Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Published By
Dr.Pranav Shah, Director, Academy for Continuing Medical Education
C/o Chakrapani Panchkarma Hospital, F-3, Sukhsanti Complex, Kalanala,
Bhavnagar -364001, M: 9328938008, E-mail: cjshah79@yahoo.co.in
Like nuclear energy, the impact can be accessed and compared through
factor has become a mixed blessing. I the Journal Citation Reports database
expected that it would be used (JCR).
constructively while recognizing that in
the wrong hands it might be abused. In The impact factor is useful in
the early 1960s Irving H. Sher and clarifying the significance of absolute
Eugene Garfield created the journal (or total) citation frequencies. It
impact factor to help select journals for eliminates some of the bias of such
the Science Citation Index (SCI)1 counts which favor large journals over
small ones, or frequently issued journals
The use of the term “impact over less frequently issued ones, and of
factor” has gradually evolved, especially older journals over newer ones.
in Europe, to include both journal and Particularly in the latter case such
author impact. This ambiguity often journals have a larger citable body of
causes problems. It is one thing to use literature than smaller or younger
impact factors to compare journals and journals. All things being equal, the
quite another to use them to compare larger the number of previously
authors. The impact factor of a journal published articles, the more often a
reflects the frequency with which the journal will be cited3, 4.
journal's articles are cited in the
scientific literature. It is derived by The following points should be borne in
dividing the number of citations in year mind when consulting impact factors5:
3 to any items published in the journal in
years 1 and 2 by the number of • Citation does not automatically
substantive articles published in that imply that a work is of high
journal in years 1 and 22. quality: a work may be heavily
cited because lots of other
authors are refuting the research
For example, for 1997 impact findings it contains.
factors the following formula was used: • Beware of citation bias: people
may cite their own work, or work
from the journals in which they
publish.
• An impact factor is a measure of
average citation impact, not
individual citation impact, so an
The impact factor will help you evaluate impact factor cannot be used to
a journal’s relative importance, measure the performance of an
especially when you compare it to others individual.
in the same field. Journal Impact factors
• Time needs to elapse before a casting votes for that journal. Impact
meaningful citation analysis can factor serves as a tally of those votes.
be made, so new journals tend to
fare badly. A journal's impact within clinical
• Not all research work is medicine, however, depends largely on
published and cited in the its importance to practitioners, most of
citation indices: conference who never write manuscripts for
proceedings, for example are publication and thus never have a chance
often poorly covered. to “vote.” Citation frequency may
• There is a bias in favour of therefore better reflect the importance of
English language material on clinical journals to researchers than
citation indices. practitioners. Because the opinions of
both practitioners and researchers are
Different fields of research publish at relevant in judging the importance of
different rates: there is generally a much clinical journals, the validity of impact
stronger culture of publishing in journals factor as a measure of journal quality in
and citing the worth of peers in the clinical medicine is uncertain. The
biomedicine than in engineering. authors therefore sought to examine
whether impact factor is a valid measure
of journal quality as rated by clinical
Conceptually developed in the 1960s, practitioners and researchers12.
impact factor has gained acceptance as a
quantitative measure of journal quality6. Citation density and half-life are also
Impact factor is used by librarians in important variables. The citation density
selecting journals for library collections, (mean number of references cited per
and, in some countries, it is used to article) would be significantly lower for
evaluate individual scientists and a mathematics article than for a life
institutions for the purposes of academic sciences article. The half-life (number of
promotion and funding allocation7, 8. Not years, going back from the current year,
surprisingly, many have criticized the that cover 50% of the citations in the
methods used to calculate impact factor9, current year to the journal) of a
10
. However, empiric evaluations of physiology journal would be longer than
whether or not impact factor accurately that of a journal of molecular biology or
measures journal quality have been astronomy.
scarce11.
