Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
© 2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY..
NO PART OF MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
495
Eduardo Marcushamer, DDS1/Teppei Tsukiyama, DDS1 For many years, the establishment
Terrence J. Griffin, DMD2/Emilio Arguello, DMD3 of health and function was the
German O. Gallucci, DMD4/Pascal Magne, PhD, DMD5 primary objective of dental pro-
fessionals. However, the goal of
modern dentistry includes not only
health and function, but also a final
Crown width/length ratios have been considered an important aspect in esthetic result corresponding to
the esthetic zone. Because previous investigations focused on Caucasian the shape, size, color, texture, and
populations, limited information is available on other ethnic groups to harmony of natural healthy teeth
propose a comprehensive approach to anterior maxillary teeth. The
and their surrounding tissues. Ad-
purpose of this study was to analyze the dimensions of anatomical crowns
ditional factors that might influence
of maxillary anterior tooth groups with respect to width, length, and
the ideal smile are ethnicity, per-
width/length ratios among an Asian population. The tooth dimensions
presented in this investigation may serve as guidelines for treatment
sonality, size, and position of teeth
planning in restorative dentistry and periodontal surgery for this particular and clinical crowns, or simply the
ethnic group. (Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent 2011;31:495–503.) perception of what is “ideal” by a
specific group or population. Dunn
et al1 established that there is no
1 Senior Resident, Department of Periodontology, Tufts University School of Dental Medicine,
correlation between specific dem-
Boston, Massachusetts. ographic groups and smile vari-
2
Chairman and Program Director, Department of Periodontology, Tufts University School of ables. The self-perception of smile
Dental Medicine, Boston, Massachusetts; Private Practice, Boston, Massachusetts.
attractiveness and the role of the
3
Assistant Professor, Department of Periodontology, Tufts University School of Dental
Medicine, Boston, Massachusetts; Assistant Professor, Department of Periodontology, smile line and other aspects were
Harvard School of Dental Medicine, Boston, Massachusetts. correlated with smile attractiveness
4
Director of Oral Implantology, Department of Restorative Dentistry and Biomaterial and their influence on personal-
Sciences, Harvard School of Dental Medicine, Boston, Massachusetts.
ity traits. The authors highlighted
5
Associate Professor, Division of Primary Oral Health Care, and Don and Sybil Harrington
Foundation Chair of Esthetic Dentistry, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, the psychosocial importance and
California. dental significance of an attractive
smile. Their results showed that
Correspondence to: Dr German O. Gallucci, Director of A.G.E. in Oral Implantology,
Department of Restorative Dentistry and Biomaterial Sciences, Harvard School of Dental
the size of teeth, visibility of teeth,
Medicine, 188 Longwood Avenue, Boston, MA 02115; fax: +1-617-432-0901; email: and upper lip position were critical
german_gallucci@hsdm.harvard.edu. factors in self-perception of smile
© 2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY..
NO PART OF MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
496
attractiveness (social dimension). cal crown width/length ratio of the all these variations should be taken
Color of teeth and gingival display maxillary anterior teeth from casts into consideration when designing
were critical factors in satisfaction of healthy subjects. However, only a comprehensive and individualized
with smile appearance (individual data from the Caucasian group treatment plan. The purpose of the
dimension). were analyzed and showed that the present investigation was to analyze
In addition, the position and Caucasian population presented a the anatomical crown dimensions
size of the anterior teeth might mean width/length ratio of 81% for of four maxillary tooth groups (cen-
have a direct influence in the clini- the three maxillary anterior tooth tral incisors, lateral incisors, canines,
cal appearance of the smile. It has groups.5 and first premolars) in Asian sub-
been argued that with the diversity In 2003, a similar study was jects with respect to width, length,
that exists in nature, the final result conducted at the University of Ge- and width/length ratios.
