Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Karly Brown
UWRT 1103
31 March 2018
The effectiveness of the criminal justice system remains a highly debated topic, leading
to the importance of rehabilitation within institutions for the incarcerated. The Oxford English
Dictionary defines the criminal justice system as, “The system of law enforcement that is directly
involved in apprehending, prosecuting, defending, sentencing, and punishing those who are
suspected or convicted of criminal offenses” (OED Online). An important term not included in
the definition is rehabilitation. Exploring the steps taken towards rehabilitation assisted in the
incarceration along with the rehabilitation programs offered in institutions. The psychological
impact incarceration has on a criminal, plus the significance it has on their chances of returning
when released can determine if incarcerating criminals strengthens them for society. The
progress of the criminal justice system shows through recidivism rates and comparisons between
other countries success. The percentage of citizens with knowledge on the criminal justice
system remains unknown, insisting that many would benefit from knowing basic information
while living in a country lead through democracy. The unanswered questions guided the
research, which enables an average citizen of the United States to understand and generate an
educated opinion on the effectiveness of institutions in America’s criminal justice system with
To thoroughly explore the effectiveness of the criminal justice system the comprehension
former privileges, status, or possessions by official decree, declaration, etc.,” is the definition of
rehabilitation according to the Oxford English Dictionary (OED Online). Prisons and jails
throughout the United States involve multiple different rehabilitation programs that are possibly
provided, such as high school classes, college courses, vocational training, and counseling.
While many institutions offered programs, through research I discovered some do not. The US
Department of Justice explained, nearly all federal prisons offer vocational training, but only 44
percent of private prisons and 7 percent of jails (“The Economic Impact”). The department also
stated that 84 percent of state prisons offer high school classes, while only 27 percent of state
prisons offer college courses (“The Economic Impact”). Roughly all federal prisons have alcohol
and drug rehabilitation programs, which is beneficial. The general public may not understand the
large need for rehabilitation programs, but the Bureau of Justice Statistics declared 68 percent of
state prison inmates had not received their high school diploma (Harlow, “Education”).
Rehabilitation programs for the addicted should hold a large focus because several inmates
received sentencing because of behaviors that supported their addiction habits and/ or found
guilty due to possession of illegal substances. The National Center on Addiction and Substance
abuse wrote, “65% of all U.S. inmates meet medical criteria for substance abuse addiction, only
11% receive any treatment” (“New CASA”). Inmates participation in the programs identify as
not mandatory, suggesting why fewer participate now than a decade ago. Statistics magnify
when discussing the topic of rehabilitation programs in the criminal justice system because they
An important question analyzed while researching was: Does being incarcerated better
someone for society? Institutions in the criminal justice system intend to teach inmates right
from wrong through consequences, but psychologists that worked with prisoners explain that
they do not establish enough attention on rehabilitation. Inmates receive expectations to re-enter
society as a productive citizen after being released. Based on the National Institute of Justice
study within three years of released 67.8 percent of prisoners were rearrested, within five years
76.6 percent of prisoners were rearrested, and of the prisoners who were rearrested, 56.7 percent
were rearrested by the end of the first year of being released (Office of Justice Programs).
Therefore, the high recidivism rates in the United States indicate incarceration does not better the
majority of criminals. Previous discoveries validate the introduction of the next question: Why
does the majority of released inmates get rearrested? It could represent a reflection evoked by the
challenges the individuals experience when trying to obtain a job because of their criminal
record. Men with criminal records create about 34 percent of all nonworking men ages 25 to 54,
noted by a recent New York Times/CBS News/Kaiser Family Foundation poll (Hamel,
“Kaiser”). Without a job transferring into a productive citizen becomes nearly impossible
because no job symbolizes no income. A lack of income can result in no house, no car, unpaid
bills and these situations can lead individuals back into their inappropriate behavior in order to
survive. Rehabilitation programs can produce a difference if they are used properly; in a way that
educates and guides individuals so that they become prepared to properly re-enter society.
Ultimately, the goal of incarceration is to encourage inmates to stray from their criminal
behaviors but it could viewed as setting the individuals up for failure through a never ending
cycle of crime and bad decisions. Institutions are capable of using a balance of punishment and
Punishment guides the institutions in the criminal justice system, instead of rehabilitation.
Providing mental health services and contributing scientific evidence to studies about the
purpose of imprisonment fulfills the job of a psychologists within a prison. Psychologists are
closely connected to rehabilitation, indicating why they validate as a great source of information
on the topic. They work many of the rehabilitation programs provided, such as screenings for
mental illnesses, group and individual therapy to assist with substance abuse, re-entry to society
counseling, and more. The prison population has rates of mental illness at least three times the
Research has shown some prisoners experience high levels of anxiety as well as other harmful
emotions when placed in solitary confinement for large amounts of time. The emotions can
continue when released because they lack the skills they need to properly cope with society.
