Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
COURT OF APPEALS
National Capital Judicial Region
Manila
x---------------------------------------x
I. THE PARTIES
This is an ordinary appeal under Rule 41 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure
filed by the herein Plaintiff-Appellant (brevity) PEDRO BATONGBUHAY, a.k.a “PETE
LIVINGSTONE”, against Defendant-Appellee PITAK REALTY, INC. seeking to SET
ASIDE and REVERSE the Decision dated 03 May 2018 of the Regional Trial Court
of Baguio City, Branch 4, in Civil Case No.4 entitled, “PEDRO BATONGBUHAY,
a.k.a “PETE LIVINGSTONE” vs. PITAK REALTY, INC., represented by its
Chairman, GLORIA BATONGBUHAY- GRACIA.”
In the appealed Decision dated 03 May 2018, the court a quo rendered
judgment against the plaintiff-appellant as follow:
Pre-trial4 and trial of the case ensued, with the parties presenting their
respective testimonial and documentary evidence. Plaintiff-appellee presented
witnesses in the persons of Ayne and Alfred Ramos, while Harvey and Selina Santos
testified for the defendants. The parties were also ordered to file their respective
1
Complaint dated 17 January 2017, pp. 6-7; Rollo, pp. 45-50
2
Defendants’ Answer (with Compulsory Counterclaims) dated 25 January 2017, pp. 3-4; Rollo, pp.57-61.
3
Defendants’ Answer (with Compulsory Counterclaims) dated 25 October 2006, pp. 3-4; Rollo, pp.57-61.
4
Pre-trial Order was issued on 22 February 2008, After attempts at setting the case proved futile, the case
was set for initial trial on 16 May 2008.
Formal Offer of Exhibits as well as the Comments/Objections thereto, and the court
accordingly ruled upon the same in its Orders dated 29 September 20085 and 15
April 2009.6
On 18 September 2009, the court rendered the Assailed Order denying the
Motion for Reconsideration filed by the defendants-appellant.9
5
Order dated 29 September 2008, Rollo, p. 218.
6
Order dated 15 April 2009, Rollo, p. 303.
7
Motion for Reconsideration dated 08 August 2009, Rollo, pp. 348-354.
8
Comment/Opposition dated 04 September 2009, Rollo, pp.358-363.
9
Order dated 18 September 2009, Rollo, pp.364-365.