Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
SOCIETY
1
Fakhr-ul-Islam, 2Khan Faqir & Malik Amer Atta3
1
Pakistan Study Centre, University of Peshawar, Pakistan
2
University of Science and Technology Bannu, Pakistan
3
Institute of Education and Research, Gomal University, D.I.Khan
ABSTRACT
Jirga is a unique institution that exists in Pukhtoons social organization. It is a Pashtu word which
means circle. (Gankoski and Malik, 2006). It is difficult to trace exact origin of Jirga. Nevertheless, it
is as old as the community itself. In this paper the writer has dwelt upon origin and evolution of Jirga.
How did Afghanistan and Pakistan adopt and accommodate the concept of Jirga as state institution
has also been taken into consideration. Apart from consulting published material, the writer reached
out to a number of people belonging to FATA (Federally Administered tribal Areas) and settled
districts of Khyber Pakhtoonkhwa province of Pakistan for ascertaining their views on the subject. In
this way, the paper contains up-to-date information and communal critique rather than review by a
single writer.
Key Word: Jirga, Pukhtoons, Tribe(s), disputes, verdict.
to Pukhtoons society. Jirga is a council of precarious situation, the Jirga ask the
elders that intervenes in disputes arising of parties to give them Waak/ikhtiar
intra-tribal clashes. It listens to parties and (mandate) which means they will accept
passes judgments which are binding on all the verdict wholeheartedly. Finally the
stakeholders. Although one may not case is decided on merit
strictly define Jirga but few writers have Interestingly, no state or non-state
given their own definitions. James authority is available to execute verdict of
W.Spain characterizes it “a group of this non-official Jirga. For effective
members of a particular sub-group of implementation of Jirga decision, surety
Pathans considering a matter of common in cash or kind (weapon, moveable or
interest”. (Spain, 1990) Qayum Afridi immovable property) by parties is
considers it a court whose judges are deposited with Jirga. Any party found
nominated in equal number by the guilty of violating the verdict may lose
disputing parties from amongst the elders their surety which may be confiscated by
of repute. (Afridi, 2003) The type, power the Jirga.(Wazir, 2010)
and function Jirga vary depending on In Khyber Agency in particular and other
nature of cases before it. There are four tribal areas in general a specific
types of Jirga namely: methodology is adopted for resolving
disputes arising out of murder. In case of
Koranay or Shakhsi Jirga: murder, both the aggrieved and assassin
In this type of Jirga, cases between parties confine to their houses. The Jirga,
individuals or families are disposed of. first of all, tries to make both the parties
Members of this Jirga are selected with agree on Tigga. Tigga is a Pashtu word
mutual consent of the parties concerned. which means stone. Symbolically, a stone
As mentioned, its scope and function is is fixed which means that the disputing
limited. How the Jirga proceeds? Here a parties have agreed to decide their case
sequence followed by koranay Jirga in through Jirga and cease fire will exist till
North Waziristan tribal area is given verdict(Afridi,2003).
which, with minor variations, may be true
of the whole FATA and Khyber Olasi or Qami Jirga:
Pakhtoonkhwa. The proceedings go like Unlike the koranay/Shakhsi Jirga, the
the following: olasi/qami Jirga is constituted for taking
The parties approach influential elders of up issues or cases of collective importance
the tribe and seek their intervention in the of a community or tribe. The basic unit of
case in question. this Jirga is every house hold which may
Upon consent of Jirga members, the send one member to it. Numerous cases of
process is kick-started. The Jirga members collective nature such as settling disputes
establish contacts with the parties and with other tribes, community share in
record their statements. forests and other natural resources,
After examining the statements, the next distribution of irrigation water, launching
stage is announcing verdict. Normally the of developmental projects, and dealing
Jirga gives its verdict at this stage, with outlaws in the area etcetera are put
however, sometimes serious problems before the Jirga. After selection of
arise. For instance, both the parties stick to members, the holding of Jirga
their stated positions and urge upon the congregation or assembly is announced.
Jirga to decide in their favour. In that During deliberations, every participant is
given the right to speak. Decision may Frontier Crimes Regulations 1901, where
arrive in one or more than one sessions community was involved in disposal of
depending on the nature of dispute. The cases. That was the beginning of Sarkari
most accurate sequence of proceeding Jirga.
