Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Corruption in Sports
Cameron K. Fischi
Abstract
Winning is the goal in sports; but there are people who go behind the rules to win. Corruption
within sports is becoming a prevalent problem with all ages. In today's world, high school sports
are being corrupted, which lead to college and professional sports being corrupt. Performance
enhancing drugs and sports gambling are the two main types of corruption, but there are a
multitude of other forms. This paper will outline and describe the different forms, while giving
examples and evidence to back up my case. The paper entails a court case, a profuse amount of
laws, and the consequences. After reading this paper the goal is for the reading to have a better
Corruption in Sports
The days of just playing amateur sports have significantly changed; elite athletes at all
levels are becoming more competitive with a greater emphasis on winning. The mindset
imprinted on athletes has caused them to find different ways to make themselves better than their
competition. The two main forms of corruption include fixing games through gambling and
performance enhancing drugs. Depending on the person, the question of whether or not gambling
and performance enhancing drugs should be legal in sports is when the line becomes blurry.
Essentially, the question is asking if whether or not people want to see some players with unfair
advantage, while others do not. This is called cheating. In reality, players are always trying to
find different ways to give them an upper hand; however, this could be limited if performance
enhancing drugs and gambling were legalized. The National Center for Biotechnology
Information, a government run website, states that performance enhancing drugs improve a
person’s strength, endurance, and allow the body to recover quickly from vigorous exercises
(Handelsman). Sports gambling can best be described through The Professional and Amateur
Sports Protection Act of 1992, also known as the Bradley Act, attempts to define the legal status
of sports betting throughout the United States (Handelsman). This act effectively outlawed sports
betting nationwide, excluding a few states. The topic of sports gambling and performance
enhancing drugs has been a hot topic in sports, especially in the National Basketball Association
In the United States of America there are about 21.5 million kids between the ages of 6
and 17 playing team sports (Atkinson). Out of those 21.5 million kids, only 7.8 million of them
play high school sports (Atkinson). Roughly 8 million students play high school sports, and
CORRUPTION IN SPORTS 4
from those eight million, only 460,000 compete in NCAA sports (Atkinson). Out of the 460,000
college athletes, only tiny fractions play a professional sport. The chances of someone becoming
a professional athlete are slim. Some athletes even think they have the inside track to athletic
success- performance enhancing drugs. Performance enhancing drugs are chemicals used to
continues to become more challenging, and because of this, athletes need to find a way to make
themselves better than their competition. Athletes will do whatever it takes to become better
than their competition. This mentality makes athletes use performance enhancing drugs, so they
are able to be better than the competition the person is competing against. However,
performance enhancing drugs are a form of cheating and are illegal in the United States. Using
performance enhancing drugs improves a person’s strength, endurance, and allow the body to
recover quickly from vigorous exercises (Handelsman). Performance enhancing drugs also
create health problems that include liver and kidney damage, cholesterol problems, impair heart
functions, lung blood clots, and many more serious health problems (Handelsman). Taking
performance enhancing drugs comes with a mammoth risk. While the benefits of taking
performance enhancing drugs improve one, it is not worth the risk of being banned from the
sport and the health risks. Subsequently, there are people who favor the legalization of
performance enhancing drugs. People who are pro legalization of performance enhancing drugs
argue that the pressure of athletes is focused on winning or being in first. This mindset for
athletes has tempted even more athletes than ever before. Even though performance enhancing
drugs has been given a negative connotation, it actually can have a positive impact on sports. If
performance enhancing drugs were legalized, doctors would be able to limit the side effects
(Handelsman). Nevertheless, the skeptics are going to question the ethical concerns behind using
CORRUPTION IN SPORTS 5
performance enhancing drugs and its fairness and clarity of the game. Each sport has a set of
guidelines in place to prevent and or stop athletes from gaining an unequal advantage or
opportunity. The use of performance enhancing drugs infringes all such ideas of equality and
fairness. However, arguments have been made that genetic predisposition provides an unfair
advantage because some people are naturally more fit than others (Handelsman). An example of
when genetics have increased the athlete’s abilities is three-time cross-country skiing gold medal
winner Eero Mäntyranta. He had a genetic mutation had caused him to have naturally higher red
blood cell counts. At the end of the day, most people come to the events to enjoy a nail biting
finish. In the fan's eye, sports are an entertainment. Fans come to sporting events to watch
athletes play good and win. A way to play better and increase a chance in winning is by using
performance enhancing drugs. No fan wants to watch a 1-0 baseball game or a 7-3 football.
Fans come to see excitement, and performance enhancing drugs is a way to bring more
excitement to sports!
