to the roots of childhood and to the ‘oughts’ interfere with this.
depths of our cultural history when psyche and
soma, body and mind, were undifferentiated (Ryce- I should add here that the ability to make use of the
Menuhin, 1992). sand in terms of a healing process is not initially
possible for a severely traumatised child1. To allow
Sandplay makes possible a return to pre-verbal for the child’s play in the sand and his or her use of
memory, which cannot be reached by talking alone. symbols to facilitate healing it is necessary to have
These earliest memories are recorded not in the had the ‘good enough’ (Winnicott, 1988)
mind but in the body. Jung wrote that ‘often the experience of mother. Children who do not have
hands know how to solve a riddle with which the this fundamental security within their early
intellect has wrestled in vain’ (Jung, 1960, Par. 80). relationships, and who have not experienced the
6 THE USE OF SANDPLAY WITH CHILDREN
freedom to play, may not have the ability to example, the therapist becomes cast as the all-
symbolise. They live in a world of concrete reality in powerful mother one can, as therapist, find oneself
which the ‘as if ’ world of the symbolic reality is caught in a no-win situation. The sand tray provides
outside their experience. For the abused and a third dimension in which the problem can be
disadvantaged child, there must first develop a looked at and reflected upon by patient and
relationship of trust with the therapist; this is therapist together instead of the therapist being seen
perhaps the first positive relationship the child has as ‘the problem’.
known. It may take some years, in this case, before
there is sufficient trust to allow the psyche to enable I have two sand trays, one with wet and the other
a healing process. with dry sand and I keep a watering can beside the
wet tray for extra wetness. Each of the trays sits on
What is depicted in the sand is a symbolic a stand and the stands have casters so they can be
expression. Symbolic expression is the natural moved to any position in the room. The dimensions
language both for children and for the unconscious of the trays are important. They are exactly the size
(Neumann, 1973). As sandplay therapists we must that can be taken in visually without the need to
learn the language of symbols in order to interpret move one’s head. They measure 22.5 x 28.5 inches
the communications in the sand. Jung described the (57 x 72 cm) and are three inches deep. The trays
symbol as ‘an intuitive idea that cannot yet be are half filled with fine silver sand and the base is
formulated in any other or better way’ (1954, painted blue to give the impression of water when
para.105). A symbol is never either this or that: the the sand is cleared from it (Ammann, 1991). On the
essential nature of the symbol is that it contains a shelves beside the trays are the miniature figures.
paradox. The snake for instance is both a symbol for Every category of figure is represented to include:
the most primitive level of life, for evil, destruction
and deceit and it is also a symbol for healing and • humans of every kind
transformation (Cirlot, 1971: Chetwynd, 1982). In • gods, goddesses
addition, of course, the snake will have a particular • mythological figures
association and resonance for each individual • animals of every kind
person. One can never be dogmatic about symbols • birds
but it is important to remember that they are an • fish
essential aspect of our work in sandplay with both • insects
children and adults. • snakes
• reptiles of all kinds
Practical Considerations
and objects both beautiful and ugly such as:
Sometimes a sandplay collection is in a separate part
of the consulting room and sometimes it is in a • buildings
different room altogether. When working with • all modes of travel
adults it is important that it is in a different space • stones
from the verbal therapy. This creates a separation • shells
between the verbal therapy and the sandplay, which • nests
can at times create a new way of relating. This is • feathers
especially true when the transference and counter- • driftwood
transference relationship is too powerful. If, for
• leaves
1 Until now nothing has been published in relation to a sandplay process with severely damaged children. Agnes Bailey worked for many
years in the North East of England, with wonderful results, with this client group. Her work is now carried on by Mike Falcus. Anyone
interested in pursuing this further can contact him on his email: michael@falcus.wanadoo.co.uk or telephone: 0794 1650 788.
THE USE OF SANDPLAY WITH CHILDREN 7
and also gives some indication about the future in the position closest to Ben as he created the tray
possibility of healing. My feeling about this tray was is more positive. The tractor can plough up the land
that it expressed a certain amount of fragmentation. and help new things to grow. It represents another
Ben had left sand, water and toys scattered over my form of horsepower and the colour red, which Ben
entire room, and it felt as though he was literally used throughout the process in relation to himself,
spilling over. I felt the wetness of the tray seemed to is a colour suggesting warmth, energy and life as
be connected to his father’s drowning as well as to well as anger. It stands out in this tray, which is
his own and his mother’s tears. He had tried to keep predominantly without colour. It feels like a positive
the little fishing vessel afloat but without success. sign, as though this little tractor symbolises the part
(In the second tray, created the following week, the of Ben that is able to survive the deluge of his own
little fishing boat literally went under and was and Mother’s sadness.
buried in sand with only the tip of the mast
showing). The wagon in the top right corner In his second tray Ben first placed six small wooden
seemed to be about Ben’s own sense of cars in the top centre portion of the tray and they
abandonment without a strong Daddy to draw his too, like the fishing vessel, were pushed under and
own personal wagon, and to give a sense of direction buried. In the bottom half of the tray we have a
in his life. The horses are disappearing off to the left, scene with dark grey buildings and a bridal couple
out of the picture. The left side of the tray is often in the bottom right corner; ‘This’, Ben said, ‘is
seen as representing the unconscious side of the Mum and Dad’. Pointing towards them is a large
personality, the right side the conscious aspect black vehicle, a Bat mobile that is usually seen as the
(Ammann, 1991). If the horsepower, or energy, in vehicle of rescue. In this tray however it looks like a
relation to this child is moving towards the huge, menacing, black arrow directed against the
unconscious it suggests regression. This was a reality parental couple. There was a strong feeling now of a
for Ben2. Regression in such a young child can be a threatened Mum and Dad. There was also a sense
cause for concern, and the movement towards the that the child’s own driving power and ego strength
left of both the fishing vessel and the tractor also was under threat, suggested by the six buried cars.
reinforces this impression. However, the red tractor In addition, that part of him that had somehow
managed to keep afloat (in relation to the buried
fishing vessel) has literally gone under.
Developing Themes the colour red with himself. The number three is of
course his age but it could also represent his broken-
The theme of abandonment occurs once again in in-three self as he is no longer held together by a
Ben’s third sand picture. He has placed the bridal united couple. The soldiers are at risk from three
(parental) couple on the right and a baby bird in a gunmen. Coming to the rescue there are a fire
nest on the left. In between lies a baby in white that engine, a repair vehicle, both placed beside the
is neither with the parents nor in the safe nest but house he now called Diana’s House, a man on
alone and abandoned in between the two. A canoe horseback and the busy broom. We can see here the
travels across the lower portion of the tray and again transference beginning to take effect with the
the movement is towards the left. healing possibilities coming from Diana’s house.
The sixth picture was a turning point. After this
There was a recurring theme throughout Ben’s there was a definite change in the pattern of Ben’s
fourteen trays. In almost every one there is the all- play. He no longer darted from one game to
important house. It made its first appearance in the another. With a great sense of purpose he went
second tray. Among the dark, rather menacing straight to my shelves and brought down the figures
buildings surrounding the parental couple is a small needed for his play.
white adobe house, which he referred to first as a
lighthouse and then as ‘Ben’s House’. Later, this Healing Begins
same house became ‘Diana’s House’. I saw this as an
early sign that what had gone badly wrong in Ben’s In the two trays that follow, Ben placed Diana’s
inner house had the potential for healing. House, (initially referred to as the light house), and
Ben’s House, shared with Mum, side by side. He
In the fifth tray Ben placed the entire doll’s house created his own ‘I-land’ space in the tray’s centre,
in the sand tray. He purposefully emptied it of all and again swept the blue space clear of every grain
furniture and with infinite care brushed away every of sand. He placed a table on the island and two
grain of sand with the doll’s house broom. The chairs, one for himself and the other for me. In the
furniture was dumped in the front right corner following tray, the second chair was for Mum while
together with the figure of mother. It was as though a small boy in a red jumper, the figure he associated
he was sweeping away unconscious material and with himself, occupies his own chair. The table is set
preparing the house that would represent himself in for breakfast (Figure 2). Ben prepared a plate with
subsequent pictures. He created an empty house three bananas for himself and a strawberry for me.
ready to be refurnished in his own way. I was The three bananas seemed to emphasise his
reminded of Winnicott’s emphasis on the infant’s masculinity and the red strawberry, like a red heart,
need to gain mental detachment from mother: suggests a new possibility in relation to feeling. In
‘That is differentiation into a separate personal self these two pictures there is a sense of everything
…’ (1940, p 197). superfluous being cleared away. The security
coming from his mother’s house was set beside
Central to Ben’s play was the recreation of the Diana’s House. This demonstrated the healing
house, which may be seen to represent the Self. His potential of the transference3. On the other side of
father’s suicide had left Ben in pieces. This my house stands Ben’s own little ‘cottage’, the
fragmentation was expressed especially powerfully individual house of the now potentially intact and
in his sixth tray by three red soldiers lying in a pool healed Self. This is the place that would become his
in the centre of the tray. Ben increasingly associated inner home. In the rear left corner are six cows that
3 The transference includes aspects of the patient’s relationships from the past, especially parental relationships, which he projects onto the
therapist. It can also represent aspects of the patient himself, which have not yet been realised. It has the possibility of disrupting the
therapeutic encounter, when the therapist represents destructive past relationships, but also contains the potential for healing. (Samuels,
Shorter & Plaut, 1987).
10 THE USE OF SANDPLAY WITH CHILDREN
seem to promise a nurturing possibility. Nearest to House’ and to the right is the married couple with
where I was sitting as he created the tray, on the left their baby, the now completed archetypal family;
side, he placed the repair lorry again, and this mother, father and baby in white. The baby, which
seemed to communicate to me that the repair work Ben said ‘had to be taken out of the Mummy’s
was in progress! In the bottom right corner of his tummy’, now beside the united parents, was
seventh tray he placed the large grey church, which associated with his newly reborn Self. The inner
appeared first in the second tray. This seemed to be possibility of the completed family had to be
connected with Dad’s funeral and burial. Beside the restored before healing could occur.
church he put a tiny house. About this he said: ‘this
Completion
echoed by five blue marbles to the left express the for my collection because he couldn’t find one
symbol of physical totality (composed of a head, there). Later this house is used increasingly in
two arms and two legs). This seemed to represent a conjunction with ‘Ben’s House’ as he begins to use
significant shift in light of the previous sense of me, in the transference, to enable his healing
physical regression, disintegration and process. Ben used the house to express both a place
fragmentation that had been reflected in the chaos of security and safety as well as an expression of his
increasing ability to recognise his own separate
internal space. The house becomes for Ben the
secure place that he shares with the now
archetypally complete family, where mother and
father are together again with baby Ben. It was also
the symbol for Ben’s increasing sense of his own
individual Self, a separate self from the house
inhabited by mother. In this process Ben has
recreated his own secure inner house after his sense
of inner fragmentation following the devastating
loss of his father. ‘Sandplay really is based on the
self-healing of the patient. Given a wound, a free
Figure 3 and protected place and an empathic witness, a self-
Ben’s Fifteenth Sandtray: ‘Dad’s Birthday’ healing process can be initiated’ (Bradway &
left behind in my room in early sessions. McCord, 1997, p. 46).
A warm relationship had developed between Ben Home is linked to our core and when
and me during these eighteen sessions in which he something is brought home to us it is
had created fourteen sand pictures. Now he was understood with our whole being…When the
quite clear that it was enough and it was time for us house is transformed into a symbolic centre the
to end. I remembered that in our sixth session I had individual may find freedom to explore, go
out and go within, attuning to the dreaming
asked him how many more times he felt he would
mind…The ground plan forms a mandala.
need to come. Without hesitation he said, ‘eight
This permits encounters with the unknown or
more’. This turned out to be exactly right. Of course terrifying through a prevailing sense of grace.
a three-year-old child has no concept of the number (Colcord, 1998, p 92).
eight or of the time that represents. However, in a
psychic process, which does not involve what is
known consciously, there is a clear sense of what is The Healing Process
needed, if we can only connect with this.
In his outer life, Ben had shown remarkable
Ben’s Use of the House development during the period of our work
together. His play was more focused and the earlier
The house as symbol of the Self was the outstanding signs of fragmentation in his behaviour had
symbol Ben used in his healing process. In our floor disappeared. His speech had developed and his
games, he made houses and used the doll’s house to mother commented on his development in relation
create a hospital, fire station, or home, according to to both home and nursery school. He was better
the game of the moment. In his sand trays the able to interact socially and was no longer needing
house became the main feature of his pictures. In to revert to babyhood when he was with his mother.
the second tray he refers to the house, which is to
become Diana’s House as The Light House. (When For me, witnessing the process of this young child as
the work was finished he brought me a lighthouse he recreated his own inner home was a very moving
12 THE USE OF SANDPLAY WITH CHILDREN
experience. I learned through working with Ben second marriage, she enjoys a full life with a large
how true it is that a child’s natural form of family of children and grandchildren.
communication is through symbolic language. ‘Of
course the child thinks his world is real, never the Diana Jansen
less, it is a symbolic world. For this reason a child’s Meadowfield House
utterances must always be taken as symbolic, not Dalton
interpreted rationalistically, from the reason Northumberland
standpoint of adult consciousness’ (Neumann, NE18 OAA
1973, p.34).