rarely follows all the mathematic neva, Switzerland, using digital im-
rules of a proportionate smile.2 It ages of extracted maxillary teeth of
seems that a good balance in the white subjects. The authors differ- Method and materials
composition of a smile is revealed entiated unworn from worn teeth
by the equilibrium between the and concluded that the anatomi- Two hundred sixty-four extracted
various visual tensions. However, cal crown width/length ratios were human maxillary teeth from Asian
this goes against the concept of 78% and 87% for unworn and worn subjects (91 central incisors, 76
absolute symmetry and the so- central incisors, 73% and 79% for lateral incisors, 54 canines, and 43
called objective of “perfection” of unworn and worn lateral incisors, first premolars) were collected from
the dental arrangement, usually and 73% and 81% for unworn and Kyushu University School of Den-
characterized by the total absence worn canines, respectively.6 tistry, Fukuoka, Japan. Teeth that
of visual tensions. Recently, Chu7 introduced inno- presented with restorations, caries
Among the objective criteria of vative esthetic measurement gauges lesions, and an undetectable ce-
natural oral esthetics, height and with the purpose of enabling the mentoenamel junction (CEJ) were
width of the maxillary anterior teeth clinician to perform esthetic surgical excluded. Teeth were categorized
have played an important role in and restorative dentistry with suc- by tooth group (central incisors,
restorative dentistry.3 In 1991, Ols- cess and predictability.8 However, lateral incisors, canines, premo-
son and Lindhe4 studied the rela- the predetermined dimensions used lars) according to their anatomical
tionship between teeth dimensions by Chu were not interchangeable characteristics and further divided
and biotype. Their results sug- for the different ethnic groups or re- into worn and unworn subgroups
gested that in subjects with a long- spective tooth groups. These mea- after undergoing scaling and ul-
narrow form, the maxillary central surements were based on the mean trasonic cleaning. The criterion
incisors experienced more reces- width/length ratio of unworn central for this selection was presence of
sion of the gingival margin at labial incisors of Caucasian subjects.6 a marked incisal wear facet along
surfaces than subjects who had a Taking into consideration that with well-defined dentin exposure
short-wide tooth morphology. Fur- data presented in previously pub- (Fig 1). Tangential light was used to
thermore, there was a significant lished studies analyzing tooth width/ show the incisal edge when view-
influence of the crown width/length length ratios have been generated ing the central incisors. All premo-
ratios on the probing attachment mainly from Caucasian populations, lars were considered as unworn,
level and the amount of gingival extrapolating this data to other eth- since all specimens displayed un-
recession on labial tooth surfaces. nic groups might be difficult without worn buccal cusps. Standardized
In 1999, another study conducted analyzing the anatomical character- photographs of the buccal surface
by Sterrett et al5 analyzed the clini- istics of these populations. Thus, were made using a digital camera
© 2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY..
NO PART OF MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
497
Fig 1 Unworn central incisor with its incisal edge covered 100%
by enamel. (right) Worn-down central incisor with a marked incisal
wear facet along with well-defined dentin exposure on the incisal
edge.
(Canon EOS 30D) with a 100-mm measure (1) the widest mesiodistal Statistical analysis was car-
macro and MR-14EX Macro Ring portion (perpendicular to the long ried out to compare the four tooth
Lite (Canon) attached to a photo- axis of the tooth) and (2) the lon- groups. A one-way analysis of vari-
graphic stand (RT-1, Kaiser). Teeth gest apicocoronal distance (parallel ance was used to compare the
were positioned visually according to the long axis, between the most mean values of width, length, and
to their main axis and recorded at apical point of the CEJ and the width/length ratio for the seven
original magnification ×1.5, re- most incisal point of the anatomical different subgroups. Multiple least
sulting in 264 digital photographs crown) (Fig 2). A special calibration significant difference range tests
(resolution maintained at 2,336 × tool built in the Image J software (confidence level, 99%) were then
3,504 pixels and 8-bit grayscale, was used to convert all distances applied to determine which means
generating 3.6-megabyte files). An into millimeters. Data were then differed statistically from others.
image-processing program (Image transferred to a spreadsheet pro-
J; Java-based image processing gram for mathematic arrangement,
program developed at the National including the calculation of the
Institutes of Health) was used to width/length ratio.
© 2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY..
NO PART OF MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
498
Table 1 Mean (SD) and range of the width, length, and width/length ratio of the four tooth
types of the maxillary dentition
© 2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY..
