Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
2, S143–S152 (2002)
In certain laria–mosquito combinations, the number of infective, third-stage larvae (L3 ) that develop in a
mosquito is not proportional to the number of micro lariae (mV ) ingested by that mosquito. As the number of
mV ingested increases, the yield of L3 per micro laria may either increase (in a process known as ‘facilitation’)
or decrease (in a process known as ‘limitation’). Each ingested micro laria that is successful (in terms of reaching
the haemocoel) increases (facilitation) or decreases (limitation) the ‘permeability’ of the stomach wall for the next
micro laria. Limitation is seen in some culicine mosquitoes, especially the Aedes spp. that transmit Wuchereria
bancrofti, which, in consequence, become relatively more eYcient as vectors as they ingest fewer mV. This
phenomenon makes the interruption of larial transmission by Aedes spp. particularly diYcult.
As the survival of anopheline mosquitoes is adversely aVected by larial infection, the use of mass drug
administrations (MDA) to reduce the prevalence and intensity of micro laraemias may increase the mean life-
span of some of the local Anopheles species. If these same species also act as vectors of malarial parasites, eVective,
drug-based control of W. bancrofti may worsen the problem posed by malaria. Therefore, wherever malaria and
bancroftian lariasis are co-endemic and caused by parasites transmitted by the same species of mosquito, MDA
should be augmented by interventions (use of bednets or house-spraying ) against adult Anopheles.
vectors (Pichon, 1974a, b; Subramanian et al., ing/mosquito, and H is the inverse of the
1989, 1998) whereas facilitation ( positive regression slope coeYcient for yield ( y/x),
density-dependence) occurs in some of in the case of limitation, or for failure
the anopheline vectors (Pichon, 1974a, b; [1 ( y/x) ], in the case of facilitation. The
Southgate and Bryan, 1992). Both phen- H parameter is a measure of the ‘reciprocal
omena can be described mathematically adaptation’ for a particular vector–parasite
(Fig. 1), limitation as the equation: combination. The combinations giving high
values of H, such as the 20 estimated for Ae.
y=Hx/(x+H ) polynesiensis infected with W. bancrofti var.
paci ca, probably represent very ancient
and facilitation as:
adaptations (see Table). Pichon (1981) used
y =x [Hx/(x+H )] this assumption, and the results of other
studies on subperiodicity, to develop the
where x is the number of mV ingested/ hypothesis that W. bancrofti speciation might
mosquito, y the number of L 3 [or, in some have accompanied the ethnogenesis of the
analyses, of rst-stage larvae (L1 )] develop- Polynesians.
FIG. 1. A diagrammatic representation of limitation (L) and facilitation (F), here shown for the production of
rst-stage larvae (L1 ) from ingested micro lariae. H, the inverse of the regression slope coeYcient b, allows for
measurement of the ‘reciprocal adaptation’ for a particular vector–parasite combination.
