Mindanao in terms of their writing ability using the English language. In order to identify the errors committed by the respondents, she made use of Chanquoy’s classification of writing errors. On the other hand, Hourani’s Common reasons of grammatical errors checklist was adapted so the cause of these errors may be distinguished. The researcher assigned the respondents to write their own argumentative essay about their affirmation or negation towards the topic “Boys are smarter than girls”. Through this essay it was discovered that the selected freshmen, has difficulties in properly using punctuation marks and using the language grammatically accurate, specifically in utilizing the verb aspect (tenses, subject agreement, and auxiliary and linking choice). Behind these errors, the mother-tongue interference along with incomprehensibility of the grammar rules and writing mechanics were the reasons identified by the respondents.