Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Teachers are required to make frequent decisions about how to best teach and
motivate students. The quality of these decisions depends on the information teachers
have about the student and their performance. Observation and recording of students'
performance and behavior is an important role of the paraeducator and an important
tool for teachers. Accurate behavior observation is essential in identifying students'
needs and developing effective instruction. This unit discusses issues and techniques
involved in gathering and reporting student performance data.
Objectives
After completing this unit and its activities the paraeducator should expect to be able
to:
1. Identifying the purposes and problems inherent with using behavior
observation as an information source.
2. Defining behavior in observable, measurable terms
3. Using systematic procedures for observing and recording behavior including:
a. Frequency
b. Duration
c. Rate
d. Percentage
e. Time sampling
f. Anecdotal records
2. Charting results of behavior observation using graphs.
Contents
Lessons
Learning Activities
Data collection and systematic behavior observation provide an objective basis for
making decisions and documenting student behaviors and performance. It can make
teacher judgment more accurate and reliable. When carried out systematically, it also
provides more frequent information on student progress.
Data on student performance can also give the teacher clues about how to adjust the
classroom environment. This may include deciding on grouping strategies, adjusting
the number and type of practice activities, changing locations in the room and a
variety of other variables in the classroom. When student progress is monitored the
effect of these changes is easier to determine.
Since data collection and observation techniques are being used to make educational
decisions, the accuracy of the information is important. The data which is collected
must also be meaningful and must reflect realistic activities which occur in the
classroom or be related to a student's success. Finally, data collection and observation
must be done in such a way that it does not interfere with the instructional process in
the classroom.
Accuracy
Consistency
Ease of Measurement
The following provide some example of observations which might lend themselves to
accurate measurement:
counting the number of times a particular behavior occurs
timing how long a behavior lasts
scoring an item as correct using a key
The following are observations which are more difficult to make because they require
more judgment on the observers part.
grading the quality of a speech
judging art projects
sportsmanship
Ease of Recording
Accuracy also requires that the observer have a systematic way to record and report
information. The system for recording the results of the observation must contain
enough information so that the observation is useful but must not be so complicated
that it interferes with the observation.
Techniques which have been used to improve the accuracy of data collection and
behavior observation include:
1. Clear description of observation procedure,
2. Clear specification of behaviors to be observed,
3. An established scoring and recording system, and
4. Opportunity for the observer to learn and practice the observation technique.
Meaningfulness of Observations
The second major concern with data collection and behavior observation is that the
behaviors being observed and the techniques used must provide teachers with
information that is relevant and useful.
Care must be taken to select behaviors which are relevant to the instructional process.
Often the usefulness of the performance or behavior data is determined by how
relevant the observed behaviors are to the objectives of the instructional program.
Sensitivity
The observation method utilized must be sensitive to changes in the frequency or the
amount of behavior. The time allotted for the observation must be sufficient to
observe the behavior occur.
Student performance and behavior can vary markedly depending on the setting.
Behaviors on the playground may be much different than during a classroom activity.
An important element in obtaining a meaningful observation is choosing the
appropriate setting for the observation and describing the conditions under which the
observation occurred. This description of conditions is often necessary to interpret
information correctly.
The teacher must carefully select the performance criteria or behavior to be observed
to reflect student knowledge or skills. Performance should not be affected by some
extraneous variable or condition which is not of immediate interest. For example,
choosing number of words written correctly during a timed spelling test might be a
poor way to measure spelling performance in a student with motor coordination
problems. It would be difficult to determine whether the student did not know the
spelling or whether they were unable to correctly write the words in the time
provided.
Comparisons of Performance
Tests, particularly achievement tests, are often used to compare student’s performance
with other students. This can be done because all students have done the same
activities under the same conditions. Data collection and behavior observation in the
classroom often occur under a wide variety of conditions with a limited number of
students. The information collected is often used to verify whether a student is
meeting specified criteria rather than to make comparisons with other students. Data
may also be collected a number of times on the same student as a means of measuring
progress. When comparisons are important in order to make data more meaningful,
observations may also be made on a number of other students in the same setting.
Observable Behavior
A behavior is observable when it can be noted through one of the senses (seen,
heard, tasted, smelled, or felt). Observable behaviors are usually described by
action words such as touching, walking, saying, or writing. These do not
include feelings or intentions which are inferred from other behaviors.
Measurable Behavior
Examples:
All of these techniques rely on precisely identifying the behaviors in observable and
measurable performance terms (as discussed in the previous lesson) to make the
results meaningful and reliable.
The Observations
When developing an observation period, the teacher will take the following
considerations into account. A paraeducator should be aware of these considerations
in order to make consistent and accurate measurements during the observation.
The target behavior will need to be defined in such a way that it is observable and
measurable to anyone that may be observing that student. It is possible that both the
teacher and the paraeducator could observe the same student at the same time and
note different behaviors. Clearly identifying specific behaviors being observed makes
communicating and interpreting the results of the observation more accurate.
The teacher should be the one to identify and define the behavior. However, the
paraeducator needs to have a clear understanding of the specific behavior.
The target behavior will also determine the time of the observation. The teacher
should schedule the observation during a time in which the behavior is likely to occur
and for a length of time that will allow opportunity for the behavior to occur.
In determining the observation technique to use, the teacher will take into
consideration the specific behavior and the information that they will want to gather
from the observation. A paraeducator will need to have an understanding of these
techniques and practice them before they can use them in an observation.
Observation Techniques
Frequency
Frequency counts are a record of the number of times a specific behavior occurs
within a specific time period. Frequency counts are useful for recording behaviors
which have a clear beginning and ending, are of relatively short duration, and occur a
number of times during the specified time period.
A tally sheet is usually used to identify the behavior being observed and to record the
frequency or the number of times which the behavior occurs. Below is an example of
a tally sheet and how the frequency of a behavior might be recorded.
A frequency count would NOT be used for those behaviors that occur at a high rate,
such as tapping a pencil on a desk, or when the behavior occurs for an extended
period of time, such as when a student sucks their thumb.
Rate
The rate of a behavior can also be averaged across a number of observation periods to
report an average rate. From a series of observations it may be determined that a
student's average rate of "out of seat" behavior may be twelve times per hour.
For example, if the list contains 20 words and the student requires five minutes to
write the list, the rate would be four words per minute.
An example follows of how one might record "out of seat" behavior as rate.
Duration
Recording the duration of a behavior is done by recording the starting and ending time
of a behavior and computing the length of time that the behavior occurs. This
technique is usually used to observe behavior which occur less frequently and
continue for a period of time.
An example of duration recording could be for a student who has crying episodes in
class. Everytime the student cries in class, you would record the beginning and ending
times, and then calculate the duration of the crying episode. A few other examples of
when duration recording could be used include how long it takes a student to finish a
math assignment; the length of time a student takes cleaning up, or how long a student
spends continuously tapping their pencil on the desk.
Interval Recording
An example of interval recording could be for a child who throws their toys during
free-time. If the free-time lasts for 15 minutes, then that time could be broken into 1
minute intervals. If in the first minute, the child throws the toy the interval is marked.
If in the next minute, they don't throw a toy then the interval is not marked. However,
if in the third minute, the child throws three different toys, the interval is only marked
once again.
Sample of Interval Record Form
Interval Recording
Student Name:
Date of Observation:
Observed Behavior:
Starting Time:
Ending Time:
Total Observation Time:
Other examples of when interval recording may be used include, a student who talks
to other students around them during work time, the amount of socializing that a
student does at recess, or if a student is attending to a book during personal reading
time.
Interval recording will work for any behaviors that can be observed, however there is
a strong time demand upon the observer which may make this technique inappropriate
or undesirable to use.
Time Sampling
Time sampling is similar to interval recording in that the observation time is divided
into intervals, however in time sampling, the behavior is recorded only if it occurs at
the end of the time period. When the specified amount of time has expired, the
observer looks at the student and determines whether or not the behavior is occurring.
In general, this technique is used for behaviors which are longer in duration.
For example, if the behavior is identified as "being out of seat", the observation time
might be 15 minutes with intervals of 1 minute. The paraeducator would mark at one
minute intervals whether the student being observed was out of his or her seat.
Since with time sampling the observation is done intermittently, the observer, such as
the teacher or paraeducator, is able to observe a behavior without having to set an
amount of time aside to observe continually. Thus time sampling is a practical way of
getting an estimation of the overall occurrence of a behavior.