TABLE. Quanti cation of the limitation (H) in some of the culicine vectors of lariae and of the facilitation (H¾ ) in some of the anopheline vectors
limitation
Aedes polynesiensis Sub-periodic Wuchereria bancrofti Tahiti L1 H=20 Rosen (1955)
L3 H=20 Prod’hon et al. (1980)
Ae. aegypti* Sub-periodic W. bancrofti Tahiti L1 H=10² Prod’hon et al. (1980)
L3 H=0 Prod’hon et al. (1980)
Ae. aegypti* Setaria labiato-papillosa Burkina Faso L1 H=3.5² Brengues and Bain (1972)
Culex quinquefasciatus* Sub-periodic W. bancrofti Tahiti L1 H=68² Prod’hon et al. (1980)
L3 H=0.3 Rosen (1955)
Cx. quinquefasciatus Periodic W. bancrofti Tanzania L3 H=3 Jordan and Goatly (1962)
Cx. quinquefasciatus Periodic W. bancrofti India L3 H=7 Subramanian et al. (1998)
Mansonia longipalpis Sub-periodic Brugia malayi Malaya L1 H=35² Wharton (1957b)
facilitation
Anopheles gambiae Periodic W. bancrofti Burkina Faso L1 H¾ =78 Brengues and Bain (1972)
L3 H¾ =78 Brengues and Bain (1972)
An. gambiae Periodic W. bancrofti Gambia L1 H¾ =120 Southgate and Bryan (1992)
An. arabiensis Periodic W. bancrofti Gambia L1 H¾ =42 Southgate and Bryan (1992)
An. melas Periodic W. bancrofti Gambia L1 H¾ =3.6 Southgate and Bryan(1992)
An. gambiae s.l. and An. funestus caused by If there is signi cant laria-attributable mor-
the rst-stage and second-stage larvae (L1 tality in the potential vectors of W. bancrofti,
and L2 ) of W. bancrofti. He found that the larial infection may limit the size of the
mean intensity of infection with the L1 or L2 population of these mosquitoes, especially
was signi cantly higher in the mosquitoes in areas where bancroftian lariasis is hyper-
coming to bite at night than in those cap- endemic. The reduction of the parasite
tured, while resting (in the same houses), population by MDA may thus produce an
on the following morning. Since the parasite increase in the numbers of the vector species.
load in these vector species only reduces
when parasites cross the stomach wall and
enter the haemocoel, the observed decrease
in larial load from night to morning could OTHER FACTORS
only be attributed to diVerential mortality
caused by the lariae in the infected In many areas, an MDA-induced increase
mosquitoes. in the mosquito biting rate may be a ‘price
Using a model of negative-exponential
worth paying’ to control LF. In some areas,
survival dependent on the parasite load
however, larial parasites are transmitted to
(Dietz, 1975; May, 1977; Pichon et al.,
the human population by the same Anopheles
1976, 1980b), Pichon et al. (1980b) found
spp. that transmit malarial parasites. For
that, if a mosquito contains one L1 , taking
a new bloodmeal decreases its probability of example, malarial parasites can be transmitted
survival to the next morning by a factor (h) to humans by the vectors of nocturnally
equal to 0.95. If the mosquito contains 10 periodic W. bancrofti in West Africa (An.
L 1 , its diVerential probability of survival funestus and the An. gambiae complex) and
during the next few hours is close to h10 Papua New Guinea (An. farauti and other
(=0.5). During the parasite’s development members of the An. punctulatus group) and
from L1 to L2 , the corresponding survival the vectors of nocturnally periodic B. malayi
coeYcient (h) is 0.84 for a burden of one in Malaysia (such as An. campestris and An.
larva, and 0.17 for a burden of 10 larvae. donaldi).
It is believed that the presence of larial Many factors will have to be considered
parasites in the thoracic muscles (which are if a realistic estimate of the impact of anti-
used for locomotion) slows down the speed larial MDA on malaria transmission is
of take-oV and of ight of the mosquito. In to be made: facilitation; diVerential vector
captivity, this phenomenon may be bene cial mortality; frequency of bloodmeals; level
to the mosquitoes, as it may reduce the risk of anthropophily; and the frequency distri-
of being wounded against the netting of the bution of infection intensities in the vectors
cage or from drowning in the water of biting an individual (Pichon et al., 1980a).
the oviposition container. However, under
The theoretical distribution of the parasites
natural conditions, an inability to respond
in each vector species of mosquito is a
quickly to the threat of predation (by ants,
zero-truncated negative binomial with para-
spiders, lizards etc.) is a serious handicap to
an infected mosquito. This could explain, at meter k =0.3 (Pichon et al., 1979; Grenfell
least in part, why the L 3 burdens observed et al., 1990; www.bondy.ird.fr/~pichon).