adopted in Olasi/qami Jirga is given In the Frontier Crimes Regulations, all
below: details about the Council of Elders ( Jirga
“In this kind of an assembly, all ) have been given in Chapter III( section 8
participants have a right to speak but most to 20). In the same regulations, the
prefer to observe only. Without any formal Council of Elders ( Jirga ) has been
facilitator, each one offers the other, defined as:
opportunity to start the talk. In the end, “…a Council of three or more persons
someone begins with a tale or a narrative, whether official or otherwise convened by
setting the stage for discussion on the the Deputey Commissioner and presided
issue. Various parameters of the issue are over by a magistrate invested with powers
discussed by addressing concern from under section 30 of the Code of Criminal
each individual from the community, Procedure 1898” (Ali I, 2003)
while the leadership listens and facilitates
further. Finally a common ground is The Provincially Administered Tribal
identified and announced for agreement by Areas (PATA) Regulations also provided
all”(Yousafzai & Ali, 2005) for Jirga system. PATA include six
Both Koranay and Olasi Jirgas are districts of Malakand Division viz Buner,
unofficial in nature; therefore, people Chitral, Dir Upper, Dir Lower, Malakand,
prefer them over Sarkari (State-controlled Shangla, Swat and some parts Hazara
Jirga). However it does not mean that Division. In these areas, a special law
people are fully satisfied with them. When namely PATA Regulations was enforced
this writer asked Pukhtoons to identify in 1975. Sections 5-11 of PATA
shortcomings of unofficial Jirgas, they Regulations, describe formation and
listed many. These defects have been procedure of Jirga. As per Section 6,
given in the survey section of the article. Jirga, to be appointed by the Deputy
Commissioner, shall consist of five
Sarkari (State-controlled) Jirga: members, one of them its President and
The evolution of Pukhtoon society from four ordinary members. The President
state-less stage to emergence of state has must be a government official, not below
affected the institution of Jirga as well. In the rank of Tehsildar or Naib Tehsildar.
1849, after replacing Sikhs in the present The ordinary members are from the
day Khyber Pakhtoonkhwa and community appointed after consultation
subsequently pursuing their Forward with the parties concerned.(Ibid) In 1994,
Policy.(Spain, 1985) towards Afghanistan, when PATARs were declared
the British Indian government faced the unconstitutional by Supreme Court of
wrath Pukhtoons. The latters were averse Pakistan,(Bangash A, 2010) the
to British occupations of Afghanistan. government promulgated the following
From 1849 to 1908, the British Indian regulations at different times:
government conducted almost 49 (i) The Provincially Administered Tribal
expeditions against the Pukhtoon tribes. Areas (Nafaz-e-Nizam-e-Shariah)
(Nevill, 1912) Finally they introduced a Regulation1994.
hybrid administrative system under (ii) The Sharia’I Nizm-e-Adl Act 1999
(4) Which type of Jirga is functional in respondents could not understand the
your area? question. 8.75% people said that they have
(5) Identify merits of Jirga system in your both types of Jirga in their area. An
area. overwhelming majority i.e. 87.5 %
(6) Identify demerits of Jirga system in informed that Olasi Jirga functioned in
your area their areas of domicile.
(7) How far Jirga is relevant after 9/11 5. There were several positive points
and rise of Taliban? presented by the respondents when they
were asked to identify merits of Jirga
1.Is Jirga inevitable for Pukhtoons system in their area. The merits are
society? summarized as follow:
Everyone can express his opinion in Jirga
Response Frequency Percentage • Jirga administers speedy justice
Yes 78 97.5 • It works as an effective conflict
No 2 2.5 resolution tool
Total 80 100 • It comes up with solution to problems
Of the two respondents who said, no, one • It resolves disputes peacefully
male belongs to Chitral and the other • It transforms enmity into friendship
female hails from Swabi • It is an inexpensive justice system
• It is a collective approach to dispute
2. Do you support continuation of Jirga resolution
system? • It brings about durable solution
Response Frequency Percentage • It protects people from intricacies
Yes 78 97.5 • Jirga announces verdict in the light of
No 2 2.5 local culture, customs and traditions
Total 80 100 • There is real democracy in the Jirga
system
3. Which type of Jirga you support, • It punishes oppressor and helps the
official or olasi? oppressed
Response Frequency Percentage • Besides local culture, customs and
official 2 2.5 traditions, it gives weight to the
Olasi 72 90 teachings of Quran and Sunnah
Other 6 7.5 • Justice is not delayed in Jirga system
Total 80 100 • Everyone is equal before Jirga law
Interestingly in the other category, 7.5% • Structurally, Jirga is quite a simple
respondents opted for both types of Jirga. body
• It promotes social harmony, peace and
4. In response to a question as to
tranquility
which type of Jirga is functional in their
respective areas, 3.75% said there was no
6. If the respondents were showering
system of Jirga existed in their respective
praises on Jirga on one hand, on the other
area. Interestingly respondents of this
hand they also highlighted its demerits of
category belonged to Chitral, Mardan and
the system. Majority of them (22.5 %)
South Waziristan. The nonexistence of
alleged that corruption has permeated into
Jirga System in Mardan and South
the jarga system. (72.2 %) of the
Waziristan is unbelievable. May be the
Ali, I.(2003). Laws Extended to the Tribal Nevill, C. H.L. (1912). Campaign on the
Areas with Jirga Laws. Peshawar: New North West Frontier Delhi: Neerj
Fine Printers. Publishing House.
Bangash, Y. K. (2010) "Three Legal The Daily Aaj, (July 22, 2012). Peshawar
Systems." Dawn, Islamabad.
The Daily Jang, (21st April, 2009).
Beg, A. (2000). Pukhtunistan Today Rawalpindi
Peshawar: Dunya Pvt,
Gazzette of Government of NWFP, The Daily Jang, (22nd November, 2012).
Extraordinary. 16th January 1999. Rawalpindi