Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Parliamentary Archives
Houses of Parliament
Parliamentary Archives
Magna Carta
& Parliament
4 5
MAGNA CARTA 1215 Magna Carta and Parliament
6 7
Magna Carta and Parliament Magna Carta and Parliament
only be levied with the ‘general consent’ ‘No free man shall be seized or Library came from the collection of the
of the kingdom; clause 14 set out the antiquary Sir Robert Cotton (1571-
imprisoned, or stripped of his
means for obtaining this consent: ‘we 1631). One, now BL Cotton MS
will cause the archbishops, bishops, rights or possessions, or outlawed Augustus II 106, was passed to Cotton
abbots, earls, and greater barons to or exiled, or deprived of his by Humphrey Wyems; where it came
be summoned individually by letter’. from is not clear but one story has it
standing in any other way, nor
At the heart of Magna Carta lay two that it was found in a tailor’s shop in
clauses, 39 and 40, which are the most will we proceed with force against London. The other copy, BL Cotton
well known and which relate to rights him, or send others to do so, except Charter XIII 31A, was sent to Cotton
and liberties. in 1630 by Sir Edward Dering. Recent
by the lawful judgement of his
research shows that this copy was in
In order to ensure that the King
equals or by the law of the land.’ the archives of Canterbury Cathedral
complied with the terms of Magna
Clause 39 in the late thirteenth century and was
Carta the barons were to elect 25
probably sent there in 1215. It was
of their number to ‘keep, and cause
‘To no one will we sell, to no one badly damaged in a fire in 1731 and is
to be observed with all their might,
now very difficult to read, but it is the
the peace and liberties granted and deny or delay right or justice.’ only one of the four originals to still
confirmed to them by this charter.’ Clause 40 have King John’s Great Seal attached.
News of the sealing of the charter
The copy held by Lincoln Cathedral
was communicated to officials in the
seven copies had been produced and is believed to have been held by the
counties who were required to see that
it is known that at least thirteen were Cathedral since 1215; the same is true
its terms were adhered to. Of the 63
issued altogether. Four original copies of the copy held by Salisbury Cathedral
clauses only 4 are still in force today: 1
of Magna Carta survive today. Two which was originally kept at Old
(part), 13, 39 and 40.
are held by the British Library, one Sarum Cathedral.
After the events of 15 June it is thought by Lincoln Cathedral and one by
that officials drafted copies of Magna Salisbury Cathedral. All are written
Carta using the terms that had been on parchment, but vary in size and
agreed at Runnymede. By 24 June shape. The copies held by the British
8 9
Magna Carta, 1215
© The British Library Board,
BL Cotton MS Augustus II 106
10
Magna Carta, 1215 Magna Carta, 1215
© The British Library Board, Lincoln Cathedral Library,
BL Cotton Charter XIII 31A A1/1B/45
12 13
Writ of King John with news
Magna Carta, 1215 of Magna Carta, 20 June 1215
Salisbury Cathedral Archives, Dean and Chapter
Press IV, C2: Royal Charters/39 of Hereford Cathedral
14 15
MAGNA CARTA AND THE
DEVELOPMENT OF PARLIAMENT Magna Carta and Parliament
In England in the thirteenth century III (1216-1272). In order to tempt their control over taxation. Second Contemporaries would usually have
there were two great constitutional Prince Louis’ partisans back into the they had a new constitution since called it a ‘council’ or ‘great council’, but
developments; the establishment of young king’s camp, in November 1216, knights representing the counties and already the name ‘parliament’, derived
Magna Carta and the emergence of the minority government issued a new burgesses the towns were summoned to from the French word for meeting or
Parliament. It was on 15 June 1215 that version of the Charter. Having won the them with increasing frequency - the discussion, was coming into use. Indeed,
King John (1199-1216) authorized the war against Louis, it did so again in beginnings of the House of Commons. a contemporary account of the events
sealing of Magna Carta. The Charter November 1217 in order to consolidate These twin developments, the of 1215 spoke of the barons meeting
met very real grievances against his the peace. Finally in 1225, in return for establishment of Magna Carta and the in a ‘parliament’. The first assembly to
rule and also asserted a fundamental a great tax, Henry III issued the final development of Parliament, were very be called a parliament in an official
principle, namely that the king was and definitive version of Magna Carta. closely linked. document met in 1237, and thereafter
subject to the law. Nonetheless in the It is chapters of Henry’s 1225 Charter the term quickly became established.
In 1215 Magna Carta laid down
short term it was a failure. Within little (in Edward I’s confirmation of 1297)
the first constitution for Parliament. In 1215 Magna Carta’s assembly was
more than a month of its issue, King which are still on the Statute Book of
Chapter 12 stipulated that the king largely baronial. It was the House of
John had asked the pope to quash the United Kingdom today.
could only levy taxation with the Lords, not the House of Commons.
the document. The barons themselves
Kings had always convened assemblies common consent of the kingdom. Only the great lay and ecclesiastical
turned to other remedies. They deposed
of the great and good to discuss the Chapter 14 defined the assembly from magnates were summoned in person.
John and offered the throne instead
affairs of the realm, but it was only which the consent must come. The earls, The other ‘tenants-in-chief ’, summoned
to Prince Louis, the eldest son of the
in the thirteenth century that they greater barons, bishops and abbots were generally through the sheriffs, were
king of France, Philip Augustus. The
began to be called ‘parliaments’. A new to be summoned individually. The rest also an exclusive body, being men who
Charter only survived thanks to John’s
term seemed appropriate because the of the king’s ‘tenants-in-chief ’ were to were direct tenants of the crown. There
death in October 1216 and the parlous
assemblies of the thirteenth century be summoned generally through the was no place for representatives from
position of the minority government
were themselves new in two ways. First sheriffs. Magna Carta did not give London and other towns. There was no
of his nine year old son, King Henry
they had a new power derived from the assembly thus convoked a name. place for elected knights representing
16 17
Magna Carta and Parliament Magna Carta and Parliament
the counties. Evidently, the great The political significance of the hear the common law assizes, a striking decades after 1215 they struggled to
magnates and the other tenants-in- burgesses and knights, implied in indication of the legal knowledge and exploit it. In Lincolnshire, they had
chief felt that they alone could speak Montfort’s summons, had already self confidence of the knights. Likewise, the chapter publicly proclaimed and
for the realm. been clear in Magna Carta. While the twelve knights, again elected in the defied the sheriff when he seemed to
Charter excluded knights representing county court (and so not nominated break it. From 1217 onwards there was
The first parliament to which knights
the counties and burgesses the towns by the barons) were to investigate the also, alongside Magna Carta, a separate
and burgesses together were summoned
from its tax granting assembly, it still malpractices of the king’s local officials. charter dealing with the administration
was the parliament held under the
recognized their importance. The These knights had great power because of the royal forest. The name ‘Magna
auspices of Simon de Montfort in 1265.
Charter had chapters protecting the they were not merely to investigate. They Carta’ itself came into being from
Montfort revered Magna Carta. During
liberties of London and ‘all other cities, were also to abolish the abuses they 1218 in order to distinguish the
the parliament, he organized a great
boroughs, vills and ports’. It also said discovered. They thus had the ability ‘Great Charter’ from its smaller Forest
ceremony, held on 14 February 1265
that no tax should be levied on London to reshape the whole structure of local companion. The Charter of the Forest
in the chapter house of Westminster
without the common consent of the government. At the local level they gave an important role to the knights for
Abbey, where the king’s adherence to
kingdom. Although they failed to get were, in effect, elected legislators in each in each county they were to determine
the Charter was proclaimed. Why then
this into Magna Carta, the Londoners county. The foundations were being laid the areas which were to be freed from
had Montfort transformed the structure
were already demanding a say in the for the appearance of knights elected by the burden of forest law. There was a
of the Charter’s assembly by summoning
giving of such consent. As for the the counties in national assemblies. great deal of argument over just how
representatives? One reason was the
knights, there would have been some, if extensive the freed areas were to be.
immediate political situation. Montfort In the event, the chapter setting up
on an individual basis, even in Magna The king advanced one interpretation
had captured King Henry III at the knights to investigate and abolish local
Carta’s assembly, for many of the lesser of the Forest Charter and the county
battle of Lewes in May 1264 and abuses did not survive into the post
tenants-in-chief were of knightly status. knights another. These struggles over
thereafter ruled the country in the king’s 1215 versions of Magna Carta. It was
The Charter also gave an important the Charters were educative and
name. His regime, however, remained replaced, however, by a new chapter
role in the localities to elected knights. empowering. The knights were cutting
unstable, and enjoyed limited baronial which regulated the whole running
Four knights, elected in the county their political teeth. Here was another
support. It was vital to reach out to other of the local courts. This was a chapter
court, were to sit with the king’s judges foundation for the summoning of
sections of society. much valued by the knights and in the
when they came four times a year to knightly representatives to parliament.
18 19
Magna Carta and Parliament Magna Carta and Parliament
The summoning of knights and Here again much was owed to Magna it was impossible after 1215 to levy a Another reason was Magna Carta. It
burgesses to Simon de Montfort’s Carta. As we have seen, it stipulated tax without the consent of parliament. had a major impact on the king’s ability
parliament in 1265 set the pattern for that taxation could only be levied with The only time Edward I tried to do so to extract money from his subjects in
the future. Henry III’s son, Edward the common consent of the kingdom. (in 1297) the protests soon forced him an arbitrary fashion. The Charter was
I (1272-1307), a king influenced, in It is true that this chapter was omitted to draw back. largely obeyed after 1215 when it fixed
many ways, by Montfort’s example, from the post 1215 versions of the the ‘relief ’, the inheritance payment
The need to secure consent to taxation
summoned them with increasing Charter of 1215, as was the chapter due from a baron, at £100. King John,
would not have mattered had kings
frequency and by the end of his reign setting up the assembly from which by contrast, had frequently charged
been able to do without the money.
their place was virtually fixed. None of consent was to come. The reason was hundreds of pounds and sometimes
If, as many thought they should, they
this, however, meant that parliament baronial selfishness. By excising the thousands. Magna Carta was also
‘lived off their own’, lived, that is, off
necessarily had power against the king. chapter, the barons were able to excise obeyed when it forbade the sale of
their own lands and other customary
Knights and burgesses might attend, along with it the parallel chapter which justice. Likewise, the offers of money
revenues, they would have no need for
just like lords, simply to applaud and limited their ability to tax their own common under John to assuage the
taxation. The twelfth-century kings
implement his wishes. That indeed tenants. The omission of the chapter king’s anger and recover property seized
had largely been in that position. The
was how the kings would have liked was, however, less significant than it by acts of will virtually disappeared
thirteenth-century kings were not. If
it. They did not, however, get their seemed. The Magna Carta of 1215 was under Henry III. Whereas under
they were to live grandly in peace
way. The second great parliamentary widely copied in the thirteenth century John the annual value of fines (offers
and act mightily in war, taxation was
development of the thirteenth and became very well known. There was of money to the king for concessions
an absolute necessity. One reason
century, alongside the summoning of no understanding that it was invalid. and favours) was over £20,000, under
for the change was the diminution
representatives, was a huge increase in The papal bull quashing the Charter Henry III it rarely exceeded £5000.
in the revenue from royal land. The
parliament’s power. The great lever, the was rarely copied and was generally Such income did not recover either
great landed estate obtained by the
source of parliament’s authority down ignored. In 1255 the magnates in under Edward I.
Norman Conquest in 1066 had been
the ages, had appeared, namely the parliament gave the failure to summon
alienated by the kings of the twelfth The conclusion was obvious, the king
control over taxation. them according to the terms of the
century, alienated in gifts both to had to find a new source of revenue.
1215 Magna Carta as a reason for
religious houses and to royal servants. That by far the best source was the one
refusing to grant taxation. In practice,
20 21
Magna Carta and Parliament Magna Carta and Parliament
provided by a general tax levied on the thirty men and three women were If it was to grant a tax, parliament
whole kingdom was clear. Such taxes assessed for the tax. The first of such demanded in return the right to choose
had first been levied in 1187 in order to taxes of which we know the yield was the king’s ministers, and control the
raise money for the papally proclaimed the seventh levied by King John in expenditure of the money, demands as
crusade to recover Jerusalem after 1207. It brought in around £60,000. radical as any faced by Charles I. Since
its seizure by Saladin. Another tax Since John’s annual income at the Henry found such terms unacceptable,
was raised in 1193-4 to help pay the start of his reign was little more than no taxes were forthcoming. The great
ransom of Richard the Lionheart after £20,000, such taxes had the power to lever, the source of parliament’s power,
his capture on his way back from the triple the king’s revenues. had thus appeared. Edward I was far
crusade. These taxes were levied as a more successful than his father. He
In 1207, John had failed to get proper
percentage of the value of everyone’s usually secured consent to taxation by
consent for his great tax. That was a
movable property, essentially clever concessions and the reform of
major reason behind Magna Carta’s
their corn and farm animals. Later the realm. He thus gained the funds
insistence that such taxes must be
evidence shows the detail in which with which he conquered Wales and
levied with the consent of the kingdom.
the assessments were made. ‘William nearly conquered Scotland.
John’s son, Henry III never tried to levy
at Netherhead: 1 heifer, 4 shillings; 1
a tax without consent. Indeed, he went Magna Carta is, therefore, crucially
bullock, 5 shillings; 1 cow, 5 shillings;
to parliament again and again asking important for the development
20 sheep, 20 shillings; 1 pig, 2 shillings;
for it. In 1225 he was successful in of Parliament. It established the
1 quarter and 2 pounds of wheat, 4s
return for the issue of what became the fundamental principle that taxation
and 2 pence; 1 quarter of drage, 3s 9d;
definitive Magna Carta. In 1237 he was needed consent. It set out the first
Total 43 shillings and 11 pence. Ninth,
successful again, this time in return for constitution for Parliament, and it
4 shillings and eleven pence’ ran the
his first confirmation of the Charter as accelerated the emergence of the
assessment of William at Netherhead
a king of full age (as he had not been House of Commons. Without Magna
for the ninth of 1297. He was one of
in 1225). Thereafter, Henry’s numerous Carta there would have been no tax
the more prosperous villagers from
requests for taxation ran into trouble. based parliamentary state.
Shillington in Bedfordshire where
22 23
Magna Carta and Parliament: the legacy Magna Carta and Parliament
By David Prior
24 25
Magna Carta and Parliament Magna Carta and Parliament
included ideas of liberty and rights which clarified or extended some of Magna Charta is such a King’s Bench, became an MP and active
and access to justice. The incorporation the clauses in Magna Carta. Altogether critic of the crown. In particular he
of Magna Carta into Parliament’s there were six statutes between 1331
fellow, that he will have wrote and pushed through Parliament
institutional memory began in many and 1369 that contributed to clarifying no ‘Sovereign’ the Petition of Right of 1628 which
ways in 1297, when the text of the 1225 or extending aspects of the Charter. Sir Edward Coke MP, was triggered by the imposition by
reissue of the charter was copied onto These changes, which were derived House of Commons, 17 May 1628 Charles I of a non-parliamentary tax.
the Statute Roll. Thereafter volumes of in part from Edward III’s need to The Petition proclaimed the illegality of
statutes often began with the text of accommodate the concerns of the King and Parliament taxation without parliamentary consent.
Magna Carta. It was also read out at House of Commons in return for During the seventeenth century Magna
the opening of parliament and during grants of taxation, became as important Carta took on a different significance
the 14th century Parliament passed Acts to later lawyers as Magna Carta itself. when it became a reference point in the
constitutional struggles which began in
the reign of Charles I and culminated
in the Glorious Revolution of 1688-89.
In many ways these struggles mirrored
those between King John and the barons
in 1215. During the reign of Charles
I opponents of the King such as John
Selden and Sir Edward Coke looked
to Magna Carta to justify their belief
in the dominance of parliamentary
power over the monarchy. Coke (1552-
1634), who was an eminent lawyer, and
between 1592 and 1616 successively
solicitor-general, attorney-general and
chief justice of both Common Pleas and
The Petition exhibited to His Majesty by the Lords Spiritual Sir Edward Coke. Jacobus
and Temporal, and Commons, in this present Parliament Houbraken after an original
assembled, concerning divers Rights and Liberties of the by Cornelius Johnson
Subject with the King’s Majesty’s Royal Answer thereunto © Palace of Westminster
in Parliament (The Petition of Right), 3 Charles I, c. 1, 1628 Collection, WOA 502
Parliamentary Archives, HL/PO/PU/1/1627/3C1n2 www.parliament.uk/art
26 27
Magna Carta and Parliament Magna Carta and Parliament
His writings articulate the ideas of the These struggles between Crown and 1689, which firmly established the
‘ancient constitution’, of the antiquity Parliament reached a climax in 1688 principles of frequent parliaments, free
of the common law and of Magna Carta when in the face of an invading army elections, and freedom of speech within
being the basis of the fundamental led by William, Prince of Orange the Parliament. The balance of power had
laws of England and in effect a contract Catholic King James II fled London finally shifted away from the monarch
between sovereign and people. for France. The following February towards Parliament. The new king
the draft Declaration of Rights was described some of the actions of James
debated by Parliament. II as ‘contrary to law and to that express
provision of Magna Charta’.
This document catalogued the means
by which James had allegedly sought Liberty
to subvert the Protestant religion of In 1679 Parliament passed the Habeas
the country. It sought to prohibit the Corpus Act, which was designed to
king from certain actions, such as codify the ancient writ of Habeas
levying revenue without parliamentary Corpus.
consent, and went on to affirm the
The Act prevented the unlawful
rights and liberties of the subject and
detention of people by the authorities,
that ‘the Freedom of Speech and Debates,
giving courts the power to determine
or Proceedings in Parliament, ought not
the legality of such imprisonment. Such
to be impeached or questioned in any
rights carried strong echoes of Magna
Court or Place out of Parliament’. This
Carta and it was erroneously believed
principle is known as Parliamentary
that the principle of Habeas Corpus
Privilege. The draft ended with the
had originated in 1215. The suspension
resolution that William and his wife
The engrossed Declaration served of Habeas Corpus in 1817 at a time of
Mary be declared King and Queen of
as the basis of the Act known as the civil unrest provoked the caricaturist
England, an offer which was accepted.
Bill of Rights, passed in December George Cruikshank to depict this as an
28 29
Magna Carta and Parliament Magna Carta and Parliament
30 31
Magna Carta and Parliament
I call it a greater Charter Radicals, Parliamentary Reform was created, allowing adult males
and the Right to Vote occupying property worth at least
of the liberties of England Amongst those in the eighteenth £10 a year to vote. In the counties
Thomas Babington Macaulay MP, century who championed parliamentary the franchise was broadened to
House of Commons, 5 July 1831, speaking in
favour of a bill for parliamentary reform.