Tel: 01661 886200
Dora Kalff believed that children are closer to the Email: Diana.Jansen@btinternet.com
truth than adults and the younger the child, the
closer they are to it. This was certainly my
experience with Ben. One can conceal the truth References
from children but at some level they already know it
so the concealment just leads to confusion. On the Ammann, R. (1991). Healing and Transformation in
final day of our work together Ben said to his Sandplay. USA: Open Court Publishing Company.
mother: ‘Daddy didn’t fall into the river, he jumped,
didn’t he?’ He was now ready to acknowledge the Bradway, K. & McCord, B. (1997). Sandplay -
truth consciously. That evening, in his bath (after silent worship of the psyche. London/New York:
we had looked together at the slides of all his sand Routledge.
trays), Ben said to his mother, ‘Looking at the
pictures with Diana was the bestest bit of the day. It Chetwynd, T. (1982). A Dictionary of Symbols.
made me sad because I miss my Daddy, but he’s still London: Paladin.
with me really, inside my head… there’s always
something ending and something else setting off, Cirlot, J.E. (1971). A Dictionary of Symbols.
Mummy’. London: Routledge.
In this paper I have given a description of sandplay Colcord, M.E. (1998). Home Sweet Home.
as the Swiss psychotherapist, Dora Kalff, conceived Harvest, 44 (2).
it. With a brief case study of a three-year-old boy I
have attempted to illustrate the unconscious process Cunningham, L. (1997). Sandplay Therapy.
as it unfolds during a sandplay process. I hope very Journal of Sandplay Therapy, 6 (1).
much that this will be of some interest to those play
therapists who are already using sandtrays in their Jung, C.G. (1936). Modern Man in Search of a Soul.
work with children. London: Kegan Paul.
: An Introduction
Theraplay
Abstract
This article introduces Theraplay1, a therapeutic model that is becoming increasingly known for its focus on
promoting parent-child attachment. First developed in America, Theraplay is currently being used in at least
eleven countries and in a wide variety of settings including schools, mental health clinics, private practice, speech
and language therapy agencies, and residential treatment facilities. Theraplay differs from Child Centred or Non-
directive approaches in that it is therapist-directed, includes physical contact, involves parents in the process
whenever possible, and is intended to be fun. This brief overview reviews the history of Theraplay, the principles
that guide it, its theoretical foundation in Object Relations and Attachment Theory (now supported by recent
findings in neurobiology), and notes recent scientific research that strongly supports its efficacy. Illustrations are
given from clinical practice. Keywords: Theraplay, play therapy, attachment, research, depression in children,
attention deficit, selective mutism, oppositional defiance, autistic spectrum, divorce.
The Beginnings: A Challenge Jernberg had been inspired by the work of Austin
Des Lauriers, a psychiatrist who sought new
Among the social innovations of the 1960s in the approaches in working with autistic children (Des
United States were two early intervention programs: Lauriers & Carlson, 1969). For example, he would
the Children’s Television Workshop (which block their attempts to leave his presence and he
invented Sesame Street) and Head Start, a pre- sometimes sang to them in an effort to
school program for underprivileged children. Early communicate. Viola Brody, also a student of Des
in the development of Head Start, a consulting Lauriers, contributed to the strategies developed by
psychologist, Ted Hurst, was awarded a contract to Jernberg (Jernberg, 1990; Brody, 1993). Jernberg
provide psychological services for the Chicago and her colleagues were able to accomplish
program. A great many of the preschoolers in Head something remarkable with the Head Start
Start presented with serious mental health issues, preschoolers: they developed a short-term (usually
often manifested in social withdrawal/depression or about fifteen weeks) intervention that seemed to
over activity/aggression. Hurst was concerned that offer the child alternatives to the withdrawn or
these children be provided direct services; rather overactive coping strategies. Thus Theraplay was
than merely be categorized while interventions were brought to birth. After Jernberg’s death, her long-
sought via the public mental health system. He time colleague, Phyllis Booth, wrote the second
needed an approach that worked quickly and edition of the essential Theraplay textbook
effectively (Myrow, 2000b). (Jernberg & Booth, 1999). Booth continues to
contribute to the development of the approach
Hurst appointed Ann Jernberg as Clinical Director. through her work at the Theraplay Institute.
1 The appellation “Theraplay” is a registered service mark of the Theraplay Institute. Early in its history, this was done as a way to ensure
that practitioners using the method were actually professionally trained in this specific approach. The intention is to make sure that the
techniques are used ethically, appropriately, and correctly. The Institute maintains control of the service mark and its use.
THERAPLAY: AN INTRODUCTION 15
2 In this approach, the therapist assumes increased responsibility for the therapeutic effort and may use unconventional techniques such as
paradoxical interventions. (For example, to a child who kicks off his shoe while entering the playroom, the therapist comments, “Wow! You
have strong legs!”)
16 THERAPLAY: AN INTRODUCTION
and a bandage, and sends him back to play adults living in group homes and their key workers.
(assuming no stitches are needed!). Grandmother The approach can help inform any therapist about
makes treats for after school snacks. the dynamics in relationships in a systematic way.
Some social workers and psychologists have
Challenge described to the author how they are including
MIM analyses as part of custody recommendations
The parent notices the child’s budding capacities in divorces.
and provides situations to help them develop.
Parents hold the infant upright when beginning to One of the most helpful aspects of the MIM is that
walk and then reach out to coax the toddler to it permits a focussed investigation of the attachment
venture his first independent steps. The five-year- relationship. This suggests specific ways that the
old is taught to tie his own shoelaces. By therapist might intervene. The MIM provides a
accomplishing ‘just-enough challenges’, children bridge from our theoretical understanding of a
start to feel competent and develop self-confidence. child’s development to actual relationship processes.
For example Attachment Theory3 has guided
Jernberg’s model has always seemed elegant and attention to the role that affective attunement plays
brilliant. The reader is challenged to identify a in the early child-parent relationship (Stern, 1985;
parental role or corresponding child need that Schore, 2001). Simply put, a caregiver’s astute
doesn’t seem to be covered by at least one of the recognition and responsiveness to a child’s commu-
dimensions. The model guides the therapist’s nications (nonverbal information is probably most
diagnostic and prescriptive thinking, as the reader important, even as the child matures) promote
will see below. This thoughtful scheme can be a neurobiological and psychological developments
guide when working with clients of any age, that are most likely to help the child relate to others
including adults. One asks, when working with an in a rewarding way. Thus she comes to feel worthy
adult, “what does this client seem to have missed and competent to meet life’s challenges (Siegel,
growing up in his family, and how is this manifested 1999 & 2003). If however the caregiver regularly
now in relationships?” fails to recognize and respond to the child
empathically, misattunement arises and various
problems in functioning can occur (Siegel, 2003).
The Marschak Interaction Method For example, a mother with postpartum depression
(MIM): An Assessment Tool for may not have the wherewithal to respond to her
Understanding Parent-Child Interaction child. Or a child may be born with a painful
physical condition that so preoccupies her
To assess these different aspects of a child-parent consciousness that she does not experience a parent’s
relationship, Jernberg developed the Marschak loving efforts to care for her.
Interaction Method analysis (MIM). In the MIM, a
child and her parent sit adjacent to each other at a These early caregiver-child interactions form
small table. The two of them engage in eight or memories that evolve into patterns of expectation
nine activities while the therapist observes, usually about relationships with others. When a child’s
via a one-way window, and makes a video. The behaviour is dysregulated or profoundly self-
tasks are selected to elicit the concerns that have defeating, we may suspect issues in the early
been identified in the initial interview. MIMs can attachment relationship. The therapeutic challenge
be done with a variety of caregivers, for example, is how to set the stage so that the child might be able
with children and grandparents or with young to come to a different sense of himself.
3 For a fascinating overview of the work and lives of Bowlby and the other Attachment Theorists, the reader is referred to Robert Karen’s
(1998) delightful volume.
THERAPLAY: AN INTRODUCTION 17
Theraplay as a Way to Reach Troubled • Parents are included in the assessment and
Children the treatment process, and are encouraged to bring
what they learn into interactions at home.
In creating Theraplay, Jernberg hoped to reach back
to the innate capacity of the child in order to A Protocol for Treatment
encourage a more positive sense of herself to
develop. Jernberg hoped that hands-on, physical Unlike early Child Centred and Psychoanalytic
experiences resembling those enjoyed by healthy, approaches, Theraplay considered the role of
typical parent-child dyads would provide a more attachment figures from the beginning. Soon after
direct way for troubled children and their parents to Jernberg began to develop the approach, she saw the
generate healthy interactions. value of including parents in the process (Jernberg
and Booth, 1999). In her initial work with families,
As Theraplay evolved, a number of characteristics Jernberg had two therapists involved in a treatment
began to distinguish it from traditional methods: session:
• The focus is on healthy parent-child 1) the child’s therapist, who worked one-on-one
relationships rather than on the child’s pathology or with the child in the playroom, and
internal processes. 2) the interpreting therapist, who joined the
• The therapist is in charge of the session, parents in observing the work via a one-way
planning and organizing the experiences to meet the window, in an adjacent room.
child’s needs.
• The activities are designed to meet the child’s This method continues to be utilized by the
emotional stage of development rather than the Theraplay Institute. It allows parents to learn about
child’s physical age. Therefore many games have a their child and to understand what the child’s
regressive aspect. Nevertheless, these experiences are therapist is attempting to do. The focus is usually
designed to meet the child’s unresolved early needs on strengths and also on the child’s efforts to get
while remaining ego-syntonic with the child’s his/her needs met. This intensive approach is not
current sense of herself. always practical. Many practitioners (including the
• The treatment includes physical, interactive, author) utilize an alternative format in which the
emotionally attuned play. This helps with building therapist works with the child for the first half of a
attachment as well as developing self-regulation. session, then meets with the parents for the second
• The therapist (not a toy or symbolic item) is the half and shows them a video of the play session.
main playroom object. The therapist utilizes the This allows discussion of the activities used with the
child’s nonverbal behaviour to make physical and child and permits therapist and parents to review
emotional contact throughout the session. the child’s needs and efforts toward the goals.
• Immediacy is central: the focus is on the
experience at the moment rather than on history, As presently practised in agencies and private
pretend play, or interpretations. therapy settings, the protocol for a course of Family-
based Theraplay is as follows:
• Nurturing touch is a natural and integral aspect
of the interaction. In this Theraplay guided by the
1) Initial interview with parents;
wealth of research in the past few decades
2) MIM with each parent;
detailing the essential role that touch plays in
3) Feedback session with parents to review the
healthy physical and emotional development (Field,
MIM videos and build a treatment plan;
1995; Mäkelä, 2003, 2005). Great care is taken to
4) Individual Theraplay, with parents observing
ensure that touch is used respectfully and that it is
directly or via video;
geared to the treatment plan.
18 THERAPLAY: AN INTRODUCTION
5) Family Theraplay, with parents joining the At the first meeting, with Tony’s parents, a careful
session; social history was obtained, including the physical
6) Termination; history, the quality of relationships with adults and
7) Post-treatment check-up/s (after a few months other children, school progress, and involvement in
or over the course of a year). organized activities. In discussing Tony, special
attention was given to looking at the care history.
The length of treatment can vary from about fifteen Also, the therapist wanted to know what it was like
sessions for the more typical case, to two or more to live with this boy; what the parents had tried in
years with severely attachment-disordered or their efforts to reach him; what specific behaviours
traumatized children. were problematic; what did his parents perceive as
his strengths; and how they played and had fun
Theraplay in Other Settings together. Given the history, the therapist also
provided some psychological education for the
Some situations require a departure from this parents, reframing some of the acting out behaviour.
protocol. For example, social workers, For example, Tony’s ambivalence might reflect his
psychologists, speech and occupational therapists desire for emotional closeness and fear of it. Mum
often use Theraplay in schools, where they may not was given support for her sadness at not having been
have ready access to parents. able to be more available to Tony when he was very
young. The main focus however was on what could
be done now to help. Finally the principles of
Tony: A Hypothetical Seven-year-old Theraplay, including the idea that unresolved
Two-year-Old regressive needs can often be addressed even in older
children, were offered to help them start to think
In order to illustrate the application of Theraplay in about a process that could help their son get better.
clinical practice, we will consider the case of The stage was set for the Marschak Interaction
“Tony,” a composite of cases seen by the author. Method analysis.
