Sie sind auf Seite 1von 6

Physiology & Behavior, Vol. 50, pp. 543-548. ©Pergamon Press plc, 1991. Printed in the U.S.A.

0031-9384/91 $3.00 + .00

Effect of Buddhist Meditation on Serum Cortisol


and Total Protein Levels, Blood Pressure,
Pulse Rate, Lung Volume and Reaction Time

RATREE SUDSUANG, VILAI CHENTANEZ AND KONGDEJ VELUVAN

Department o f Physiology and Anatomy, Faculty o f Medicine, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok 10330, Thailand

R e c e i v e d 16 N o v e m b e r 1990

SUDSUANG, R., V. CHENTANEZ AND K. VELUVAN. Effect of Buddhist meditation on serum cortisol and total protein
levels, blood pressure, pulse rate, lung volume and reaction time. PHYSIOL BEHAV 50(3) 543-548, 1991.--Serum cortisol and
total protein levels, blood pressure, heart rate, lung volume, and reaction time were studied in 52 males 20-25 years of age
practicing Dhammakaya Buddhist meditation, and in 30 males of the same age group not practicing meditation. It was found that
after meditation, serum cortisol levels were significantly reduced, serum total protein level significantly increased, and systolic
pressure, diastolic pressure and pulse rate significantly reduced. Vital capacity, tidal volume and maximal voluntary ventilation
were significantly lower after meditation than before. There were also significant decreases in reaction time after meditation prac-
tice. The percentage decrease in reaction time during meditation was 22%, while in subjects untrained in meditation, the percent-
age decrease was only 7%. Results from these studies indicate that practising Dhammakaya Buddhist meditation produces
biochemical and physiological changes and reduces the reaction time.

Buddhist meditation Serum cortisol Total protein Blood pressure Pulse rate Reaction time

DURING the practice of various techniques of meditation, ex- from all traces of wavering and distraction. After practicing for
pert Zen monks may show a decrease in rate of respiration, ox- a period of time, the meditator becomes serene and his mind
ygen consumption, and spontaneous galvanic skin response (GSR), mounts to actual concentration (19). In transcendental medita-
and their pulse rate and blood pH increase slightly (18). In a tion, a person allows his mind to experience a relaxed and en-
study by Anand et al. (1), the electroencephalogram of yogis joyable state, which draws his attention inward. He experiences
during meditation showed an increase in alpha-wave amplitude quiet levels of the mind in which he becomes increasingly aware
and activity, and in a few of the yogis studied, there was a loss of the unbounded nature of his awareness in the absence of ob-
of the alpha blocking response to all external simuli. ject, which is termed pure awareness (5). In doing Zen training,
Wallace (20) has found that during transcendental meditation, the student engages in a practice such as counting his or her
oxygen consumption and heart rate decrease, skin resistance in- breaths or working on a koan. He may also reach a state in
creases, and the electroencephalogram may show specific changes which the normal, logical, or sequential activity of conscious-
in certain subjects (20). There was a report of breathing suspen- ness is arrested, yet the mind is still very much active with
sion during this technique, which indicated a possible physiogi- whatever it is concentrating on (12). In a comparison between
cal correlate of some episodes of the "pure consciousness" these three methods of training, Buddhist meditation is more
experience (24). Werner et al. (23) reported long-term endoeri- similar to Zen than to transcendental meditation.
nologic changes in thyroid stimulating hormone, thyroid hor- In this study, we investigated the effects of Dhammakaya
mone, growth hormone, prolactin and cortisol in subjects practicing meditation on serum cortisol and total protein levels, blood
transcendental meditation. pressure, pulse rate, lung volume, and reaction time. The results
Buddhist meditational practice is different from that of other from this study could demonstrate the effect of Buddhist medita-
schools. The aim of the practice is Right Concentration (samma- tion on physiological changes, and the possibility of applying
samadhi). It has been developed into two methods: Samadhi and Buddhist meditation to reducing anxiety, and of using methods
Vipassana. Samadhi meditation consists of achieving the utmost similar to transcendental meditation to treat hypertension or
concentration of thought upon a given subject of salutary nature, asthma.
and then raising one's conception of the subject to an abstrac-
tion. In this form of meditation, consciousness is raised from a METHOD
lower to a higher plane with the elimination of its inferior ten- The experimental subjects consisted of 52 male college Thai
dencies (19). Dhammakaya is one of various methods of Samad- students 20-25 years of age, who had never practiced medita-
hi meditation. This method signifies the concentration of the tion before joining the Dhammadayada program. This program
mind and thoughts upon a round clear glass ball object, free aimed to teach Dhammakaya meditation to college students for

