Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
1. The research novelty: Rate the novelty and originality of the ideas or results presented
in the paper.
a. A pioneering piece of work. Striking novel ideas or results.
b. Significant original work and novel results.
c. Some interesting ideas and results on a subject well investigated.
d. Minor variations on a well investigated subject.
e. It has been said many times before.
4. The Clarity of Research Question: The clarity of research question/ problem and
relevance of the literature overview.
a. Problem is easily identified in the introductory section, and clearly related to
literature review.
b. Problem can be identified, and related to literature review.
c. Problem is incompletely reported, and the relevance to literature review is not
clear.
d. Problem is incomprehensible, and literature review is vague.
e. Problem is not reported, and literature is poorly reviewed.
7. Detailed Comment: If answer No. 6 is “Yes”, please justify your recommendation and
suggest improvements in :
a. Technical content
1. Makalah membahas tetang aplikasi atau implementasi odel Hadley-Within untuk
menyelesaikan masalah inventory di PT. XYZ, namun demikian perlu dijelaskan
secara lebih spesifik dari sekian banyak model, mengapa continuous review dan
Hadley-Within yang digunakan, sebaiknya salah satu model saja yang digunakan
dalam makalah ini.
2. Perlu penjelasan hubungan antara Continuous Review model dengan Model Hadley
Within dalam makalah ini karena keduanya dapat digunakan untuk menyelesaikan
masalah yang sama, dimana penyelesaian continuous review secara analitik
sedangkan Hadley Within Heuristik.
b. Presentation (ex: writing rules, format table, format picture, etc. )
Lihat detail komentar pada naskah.
8. Detailed Comment: If answer No. 6 is “No”, please justify your reason and suggest
improvements in technical content or presentation to the next paper.
a. Technical content
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________