Seven-year-old Tony, in an intact family, had started
Day Care at six weeks when his Mum’s employer For the first MIM, Mum and Tony were seated next
required that she return to full time work. She to each other behind a small table. Mum was given
regretted this, having stayed at home for a few years a stack of instruction cards. She was asked to read
after the birth Tony’s older brother. The parents the directions for each activity aloud first and to
changed Tony’s care arrangements twice: when he decide at what point to commence each task. The
was 9 months for logistical reasons, and again at 27 therapist then retired to the other side of the one-
months because they felt that the care was not way window and gave the signal for Mum to start.
attentive and warm enough. By the time that they
brought him for treatment, Tony avoided physical The first activity invited Mum and Tony to have
closeness, and had tantrums whenever he couldn’t two toy animals play together. As soon as Mum
get his way. He broke many of his toys, and read the directions, Tony took his toy and “bopped”
sometimes took others’ things. Family outings to Mum’s with it. Mum asked him not to do this, but
parks and restaurants were often disastrous: Tony he repeated the bopping. Mum then suggested they
might bully other young children or refuse to sit still have a race. This helped Tony to calm down. The
for a simple meal together. His parents had had few two then engaged in seven additional MIM tasks. A
problems raising his twelve-year-old brother, and week later, Dad and Tony came for the second
were perplexed about Tony’s behaviour. How might MIM. The first task was for the two to “put hats on
one conceptualize these concerns and intervene as each other.” Dad put a nice baseball hat on his son,
expeditiously as possible to help Tony and his family attempting to look him in the eye. Tony avoided
grow together and enjoy life? eye contact, and, laughing, grabbed a lady’s hat and
THERAPLAY: AN INTRODUCTION 19
put it on Dad. Dad put away the box of hats and To accomplish these goals, the following methods
went on to the next of his eight activities. were planned:
Reviewing the videos with the parents, observations A. Individual and then Family Theraplay,
were organized along the SENC dimensions. For including psycho-educational work with Mum and
example, even though he sometimes resisted, Tony Dad to help them develop management strategies at
became calmer and focussed more when parents home that coordinated with the Theraplay sessions.
structured and took charge of the activities. B. Coordination with school personnel, to help
Although they offered eye contact, he seldom them understand Tony’s behaviour and support the
returned it. He seemed to crave nurturing but work.
defended against their efforts to provide it. In the
few cases when they persisted in challenging him to Theraplay begins
try a slightly frustrating task, he gave up too easily.
The parents started to see that this was an anxious Child-centred play therapy practitioners are usually
boy whose negative and avoidant behaviour kept surprised to find that there are few toys visible in the
him from what he really wanted and needed. Tony playroom. When using Theraplay, the therapist is
in some ways behaved like a rapprochement-stage the primary “object” in the room, and the focus is
child who was struggling for autonomy (Mahler, on how child and therapist interact.
Pine & Bergman, 1975). He threw tantrums when
frustrated, yet tried to engage his parents but always In the waiting room Tony alternated between sitting
on his terms rather than theirs. He was highly at a table working on a puzzle and coming over to
ambivalent and constantly tried to control his Mum’s chair, asking her when the session would
situations to make sure his needs were met. He was begin. This behaviour resembled that of a two and a
full of shame generated by his negative attention half year old who plays independently, then
seeking, which brought endless “corrections” from sporadically checks in with Mum for “refuelling.”
teachers and an inconsistent combination of The therapist took Tony’s hand and they headed to
punishments and indulgences from his perplexed the playroom. Once there, it was explained that
parents. When the therapist explained that, though shoes were to be removed. Tony kicked off his
Tony was seven-years-old physically, he was mostly sneakers and lunged toward a beanbag chair.
two-years-old emotionally, Mum and Dad started to However the therapist kept holding his hand and
make more sense of his behaviour. The therapist carried Tony over to the beanbag chair. It was
and they devised treatment goals designed to reach explained that a video would be made for parents to
out to the toddler in Tony and help him move on see later so that they could learn some of the games
developmentally: that were to be played. The therapist stated the two
rules of the playroom: “First, No one gets hurt –
• Tony will be comfortable with emotional neither You (gently touching Tony’s chest) nor I.
intimacy and be able to have fun with his parents Second, Everybody has as much fun as possible!”
and others. His laughter will be genuine. Tony smiled, perhaps relieved that this wasn’t going
• Tony will accept clear, consistent, firm limits to be all torture or a “lecture session” from an adult.
from adults.
• Tony will accept nurture from his parents end Then the therapist performed a “check-in.” The
enjoy his role as a child in the family. therapist pointed to the boy’s very dark brown eyes,
• Tony will be able to manage frustration “even darker than mine!” (a move, which caused
appropriate for his age and increase self- regulation Tony to look at the therapist’s eyes for a moment).
generally. He will be able to ride out challenges. Appealing to the seven-year-old part of him, the
His parents will look to provide just enough therapist counted Tony’s fingers: “Let’s see, there
challenge to stretch him developmentally. should be 10, right? 10-9-8-7-6 on this side and 1-
20 THERAPLAY: AN INTRODUCTION
2-3-4-5 on this hand. Hmmm – 11!” The therapist The next activity was a Staring Contest. Therapist
smelled his hair (lovely!) and felt how soft it was. and child sat cross-legged, with knees touching. The
They checked to see if Tony could touch his chin therapist gently held Tony’s shoulders and Tony put
with his tongue. It was noted that when Tony his hands on the therapist’s arms. This provided –
smiled, he made dimples. The therapist used his literally - a “holding environment”! When the signal
fingers like a callipers to show Tony how his biceps was given, each tried to keep eyes open the longest.
became bigger when he pointed his fists toward his
ears rather than forward. The therapist noticed that The last activity was Guess the Goodies, an activity
Tony had a little bruise on a forearm, and put a drop that helps build trust. Still sitting with knees
of lotion on it - then more lotion for a scratch on his touching, an envelope was brought out with Tony’s
hand. When his toes were counted, Tony name on it. The therapist said, “There are some
unexpectedly pulled off a sock to show a bruise on delicious goodies in this envelope. Close your eyes
his shin. This “invitation” was most fortuitous, and I’ll put one in your mouth, and then you can
because then the therapist took his feet and used open your eyes and tell me what it is.” Tony quickly
them to “pop” the therapist’s inflated cheeks, which guessed when he was fed an M&M, but then Tony
led to some very hearty, baby-like laughs, and a became resistant. He would accept another morsel
chance to play This Little Piggy. In sum: within the (perhaps a jelly bean or tiny cookie), but
first few minutes of his first Theraplay session, it immediately take it out and examine it. It was
was possible to get this typically unhappy, tempting to say, “no, you can’t look, you’re breaking
uncooperative boy engaged in activities that the rules.” Instead, the therapist commented, “Oh,
identified some of his delightful qualities and I see you wanted to know for sure what it was.” A
engaged core affect. correction would have added to Tony’s shame
experiences.
From this initial activity, the therapist applied lotion
to his and Tony’s arms and initiated a Slippery Arm Meeting with Parents
Game (each player has to try to pull the other over
to his side), followed by a Hopping Race. Tony Tony then waited in the playroom, while his parents
loved winning the first race. However, for the viewed the video of the session. The parents saw
second race, he became dysregulated, jumped the how Tony responded to the regressive experiences
gun for the “start,” and had to be called back for a by becoming calm and engaged. The Staring
re-start. This gentle, firm insistence on adult-in- Contest was role-played so that parents could try
charge is a big part of Theraplay. It is an important this at home. This format continued over the next
contributor in rehearsal for regulation of affect. five meetings.
eating game would occur later in the session, but behaviour, or oppositionality, Theraplay can work
that didn’t satisfy him. He folded his arms and very quickly and effectively by itself. When
pouted. After Hughes (1999), the therapist children present with other situations – divorce or
interpreted (not usually a Theraplay move), “I loss of a caregiver, for example - Theraplay activities
wonder if you’re angry that we can’t do exactly what can quickly build trust and comfort, making it
you want right now. Maybe you think I don’t like easier to utilize more traditional, Child-Centred or
you if I won’t let you do it right now.” This was Cognitive methods. Theraplay has great utility with
successful, and so it was possible to move on to the children who have Autistic Spectrum and Pervasive
next game, Tunnels. Developmental Disorders (Bundy-Myrow, 2000).
Group Theraplay (Rubin & Tregay, 1989), which
For Tunnels, the three adults made parallel arches. has had wide application in school classroom
On the signal, Tony had to crawl through before the settings, has also been used with children with
count ended and the tunnels collapsed. On Autistic Spectrum disorders.
succeeding crawls the number of counts was
reduced, so that Tony’s parents eventually caught Research on Efficacy
him in warm hugs. Moving to a quieter game with
a large Nurturing component, Mum and Dad sat Clinicians who use Theraplay have reported success
facing each other, with Tony in Dad’s lap. Mum with even the most challenging cases (cf. Munns,
played Guess the Goodies. This gave Tony a chance 2000; Mäkelä, 2005; Koller and Booth, 1997;
to have a feeding experience with his Mum, to Lindaman and Haldeman, 1994, as well as
renew and extend intimacy and nurturing from the numerous articles in the Theraplay Institute
early years, and with Dad symbolically and literally Newsletter). Mäkelä and Vierikko (2004) have
holding him. reported systematic assessment of Theraplay with
disadvantaged children and their families. Franke
This session concluded with a Blanket Swing. Tony and Wettig in Germany have done by far the most
lay in a folded blanket, facing his parents while the comprehensive and robust assessment. In a
therapist took the opposite end and they slowly controlled, longitudinal study conducted between
rocked their seven-year-old, singing, “Twinkle, 1998 and 2005, sixty children diagnosed with both
twinkle, little star. What a handsome boy you are! speech-language and severe behaviour disorders
Dark brown eyes and very smart. We love you with were given Theraplay treatment and compared to
all our heart!” At first, Tony wiggled in the blanket, thirty non-symptomatic children over time. A much
even turned over to hide his eyes. By the third time, larger, multi-centre study looked at the results of
he was looking into his parents’ eyes and seemed Theraplay treatment conducted in nine different
quite relaxed. settings, including a centre for early intervention, a
kindergarten in a socially impoverished area, a
The Many Applications of Theraplay family therapy psychology practice, and practices
for speech-language pathologists. The children
This case is an example of Theraplay with a child ranged in age from two years and six months to six
whose changes in caregivers in his early years years-11 months. Presenting problems included
probably played a part in developing insecure attention deficit, oppositional defiance, shyness,
attachments with his parents. Theraplay has many social anxiety, selective mutism, lack of social
more applications. Although it is used most often mutuality and aggressiveness. Assessment included
with pre-schoolers to early teens, elements of tabulation of 53 symptoms seen as relevant to
Theraplay can be utilized with older teens and even Theraplay intervention. The findings (reported in
with geriatric clients. In day-to-day practice, where Wettig, Franke, and Fjordbak, 2006) showed
most of the children experience problems of over consistently strong effects. Problems seen as having
activity, depression, obsessive-compulsive a more biological basis (e.g., attention deficit
22 THERAPLAY: AN INTRODUCTION
problems and autistic-spectrum concerns) had Developmental Play Therapy. Treasure Island,
strong and statistically significant effects, but to a Florida: Developmental Play Training Associates.
somewhat more modest degree. The authors rate
their research on standards written by the American Bundy-Myrow, S. (2000). Group Theraplay for
Psychiatric Association for evidence-based children with Autism and Pervasive Developmental
treatment; based on these criteria, their work Disorder. In E. Munns (Ed.), Theraplay: Innovations
appears to be robust and compelling. in Attachment-Enhancing Play Therapy (pp 301-
320). Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson.
Theraplay is a very different approach from what
most of us have learned in our training. The Des Lauriers, A. & Carlson, C.F. (1969). Your
conceptual scheme is based on Attachment Theory Child is Asleep – Early Infantile Autism: Etiology,
and the clinical approach is physical, therapist- Treatment, and Parental Influence. Homewood,
directed, affectively engaging – and aims to be fun! Illinois: Dorsey
It is not possible to learn how to do Theraplay from
reading a book. Experiential training is the only Field, T.M. (1995). Touch in Early Development.
way to really “get it,” and to see how powerful it can NJ: Laurence Ehrlbaum Associates
be. Since it makes emotional and even a few
physical demands (comfort with touch, for Haley, J. (1973). Uncommon Therapy: the Psychiatric
example) on the therapist, it is not every one’s cup Techniques of Milton H. Erickson, M.D. New York:
of tea. However, in the author’s own training, and Norton.
in many years of training colleagues, it has been a
very pleasant surprise to find how many people Hughes, Daniel A. (1999). Building the Bonds of
really take to Theraplay once they try it. Attachment. London: Jason Aronson.
Bowlby, J. (1969). Attachment and Loss. Vol.1: Lindaman, S. and Haldeman, D. (1994). Geriatric
Attachment. New York: Basic Books. Theraplay. In C.E. Schaefer and K.J. O’Connor
(Eds.), Handbook of Play Therapy, Vol. 2: Advances
Brody, V. A. (1993). The Dialogue of Touch: and Innovations. New York: Wiley.