Some other examples of behaviors that time sampling can be used with include, a
student reading a book, nail biting, participation in a game during recess, or working
on math assignments.
Time sampling would generally NOT be used with behaviors with a short duration
such as hitting, kicking or spitting. If the behavior does not have a long enough
duration, then it may not be observed at the specified intervals.
The observer may utilize a timer or a tape recorder with beeps to determine when to
record if the behavior is occurring. In a variation of this technique, tapes with random
beeps are sometimes used to record observations at random times during the
observation period. With this variation the observer and the student do not know
ahead of time when the recording will occur.
Anecdotal Records
Anecdotal records are written notes describing events or incidents that occur. These
notes usually become part of a student's file. Anecdotal records may be used to
document:
a significant event which occurs unexpectedly or infrequently;
the settings or conditions in which a behavior occurred;
the antecedents (what happens before) and the consequences (what happens
after) of a problem behavior; or
a conversation with parents.
If a paraeducator is working with the student at the time of the incident, they may be
asked to assist in completing the anecdotal record.
The purpose of the anecdotal record is to document the event as clearly and accurately
as possible. The following guidelines should be observed when writing the record:
1. Record observation at the time behavior is observed rather than at a later time.
2. Utilize a standardized anecdotal record form to record the information to help
insure that all relevant information is included.
3. Record what is actually observed rather than your feelings about the incident.
4. Use performance terms to describe behavior.
5. Be careful about including information about other students (by name) in the
record.
6. Be aware that parents and other professionals will have access to the record.
Anecdotal records are usually recorded on preprinted forms to insure that all relevant
information is included. These anecdotal record usually includes the following:
1. Name of the observer
2. Date of the incident
3. Time when the incident occurred
4. Name of the student involved
5. A description of the incident
6. Location/setting where the incident occurred
7. Notes/Recommendations/Actions taken (be careful here)
8. Signature
Reporting Information
The following are not specific techniques for observing behaviors, however they do
allow the observer to interpret the information that is gathered during the observation.
By calculating the percentage and average, a large amount of information about the
behavior's occurrence can be summarized briefly.
Percentage
Percentage is the ratio of the number of times an event occurs to the number of
possibilities for that event to occur times 100. For example, if we are interested in
determining the percent of math problems a student does correctly while completing a
math worksheet, and the student gets fifteen of twenty items on the sheet correct, then
the percentage would be the ratio of the number correct (15) and the number possible
(20) times 100 or 75 percent.
You may be familiar with using percentage in recording academic work, but
percentages are also used with observing behaviors. Following are some of the
observation techniques presented in this lesson, and how a percentage can be
calculated with the information gathered in the observation.
Time Sampling Reported as Percentage
If the observation using a duration technique is done during a specific period of time,
the percentage of time that the behavior occurs may also be computed. All
occurrences and length of time the behavior occurred are recorded. For example, if
the behavior being observed was "being out of seat", the paraeducator could use a
stop watch to measure the number of minutes and seconds during a 30 minute period
in which the student was out of his/her seat. If the number of minutes and seconds is
divided by 30 minutes and taken times 100, the percentage of time that the student
was out of his/her seat can be determined.
Again, recording the percentage requires that the observer record the number of
possible attempts or opportunities divided by the number of times that the student
meets the criteria. The result is then taken times 100.
Average
Averaging Frequency/Rate
Averaging Duration
If the student sucks their thumb for 10 minutes, 7 minutes, 4 minutes, 3 minutes, then
one calculates the average duration of thumb sucking as follows:
Average Duration = 10+7+4+3 = 24 minutes total
Summary
Although the techniques and strategies for recording behavior are not difficult,
carefully developed procedures and practice are essential in gathering accurate data.
The following guidelines may be helpful:
1. Describe as precisely as possible the behavior you are recording before you
begin to record it. Discuss examples of the behavior to make sure that you
have the same understanding of the behavior as the teacher.
2. Prepare the recording technique ahead of time. Make sure you are familiar
with the form and the method for recording.
3. Carefully observe the time limits and time intervals used in recording.
4. Try to prepare so that you need to make the fewest judgments while recording.
Record the behavior every time it occurs, regardless of how much it occurs.
For example, if you are recording how often a student touches other students,
you should record all touches whether they are gentle or hard. If you can't tell
whether a behavior fits the criteria you and the teacher need to further refine
the criteria so that it matches the intent of the observation and is observable
and measurable.
