Sie sind auf Seite 1von 5

Persepolis - Debate Worksheet (Religion in politics)

Group Members: Earn, Praew, Orm, Pang, and Cliff  Class #: 1202

Topic: D​ oes religion create more violence or more peace? 


 
Print this worksheet and bring it for the class debate. Worksheets will be submitted to the instructor. 
 

Peace (possible arguements) Violence (Our side)


Argument 1 - make merit in a group
(united) ● Topic: Religion causes more
List arguments in bullet-point format. - moral principles violent in the world such as
war, which mostly happened
- humanitaritian
You may use phrases; complete between Christian and Islam
sentences are not required. assistance ● Example: The Crusades War is
- religion is a spiritual a religious war between
anchor Muslims and Christians,
- religion helps us to be basically to secure control
a good person holy places which justifies
- education (in the past) which religion is more
superior​. The war lasts for
-> religion
about 200 years.
● Concluding sentence:
Obviously, violence can
caused by religion such as war
among different religions.
● Death toll is at a high
rate(about 7 million people)
(Christians&Muslims)
● When Jerusalem was
captured, Muslim and Jewish
residents in the city were
killed, including women.

Sources - https://www.usip.org/pu - http://www.religioustoleranc


List websites, articles, videos, quotes, blications/2006/01/religi e.org/chr_maco1.htm​ (abt
and authors/organizations. ous-contributions-peace denominations)
making-when-religion-bri
ngs-peace-not-war

Argument 2 - Different denominations ● if people don’t follow, it


don’t matter-> buddhism means nothing + atheist also
List arguments in bullet-point format. - Some people twist and know e.g. south korea
misinterpret the religion ● different denominations
You may use phrases; complete → those who commit cause different belief ->
sentences are not required. crime in the name of conflict
religion does not really ● The main religion that causes
understand the teaching war are Christianity and
- not only religion that can Islam. Religion is very good
cause coflict→ country for providing moral sense of
and race etc. moral superiority on its
- the successful followers. This makes the
mediation the follower to feel superior and
Rome-based saying that ones that don’t
follow our religion is basically
Community of
wrong. Therefore, the
Sant'Egidio achieved to process of converting
help end the civil war heathens to christianity
in Mozambique in causes violence.
1992. ● Violence usually comes from
- racists (religion
discrimination)
● belife in religion, but don’t
follow the moral-> nothing
● emotion -> emotion over
moral -> greedy people +
revenge
● "And when you are praying,
do not use meaningless
repetition as the Gentiles do,
for they suppose that they will
be heard for their many
words.​ (Matthew 6:7)
● Heathens should burn in hell
because they are doing the
wrong thing.
● This belief that the follower is
superior than others is also in
Islam, and Jews religions.
● there are nearly 1.1 billion
Catholics, Catholics comprise
50 percent of all Christians
worldwide and 16 percent of
the world’s total population.
● “​Fight those who do not
believe in Allah or in the Last
Day and who do not consider
unlawful what Allah and His
Messenger have made
unlawful and who do not
adopt the religion of truth
from those who were given
the Scripture – [fight] until
they give the jizyah willingly
while they are humbled. ​–
Qur’an 9:29
● Quran (2:244​) - ​"Then fight in
the cause of Allah, and know
that Allah Heareth and
knoweth all things."
● Quran (3:56)​ - ​"As to those
whเดo reject faith, I will
punish them with terrible
agony in this world and in the
Hereafter, nor will they have
anyone to help."
● religion has potential to cause
more conflict → deal with
extreme thigns (god)

Sources - https://bible.knowing-jesus.co
List websites, articles, videos, quotes, m/topics/Heathen​ (the bible
and authors/organizations. about heathens)
- https://www.kingjamesbibleo
nline.org/Heathen/

Argument 3 - gather together to do ● Violence - "the intentional use


good things of physical force or power,
List arguments in bullet-point format. - religion is the ritual threatened or actual, against
anchor oneself
You may use phrases; complete - religion is what teach us ● difference beleif cause more
sentences are not required. to be a good person confilct
- living together peacefully ● power under the name of
by usuaing religion’s religion
morals

Sources http://www.salvationarmy.org.nz/our-c
List websites, articles, videos, quotes, ommunity/faith-in-life/soul-food/does-r
and authors/organizations. eligion-cause-war

 
 
 
 
 
 
Debate Format 
Main Arguments - Peace  4 minutes 
Main Arguments - Violence  4 minutes 

Working Period  4 minutes 

Rebuttals - Peace  3 minutes 


Rebuttals - Violence  3 minutes 

Working Period  3 minutes 

Summary - Peace  2 minutes 


Summary - Violence  2 minutes 

Audience Vote  Total Time = 25 minutes 

 
Audience Vote -- 5 Points 
Audience members will vote on who they believe makes the strongest, most well-supported arguments: 
● the quality of the arguments presented. 
● the quality of challenges (to your opponents) raised. 
● the clarity, organization and cohesiveness of the argument. 
● the quality of supporting evidence. 
 
● NOT​ on who they personally agree with.  
● NOT​ on who they are friends with. 
● NOT​ on who screams the loudest. 
 
 
 
 
 
 
To summarise, I am sure of what you have said is correct, but only in your perspective, because the truth is religion do 

cause violence, not it all cases, but certainly many. For example, the crusade war, according to professor Jonathan from 

Cambridge university, h
​ e had stated that the troops that went for the attack did not expect any wealth gain​, 

the ​primary motivation was the reward that they received which is was spiritual merit​from​ the priest​, this 

certainly​ shows that religion is used in ways that causes violence​. Moreover, it was said to be a​n act of sacrifice 

ands piety for the lord christ​. Are you convinced? Then, what about the verses that had been stated in the Qur’an 

where it says, I​ shall cast terror into the hearts of the infidels (non-believers). Strike off their heads, strike off 

the very fingertips​- Quran (8:12). Furthermore, The bible also said that f​ or these enemies of mine, who didn’t 

want me to reign over them, bring them here and slaughter them before me.​It contradicts with your verse (…) 

doesn’t it. So, what can the followers believe? But, the slaughtering people and religious war which seems to be the 

popular one, such as, the ISIS and the taliban terrorism which is based on religion (BBC). The bible and Qur’an 

certainly teaches how be a morally good person, but it doesn’t accept other religions, and ending them by using brute 

forces. Now isn’t that a valid evidence. I mention about christianity and Islam a lot because they are the two biggest 

religions in the world. Hence, religious wars, and conflicts in the world are because of them. Religions do shape a 

human’s perspective. Therefore, i hereby certify that religions do cause violence and also inflame conflicts between 

people’s peacefulness.   

Earn and Praew 

note :  

- a good person should not kill people ​ wa​r different denomination q


​ ou​tes 
- share common principle -> no kill​ ศลี 5 
- christ -> linving by moral values 
- act of violence who do is not religon people  
- to be united 
- avoid to do something wrong 
- approach love 
- islam -> peace (meaning) ISIS they don’t teach 
- not reali islamic people  
- war causwed by humans 
- to be a good person 
- one common principle, avoid the sin 
- ศีล5 
- to live by a moral value 
- teach about moral 
- not a religion people  
- teach people to be united 
- avoid to do something wrong 
- islam arabic → peace 
- for their want, not their need 
- war caused by huma 
 
Religion does possess a potential for extremism because it deals with extreme things. People
can compromise with small disputes over borders and territory, but people cannot compromise
with the will of God since it is absolute.  

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen