You are on page 1of 7

Join for free Log in

Question Asked 3 years ago

Raman S Chary
Czech Technical University in Prague

Why am I getting temperature divergence in AMG solver?


Hello,

The case is with regards to a 2-D Axis-symmetric pipe - turbulent flow - water - density varying with
temperature - polynomial ( 6th order )

I have reduced the under relaxation factors for all of them to very low but am still getting the same
error.

Thanks a lot.. !!!

ThermoFluids Modeling using CFD CFD Coding CFD Simulation Computational Fluid Dynamics ANSYS

FLUENT Polynomials Turbulent Flow AMG

Share

All Answers (18)

John Kaiser S. Calautit 3 years ago


University of Nottingham

Try the following:

- Refine your mesh

- Check boundary conditions

- If available, use Hybrid initialisation

Soheil Akbari 3 years ago


Iran University of Science and Technology

choose the variation of water properties according to operating conditions and use multiphase model
(mixture model).

fixed the temperature of vapor phase in cell zone condition.

Raman S Chary 3 years ago


Czech Technical University in Prague

the mesh is already refined... and after using Hybrid Initialization


Divergence in AMG solver : "k"

Ashish Saxena 3 years ago


Nanyang Technological University

Try with using second order solvers. Let us know how you will be able to solve the same, if you will.

Raman S Chary 3 years ago


Czech Technical University in Prague

I used 2nd order solvers as default... even before the error came. !!

I then changed the Dentsity equation to 2nd order... then it solves faultlessly.. !!

But not with the 6th order I first tried... !!

Thanks a lot everyone for your contributions.. !

Mahesh K. Varpe 3 years ago


Ramaiah University of Applied Sciences

Check mesh quality for skewness (0.5 is adequate). Check the model if its is properly scaled or for  units. 

First switch off energy equation and density variation. If simulation runs smooth then enable energy
equation. After this if it is OK, specify density variation ( first try simple relation and then custom desired).
2 Recommendations

Rajesh Alayil 3 years ago


Indian Institute of Technology Madras

Hi Raman,

along which axis are you applying axis-symmetry. 

usually this error appears when you have any problem with mesh, boundary conditions, models etc. But
for axis symmetry problems, it can be due to the axis also. the axis-symmetry condition should be always
along the x direction. Please check this out and try it.

Regards,

Rajesh
2 Recommendations

Raman S Chary 3 years ago


Czech Technical University in Prague

Yes... I checked with the axis-symmetric conditions and it was along the x-direction.

As Mahesh said I also tried switching off the density variation and energy equation at the beginning. The
simulation was very smooth without them. With energy its okay but the the problem starts with the density
polynomial.
I was forced to use a polynomial of lower order the problem got solved.

Thanks everyone... !!!

Raman

Jigar Soni 3 years ago


Gujarat Technological University

sir i am also facing the same problem of divergence but i don't know how to check the axis
symmetry...please guide

Rajesh Alayil 3 years ago


Indian Institute of Technology Madras

@Jigar,

check where you have applied axis symmetry condition in the solution domain. Is it along the x or y axis.

Regards,

Rajesh.

1 Recommendation

Rajesh Alayil 3 years ago


Indian Institute of Technology Madras

@Raman, how about the quality of your mesh. What initialization scheme are you using ?

Regards,

Rajesh.

Raman S Chary 3 years ago


Czech Technical University in Prague

Im using Standard initialization calculated which has been to all zones. !!

I think the problem is with the 6th order equation of pure water's density dependance on temperature. Its
provided by UNESCO so I thought of going ahead with it. .!!

Its equation number : 8.4 on the second page.. !!!

Is this equation legitimate. ?

ocen689ch8.pdf · 178.69 KB

Steffen Hain-Würtenberger 3 years ago


Magna Powertrain Bad Homburg GmbH

Hello Raman,
Often when I had problems with temperature divergence, it could be managed by setting a lower
temperature limit. Default value in many CFD packages is 6000 K or so. If you allow the solver for such
unreasonable numerical excursions (in common engineering problems), it may happen that you
are already lost right at the beginning and numerical stability is gone and can't by recovered by any mean.
This is not necessarily a question of mesh quality. Just try it.