THERAPLAY: AN INTRODUCTION 23
Lyons-Ruth, K. (1998). Implicit relational Siegel, Daniel J. (1999). The Developing Mind: How
knowing: its role in development and psychoana- Relationships and the Brain Interact To Shape Who We
lytic treatment. Infant Mental Health Journal, 19 Are. New York: Guilford Press
(3), pp 282-289.
Stern, D.N. (1985). The Interpersonal World of the
Mahler, M.S., Pine, F., and Bergman, A. (1975). Infant. New York: Basic Books.
The Psychological Birth of the Human Infant. New
York: Basic Books. Tronick, E. Z. (1998). Dyadically expanded states
of consciousness and the process of therapeutic
Mäkelä, J. (2003). What Makes Theraplay® change. Infant Mental Health Journal, 19 (3), pp
Effective: Insights from Developmental Sciences. The 290-299.
Theraplay® Institute Newsletter, Fall/Winter 2003.
Winnicott, D.W. (1957). Mother and Child. New
Mäkelä, J. (2005). The importance of touch in the York: Basic Books.
development of children. Finnish Medical Journal
60, pp 1543–9. Wettig, H.G., Franke, U., and Fjordbak, B.S.
(2006). Evaluating the effectiveness of Theraplay.
Mäkelä, J. and Vierikko, I. (2004). From heart to In Schaefer, C.E. and Kaduson, H.G.,
heart: Interactive therapy for children in care: Report Contemporary Play Therapy (pp 103-135). New
on the Theraplay project in SOS Children’s Villages in York: Guilford Press.
Finland 2001-2004. Billrothstr. 22A-1190 Vienna,
Austria: SOS-Kinderdorf International
Chris Daniel-McKeigue
Abstract
There is limited research available within the field of play therapy to draw upon when formulating a research
investigation. The author suggests that it is advisable to consult the development of research design within the
wider field of the arts therapies. It is acknowledged that quantitative methods have earned respect as credible
approaches to research within this genre. Alternatively it is recognised that a qualitative approach may be
efficacious for certain investigations within the creative arts therapies. The particular benefits of working within
a qualitative paradigm are explored: the affinity with the therapeutic medium; the utilisation of the therapist’s
skills; the opportunity to use a combination of approaches within the design; the concept of bricolage; the ability
to triangulate data and the more complex concept of crystallisation. The application of these principles are
applied to the author’s own investigation which uses a heuristic framework to discover more about the nature of
change within play therapy. In the spirit of heuristic research the author invites readers to respond to the ideas
within this paper and would welcome correspondence via letter or Email. Keywords: arts therapies, heuristic,
methodology, play therapy, qualitative research, researcher-practitioner, art-based, arts-based.
Introduction: the impetus to the search for Play therapy as a creative arts therapy
an appropriate methodology within play
therapy When designing a research study a researcher would
naturally draw inspiration and seek direction from
The author is conducting a research study, previous investigations. However play therapy is an
supported by the NHS North West Region emerging profession without a strong research
Research and Development Directorate, to tradition, and previous evaluation in the field both
elucidate how play therapists perceive change in the within the United Kingdom (Carroll, 2000, 2001;
play therapy dynamic with children. Consulting Daniel-McKeigue, 2004) and internationally is
with therapists is regarded as a first step toward scant (Broomfield, 2003; LeBlanc & Ritchie,
establishing what effect play therapy has on child 2001). To provide guidance on how to examine the
clients. It is hoped that this will help identify an process of play therapy through the discipline of
appropriate assessment tool that can be used to research I would suggest that we may learn from the
monitor the progress of therapy. This would be experience of other investigators involved in
useful on an individual basis with clients and on a therapies particularly those working with children
larger scale to conduct outcome studies that would and within the arts therapies.
document the efficacy of the play therapy approach.
Play therapy is not always included in the definition
PLAYING IN THE FIELD OF RESEARCH 25
of the ‘arts therapies’; this is a generic term that is likely to consider themselves as artists in the same
used to describe a variety of arts therapy way that an art therapist, dramatherapist or music
practitioners. Cattanach, editor of ‘Process in the therapist may have a particular skill within a certain
Arts Therapies’ (1999), uses the term to include art craft. Nevertheless play therapists do share the
therapists, dance therapists, dramatherapists, music media of the creative arts therapies within their
therapists and play therapists. However, within the approach, for example image making, role-play,
same publication Barham (1999) outlines that the voice and percussion.
only officially recognised Arts Therapists within the
Council for Professions Supplementary to Medicine For the purpose of this paper I propose to consult
(CPSM) are Art, Drama and Music. Now known as other therapy practitioners, primarily those who
the Health Professions Council (HPC), this also rely on the creative arts as the principle means
regulatory body (at June 2006) recognises that the of communication. I will use the term ‘arts
arts therapy profession has four protected titles, art therapist’ in the spirit of Cattanach and McNiff to
therapist, art psychotherapist, dramatherapist and embrace a wide range of creative art therapy
music therapist. In a previous publication that practitioners including play therapy.
summarised the available research within the arts
therapies Payne (1993) does not acknowledge play Quantitative versus qualitative research
therapy and focuses on art, drama, dance movement
and music therapies. In contrast, American writer It is vital that the practice of play therapy is
McNiff (1998) is inclusive in his definition of the underpinned with research and proves to be
arts therapies. He outlines an arts-based approach evidence-based. It is important that investigation is
to research and does not specify the limits of the not intrusive to the client’s therapeutic process but
definition but collectively describes the creative art takes place in harmony with clinical work (Daniel-
therapies as ‘an outgrowth of psychology’s aesthetic McKeigue, 2004). In 1993 Junge and Linesch
aspect’ (p.15). outlined that hitherto art therapy researchers had
relied on traditional quantitative research methods.
Play therapists themselves may not necessarily They exhorted practitioners to move away from the
regard their practice as an arts therapy. Currently empirical studies that had been regarded as
(at June 2006) the British Association of Play ‘legitimizing’ the profession and embrace new
Therapists (BAPT) is seeking professional paradigm research. Postmodern thinking has
validation by either the HPC or the United challenged the underlying philosophy of
Kingdom Council for Psychotherapy (UKCP). quantitative paradigms and given birth to
There is some dispute as to the most appropriate qualitative approaches that focus on the
category: arts therapy or child therapy. I would investigation of experience as well as effect. Driven
suggest that play therapists are ambivalent about by philosophies such as humanism and feminism it
their profession being regarded as an arts therapy is conceivable that within qualitative design the
and I would go further to propose that they may be research can be adapted to and congruent with the
more inclined for it to be recognised as a child phenomenon being investigated. Linesch (1994)
psychotherapy. Similarly other arts therapies also compares the ‘subjective, open-ended, intuitive and
have an allegiance to psychotherapy, for example qualitative’ nature of art therapy practice and
dramatherapists continue to debate whether this contrasts it with the attempts to research the process
should be integrated into their title in the same way that are generally ‘objective, narrowly focussed,
as art psychotherapists (British Association of empirical and quantitative’ (p.185). Arts therapists
Dramatherapists (BADth) Conference 2005) are familiar with the struggle for acceptance of their
therapeutic approach within the psychological
I would suggest that play therapists differ from the therapies; perhaps practitioners are wary of
other arts therapy professions in that they are less repeating this conflict within the field of research,
26 PLAYING IN THE FIELD OF RESEARCH
concluding that if an ‘acceptable’ methodology is quadrupeds that chanted ‘four legs good, two legs
selected then the therapeutic approach will be bad’ (p.4), asserting the supremacy of one state of
ratified. being to the detriment of another. It is in fact not
necessary to prove that one paradigm is superior to
Within ten years of Junge and Linesch’s recommen- another or even to establish their equality, but rather
dation the investigative tide may have changed. to recognise the merits of each approach and their
Barham (2003) identifies that qualitative benefit for certain investigations.
approaches are frequently the methodological
approach of choice for arts and play therapy Describing the situation within child psychotherapy
researchers within the School of Psychology and Midgely (2004) uses a vivid description of two
Therapeutic Studies at Roehampton University. Greek sea monsters, Charybdis and Scylla, who each
This is apparently synchronous with their lie on either side of a strait, in trying to avoid one
psychological counsellor counterparts and in you are sure to become victim to the other. He
contrast to their psychology colleagues within the draws comparison to opposing standpoints within
deanery (Barham, personal communication by the profession and proposes that in the same way
email 13.01.2006). In parallel, within the world of that Jason and the Argonauts managed to navigate
child psychotherapy Midgely (2004) highlights a between them, qualitative approaches can offer an
small but significant change in the research culture alternative course between ‘the Scylla of large-scale
that is beginning to embrace the qualitative quantitative research and the Charybdis of the
paradigm and notes a small number of published clinical case study’ (p.92).
research articles in this style since 2003. He
attributes this change to a shift within academic By sailing too close to the dominant ideologies
institutions that have begun to support such of evidence-based practice and the logic of the
methodologies within their clinical awards. randomized control trial we risk losing what
is most distinctive and most central to the
However the credibility of research may continue to psychoanalytical approach. Yet if we steer too
be associated with what Junge and Linesch (1993) far the other way, and insist on maintaining
describe as ‘the single predominant paradigm of an exclusive reliance on our traditional
Western science, positivism and the empirical, methods of ‘clinical wisdom’, we are at risk.
quantitative model’ (p.61). This is exemplified by (p.91)
Kim, Ryu, Hwang and Kim (2005) who state that
they recognise the ‘empirical, heuristic and
Whilst it has been demonstrated that qualitative
subjective nature of current art psychotherapy
approaches are emerging, their validity continues to
methods’ (p.59). Their pictorial representation of
be a topic of debate and is played out on many
an arts therapy researcher in a white laboratory coat
stages. McLeod (2001) suggests that they remain
(2005, Fig.1) seems an incongruous image, and
on the ‘margins of the counselling and
does little to convey their confessed understanding
psychotherapy research enterprise’ (p.14). Within
of a practitioner/researcher. Kim et al propose an
the health sciences Mays and Pope have made a
‘expert system’ (p.59) based on a computer
significant contribution to promoting the merits of
programme of diagnosis that will assist art
qualitative approaches and their application. In
psychotherapy research. However it is likely that in
1995 they published a series of articles to address
systematically unifying theories they will overlook
the resistance to the acceptance of such
and lose the individual detail and variation in
methodologies in the British Medical Journal (BMJ)
human experience. In contrast qualitative
(Mays & Pope, 1995a; 1995b; Pope & Mays, 1995)
approaches would highlight such nuances. In the
and again in 2000 they are series editors of a set of
spirit of Animal Farm (Orwell, 1946) there is a
articles with a similar agenda (Mays & Pope, 2000;
danger that we will fall into the same trap as the
PLAYING IN THE FIELD OF RESEARCH 27
Pope, Ziebland & Mays, 2000; Meyer 2000). The health on music practitioners and concludes that
proof of the pudding will be in the publishing; the ‘music and music making can offer useful resources
acceptance of qualitative approaches will be for inquiry’ (p.8).
signified when journals such as the BMJ themselves
print substantial research articles in this modality. I would question whether a solely creative arts based
approach would have sufficient credibility to be
Qualitative and quantitative methodologies are not useful as a means of investigation. Arts-based
mutually exclusive; indeed both approaches could research is a method that would utilise, indeed
be married within a study (Pope & Mays, 1995). maximise the therapist’s skills but there could be a
Essentially it is important that a methodology is danger of collusion, by using an investigative tool
chosen that is an effective means of eliciting data, it that is so closely connected to the topic under
must also be in harmony with the needs of the investigation. Would the design offer sufficient
clients/participants involved and congruent with challenge and could the data be considered as
the focus of the study. Qualitative approaches do reliable or judged as having any degree of accuracy?
offer certain benefits to arts therapy researchers as Payne (1993) further suggests that arts based
such research design can be both sympathetic to the research would have little credibility outside of the
underlying philosophy of the creative arts and field. Whilst the randomised control trial may no
therapies and also promote ethical practice. longer be the gold standard of research practice,
However to what extent should practitioners qualitative methodologies that endeavour to
incorporate the ‘framework of artistic experience’ elucidate the nature of experience still struggle for
(Grainger, 2001, p.11), that is so important to arts- recognition alongside the more traditionally
based researchers and arts therapists, within the accepted quantitative approaches (Pope & Mays,
methodology? 1995). This is supported by my own experience of
submitting a qualitative based study to an NHS
research ethics committee. It was reviewed by a
Art-based and arts-based research
group whose principle expertise was within a
Proponents of art-based research1 argue that arts quantitative paradigm, which influenced their
therapists do not need to look outside of their judgement and opinion of my proposal.
profession to find congruous research models since
the discipline itself is intrinsically valid as an Malchiodi (1995) proposes that art therapists’
investigative method of enquiry. McNiff (1998), understanding of the therapeutic process is borne
an advocate of art-based research, describes that from their own experience of the ‘powerful and
whilst he is sympathetic to the philosophy of personally fulfilling experience of artmaking’
qualitative research, particularly hermeneutic, (p.155) therefore she concludes that:
phenomenological or heuristic models, he is also
satisfied with the validity of the creative arts as a identifying the efficacy of art therapy will
research methodology in itself. He cites numerous come from deeper understanding and
examples of therapists, many involved in graduate exploration of media, the art process and
studies, who have used their therapeutic medium as therapeutic space, and how we define these as
the means of investigation. This viewpoint is also artists. The answers to our search will not
supported within other non-therapy arts disciplines, come from our clinical expertise alone, but
for example Daykin (2004) endorses an arts-based rather from our knowledge of art and from an
research2 approach that has a similar philosophy. She intimate, personal connection to our own
utilises musical expression as a research tool in her artmaking. (p.156)
consideration of the impact of insecurity and ill
1 Art-based research is a term adopted by therapy practitioners to describe the use of elements of the creative arts therapy experience
within an inquiry, see McNiff 1998.