543
544 SUDSUANG, CHENTANEZ AND VELUVAN

"FABLE 1
EFFECTS OF BUDDHIST MEDITATION ON SERUM CORTISOL LEVEL (ixg%*)

Before After 3 Weeks After 6 Weeks


Groups Meditation Meditation p Value Meditation p Value

Expt. Gr. A 12.33 +_ 2.82 9.02 _+ 1.31 <0.01 9.31 +_ 1.79 <0.01
(n = 15)
Expt. Gr. B 10.54 _+ 2.37 9.51 _+ 1.96 <0.01 10.40 _+ 2.04 NS
(n=27)
Expt. Gr. A + B 11.43 -- 2.59 9.26 _+ 1.63 <0.01 9.85 _ 1.91 <0.01
(n = 52)
Control group 11.39 +- 1.64 11.34 -+ 1.69 NS 11.43 +_ 1.39 NS
(n = 30)
Comparison between NS <0.01 <0.0l
Expt. Gr. A + B
and control
(p value)

*Values are expressed as mean -+ SD.


NS = not significant.

2 months during the summer vacation. All the subjects had to evaluated separately as well as together.
stay in the monastery as the monks, and had no other activities
except walking for about 1 km to receive food from people in Effects of Meditation on Serum Cortisol Level (Table 1)
the morning. The control group included 30 males who were
nonmeditating college students of the same age. This group In nonmeditators (control group), serum cortisol did not dif-
stayed at home for summer vacation, and no special religious fer significantly betwen the 3 times of measurement 3 weeks
activities were performed. apart. In experimental groups A and B, serum cortisol showed a
Serum cortisol level was examined by using a Gammacoat significant decrease (p<0.001) after the first 3 weeks of medita-
TM (1251) cortisol radioimmunoassay kit (Clinical Assay Divi- tion. After 6 weeks, the serum cortisol increased somewhat from
sion of Laboratories Inc.) (25). Serum total protein level was the first 3 weeks, but in group A it was still significantly lower
assayed by the Biuret method (11,15). Blood pressure of sub- than before meditation (p<0.01). Serum cortisol in group B af-
jects in a sitting position was recorded by a standard mercury ter 6 weeks was not significantly different from before medita-
sphygmomanometer. Radial pulse was determined for pulse rate. tion. The experimental group as a whole revealed a significant
An Autospiro AS-500 was used to measure vital capacity (VC), decrease in serum cortisol after meditation at both 3 weeks and
tidal volume (TV), inspiratory reserve volume (IRV), expiratory 6 weeks.
reserve volume (ERV) and maximal voluntary ventilation (MVV).
Reaction time was recorded with a visual choice reaction time Effects of Meditation on Serum Total Protein (Table 2)
machine.
The measurements were performed before the meditation In nonmeditators (control group), the serum total protein did
program began, at 3 weeks and at 6 weeks into the program. not significantly differ between the 3 measurements. In both
During the first 3 weeks after joining the program, the subjects meditator groups, the serum protein after 3 weeks showed no
practiced meditation for 4 hours a day. In the last 3 weeks of significant difference from before practice, but after 6 weeks the
the program, they practiced 2 hours a day. Blood samples were serum total protein level in Group A exhibited a significant in-
collected between 9:30 and 10:00 a.m. and other parameters crease from before meditation (p<0.05).
were measured between 9:30 and 10:00 a.m., just after they had
finished practicing for 1 hour in the morning. Effects of Meditation on Blood Pressure (Table 3)
Subjects were asked to complete a questionnaire 3 weeks af-
ter the start of the program. The purpose of the questionnaire In both groups of meditators, systolic blood pressure and di-
was to obtain information about the feelings of the subjects dur- astolic blood pressure decreased significantly after 3 weeks
ing meditation and to classify the subjects. (p<0.01). The control subjects showed no decline. After 6
The parameters obtained before and after the meditational weeks of practice, blood pressure in group A only was signifi-
program were compared by using Student's t-test. The control cantly lower (p<0.01). In group B, blood pressure was higher
group was compared with the experimental group in the same than it was at 3 weeks, but still significantly lower than its ini-
statistical test. tial value before practice (p<0.05).