Psychologists that contribute to the criminal justice system explain that the resources vary due to
the facilities being understaffed with psychologist plus the ones that are working experience a
large bulk of caseloads. A psychologist at Texas Tech University who has worked in federal and
state prisons and studies treatment methods for inmates, Robert Morgan, PhD, said, "Right now
there's such a focus on punishment--most criminal justice or correctional systems are punitive in
Punishment may be the way prisons function now, it does not present as the most effective or
that it will continue to overpower. “When properly implemented, work programs, education and
psychotherapy can ease prisoners' transitions to the free world,” said Craig Haney, PhD, a
constantly being generated in hopes of achieving a successful prison system that benefits the
When the United States criminal justice system is compared to other countries it
advances to an unpleasant shock. The US has the highest incarceration rate in the world,
obtained from the Bureau of Justice Statistics data. Stated on the American Civil Liberties Union
website the US holds only 5 percent of the world’s population but more than 20 percent of the
world’s prison population (“The Prison Crisis”). Issues within the criminal justice system seem
apparent, especially with the prison techniques used. Researching Norway, which has the
world’s most successful prison system assist in exploring areas of improvement in the US. One
source stated, “Norway’s incarceration rate just 75 per 100,000 people, compared to 707 people
for every 100,000 people in the US” (Benko, “The Radical”). Norway focuses on rehabilitating
their prisoners by attempting to prepare them for release so inmates will be ready to re-enter
society. Many Norway prisons are set up for normalcy, for example Halden prison includes
actual furniture, fully equipped kitchens, no uniforms, artwork, and bar-less windows. A prime
example that Norway’s main focus does not point to punishment and instead aims towards
sending all inmates back into society without their criminal behavior. Their prison systems show
signs of success, Norway’s recidivism rates are one of the lowest in the world at just 20 percent,
compared to the United States 76.6 percent within five years of being released (Benko, “The
Radical”). One concern with providing a prison focused on rehabilitation is the cost. The Halden
prison in Norway spends more than $93,000 per prisoner per year and the US spends about
$31,000 per year, which is three times less than Norway (Benko, “The Radical”). Due to the
large incarceration population annually the US manages to spend more than Norway. The
success of other countries continue to raise awareness on the most efficient approach when
rehabilitating inmates.
Brown 6
Currently, the perfect prison does not exist so the US prison system undoubtedly has
room for improvement. Multiple American citizens do not have any direct ties so they aren’t
necessarily inclined to understand the system and how it could improve. To better educate
myself on the topic researched, individuals who had first hand experience with the criminal
justice system held a priority. The first example is Bernard Kerik, a former police commissioner
of New York City who plead guilty to tax fraud and served three years in prison (“Prison
Rehabilitation or”). In an interview Kerik said, “you’re going to give him an education, if you
don’t teach him an education, if you don’t give him a GED, if you don’t teach him discipline and
you don’t teach him respect and you don’t. And we don’t, absolutely we do not choose what he
learns. He learns how to steal, cheat, lie, manipulate, gamble, and con. Most importantly he
learns that if he has a verbal altercation with someone it’s going to end in a cutting or a
beatdown” (“Prison Rehabilitation or”). Kerik was referring to what happens when someone is
incarcerated within the US prison system. People gain knowledge unconsciously, therefore a
beneficial education for inmates holds an importance if they’re expected to improve. The overall
opinion of Bernard Kerik portrays that prison does not better people for society and if anything it
worsens them. He feels as though this is due to the lack of rehabilitation programs, specifically
the ones that educate inmates as well as the quickness to sentence someone to prison. Kerik
prevails as a great source of non-biased knowledge on the topic because he obtained first hand
experience. He took part in both sides of the criminal justice system; someone who sentenced
people and tried to stop crime then later he became a prisoner due to crimes he committed.
After weeks of well developed research that was guided through multiple educated
questions based on the effectiveness of the United States criminal justice system, I built a
personal opinion. I do not believe that the system is effective which is due to the lack of
Brown 7
rehabilitation programs within the prison system. As I researched the topic I remained open
minded because I felt as though it would allow me to obtain the most honest information. I
realized that the majority of the information did not support the way the institutions within the
US system perform. Based on recidivism rates, incarceration rates, and opinions from those with
first hand experience it seems relatively impossible to not agree that the system needs
improvement. The improvement in the institutions would benefit the average American as well
as the incarcerated population. Less crime in the US creates safer communities. Efficient
amounts of rehabilitation programs such as academic education, vocational training, therapy, and
counseling would better prepare inmates once they’re released and need to re-enter society. It
would assist prisoners in a physical way because it would allow them to get a job but it would
also help them mentally due to the negative impact incarceration can have on ones emotions.
Finally, I feel that if rehabilitation programs are asserted within the institutions in the criminal
justice system of America, it could be the difference that reforms criminals into productive
citizens of society.
Overall, the criminal justice system plays a large role in America since over 2 million of
the population remain incarcerated. It foreshadows the ability criminals have for a chance of
improvement for society. The research provided basic knowledge along with the opinions from
individuals who have personal experience with the prison institutions. Large amounts of the
information shinned a light on the need for improvement through more and better equipped
rehabilitation programs. The importance for the average citizen of the United States to be aware
of the current techniques being used within the criminal justice system remains; in hopes to bring
awareness to the need for change. Many people fail to realize that the criminal justice system not
Works Citied
Benko, Jessica. “The Radical Humaneness of Norway's Halden Prison.” The New York Times,
Benson, Etienne, “Rehabilitate or punish?” American Psychological Association. vol. 34, no. 7,
Hamel, Liz, et al. “Kaiser Family Foundation/New York Times/CBS News Non-Employed
finding/kaiser-family-foundationnew-york-timescbs-news-non-employed-poll/. Accessed
6 Mar. 2018.
Harlow, Caroline Wolf. “Education and Correctional Populations.” Bureau of Justice Statistics
“New CASA* Report Finds: 65% of All U.S. Inmates Meet Medical Criteria for Substance
Abuse Addiction, Only 11% Receive Any Treatment.” The National Center on Addiction
2018.
Brown 9
“Programs Keep Inmates From Returning To Prison.” LAW from NPR. 17 Jun. 2014.
https://www.npr.org/2012/10/10/162652805/programs-keep-inmates-from-returning-to-
prison.
“The Economic Impact of Prison Rehabilitation Programs.” Penn Wharton Public Policy
publicpolicy.wharton.upenn.edu/live/news/2059-the-economic-impact-of-prison-
Tsai, Tyjen, and Paola Scommegna. “U.S. Has World’s Highest Incarceration Rate.” prb.org.
2018.
Brown 10