2 Arts-based research describes inquiry that utilises a creative medium – but is not necessarily related to therapy.
28 PLAYING IN THE FIELD OF RESEARCH
It seems important that creative arts therapists description and the element of storytelling within a
embrace their art form and use their advanced case study approach that contributes to its
understanding and expertise to enhance the research effectiveness, he regards ‘artistry and the power of its
that they conduct. rhetoric’ (p.162) as key. Conversely it may be
suggested that it is this lack of objectivity and the
Therapy as research, research as therapy editing necessary to create a case study that
transforms it into a work of fiction. Newsom
Within the field of therapy it is also proposed that (1992) disputes the accounts of child clients
the process of therapy is itself research. Coming proffered by practitioners such as Axline, Klein and
from a Rogerian perspective O’Hara (1986) Winnicott by suggesting that they “seemed too neat
suggests that ‘client-centred therapy is, itself, a and the children too articulate: could the mute
heuristic investigation into the nature and meaning Dibs, after only a short time in therapy, really have
of human experience’ (p.174) in which the therapist uttered the poetic words ‘I am a builder of cities’?”
is engaged as a co-researcher. It is true that the (p.89).
processes and nature of both therapy and qualitative
research share some similarities; for example the Utilising a case study may not be as objective or
emphasis on self-reflection, the collaborative nature reliable as an investigative study may purport to be
of inquiry, the rich description and attention to since it is not subject to the rigours of a research
depth and detail. However does this journey of process, however it may still have some merit in
discovery offer the appropriate discipline and illustrating innovative practice. The Royal College
scrutiny necessary to be described as research? of Psychiatrists (2000) endorse a principle explained
by the Royal College of Physicians (1996) that
Case study as research understanding may emerge from clinical practice.
The original intention of the work may not be to
The process of therapy is often described by formulate research, however the implication is that
therapists in case studies which convey the practice the resulting knowledge may be equally significant.
and meaning of therapy; indeed much of the
innovatory work of pioneer psychotherapists in the The evolution of research from case study
early 1900’s, conducted by practitioners such as to formal investigation
Freud, Jung and Klein, was communicated by
publication of work in this format. This is a one Perhaps the focus on narrative case study within
sided depiction; rarely do clients tell their own story play therapy is consistent with the relative infancy
(Sands, 2000). Hitherto play therapy practitioners of the play therapy profession; as the discipline
in the United Kingdom have largely relied on the develops so may the research expertise evolve into
presentation of single cases to underpin their more formalised investigations. Such a progression
approach (Cattanach, 1992, 1994, 1999, 2003; seems to be mirrored in the other arts therapy
Carroll, 2000, 2001; Jennings, 1999; Ryan disciplines that are establishing an increasing
&Wilson, 1998; Wilson, Kendrick & Ryan, 1992). foundation of evidence-based practice. McLeod
However in contrast to the predecessors in adult (2001) supports this idea based on his observations
psychotherapy, contemporary play therapy of the development of the psychology and
practitioners are more reserved in what they publish psychotherapy professions and proposes that ‘there
and pay due regard to the ethical complexities of is a necessary relationship between the historical
describing interventions with clients as described by development of a profession or academic discipline
Polden (1998). and the methods of inquiry which it espouses’
(p.11). He describes the early stages as ‘formative’
McNiff (1998) suggests that it is the rich where the focus is on descriptive research that may
PLAYING IN THE FIELD OF RESEARCH 29
be compatible with an alternative learning style in the limited existing research in the field of play
which experimentation and playing are key, as therapy and the associated arenas of the arts
opposed to reliance on analytical thinking. There is therapies.
a danger that such resourcefulness may be regarded
as an inability to anticipate eventualities. However As there is not a custom-made methodology for arts
it is not always possible to predict the course of an therapy research, practitioner researchers need to
investigation and it may be helpful to be free to develop a bespoke research design that reflects the
respond to the development of the research process. particular needs of the study and is sympathetic to
A bricolage approach may not always be necessary the therapy and modality. Since a principle
or warranted; what is important is that such an consideration of this study was to preserve the
approach is beneficial to the study. In effect process of therapy and investigate the natural course
bricolage is not ‘making do’ but adopting the most of therapy without disturbing it, a non-invasive
effective approach for the investigation. design was necessary that would rely on the
therapist’s reflection on their practice. For this
I would also suggest that there may be some reason a qualitative methodology has been adopted
sympathy with the term bricolage to the play that will elucidate the nature of the experience
therapy approach itself. A play therapist needs to be rather than attempt to establish a ‘truth’ about the
a Jack (or more likely a Jill) of all trades in order to phenomenon.
respond to needs of the client, working with a
variety of media such as clay, paper, paint, Heuristic model
percussion, dressing up clothes. Indeed maybe
bricolage is the play therapist’s specialist craft. In In order to facilitate the self-reflection of the
the nature of being client-centred play therapists are primary researcher and to engage other therapists as
themselves a bricoleur or bricoleuse, a resourceful co-researchers to reflect on their own practice I have
and creative person. In collaboration with a child, elected to adopt a heuristic methodological
to facilitate expression and communication, they approach. The heuristic model, pioneered by
use play and art materials in new creative ways. It is Moustakas (1990, 1994), is informed by humanistic
perhaps natural that a client-centred practitioner philosophy which is compatible with and
would naturally conduct research in this bricoleur sympathetic to the therapeutic process. Indeed
fashion, becoming a ‘research-centred’ practitioner, Moustakas’ work has contributed to the
allowing an investigation to have an organic quality development of play therapy practice (Cattanach,
and freely respond to the demands of the study. 1992; Moustakas, 1997). This heuristic framework,
which has been used in a number of therapy based
Creating a bespoke methodological design studies (Atkins & Lowenthal, 2004; Fenner, 1996;
to investigate what therapists perceive as Moustakas, 1990; O’Hara, 1986), focuses on ‘a
process of internal search through which one
change in play therapy practice. discovers the nature and meaning of experience and
develops methods and procedures for further
In the light of the preceding discussion I will, in this investigation and analysis’ (Moustakas, 1990, p.9).
final section of the paper, consider the development Therapists are already accustomed to some of the
of my own investigation into how therapists investigative skills utilised in this approach within
perceive change within play therapy. It is important their practice, self- reflection, rapport building and
to acknowledge that this focuses on a singular communication skills for example. The
perspective and that the findings would need to be methodology also harnesses a creative approach that
clarified in the light of other research conducted is familiar to the arts therapist. During the sixth
with child clients, family, and other relevant parties. and final stage of the process, data is subject to a
The aim of this initial investigation was to build on creative synthesis that attempts to express the
32 PLAYING IN THE FIELD OF RESEARCH
essence of the findings and may take a number of The individual interviews have evolved and
forms such as poetry, sculpture, movement or incorporate a creative element; the interviewee is
music. A heuristic approach can satisfy the drive to invited to draw or describe an image or metaphor
produce credible research and also embrace the that symbolises change by expressing the child client
creativity and sensitivity of the play therapy before therapy and after closure. This has served as
approach, that arts based researchers would be keen a useful introduction to the interview; it uses the
to preserve. play therapist’s craft and allows for the creative
expression of tacit understanding which can be
The research will focus on working with a small difficult to communicate solely using language.
number of therapists, through individual
During the process of supervision it became
interviews, focus groups and diary keeping. Such
apparent that to truly investigate the question from
an investigation will generate data that is rich in
the therapist’s viewpoint it would be helpful to enter
description and that will contribute to the depth of
into the process of play therapy myself and witness
understanding. It will be the role of subsequent
the process from within. This developed into a
research, which may draw upon a quantitative
collaborative inquiry with another practitioner who
paradigm, to investigate the principles elucidated by
documented her process of being my therapist in a
this study and consider the breadth of their
research journal.
application.
To facilitate the process of creative synthesis, which
Anticipating the development of the study
could so easily be heavily influenced by a sole
researcher, a number of other arts professionals,
It was necessary to anticipate the development of
with specialisms in art therapy, music and dance
this investigation in an initial proposal that was
have worked with the raw data from the co-
submitted for funding from the North West
researchers and created their own visual image of the
Research and Development Directorate and for
tacit nature of the play therapy relationship.
registration as PhD research at Manchester
Metropolitan University. In addition the process of
Triangulation and crystallisation
applying for ethical approval from the NHS Central
Office for Research Ethical Committees (COREC)
These evolutionary elements of the investigation
required that the study be clearly described. Such
have further contributed to the process of
delineation could forestall the opportunity for
triangulation that hopefully will serve to strengthen
organic development of the process. However
the final depiction of the data. This maturation of
there is a degree to which the heuristic framework
the research is also indicative of crystallisation; the
itself facilitates flexibility and means that there is
research is growing, changing and altering as it
some capacity for the research to evolve in a living
develops, in the same way as a crystal may evolve
and natural way.
until a balance or equilibrium is reached. The
research process will be subject to further
Acting as a bricoleur
weathering and development. The result will be a
multidimensional investigation that will contribute
I would suggest that I have been able to be a
to the understanding of what therapists perceive as
research-focused practitioner and have drawn upon
change within the play therapy dynamic and which
my creative resourcefulness by acting as a bricoleur
may lead to further research and analysis.
in developing further strands to the investigation in
response to the changing demands of the research.
This has enhanced the original proposal and further Conclusion
contributed to the process of triangulation.
Consistent with a relatively youthful profession play
PLAYING IN THE FIELD OF RESEARCH 33
Cattanach, A. (1994). Play therapy where the sky Kim, S., Ryu, H., Hwang, J. & Kim, M, S. (2006).
meets the underworld. London: Jessica Kingsley An expert system approach to art psychotherapy.
Press. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 33(1), 59-75.
Cattanach, A. (Ed.). (1999). Process in the arts Linesch, D. (1994). Interpretation in art therapy
therapies. London: Jessica Kingsley Press. research and practice: The hermeneutic circle. The
Arts in Psychotherapy, 21(3), 185-195.
Cattanach, A. (2003). Introduction to play therapy.
East Sussex: Brunner-Routledge. LeBlanc, M. & Ritchie, M. (2001). A meta-analysis
of play therapy outcomes. Counselling Psychology
Daniel-McKeigue, C.J. (2004). Transforming Quarterly, 15(2), 149-163.
therapy into research. British Journal of Play
Therapy, 1(1), 47-55. McLeod, J. (2000). Qualitative research as
bricolage: Paper presented as an introduction to a
Daykin, N. (2004). The role of music in arts-based panel on: ‘Qualitative inquiry in action: Researcher
qualitative inquiry. International Journal of as bricoleur’ at the Society for Psychotherapy
Qualitative Methods, 3(2). Article 3. Retrieved Research Annual Conference, Chicago,
06.06.2004 from http://www.ualberta.ca/~iiqm/ 22.06.2000. Accessed 08.10.2005. http://
backissues/3_2/ html/daykin.html shs.tay.ac.uk/shtjm/Qualitative%20Research%20as
%Bricolage.html
Denzin, N.K. & Lincoln, Y.S. (Eds.). (2005). The
Sage handbook of qualitative research. London: McLeod, J. (2001). Qualitative research in
Sage. counselling and psychotherapy. London:Sage.
Dingwall, R., Murphy,E., Watson, P., Greatbatch, McNiff, S. (1998). Art-based research, London:
D. & Parker, S. (1998). Catching goldfish: Quality Jessica Kingsley Press.
in qualitative research. Journal Health Service
Research Policy, 3(3), 167-172. Fenner, P. (1996). Malchiodi, C. (1995). Studio approaches to art
Heuristic research study: Self-therapy using the therapy. Art Therapy: Journal of the American Art
brief image-making experience. The Arts in Therapy Association, 12(3), 154-156.
Psychotherapy, 23(1), 37-51.
Martineau, H. (1838). How to observe morals and
Grainger, R. (2001). Thoughts on the future of manners. In Dingwall, R., Murphy,E., Watson, P.,
dramatherapy research. Dramatherapy, 23(3), 9-11. Greatbatch, D. & Parker, S. (1998). Catching
goldfish: Quality in qualitative research. Journal
Jennings, S. (1999). Introduction to developmental Health Service Research Policy, 3(3),167-172.
playtherapy. London: Jessica Kingsley Press.
