Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
1, FEBRUARY 2006
Abstract—Wireless communication and networking often proves The authors strongly believe, as do many others [4]–[9], that
to be a quite challenging subject to teach in a meaningful way, students learn more effectively from courses that provide for
because many students appear to find the subject rather dry and active involvement in hands-on learning experiences. To that
technical, and thus quite boring. The authors have prepared some
end, some interesting projects have been prepared that facili-
interesting projects to provide the students of wireless communi-
cation and networking with a hands-on learning experience. These tate an interactive, hands-on approach to learning wireless com-
projects are designed around low-cost Wi-Fi modules and PC cards munication and networking concepts. The first of these projects
that are available from local electronics shops. The projects are used the programmable interface controller (PIC) Sound Gener-
suitable for classroom use in introductory-level courses about wire- ator project described in [10] and the infrared (IR) signals pro-
less networking. The effectiveness of these projects has been eval- duced by a pair of TV remote controls. The second project in-
uated by both students and teaching team. The feedback from stu-
volved setting up a wireless link between two computers. This
dents indicates that both the development and implementation of
the projects were successful. This paper describes these projects, project used a pair of commercially available receiver and trans-
their overall effectiveness, and plans for further projects. The im- mitter modules that operate in the 2.4-GHz band and have audio
pact of Wi-Fi projects on student learning and comprehension is and video inputs and outputs, respectively. The third project in-
also discussed. volved the students setting up a peer-to-peer wireless link, using
Index Terms—Evaluation, hands-on experience, IEEE 802.11, a pair of computers fitted with commercially available Wi-Fi PC
Wi-Fi modules, wireless networking. cards. Finally, several such links were formed into a wireless
network. These projects can be used either in the classroom, as
a demonstration to enhance the traditional lecture environment,
I. INTRODUCTION
or in the laboratory to provide a practical hands-on learning ex-
TABLE I
WI-FI PROJECTS AND RELATED WIRELESS NETWORKING CONCEPTS
A. Project 1: Infrared Remote Controls simultaneously. The storage oscilloscope can be used to cap-
ture also a display of the serial signal used to control the LCD
Attention is drawn in [18] to the similarities between commu-
display described in [10] and the RS232C signals produced by
nication links that utilize IR and wireless links that utilize radio
the project described in [19]. Many students have indicated that
transmission in the 2.4-GHz band. The first project exploits these
they found being able to experience in new ways something as
similarities as a means of introducing Wi-Fi to students via a tech-
familiar to them as a TV remote control unit was both enlight-
nology with which they are already familiar—IR remote control
ening and intriguing, and they were thus better able to appreciate
units. Project 1 uses an IR-detector module from a dismantled
the behavior of a wireless communication link.
computer to detect the IR pulse-modulated signals produced by
a pair of TV remote controls. The IR detector and power supply B. Project 2: A 2.4-GHz Wireless Link
were assembled on a breadboard, and the output from the IR de-
tector was captured on a Tektronix 2230 storage oscilloscope. Leading on from the first project, this project endeavors to
The same signals were also fed to the PIC Sound Gener- provide students with an appreciation of the characteristics of
ator project described in [10], where they were filtered and then another part of the electromagnetic spectrum, viz. microwave
passed to the audio amplifier built into that project. As a re- radiation as an information carrier. The project is based around
sult, students could both see and hear representations of the IR two commercially available kits,3 which comprise an FM trans-
signals being produced by the two remote control units. Fig. 1 mitter and a matched receiver. These modules are pretuned to
shows the signal train produced by a single remote control. In one of four frequencies within the 2.4-GHz band. Again, stu-
Fig. 2, the overlapping of the IR signals produced by a pair dents will be familiar with the some aspects of the technology
of TV remote controls when one controller is operated slightly involved through their experience with FM broadcasting and
later than the other can be seen. The importance of the receiver television broadcasts, although these services operate at lower
being able to distinguish between overlapping signals can be frequencies than Wi-Fi. The kits were installed in plastic project
well demonstrated by the refusal of devices (such as a TV set) 3Oatley Electronics [Online] Available: http://oatleyelectronics.com/kits/
to react as expected when both remote control units are used K199.html
100 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON EDUCATION, VOL. 49 NO. 1, FEBRUARY 2006
TABLE II Wi-Fi projects described in this paper are easy to use and set
IMPACT OF WI-FI PROJECTS ON STUDENT LEARNING AND COMPREHENSION
up for class demonstrations. The projects consist of inexpen-
sive and widely available modules and kits and are thus likely
to be within reach of even already extended budgets. Student
responses to the project demonstrations were mostly favorable.
The students indicated that they had found the Wi-Fi projects
easy to use and helpful in gaining an understanding of wire-
less communication and networking fundamentals. The Wi-Fi
projects demonstration has had a positive impact on student
learning and comprehension.
More projects, such as IEEE 802.11a, IEEE 802.11g, and
integrating Wi-Fi and PIC projects, are being prepared. These
materials are available to faculty interested in using the Wi-Fi
projects to supplement their wireless communication and net-
working courses or as the basis for more complex projects. More
information about the Wi-Fi projects and demonstration mate-
rials can be obtained by contacting the first author.