Regards,

Steffen

Ashish Saxena 3 years ago


Nanyang Technological University

Have you tried using second order upwind solver scheme??

Raman S Chary 3 years ago


Czech Technical University in Prague

Yes Im using Second Order Upwind solver... and I changed the limits according to Steffen... The problem
persists because of the 6th order density equation of water.. !!

The problem solves flawlessly when changed to a simple 2nd order equation.
1 Recommendation

Leandro Campos 7 months ago


ArcelorMittal

Hey Raman, did you solve your problem? Would you mind to share with us? I'm having the same here...
Thanks!

Raman S Chary 7 months ago


Czech Technical University in Prague

Hey Leandro,

The problem was that I was trying to use the 6th order polynomial for the relation of density of pure water
with respect to change in temperature.

It was way too much for fluent :D

I used a 2nd order polynomial and the simulation worked effortlessly.


1 Recommendation

Pei Sun 3 months ago


University of Sussex

Hi Raman,

Thank you so much!


Can you help by adding an answer?

Answer

Enter your answer

Add your answer

Question followers (19) See all

Similar Questions

How can I solve AMG divergence in fluent?


I am working on a flame affected by external magnetic field using MHD module with fluent 14.5 . I am using
compiled UDF to produce non-uniform...

13 answers added

How do I deal with this error message in ANSYS FLUENT?


Any ANSYS FLUENT users here, please how do i deal with this error message "Error: received a fatal signal
(Segmentation fault). Error Object: #f"...

18 answers added

Divergence detected in AMG solver: Is it a problem with the temperature?


Hi, I just started to work with Fluent. I am trying to model a 2D axisymmetric problem. The simulation is
transient conduction (material has...

2 answers added
How can I control Divergency in AMG solver in Fluent software?
I am modeling Boiling in a vertical tube in Fluent 14.the model that i used is RPI  model.after setting up, I faced
this message: 'Divergence...
27 answers added

How can the error of Divergence detected in AMG solver: x-momentum be solved?
 I am doing transient simulation for what is called friction stir welding processes of Aluminium 6061, so far the
model is facing a problem. The...
5 answers added

Can anyone tell me how to fix reverse flow in fluent flow analysis using ansys 14.5?
My project is temperature analysis of a double pipe helical type heat exchanger using water as fluid.
23 answers added

How can I improve mesh quality?


In terms of skewness, I got max 0.98 that means my model is very poor. I try to remesh and fix it. Anyone know
the way to improve and reduce...
15 answers added

Divergence detected in AMG solver: x-momentum -> Increasing relaxation sweeps! how do I solve
this and what is the reason behind it?
this fluent problem...when i am calculating solidification in shell-tube storage system which is alien in Y-
direction, i am facing this problem.
10 answers added

What does 'divergence detected in AMG solver: x-momentum' mean and how can I solve this
problem?
I am investigating the wave propagation in a tube with a Helmholtz resonator attached to one end by using
CFD. I am using a temperature profile...
3 answers added

Why did I receive the Error message ''Divergence detected in AMG solver: x-momentum'' in Ansys
Fluent?
Im solving 2D axisymmetric problem in Ansys Fluent. 
11 answers added

Reads 3793
Followers 19
Answers 18

Related Publications

Mathematical simulation of ammonia gas release in a complex urban terrain using CFD
and a statistical approach
[Show abstract]

Conference Paper · Sep 2013

Milada Kozubková Marian Bojko O. Zavila +1 more author... Pavel Danihelka

Read

CFD Simulation of Shortstopping Runaway Reactions in Vessels Agitated With


Impellers and Jets
[Show abstract]

Article · Nov 2006

D. Dakshinamoorthy Avinash r Khopkar Joseph F. Louvar Vivek V. Ranade


Vivek V. Ranade

Read

CFD simulation of mixing in stirred reactor


[Show abstract]

Article · Jan 2008 · Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries

X.-C. Cao T.-A. Zhang Q.-Y. Zhao

Read

© 2008-2018 ResearchGate GmbH. All rights reserved.

About us · Help Center · Careers · Developers · News · Privacy · Terms · Copyright · Impressum  |  Advertising · Recruiting