PLAYING IN THE FIELD OF RESEARCH 35
Mason, J. (2002). Researching your own practice: The Papert, S. (1994). The children’s machine: Rethinking
discipline of noticing. London: Routledge. school in the age of the computer. London: Harvester
Wheatsheaf.
Mays, N. & Pope, C. (1995a). Qualitative research:
Observational methods in health care settings. Payne, H. (Ed.), (1993). Handbook of inquiry in the
British Medical Journal, 311, 182-184. arts therapies: One river, many currents. London:
Jessica Kingsley Press.
Mays, N. & Pope, C. (1995b). Qualitative research:
Rigour and qualitative research. British Medical Polden, J. (1998). Publish and be damned. British
Journal, 311, 109-112. Journal of Psychotherapy, 14(3), 337-347.
Mays, N. & Pope, C. (2000). Qualitative research Pope, C. & Mays, N. (1995). Qualitative research:
in health care: Assessing quality in qualitative Reaching the parts other methods cannot reach: An
research. British Medical Journal, 320, 50-52. introduction to qualitative methods in health and
health services research. British Medical Journal,
Meyer, J. (2000). Qualiatative research in health 311, 42-45.
care: Using qualitative methods in health related
action research. British Medical Journal, 320, 178- Pope, C., Ziebland, S., & Mays, N. (2000).
81. Qualitative research in health care: Analysing
qualitative data. British Medical Journal, 320,
Midgley, N. (2004). Sailing between Scylla and 114–116.
Charybdis: Incorporating qualitative approaches
into child psychotherapy research. Journal of Child Richardson, L. (2000). Writing: A method of
Psychotherapy, 30(1), 89 – 111. inquiry. In Denzin, N.K., & Lincoln, Y.S. (Eds.),
Handbook Of Qualitative Research (2nd edition.),
Moustakas, C. (1997). Relationship play therapy. (pp923-948). London: Sage.
London: J. Aronson.
Rowan, J. (1993). Foreword. In Payne, H. (Ed.),
Moustakas, C. (1990). Heuristic research: Design, Handbook of inquiry in the arts therapies: One river,
methodology, and applications. London: Sage many currents (pp.ix-x). London: Jessica Kingsley
Publications. Press.
Abstract
This presentation aims to provide a case example of how play therapy can provide an effective therapeutic
intervention for trauma experienced by child survivors of natural disasters. It illustrates how play therapy can
assist psychological recovery. It describes the author’s work with a nine-year-old girl who experienced the tsunami
of 2004 and saw her sister swept away. Keywords: Non-directive play therapy, tsunami, trauma.
From the beginning, Norliza engaged with me From the second session onwards, as Norliza
Self-protection
Withdrawing Energy
from the Past and
Reinvesting in Other
Relationships
During the time when Penang was alerted to Dengue Fever, in February 2005, Norliza pretended to be the
doctor treating the patients with Dengue fever. She also drew a poster to alert people to the importance of
keeping the environment clean in order to get rid of the dengue mosquitoes. This is parallel to the child’s
pre-occupation with the thematic issue of protecting and guarding oneself against ‘natural disaster’, which
can be
unpredictable
and dangerous.
The drawings
that Norliza
made during
the sixth session
represents her
current family
re l a t i o n s h i p s
without her
deceased sister.
This suggests
that Norliza
was at the
fourth stage of
grief process,
able to re-
engage with
people around
her and
renegotiate her
c l o s e Poster: ‘Keep the Environment Clean’
re l a t i o n s h i p s
with her other sisters (Baker, Sedney & Gross, Norliza has depicted herself in black although the
1992). In the drawing with her two older sisters sisters are colourful. Perhaps the lack of colour in
Norliza & her youngest sister Norliza’s parents and the youngest sister
44 CHILD SURVIVOR OF THE TSUNAMI
comparison to her
older sisters may
represent Norliza’s
sense of loss of
her special
companion, while
her sisters still
have each other.1
Afterwards
1Although the lack of obvious hands in this picture may suggest helplessness, I feel that it probably signifies the long sleeves worn by
Moslem females to cover their arms.
CHILD SURVIVOR OF THE TSUNAMI 45
the involvement of extended family is usually active, The Efficacy of Play Therapy With Children: A
so probably she has been able to gain a sense of Meta-Analytic Review of Treatment Outcomes.
security not only from her parents and sisters but Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 36 (4),
from the closely-knit extended family as well. pp376-390.
Conclusion
British Association of Play Therapists, Internet
The play therapy provided Norliza a space to www page at URL: http://www.bapt.uk.com
express and contain her traumatic experience, to (accessed 04/11/06).
accept the loss and say goodbye to her beloved sister.
She showed repetitive play typical of trauma victims
during three of the sessions. She was given the Cattanach, A. (1992). Play Therapy with Abused
opportunity to acknowledge and express her pain, Children. Jessica Kingsley.
explore her thoughts and feelings about death and
dying while finding meaning in life and living. It
Eth, S. and Pynoos, R. S. (1985). Post-Traumatic
seems likely that her experience of close family
Stress Disorder in Children. American Psychiatric
relationships and community helped her to feel safe
Press.
enough to explore and resolve her trauma in a
relatively short time (although the normal grieving
process would clearly be expected to take its
Herman, J. L. (1992). Trauma and Recovery.
course). Bratton, Ray, Rhine & Jones (2005)
Pandora.
suggest that a small number of sessions could be
effective for children in crisis situations. This may
Jennings, S (1999). Introduction to Developmental
apply where there is likely to be a pre-existing
Play Therapy. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
baseline of security.
Joseph, S., Williams, R. and Yule, W. (1997).
Correspondence Understanding Post-Traumatic Stress. Wiley.
Baker, J., Sedney, M. and Gross, E. (1992). Webb, N. B. (1991). Play Therapy with Children in
Psychological Tasks for Bereaved Children. Crisis. New York & London: The Guilford Press.
American Journal of Orthopsychiatry. 62 (1), 105 –
115.
Angie Naylor
School of Education
Liverpool John Moores University
Abstract
This paper brings together various theoretical standpoints to highlight the key issues in research with children
engaged in therapy and the complexities this can involve. Children’s rights, power dynamics and their impact on
the research process can be understood within discourses of childhood. Trust between the child and
therapist/researcher is a further dynamic as well as issues of informed consent, gatekeepers, confidentiality and
the possible impact on the intervention. Whilst research into the process of Non-directive Play Therapy is
important, this needs to be understood and acknowledged within a multi-faceted child-centred framework.
Keywords: Non-directive play therapy, ethics, children.
Various professional bodies have issued ethical (1995) in Listening to Children provides an excellent
guidelines for research involving children. The consideration of issues surrounding participatory
British Medical Association (BMA) states that 15 research with children, as do Save the Children
professional bodies include reference to children’s (Neill, 2005).
consent to research (BMA, 2001). The British
Paediatric Association (renamed the Royal College Ethical considerations though can often make
of Paediatrics and Child Health (RCPCH) research with children, essentially in a clinical
published specific guidance on the conduct of setting, difficult. Issues of confidentiality,
medical research with children in 1992 and was anonymity and protection from harm can make it
revised by RCPCH in 2000. As Neill (2005) difficult for researchers who are outside of the
highlights, the guidelines are very medically based, playroom and play therapy process. However, a
focusing on research on children rather than with process that is essentially non-directive and free
them and importantly for NDPT, not considering from therapist intervention may find it difficult to
qualitative research, which usually involves small justify ‘intrusive’ research, i.e. in the form of
samples. There is a clear emphasis on physical risks administering scales or measurements within the
rather than potential psychological harm. playroom setting.
Fig 1: Six principles for research involving children Clearly, the way that a research project is planned
(RCPCH Ethics Advisory Committee, 2000) should prioritise the needs of the child client.
However, this in itself can cause complications. As
1. Research involving children is important to Daniel-McKeigue (2004) argues, there is the danger
benefit all children and should be conducted in an that a study that was designed to be sensitive to all
ethical manner. the issues may not significantly add to the body of
2. Children are not small adults; they have an knowledge, and the lack of research in this area
additional, unique set of interests. reflects the complexity of this issue. Alternatively
3. Research on children should only be done if the therapeutic method may be over-analysed to the
comparable research cannot be done on adults. extent that the natural process is ignored or missed.
4. Research not of direct benefit to the child is not
necessarily unethical or illegal. Research & Children’s Rights
5. All proposals involving medical research on
children should be referred to a research ethics Clearly, the current thinking around children can
committee. have a huge impact on our practice of research. As
6. Legally valid consent should be obtained from Neill (2005) argues, traditionally research involving
the child, parent or guardian as appropriate. children has been on rather than with them.
Parental consent for school children should also However, the last two decades have seen a shift in
have the child’s agreement. thoughts concerning children in research, and
children have begun to be involved as participants
The potential impact of the research process on the in their own right. Such changes concerning the
child at the time of data collection and after is recognition that children have a valuable
addressed by The National Children’s Bureau contribution to make and have rights may be partly
(NCB) Guidelines for Research (2003). The NCB attributed to the United Nations (UN) Assembly
has subscribed to the British Sociological adopting the Convention on the Rights of the Child
Association Statement of Ethical Practice and added in 1989. This has impacted on current thinking
material specific to research with children around around research and children in several ways.
informed consent; child protection and confiden- Children’s participation and autonomy rights were
tiality; monitoring the impact on the child; and given more emphasis alongside protection and
payment to participants. In addition, Alderson nurturance rights. The UNCRC (1989) emphasise
48 THE ETHICS OF RESEARCHING CHILDREN
that children have the right to freedom of speech For example, Carroll (2000) reports methodological
and opinion, to be consulted and taken account of challenges in attempting to include children’s
and to challenge decisions made on their behalf opinions about the play therapy experience.
(Lowden, 2002). The concept of the child at the
centre of the research process is one that is Advocacy for children seems to have only seriously
supported by the Children Act 1989 and the begun since the implementation of the Children
UNCRC (1989). Such legislative measures Act 1989. It can be argued that this gives the child
encourage children’s voices to be heard and their a voice and to provide representation. The role of
opinions sought on matters that affect them. the advocate, as of the play therapist, is to express
the voice of the child, both to the child and to those
The UNCRC (1989) considers two fundamental who have the responsibility of making decisions for
challenges to traditional practices in respect of the child. The underlying reasons for working with
children. Firstly, the means by which the best a child, whether it is to assess, enable the child to
interests of the child are assessed must primarily express a view, provide therapy or a mixture of these
demonstrate consideration for the extent to which should be transparent in this process (Colton,
all of their human rights are respected. Secondly, Sanders & Williams, 2001). Perhaps, part of the
children must have the opportunity to be heard and difficulty in finding appropriate ways of including
listening to children through research can be argued children in the research process is that in the UK as
to be an essential element in ensuring their in many other countries, we do not have a culture of
protection. However, the welfare model of childcare listening to children and the consequence of this
may have perpetuated the view that children lack means we are not used to talking to children to try
the capacity to contribute to their own well-being, to ascertain their views and opinions. The challenge
not having a valid contribution to make. for social research may be to find suitable routes for
Additionally, Morrow (1999) argues that in UK sourcing children’s opinions and experiences and
social policy research, relatively few studies have developing appropriate methods and strategies to
been based on children’s accounts of their deal with ethical dilemmas that may arise (Morrow
experiences. & Richards, 1996).
There has been a huge shift towards acknowledging Morrow (1999) states that as well as the usual
children as social actors with views and under- ethical guidelines, there are four key considerations
standings that adults might learn from them driven in research with children. Firstly, children’s
by pressure on individuals and agencies to ‘consult competencies, perceptions and frames of reference
children’ or ‘listen to children’ for research and may be different at different ages, having
policy initiatives. However, it should be noted that implications for the consent process, data collection
whilst this is a positive move, involving children in methods and interpretations. Adult responsibilities
research or consultation may have unanticipated to children must be considered because children can
consequences and may not always lead to the be vulnerable to exploitation in interactions with
expected outcome for children involved in the adults. Awareness of the differences in power
process (Cree, Kay & Tisdall, 2002). Caution between the adult researcher and child participant
perhaps needs to be noted when trying to involve must be considered and could become problematic
children in research as although including their at the point of interpretation and presentation of
views will undoubtedly strengthen the research, research findings. In addition, access to children has
participation in research may not always be in the to be mediated via adult gate-keepers, and this has
child’s best interests. How children are actually implications for the consent process.
listened to, the approach used to involve children in
research and the ways in which the subsequent
results are interpreted needs serious consideration.