NO PART OF MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
499
Table 2 Results of statistical analysis for Table 3 Results of statistical analysis for
width length
Mean Homogenous
(%) groups*
Lateral incisors: unworn 67
Canines: unworn 67
Central incisors: unworn 72
Lateral incisors: worn 75
Canines: worn 75
Central incisors: worn 78
Premolars 87 –
P < .001.
*Homogenous groups determined by multiple range tests
(confidence interval, 99%).
© 2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY..
NO PART OF MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
500
groups by measuring clinical crowns dentition has not been presented gingival level can show variations
of normal white subjects with stone in tooth morphology sources for within and above normal range,19
casts and excluding teeth with the Asian population. Thus, it is sometimes exposing part of the
incisal wear as well as premolars. indispensable to investigate the root and sometimes covering the
Because of limited ethnic diversity, tooth dimension and ratio in each enamel, an example of which would
only data from the Caucasian group individual population to establish be incomplete passive eruption.21
were analyzed. A similar study was conclusive esthetic parameters for In this context, it seems appropriate
conducted in the University of a specific ethnicity. to use the CEJ and not the free gin-
Geneva in Switzerland using digi- Using the data shown in the gival margin as a reference for the
tal images of extracted maxillary present study, the following ranking establishment of “natural” guide-
teeth of white subjects, measuring for crown width can be established lines. Accordingly, mean crown
the width, length, and width/length for the Asian population studied lengths in the study from Magne
ratios for the anatomical crowns of (Table 2): central incisors > canines et al6 were approximately 1 mm
unworn and worn maxillary incisors, > premolars/lateral incisors. Within longer compared with clinical mea-
canines, and premolars. Rosenstiel the same tooth group, these mea- surements by Sterrett et al.5
et al14 evaluated dentists’ preferred surements were not influenced log- Additional factors such as
maxillary anterior tooth proportions ically by the degree of incisal wear. ethnicity should be taken into
and found that the majority chose Regarding the general ranking consideration to lead to more
smile proportions that resulted in of crown length for all specimens, comprehensive guidelines when
central incisors that were closest to the following was established for the treating and restoring patients
the 75% to 78% width/length ratios. Asian population studied (Table 3): that present with excess gingival
However, most data presented by unworn central incisors > unworn display or loss of dental structure
these investigations are based on canines > worn central incisors > because of different circumstances.
Caucasian subjects. worn canines > lateral incisors > A frequent clinical situation is
Additional factors such as eth- premolars. The ranking for width/ the presence of incomplete passive
nicity should be taken into consider- length ratio for the specimens eruption, as illustrated in Fig 3. The
ation to lead a more comprehensive studied (Table 4) emphasizes the presence of short clinical crowns
observation. It should be pointed difference between unworn teeth, or excessive gingival display is a
out that previous publications of with mean ratios between 67% and common complaint of patients
tooth size and tooth morphology in 72%, and worn teeth, with mean ra- with high esthetic demands. Fig-
various populations have shown dif- tios between 75% and 78%. ure 3e demonstrates an anatomi-
ferences both within and between Width measurements of ex- cal crown with exposed CEJ and
ethnic groups.15–17 A study by Bai- tracted teeth can be extremely a 78% width/length ratio for the
lit18 in 1975 stressed the importance precise because of the proximal maxillary central incisors, consis-
of clinicians taking into consider- clearance (absence of neighbor- tent with the range found on previ-
ation these minor variations in den- ing teeth); the precision of clinical ously measured teeth. Osteoplasty
tal traits among population types. measurements, including those and ostectomy were performed to
These differences could influence made on casts, can be jeopardized, locate the bone crest 2 mm api-
the prosthodontic restoration of an especially with overlapping teeth. cal to the CEJ to create space for
esthetic smile. Length measurements were con- the dentogingival junction over the
In the past, the crown width/ fined apically by the CEJ, which nor- root surface and the formation of
length ratio that is currently a key mally sets the position and structure a healthy sulcus over the enamel,
factor in achieving an esthetic of the soft tissues.19,20 However, the preventing the formation of re-
outcome in the maxillary anterior relationship between the CEJ and cession defects. This will create a
© 2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY..
NO PART OF MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
501
b c d
e f g
© 2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY..
NO PART OF MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
502
© 2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY..
NO PART OF MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.
503
© 2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY..
NO PART OF MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.