reform was the radical MP John Wilkes include the more substantial
(1725-1797), who in 1776 made the tenant farmers, small landowners
first motion in the House of Commons and shopkeepers. Fifty-six towns
on the subject. Images of Wilkes often with less than 2,000 inhabitants
depict him with Magna Carta and the (‘rotten boroughs’) lost separate
Bill of Rights. representation and 31 further towns
were reduced to one MP. Sixty-seven
The passing of the Great Reform Act
new constituencies were created.
in 1832 was a mixture of political
circumstance and popular pressure. The
pro-reform Whig Lord Grey became
Prime Minister in 1830 and agitation
from extra-parliamentary radicals
finally convinced a sceptical King and
hostile Tory peers that reform was
necessary. The effect of this Act was
to enable the middle classes of the big
industrial towns to share in political
power. A uniform borough franchise
32
Magna Carta and Parliament Magna Carta and Parliament
The Great Reform Act was followed methods, and such women became Women, however, were still not equal to
by further Acts which widened the known as suffragettes. The cover of men in terms of the franchise, as men
male franchise in 1867 and 1884. By the 27 January 1911 edition of Votes could vote from the age of 21.
the early 1900s some women had for Women, a suffragette publication, The requirement to be 30 years old
become frustrated that years of peaceful featured a representation of the scene at or more was to ensure that women
campaigning by groups such as the Runnymede in 1215 with the sub-title did not form the majority of the
National Union of Women’s Suffrage The Story of how Militant Methods Won electorate; if women had been
Societies had not yet obtained them the Great Charter is told by Mr Joseph enfranchised on the same terms
the vote. They formed new associations Clayton on page 277 . as men, they would have been
which used more forceful and direct in the majority because of the
An Act to further reform the electoral
system was deemed necessary during the
First World War as millions of returning
soldiers were not entitled to the vote
because of property and residential
qualifications. The Representation
of the People Act of 1918 widened
suffrage by abolishing almost all property
From the late 1830s to the 1850s the qualifications for men and enfranchising
Chartist movement demanded further women over 30 who met minimum
reform. The Chartists campaigned property qualifications. These changes
for the male right to vote and listed saw the size of the electorate triple
their demands in The People’s Charter, a from 7.7 million to 21.4 million.
manifesto with obvious echoes of Magna Women now accounted for about
Carta, which was launched in 1838. 43% of the electorate.
34 35
Magna Carta and Parliament Magna Carta and Parliament
loss of men in the war. Ten years in its insistence that governments Further reading
later the Equal Franchise Act was follow the law and due procedure.
Ashley, M.
passed ‘for the purpose of providing
Taking Liberties: The Struggle for
that the parliamentary franchise shall
be the same for men and women’. It
The Magna Carta, the Britain’s Freedoms and Rights
(The British Library, 2008)
lowered the voting age for women Petition of Right, and the Bill
to 21, giving the vote to five million of Rights are documents held Breay, C.
women. Men and women now had the Magna Carta: Manuscripts and Myths
in veneration by democrats
same qualifications based on residence, (The British Library, 2010)
business premises, or being the spouse throughout the world
Carpenter, D.
of a person with a business premises Nelson Mandela,
Magna Carta
qualification. Supreme Court of South Africa,
20 April 1964 (London, 2015)
The Modern Legacy
Shenton, C., Prior, D.,
During the 19th century Parliament
and Takayanagi, M.
repealed many of the clauses in Magna
Victoria Tower Treasures from
Carta. In particular, the Statute Law
the Parliamentary Archives
Revision Act of 1863 repealed certain
(Parliamentary Archives, 2010)
clauses in the 1225 re-issue of Magna
Carta which had been entered onto the Vincent, N.
Statute Roll in 1297. Today only clauses Magna Carta: The Foundation
1 (part), 13, 39 and 40 remain in force. of Freedom 1215-2015
(London, 2014)
In 1998 the Human Rights Act
incorporated the European Convention
on Human Rights into British Law.
The Convention echoed Magna Carta
36 37
Magna Carta and Parliament
38