THE ETHICS OF RESEARCHING CHILDREN 49
Power Issues in the Research Process often seen to be a need for protection for children
from exploitative researchers, and as the objects
Research with children will undoubtedly raise rather than the participants of research. Morrow &
methodological and ethical issues. Not only is the Richards argue that we need to move away from
balance of power a sensitive issue within NDPT but such epistemological assumptions about what
also in any research carried out with children. There children are, based on a specific formulation of the
is clearly the potential for the adult researcher to category ‘child’, if we are to attempt a social analysis
influence the process at every stage of data of children’s experiences, and hence see children as
collection and interpretation. The differences in social actors in their own right. Certainly, an overly
power and status between adults and children protective stance towards children could actually
certainly present an ethical challenge. reduce children’s potential to participate in research.
Research with children can present a powerful
Although the view of childhood has shifted, society tension between two sometimes conflicting social
does seem to continue to view children as goals; that is protecting individual children from
vulnerable, incompetent and in need of protection. harm and exploitation, while at the same time
Children can be viewed as inherently vulnerable increasing our body of knowledge about children in
because of their physical weakness, and their lack of order to develop beneficial interventions such as
knowledge and experience, which renders them play therapy. However by ‘protecting’ children from
dependent upon the adults around them and any involvement in research we commit ourselves to
structurally vulnerable because of their total lack of ignorance about children’s views and important
political and economic power and their lack of civil aspects of their experiences of NDPT. Thus the
rights deriving from historical attitudes and methods employed, the research populations and
presumptions about the nature of childhood participants, as well as the interpretation of the data
(Lansdown, 1994). collected, are all influenced by the view of children
that we take.
Certainly, research with children in the UK has
tended to be dominated by concerns about groups Children receiving therapy are rendered to some
of children who are vulnerable in some way extent vulnerable due to their experiences and this
(perhaps for funding and social policy reasons). This will consequently raise ethical questions in the
has undoubtedly contributed to the dominant research process. These may not be adequately
conceptualisation of children as weak, passive and addressed. The key aim in such research must be to
open to abuse (Morrow & Richards, 1996). ensure that the research process in no way exposes
Children’s assumed lack of competence means that the child to any further ‘damage’ or abuse. Ethical
their ability to make decisions about whether to guidelines that avoid undue intrusion, and methods
participate in research and therefore competence to that are non-invasive and non-confrontational
provide valid sociological data is questioned. might help to lessen the ethical problems of
Morrow & Richards argue that mainstream imbalanced power relationships between researchers
developmental psychology often perceives children and researched at the point of data collection and
to be less competent than adults, and can impose interpretation
methods and interpretation on data collected from
children which may be quite out of line with what Trust
the children meant; rarely do researchers return to
their research participants to confirm. The distinctive ethical dimension of NDPT
practice is the trust placed by child clients in
The concept of the ‘vulnerability’ of children within practitioners. This trust is not only essential to
the research process has an impact on discussions of achieving therapeutic goals for the client but also for
ethical dilemmas in play therapy research. There is the practitioner to establish the quality of
50 THE ETHICS OF RESEARCHING CHILDREN
relationship and interaction that makes the work consent and protection of research respondents. In
possible. Ethical researchers need to take account of the UK, consent is usually taken to mean consent
the quality of trust required to make play therapy from parents or guardians and it could be argued in
possible and also seek the highest possible levels of this respect children are to a large extent seen as
trustworthiness and integrity for themselves with their parents’ property, devoid of the right to say no
regard to the relationship with the people being to research. In practice, researchers usually obtain
researched and all other people involved directly in consent from a wide range of adult gatekeepers
the research. (parents, school teachers, head-teachers, school
governors, local education authority officers and so
Perhaps then the person best placed to carry out on in the case of school-based research) before they
research with children in therapy is the therapist are allowed anywhere near the children, and may
him or herself. However, even this can be feel unwilling to jeopardise their research project by
problematic, as the therapist may already sense a asking the children explicitly for their ‘informed
need to try to compensate for a power imbalance. consent’ (Morrow, 1999).
This could be made more difficult by introducing a
research dynamic that involves the child without Informed consent is a difficult issue for the play
then compromising the relationship. Many children therapy researcher, who is faced with two essential
referred for play therapy have a history of neglect, considerations: firstly how to go about obtaining it;
abuse or trauma; that is to say they have experienced and secondly how to ensure that the consent really
abusive relationships with adults in the past. It is is ‘informed’. Participants in research projects
essential that the therapy does not repeat these should of course be fully informed and provide
dynamics but works to empower the child and consent to their involvement. All research
demonstrate the capacity to form positive participants, including children, have the right to
productive relationships. If the therapist is working have explained to them, in language appropriate to
to nurture a child within therapy then it may seem their level of understanding, all aspects of the
to be represent a conflict of interests to introduce a research that may affect their willingness to
dynamic which is not strictly of benefit to the participate. Children and the adults responsible for
individual. However if the aim of the research is to them, have the right to discontinue participation in
study a phenomenon with a view to finding out the research at any time. It is worth considering that
more about current practice as a means of children may also be deprived of the right to
informing future practice, then this may primarily consent by a gatekeeper wishing to protect the
benefit subsequent clients rather than the individual child’s or their own interests.
client who is participating in the research.
Furthermore the research could also be construed as In relation to informed consent in research, the
being of benefit to the therapist, developing their BAPT Ethical Basis for Good Practice in Play
skills, knowledge, career etc. Since therapy should Therapy (2002) states that play therapists do not
prioritise the client’s needs, Daniel-McKeigue put pressure or coerce clients to participate in
(2004) proposes that research conducted whilst research. When the research involves participants,
therapy is in progress is likely to represent a conflict the researcher must obtain the informed consent of
of interests and may repeat the pattern of imbalance the participant, or if legally incapable, the person
of power in relationships that the child has holding legal responsibility for the participant.
previously experienced. Guidance is given as to how ‘informed consent’ can
be interpreted. This includes that the person has:
Informed Consent
• the capacity to make a voluntary choice;
General discussions around research ethics are often • an understanding of the research aims,
centred around two key preoccupations: informed objectives, methods and procedures;
THE ETHICS OF RESEARCHING CHILDREN 51
• been able to ask questions and receive answers literature about consent and children. Alderson’s
regarding the research; (1995) Ethical Guidelines suggest that children and
• given their voluntary and continuing young people must agree to take part in a research
permission for their involvement. study and this agreement should be open for review
before and during the interview itself. The consent
The NCB poses several questions for researchers, should be free from pressure or undue persuasion on
with the understanding that the child gives the a child or young person to take part, especially when
consent rather than their parent or guardian: this person is in a position of power over that child
or young person (Masson, 2004). Additionally
Fig 2: Questions for researchers obtaining some children may give consent in order to ‘please’
informed consent from children (NCB in Neill, their therapist; researchers need to be aware of this
2005) potential dynamic. Children and young people
should be able to give informed consent by knowing
• Have children been told about the research in a and understanding the purpose of the research.
way that they can understand?
• Are the children clear that they can agree or However, in practice it can be difficult to negotiate
refuse to take part – without any adverse such principles. Cree, Kay & Tisdall (2002) argue
consequences? that without the active support of adults who have
• Is the child clear that he or she can withdraw at responsibility for children and young people (that
any time? is, their parents, carers and child care workers) they
• Has the researcher agreed a signal with the child would have had no research study. Parents are more
to enable them to do so easily? likely to consent to the child’s participation in the
• Have the researchers considered how very project when the researcher has been introduced by
young children, children with learning disabilities, a trusted professional (social worker or child care
or children with communication problems are to worker). Likewise, children are more likely to agree
be informed and their consent gained? if both their social worker/childcare worker and
• If the research is to take place in schools, how parents seem supportive of the research. Therefore
does the researcher ensure that each individual child trust in one individual or agency is passed onto the
has given their informed consent to participate? researcher resulting in a kind of ‘sponsorship’. This
then makes it impossible to be certain that all
The most appropriate way to research NDPT may children and young people have made their own
well be whilst the therapy is in progress. However ‘freely given’ decision to participate. Such practical
requesting informed consent from a minor realities are not unique to research with children. As
depending on their age is likely to involve the parent Lindsay (2000) comments research is always an
or guardian. Determining who is competent to give ‘intrusion’ as people who consent to be research
consent, and implications following from this, is participants rarely have a full understanding of what
one of many of the issues that would be crucial to they are letting themselves in for.
resolve when dealing with the matter of researching
children in therapy. A further dilemma is gaining Gatekeepers
‘informed consent’ in the context of a therapeutic
approach that relies on play as the primary means of When considering the more practical aspects of
communication. Methods of consent through the carrying out research with children in play therapy,
process of play may not be deemed as appropriate gatekeepers to the research data collection are
and fulfil the criteria on consent forms issued by perhaps necessary for the child’s ‘protection’ but can
ethical committees. make access to research participants difficult for the
potential researcher. The NCB (2003) recognises
There has been extensive discussion in the research the need for children themselves to give consent to
52 THE ETHICS OF RESEARCHING CHILDREN
participate but recognises that often it is necessary 2002). However, they can never be more than this
to seek permission from the child in order to because ambiguities and complexities will always
approach the parents. As a researcher outside of the remain. Issues such as informed consent, power and
therapy process, access to the appropriate client confidentiality are central to any research, but
group can be difficult, as Carroll (2002) found become all the more complex in research with
when seeking to gather children’s views on play children, particularly in such a sensitive area as
therapy for her study. She maintains that actually NDPT. Indeed, the questions of access and consent
collecting the sample was a technical challenge due are both fundamentally tied up in the wider issue of
to the issue of gatekeepers even though the children confidentiality. In most ethical research guidelines,
had been identified via play therapists, and were confidentiality implies giving attention to
contacted via training courses and the British anonymity in research reports, and making it clear
Association of Play Therapists. when a researcher may need to pass on information
to others (such as if a child discloses that they are
The extent to which the children presented in the being abused or are abusing someone else).
study are representative of the wider population can
present an ethical challenge. Often researchers may The NCB (2003) makes it clear in the context of
have to rely on the various gatekeepers’ decisions to research there must be limits to any guarantee of
carry out the research, which in turn influences the confidentiality or anonymity in the case of child
research participants that can be included in the protection:
study. For example in Carroll’s (2002) play therapy
research, she indicates that the children included are “Where a child or young person divulges that
not a representative sample and therefore she cannot they or others are at risk of significant harm,
know if another group of children would feel the or where the researcher observes or receives
same. It is often not possible to say that because evidence of incidents likely to cause serious
certain elements changed in the children under harm, the researcher has a duty to take steps to
study, that these would be the same for other protect the chid and other children.”
children attending play therapy, although there may (NCB, 2003: 3)
be common elements. It could be expected that
therapists (gatekeepers) would select children whose Children and young people should be told at the
therapy was deemed successful. onset of the research that if such information is
shared, confidentiality cannot be guaranteed. This
There can be routine reasons for access difficulties, type of initial boundary setting will undoubtedly
which are likely to be experienced by all those impact on trust and honesty within the researcher-
conducting research with children. Researchers can client relationship.
only usually get access to children via the
cooperation of a number of different ‘gatekeepers’. Impact on Intervention
Some professional ‘gatekeepers’ see the merits of
such research and make it their concern but others The final ethical consideration is how to collect data
may not be so willing to do this. Scepticism about and conduct research into the therapeutic process
the usefulness of the study, pressure in jobs and without influencing that process in some way.
feeling unable to take on yet another external Research into non-directive play therapy raises the
demand can all be detractors. issue of the impact on the therapy itself of such an
intervention. As Daniel-McKeigue (2004) notes
Confidentiality one of the major issues that children explore in
therapy is self-esteem. The idea is that the therapist
The codes of ethics and guidelines for good practice should be engaged as a neutral facilitator of the
provide a good starting point (Cree, Kay & Tisdall, child (someone who is not involved in the child’s
THE ETHICS OF RESEARCHING CHILDREN 53
Abstract
This paper introduces the concept of the Communicube and the Communiwell, two structures that have been
developed as communication tools for the 21st century. It presents a therapeutic method of using these tools, the
Five Story Self Structure. Information is provided on the origin, design and theory. In order to demonstrate the
flexibility of the tool brief examples of practice with adults are given followed by more detailed accounts of work
conducted by dramatherapists with school age children in Britain and France. Keywords: Communication, play,
levels, self, structure, miniature, patterns, story, container, assessment, therapy, education, distance, fun.
During doctoral research (1996-2002) into The Communicube is a transparent, open, five level
dramatherapy and psychodrama as psychothera- structure. Light reflects off the shelves, which are
peutic interventions with people who hear voices each printed with a grid of twenty-five squares.
(auditory hallucinations) I invented the Five Story These grids float within the structure like a series of
Self Structure; I was looking for a safe way of transparent chessboards, one above the other. When
working with people who may be overwhelmed by objects such as buttons, stones or other small objects
complex experience. It soon became clear that it was are placed in the grid squares they may be reflected
useful to other clients, including children and by the other shelves, the images on one level faintly
young people who were not struggling with mirrored in another; colours glitter; shadows fall
psychosis or voices. Over the following six years this through the structure; a floating world holds within
way of working has developed and is now being it the tension of opposite polarities and related
used by therapists of different orientations. The objects, whether close or distant, echoing the larger
Communicube is a communication tool; the Five cosmos.