in the eld are generally much smaller than The potential impact of the MDA-based
those seen after experimental infections in eradication of micro laraemia on the survival
the laboratory. Most estimates of the laria- of a cohort of 100,000 female Anopheles
attributable mortality in mosquitoes are has been simulated (Fig. 3) using the Para-
probably under-estimates, as they take no Dis ‘freeware’ (www.bondy.ird.fr/~pichon/
account of any mortality caused while the paradis/parad2.html). It is estimated that, in
parasites are L3 . Tingrela, in Burkina Faso (a highly endemic
DYNAMICS OF FILARIAL TRANSMISSION 149
FIG. 3. Potential impact of the clearance of micro laraemia (using mass drug administrations) on the survival
of 100,000 potential vectors of human malaria. The two graphs indicate (a) the diVerential survival of a cohort
of Anopheles exposed to high micro laraemias, and (b) the survival of An. gambiae s.l. in the presence (d ) or
absence (s ) of micro laraemias. The arrows indicate periods of ‘post-prandial’ mortality attributable to the larial
development in the infected mosquitoes.
focus of LF; Brengues et al., 1975), the sup- Even if the true value is slightly higher than
pression of micro laraemia caused by MDA 233, it would still be too low to indicate that
would result in 233 potentially malaria- anti larial MDA (in areas where malaria and
infective mosquitoes for every 100 that there LF are co-endemic) would have an immense
would have been in the absence of MDA. impact on the prevalence of malaria or the
The value of 233 is almost certainly an under- level of malaria-attributable morbidity. (The
estimate as it takes no account of any laria- survival of most laria-positive mosquitoes
attributable mortality that may occur more is not markedly aVected by the infections
than 12 days after the ingestion of the mV. because the intensity of the infections is
150 PICHON
FIG. 4. The hypothetical relative durations of the malaria-transmission season (MTS) in areas where Wuchereria
bancrofti is hyper-endemic (h ) or absent (j ). Only in the laria-free area are the numbers of potential vectors of
malaria [surviving long enough to be infective (i.e. 12 days) ] high enough in June and October to support
signi cant malaria transmission in these months.
generally low.) In a highly endemic focus cularly of members of the An. gambiae com-
of LF in which each resident is bitten plex, can be estimated. Such mortality will
400 times a year by mosquitoes carrying have to be considered if the prevalence of
Plasmodium falciparum sporozoites, elimi- micro laraemia is to be accurately estimated
nation of the LF might increase the annual by xenomonitoring (Chadee et al., 2002;
number of malaria-infective bites to 900/ Ramzy, 2002; WHO, 2002).
resident. Although the impact of the MDA
on malaria may be slight, it may well be long
lasting. Moreover, in climates with a short
rainy season, the malaria-transmission period REFERENCES
could be lengthened by anti larial MDA
(Fig. 4). Therefore it is recommended that, Adams-Chapman, H. (1965). Rapport Annuel. Papeete,
in highly endemic LF foci where the mos- Tahiti: Institut de Recherches Médicales de Polynésie
Française.
quitoes acting as the larial vectors may also
Bain, O. (1971). Transmission des larioses. Limitation
be malarial vectors, anti larial MDA should des passages de micro laires ingérées vers l’hémocèle
be augmented with vector control (such as des vecteurs; interprétation. Annales de Parasitogie
the use of insecticide-treated bednets) and Humaine et Comparée, 46, 613–631.
adequate malaria surveillance. Similar obser- Brengues, J. & Bain, O. (1972). Passage des micro-
laires vers l’hémocèle du vecteur, dans les couples
vations to those of Brengues et al. (1975)
Wuchereria bancrofti–Anopheles gambiae, W. bancrofti–
should be made on other eld populations Aedes aegypti et Setaria labiatopapillosa–A. aegypti.
of larial vectors, so that the ‘post-prandial Cahiers O.R.S.T.O.M., Série d’Entomologie Médicale
parasitic over-mortality’ (PPPOM), parti- et Parasitologie, 10, 235–249.