RESULTS Effects of Meditation on Pulse Rate (Table 4)

On the basis of the questionnaires, the experimental group Both experimental groups illustrated a significant decrease in
was divided into two categories before analysis of the data: pulse rate after meditation (p<0.01 in group A and p < 0 . 0 5 in
group A, who were able to meditate successfully each time and group B) compared with before practice and with that of non-
achieve a state of ~anquility, and group B, who were not able meditators. In nonmeditators, there was no change in pulse rate
to achieve this consistently. The responses of the groups were in 3 measurements.
PHYSIOLOGICAL EFFECTS OF MEDITATION 545

TABLE 2
EFFECTS OF BUDDHIST MEDITATION ON SERUM TOTAL PROTEIN (g%*)

Before After 3 Weeks After 6 Weeks


Groups Meditation Meditation p Value Meditation p Value

Expt. Gr. A 7.69 ± 0.98 8.17 -+ 1.19 NS 8.43 --- 0.54 <0.05
(n = 15)
Expt. Gr. B 7.75 +-- 0.95 7.87 +-- 1.08 NS 7.9 - 0.95 NS
(n = 37)
Expt. Gr. A + B 7.72 --- 0.96 8.02 --- 1.13 NS 8.16 --- 0.74 <1.01
(n = 52)
Control group 7.75 - 0.77 7.79 --- 0.43 NS 7.72 _+ 0.83 NS
(n = 30)
Comparison NS NS <0.05
between Gr. A + B
and control
(p value)

*Values are expressed as mean - SD.


NS = not significant.

Effects of Meditation on Pulmonary Ventilation Volume T h e percentage decrease in reaction time w a s largest in experi-
(Table 5) mental g r o u p A (19% after 3 w e e k s a n d 23% after 6 weeks). In
experimental G r o u p B, the percentage decrease (13% after 3
Vital capacity, tidal v o l u m e and m a x i m a l voluntary ventila-
w e e k s and 20% after 6 weeks) w a s greater than o f the control
tion in all e x p e r i m e n t a l g r o u p s were significantly lower after
group. In the control group, the percentage decrease w a s 5% af-
practicing meditation than before ( p < 0 . 0 5 ) . T h e inspiratory and
ter 3 w e e k s and 7% after 6 weeks.
expiratory reserve v o l u m e s were not c h a n g e d , h o w e v e r .

Effects of Meditation on Reaction Time (Table 6) DISCUSSION


Both the control group a n d the e x p e r i m e n t a l g r o u p s exhibited
significant d e c r e a s e s in reaction time after 3 w e e k s and 6 weeks. T h e results o f the present study indicate that B u d d h i s t medi-

TABLE 3
EFFECTS OF BUDDHIST MEDITATION ON SYSTOLIC BLOOD PRESSURE AND DIASTOLIC BLOOD PRESSURE (mmHg*)

Before After 3 Weeks After 6 Weeks


Groups Meditation Meditation p Value Meditation p Value

Expt. Gr. A 111.33 ± 8.33 103.73 --+ 8.97 <0.01 104.66 --- 10.06 <0.01
Systolic BP.
Diastolic BP. 73.33 _+ 6.17 64.0 ± 8.28 <0.01 64.33 • 6.39 <0.01
(n = 15)
Expt. Gr. B 116.72 --+ 9.50 107.83 __. 10.03 <0.01 113.78 - 12.50 <0.05
Systolic BP.
Diastolic BP. 74.59 _ 8.02 66.48 --- 10.59 <0.01 70.27 ___ 9.27 <0.05
(n = 37)
Epr. Gr. A + B 114.02 --- 8.91 105.78 ___ 9.50 <0.01 109.22 _ 11.55 <0.01
Systolic BP.
Diastolic BP. 73.96 --- 7.09 65.24 ± 9.43 <0.01 67.80 - 7.83 <0.01
(n = 52)
Control 115.16 - 12.14 117.10 _ 9.78 NS 116.83 __. 7.93 NS
Systolic BP.
Diastolic BP. 75.66 _+ 7.73 75.66 + 7.73 NS 76.33 ± 6.68 NS
(n = 30)
Comparison between
Expt. Gr. A + B and
control (p value)
Systolic BP. NS <0.01 <0.01
Diastolic BP. NS <0.01 <0.01
*Values are expressed as mean ___ SD.
NS = not significant.
546 SUDSUANG, CHENTANEZ AND VELUVAN