APPENDIX
ASSESSMENT TEST
Maximum time allowed: 20 minutes
Please answer as many questions as you can. Thank you for
your participation.
1. What is the maximum distance an IEEE 802.11b net-
work can cover?
a) 100 meters
b) 10 meters
c) 1000 meters
mix. The exam consisted of 19 multiple-choice questions cov- d) 20 meters
ering various aspects of wireless and mobile networking tech- 2. What is the maximum theoretical speed of IEEE 802.11b
nology, including ad hoc and infrastructure WLANs, Bluetooth, and IEEE 802.11g?
and wireless security (see the Appendix for a listing of the test IEEE 802.11b IEEE 802.11g
questions). a) 12 Mbps a) 12 Mbps
Table II shows results of these tests. The question num- b) 54 Mbps b) 54 Mbps
bers of the 19 multiple-choice questions are indicated in the c) 22 Mbps c) 22 Mbps
first column. The fraction of the students in the class who d) 11 Mbps d) 11 Mbps
answered correctly (expressed as a percentage) in each of the 3. What security protocols are commonly used in Wi-Fi?
19 questions in the class test before and after they had expe- a) MAC address restrictions
rience with the Wi-Fi projects are shown in columns 2 and 3, b) WEP Key 64/128 bit
respectively. c) BLT on rye
As seen in Table II, on each of the 19 questions, the class d) USB access key
as a whole showed an improvement ranging from 8% to 100%, 4. What does SSID stand for?
and the overall improvement for the test is 33%. This improve- a) Super Security Implementation Device
ment can be accounted for by the practical experience that the b) Seismic Standard Identification Deployment
students gained from the Wi-Fi projects between the two tests c) Service Set IDentifier
since no other forms of instruction were given to the students d) Slow Service IDentifier
before the second test. The tests (before and after) were con- 5. What is the difference between WEP and MAC filtering?
ducted among students having the same background and who a) One’s hardware and one’s software
had been exposed to the same theoretical material. b) They’re the same thing
c) One is a pie protocol
V. CONCLUDING REMARKS d) WEP has a greater maximum distance
A series of interesting projects has been developed, which 6. What is a MAC address?
can be used either in the classroom for class demonstrations, a) Location of the closest McDonald’s
in enhancement of the traditional lecture environment, or in b) Management address character for Wi-Fi
the computer laboratory for hands-on practical work in intro- c) The numeral ID of your network card
ductory wireless communication and networking course. The d) Closet reseller of Mac trucks
SARKAR AND CRAIG: TEACHING WIRELESS COMMUNICATION AND NETWORKING FUNDAMENTALS USING WI-FI PROJECTS 103
Nurul I. Sarkar (M’01) is a Senior Lecturer in the School of Computer and Trevor M. Craig received the M.Sc. degree in statistics and mathematics from
Information Sciences at the Auckland University of Technology, New Zealand. Massey University, New Zealand, in 1986, the Ph.D. degree in computer science
He has more than ten years of teaching experience in universities at both under- from the University of Sydney, Australia, in 1996, and the M.A. degree in ap-
graduate and postgraduate level and has taught a range of subjects, including plied linguistics via distance learning from the University of Southern Queens-
computer networking, data communications, computer hardware, and e-Com- land, Australia.
merce. He has published in the international journals and conferences, including Upon completing the Ph.D. degree, he held a teaching position at the Sydney
the International Journal of Electrical Engineering Education, the International Institute of Technology, Australia, where he taught mathematics to students
Journal of Information and Communication Technology Education, the Inter- studying for various trade qualifications. This environment and his involvement
national Journal of Business Data Communications and Networking, Measure- in amateur radio encouraged his interest in the use of electronic equipment and
ment Science & Technology, the 3rd IEEE International Conference on Informa- computer software as teaching aids. In 2001, he took this interest a step fur-
tion Technology Research and Education, the 35th ACM Technical Symposium ther by taking up a position teaching English at a technical college in Daegu,
on Computer Science Education, and the 4th IEEE International Conference on South Korea. In 2001, while in Korea, he completed the RSA/CELTA (Royal
Advanced Learning Technologies. His research interests include wireless com- Society of Arts/Certificate in English Language Teaching to Adults) certificate
munication networks, simulation and modeling of computer and data communi- at the British council, Seoul, Korea. Since returning to New Zealand in 2004,
cation networks, and tools to enhance methods for teaching and learning com- he has been teaching freshman mathematics and statistics at Wollongong Col-
puter networking and hardware concepts. lege, Auckland (Wollongong College, Auckland, is a University of Wollongong,
Dr. Nurul is a Member of IEEE Communications Society. He served as Re- Australia enterprise).
gional Editor of the Pakistan Journal of Information and Technology; Chair
of the IEEE New Zealand Communications Society Chapter; Executive Peer-
Reviewer of the SSCI indexed Journal of Educational Technology & Society;
member of editorial review board of the International Journal of Information
& Communication Technology Education; and a member on the IASTED Tech-
nical Committee on Computers and Advanced Technology in Education.