DYNAMICS OF FILARIAL TRANSMISSION 151
Brengues, J. & Coz, J. (1972). Réceptivité comparée Pichon, G., Perrault, G. & Laigret, J. (1974).
de trois espèces du complexe Anopheles gambiae Rendement parasitaire chez les vecteurs de larioses.
présentes en Afrique de l’Ouest vis-à-vis de Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 51,
Wuchereria bancrofti. Cahiers O.R.S.T.O.M., Série 517–524.
d’Entomologie Médicale et Parasitologie, 10, 207–215. Pichon, G., Prod’hon, J. & Rivière, F. (1975).
Brengues, J., Bouchite, B., Nelson, G., Ouedrago, C., Distribution des Micro laires ingérées par les Moustiques.
Gbaguidi, P., Oyemkouma, A. & Ochoumaré, J. Document WHO/FIL/75.139. Geneva: World Health
(1975). La Filariose de Bancroft en Afrique de l’Ouest. Organization.
Mémoires ORSTOM No. 79. Paris: OYce de la Pichon, G., Prod’hon, J. & Rivière, F. (1976).
Recherche Scienti que et Technique d’Outre-Mer. Rendement Parasitaire chez les Vecteurs de Filarioses.
Burkot, T. R. & Ichimori, K. (2002). The Paci c III. In uence combinée de la Mortalité Vectorielle
program for the elimination of lymphatic lariasis: due au Parasitisme et du Surpeuplement Parasitaire.
will mass drug administration be enough? Trends in Document WHO/FIL/76.140. Geneva: World Health
Parasitology, 18, 109–115. Organization.
Burkot, T. R., Taleo, G., Toeaso, V. & Ichimori, K.
Pichon, G., Merlin, M., Fagneaux, F., Rivière, F. &
(2002). Progress towards, and challenges for, the
Laigret, J. (1979). Etude de la distribution des
elimination of lariasis from Paci c-island com-
densités micro lariennes dans des foyers de lariose
munities. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology,
lymphatique. Tropenmedizin und Parasitologie, 31,
96 (Suppl. 2), S61–S69.
165–180.
Chadee, D. D., Williams, S. A. & Ottesen, E. A. (2002).
Pichon, G., Prod’hon, J. & Rivière, F. (1980a).
Xenomonitoring of Culex quinquefasciatus mosquitoes
as a guide for detecting the presence or absence of Hétérogénéité de l’ingestion des parasites sanguicoles
lymphatic lariasis: a preliminary protocol. Annals of par leurs vecteurs: description quantitative et
Tropical Medicine and Parasitology, 96 (Suppl. 2), interprétation. Comptes Rendu de l’Académie des
S47–S53. Sciences de Paris, Série Biologie, 18, 1011–1013.
Dietz, K. (1975). An Epidemiological Model for Filarial Pichon, G., Prod’hon, J. & Rivière, F. (1980b).
Infections. Geneva: World Health Organization. Filarioses: surdispersion parasitaire et surinfection
Esterre, P., Plichart, C., Sechan, Y. & Nguyen, N. L. de l’ho̧te invertébré. Cahiers O.R.S.T.O.M., Série
(2001). The impact of 34 years of massive DEC d’Entomologie Médicale et Parasitologie, 18, 27–48.
chemotherapy on Wuchereria bancrofti infection and Prod’hon, J., Pichon, G., Rivière, F., Dejardin, J.,
transmission: the Maupiti cohort. Tropical Medicine Géry, M., Doué, F., Faugère, C. & Verneuil, M. P.
and International Health, 6, 190–195. (1980). Etude quantitative de la réduction parasitaire
Jordan, P. & Goatly, K. D. (1962). Bancroftian lariasis stomacale chez les vecteurs de larioses. Cahiers
in Tanganyika: a quantitative study of the uptake, O.R.S.T.O.M., Série d’Entomologie Médicale et
fate and development of micro lariae of Wuchereria Parasitologie, 18, 13–26.
bancrofti in Culex fatigans. Annals of Tropical Medicine Ramzy, R. M. R. (2002). Field application of PCR-
and Parasitology, 56, 173–187. based assays for monitoring Wuchereria bancrofti
Lardeux, F., Rivière, F., Séchan, Y. & Loncke, S. infection in Africa. Annals of Tropical Medicine and
(2002). Control of the Aedes vectors of the dengue Parasitology, 96 (Suppl. 2), S55–S59.
viruses and Wuchereria bancrofti: the French Rosen, L. (1955). Observations on the epidemiology of
Polynesian experience. Annals of Tropical Medicine human lariasis in French Oceania. American Journal
and Parasitology, 96 (Suppl. 2), S105–S116. of Hygiene, 61, 219–248.