TABLE 4
EFFECTS OF BUDDHIST MEDITATION ON HEART RATE (BEATS/MIN*)

Before After 3 Weeks Alter 6 Weeks


Groups Meditation Meditation p Value Meditation p Value

Expt. Gr. A 83.69 -+ 11.29 72.13 _~ 6.52 <0.01 74.8 ± 9.15 <0.01
(n = 15)
Expt. Gr. B 80.75 -+ 6.98 75.13 -+ 9.15 <0.05 76.16 ± 8.63 <0.05
(n=37)
Expt. Gr. A + B 82.17 -+ 9.13 73.63 -+ 7.83 <0.01 75.45 ± 8.89 <0.01
(n=52)
Control group 80.26 -+ 5.24 80.06 ± 4.40 NS 80.73 -+ 7.72 NS
(n = 30)
Comparison between NS <0.01 <0.05
between Gr. A + B
and control (p value)

*Values are expressed as mean _+ SD.


NS = not significant.

tational practice produces reductions in serum cortisol level, meditational practice may be related to an increase in total pro-
blood pressure, pulse rate, vital capacity, tidal volume, maximal tein because of reduction of gluconeogenesis and increased total
voluntary ventilation and reaction time. The serum total protein protein synthesis by the liver (8).
level increased after 6 weeks of meditation. The cortisol level Blood pressure and pulse rate decreased significantly after
has been proposed to be an index of stress in physiology (16). meditation practice (Tables 3 and 4). The tranquility during
Therefore, Buddhist meditation may reduce some stress in a way practice may have been responsible for a decrease in autonomic
similar to transcendental meditation (21). In experimental group function and reduced blood pressure and pulse rate. Studies of
A, the subjects claimed that they were in a state of tranquility transcendental meditation or other kinds of meditation have
every time during their practice, and in this group the serum shown similar effects on pulse rate (18, 20, 21) and blood pres-
cortisol showed the lowest levels. In experimental group B, who sure (3, 6, 22). A decrease in blood pressure can occur in hy-
were able to encounter the state of tranquility some times but pertensive subjects who practice meditation (2). Hafner (9) reported
not every time, the serum cortisol decreased after 3 weeks of that meditation plus biofeedback-aided relaxation produced a fall
practice, but increased somewhat after 6 weeks of practice (Ta- in diastolic blood pressure earlier in the training program than
ble 1). This rise could be due to shortening of the period of did meditation alone.
practice from 4 hours to 2 hours a day. It has been suggested The reduction of lung volume in this study probably indicates
that discontinuous practice or reduction of the period of practice a lower need for oxygen by the body. However, the reduced
can reverse the state of tranquility of the mind (19). values were still within normal limits. Wallace and Benson (21)
Experimental group A had elevated serum total protein after reported decreases in respiratory rates and oxygen consumption
6 weeks of meditation (Table 2). Sitprija and Suvanpha (17) during transcendental meditation. The data of Pellitier and Garfield
studied chronic renal failure in Buddhist monks and found that (14) showed a 3-fold decrease of metabolic rate during medita-
the monks who practiced meditation were not in the state of se- tion. Wolkove et al. (24) suggested that the decrease in minute
vere uremia during the 3 year period of study. This suggests that ventilation during transcendental meditation was due to a de-
meditational practice might have reduced protein metabolism, crease in tidal volume resulting from a shortened inspiratory
which in turn reduced uremia. The cortisol reduction during time. Oxygen consumption and metabolic rate should be studied

TABLE 5
EFFECTS OF BUDDHIST MEDITATION (EXPT. GR. A + B) ON PULMONARY VENTILATIONVOLUME (LITRES*) (n = 12)