Story Self Structure is one method of using this tool.
The decision to use five levels was deliberate: there
is a top, bottom, middle and two intermediate
levels. It is important that there is a central level
with a central square through which all diagonals
pass: this is psychologically integrating. Five is also
archetypal: I write further about this in the users’
manual (Casson, 2005), which comes with the
structure. The pun on story/storey is also deliberate:
the structure evokes different stories on different
storeys.
Illustration: The Communicube
55
56 THE FIVE STORY SELF STRUCTURE
miniature. This serves to enhance the observer ego - people or things in your life.” As clients talk of
the part of us that is able to stand back from our various elements in their experience I encourage
experience and reflect - promoting insight and them to symbolise each element. For example when
integration. It can help clarify the inter-connections someone says, “I feel stuck” I would invite them to
between different levels of experience. It provides find a button that represents their experience of
sufficient distance from material that might feeling stuck and place it where they feel it belongs
otherwise overwhelm, enabling people to play, to in the structure.
think about, observe and share perceptions of self,
other and their world. It is fun. 6) Buttons now represent roles, and there may be
dialogues between objects on the structure. I may
The structure is best positioned on a white base so ask, “What might the dark blue button say to the
the items placed on it can be clearly seen. While white stone?” The drama within the structure can
some individuals may prefer to use black or another develop so that objects may be moved: “If the small
colour, the base should be plain so as not to confuse yellow button wants to be safer and more powerful,
the picture created by the pattern of buttons. The where might it move and what other button might
process may proceed as follows: help it? Shall the red button stay on this level or do
you need to move it to another level, now that the
1) I show the person the structure and ask them green one has been moved up?” New roles may
what they see, notice, imagine that it is. Often the emerge and buttons or other objects be found to
structure has reminded people of the three- symbolise these. “What will this silver buckle say as
dimensional chess set in Star Trek or, alternatively, a it enters the structure? What is the response of the
multi-storey car park, office block, department store other buttons?”
or house. We might explore this image and develop
a story. The structure clearly intrigues people and if 7) Clients are now asked to step back and look at
they are willing to continue to use it we move on to the pattern they have created from different sides
step 2. and angles, and to relate what they notice. Often
shadows and reflections of buttons on different
2) I produce the buttons and offer the opportunity levels, or new alignments between elements become
to choose buttons and place them wherever the apparent during this observing stage.
person wishes. This might also lead to story making
or to developing a pattern. This step gives the 8) They are then invited to “Look from above so
person maximum freedom to project whatever they you can see the whole pattern through the different
will onto the structure. Alternatively we might miss layers (of the transparent shelves). What do you
this step and pass straight to stage 3. notice? Are there any changes you want to make?”
3) I invite the person to choose one button to 9) Finally clients are asked to reflect and verbalise
represent themselves and to place it wherever they their feelings and observations.
are or wish to be (two buttons may be chosen here
- a real self and an ideal self ). This has proved an extraordinarily flexible and
useful technique. The structure facilitates play and
4) When working with someone who hears voices I concentration; it fascinates and focuses (due to its
ask them to choose other buttons to represent the interesting, concentric design). It enables people to
voices and place those in relation to the button explore creatively, through stories and patterns
representing the self. (right brain activities), their mental/spiritual
‘geography’. They can in effect create a ‘three-
5) The client is then asked to choose and place more dimensional’ model of their psyche and so observe
buttons to represent “other aspects of yourself, or structure emerge from chaos. With such structure
58 THE FIVE STORY SELF STRUCTURE
emerges meaning. Miniaturisation also places the game proceeds as each player chooses an object and
person in control and allows him to feel powerful. places it in the structure, and explains to the group
Viewed from above the whole Communicube is what it symbolises in the context of a story or
instantly visible: a mandala containing disparate memory. The next player chooses another item
elements yet integrated into one metaphor for the prompted by their free association with what a
self. Jung (1972) considered the mandala to be a previous player has said. A pattern of associations
symbol for the Self. builds up until the group decide by consensus what
is the Quintessence, that is the underlying theme of
The different levels of the Communicube do not these associations. An object is then placed to
have intrinsic meaning: their significance is for the symbolise this on the central square on the central
individual client to attribute. It is in effect a toy level. The group may then further explore the
theatre of the Self - a world in miniature. Working emergent issues in drama. One therapist told me
thus through projected play promotes that her group of adolescent anorexic girls disclosed
symbolisation: the concrete becomes metaphor, a more during a game of Quintessence than they
means of communication and of forming would in a typical session.
relationship.
Working with Children: Examples of
Further developments Group and Individual Practice
The Communiwell is a circular version, which 1. Debra Kaatz, a dramatherapist who works with
instead of the grid of squares has three concentric children in a primary school (aged 4-11) in the
circles. Some people prefer this version: it offers South of France, writes (personal communication,
clients and therapists a choice. The Communicube May 30, 2005):
and Communiwell are being further developed as
tools in therapeutic work with couples, groups, Using the Communiwell, each child has created
families, supervision, team building and in a completely different world. When I have used
education. it in pairs with several children who have some
difficulties with each other or with
concentration the enjoyment has overcome
those difficulties. It is like a modern sand tray.
the girls had been identified as having issues suggested we use it to look at how the group was
concerning self-esteem, self-confidence, functioning at the present time.
interaction with peers, turn taking and listening
skills by the staff who had referred them. It was Child B and Child C were captivated by the
hoped that the girls might find new, more variety of buttons. They explored their colours,
appropriate coping strategies in conflict sizes and textures for some time. I also offered
situations. some small animals and other miniature objects
for the children to use.
For the first few months it was clear the creative
structures offered in the sessions were benefiting Child A sat observing in the ‘watching space’
the girls. They showed empathy and whilst the exploration took place.
consideration for each other’s needs. The
dramatherapy space was invaluable in providing Child B chose a sun button to represent herself
‘time out’ from the usual pace of life, away from and Child C a small elephant. Both these were
any academic pressure, in which their feelings placed at the centre of the Communiwell on the
could be acknowledged and witnessed. top level. Various other choices were made by
the girls to represent the creative things we had
It is important to state that throughout this used in the group - puppets, stories, musical
time, despite previous traumas, the children’s instruments and so on. Other buttons were
home environments were reasonably stable. chosen to represent listening to each other and
However, as time progressed the sessions were feelings about the work.
disrupted by one child who was experiencing
further crises at home. The ground rules were Child B asked Child C if she could place a
not being kept and it was difficult to meet the candlestick at the centre of the level to represent
needs of all the girls, whose diverse individual anything they had forgotten.
issues impacted negatively on their work
together. I felt it more appropriate for them to Child C then chose three small buttons to
have individual sessions but was reluctant for symbolize the watching space.
this idea to come from myself rather than the
group. Child B then asked Child A if she could put a
button on for her.
I was particularly concerned about child A as
her pattern had always been to push boundaries Child A nodded, watching closely all the time.
until they could no longer ‘hold’ her. I
recognised it was fundamental that she felt Child B chose two buttons, a bright gold one
‘held’ so she could begin to trust that some and a pink one. She placed them on the outer
adults could cope with her emotions and keep circle and commented that this was Child A
her safe. I felt that closure of the group might playing with her ball while the rest of the group
reinforce her long term coping strategies of were trying to do something else.
controlling and disociation. It was important
that the girls made the decision to change the Child A asked to join in and moved the two
way they worked therapeutically and the buttons representing her and the ball to the
Communiwell greatly assisted this process in a centre next to the other pieces. She commented
way that was most remarkable. this was where she really wanted to be but she
was aware she stopped herself from being there.
Child A was reluctant to join the two other girls The other two children made comments to this
when I produced the Communiwell and effect and Child A was able to listen without
60 THE FIVE STORY SELF STRUCTURE
disengaging. It was rare for Child A to be able their own conclusions about their present needs
to do this. with the aid of the Communiwell. The objects’
small size, and the distance achieved by this
On the second level of the Communiwell I form of projective representation, had allowed
asked the group if there was anything else they the girls to ‘look in’ on themselves. This process
wanted to sculpt. They decided to show me had increased their self-awareness. The girls all
what it was like in their classroom. Again each went on to experience some valuable individual
child chose objects and buttons to represent work and came together to work in the group at
various actions and feelings. the close of the dramatherapy project.
Child B placed a button to represent all the I was not sure what I was going to offer the girls
time she had been absent from class and one to with the Communiwell when I introduced it.
show the anxious feelings around this when she However, I had an intuitive feeling that it would
was unaware of what was expected of her. be useful and the process would unfold. This
happened far beyond my expectations and
Child C selected a small butterfly, which she demonstrated the versatility of the Five Story
wanted to float around this level. She felt it was Self Structure. I now feel the ways in which this
hard to concentrate on her work. can be used are unlimited.
Child A placed four buttons to represent hard 3. Sue Seager further writes of using the approach in
work, her angry and muddled feelings, putting individual work with a boy:
her head down on the table and refusing to
work. Before the session closed the girls were The use of the Communiwell proved an
able to look down and reflect on the structure invaluable tool for Harry (aged 12) to examine
and relate the two levels to each other. the process and consequences of an aggressive
incident in which he had been involved. Harry
Child A remarked, ‘I know there are things I began to look at strategies as to how he could
would like to do on my own with Sue. When I achieve self-regulation to control his behaviour.
get angry I don’t want to join in with everyone He selected small animals and buttons to
else’. represent the children, teacher, feelings and
consequences of his actions and used the
The other girls agreed they would like some Communiwell to re-enact each stage of the
individual sessions. So we decided we would incident. He was able to identify at what points
have three further sessions together before he made things a lot more difficult for himself
commencing individual work. In the closing and play out an alternative path. As well as
sessions that followed we kept the original applying his insight to how his body felt when
pieces on the two top levels and explored one he began to feel angry, he later commented that
situation in the playground on the middle level, he felt this experience had enabled him to avoid
the girls’ relationships with each other on the some other possible incidents. This enabled him
second to bottom level and on the final level to see his progress and further acknowledge his
how they hoped the group would be if they power and responsibility in making choices. He
worked together again. also explored how his choices affected his
friends’ behaviour and how they benefited in
There were no disruptive incidents in these turn.
closing sessions. The girls were able to talk
through situations, actions and feelings and
how these were interrelated. They had formed
THE FIVE STORY SELF STRUCTURE 61
issues is as yet undeveloped, and there may be the University of Sydney, Australia, leads a hospital
external pressures to solve the most distressing cases. programme for the treatment of and research into
Wilson & Ryan provide very sound explanations in borderline personality disorders. Meares takes the
this regard that, if adhered to, will help to ensure a reader on a thought-provoking exploration of the
responsible approach. Always characteristic clarity self, which he regards as one of the numerous
of thought and sound rationale is delivered that different forms of consciousness which shift and
supports the highest regard for children’s well being. change during ordinary existence. His sensitivity
and deep theoretical understanding of the skills and
I wholeheartedly recommend this volume to all who attitudes involved in the therapeutic process filled
wish to practice in play therapy or to understand the me with renewed awe and he concludes that ‘the
underlying processes. It will also help other experience of self arises in the context of a particular
professionals, parents and carers who wish to gain form of relatedness.’ In my opinion this book is an
greater insight into central themes in children’s play essential read for play therapists aiming to deepen
and behaviour. The fundamental principles and their therapeutic work with children.
guiding light underpinning this book’s aims are
firmly rooted in children’s needs at any stage of Meares considers the importance of play in the
development. This informs all, from moment to formation and development of the self and reaffirms
moment practice of skills in the playroom, interpre- the critical role of play for the evolution of a mature
tation of children’s communications to others, psychic life. He makes comparison with Winnicott’s
working with parents and carers, to advocacy in the concept of the ‘transitional space’ in his exploration
wider arena of society. of the meaning and significance of play. Core skills
and attitudes, such as acceptance and empathy that
Anne Barnes are familiar to all non-directive practitioners, are
MA/Diploma in Play Therapy seamlessly interwoven throughout the text, as are
Notre Dame Centre the author’s self-awareness and sense of timing.
Glasgow
A concise look at developmental features and a
thorough explanation of the workings of memory
are extremely useful. This leads into a very readable
The Metaphor of Play: Origin and and informative section relating to traumatic
Breakdown of Personal Being memory. The focus then turns to the treatment of
Author: Russell Meares developmental trauma that so often underpins the
Date Published: 2005 difficulties of day-to-day life for our young clients.
Publisher: Routledge This publication is a joy to read and emphasises the
relationship as the transformational element in
ISBN: 1 58391 967 8 therapy. Meares’ primary achievement in this book
Price: £18.99 (amazon.co.uk) is to clarify fully the form of relatedness necessary
for that transformation.
EDITORIAL
Anne Barnes 3
PAPERS
Theraplay: An Introduction
David L Myrow 14
Book Reviews 63
ISSN 1744−1145
02
Laser Proof