Performance enhancing drugs is becoming a popular trend with baseball players. The
Major League Baseball (MLB) has enforced a system to crack down on players using
performance enhancing drugs. Manny Ramirez was a talented hitter who could not stop taking
steroids. His first offense occurred in 2009 because he tested positive for human chorionic
100 game suspension, but he chose to retire. After a year into retirement, Ramirez asked to be
reinstated, but in order for that to happen he had to serve another 50 game suspension (Jussim).
Another example, is Dee Gordon, a quick infielder for the Miami Marlins at the time. He
received an 80 game suspension for violating MLBs performance enhancing drug policy
(Jussim). Starling Marte, another talented baseball player, who can be added to the list of players
CORRUPTION IN SPORTS 6
who tested positive for performance enhancing drugs. The Biogenesis scandal exposed Ryan
Braun and Alex Rodriguez of using performance enhancing drugs. Ryan Braun, a top outfielder
in the league, was suspended 65 games. Alex Rodriguez, a superstar in the MLB, was suspended
211 games. Two baseball players who allegedly took PEDs are Roger Clemens and Barry Bonds.
Throughout Mr. Clemens baseball career he has always denied the accusations of using
performance enhancing drugs, but there is still a suspicion that he used back in the day. Barry
Bonds was caught up in a scandal with steroids, which he claims he did not know they were
steroids. He was convicted of obstruction of justice charges, but they were later overturned
(Jussim). Bonds was cleared of all his charges, but he is still un able to be in the Hall of Fame
because of the performance enhancing drug scandal. These drugs have increasingly became more
popular throughout the game of baseball and the MLB needs to find a solution in order to keep
Sports Gambling
Sports gambling can be best defined as a betting action involved with the prediction of a
sporting event and placing a wager on the outcome of that event in order to win money (Fox).
Sports gambling may seem like a simplistic idea on ground level, but it is more complex than it
sounds. Betting on a game can lead to bribery of a public official, fraud, and corruption within
the sport; these crimes are all considered federal charges. According to Legal Information
Institute, a reputable online legal website that has provided law since 1992, 18 U.S. Code § 201 -
Whoever—
(1) directly or indirectly, corruptly gives, offers or promises anything of value to any
CORRUPTION IN SPORTS 7
public official or person who has been selected to be a public official, or offers or
promises any public official or any person who has been selected to be a public official to
(B)
to influence such public official or person who has been selected to be a public official to
commit or aid in committing, or collude in, or allow, any fraud, or make opportunity for
There has been a recent scandal of bribery within NCAA Men’s Basketball. The Federal
Bureau of Investigation (FBI) has been investigating the NCAA for awhile now, and a couple
months ago, four college basketball coaches were charged with federal fraud and corruption.
Also, major sporting companies and representatives were charged with federal crimes from the
fallout. Coaches of different schools at top basketball programs were receiving cash bribes and
employers of Adidas were funneling money to high school recruits and their families. The
investigation has continued for the FBI and United States Attorney Offices (USAO), which has
led to the discovery of more bribes from athletic advisors to student athletes. The NCAA has had
numerous problems with corruption in sports, but the Boston College point shaving scandal is at
the top of the list. In 1980, the fixing of games was uncovered because of the Lufthansa heist.
The Lufthansa heist was $6 million robbery at Kennedy Airport in 1978- one of the largest cash
thefts in American history (“Mobster”). The heist inadvertently occurred during the point
shaving scandal. Hill, a person that took action in both the heist and fixing, accidentally talked
about the point shaving operation when he was being interrogated for the heist. After Hill spilled
the beans about the game fixing, the FBI investigated into Boston College and was able to find a
conspiracy. Some people think that if Hill did not say anything about the fixing, then the crew
CORRUPTION IN SPORTS 8
might have been able to pull off the fixing of Boston College games (Gary). Just like any new
stories, there were two different stories. The story told by the basketball players was that they
only had a vague conversation with the gamblers, while the gamblers claimed they had multiple
players participate in the point shaving. From the article, the gamblers circled nine specific
games they were going to fix. The first of the conspiracy was the Boston College vs. Providence.
Boston College was projected to win a close basketball game, but the Eagles lost by a lot, which
cost the gamblers big bucks. Another example was Boston College vs. Harvard. Harvard was
projected to get blown out; however, they battled and lost by 3 points. The gamblers wanted a
close game, and they received a close game, which made them content. Because of the close
game, a large sum of money on the Boston College vs. BC- Holy Cross rivalry game. The
gamblers told the players that they need to lose by more than three points. After the star player
intentionally fouled out for BC, they somehow managed to lose 98-96, which caused the
gamblers to lose all their money (Gary). There was never any proof that point shaving was
intentional, but the conspiracy is all the court system needed to convict the victims of the
scandal.
Paper Classes
The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill is a prestigious public university and a
well known school with top tier sports programs. A couple years ago, athletes from UNC filed a
lawsuit against the university and the NCAA arguing that the athletes were not offered a high-
class education because of second-rate courses, also known as paper classes (Svrluga). A paper
class is an easy class that is designed for athletes to pass with ease. The purpose of paper classes
were “Minimal or no teaching and immensely generous grading for tasks that took minimal time
and effort”(Svrluga). The lawsuit charges the NCAA of negligence, declaring that “The
CORRUPTION IN SPORTS 9
organization had previous knowledge of academic fraud in member schools’ athletic programs;
however, the organization failed to supply sufficient monitoring. It violates the contract against
the university for not allowing academically sound classes with legitimate educational
instruction” (Svrluga). This is a perfect instance how colleges view sports compared to
academics. UNC is just one of many schools who give priority to college athletics and the money
it brings in for the school instead of caring about the athletes education. The NCAA ruled that
UNC did not violate academic fraud (Svrluga). North Carolina had no penalties from the scandal
because no rules were broken. The reasoning behind why UNC will not be punished for the
scandal is because the panel that analyzed the case “could not conclude that the University of
North Carolina violated N.C.A.A. academic rules,” the NCAA stated in an announcement
(Svrluga).
A controversial topic for many decades in sports became even more vexed when Adam
Silver, NBA commissioner, stated that he was in favor of legalizing sports betting in the NBA
(Mcgugan). His reasoning is how prevalent gambling has been in all sports. Gamblers want to
find a way to fix the game, and basketball is the easiest game to manipulate. Basketball is the
easiest because there is such more scoring, and if one person were to have a bad game, it could
easily change the outcome of the game. Bookies will put a spread on the game; a spread is when
the better team is favored to win by 15. Then a gambler will put money on the game that the
underdog will lose, but by less than 15. A way to make sure the underdog loses by less than 15
is to pay a player or players to make sure the underdog team loses by less than 15. If the players
lose by less than 15, then the gambler will win a certain amount of money. By making sports
betting legal, bookies will do anything possible to make sure the games are not fixed. Ian
CORRUPTION IN SPORTS 10
McGuan talks about many example of games being fixed, examples of solutions and proof of
how legalizing sports betting has helped the sport. Also, a well written article by Ian Mcgugan
titled Risk Factor has a few reliable and current statistics that help prove why gambling should
be legalized. Not only does the article talk about basketball; it also ties in other sports,
organizations, and countries. The article also has different research from prestigious universities
Legal Aspects
The U.S. government feels it is time for a change. Originally the Professional and
Amateur Sports Protection Act of 1992 (PASPA) and the Wire Act of 1961 set precedent over
other laws, however; after many legal altercations, the court system created the Unlawful
Internet Gambling Enforcement Act of 2006 (DOJs). The Professional and Amateur Sports
Protection Act of 1992 is a federal statute that makes it unlawful for a state to "authorize by law"
sports betting (DOJs). The Department of Justice (DOJ) amended the Wire Act to “prohibit any
telecommunicated wager placed or received by a person located in the United States; this
includes Internet wagers placed and accepted within the same state violated the Wire Act.” In
2006, Congress came to the realization that a new law in total was needed for sports gambling.
So, Congress dropped the Wire Act and created the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement of
2006. The Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement of 2006, “prohibited the acceptance or
processing of a financial instrument for the purpose of ‘unlawful Internet gambling’ but did not
directly define that term, instead relying on other federal and state laws as to what wagers were
illegal” (DOJs). In summary, the act bans the gambling community from allowing settlement in
exchange for another person partaking in betting through the Internet and that breaks any laws
(DOJs).
CORRUPTION IN SPORTS 11
The governor of the state of New Jersey took the National Collegiate Athletic
Association to the Third Circuit Court of Appeals because of sports gambling. The issue
surrounding the case deals with the unfinished rescind of its banning on sports gambling
(DeJarnatt). In 2014, New Jersey legislative system repealed a statewide ban on sports gambling.
After the repeal, the law allowed for sports betting at casinos and racetracks; however, the repeal
violated the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act. Because of the law being altered,
this “...Permitted certain entities to engage in sports gambling while not permitting others to
engage in sports gambling, resulting in an authorization by law for those entities permitted to
engage in it” (DeJarnatt). Congress offered New Jersey an opportunity to enact a sports gambling
law within one year of ratification, but New Jersey chose not to legislate any laws.
Consequences
● The second violation occurred within five years of the starting date of the penalty
assessed in the first case. The second major case does not have to be in the same sport
committee on the basis of specifically stated reasons, may include any of the
following:
the latest major violation for one or two sport seasons and the prohibition
CORRUPTION IN SPORTS 12
period.
○ The requirement that all institutional staff member serving on the NCAA
Southern Methodist University (SMU) is an example of a school who received the death
penalty. The sports programs at SMU have not been the same ever since the horrific incident.
SMU was in the Southwest Conference for football, but after the death penalty and other
scandals, there was no more conference (Dodd). The penalty caused SMU to no longer be a
major college football program. Ever since the death penalty, SMU has not been the same
school. When the Big 12 was formed, SMU was not invited into the conference, coaches no
longer want to coach at SMU and have only had three winning seasons since the scandal (Dodd).
It is safe to say, SMU still has not been able to fully recovered from this incident.
Throughout the years, there have been schools on the verge of receiving the death
penalty, but none were as fortunate as SMU. In 2005, Baylor basketball was almost eliminated
because of the Patrick Dennehy murder, academic fraud, unethical conduct and hidden drug
CORRUPTION IN SPORTS 13
positives (Dodd). The punishment for the program was that they were only allowed to play
conference basketball games that season. The 2012, Penn State Jerry Sandusky sexual abuse
scandal caused the football program to not be able to play in a bowl game for four years and the
program lost 40 scholarships (Dodd). Penn State was an exception to rule because they were
somehow able to recover rather quickly from the penalties. Reggie Bush, a former running back
for Southern California, (USC) created a mess for the school. The Trojans received a two year
ban on bowl games, lose of 30 scholarships, the Trojans no longer can say they won the 2004
national championship and Bush got his Heisman Trophy taken away (Dodd). These are just a
couple recent scandals that show how college sports has become more corrupt than ever before.
Collegiate Example
Derrick Rose is a basketball player who went to Memphis University. He failed the ACT
multiple times, so for the SAT he had someone take his test under his name. The NCAA found
out that Derrick Rose was not eligible to play collegiate basketball because another person took a
test for him. As a result, the Memphis Tigers were stripped of their school high 38 win and their
Corruption in sports has weaved its way into high school football. Here in Virginia
Beach, is a prime example of a high school coach corrupting the game. Ocean Lakes head
football coach, Chris Scott, was suspended for three games and most of preseason practice, and
placed the program "on warning" for three years, according to Virginia Beach City Public
Schools. The Ocean Lakes Dolphins went 15-0 and capped the season off by winning the
Virginia state championship. The VHSL has a specific rule that prohibits schools to allow
students to transfer from one school to another school for sports (Frankenberry). Nancy Farrell,
CORRUPTION IN SPORTS 14
the principal at First Colonial High School stated in a letter “The Beach District Executive
Professional Example
Not only is baseball corrupted with performance enhancing drugs; they also had a
gambling scandal with a former coach. Pete Rose, former Cincinnati Reds coach, was banned
from the MLB. Pete Rose was banned from the MLB because he would bet on his team to win
when he was the manager for the Reds. When the argument of whether or not Pete Rose should
or should not be banned,the popular question is “Pete Rose only bet on the Reds to win when he
was the team’s manager. He believed in his club. How can that justify lifetime banishment from
baseball?” (Rodenberg). In spite of that, the MLB has a rule stating “Any player, umpire, or club
or league official or employee, who shall bet any sum whatsoever upon any baseball game in
connection with which the bettor has a duty to perform shall be declared permanently ineligible.”
This is a hot topic because many people believe his punishment did not fix the crime. Contrary,
there are many people who believe he should still be banned from the MLB. No matter the side,
both can agree that betting on the game is corrupt. It is corrupt because it erodes the honor within
the game, while still exposing the league by showing who controls the game (Rodenberg).
Conclusion
Corruption has found ways to spread into a variety of sports and this creates serious
consequences, such as towering societal, economic problems, and pervades the whole sports
community (Dimant and Deutscher, 2015). With corruption occurring in sports, this eliminates
the crucial aspect of the unpredictability of the outcome it brings to the fans. Having said that,
corruption affects the ground of sporting integrity within the game (Cashmore and Cleland,
CORRUPTION IN SPORTS 15
2014). Corruption within sports is inevitable, but there are still different ways for each sports
league to prevent corruption. Some sports celebrities can bring out corruption by betting on
games. The betting of games can lead to fix matches, which alter the outcome of the game. The
toughest part about corruption is that it is not obvious to detect. Corruption can sometimes be
unnoticeable, which makes it that much harder to try and prevent corruption. With an increase in
corruption, the government and national sporting entities have teamed up to try and find
corruption that include: “Backing of national schemes on match fixing and sports doping; setting
up of sport probity entities both at the state level and by separate sporting principles;
significant criminal offences in national and territory legislation” (Bricknell, 2015). Sports have
started to become a national newspeak and have expanded commercially and this is partially due
to the corruption within sports (Brooks et al., 2013). With corruption being a presiding force in
References
“18 U.S. Code § 201 - Bribery of Public Officials and Witnesses.” LII / Legal
sks.sirs.com/webapp/article?artno=0000394011&type=ART.
Ap. “Mobster Implicated in 1978 Lufthansa Heist Headed to Court.” CBS News, CBS
heist-trial-opens/.
Atkinson, Jay. “How Parents Are Ruining Youth Sports - The Boston Globe.”
parents-are-ruining-youth-sports/vbRln8qYXkrrNFJcsuvNyM/story.html.
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK305894/.
Governor of the State of New Jersey, Et Al. - Third Circuit, 28 Aug. 2015,
apps.americanbar.org/ababoards/blog/blogpost.cfm?threadid=32332&catid=14911.
Dodd @dennisdoddcbs, Dennis. “30 Years Later: The Legacy of SMU's Death Penalty
and Six Teams Nearly Hit with One.” CBSSports.com, 22 Feb. 2017,
www.cbssports.com/college-football/news/30-years-later-the-legacy-of-smus-death-
penalty-and-six-teams-nearly-hit-with-one/.
CORRUPTION IN SPORTS 17
“DOJ's Reversal on the Wire Act - What It Means for Internet Gaming.” The
act-what-it-means-internet-gaming.
www.casinopedia.org/terms/s/sports-betting.
lakes-football-coach-suspended-after-recruitment-violation/article_ecac21ad-ea9d-5dd0-
a655-a6f7bce7b906.html.
Gary Parrish
@GaryParrishCBS. “Four College Basketball Assistant Coaches Hit with Federal Fraud,
basketball/news/four-college-basketball-assistant-coaches-hit-with-federal-fraud-
corruption-charges/.
June 2015,
search.proquest.com/docview/1697782597/3DC178EAE24542EFPQ/1?accountid=3785.
Jcoram. “Enforcement Process: Penalties.” NCAA.org - The Official Site of the NCAA, 27
Jussim, Matthew. “The 15 Biggest Steroid, P.E.D., and Doping Scandals in Sports
www.mensfitness.com/sports/baseball/15-biggest-steroid-ped-and-doping-scandals-
sports-history.
sks.sirs.com/webapp/article?artno=0000396845&type=ART.
Mcgugan, Ian. “Risk Factor.” New York Times Magazine, 25 Jan. 2015, pp. 16–18.
Purdum, David, and Ryan Rodenberg. “Future of Sports Betting: the Marketplace.”
how-sports-betting-legalized-united-states-the-marketplace-look-like.
www.espn.com/espn/chalk/story/_/id/11633538/betting-chronicling-worst-fix-ever-1978-
79-bc-point-shaving-scandal.
Reagan, Brad. “Leagues Warm Up to Legal Betting.” SIRS Knowledge Source, 1 Apr.
2017, sks.sirs.com/webapp/article?artno=0000392116&type=ART.
Rodenberg, Ryan. “Pete Rose's Reckless Gamble.” The Atlantic, Atlantic Media
rose-still-cant-be-absolved/378866/.
Ryan, Shannon. “NCAA Penalizes Memphis in Derrick Rose Test Case.” Tribunedigital-
21/sports/0908210085_1_penalizes-memphis-coach-john-calipari-infractions-report.
CORRUPTION IN SPORTS 19
search.proquest.com/docview/225950568/980366F2B44441E0PQ/10?accountid=3785.
search.proquest.com/docview/1757116323/980366F2B44441E0PQ/14?accountid=3785.
search.proquest.com/docview/1757116323/980366F2B44441E0PQ/14?accountid=3785.
Svrluga, Susan. “Lawsuit Filed against NCAA, University of North Carolina in ‘Paper
www.washingtonpost.com/news/grade-point/wp/2015/01/22/lawsuit-filed-against-ncaa-
university-of-north-carolina-in-paper-class-athletics-scandal/?utm_term.
Tracy, Marc. “N.C.A.A.: North Carolina Will Not Be Punished for Academic Scandal.”
The New York Times, The New York Times, 13 Oct. 2017,
www.nytimes.com/2017/10/13/sports/unc-north-carolina-ncaa.html.