The impact factors currently reported by
The use of impact factor as an index of the Institute for Scientific Information in
journal quality relies on the theory that Journal Citation Reports (JCR) may not
citation frequency accurately measures a provide a complete enough picture for
journal's importance to its end users. slower changing fields with longer half-
This theory is plausible for journals lives. Nevertheless, when journals are
whose audiences are primarily studied within disciplinary categories,
researchers, most of whom write the rankings based on 1-, 7- or 15-year
manuscripts for publication. By citing impact factors do not differ significantly,
articles from a given journal in their own as was recently reported in The
manuscripts, researchers are in essence Scientist.13, 14
Abstract:
Disturbances in autonomic functions have been observed in many diseases
including hormonal disorder (Banisters 1983). Present study was undertaken to study the
autonomic functions in thyroid hormones on in 60 untreated hypothyroid patients, using
Valsalva and deep breath test, cold pressor test, hand grip test and orthostatic test to
assess the sympathetic and parasympathetic reflexes. The results obtained in this study
were compared with the age sex matched controls. It is concluded that the sympathetic
response is not altered in the hypothyroid cases while reflex vagal activity is significantly
reduced.
Abstract:
Total 4210 babies were studied in the neonatal period immediately after birth,
which shows overall 0.88%. incidence of congenital malformations. Incidence was
significantly higher (6.1%) in mothers aged > 30 years as compared to younger age
group. Religious pattern of mother and consanguinity of marriage had no much effect on
the incidence. The incidence was marginally higher in primiparous patients (47.2%).
Only in 12% of cases some etiological factors could be found, of which maternal fever in
first trimester was the most common. 10 cases with CNS malformations had
hydroamnious. The anomaly was detected antenatally in 49%cases with the help of USG.
The ration of still birth to live birth was 4.19:1 suggesting that many of the anomalies are
incompatible with life. There was no overall difference in the sex of the babies. However
most of anencephalic babies were female. Preterm babies had four times more incidence
of congenital malformations as compared to term babies. This represents “phenomenon
of nature’s selection”. Associated hydroamnios also accounts for preterm labour similarly
congenital malformations were more commonly found in low birth weight baby. Out of
all system involved in congenital mal formation, CNS was the commonest and accounted
for 1/3 rd of the cases.
INCIDENCE (%)
5
during pregnancy or positive family 4
history. Observation was tabulated and 3
2
analyzed at the department of Anatomy, 1 0.7
1.5
0.4
Medical College, Bhavnagar. 0
< 20 21-25 26-30 > 30
MATERNAL AGE
Observation and discussion:
With improved control of infections and Incidence (%)
The Table I shows that the incidence of selection”. Whether the relationship
malformations is slightly higher in those between pre maturity and congenital is
mothers who had not received antenatal cause or effect is difficult to comment.
care. Clinical suspicious supported by
USG help in detection of some In present study out of all malformed
anomalies in booked cases. These babies 79% were heaving low birth
patients are offered selective termination weight and there is inverse relationship
of pregnancy. Only in 12% cases between incidence of malformations and
etiological factors could be detected. birth weight (shown in Graph II) This
Commonest being fever in 1st trimester. association of low birth weight and
In remaining 88 %, we are not able to malformations has been well
find out the cause of anomalies. documented 23,28.
0.4
>2.5
malformations. In present series 3
mothers had history of drug ingestion in
0.4
2.1-2.5
Wt IN Kg
early pregnancy mostly in the form of
0.7
1.6-2.0
antibiotics an antiepileptic. However it
was difficult to find exact nature of drug
7.5
<1.5
Abstract:
In regard to arthroscopic treatment of popliteal cysts, we explored the refuted
pathology for popliteal cysts proposed by others. Here we introduce an
arthroscopic technique using posterior portals to treat a popliteal cyst based on
our observation that the opening of the cyst in the joint is a slit-like structure in
the posterior wall of the capsule. By disrupting this slit-like structure with our
procedure, the popliteal cyst ceased to be palpable and was no longer
symptomatic. This technique also provides excellent arthroscopic visualization of
the cavity of the popliteal cyst through the knee joint approach. After completion
of the resection of the opening, we can easily insert an arthroscope into the cavity
of the popliteal cyst from the posteromedial portal through the resected opening.
Arthroscopic visualization of the cavity of the cyst showed that the inside wall of
the cavity was smooth and had no synovitis. We believe that to disrupt this slit
structure is the most pathologically reasonable procedure to treat popliteal cysts
surgically.
Key Words:
Arthroscopic surgery, Popliteal cyst, Baker’s cyst, Posterior portal, Knee.
FIGURE 1. (A) Opening at the wall of the posterior capsule in the posteromedial
compartment of the knee joint. A 30° arthroscope is placed in the posteromedial
compartment through the posteromedial portal. (B) Resection of the capsular tissue with
a motorized shaver.
thology for popliteal cysts proposed by
joint disorders are often associated with others. Here, we introduce an
4-8 arthroscopic technique to treat a pop-
popliteal cysts. This has led to the
concept that the underlying intra-
articular lesions should also be treated, liteal cyst and explain our observation of
with the expectation that surgical the slit-like structure between the joint
correction of the intra-articular disorders and the bursa. This tech-nique provides
excellent arthroscopic visualization of
would abolish the cyst. This treatment is
the cavity of the popliteal cyst through
supported by the hypothesis that
the knee joint approach.
popliteal cysts arise from fluid
distension of a com-municating SURGICAL TECHNIQUE
gastrocnemius-semimembranous bursa
with the joint cavity, and the intra Patients are placed in the supine
articular disorders cause the position and the affected knee joint is
inflammation and effusion of the joint flexed 90° under general anes-thesia.
cav-ity. The other hypothesis is that Routine arthroscopic examination of the
intra-articular disor-ders play a role as a knee joint is performed using standard
anterolateral and anteromedial portals.
valve-like structure in the
The first step in the arthroscopic
communication between the joint and
treatment of a popliteal cyst is to
cyst, e.g., the meniscal body and the
establish a posteromedial portal. We
posterior horn that extend to an opening
make a posteromedial portal by the
of the cyst in the articular capsule.
methods de-scribed by Ahn and Ha.9
However, in our experience in Briefly, a 30° arthroscope is inserted
arthroscopic treat-ment of popliteal through the anterolateral portal into the
cysts, we explored the refuted pa-
FIGURE 3. Arthroscopic views of the inside of the cavity of a popliteal cyst. (A) The
same popliteal cyst shown in Figs 1 and 2. (B) A popliteal cyst in a different patient.
and at the end of the procedure, in 27 of
cavity to the cyst, and is one of the 30 cases, there appeared an oval opening
factors responsible for the appearance located between the meniscal body and
and persistence of the cyst. Therefore,
the pathogenesis of the retention of the the posterior horn that extended to the
fluid in the bursa has 2 factors, joint articular capsule. They proposed that the
effusion and a 1-way valve-like tear of the posterior horn of the medial
mechanism. meniscus in all of the structures might
act as a valve. However, we remain
There are 2 methods of treating a doubtful that the posterior horn of the
symptomatic popliteal cyst. The first is medial menis-cus in all of the structures
to treat the intra-articular disorders, such might act as a valve. One reason for this
as meniscal tears and chondral lesions, doubt is that Rupp et al.8 studied the
to reduce the joint effusion. The second prevalence of popliteal cysts and the
is to disrupt the 1-way mechanism be- associated intra-articular lesions in 100
tween the joint and bursa, and to patients for arthroscopic sur-gery of the
establish an unob-structed freeway knee without removal of the cyst and
connection between them. they found that articular cartilage lesions
were the intra-
There have been several reports on intra-
articular disorders associated with articular lesion most often associated
popliteal cysts, and some authors have with a popliteal cyst. They suggest that
proposed that intra-articular disorders act lesions of the articular carti-lage have an
as a valve at the communication between important role in the pathogenesis of
the joint and the bursa. Sansone and De secondary popliteal cysts. The articular
Ponti6 noted 27 medial meniscal tears in cartilage le-sions can cause the joint
30 patients (90%) with popliteal cysts. effusion, but cannot act as a valve. The
They per-formed a selective second reason is that, in our experience,
meniscectomy of the medial me-niscus, the arthroscopic visualization through
the posterior portal showed that there is the knee joint, there was also synovitis in
a significant wide space between the rim the posterior medial com-partment and
of the posterior horn of the medial in the bursa. However, we are not sure
meniscus and the opening of the bursa, whether the authors of these reports
and it is not likely that the structure of actually visual-ized the correct opening
the intra-articular disorders can extend to and the cavity of the popliteal cyst. In
the opening of the bursa located in the our experience, the opening of the cyst
medial-posterior wall of the joint in the joint is a slit-like structure in the
capsule. Therefore, the intra-articular posterior wall of the capsule. It is often
disorders can cause the joint effusion impossible to observe the slit-like
leading to a secondary popliteal cyst opening of the cyst from anterior portals
through the com-munication between the because the opening is located in the far
bursa and the joint, but do not seem to be medial side of the posterior compartment
able to act as a valve for the communica- of the joint. Furthermore, as the cysts
tion.
extend from the opening downward in
There have been several reports about
the distal direction, an arthroscope
arthroscopic visualization of the opening
would need to be inserted in a more
of the bursa in the joint, and 2 reports on
vertical direction to inspect the cyst
the direct arthroscopic visualization of
deeply enough, which is impossible from
the cavity of the popliteal cyst through
the anterior portals. Arthroscopic
the joint space. Sansone and De Ponti6
visualization of the intracavity of the
described that it was possible to
cyst showed that the inside wall of the
introduce the arthroscope into the
cavity was smooth with no synovitis,
capsular orifice to inspect the cyst
which refutes the results reported by
connection, which did not seem to have
others concerning the myotendinous
a wall of its own but appeared instead to
struc-ture or the presence of synovitis
give access to a cavity defined by the
inside of the cyst.
myotendinous structure of the popliteal
Some cysts have no communication to
region. Johnson et al.10 performed the joint, and thus no opening inside the
diagnostic arthroscopy to identify the joint. Therefore, we rou-tinely confirm
pres-ence of popliteal bursa in 195 the communication between the joint
knees; 37% of knees had a popliteal and bursa using axial view MRI before
bursa identified by the communica-tion surgery. If we do not confirm it by MRI,
with the posterior medial compartment then we confirm it by arthrography by
from the routine anterolateral portal via injecting a contrast dye into the joint. If
the intercondylar notch or a posterior there is no filling of the dye into the
medial transcutaneous approach. The bursa, we do not perform this
method of evaluation used in their study arthroscopic technique. In such a case,
provided direct visualization with open surgery is necessary.
magnification for identifica-tion of the In summary, we found a slit structure
posterior medial compartment for a com- at the com-munication between the joint
munication with the popliteal bursa. and popliteal cyst. Al-though we have
They described the entry in the cyst not yet firmly established whether this
behind a capsular fold of the posterior slit structure acts as a valve, we do
wall of the medial compartment. In their believe that to disrupt this slit structure
observations, if there was synovitis in is the most pathologically reasonable
Abstract:
60
NO OF PATIENTS (%
50
40
30
20
10
0
Physiotherapy Intra articular Manipulation
injection Under G/A
TYPE OF TREATMENT
Abstract:
Communication is a complex phenomenon. Definitions vary in their emphasis on
the verbal, non-verbal, content, process, informational, relational and cultural aspects of
communication. Present study was done in 85 first year MBBS student by using 13
questions with yes or no single answer, developed by Work Communication, UK. Study
shows that medical schools should access the communication skills of entry level
graduate and give special training of communication in the clinical years apart from their
clinical teaching in ward and develop assessment tools to evaluate affective domain and
communication skill.
Introduction: (Appendix I)
Graph I
Graph II
10. STUDENTS (Medical) the students in Major source of data collected is primary
the medical faculty are all interested in which might limit the study.
knowing more about this science. They
have shown keenness to learn SuJok Our own inexperience in the research field
therapy and its practices only after they might have affected the results.
attended the seminar before which most
of them were not even aware of the word
SUJOK. Hence to create awareness of References
this system very hard work is required
from totally dedicated selfless workers, 1. Arnold, David. Science, Technology,
who have full knowledge of this field and medicine in Colonial India.
Cambridge: UP, 2000.
11. DOCTORS some of them have shown 2. Barbour, Ian G. When Science Meets
interest as it is an easier way to impart Religion. San Francisco: Harper San
treatment and it covers all aspects of Francisco, 2000.
human physiology. But as they are in the 3. Basalla, George, ed. The Rise of
main stream of medicine they have to be Modern Science: External or Internal
convinced with research and practical Factors?Lexington, Mass.: D. J.
findings which is bound to take a lot of Heath, 1968..
time money and energy. 4. “The Spread of Western Science.”
Science. 156 (1967): 611622.