Ventilation Before After 3 Weeks After 6 Weeks


Volume Meditation Meditation p Value Meditation p Value

Vital capacity 3.76 ± 0.48 3.38 + 0.65 <0.05 3.29 + 0.58 <0.05
Tidal volume 1.25 - 0.82 1.03 ± 0.60 <0.05 0.99 ± 0.79 <0.05
Inspiratory 1.33 ± 0.54 1.28 ± 0.70 NS 1.35 --- 0.67 NS
reserve volume
Expiratory 1.06 --- 0.42 1.08 - 0.44 NS 0.95 ± 0.58 NS
reserve volume
Maximal voluntary 127.79 ± 29.4 119.06 ± 30.95 <0.05 121.0 +__ 28.3 <0.05
ventilation
*Values are expressed as mean -+ SD.
NS = not significant.
PHYSIOLOGICAL EFFECTS OF MEDITATION 547

TABLE 6
EFFECT OF BUDDHIST MEDITATION ON REACTION TIME (MS)*

Before After 3 Weeks % After 6 Weeks %


Groups Meditation Meditation Decrease p Value Meditation Decrease p Value

Expt. Gr. A 236.87 --- 29.12 191.12 --- 49.58 19 0.01 180.75 --- 32.65 23 0.01
(n = 8)
Expt. Gr. B 244.31 ± 37.39 210.06 --- 42.66 13 0.01 194.75 - 38.33 20 0.01
(n = 32)
Expt. Gr. A + B 240.59 - 33.25 200.59 _-. 46.12 16 0.01 187.57 --. 35.49 22 0.01
(n = 40)
Control 255.33 -4- 30.93 241.55 +-- 37.79 5 0.01 237.73 --- 41.62 7 0.01
(n = 30)
Comparison NS <0.01 -- -- <0.01 -- --
between Expt.
Gr. A + B and
control (P value)

*Value are expressed as mean ± SD.


NS = not significant.

further in Buddhist meditation to clarify the effects on respira- after practicing the technique. In other studies (1, 18, 20), mea-
tory action. surements were taken during practice and compared with those
The reaction time in experimental group A was 23% lower taken before and after practice. These studies also used subjects
than that measured before practice (Table 6). This may indicate who were experts with years of practice. In our experiment, we
that nerve conduction velocity in the visual reaction circuit is started with subjects who had never practiced before, and then
increased after meditation. Orme-Johnson (13) reported that peo- practiced only a short period of 4 - 8 weeks. We are unable to
ple practicing the transcendental meditation technique had faster verify if the different techniques of meditation produce similar
reactions after a period of meditation than after a period of rest. physiological measurements because they produce the same state
The reduction of reaction time could be due to a variety of fac- of tranquility in the subjects. However, a recent report (4) on
tors, such as closer attention, reduced anxiety and excitement, Tibetan Buddhist monks using advanced Buddhist meditation
and appropriate arousal. Hebb (10) claims that psychomotor per- techniques suggested that such meditative practices may yield
formance is low at both extremes of the arousal continuum, i.e., different alterations in metabolism (there are forms of medita-
in situations of boredom or sleepiness and in situations of hy- tion that increase metabolism). The mechanisms involved in
perstimulation or overly strong environmental demands. The re- producing these effects remain unclear and invite further investi-
duction in reaction time in our control group (7%) may have gation.
been due to the repetition of performance or training: the reduc-
tion in the experimental groups was therefore not entirely due to
effects of meditation practice. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The present study shows that Dhammakaya meditation pro-
We are grateful to Dr. Warren Y. Brookelman for reading the manu-
duces effects similar to Zen or transcendental meditation. In our script and giving us helpful advice, and also to Mr. Maethee Visutthi-
study, however, the timing of measurements was different from varn for his secretarial help. This work was supported by Rajadaphisek
other studies in that we measured variables before learning and Sombodhi Grant, Faculty of Medicine, Chulalongkorn University.