Lesson 5:
Charting Student Performance
Behavior observation data is often graphed because it makes it easier to quickly
review the data and to see changes in student behavior or performance. After a
number of observations have been made, the result of each observation is marked on
the chart. Numerous observations can be quickly summarized on one chart. Charts are
also beneficial for providing information and feedback to students and parents.
Teachers often utilize paraeducators to maintain updated copies of performance charts
in students folders.
A horizontal axis was created with an interval for each day of the observations. A
mark is placed on the chart for each day's corresponding frequency. Often a line is
used to connect these points and indicate a trend in the performance or behavior.
Labels are provided for the vertical (Frequency) and horizontal (Days) axis.
The number of observations and the length of the observation period is determined by
how the data was collected and the number of observations which occurred.
Activity 1:
Observable and Measurable Behavior Activity
First Last
Name:
Email address:
Please provide us with information about how you are participating in the program.
Section/Site:
Position:
Define the following terms so that they are both observable and measurable. Imagine
that you see these behaviors while working with small groups of students. How could
you report back to your teacher what you saw in both observable and measureable
terms. Please be as specific as possible with your description. This will help ensure
that the behavior is both observable and measurable.
1. Talking out:
2. On-Task:
3. Teasing:
4. Arguing:
5. Good Sitting:
6. Day Dreaming:
The following activities are optional activities designed to help you learn and practice
behavior observation skills. These activities utilize quicktime movie clips of students
working in a small group setting. Use the clips to practice observing and recording
specific behaviors. Each video clip is downloaded by clicking on the link.
Downloading the movie clips can take a considerable amount of time on a slow
connection.
In order to view these clips you must have your web browser set up properly, your
computer must be capable of viewing quicktime movies, and you must have an
application which plays quicktime movies such as Movie Player.
These activities are optional due to the experimental nature of using video over the
World Wide Web. Certain requirements exist for your computer in order to view these
movies. If you wish to continue with the activities, follow the guidelines below.
Requirements
i.e. if you are using a modem, it might take about 1 hour to download
the movie depending on how fast of a modem you are using.
Quicktime version 2.5 properly installed.
Quicktime plug-in 1.1 properly installed into your Plug-ins folder for your
web browser.
Computer with a reasonable amount of memory.
Optional Activity: Behavior Observation
In this scene students are working at their seats in a classroom setting. You should use
this video clip to complete practice activities one, two and three. Watch the movie first
to become familiar with the student's names. The seating chart available describes
who is sitting where. After you have watched the movie the first time, scroll down to
the first activity. Read the instructions for that activity, then scroll back up to the
movie. Watch the movie and scroll back to that activity to record your answers. When
you are finished with that activity, scroll down to the following activity.
TIME: 1:30
DESCRIPTION: Students are seated in pairs at tables arranged from the front of the
room to the rear. They are working individually at their seats
completing division problems on a math quiz.
The movie should start playing automatically before the entire movie has been
downloaded. The bar below the movie should turn colors from grey to black as the
movie downloads. The movie is finished downloading when the bar is completely
black.
The controls for the movie are beside the bar that changes color. To start playing the
movie, press your mouse on the sideways triangle. That triangle will then turn into an
up & down equals sign becoming the stop button. To adjust the sound level, press
your mouse on the megaphone button (to the left of the start/stop button). Now move
your mouse up or down while pressing the megaphone to adjust the sound level.
When you are satsified with the sound level, release your mouse. If you have watched
the entire movie, and you wish to see it again, press on the play button. The movie
should start from the beginning. If you are halfway through, and wish to stop to write
something down, press the stop button, do what you need to do, then repress the play
button. It will start where you left off.
Please enter your name and email address below
First Last
Name:
Email address:
Please provide us with information about how you are participating in the program.
Section/Site:
Position:
Part One
ACTIVITY: 1. Watch the video clip and identify at least two behaviors you feel
might be significant
Part Two
ACTIVITY: 1. Watch the video clip and count the number of times Christi raises
her hand.
2. Record the frequency in the form below and submit your answer.
Part Three
ACTIVITY: 1. Watch the video clip and count the number of times Belinda looks
at the ceiling
2. Record the frequency in the form below and submit your answer.