Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Ms.O’Keefe/Mr.Kelly
American Literature
1 April 2018
One of the main goals in many societies of the world is for people to be ‘good’ as much
as possible. By ‘good’ we mean ‘ethical. An ethical person is one who knows what is right from
wrong in situations. Ethics has been known to relate to justice. If a person is trying to make
justice in a situation, then they have to consider the ethics that were involved and what are the
ethical choices they have, to create justice. Sometimes justice and ethics can create controversy
as a person can seem to be creating justice but violating the ethics. As people continue to
question what qualities a ‘good’ person, it is important to follow and consider 10 rules, which are
The first rule that everyone should aby by would be “Do No Harm”. This rule is
important because it is obvious that we should not cause harm to another person to prevent
yourself to be harmed as well. This is reflected in “Justice: What’s the right thing to do?” where
the author, M. Sandel, states “ They include the duty to treat persons with respect, to do justice,
to avoid cruelty, and so on” (223). This shows the importance of the rule because it connects to
the natural duty of everyone to treat people with respect. We owe it to everyone to not harm
them simply because we are all rational human beings. This also related to the Consequentialist
Framework. According to the reading, ‘A Framework for Making Ethical Decisions’ it states
“The person using the Consequentialist Framework desires to produce the most good.” If
everyone follows the rule ‘Do No Harm’ then the most good would be produced.
The next rule to live by is to offer help to others in ways you know how. This rule is
important because it fosters a community in which one person helps another. It also removes the
stigma of race. For example, this rule would remove the idea that different ethnicities cannot
cooperate. This rule would aid in removing any racism as the rule would make people help each
other regardless of color, tongue, ethnicity and etc. The text references that an aspect of natural
duty is to have these duties come naturally, and therefore not need an act of consent. Typically,
helping others comes naturally and that would make it a natural duty and produce the most good
This next rule is similar to the last two rules which is to be respectful. This rule is
important because it is essentially the base of every other rule. In order to be a good person, the
idea is that one must be at least respectful to others at the very least. The text, Justice, directly
states that one must be respectful. It states “They [natural duties] include the duty to treat persons
with respect…” (Sandel 4). This rule can be connected to natural duties because it can be
considered that we (at minimum) need to show respect to everyone. In the Consequentialist
Framework it states “among the advantages of this ethical framework is that focusing on the
results of an action pragmatic approach”, which proves that being respectful to others deals with
The fourth and fifth rule relate to each other which are; be considerate of others and do
not be selfish. These rules obviously correspond with each other because they focus on others
and putting yourself aside for a while. In the Consequentialist Framework it states “some actions
that are expected to produce good consequences might actually end up harming people,” these
rules relate to this because a person sometimes has to sacrifice themselves for the better good . In
the Sinking Ship Scenario, it was necessary for the crew member to sacrifice themselves for the
better good and save the other people on the boat. If they would have been considerate of others
and not selfish they would have been following the Consequentialist Framework and their
The rule that has brought a lot of doubt is to not judge others but a better way to say this
is do not judge others until you know the facts. While it may seem just to never judge anyone,
sometimes it is ethical to do so because when they are violating a natural duty a person can
confront them and that is a form of judging . But it is important to know the acts before you
judge because judging by only rumors can cause conflicts as those rumors can be inaccurate. The
next rule relates to this, which is judge yourself and admit your wrongs. If we judge ourselves
right and admit when we are not being ethical then it will help us to react more correctly in our
natural duties when we see people being unjust . This will help in the process of judging others
“Be honest with yourself and others” is the next rule in which a person should follow so
they can become a good person. This rule is important because it fosters a society where people
no longer lie, but still remains true to the first rule which is to not do harm. Sometimes the truth
is just too much for a person to handle, and the truth would do less harm than telling the lie, for
leaving something out can cause more distrust and conflict. This rule connects to natural duties
because it, again, brings forth the idea that a good human being would not lie to another person.
The last couple of rules are related to yourself as an individual which are to be humble
and to be forgiving to those who deserve it. These relate to natural duties because they do not
require consent and we owe it to OURSELVES to be humble and forgiving. Holding grudges
and greed do nothing to person but cause conflicts. Forgive people, not specifically because they
apologized and deserve it, but because you deserve that peace in your own life. These rules of
course relate to the Consequentialist Framework because it states that it focuses on future affects
and being humble and forgiving will lead to a better and more peaceful future for yourself. These
rules also relate to the Virtue Framework as it states “we try to identify the character traits that
might motivate us in given situations”. By having character traits of being humble and forgiving
it will give a better chance of being more ethical in certain situations and create justice.
Throughout the making of these rules I changed them up a couple of times from my first
attempt on rules that foster good people. The rules for the most part stayed the same but became
more specific. For example for my third rule I had first put to never judge and later changed it to
‘Don’t judge until you know the facts” because sometimes it is ethical to judge someone if they
are clearly violating ethics and natural duties such as committing a crime. Another example of a
rule I made more specific was my second rule which was to be helpful, I then changed it to “be
helpful in ways you know how” because sometimes it is better to not involve yourself in
situations and issues that you don’t understand because it will only cause more chaos and
confusion, it is good to be helpful but make sure you’re being efficient in doing so.
As mentioned before, many societies desire a place with peace and full of good people. If
everyone follows these rules then the world would have so many less conflicts, chaos and evil.
As humans we are still improving ourselves and morals as time goes by and of course there has
been a lot of change since the beginning of time but we must consider others and ourselves
ethically to foster a world at peace . As an individual myself , I can honestly say I try to improve
as a person as I grow and mature . These rules that I am determined to follow will help me create
a peace of mind of my own and overall make me happier because I know that good is being
Works Cited
“Brown University.” A Framework for Making Ethical Decisions | Science and Technology
Studies,
www.brown.edu/academics/science-and-technology-studies/framework-making-ethical-de
cisions.
Sandel, Michael J. “'Justice,' by Michael J. Sandel.” The New York Times, The New York Times,
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Brown_(ship).