May, R. M. (1977). Dynamical aspects of host–parasite Southgate, B. A. & Bryan, J. H. (1992). Factors
associations: Crofton’s model revisited. Parasitology,
aVecting transmission of Wuchereria bancrofti by
75, 259–276.
anopheline mosquitoes. 4. Facilitation, limitation,
Pichon, G. (1974a). Relations mathématiques entre
proportionality and their epidemiological signi cance.
le nombre des micro laires ingérées et le nombre
Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine
de parasites chez diVérents vecteurs naturels ou
expérimentaux de larioses. Cahiers O.R.S.T.O.M., and Hygiene, 86, 523–530.
Série d’Entomologie Médicale et Parasitologie, 12, Subramanian, S., Vanamail, P., Ramaiah, K. D.,
199–216. Pani, S. P. & Das, P. K. (1989). A single deterministic
Pichon, G. (1974b). Etude mathématique de la model for host–parasite relationship in Wuchereria
réduction parasitaire chez diVérents vecteurs naturels bancrofti and its relevance to regulation of parasite in
ou expérimentaux de larioses. Comptes Rendu de human host. Indian Journal of Medical Research, 89,
l’Académie des Sciences de Paris, Série Biologie, 278, 411–417.
3095–3098. Subramanian, S., Krishnamoorthy, K., Ramaiah, K. D.,
Pichon, G. (1981). Migration des micro laires et des Habbema, J. D. F., Das, P. K. & Plaisier, A. P.
peuples océaniens. Annales de Parasitologie Humaine (1998). The relationship between micro larial load
et Comparée, 56, 107–120. in the human host and uptake and development of
152 PICHON
Wuchereria bancrofti micro lariae by Culex quinque- Wharton, R. H. (1957a). Studies on lariasis in Malaya:
fasciatus: a study under natural conditions. Parasitology, observations on the development of Wuchereria
116, 243–255. malayi in Mansonia (Mansonioides) longipalpis. Annals
Webber, R. H. (1977). The natural decline of Wucheria of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology, 51, 278–296.
bancrofti infection in a vector control situation in the Wharton, R. H. (1957b). Studies on lariasis in Malaya:
Solomon Islands, Transactions of the Royal Society of the eYciency of Mansonia longipalpis as an experi-
Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 71, 396–400. mental vector of Wuchereria malayi. Annals of Tropical
Webber, R. H. (1979). Eradication of Wuchereria Medicine and Parasitology, 51, 422–439.
bancrofti infection through vector control. Trans-
World Health Organization (2002). De ning the Roles
actions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and
of Vector Control and Xenomonitoring in the Global
Hygiene, 73, 722–724.
Programme to Eliminate Lymphatic Filariasis. Report of
Webber, R. H. (1991). Can anopheline-transmitted
lariasis be eradicated? Journal of Tropical Medicine the Informal Consultation held at WHO/HQ, Geneva,
and Hygiene, 94, 241–244. 29–31 January 2002. Document WHO/CDS/CPE/
Webber, R. H. & Southgate, B. A. (1981). The maxi- PVC/2002.3. Geneva: WHO.
mum density of anopheline mosquitoes that can be Zang, S. Q., Zang, Q. G., Cheng, F., Wang, L. L. &
permitted in the absence of continuing transmission Pen, G. P. (1991). Threshold of transmission of
of lariasis. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Brugia malayi by Anopheles sinensis. Journal of Tropical
Medicine and Hygiene, 75, 409–506. Medicine and Hygiene, 94, 245–250.