REFERENCES
1. Anand, B. K.; Chhina, G. S.; Singh, B. Some aspects of EEG dental meditation technique. Psychosom. Med. 42(2):133-153;
studies on yogis. Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. 13:452- 1982.
456; 1961. 8. Ganong, W. F. Review of medical physiology. 14th ed. Los Altos,
2. Benson, H.; Wallace, R. K.. Decreased blood pressure in hyperten- CA: Lange Medical Publishers; 1989:245-250.
sive subjects who practiced meditation. Circulation 45(Suppl. II): 9. Hafner, R. J. Psychological treatment of essential hypertension: A
516; 1972. controlled comparison of meditation and meditation plus biofeed-
3. Benson, H.; Alexander, S. Feldrnan, C. L. Decreased premature back. Biofeedback Self Regul. 7(3):305-316; 1982.
ventricular contractions through the use of relaxation response in 10. Hebb, D. O. Drives and the C.N.S. (conception nervous system).
patient with stable ischemic heart disease, Lancet 2:380-382; 1975. Psychol. Rev. 62:243-254; 1955.
4. Benson, H.; Malholtra, M. S.; Goldman, R. F.; Jacobs, G. B.; 11. Henry, R. J.; Sobel, C.; Berkan, S. Plasma protein analysis. Anal.
Hopkins, P. J. Three case reports of the metabolic and electroen- Chem. 92:149; 1957.
cephalographic changes during advanced Buddhist Meditation tech- 12. Grimstone, A. V., ed. Katsuki Sekida: Zen training, methods and
niques. Behav. Med. 16(2):90-95; 1990. philosophy. 1st ed. New York: Weatherhill; 1975.
5. Bloomfield, H. H.; Cain, M. P.; Jaffe, D. T. Transcendental medi- 13. Orme-Johnson D.W.; Kolb, D.; Hebert, J. R. An experimental
tation. New York: Delacorte Press; 1975. analysis of the effects of the transcendental meditation technique on
6. Detay, K.; Deshmukh, S.; Dalvi, C.; Venikar, S. Shavasan: Ayogis reaction time. Scientific research on the transcendental meditation
exercise in the management of hypertension. Angiology 20:325-333; program, collected paper. 1:326-330; 1977.
1969. 14. Pellitier, K.; Grafield, C. Consciousness, east and west. New York:
7. Farrow, J. T.; Hebert, J. R. Breath suspension during the transcen- Harper and Row; 1976.
548 SUDSUANG, CHENTANEZ AND VELUVAN

15. Rice, J. D. Determination of serum protein levels: Biuret method. 22. Wallace, R. K.; Silver, J.: Mills, P. J.; Dillbeck, M. (_'~; Wagoner,
Am. J. Clin. Pathol. 45:277; 1966. D. E. Systolic blood pressure and long-term practice ~)1"the tra1~
t6. Selye, H. Present status of the stress concept. Clin. Ther. 1(1):3- scendental meditation and TM-Sidhi program: Effects of TM ~n
19; 1977. systolic blood pressure. Psychosom. Med. 45(1):41-46; 1983.
17. Sitprija, V.; Suvanpha, R. Low protein diet and chronic renal fail- 23. Werner, R. G.; Wallace, R. K.; Charles, B.; Jansen, G.; Stryker,
ure in Buddhist monks. Br. Med. J. 287:469-471; 1983. T.; Charmers, R. A. Long-term endocrinologic changes in subjects
18. Sugi, Y.; Akutsu, K. Studies on respiration and energy-metabolism practicing the transcendental meditation and TM-Sidhi program.
during sitting in Zazen. Res. J. Phys. Educ. 12:190-206; 1968. Psychosom. Med. 48:59-61; 1986.
19. Vajiranana Mahathera, P. Buddhist meditation in theory and prac- 24. Wolkove, N.; Kreisman, H.; Darragh, D.; Cohen, C.; Frank, H.
tice. Colombo, MD: Gunasena and Co., Ltd.; 1962:1-5. Effect of transcendental meditation on breathing and respiratory
20. Wallace, R. K. Physiological effects of transcendental meditation. control. J. Appt. Physiol. 56(3):607-612; 1984.
Science 167:]751-1754; 1970. 25. Yallow, R. S.; Benson, S. A. Cortisol radioimmunoassays. In:
21. Wallace, R. K.; Benson, H. The physiology of meditation. Sci. Odell, W. D.; Daughaday, W. H., eds. Principles of competitive
Am. 226(2):85-92; 1972. protein binding assays. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co.: 1971.

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen