Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/321017137
CITATIONS READS
0 28
5 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Estimation and Identification of Rate of Severity and Hazard Characteristics during Oil and Gas Well
Drilling Operation. View project
Identification of Hazardous Characteristic of on and offshore Well Casing and Cementing Operation.
View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Engr Muhammad Mujtaba Asad on 12 November 2017.
ABSTRACT
This paper discusses the major hazardous activities during the casing and cementing
operation with potential associated hazards in the on and offshore oil and gas industries
of Malaysia, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia. The researcher adopted the explanatory research
approach for the quantitative (survey questionnaire) and qualitative research methods (semi-
structured interview) in the data collection process. Eighty drilling crew were randomly
selected for quantitative research, while three safety officers were purposively selected for
qualitative research from each targeted industry. According to the findings of this study,
running casing to wells and circulation cementing activity is considered highly hazardous
at the offshore site. At the Saudi Arabian onshore domain, running casing to holes is more
hazardous, while at offshore domains, installation of casing and casing accessories is more
hazardous than in Malaysia and Pakistan. The participants from the Pakistani offshore
industry reported that installation of casing and circulation of cementing activity were
highly hazardous. In the context of overall
casing and cementing operation among
the focus industries, the Malaysian on and
ARTICLE INFO offshore oil and gas industry considers
Article history: the casing and cementing operation as
Received: 01 November 2016
Accepted: 15 March 2017 more hazardous compared to that of other
E-mail addresses: industries, with a total mean range of 3.37
razalih@uthm.edu.my (Razali Bin Hassan),
mujtabaasad11@gmail.com (M. M. Asad), for onshore and 3.45 for offshore sites that
qadir_mehmood@yahoo.com (Q. M. Soomro),
fahadsherwanis@gmail.com (F. Sherwani)
lie under a moderate level of the mean range.
* Corresponding author
The dangers are associated with potential with the production string, which takes
ergonomic, chemical and safety hazards place during well completion (Wiseman,
during on and offshore operation. 2009). The number of critical injuries and
fatalities is high during installation of well
Keywords: Casing, cementing, drilling, hazard,
surface casing in on and offshore drilling
offshore, onshore
in the petrochemical extraction industry
(Skogdalen & Vinnem, 2012).
INTRODUCTION
Advancement in the oil and gas industry PROBLEM STATEMENT
has evolved over time and the various uses The casing and cementing operation is
of these fuels have likewise extended and considered hazardous due to the nature
turned into an essential part of today’s of the job, in which drilling crew and
worldwide economy (Blackley et al., workers have to deal with heavy casing
2014). Oil inevitably supplanted coal as accessories, tools and toxic and harmful
the world’s main fuel in the early 20th drilling fluids such as oil base mud, silica
century (Bennear, 2015). The methods and radioactive materials (Kargbo,Wilhelm,
and procedures involved in producing and & Campbell, 2010). According to accident
dispersing oil and gas are very unpredictable cases reported by the USA Occupational
and critical and they require state-of-the-art Health and Safety Department, many
technologies (Ingraffea et al., 2014). One fatalities have been recorded due to loose
of the major and most important operation casing due to wire rope and slings having
in the oil and gas industry is the oil-well fallen and become unstuck and tripping
drilling process. In this process, an oil well due to heavy casing accessories (Medina &
is bored in the earth to conduct petroleum Krasuk, 2015). Accidents during the casing
oil hydrocarbons to the surface. There are and cementing operation are unpredictable
several operations and activities involved and can differ greatly one from another
in the drilling operation. Each activity due to the installation environment and
comes with physical, ergonomic, safety and installation equipment (Livingston et al.,
chemical hazards that can cause injuries and 2016). Although casing and cementing
also lead to immediate death (Blackley et activity represents less than 10% of well
al., 2014). cycle time, the injury rate during this phase
According to statistical data, most is more than 10%; indeed, 50% of fatal
of the hazards were reported during the accidents on a drill rig happen during casing,
casing and cementing operation (Brenner & according to International Association of
Cawley, 2015). The casing and cementing Drilling Contractors (IADC) (Medina &
operation occusr intermittently during the Krasuk, 2015). Before performing casing
drilling process initiated with the surface and cementing activities, special services
casing and intermediate casing and ending crew and safety officials perform risk
130 Pertanika J. Soc. Sci. & Hum. 25 (S): 129 - 138 (2017)
Severity of Casing and Cementing in Drilling Process
Pertanika J. Soc. Sci. & Hum. 25 (S): 129 - 138 (2017) 131
Razali Bin Hassan, Muhammad Mujtaba Asad, Qadir Mehmood Soomro and Fahad Sherwani
and offshore casing and cementing operation from each industry were selected through
in the drilling process. For the qualitative purposive sampling to participate in a semi-
study, three health and safety experts structured interview as shown in Table 1.
Table 1
Participants of the study
132 Pertanika J. Soc. Sci. & Hum. 25 (S): 129 - 138 (2017)
Severity of Casing and Cementing in Drilling Process
Table 2
Research question analysis approach
Pertanika J. Soc. Sci. & Hum. 25 (S): 129 - 138 (2017) 133
Razali Bin Hassan, Muhammad Mujtaba Asad, Qadir Mehmood Soomro and Fahad Sherwani
3.67. Also, the survey response for offshore seen as being the most hazardous, with a
cementing and casing operation indicated moderate level of mean score, 3.62.
that installation of casing tools activity was
Table 4
Mean of response from targeted industries
134 Pertanika J. Soc. Sci. & Hum. 25 (S): 129 - 138 (2017)
Severity of Casing and Cementing in Drilling Process
Second Research Question: Potential from the Pakistani oil and gas industries
Hazard Associated with Hole reported that ergonomic hazards were the
Cementing and Casing operation cause of injuries during offshore operations.
Table 5 shows the potential hazards A total of 55% of the respondents from
associated with hole cementing and casing the Malaysian onshore oil and gas industry,
operation at Malaysian, Saudi Arabian and 52% from the Saudi Arabian and 65% from
Pakistani oil and gas drilling sites. According the Pakistani indicated that safety hazards
to the findings, 45% of respondents from such as falling, getting stuck and tripping
Malaysian, 38% from Saudi Arabian and were potential hazards, while 67 % of
35% from Pakistani onshore oil and gas the respondents from the Malaysian, 52%
industry have considered ergonomic hazards from the Saudi Arabian and 75% from the
are potentially hazardous during hole Pakistani offshore oil and gas industries
cementing and casing operation. A total of answered that safety hazards were potential
33% of the respondents from the Malaysian hazards during the hole cementing and
and 48% from the Saudi Arabian and 25% casing operations.
Table 5
Hazard Associated with On and Offshore Cementing and Casing Operation
Pertanika J. Soc. Sci. & Hum. 25 (S): 129 - 138 (2017) 135
Razali Bin Hassan, Muhammad Mujtaba Asad, Qadir Mehmood Soomro and Fahad Sherwani
Ergonomic and Safety Hazards Associated with Safety and Ergonomic Hazards Associated with Running
Installation of Casing Tools
Casing
Figure 1.Block
Figure 1. Blockdiagram
diagram for ergonomic
for ergonomic safety FigureFigure
andhazards.
and safety 2. Block
2. Block diagram
diagram forforergonomic
ergonomic hazards.
hazards
hazards
Safety and Ergonomic Hazards Associated with Installing the Casing Accessories
Participants from 136
Malaysia, Saudi Arabia and Pakistan Pertanika
identifiedJ. dropping
Soc. Sci. &accessories such
Hum. 25 (S): 129 as
- 138 (2017)
entralisers, scratchers, guide shoes and float collars as hazards during installation of casing
12
accessories in the interview. Participants MY1 and MY2 from Malaysia and SA2 from Saudi
Arabia highlighted dropping accessories as hazards and pointed to critical injuries suffered by
crew on the feet and hands during offshore casing accessories installation, but Participant PK1
from Pakistan during the interview referred to dropping objects as a hazard at onshore sites, as
shown in block diagram Figure 2.
Severity of Casing and Cementing in Drilling Process
sites, and
blowout during cementing. that MY3
Participant these fromhazards
Malaysia led to healthSA1 blowout
and participant from Saudi hazards were equally prominent as
Arabia agreed that chemical hazards are repeatedly reported at onshore sites, andhazards that theseduring the activities of circulating
problems such as skin infections and burns.
hazards led to health problems such as skin infections and burns. cementing and casing accessories in the
Malaysian, Saudi Arabian and Pakistani on
Chemical Hazards Associated with Circulating Cementing and offshore sites.
and Casing
Exposure to REFERENCES
Additive dust Blowout
chemicals
Asad, M. M., & Hassan, R. (2015). Development
of KBES with hazard controlling factors and
Figure
Figure3.3.Block diagramforfor
Block diagram chemical
chemical hazards
hazards. measures for contracting health and safety risk in
oil and gas drilling process: A conceptual action
CONCLUSION
CONCLUSION plan. Proceedings of the 9th Malaysian Technical
The qualitative and quantitative results obtained from this study on the Malaysian, Saudi Arabian
Universities Conference on Engineering and
The
and Pakistani oil and gasqualitative andfour
industries indicated quantitative results
activities as being hazardous in on and
Technology, Johor Baharu, Malaysia. Retrieved
obtainedoffrom
offshore sited. The participants thiswere
the study study oncrew
drilling theandMalaysian,
safety professionals from the
from http://eprints.uthm.edu.my/7583/1/5.pdf
three countries. TheSaudi Arabian
respondents and considered
from Malaysia Pakistani
the oil and gas
hole casing cementing operation
Babbie,
as being the most hazardous operation, with a total mean range of 3.37 for onshore and E. R. (1990). Survey research methods.
3.45 for
industries indicated four activities as being
offshore sites, both lying under the moderate level of the mean range, and were associatedBelmont,
with California. Wadsworth Publishing.
potential ergonomic, chemical and safety hazards during on and offshore operations. The
qualitative findings showed that safety hazards related Pertanika
to installation of casing
J. Soc. Sci. & Hum.tools such
25 (S): 129as
- 138 (2017) 137
getting stuck in casing, wrong body posture and being hit by tools and equipment were also
prominent. In the activity of running casing into holes, the participants reported that dropping,
pinched points and wrong body posture at both on and offshore sites were hazards. In addition,
13
Razali Bin Hassan, Muhammad Mujtaba Asad, Qadir Mehmood Soomro and Fahad Sherwani
Bennear, L. S. (2015). Offshore oil and gas drilling: Landell, K. (1997). Management by menu. London:
A review of regulatory regimes in the United Wiley and Sons Inc.
States, United Kingdom, and Norway. Review
Livingston, D. A., Andes, D., Czerneski, M., Bauer, S.,
of Environmental Economics and Policy, reu013.
Castro, B., Gorr, K., & Beebe, L. (2016). Team
Blackley, D. J., Retzer, K. D., Hubler, W. G., Hill, R. approach to horizontal drilling optimization in the
D., & Laney, A. S. (2014). Injury rates on new Marcellus delivers record setting performance.
and old technology oil and gas rigs operated Proceedings of IADC/SPE Drilling Conference
by the largest United States onshore drilling and Exhibition, Texas, USA. Retrieved from
contractor. American Journal of Industrial http://toc.proceedings.com/32198webtoc.pdf
Medicine, 57(10), 1188–1192.
Medina, J., & Krasuk, R. (2015). Cementing operation
Brenner, B., & Cawley, J. C. (2015). Occupations most in underbalanced casing drilling: A successful
at-risk in fatal overhead power line incidents: case history in an unconventional shale reservoir
Using OSHA data to get a better understanding. in Argentina. Proceedings of SPE/IADC
Electrical Safety Workshop (ESW), 2015 IEEE Managed Pressure Drilling and Underbalanced
IAS, 1–6. IEEE. Operations Conference and Exhibition, Dubai,
UAE. Retrieved from http://toc.proceedings.
Ingraffea, A. R., Wells, M. T., Santoro, R. L., &
com/27708webtoc.pdf
Shonkoff, S. B. (2014). Assessment and risk
analysis of casing and cement impairment Skogdalen, J. E., & Vinnem, J. E. (2012). Quantitative
in oil and gas wells in Pennsylvania, 2000- risk analysis of oil and gas drilling, using
2012. Proceedings of the National Academy of Deepwater Horizon as case study. Reliability
Sciences, 111(30), 10955–10960. Engineering and System Safety, 100, 58-66.
Kargbo, D. M., Wilhelm, R. G., & Campbell, D. Wiseman, H. J. (2009). Untested waters: The rise of
J. (2010). Natural gas plays in the Marcellus hydraulic fracturing in oil and gas production
shale: Challenges and potential opportunities. and the need to revisit regulation. Fordham
Environmental Science and Technology, 44(15), Environmental Law Review, 20, 115.
5679–5684.
138 Pertanika J. Soc. Sci. & Hum. 25 (S): 129 - 138 (2017)